Wade v. Astrue
Filing
16
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 8/26/13. (med)
J
D
CE
- F*œ: OFFI U,S. ST COURT
DI .
AT ROANOKE,VA
F1 ED
L
I TH E UM TED STATES DI
N
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTER N D I
STRI T O F V I I I
C
RG N A
RO A N O K E D I SI N
W O
ALC 2s 2 1
03
9J 'A Du
KUL #.
I
%'
,
?Jj'
'h
j
, ERx
cu
LE
'
.
;
PEG G Y W A DE ,
.
C i lA c i N o.7: 2- vvi ton
1 c 00621
Pl ntff
ai i ,
M EM O R AN DU M O PI O N
NI
V.
CA R O LY N W . COLVI 1
N,
A c i C om m i s one ofSoci Sec iy,
tng
si r
al ur t
By:
Judge Ja esC .Tur
m
k
Se or U ni e St t D i t i tJudge
ni
t d a es s r c
D ef
endant
.
Plitf Pe g W a e(t a e' b o h ti a o c le gngt efn ld cso o t e
anif g y d ( d ' r ug t h s din haln i h ia e iin f h
W
)
Commisone of Soca Se iy (t
si r
il curt çcommiso ' fndi he not dia ed a t r o e
siner), i ng r
s bl nd heefr
i i bl f bot s pplme a s c iy i ome (ç ' a dia lt i urnce be ft,
nelgi e or h u e ntl e urt nc
çSSl' nd s biiy ns a
)
neis
(1 B',u d rt So ilS cli Ac (ç t' 4 U. C.j 4 - 3 1 81 1 8 f Th sCo r
t ' n e he ca e t t t û ', 2 S. j 0143 , 3 - 3 3 . i u t
Dl )
ry
Ac )
.
ha jzid cino e tea to p rua tt 4 U. C. 4 5 g a d 4 U. C.j1 8 ()3 . t
s t s ito v r h ci n u s n o 2 S. j 0 ( ) n 2 S.
r
3 3 c( ) Bo h
W ade a t Co m i s one fl d m oto f Slm m a y J
nd he m s i r ie
i ns or l
r udgm e . ECF N os 1 1 Or l
nt
. 0, 2. a
a gum e wa he r on J y 25, 3 a t m oto ar now rpef diposton.
r
nt s a d
ul
201 nd he i ns e
i or s ii
The pr m a y i s r s d by W a i t s c e i whe he t Com m i s one e r d i
i r s ue ai e
de n hi as s
t r he
s i r re n
f ii t c i r e de s s i t t t Appea s Cot c l s e ofw li h w a o a ne
a lng o ons de vi nce he ubm ted o he
l
m i, om
zc
s bt i d
ls t n tre we k atr Ad n srtv La J d e (ç ,' J n ie M .Ho is e a
e s ha h e e s fe miitai e w u g & J' e nf r
At )
nw su d
de ii n de ng W ade be tt .W a s is t tt e denc i ne and ma e i l She
c so
nyi
neis
de ubm t ha he vi e s w
t ra .
r ue t t tt Cour eihe r m a t c s ba k t t A ge y i or f t r de l pm e ' or
eq s s ha he
t t r e nd he a e c o he
nc i ur he ve o nt'
f
t ti G e r e t A LJ S d i i n o rghta a a d di a lt a SS1be tt . ECF N o.11 a
ha t d ve s he
r
' ec s o ut i
nd w r s biiy nd
nei s'
'
t
8.Def nda co e s t tt ne e de pr de by W a w a notm a e i lbo h be a e i
e nt unt r ha he w vi nce ovi d
de s
t r a t c us t
'Ca ol W . Col n be m et Aci Com m isi rofSocalSec iy o Fe ar l 201 Ptruan
r yn
vi ca he tng
s one
i
urt n bnz y 4, 3. ts t
t Rue2 ()o teFe ea Rue o CiiP o e ue Caoy W . li i hee sb t ue frMih e J Asr e
o l 5d f h d rl ls f vl r c d r, r ln Covn s rby u si td o c a l . tu
t
ast de enda i t s s t
he f nt n hi ui.
does not r a e t t pe i on or be or t dae of t ALJ' de i i a be a e t
elt o he rod
f e he t
he
S c son nd c us he
addii li or ton woul notha c nge t out m eoft c e.ECF No.13a 1
tona nf ma i
d
ve ha d he co
he as
t .
Fort r as s tf t be ow ,t Cot ' c nc udest tPl i if s e de e i bo h ne
he e ons e orh l
he ut o l
ha a ntf ' vi nc s t w
a ma e i a t tar m a t t Age f f t rdeve o e i wara e Acc di y,
nd t ral nd ha e nd o he
ncy or urhe
l pm nt s r ntd. or ngl
t Commi soners M oton f Slmma y J
he
si '
i or l r udgme i DENI a Pli ifs M oton f
nt s
ED nd antf
i or
Summ a y J
r udgme i GR ANTED.The Age y' d ii n i REVERSED a t sm a tri
nt s
nc s ec so s
nd hi te s
REM ANDED t t Age y puruan t sntnc f z of 42 U. C.j 405() f f t r
o he nc
s t o e e e olr
S.
g or urhe
pr ee ngsc itntwih t sopi on.
oc di
onsse
t hi ni
1
.
STANDARD OF REVI
EW
W he r viwi t Co mi sone ' fnaldec son,t Co ts r viw i lmie t
n e e ng he m s i r s i
ii
he ur ' e e s i t d o
de e m i ng w he he t Co m i s o r s fndi a e s
t r ni
t r he m s i ne ' i ngs r uppored by s t nta e de e a
t
ubs a i l vi nc nd
whehe t wer r a he t ough t a i to oft co r c l ga sanda ds Se 42 U. C.
t r hey
e e c d hr
he pplcai n he r e t e l t r . e
S.
j4 5 g ; nc c v. tu , 6 F.d4 0 47 ( t Ci. 01 ) Th Co sin rsfn i o
0 ( ) Ha o k Asr e 6 7 3 7 , 2 4h r 2 2 . e mmiso e ' idng f
a f c i c l i pr de i i s
ny a t s onc us ve ovi d t s uppored by s bs a i l e de e.Ri ha ds v.Pe a es
t
u t nta vi nc
c r on
rl ,
402 U. 389,390 ( 971.Subsa i evi nce i dei as Ts h r e nt e de e as a
S.
1 )
tntal de
s fned iuc elva vi nc
r ona e m i mi htac e a a uae t s
eas bl nd g
c pt s deq t o uppor a concuson. Pe al ,40 U. a 401
t
l i ' r es 2 S. t ;
'
H a oc 667 F. a 47 Subs an i e de e i not a d a g or c i r bl n o
nc k,
3d t 2.
t tal vi nc s
t re
l
ons de a e m unt of
evi nc ,'Pir v.Unde ood,48 U. 552,565 ( 988 ,buti d nsssofmor t namer
de e' ece
m
7 S.
1 )
t t it
co
e ha
e
sitlaofe de ebutma bel st n aprpondea e. Hanc k,667 F.d a 472 (iai
cnil vi nc
y es ha
e
r nc '
'
oc
3 t
ctton
o te )
mitd .
l t Com m i s one ' det r i tons ar s
f he
s i r s e m na i
e uppor e by s bs a i le de e,a r vi w i
td
u t nta vi nc
e e ng
c tma nots siut isj me f t toft Commisone,buti tad mus dee t
our y
ub tt e t udg nt or ha
he
si r
nse
t fr o
t o ed tr nains Ha sv. ulv n, 0 F.d 1 3 1 6(t Ci.1 9 ) 4 U. C. 4 5 g ;
h s ee mi to . y S lia 9 7 2 45 , 45 4h r 9 0 ; 2 S. j 0 ()
Ac r i y, tlq rviwi f s tnil e de e, we do not unde t t rweg
co dngl ûin e e ng or ubsa ta vi nc
rake o e ih
2
c nlcig e d n e ma ce iii d tr n to s o s b ttt ol j g n f rt to t e
o titn vie c , ke r dblt eemi ain , r u siue t ud me t o ha f h
y
r
ALJ... he ec lc i e de a l r s bl m i t dif rast whe he a cam a i
W r onfitng vi nce lows ea ona e nds o fe
o
t r li nt s
dia e t r ponsbiiy f r t t de ii n f ls o t ALJ. Ha
s bl d, he es i lt o ha c so al n he
' ncoc 667 F. a 47
'
k,
3d t 2
(ntr latrtonsa ciatonsomitd)
i ena leai nd t i
te .
I.
I
BAC K G R O UN D
A.
Proc dur H it y
e al s or
W ade a i d f bo h DI and SS1a al ge a dia lt o e dae ofDe mbe 21
pple or t B
nd le d
s biiy ns t t
ce r ,
96 r ai
20112 R .22,284- . He cl m s wer de ed on bot i ta r vi and on r c i r ton.R.
.
e ni
h nii l e ew
e onsde a i
62- 4.
9
Afe a he i on Fe a y 29,201 ALJ Ho ne is d a de son on M a c 28,201
tr
arng
bnz r
2,
r s ue
cii
rh
2,
fndi t t W ade was notdia e due t he a lt t pe f m he pa tr lvan wor a a
i ng ha
s bl d
o r biiy o ror
r s ee t k s
j wee.R.1 - 3 Th ALJprpel u iie t e fv -tp pr c s fr d tr nn wh t ra
e lr
93 . e
o ry tlz d h ie se o e s o ee miig ehe
cama ti d s be S eJ h s nv. r h r 4 4 F.d65 6 4n. (t Ci. 0 )(e c rn
li n s ia ld. e o n o Ban a q 3 3 0, 5 1 4h r 20 5 p r u im)
( tng 20 C. R.j404.520) (he tve se ak,i s que e whehe t cli nt () i
cii
F.
1
t i tps s n e nc , t r he ama : 1 s
wor ng; ( ha a svee i imen; ( has a i ime t t mees or e l t
ki 2) s e r mpar t 3)
n mpar nt ha
t
quas he
r q ie n so a l td i ime t ( )c n rt r t h sp s r lva twok;a d i no,( )
e urme t f i e mpar n ; 4 a eu n o i a t ee n r n f t 5
s
whehe he c n pe f m ot rwok) The ALJ frtdeemi d t tW ade meest i tr d
t r a ror he r .
is tr ne ha
t he nsle
sa us r quie nt of t Ac t ough De embe 31 201 and t s has note ag i
tt e r me s
he t hr
c
r , 4
hat he
ng ed n
s t ilganf aci t snc De mbe 21 2011, he a nded a lged ons tda e. 2 The
ubsnnta i ul tviy i e ce r ,
t me
le
e t R. 4.
ALJ a s co l
lo ncuded t t W ade has t f l ng s ve e i ime s ce vi l a ll r
ha
he olowi e r mpar nt : r ca nd tmba
de
gene a i dic di e s ,obe iy,di be e m e lt t 1 ,a dibe i ne opa hy,butt t
r tve s s a e
st a t s lius ype I nd a tc ur t
ha
none ofhe i pa r e s o c bi ton o i pa nne s m e t o m e c ly e l t s ve iy
r m im nt r om na i f m i nt
e s r di a l qua s he e rt
ofa lse i r nt J a 2 25.
ny itd mpaime .#. t 42 sheha i tal ale d t ts wasdia edbegi ng Jm e l , 201 butl t ramende he ons tda e
d niily lge ha he
s bl
nni t 5
0
ae
d r e t
t De mbe 21 2011 R.22.
o ce r ,
.
3
Bas d on t e de e bef r her i udi a lt me c le de e a t tpoi ,t
e
he vi nc
o e , ncl ng 1 he di a vi nc t ha
nt he
ALJ de e mi d t t W a ha t r sd l fmci na c pa t t pe f r t f l r nge of
t r ne ha
de d he e i ua t to l a ciy o r o m he ul a
s de a y w or w ih c r a n e e i ,t w i:l he c n lf or c r y up t 1 po m ds c n s t 6
e nt r
k t e t i xc ptons o t t
s a it a r
o 0 t ,a i
holr i a 8zs n n hourw or
kday,and c n s a a or wa k 2 hotr i a 8 hotr w o kda wih t
a t nd nd/
l
ls n n - l r y, t he
opton t at r t sti a sa ng as desr She c onl pe f r oc aso lci ng,
i o lenae itng nd t ndi
ied.
an y r o m c i na lmbi
baa i kneei soopi be ng,couc ng and cawlng (nd)woul mis up t one
lncng, lng, t ng, ndi r hi
r i a
d s
o
wokd pe mont 'J a 25.Ba e ont sRFC,t ALJdeemi d t tW a wa ca bl
r ay r
h. A t
'
s d hi
he
tr ne ha de s pa e
o p ro migh rp s rlv n wok a aj wee a n r lypefr d..z t28 Ac o dn l,
f ef r n e a t ee a t r s e lr s o mal ro me J.a . c r igy
p
t ALJc
he
ondude W a w a notdia edundert Ad .
d de s
s bl
he
A f e t A LJ i s d he de i i n a w hie W ade' r ques f r r vi w was pe ng
t r he
s ue
r c s o nd
l
s e
t o e e
ndi
be o e t Appe l Counc l W ade s itd a to l medial r c ds a evi nce a
f r he
as
i,
ubm te ddii na
c e or nd de , s
des i d be ow. The Appe l Counci sa e t t i c i r d t ne e de e, but
crbe
l
as
l t t d ha t onsde e he w vi nc
no t e sde ed W a sr ques f r vi w wihoutf t rexplnai n.R.1 2.W a tmel
nehels ni
de' e t or e e
t
urhe
a to
de i y
fl t sCom pl i ts e ng r vi w oft A ge y' de s on.
ied hi
a n e ki e e
he
nc s ci i
B.
M edi Evi
cal dence
1.
M edi alEvi nc Be ore t ALJ
c
de e f
he
As t ALJ r cie wih r r t W a s m e c l hit y, s r ceved m e ca
he
e t d t ega d o
de'
di a sor he e i
di l
t e t e a ea l a 2008 r ga di pa n i he ba k.A t a i CT s an i N ove be 2008
r a m nt s ry s
e r ng i n r c
hor c c
c n
m r
r ve l d pos mye ogr m a mid dege r tve dic die s R.457,460.A l
e ae
t l n nd l
ne a i s s a e.
umba CT s n on
r
ca
t s
he nme da e s
t howed de ne atve dic die e,f c ta tr pahy a pa sfa t e oft L4ge r i
s s as a e rl o t nd r r c ur s he
l
L5 S1 lves R.462. l J ua y a Fe ta' 2011,c am a a t d 6 physca t r py
- e l.
n an r nd brzl
y
l i nt tende
i l he a
s s in , ihr s le i s mep o rs o he p i s ae(r m a6 1 t 2 1 )a as me a
e so s wh c e utd n o r g e s n r an c l fo
/ 0 o /0 nd o wh t
i pr d t nk r ng of m oton,whi h alow e he t c pl t da l a tvii w ih de r a e
m ove nl a e
i
c l d r o om e e iy c i tes t c e s d
l ba k pai R .438- A J m e 29,2011 ll ba M l l s n r a e m id s na c nals e i
ow c
n.
52. t
tm r t ca eve l d l pi l a
t nos s
4
an s ve e biae a ne alf r mi na
d e r l tr l ur o n na nowi wih i nge e upon e si 14 ner r t
ng, t mpi m nt
xitng .
ve oo s
a L4 L5 S rc ie a e iu a seo dij ci na t ee o J y whihh le wi t elw
t - . he e ev d n pd r l tr i ne to t h nd f ul, c ep d t h o
h
ba pai rghtl g a hi pai but a a Aug t2011 a nt ntwih Dr He
ck n, i e nd p n,
t n
us
ppoi me
t . mphil her
l,
r gul r phys c a W a s ilc pl i of l f 1 pai A s not W a s o d wor ng an
e a
i i n, de tl om a ned
e t eg n.
ed, de t ppe
ki
d
ha notw or d f o Dec m be 21, 1 t o h t pr e .
s
ke r m
e r 201 hr ug he es nt
Ata J nua y 20,201 c c
a r
2 he kup,Dr He
. mphilis a r por whi h r e e ed a lte
l s ued e t c ef r nc
e tr
f om J m e Vas i M . . a hi opi on t tPl i ifw asnota c ndi t f ba k s ge y. r
r
n s
c k, D , nd s ni ha a ntf
a da e or c ur r D .
He
mphils r por i c t d t t W a sil ha sgnik an pan down he l f 1g a
l' e t ndi a e ha
de tl d i t t i
r e t e nd
r c me d t ts obt i a s c ne os ge y opi on a havene ve c
e om nde ha he an e ond ur ur r
ni nd
r onduc i sudi s
ton t e
pe f m e None he e s bas d i pa ton Dr Va ck' opi o Dr He
ror d.
t ls , e n r
. s i s ni n, . mphili l d i he
l ncude n r
r
epor t t W a c d pr
t ha
de oul obabl r um e w o ki on M a c 1 201 R.597,602.I he de s on,
y es
r ng
r h , 2.
n r ci i
t A LJ g ve ç nt oli w ei t't D r Hem phil sJ nua y 20,201 r por a i pa tc a ,
he
a ç r lng
co
gh ' o .
l' a r
2 e t nd, n r i ul r
t Dr He philso ni n t tPl i ifc dpr bl r um ewor ng i M a c 201 R.28.
o . m l' pi o ha antf oul oba y es
ki n r h 2.
The ne ol ca co ula i Dr He
ur ogi l ns t ton . mphilhad r c
l
e omm e d wa pe f med b Roli
nde
s ror
y ln
J.H a l y,M . .on J nua y 26,201 D r Haw l y s d W a s ne v co
we
D
a r
2. .
e ai
de' r e nduc i s udi a
ton t es nd
EM G ofhe lf l r e r t i c t d s ve e s ns y nezo t He a s opi d t tt
r e t owe xtemiy ndi a e e r e or lr pa hy.
lo ne ha he
cli a ha biae a L5- 1 r di ul t c usng he l w ba k,biae a butoc a lwer
am nt d l tr l S a c opa hy, a i
ro
c
lt r l t k, nd o
e r m iy pan. he di be i ne opahy, . wly s
xte t i For r a tc ur t Dr Ha e uggese c i d bl s rc r
t d ontnue ood uga ontol
a a m uli e B vin i Fo he lz ba r c o t he s
nd
tpl
t m n. r r lm r adi ul pa hy,
ugge t d c e va i ca e of her
s e ons r tve r
l bac i udi we g l sa pa n mediatonsf he r aedpan.SeeR.754ow
k ncl ng i ht os nd i
c i or r elt
i
755.
On Fe ta y 2,201 Dr Vas i i or e W ade t t Dr Ha e s elc rc sud
brz r
2, . ck nf m d
ha . wl y' e tial t y
s
howe di be i ne opa hy i he l re r mii ,whi h ca e num bne sa tnglng down
d a tc ur t n r owe xte tes
c us d
s nd i i
he l gs H e t d hert w o k w ih D r H e philt ke p he bl s rl ve sunde c r a
re .
ol
o r t . m l o e r ood uga e l
r ontol nd
pr ve wor eni ofhe s
e nt s ng
r ympt s R.
om . 769.
5
2.
A ddii
tonalM e c Evi nce Pr e ed t t A ppe s Counc l
di al de
es nt o he
al
i
The a tona e de e t t Pl i if pr en e t t Appeas Cot l c it of
ddii l vi nc ha antf es t d o he
l
mci onsss
m e c lr or fom Aprlt oug Oc o r201 i udi a r c d of W a sr t n vii t
di a ec ds r
i hr h t be
2, ncl ng e or
de' e ur st o
D r H e philon A pr l1 201 l st n t ee we a t t A LJ' de i i n.A tt ttm e,D r
. m l
i 6, 2, es ha hr
eks fer he
S c so
ha i
.
He
mphilopi d t tpl i ifwa tcea l i pai a cn
l ne ha antf s ll ry n n nd nnotwo k c r ty. R.776.Shealo
r uren l '
'
s
r f re pli tf t s Dr Cannouc f a ce vi ls na e l to a t o an a s ond
e e r d a n if o ee .
he or
r ca/pi l vauai n nd o bt i
ec
ne os ge y opi on.
ur ur r
ni
Shorl t r fe ,on Apr l20,201 a M R I of W a s ce v ca s ne w a pe f m e
ty he ea tr
i
2, n
de' r i l pi
s r or d,
whih wa a s s
c
s lo ubmitd a ne e de e.R.771 7 The M Rls
te s w vi nc
- 2.
howed de ne ai c ng
ge r tve ha es
epe ily a C5C6a d C6 C7 f c t on a tztsa C4 5a tro a d p seiro to h o i
s cal t - n - ; a e j it rh ii t - neir n o tro se p ytss
a C5 C6 wih br d dic ose
t t oa s t ophyt co plx c usng s
e m e a i ome i pr s i on c d a m i c nta
m e son
or nd d e r l
c na nar wi a modeael tsdeda s veerghtsdedfr mi lnar wi J=
a l ro ng; nd
rt ef i nd e r i -i o n na ro ng./.
The r co dsalo i l aJ y 3, 2 r por fo Dr Ca mouc who i a orhopedi
e r s ncude ul 201 e t r m . r
he,
s n t
c
slge Dr Ca mouc r viwe W a ' r c ntdignosi t t a opi d t tW ades f r d
tr on. . r
he e e d de s e e
a tc ess nd ne ha
ufe e
fom a he i t dik and t t s ge y woul i f t he p he .Dr Ca m o he alo e i ty
r
m aed s
ha ur r
d n ac l r . r uc
s xplcil
sae t a h rv e d Dr Vack' n t a dt a h ç ia r ed wi tes g sin ta t r
ttd h t e e iwe . s i s o e n h t e t sg e g) t h ug eto h t hee
d
h
i no s g c lteamen .She has a s ne de onniy,m ode a e t s ve e se i a 14- a
s
uz i a r t t
pi
f t
r t o e r t noss t , 5 nd
s ver f a i lna r ng a L4- ' R.798.Dr Ca m o he a s not t tPl ntf co d no
e e or m na rowi t 5.
'
. r uc lo ed ha ai if ul t
sa u i a wa i co i r bl pan. i.
t nd prght nd s n nsde a e i J
.
11
1.
DI
SCUSSI
ON
Pl ntf a guest tt a tonale de e s s itd t t Ap a s Co lc ss
ai if r
ha he ddii
vi nc he ubm te o he pe l unci a t
gr doubt on t ALJ' tndi t t Pl i if wa not dia ed.As t Fourh Cic tha
ave
he
S i ng ha antf s
s bl
he
t r ui s
e a ne w he a tonale de i s i t t a c i r by t Appe l Counc l but
xpl i d, n ddii
vi nce s ubm ted o nd ons de ed
he
as
i,
r vi w i none hel s de e a c t m us co i r t en ie a i sr tve r or i udi
e e s
t es ni d, our
t ns de he tr dm ni t a i ec d, ncl ng
6
t addii na e de
he
to l vi nce,t deer ne whehe t ALJ' de son i s
o t mi
t r he
S cii s uppore by s t nta
td
ubsa il
e de e. iki v.Se y Dep . He t & Huma Ser s,953F. 93, - ( h Ci.1 )
vi nc W l ns c'
t of a1h
n v.
2d 9596 4t r 991.
Th pa t s a r e t a,t j tf a rma d f r c nsd r to o ne e d n e t
e ri g e h t o usiy e n o o ie ain f w vie c , he
e
e de mus beç w andmaeil'SeeECF No.1 a 5(ii W iki ,953F. a 95-6)
vi nce t t
ne
tra.'
3 t ctng l ns
2d t 9 ;
ECF No.11 a 3 (r ui t evi nc s mitd t t a asc
t a g ng he de e ub te o he ppe l ounci wasbot ( w a
l
hE
ne nd
matra' Ase ai d byt FourhCicui,çll de ei new ...i i i notduplc tveo
eil). xpl ne
he
t r t sevi nc s
ft s
iai r
cz ai ...( i maeili t r i ar s na epos i lt t tt ne e de ewoul
tmultve
and) s tra f he e s ea o bl sbiiy ha he w vi nc
d
ha c nge t out
ve ha d he come. W iki ,953 F. a 96.l mus as ç eaeg t t pei on or
' l ns
'
2d t t t lo ç lt j o he rod
r
be or t da eoft ALJ' dec son. l
f e he t
he
S ii ' d.
'
The Age y c e t tt a tonale de e he e doe no r lt t t r lva
nc ont nds ha he ddii
vi nc r
s t ea e o he ee nt
tm e pe i a f t ra g t tt addii le de e i notmatra bec us i woul not
i
rod, nd urhe r ues ha he
tona vi nc s
eil a e t
d
ha c nge t dec s o oft A LJ Se ECF N o.1 a 1 5- As e ai d he e n,ne t rof
ve ha d he i i n he
. e
3 t , 6.
xpl ne r i
ihe
t ear um e si pe s sveon t s ct f t he e.
hes g nt s rua i
he pe ik ac s r
Fis, at
r t lhough t e mi tons a t t co ane i t ne e denc a itdl
he xa nai
nd ess nt i d n he w vi e dm te y
oc ur e a t rt A LJ Sde i i i i c ea t tt r l t t i pa r e st tW a ha d i
c r d f e he
' c son, t s l r ha hey e a e o m i m nt ha
de d ur ng
t r lva pe i as we l a t s ve iy of a r src i
he ee nt rod,
l s he e rt - nd e titons ne s ia e by t e
ce st t d - hos
i imen s I pa tc a ,M s W a s i ime s di notoc ur over gh ( d i t
mpar t . n riulr . de' mpar nt d
c
ni t or urng he
c l s o a fw we k o l l e n mo t ) Th s t e e n w tss a d o ii n fo h r
oz e f e
r
e s r i y ve nhs. u , h s e et n pn o s r m e
ke
te tng physcansr a e ba k t t r l va tme pe i See e. ,Re ds v.Asnz 2008
rai
i i elt c o he e e nt i
rod. . 2. ynol
t e,
W L 3 08 3,* ( . Va 2 0 )( o ig ta e i e c fo t mo t s bsq e tt t
91 3 3 W D. . 0 8 n tn h t v d n e rm he nhs u e u n o he
d cso o t eALJweerlv n t tep ro o tmea j iae b t ALJwh r t eewa
e iin f h
r ee a t o h e id f i dudc td y he
ee h r s
no basst çs
i o tuppor
t
.t ase ton t t (he cli nts ba k co ton c nge t a
he s ri ha t ama ') c ndii ha d o ny
a e ibl de e i ghajt e o f l mont pei 'a whe e a M lletbls ng dic
ppr ca e gre n t t hre r otr
h rod' nd r n t sa ihi s
h r ain wa c mp ee te st a t mo ts' fe t eALJSde iinl ç s r v Asr e
enito s o ltd ç s h n wo nh 'a tr h
l
' cso ; f Bid . tu ,
7
6 9F.d 3 7 3 0 ( t Ci.2 2 (ç dc le au to sma ea tracama tsi t e sau
9 3 3 , 4 4h r 01 ) t ia v lain d fe li n ' nsl d tts
Me
r
has expie a e no a oma i ly ba r d fo c i r ton a m a be r lva t pr a
r d r t ut tcal re r m onsde ai nd y
ee nt o ove
d sbit aii gbeo et edama ts( t o ls i t e )' .
ia l y rsn f r h i n ' dae f at nsl d .)
i
r '
TheCour a s fndst onvi ng t Comm isonersa gu e st tt ne e de e
t lo
mc nci he
s i ' r m nt ha he w vi nc
i notma e i .Not bl i he de ii t ALJ ga çc r lng we g ' t Dr Hemphils
s
t ral
a y, n r c son he
ve çontoli
i ht' o .
l'
opi on ( e e s i J nuay 201 t tW adeco d pr bl rt n t wor i M ac l
ni as xpr sed n a r
2) ha
ul oba y eur o k n rh. n
Aprl howeve ,Dr He phils opi on,bas d on ne i or a i had c
i,
r . m l' ni
e
w nf m ton,
hange Be a e t
d. c us he
ALJdi no ha t te de ,and be us t AppeasCot ldi no c i ri,t r i no
d t ve ha vi nce
ca e he
l
mci d t onsde t he e s
w a f t s Co tt deer ne whehe -orhow-t Age y woul ha r c ie t s t
y or hi ur o t mi
t r
he
nc
d ve e onc ld he e wo
o ni .
pi ons
Si ia l t ne e de i l d Dr Ca m ouc s opi on t tW ade s f e f o
m l ry, he w vi nce nc ude
. r
he'
ni ha
uf er d r m
ahe ni t dik a t ts ge y woul i f c he p he . .Ca mouchealo e iil sa e t t
r aed s nd ha ur r
d n a t l r Dr r
s xplcty t t d ha
he rviwe Dr Va ck' n t a d t a h ç ia re d wi te s g sin t a t ee i n
e e d . s i s oe n h t e k s g e g ) t h ug eto h t h r s o
d
h
s g c lte t e .She has a s ne de or t m ode a e t s ve e se i a 14- a s ver
ur i a r am nt
pi
f miy,
r t o e r t noss t . 5 nd e e
f mni lna
or na now i a L4- ' R .798.M or ve ,Dr Ca m ouc not t t Pl i if c d not
ng t 5.
'
eo r . r
he ed ha a ntf oul
sa u i and was i consde a e pan.I Agan,t r i not ng i t Age y' fnal
t nd prght
n
i r bl i d. i he e s hi n he
nc s i
opi on t i c t s how t r c l Dr Ca mouc sopi on wih Dr Vas k' orwhy Dr
ni hat ndia e
o e oncie . r
he' ni
t . ci s
.
Va ck s dha be n c e t d i t d ofDr Cn mouc .
s i houl ve e r die nsea
. r
he
Addii lysone oft r as t tt ALJdico t d W ade' c
tona l
he e ons ha he
s un e
s ompl n sofpan wa
ait
i s
be us oft f tt tDr Vas k' sa e e t ts di notnee s g r R.27- M u of
ca e he ac ha . ci s tt m nt ha he d
d ur e y.
28. ch
t ne e de e,howe r s
he w vi nc
ve , uppors Pl i ifs c
t antf ompl i s ofpan a sgniia l bolt s
ant
i nd i fc nty ser
Pl n if sc edi lt on t s is Thus whe pr e t d wih t sne e de e,t ALJ ma
aitf r biiy
hi s ue.
, n es n e t hi w vi nc he
y
w e lm a a dif r ntdec son.Si iary,t A LJ s d t r w a no e de ofpr bl m s wih
l ke
fe e
ii
m l l he
ai he e s
vi nce
o e
t
W a sn msorha and t dic mt d he t si ony t ts ha d fk uly wih ha pai
de' r
nds
hus s ot e r e tm
ha he d it t t nd n.
8
R.28.Butt addii lme c evi nc i f c s
he
tona dial de e n a t uppors he c am t the ha an n ms
t r l i ha r nds d r
mi htha bee a f t d be us i s
g
ve n fec e ca e t howe s had ahe nit d c vi ldik,whi h c d c us
d he
r a e er ca s
c oul a e
we knes ,numbne s pai ortnglngi t nr a ha . eR.
a
s
s , n i i n he ms nd nds Se 798.
l t r s ofw he he r m a i war a ed,t s c e i a n t M e r v.A s nl ,i whi h
n em
t r e nd s
r nt hi as s ki o ye
t e n
c
t eFo t Cic i c n l e t a ar ma dwa p o e . 6 F.d 7 0 (t Ci. 01 ) l M e e,
h urh rut o cud d h t e n s r p r 6 2 3 0 4 h r 2 1 .n y r
a he e,t ne evi nce i l d ar por fom a teai physcan t tcon r di td t ALJ'
s r he w de
ncude e t r
r tng
i i ha
ta ce he
S
de ii n ofnon- s biiy.TheM e rc t ea o d:
c so
dia lt
ye our r s ne
The e de e i t s c e,howeve ,i no asone sde ast ti
vi nc n hi as
r s t
-i d
ha n
rt rc s sprv o sy ds u s d .On c nsd rto o ter c r
ohe a e e i u l ic se )
o i eai n f h e o d
a a whol we sm pl c nnot de e m i whe he s t tal
s
e,
i y n
t r ne
t r ubsan i
e de e s
vi nc uppo t t ALJS de a of be ft he e. The ALJ
rs he
' nil
ne is r
e a sz t tt r or be or i lc ç e ti tonspl e on
h pha i ed ha he ec d f e t a ked ç srci
r
ac d
t cai a t by a teai physca ' s
he l m n
r tng
i in, ugge tng t t t s
'
si
ha hi
e d ta y ga plyed a r e i isde son.M e rs e nty
vi en i r p a
ol n t cii
ye ubs que l
obt i d t s m i s ng e de e f o hi tea i phys c a That
a ne hi s i vi nc r m s r tng
i i n.
e d e c r a es t opi o of Dr W eis as ,whi h t
vi enc orobor t he ni n
.
s gl s
c he
ALJha rj ce Bu oh rr c r e ie e ce i d b t ALJ
d ee td. t t e e o d vd nc r dt y he
e
c lc s w ih t ne e de e. The A ppe s Counc l m a t
onfi t t he w vi nc
al
i de he
ne e de e pa tof t r co d but sl a iy de e r vi w of
w vi nc r
he e r
lmm rl nid e e
t A LJ dec son.Thus no f c f nde ha m a a fndi as t
he
ii
, a t i r s de ny i ngs o
t tea i phys c an' o ni or a t m pt d t r onc l t
he r tng
i i s pi on
te e o ec ie hat
e de e wih t confi tng a s
vi nc
t he
lci
nd uppori e de e i t
tng vi nc n he
r c d. A s es i t pr tve val of com pe i e denc i
e or
s s ng he oba i
ue
tng vi e s
qui es e ily t r e oft f tfnde .W e ca
nt s nta l he ol
he ac i r
nnott ra i
mde tke t
i t frt i t nc The ef e, we mus r m a t c e f
n he is nsa e. r or
t e nd he as or
f rhe f tfndi
u t r ac i ng.
662 F. a 707.
3d t
Si ia l t Co tco l s t t t ca e a ba r quies r m a The ne e de e
m l r y, he ur nc ude ha he s t r e r e nd.
w vi nc
i l
ncudes a r por fom a te tng physc a t s me one t tt ALJ as i
e tr
r ai
ii n, he n
ha he
sgned t ontoli
i r lng
c
weght't wih r ga d t he ea le r por.Tha physcin bele d W ade woul be a e t
i ' o t e r o r ri r e t
t
ia
ive
d
bl o
retl t w or att tm e oft ALJ' deci on,buti a r
lrn o
k he i
he
S
si
n eporti ued l t t ee w eeks aft
ss
ess han hr
er
t ALJ S de son, sa e t t W a cea l c d not wor Furher e, t a to l
he
' cii
t t d ha
de l ry oul
k. t mor he ddii na
e de efom Dr Camouc (ncudi hi opi ont tPli ifha ahenit dica wa a
vi nc r
. r
he i l ng s ni ha antf d r aed s nd s
9
c n i ae f rslg r )c n lcswi Dr Va ck' e rirrp r. noe tssDr Camo c e
a d d t o t e y o fit t . s i s ale e o tAs td, et . r u h
r
h
r viwed as a wer s e of t ALJ' quesi a t whehe W ade' compl nt we e
e e
lo ns
om
he
S
tons s o
t r
s
ai s r
c e bl
r di e.
i ngs
o he r i
l s o t j s a i Me e ,ûno f ct fnder has m ade any fndi as t t teatng
n h r, u t s n y r t a i
e ed o e
l ha
de
t he
lc i
physca s k wl opi on or attm pt t r concie t t evi nce w ih t confi tng and
iin' ne
ni
s
uppori e de i t r co d'and t sCour Gc nnotunde tke's h a a s s nt( n t
lng vi nce n he e r '
hi
t sa
ra ' uc n s es me t he
i
frtisa c .S ej, s eas sec.Bu tn v Cov n 2 3 W L 3 51 2 ,* ( S. J l 1 ,
is n tn e e . ; e lo . , ro . li , 01
(
.
1
5 1 0 3 D. C. u y 1
2013 (Qn lg oft ne e denc t ta ast co lc wihoneo mor c iia ba e i t
) 6I iht he w vi e ha ppe r o ntit t
r e rtc l s s n he
A LJ S opi on,a t l c of e a ton by t A ppe l Cot c la t why t tne e de e
'
ni nd he a k
xpl na i
he
as m i s o
ha w vi nc
di nota f Pl ntf' dia lt de e mi ton,t c tc
d
fed ai ifs s biiy t r nai he our anno s y t tt ALJ' decson i
t a ha he
S ii s
s pp re b s b tn il v d n e' 3
u o td y u sa ta e i e c .
l.
I .
V
C O N C LUSI N
O
For t f eg ng r as ,t s Cour REVERSES t de e n ' fnalde son a
he or oi e ons hi
t
he f nda ts i
cii nd
REM ANDS f rf rherpr e di plrua t s ntncefurof42U. C.j405( .TheCour
o ut
oc e ngs zs nt o e e o
S.
g)
t
a s DENI t Comm isone ' M oto f Summa y J
lo
ES he
s i rs
i n or
r udgme ,ECF N o.1 a GI NTS
nt
2, nd G
t Pl i if sM oton f Sm nm a y J
he a ntf '
i or
r udgm ent ECF N o.1 A n a o i t or r s li s t s
,
0.
ppr pr a e de hal s ue hi
da
y.
3 Tot e e tt tW adea g st tt Appe sCot lwasdet e f no dic sngt ne
he xt n ha
r ue ha he
al mci
kint or t s us i he w
evi nce t Cour dia e .Thede son oft AppeasCouncli c e t ti di r viw t a tonal
de , he
t s gr es
cii
he
l
i ndiats ha t d e e he ddii
e ie c Wa sb t d b t o eheesd ne rviw. e R.12( tc o Ap e l Comcl to (l
vd n e de u mit , u n n t ls e id e e se - Noie f p as t iAcin) ûn
e
d
l ng a yourca e, consde e t r as nsyo dia e wiht decson a t a tonale de elsedon
ooki t
s we
i r d he e o
u s gre t he ii nd he ddii
vi nc it
t e l e Or rofAppe sComcl .W f mdt tt si or ton doe notpr deabassf rc ngi t
he ncos d de
al t i.
ot ha hi nf mai
s
ovi
i o ha ng he
( 'Id cso '. eAp e l Co n i' fiuet dsus t a dto l vd n ei a ydealh we e,sn t
ALJS e iin.) Th p as u cls alr o ic she d iina e ie c n n ti, o v r i o a
'
gr dsf r r a orr ma W hie imi havebe n hel t t t sCou thadt AppeasCounclex ai d is
oun or eve s l e nd. l t ght
e pfl o hi
l
r
he
l
i pl ne t
detr nai t r i nos h r quie nti
emi ton, hee s uc e r me mpos d o t Appe sCo i wher i de e r viw.Se M e r 6
e n he
al uncl
e t nis e e
e ve, 62
F.da 7 50 (h r g ltr sh meo teAc d e n t e ur teAp e l Comcloat uaei rao sfr
3 t 0 -6 te e uao y c e fh t o s o rq ie h p as t it ri lt t e sn o
c
s
d n i rve e e wheei c n iesne e ie e at u hs ha a ayssi ud(e h lf lo p r o e o
e yng e iw v n r t o sd r w vd nc , l g uc n n l i ç l b l ep u fr up s s f
ho
wo
j dca rviw'.
u iile e '
)
The Cl k i dieced t s d copis oft s M e or ndum Opi on a ac ompa ng
er s r t o en
e
hi
m a
ni nd c
nyi
Or t a1c
der o 1 ouns lofr co d.
e
e r
A
ENTER:Ths.va o Auut2 1.
i:? y f g s 03
s
,
esC. k
Tur
Se orUnie St t sDiti J ge
ni
t d a e src ud
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?