Karavias v. Commonwealth of VA et al

Filing 34

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 7/26/2013. (tvt)

CLERK' OFFI U. DI .
S
CE S, ST COURT
AT M NVI E,
LL VA

I T EU IE SA E DSRC C U T
N H NT D T T S IT IT O R
FO R TH E W ESTER N D I
STR I O F VI G I A
CT
R NI
R O A NO K E D I I O N
V SI

j 2LX Wt E'j
'g
zg
2
UL

BY:

E C RK
Y
*

D

JA SO N S.K AR AVI S, l
A l,
Pl nt f ,
ai i f

cu K

Ci lA c i N o.7: 2- vvi t on
1 c 00624

M EM O R AND U M O PI O N
NI

COM M ONW ER TH OF VA,e aI,
t .
D ef ndant .
e
s

By:

H on.Jac t on L . i e
ls
K sr
Se or U nie St t D i t i tJudge
ni
t d a es s r c

J on S. z vi s aVigi ai aepr e ng pr K ,fl d aci lrght a ton pur ua
as
Ka a a , r ni nm t oc edi
o
ie
vi i s c i
s nt

t 4 U. C. 1 3wi ti dcinv se i 28U. C. 1 4 .Plitf iiil n me a
o 2 S. j 98 t u s ito e td n
hj
S. j 3 3 an if n tal a d s
y
dee nt t Commonwe 1hofVigi a Core i Ofke (ç O' D. r r a Nure
fnda s he
at
r ni, rctonal t r I ' Fame, nd s
C/ )

W ht, n Ip e o syd s se camsa an t reW ht wi o t rj d c a dtr nae
ita d rviu l imisd li g i s Nu s it t u p eu ie n emi td
h
he a ad fnd n , u s a tt 28U. C. 1 5 e( )B)i a d j1 5 b ( ) P an if
r s ee a tp ru n o
S. j 91 ()2 ( (i n 91 A( )1. litf
)
a l ge t tC/ Fa rus e es i f c ,i vi a i oft Ei ht A m e
le s ha O nne ed xc s ve or e n ol ton he g h
ndm e oft
nt he

Unie Stt sConsiuton.TheComm onweat ofVigi a a C/ Fa m e tl am o i f
td ae
tt i
1h
r ni nd O r r ied
ton or

s mmayj dg n ;h c u t n ee is tc , ls n t Ro e o ov. rio 5 8F.d 3 9
u r u me t te o r e trd t Noie pt ua t o s b r Gars n, 2 2 0
r
(t Ci.1 ) a t c tne rcevedaflngfom pli ift tt Clr dockee a a
4h r 975 ; nd he our xt e i
ii r
antf ha he ek
td s

r s ns i o p sto t d fn a t ' to f rs mma yj d me t Be a s tec s wa
epo e n p o i n o ee d n s mo in o u r u g n . c u e h a e s
i
c i r rpe f di pos ton,lr vi w e t r c d a g a t de e nt m oton f
ons de ed i or s ii
e e d he e or nd r n ed f nda s' i or

sl r j g n .In tdi t eM e rn l Opn o t a tedo u n d c ee a
t
mmay ud me t o e n h mo a dz ii n h t h c me t o k td s
m
plitf srs o s i o p iint t es mmayj d me tmo ind dno c n anv rfe
an if e p n e n p osto o h u r u g n to i t o ti e iid
e de e a t , r le on t ve ii d Com pl i t oppos t e denc s
vi nc , nd hus I e i d
he rt e
a nt o
e he vi e uppori
tng

d fn a t' to f rsl yj g n .
ee d n s moin o l
mmm' ud me t
Howe r t c tha now rceve pli ifsmotonf s
ve ,he our s
e i d antf
i or ummmyj
udgmen a
t nd
a fda t w hi h he a l gedl s gne on J y 11 201 a wihi t tm e pe m it by t
f i vi, c
le y i d
ul , 3, nd t n he i
r ted
he

c tsRos bor notc A s a c tcu tng m e tr i r pons t t c r tbudge a y
our '
e o i e.
os- ti
asle n es
e o he ur en
tr

e r e , heClr r c nty t r na e t pos ofk ebox t whi h pl i ifs nthi m o i
nvionm nt t
e k e e l e mi t d he t t
o c antf e s ton

f rs mma yj d me t a dr -o tn o temal e utdi t ed lyf risd l r t te
o u r u g n , n er u ig f h i r s le n h ea o t ei y o h
ve

Clr sOfi e Be a eplitf i e tte t h v h smoinf rs mmayj dg n a d
ek' fc . c us anif s nild o a e i to o u r u me t n
a tdavi co i r d i lg oft docke i a pos a de ay,Iva a e t prorM e or ndum
fi t ns de e n i ht he
tng nd t l l
c t he i
m a

Opi on a Or r Bec us eve wih t ne e de epli tf i note il d t r i ,Ig an
ni nd de . a e n t he w vi nc a n if s
ntte o elef r t

d fn a t'a dd n p an ifsmo in frs mmayj d me t
ee d n s n e y litf
to s o u r u g n .
1
.

Dee a t p e e t h f l wi f csi s p o t ft ermoinf rsl r j d me t
fnd n s r sn t e ol ng a t n u p r o h i to o l
o
mmay u g n .
On Nove
mber1 2011 C/ Gi on a C/ Buc na r tived l h ta fo e h i ae
4,
, O bs nd O
ha n ere
unc r ys r m ac nm t

i p anifsp da t eRe On o S aePrs n(ROS '. Toa c mpiht i ts t o t r
n litf o t h d i n tt io E P' 1 c o ls hs a k,he fke s
C
)
us atr y sotbox, whi h i am ealbox wih a o n sdepl c a i tac ldoo a
ed t a l
t
' c s
'
t
t n pe i a ed gans el r nd

a hersd t tha ahi ed l t s cte ie si i .2 The ta so box i afi d t t ta
not i e ha s ng ock o e tr tm nsde
r y lt
s fxe o he r y
s oton a ce ldoorby l e i t tay s o i o t bo a by s i ng t t p oft box ove t
l
l
ow rng he r l t nt he x nd
ldi he o
he
r he

ta sotlt h. Theta sotbox t n be omesaba e bewee t i t a sa fde piet
ry l ac
r y- l
he c
ni r t n he nma e nd t f s t he
ope ta so on t c l door
n r y l t he e l
.
W he C/ Gi on putt t a s otbox on pl i if s doo t r t i ve pl i i f sl
n O bs
he r y- l
a ntf
r o ere
a ntf unch

ta pl i ifsuc hi handsi i t box. C/ Gi o o de e pl ntf t r m ovehi ha
r y, antf t k s
nsde he
O bs n r r d ai if o e
s nds

1RO SP i co i r a t d i srtveLong Tem Segr to Uni,'m ea ngt tm os ofisi ats lke
s nsde ed n ç m nitai
A
r
egain t ' ni ha
t t nm e , i
pli if a eke i t rsnglantf, r pt n hei i e bunkcel f ra oxi t yt nt hr holspe da Thi t ofs c e
ls o ppr mael we pt ee tr r y. s ype e ur
housngi de i
i s sgnedf t VDOC' mos vi e o defa i t .
or he
S t olnt r int nmaes
2I e e tngl , onl pl ntf des rbest t a sotbo aswei ng t ry- i pounds Pl i tf doe note a n
nt r s i y y ai if c i he r y- l x
ghi hit fve
. anif s
xpl i
how heknow show muc t box weghs a Leve- i aesa RO SP ar notper it t w akar
h he
i , nd
ls nm t t
e
m ted o l oundt pod
he
wih t boxt fedot ri aes Plitf ' knowldgeoft bo sw eghtc d oc by,f e
t he
oe
he nm t . an ifs
e
he x' i oul cur
or xampl lfi o
e,itng r
pus ngt boxof ofaceldoor
hi he
f
l
.

2

f om t box,butpl ntf e u e a t i d t knoc t box oft ce ldoor C/ G i o ca l d
r he
ai ifr f s d nd re o
k he
he l
. O bs n le
C/ Fn m e f as i t nc bec us C/ Fa m e w a a s ni of i e w ho w a a hor z t c r y
O r r or ss a e a e O r r s e or f c r
s ut i ed o a r
pe rs a W he C/ Fn m e a rve a t c l he s w pl i if s a m si t ta sot
ppe pr y.
n O r r r i d t he el, a
a ntf ' r n he r y l ,
t yi t pus t ta s o box f om t door s w pl i ifhol ng wha l
r ng o h he r y- l t
r he
, a a ntf
di
t ooke lke a pl s i
di
a tc

ba a he r pli ift z a e t t ow f eson t ofie s C/ Fa m e ti d t r ta h t
g, nd a d antf h e t n o hr ec
he fc r . O r r re o eat c he
bo t t doo s ve a tm e t s clet ba re be wee t ofk e sandpl n if sa m s
x o he r e r l i s o e tr he ri r t n he t r
aitf r .
Alhoughpli ifc i
t
antf ontnued t pus t bo a y fom t door C/ Far rwasuli ael
o h he x wa r he
, O
me
tm t y
a et l k t ta sotcos d afe s c i t ta sotbo
bl o oc he r y l l e tr e urng he r y- l x.
Pl i ifm e el a lgesi t ve ii Co pl ntt tC/ Fn me r peaedl hi
antf r y le
n he rted m ai ha O r r e t y t
pli ifsa msa ha wih t bo c usng br n fnge s bnzs s a s r pes Pl i if
antf r nd nds t he x, a i
oke i r , ie , nd c a . antf
a gue t tt s f c w ase e s ve be us pl ntf wasl ke i i a ce l a he r
r s ha hi or e
xc s i
ca e ai if
oc d ns de
l, nd
eque t
ss

$ 00 0i d ma e .I hi afd vii s p o t fhsmo inf rsl r j d me tplitf
3 ,0 n a g s n s fia tn u p r o i to o l
mmay u g n , an if
ad isha ng hi ha i i t ta sotbox, hedoesnotdenytyi t dil
m t vi s nds nsde he r y- l
but
r ng o sodget ta
he r ysotbox fom t doo .Pl i ifde e t tapl tcbagoff ese se but no a y,doe not
l
r he r antf ni s ha
asi
ec xit d , t bl
s
a rt thene rtle e d t t o f eson sa f
ve ha
ve lr atne o hr w ec
tf.

II.
A.

A p ry i e t ldt s mma yj d me ti t epe dng ,h ds o ey a dd sl s r
a t s ni e o u r u g n f h la i s te ic v r n ico u e
t
m a e il on fl,a a afi viss
t ra s ie nd ny fda t how t tt r i no ge nedipu e a t a m aera f c .
ha he e s
nui s t s o ny t il a t

Fe R. v. 5 () M aeil a t aet o en c s ayt e tbiht ee n so apat s
d. Ci P. 6 a . tra f cs r h s e e sr o sa l he lme t f ry'
s
ca eofa ton.Andes v. be t Lo l ,477U. 242, ( 986 .A ge neis of
us ci
ron Li ry bbvsnc.
S. 248 1 )
nui sue
m a e i lf c e s si , n vi w i t r cor a al r as bl i e e s dr wn t r f o i a
t r a a t xi t f i e ng he e d nd l e ona e nf r nce a he e r m n

lg m os f vor bl t t noni ht t a a e o he
movi pa t ar as bl f tfnde c dr tu' ave ditf
ng ry, e ona e ac-i r oul et n
r c or

t non- o n .L. Themovi pa t hast bur n ofs ng tha t r i a abs nc of
he
m va t ds
,
ng ry
he de
howi t t he e s n e e
t
e de e t s
vi nc o uppor t nonm ovi pa t sca e ' Cel e Cor v.Ca r t , U . 31 325
t he
ng ry' s .' ot x
p.
te t 477 S. 7,

( 986) l t mova ts tsi st sbur n,he t no mova mus s tf t s cfc
1 . f he
n aite hi de t n he n- nt t e orh pe ii,
a s i ef c st tdemonsr t t e se e ofage ne is off c f ti .I a 322dmisbl a t ha
ta e he xit nc
nui s ue a t or ral d. t
23;

s eW iln v Grfi 95 F.d8 0 8 3( t Ci.1 91 ( oigalg to i av rfe
e l ms . ifn, 2 2 2 , 2 4h r 9 ) n tn l ains n eiid
i
e
c
ompl i ba ed onpe s lkno e a e t e valntofa o
ant s
r ona
wl dge r he qui e
n pposng a fda tf sl a y
i fi vi or tmm r

j d me t u po e) A p ryi e tte t s mmayj d me t f h r c r a awh l c udn t
u g n p r s s. a t s n i d o u r u g n i t e e o d s oe o l o
l
lada r tona tiroff tt fnd i f voroft no m ova . W ila s 952 F. a 823. A
e
a i l re
ac o i n a
he nnt lim ,
2d t
pa t tc nnotcr a eagenui i s ofm a e i f c tlough m e es c a i ort buidi of
ry ln
et
ne s ue
t ral a t lr
r pe ul ton he l ng

o i e e euponanot r' Be ev. r 769F. 21 21 ( hCi.1 .The eor,
ne nfr nc
he . al Hadv,
'
2d 3, 4 4t r 985) r f e

çml r t u po tds c ain. .sn te o g t d f a aml r j d me t to .
t e e ms p re pe ulto . i o n u h o ee t mmay u g n moi n'
l
'
En i v. tlAs ' o Bu . Ed c Ra i. n .5 F.d5 , 2( t Ci. 9 5 .
n s Na' sn f s & u . do l c, 3 3 5 6 4h r 1 9 )
B.

Pli ifc nnotrco rdn gesa ns deenda si a ofiilca ciyvi j1 3.
antf n
e ve ma gai t f nt n n fca pa t a 98
N et asa enorisofi i sa tng i t i ofk i lc pa ii a epe s f rpup os of
iher t t
t fcal c i n her t a a ctes r r ons o
es

j1
983.W ilv. ihi nDe tofStt Polc 491U. 58( 989) c di y,Fnme , n
l M c ga p'
ae ie,
S. 1 .Ac or ngl r r whe
s i a ofi ilc pa iy,a t Comm onweat ofVigi a a ei mt fo t ss t 1
ued n n fca a ct nd he
1h
r ni r m me r m hi ui. d.
C.

C/ Fa me a gue t tt e es i f cec am a s re agans hi i a i vi l
O r r r s ha he xc sve or l i s e td i t m n n ndi dua

c pact i ba e byt docrneofqualfe i miy.Quaii di
a iy s n'd he ti
iid mmt t
lte mmuniype mis
t r t
4 r me ofki spef mi dicei r fmcins...(obe s el dfom la lt f
t n nt t al ror ng s rtonay t to
gove
t 1 hi de r ibiiy or
c vi dn a i of ra t i c
i l m ges ns a s her onduc doesnotvi ae cea l esa ihed saut yor
t
olt l ry t bls
t t or
4

c tt i rght ofwhih ar as bl pe s woul haveknown.
onsiutonal i s
c e ona e r on
d
' row v. t r l
'Ha l
Fizge a d,

457U. 800,81 ( 982) Quaiidi miypr d i
S.
8 1 . lfe mmt t ovies mmuniyfom s trt t namee
t r ui aher ha
r
de e et la lt Thus whet ra de e
f ns o ibiiy.
,
he
f ndan ca c am q lfe i mt t i apur que ton
t n l i uaii d m miy s
e si

o 1w a di p o el d tr n dp era.S u irv. t, 3 U. 1 4 2 0 01( 0 )
f a n s r p ry eemie rtil a ce Kaz 5 3 S. 9 , 0 - 2 01,
o ruld pqohe g omd h P as nv. la a , 5 U.. 2 ( 0 9 ( e tiglwe c t t
ve r e
t r r t s y e ro Calh n 5 5 S 2 3 2 0 ) p nnit o r ol s
n
r
.

t dicetont deenni whihqualfe i
he sr i o t ne c
iid mmuniypr t a l efrt.
t ong o nayz is)
Onc ade e ntr s st q lfe i muniy de e e,apl n ifbe r t btr n t
e
f nda aie he uaii d m
t f ns
aitf a s he lde o
s
how t ta de e n ' c
ha
f nda t s onduc vi a ed t pl i if sr ght H e ly v. ne l 501 F. 374,
t ol t he a ntf i . rr Pur l,
3d

3 8(t Ci. 0 7 .çf eu lwf l e sofhea to mu tb a pae t e a s se fo t e
7 4 h r 2 0 ) s' na u n s t cin s e p rn wh n se s d r m h
-h
p rp ci o a o j ciey ra o a eo fca c a g dwihk o e eo etbl h dlw.
e s e tve f n b e tv l e s n bl fiil h r e t n wldg f sa i e a '
s
'
Lo zv. bns n, 4F.d4 6 4 9( t Ci.1 9 ) s eAn e s nv. eg t n, 3U. 6 5
pe Ro i o 91 2 8 , 8 4h r 9 0 ; e d ro Cr iho 48 S. 3 ,
6 ( 9 7 (i-i i n t os yt a a o tca a to i p o e tdb q lfe i mi u ls
40 1 8 ) çl s s o t a h t n fi il cin s r tce y uaiid mmt t n e s
-h
y
t ve y aci n i quesi ha pr vi l bee hel t a u ... i i t s yt ti t lg
he r to n
ton s e ousy n d mlwf l but t s o a ha n he i ht

o p e e itn 1w teu lwf l s mus bea p r n .l s eas Ed r sv Ci of ls o o
f r -x sig a h na une s t p ae t'; e lo wad . t God b r ,
'
y
1 8F.d2 , 51( t Ci.1 9 )(ttn ce ry etb ihe 1w i t eFout Cic i rfr t
7 3 31 2 4h r 9 9 saig lal sa ls d a n h t' rut ee s o
h
de i i oft Supr e Co toft U nie St t s t Co tofAppe l f t Fo t Cic t
c s ons he
em
ur
he t d a e , he ur
a s or he urh r ui,

a dtehihe t o r o tesaei whiht c s ao e.
n h g s c u t f h tt n c he a e r s )

A p io e algn e e sv f r emus o j cieys o ta ad fn a tSntitd
rs n r l ig xc sie o c
e
t b e tv l h w h t e e d n t lce
i
ul c s r a wa onpana s frng. W hilvv. ber, U. 31 320( 986) s e
me esay nd nt i nd ufei '
' te Al s 475 S. 2,
1 ;e
W is nv.Seie ,5 U. 294,298( 991 ( di t tanEi hAme
lo
tr 01 S.
1 ) hol ng ha
ght
ndme tcli f
n am or

e c siefr er q r sa o j cied prv to o ab sch ma n e a dta p io o fcas
x e sv o c e uie n b e tv e iain f a i u n e d n h t rs n fiil
s j ci l a tdwihas tcenl c pa esaeofmi .The eo e t pr ri uiyi
ub e tvey ce t ufi i ty ul bl tt
nd) r fr ,he ope nq r s
whe he t f c a i d w a C n a good f ih e f t o m a nt n orr s or di c plne or
t r he or e pple
sç
i
a t f or t
i ai
et e si i
5

malciusy a s ditc ly f t ve y pur eofc i hn m . W hilv,475U . a 3 21
i o l nd a si a l or he r
pos
ausng r '
'
te
S. t 20- .

Th s be t c mpo n e c mp se ( u h fco sa ten e f rt a pl ain o fr e te
e u j ci o ne t n o a s s t c a tr s h e d o he p i to f o c ,h
ve
s
c

rlto hpb t e t n e a dten t o f ret a wa u e , n t ee tn o ij r
eains i ewe n he e d n h mo mt f o c h t s s d a d h x e t f nu y
ifitd' l . t3 1(ne n l u tto maks atrto s a dctto o te ) Th o j cie
n lce . d a 2 i tr a q o ai n r , leain , n i in mi d . e be tv
'
a
l
ee ntge r l rquiesmoet naX mi mi us off ce.Huds v. c ila 503U.
lme nealy e r
r ha
ni s e or
on M M lin,
S.

1 9 1 ( 9 2 .Cor cin l tf mus a tt h se u d rp e s r, ndfe u n l wi o t h
, - 0 1 9 ) re to a saf t c dn a t, n e r su e a rq e ty t u t e
i
h
lz y ofa s co c nce ' and t cou tm us g ve pr s ofk i l twi - a ng de e enc i
lxur
e nd ha ,'
he r
ti
i on t a s ç de r ngi
fr e n

tea o to a e e u ino p lce a dp a tc st a i ter u g n a en e e t p ee v
h d p in nd x c to f o iis n rcie h t n h ij d me t r e d d o r s r e
i e na or ra dicplnea t m ant i i tt tona s urt ' W hil y,475 U. a 320*
nt r l de nd s i i nd o i an nsiu i l ec iy.'
te
S. t ,
Huds 503 U . a 7.
on,
S. t

Afe r l ng on t ve ii d Compli a r ce afi vi,pl ntf f ist pr de
tr eyi
he rfe
ant nd e nt tda t ai if a l o ovi
s ii ,a isbl f t t tde onsr t how C/ Fa m e us d f c malci l a
pecfc dm s i e ac s ha m tae
O r r e or e i ousy nd
s si a l t pu pos l ca eha m. Cons que l C/ Fa me i en il t qua ii
aditc ly o r ey us r
e nty, O r r s tted o lfed
i uniy bec us t r cor e nce C/ Far r sus off c a agood f t e f t o m ant i
mm t
a e he e d vi s O
me ' e or e s
aih for t
i an
orr s or di ci i .
e t e s plne

Pl i ifsa gumen t tt f c wase e svebe us hewa l ke i i t c l i
antf r
t ha he or e
xc s i
ca e
s oc d nsde he e l s
s i be us he f l t ofe a e de e t e a n w hy hi n w e e o s de t c la
pec ous ca e ais o f r ny vi nc o xpl i
s nns r ut i he el t
a i e. Pl ntf sa
nyt
m
ai i f nns di notbe ong out i ofhi c lw he r t ni t l
d
l
sde
s el
n e ur ng he unch t a a hi
r y, nd s

pe sse r u a t c
r itnt ef s l o ompl wih sa f sor r r quie s
y t t f ' de s e r d omet peoff c t r t e dicplne
y
or e o esor s i i
a or r C/ Fn me ' f c f la tmpt t hi t tay sotbox on t c ldoort ke p
nd de . O r rs or e u te s o nge he ' l
r
he el
o e
pl i tf s ha s c el a a f om t ofi e sw a a diec cons ue e ofpl i t f sr f al
a n if
nds e ur y w y r he t c r s r t
eq nc
a n if e us
t r tr hi ar si de t cel and hearng pl ntf st
o etzn s m nsi he l
i
ai if hreatt t ow f
o hr
eces on t of i ,
he fcers

r ga dl s t t ac ua e s e ofa pl s i ba off ce . A n i a e' t e tt t o f e on
e r e s o he t l xit nce
a tc g e s
nm t s hr a o hr w ec s
6

c r tonalsa fundoubt dl c us ssa ft a ti ha t a t rpr s ur ,a C/ Fa m e '
oreci
tf
e y a e t f o c n se nd mde e s e nd O r rs
de i i t qui y a f c f ly s tr t box i w o t ofdef r nce
c s on o ckl nd or e u l ec le he
s r hy
ee .

Al o g pan ifalg d ys tie b o ntn e s b us s a d sr p s te eijzis
t u h litf le e l usan d r ke i g r , r ie , n c a e ,h s nl e
h
r
c d onl ha ha ne i pl n ifr us t r t r hi ha i i t c ldoo . Pl i if s
oul
y ve ppe d f ai t f ef ed o e ' n s nds ns de he el
u
r a ntf

alge ybr nfnge sa X mi mi br s a sr pesaeno c
le dl oke i r nd
ni s uies nd ca r t omme urt wiht
ns ae t he

dskl e n t tc u dh v be nc u e i t tit-i epo ndse l xweerp ae l
if z me tha o l a e e a s d f he h ry fv u te bo r e e tdy
r
s a he ma ii l a s ditc l ac os pl i ifsha a a msaspl i ifa lges
m s d lc ousy nd a sialy r s antf
nds nd r
antf le .
Alhough C/ Fn me c dha us d pe
t
O r r oul ve e ppers a ordie tphysc f c t c
pr y
rc
ial or e o ompe pl i ifs
l antf
obe e e C/ Fa m e pe s sed i s c li t t a s otbox t r s or or w ihouta gr a e
di nc , O r r r i t n e tr ng he r y l
o e t e der t
e tr

rs o ij r t p an ifo saf Ac o dn l , ant ff i t p e e te i e c t a C/ Fn r
ik f nu y o litf r tf c r ig y pli i al o r sn v d n e h t O me
f s
us f cemalci l a s si ly,a C/ Fn me i e il t qua ii i t t
ed or
i ousy nd aditcal nd O r r s ntted o lted mm miy.

11
1.

Fort f e ngr a ons 1va a et prorM e a
he or goi e s , c t he i
mor ndum Opi o a Or r gr nt
ni n nd de , a

d fn a t' to f rsl r j dg n , e ypanifsmoinf rs mmayj d me t a
ee d n s moin o l
mmay u me t d n lit
f
to o u r u g n , nd
de a m ootpl i if s m oton t com pe .3
ny s
a ntf
i o
l

TheCl r i diece t s nd c e oft sM e a
e k s r td o e opi s hi mor ndum Opi on a t ac mpa ng
ni nd he co nyi

Or rt pl ntf a c
de o ai if nd ouns lofr c d f def nda s
e
e or or e nt .
ENTER :
Thi

da ofJ y, 3.
y ul 201

f

.

4

e o Unie St t Diti tJ
ni
t d aes src udge
3Pl i ifs moton t c pela ks me t or rno de enda st pr de pl i ifwih pe a pa a tr
a ntf '
i o om
s
o de n- f nt o ovi a ntf t n nd per fe
c r c i safaleg y r
ore tonal t f l edl evoke pli ifspos e sonoft eie sbec eaw om a c
d antf
ssi
hes tm
aus
n ompli d a
ane boutalte
e tr
plitf s nthe .Ther co dr ve spli ifhasbe n a et f l rpl t defnda s m oi a cou o de s
anif e r
e r e al antf
e bl o uly e y o e nt' ton nd rt r r ,
a t r que tf pe a pa i mootbe us t smate i r s vedandnor po e fom pl ntf i r quied.
nd he e s or n nd per s
ca e hi
tr s e ol
es ns r
ai if s e r

7