Newman v. McPeak et al

Filing 8

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 2/19/2013. (tvt)

edw< gOFFI U.s.D6 .
CE
AT* 0< ST COtRT
'l
FIED
L

,

V
A

FEB 1S 2 1
23
I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI O F VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O A N O K E D I SI N
VI O
R I H A RD G LEN N NEW M AN ,JR .
C
,
Pl ntf ,
ai i f

G ER ALD A .M C PEA K ,e aI,
t .
Def
endant
s.

)
)
)
)

)
)
)

JULAC.
BY: I D
.c ERK
,
2R CL ...
ér
DE

Ci lA d i n N o.7: c 00015
vi
o
13- v-

M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
By:

H on.M i hae F.Urbans
c l
ki
U nied St esD i t ctJudge
t
at
s ri

l iha dGlnn Newm a J .aVigi ai a epr e di pr K ,tl acvi rg s
tc r e
n, r, r ni nm t oc e ng o Red i l i ht

a t npt s a tt 4 U. C. 1 8 wihjzid ci nv se i 2 U. C. 1 4 .Plitf
ci l u n o 2 S. j 9 3 t l s ito e td n 8 S. j 3 3 an if
o r
r
n me a d fn a t t eNe lie ValyRe in l al(J i' a dGeadA. c a t
n s s ee d n s h w tv r le go a J i : al) n rl M pe k,he
ç '
J lsSupe i e nt Pl i ifal geshi cvi rgh swe evi ae by notr c vi de a fos .
ai'
rnt nde . antf le
s i l i t r olt d
e ei ng nt l l s

Thi matri befr t c r f s reni purua t 28U. C.j1 5A.Afe rviwi
s te s oe he ou t or ce ng, s nt o
S. 91
tr e e ng

p an ifss b si n ,hec u t imis st eCo an wi o t rj dc f rfiigt saea
litf u miso s t o r d s se h mplit t u p eu ie o al o tt
h
n
cl m upon w hi h r le m a be gr nt
ai
c ei f y
a ed.

Thec tmus dim isa aci o cai fld by a i t i t c tdee ne t t
our
t s s ny ton r l m ie
n nma e f he our t nni s ha
t a ton orcli i fi ousorf l t saeacl m on whih r i m a be g a t Se 28
he c i
a m s rvol
ais o tt
ai
c elef y
r n ed. e

U. C. j 1 5 e( ) 1 5 b () 4 U. C. 1 9 e c.Th trtsa d r i ld scams
S. j 91 ()2 , 91 A() 1; 2 S. j 9 7 () e is tn ad ncu e li
bas upon i n i s a y m e il sl lt r 't am sofi rnge e ofa lgali e e t
ed
l ndiput bl rtes ega heo y,'t i
a
cl
nfi m nt
e ntr s
w hi h c e l doesnote s y o c a m s whe e t G a t lc en i a e cl r y ba e e s'
c l ary
xi t' r l i
'
r he l c ua ont tons r ea l s l s .
f
'

Netkev. il ms 4 0U.. 9 3 7( 9 9 .Th s c ndsa d r i t efmiirsa d r f r
iz
W li , 9 S 31 , 2 1 8 ) e e o tn ad s h n la tn ad o
n
amoint ds s u d rFe ea Ru eo Cii P oc dle1 09( ) a c p igap an ifs
to o imis n e d r l l f v l r e t 2 6 , c e tn litf
r
f t la l ga i a t u A c pl i ne ta s ta pl i sa e e oft c ai s i
ac ua le tons s r e. om a nt eds û hor nd a n t t m nt he l m how ng

t tt plade i e ildt r le ' nds fcintçljcua algai ...oriearghtt
ha he e r s ntte o eif a ufi e lfa t l le tons t as i o

r ifabovet s ultvelvel.... Bel At.Com . . Two l, 5 U. 5 4, 5 (0 7
ele
he pec ai e
'
' l l
v
mby 5 0 S. 4 5 5 2 0 )

(ntma quoai maksomitd) A pli ifsba i f r le çe rsmor t nlbel a
i e l tton r
te . antf ss or eif t quie
r
e ha a s nd
c usons....'1 The e or apli ifmus ç le f t s fcentt saea1 t e e nt
oncl i
' d. r f e, antf
t s lge ac s uf i o tt 1 he l me s
a
'
s
o (h )cam.1 B a sv. ..
f t e li ' s E I DupontdeNem our & Co., 3 4F.d7 , 65(t Ci. 0 3 .
2 3 61 7 4 h r 2 0 )

Tosatacam t e j 1 8 , plitf mus alg thevo aino arg tsc r db
tt li md r 9 3 a an if t l e ç ilto f ih e u e y
e t
t Consiuton a l wsoft Unie Stt s a mus s t tt alege de i ton wa
he
tt i nd a
he t d a e , nd
t how ha he l d prva i
s

c
ommitdbyaperonaci t rc o ofsaelw. W etv.At ns 487U. 42,48( 988 .
te
s tng mde olr tt a ' s
'
ki ,
S.
1 )
Howe r t J i i notaç es 'orpu pos sofj1
ve ,he al s
ç ron'f r e
p
983.SeeMccoyv.Che a akeCor.
s pe
r

Ct.7 8F. u p. 9 ( D. . r l ,1 9 )(e s nn j isaeno a p o raed fn a t t
r, 8 S p 8 0 E. Va Ap . 3 9 2 r a o ig al r t p r p it e e d n s o
a j1 a ton) Furhemor,pl ntf fist algea f t ag ns M c a Pl ntf s e
983 ci . t r e ai if al o le ny acs ai t pe k. ai if ol
alega in i t tç f nda r us t gi pl i ifde alfos ,whi h c us c vii ,pan,
l to s ha û e nt ef es o ve antf nt l s
de
c a ed a tes i a
l tt h,a t h de a ' Pl i ifdoesno pr dee denc ofM c a si ve e t
os 00t nd 00t c y. antf
'
t ovi vi e
pe k' nvol m n
be
yond hi me ec uson,a pl i ifsg i va e dono r vea M c a spe s la tor
s r oncl i nd antf re nc s
t e l pe k' r ona c
o ison t tc d c tt edelbe ae i fe e et as rousme c lne d.Pl i ifcn
m s i ha oul onsiut i r t ndif r nc o e i
di a e
antf nnot

pr ce agans t J i' Supe i e nti aj 1 a tonvi r s nde ts ror Se se. ,
o ed i t he als rntnde n
983 ci a epo a upe i . e a.
M onelv. p'ofSoc.Se vs,436U. 658, 3n. ( ) Esel v.Gn e 429U. 97,
l De t
r .
S. 66 7 1978 ; tle
mbl,
S.
1 ( 97 .M oroverplitf fist desrbehow a i lt t pos e sde a fos i not
O4 1 6)
e , anif al o c i
n nabiiy o s s ntl l s s
'Deer ni whet ac
t mi ng
her ompli sae aplusbl cl m f r le i t co exts cik t k t tr quiest
ant tts a i e ai or eif s d nt -pe t as ha e r he
a

rve n c u tod a o is u iile p re c a dc mmo sn e' Asco t l b l5 6U., 6 , 7 -9
e iwig o rt rw n tj dca x ein e n o n e s . h r fv.n a, 5 S 6 2 6 87
'
( 0 9 .Thu, c ut ce nn ac mplitu e Rue1 ()6 c nie typla n sta aeno e tt dt a
2 0 ) sa o rs re ig o an nd r l 2b () a d ni e dig h t r t nil o n
f
e
asumpto oft-t be aus t y c itofno mor t n l l andco l i I Alho t c tlbe al
s in l h c e he onss
u
e ha abes
ncusons. d. t ugh he our i r ly

c ntu sp o. c mpans Hane v. re, 0 U.. 9 5 021(9 2,h c u t o sno ata a imaes
o sr e r K o lit, i s Ken r 4 4 S 51 , 2 - 1 7 )te o r d e t c s n n t'
advoc t s s ede l ngsaut y a c tt ina cam snotcl ryr s i acompl nt SeeBr kv.
ae, ua pont veopi tt or nd onsiuto l li
ea l aied n
ai .
oc

Ca la1 7F.d 2 , 4 ( h Ci.1 9 )( ti, . c n u rn ) Be u et Ciyo Ha t n 7 5 F.d 1 7 ,
=o l 0 3 41 2 3 4t r 9 7 Lu t J, o c ri g ; a d t v. t f mp o : 7 2 2 4
g
1 78(t Ci. 98 ) Se as God nv Leke 5 4F. 1 4 ,l 51(t Ci.1 7 )(e o nzn ta adsrc
2 4h r 1 5 . e lo ro . e , 7 2d 1 7 1 4h r 9 8 rc g ilg h t itit
cour i note td t asumet r eofa
ts
xpece o s
he ol
dvocaef apr > panig.
t or o ç litf
..

2

r s
ea onabl r aed t l tma epe ogi li e essorc tt esacr la unus lvi
y elt o egii t nol ca nt r t
onsiut
ue nd
ual i ng

co iin.See e. ,- ne v.Sa:e 48 U. 78,1 ( 987) Rhode v.Cha n,452U.
ndto
. g.l r
-ur
y, 2 S. 07 1 ;
s
pma
S.
337( 981 .Se e. ,Rhode v.Cha n, U. 337( 981 .Ac or ngy,heco t
1 ) e. c.
s
pma 452 S. 1 ) c di l t ur
dimi s t Compl ntf f lngt sa eacli upon whih r le m a begr nt d,purua t
s s es he
ai or aii o t t
am
c e if y
a e
s n

t 2 U. C. 1 5 b)1.
o 8 S. j 91 A( ()
The Clr i die t d t s nd co e oft sM e and l Opi on a t ac ompa ng
ek s r ce o e
pis hi mor tm
ni nd he c
nyi
O r rt pl i if
de o a ntf .

ENTER:T i /.
hs 5

dyo Fbur,02
a f eray2 1.

#

@

'.

Unie St t D it i tJ e
t d a es s rc udg

.