McMilllian v. Astrue
Filing
19
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 3/10/14. (med)
CLERK' OFFI U. . sT. '
S
CE S DI COURT
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED
I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI T CO UR T
C
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI I A
CT
RG NI
R O AN O K E D I SI N
W O
MA2 12 2 1
24
JULA C.
I DUDL , ERK
EY CL
DY; BWEEKS
DEPUTY CLERK
ST EPH A N I N .M CM ILLIAN ,
E
C i lA c i N o.7: 3- vvi ton
1 c 19
Pl ntf ,
ai if
M EM O M N D UM O PI I
N ON
V.
CA R O LY N W . C O LV I ,
N1
A c i Com mi so ofSoc a Se ur t
tng
s i ner
i l c iy,
H on.Jam e C . urk
s T
Se or U nie St e Di t i tJudge
ni
t d at s s r c
Dee
f ndant
.
Plitf S e a i N.M c il n Cs anif'o G c il n' b o g tti a to fr
an if tph n e
M la plitf r t M li ' r u h l s cin o
i
M
a l
z
rviw o Dee a t Caoln W .Covn' (t e Co sine' fn ld cso d n i h r
e e f fnd n r y
l i s çh mmiso r' ia e iin e yng e
G
)
cli frdiabiiy i urncebe t (t B')t rTil 1 oft SocilSe urt Ac (the
am o s lt ns a
neks :DI ' mde te 1 he a c iy t ç
t
Ac', sa n e . 2U. C.j 4 - 3 Th sCo r h s u idcino e t ea to p rua t o
t' a me d d 4 S. j 014 4. i u t a j rs ito v r h cin u s n t
)
42 U. C. j405g)
S.
( .Bot M c ila a t Commisone fld moi f sl r
h M lin nd he
si r ie
tons or lmmay
j d me t ECFNo . 1 1 . eCo r he r a g me t nt emoin , e ECFNo 1 , n te
u g n.
s 1 , 3 Th u t ad r u n o h to s s e
. 8 ad h y
ar now rpe f r dipost o
e
i o s ii n.
Thi ca e se s fo Pli if s s co a i a i f DI a a ha ned wih he
s s t m r m a ntf e nd pplc ton or B, nd, s ppe
t r
frtcam f rbe eis t e Ad n srtv La J d e (ALJ' b lw c n ld d t a Plitf
is li o n ft, h miitaie w u g ç ' eo o cu e h t anif
t )
wa notdia e Thepe i ofalege d s biiy t tt ALJ i t sca ewase l tng be n
s
s bl d.
rod
l d ia lt ha he
n hi s
vauai
ga
J 1 22, 2008 a e d Dec m be 31 201 2 Alhough Pli if alege s r l d s blng
uy
nd nde
e r , 0. t
antf l d eve a i a i
c to ,t prm a y lm ii condii a is i t sa ala ie fom s de ,ba k,a
ondii ns he i r i tng
tons t s ue n hi ppe rs r houl r c nd
1Car l n W .Col n became t Actng Com m isonerofSoci Securt on Fe ar 1 , 201
vi
he i
si
al
iy
bnz y 4
Oy
3.
Pu s a tt Rul 25 d ofte Fe e a Rulso Ci lPr e r ,Ca ol W .Col n i hee s bsiutd
r u n o e ( ) h d r l e f vi oc du e r yn
vi s rby u tt e
f Mi
or chaelJ.Asrueast def ndanti t ss t
t
he e
n hi ui.
2A lhough M c ilan' applcaton aleges di biiy begi ng on Sept ber30, 2005,R .174t
M li s
i i l
sa lt
nni
em
80,t ALJ e ai i hi decii t t r evantpe od f t s cl m began on Jul 22,2008,
he
xpl ned n s
son hat he el
ri or hi ai
y
be a ePli ifse tte n t be ft f tepirp ro ha ara ybe nfn lyaj diae i a
c us antf' nilme t o neis or h ro eid d le d e ial du ctd n n
earirALJdecii da ed Jul 21,2008.R.17-1 Addii l herdat l ti ur wasDecember31,
le
son t
y
8.
tonaly,
e as ns ed
201 Shedoesnotc es t ac acy oft e dat
0.
ont t he cur
hes es.
n c ij re s e s tie i t s p rt c ra cd ns i S pe e 2 0 a d J l 2 0 ,
e k nu is h usan d n wo e aae a c ie t, n e tmb r 0 5 n uy 0 9
r s c i y.
e pe tvel
l r ac ng hi de son t tM c ila wasnotdia e t ALJ a pt i lr pa t
n e hi
s cii ha
M li n
s bld, he
do ed n a ge r
t f tonallm iai r omm e
he unc i
i t tons ec
nded by one ofM c ila steai phys ca ,Dr Ric e
M lin' z tng
i ins . thi ,
i Se ehbe 2011.The ALJ di noti ude t r srci n s tf t by Dr Ric e,howeve ,
n pt l r
d
ncl
he e ti to e orh
. thi
r
t tPl i ifc d no e
ha antf oul t ngage i a r c ng,fndi i t d t ts s d be lmie t no
n ny ea hi i ng nsea ha he houl
i td o
o r ad r c ng.Li wie t ALJdic t d Dr Richi so ni t tPli ifwoul mi s
ve he ea hi
ke s , he
s oun e
. t e' pi on ha antf
d s
wor a las t da pe m ont duet s ve epai TheALJi t a c l d t tM c ila
k t e t wo ys r
h
o e r
n.
nse d onc ude ha M li n
ha t rsd lf tonalc pact (t ' t pefr almie r ngeofs nt ywor wih
d he e iua unci
a iy t
RFC' o rom i td a
)
ede ar k t
addii l r t i tons i l ng no t hi a puli of n m co r s' a no û ea hi
tona esr c i
nc udi
t
pus ng nd
lng
r
ntol ' nd
û c ng
r
'
3 ed
hi
nd he de e e or ncudi esi
o r a 'R .22. Bas on t sRFC a ot revi nc ofr c d, i l ng t tmony fo a
ve he d.
rm
vo ain le p r (VE',t ALJ d tr n d t a Plitf r man d c p bl o p ro mi
c to a x e t 1 ' he
ç )
ee mie h t an if e ie a a e f ef r ng
wor t te ssi sgnik a ntmbe si t r gi
k ha xit n i t nt l r n he e onala nai na e onom i a t wasno
nd to l c
es nd hus
t
dia e R.28;sege r l R.1 30( cson ofALJ.
s bld.
e nealy 7- de ii
)
l h rmoin f rsl r j g n , c l a c n e d t a te Co sin re rd
n e to o t
mmay ud me t M Mil n o tn s h t h mmiso e re
i
i co l ng s w a not di a ed.H e pdm a y a g e i t t t A LJ t r d by di c r ng
n nc udi he s
s bl
r
r r um nt s ha he
re
s a di
po tonsofDr Ric e' o ni n a c ry- c ng onl pa t ofi t r l upo She as post
ri
. t hi s pi o nd he r piki
y rs t o ey n.
lo is
t t S he A LJ f l d t ana yze t c l ul tve e f c of a 1 of he m e ca pr e s' 1 a 8.
ha l
t
aie o
l
he lm a i f e t
l
r di l obl m . d. t
'
M c ila a s c lnge t ALJS de ii n by poi i t t m i tn opi on pr de by he
M li n l o hale s he
' c so
ntng o he te
ni
ovi d
r
i pe ntVE,M r Hn ns who opi t tDr Ric e' r ommende physc f tona
nde nde
. nki ,
ned ha . t hi s ec
d
ial unci l
lm ia i woul r nde he t bl t pe f
i t tons
d e r r ma e o ronn t r uie e sof a postonst te s i
he eq r m nt
ny
ii
ha xit n
sgnik a number i t r onalorna i le onomy.
i t nt
s n he egi
tona c
ECF No.1 a 72 t 8.
For t r a ons sae beow, t Cour fnds t t s tntal e de e s
he e s
t td l
he
ti
ha ubsa i vi nc uppors t
t he
3The Adm i sr i Recor , i udi a Supplm ent Rec d,hasbee fl atECF N os.8 a
nitatve
d ncl ng
e
al or
n ied
nd
15.He ei t Cour ciest s cii pagesoft Recor as(R. .'
r n, he
t t o pe fc
he
d $
'
Comm isone ' fnal de son. Ac or ngl t Comm isone ' M oton f Slm ma y
si rs i
cii
c di y, he
s i rs
i
or l r
J
udgm e ,ECF N o.1 i G R ANTE D a Pl i if s M o i f Sum m a y J
nt
3, s
nd a ntf '
ton or
r udgm e ,ECF N o.
nt
11,i D EN I .
s
ED
1
.
STANDARD OF REVI
EW
W he r vi wi t Comm isone ' fnalde son,t Cour i lm ie t de e mi ng
n e e ng he
s i rs i
cii he
t s i t d o t r ni
whehe t Comm isone ' fndi a e s
t r he
s i rs i ngs r uppore by s tntale de e a whe he t
td
ubsa i vi nc nd
t r he
Comm isone r a d t e fndi t ough a ia i oft co r c lgalsa r .Se 42
s i r e che hos i ngs hr
pplc ton he r e t e
t nda ds e
U. C. 40 () Ha c c v. tu , 7F.d4 0 4 2( t Ci. 01 )
S. j 5g ; n o k Asr e 66 3 7 , 7 4h r 2 2 .
Subsa i le de e i ç uc r l va e de as a r s bl mi m i ac e a
t nta vi nc s û h e e nt vi nce
s
ea ona e nd ght c pt s
a qua et s
de t o uppo ta c l i n;i c it ofmor t n am e e s ntla ofe denc butma be
r oncuso t onsss
e ha
r ci il
vi e
y
s wha ls t n aprpondea e. Cr gv.Chae,76F. 585,58 ( hCi.19 )(nenal
ome t e s ha
e
r nc ' ai
'
tr
3d
9 4t r 96 itr
cttons omit ) Ha k, 667 F.d a 472. l t Co si rs dee mi tons at
iai
ted ; ncoc
3 t
f he mmisone ' tr nai
r
s p o td b s b tn ile i e c ,a rv e n c u tma n ts b ttt i j d me tf rt
u p re y u sa ta v d n e e iwig o r y o u si e t u g n o he
u s
Comm iso rs but i t ad mus de e t t e deenni to .Ha v.Suli n,907 F.
s i ne ' ,
nse
t f r o hos t na i ns vs
lva
2d
1 3 1 5 (t Ci.1 9 ) 4 U. C.j 40 () Ac o dn l ç in rv e n fr s b tn il
45 , 4 6 4 h r 9 0 ; 2 S.
5 g . c r igy, ç l e iwi g o u sa ta
l
e ie c , ( s Co td e ) n t u d ra e t rweg c nlcig e d n e ma e c e iiiy
vd n e t
hi ur o s o n e tk o e ih o fitn vie c , k rdb l
t
d tr n to s o s b tt t ( s j d me tfrt to t ALJ . . W h r c n l t e i e c
eemiain , r u siue i ) u g n o ha f he
t
. . e e o fi i v d n e
c ng
alowsr as bl mi t dif rast whehe acli a i dia ed,t r ponsbiiy f t t
l
e ona e nds o fe
o
t r am nt s s bl he es i lt or ha
de sonf l ont ALJ'Ha oc 667F. a 472(ntr latrtonsa cttonsomitd)
cii als he . nc k,
'
3d t
i ena leai nd iai
te .
M c ila be r t btr n ofpr ng t ts i dia e wihi t m e ni oft Ac .
M li n a s he lde
ovi ha he s s bld t n he a ng he t
Enals v.Shaaa,1 F. 1 1 2 ( hCi.1 (ii 42 U. C.j423d)5( 6).
ih
ll 0 3d 080, 08 4t r 993) ctng
S.
( ()200 ) The
Ac detnesidiabiif'a t Gna lt t e gei a s t nta ganf a tviyby r a on of
t i ' s lt s he ç biiy o nga n ny ubsa i l i ul c i t
i
es
a m e c ly de e m i bl physca orm e ali im e ,whi h ca be e c e t r s ti
ny di al t r na e
i l
nt mpa r nt
c n
xpe t d o e ul n
de t o whi h has l t d or c n be e c e t l s f a c i
ah r
c
as e
a
xpe t d o a t or ontnuous pe i ofno l s t n 1
r od
t es ha 2
mo t . 4 U. C. 42 ( )1( . sb l yu d rt eAc rq ie s o ngmo et tefc
nhs' 2 S. j 3 d ()A) Dia ii n e h t e ur s h wi
'
t
r h% h a t
t tt cli nts f r fom an i par ntwhih a f c she a lt t pe f m daiy a tvii
ha he a ma ufe s r
m ime
c fe t r biiy o ror
l c i tes
o c r a n f r s of wor Ra he ,a cl i a m us s
r e ti o m
k. t r
a m nt
t how t the i pa r e s pr ve he f o
ha r m im nt e nt r r m
e gi i a1 f m s of s t talga nf l e oyme gi n he age e
nga ng n l or
ubsan i
i u mpl
nt ve
r , ducai a wor
ton, nd
k
e ein e S e4 U. C. j4 ()2 .
xp re c . e 2 S. j 23d ()
The Com misone us a fve-t p pr es t e l t a dia lt c am . W a l v.
s i r es i se oc s o vauae
s biiy l i
ls
Ba n r,296 F. 287,290 (t Ci.2002) The Co si ras ,i s que e,whehe t
r ba t
3d
4h r
.
mmisone ks n e nc
t r he
cama t ( )i wo kng ( )h sas v r i ar n ; 3 h sa'i ar n t a me t o e u l
li n : 1 s r i ; 2 a e ee mp ime t () a l mp ime t h t es r q as
l
t er q ie n so alse i iue t4( )c n rtl t h rpatrlva two k; n i n t ( )
h e urme t f itd mpan n ; 4 a eu' o e s ee n r a d f o, 5
n
whehe s ca pef n ot rwor He klrv.Ca
t r he n ron' he
k. c e
mpbel 461 U. 458,460- ( 98 ;
l,
S.
462 1 3)
J h s n v.Bamh r,4 4 F.d 6 0 6 4 n 1 (t Ci.2 05 ( e clim) (iig 20 C. R.
o no
r a t 3 3 5 , 5 . 4h r 0 ) p r t a ctn
r
F.
j404.5 .Thei r c as si t Commisone fndst cama diabld a a se of
1 20)
nquiy e e f he
si r i he li nt s e t ny tp
t ep o e s 2 C. R.j 4 4.5 0 a ( )41 .20 a( ) Th cama tbe r t bzd no p o f
h r c s. 0 F. j 0 1 2 ()4 , 69 ()4 . e li n as he l e f r o
r
a s e one t ough f l t e t bls a prm a f ci ca e f di a lt The btr n s fs t t
t t ps
hr
otr o s a i h
i a e s or s biiy.
lde hi t o he
Co misone a se fve t esabls t tt ca ma mai ai t RFC,c i rng t
m s i r t t p i o t ih ha he li nt nt ns he
onsde i he
cli a ' ag e a i wo k e re e a i ime s t pe f m a lbl at m a i
am nts e, duc ton, r xpe inc , nd mpar nt, o ror vaia e le tve
wor i t l a a nai e onomi .42U. C.j423( ( ( ;Tavl v.W enbe ce,51
k n he oc l nd tonal c
es
S.
d)2)A)
or
i r r 2
F. 664,666( h Ci.1 .
2d
4t r 975)
1
I.
PR O CED UR AL H I
STO R Y A N D FA C TU AL BA C K G R O U N D
A.
Pr e alB ac ound
oc dur
kgr
M cM ila w a bor on Aug t 31,1
li n s n
us
970,R.43,a w a f t one ye r ol a t tm e
nd s or ya s d t he i
4 A (lsed i r ent'i one consi ed by t Soci Securiy Adm i sr ton ç o be s e
sit mpaim ' s
der
he
al
t
nita i i
t
ever
e
nough t pr ventan i vi fom doi any gai ac i t r dl ofhi orherage,tducaton,or
o e
ndi dual r
ng
nful tviy, egar ess
s
i
wo ke pe in e'20C. R. 40 1 25 *.
r x re c .
'
F. j 4.5 (
4
oft ALJ Sde son on Oc obe 1 2011 Ata 1r lvan tm e ,t r f r ,s wa atyounge
he
' cii
t r 4,
. 1 ee t i s he e o e he s G
r
pes n' n e t Ac. 0 C. R. 4 4.5 3 c . h h sah g s h o e u ain a dp e o sy
ro 'u d r he t 2 F. j 0 1 6 () S e a ih c o l d c to n rviu l
wor d f s ven ye r asaf ltme pa ol ce k. 43.
ke or e
as
ul-i
yr l lr R.
She fl a pro a i to f D1 i Nove be 2006, ale ng dia lt snce
ied
i r pplcai n or B n
m r
l gi
s biiy i
Se e b 30,2005.R.77.Tha cai wa uli t y de e by t ALJ a t a hea i s R.
pt m er
t l m s tma el nid
he
fer
rng, ee
77- 7,a de son uphed by t Appe sCot i.R.1 M c ila fl d he s cond a i to
8
cii
l
he
al
mc l
7. M lin ie r e
pplcai n
f D l t one a i s he e i J y 2009. 1 18
or B- he
t s ue r - n ul
R. 74- 0.
Pl i ifs c am wa de ed a t i tala r c i r i lvel of admi sr tve
antf l i
s ni t he nii nd e onsde aton e s
nitai
r e .R.11 11 21 Ata Se e be 1 2011 vi he rng be or ALJJ e T.Sc t n,
eviw
2, 9- .
ptm r 4,
deo a i
f e
os ph
nzo
bot Pli if( wa rpr e e b c e)andaVE tsiid.Se R.36- (rnsrptfom
h antf who s e esntd y ouns l
etfe e
62 ta c i r
heai .The ALJ is d hi decson on Ocobe 1 2011,fndi t tM c ila wasnot
rng)
s ue s ii
t r 4,
i ng ha M lin
diabld d t he a lt t peror s den a y wor wih s cik a tonal lmia i
s e ue o r biiy o
f m e tr
k, t pe t ddii
i t tons
d s u sdb lw. eR. 2; e as c n rlvR. 7 3 ( ' d cso )
ic se eo Se 2 s e lo e eal 1 - 0 ALJS e iin .
l r ac ng t s c uson, t ALJ pr pe l utlz t fve se pr e s f
n e hi hi oncl i
he
o ry iied he i - tp oc s or
deemi ngwhet racli nti dia ed.Se J onv.Banha t434F. 65 65 n. ( h
tr ni
he ama s s bl
e ohns
r r,
3d 0, 4 1 4t
Ci. 0 5 ( rczim)(iig20C. R. 4 4 1 2 )(et gf rh tefvese ) Th ALJfrt
r 2 0 ) pe l a ctn
r
F. j 0 .5 0 s ti o t h i tps. e
n
is
de e ne t tM cM ila l tm e t i tr d sausr uie e soft Ac on Dec mbe 31,
t nni d ha
lin as t he nsle t t eq r m nt
he t
e r
201 a t ts had note
0, nd ha he
ngage i s t nta ganf a tviy snc he al ge o e dat
d n ubsa il i ul ci t i e r le d ns t e
t ough he da el s i ur d.R. Att s ond se t ALJc ude t tM cM ila had a
hr
r t a t ns e
20. he ec
tp, he
oncl d ha
li n
num be of s ve e i pa r e s s cik a l K
r
e r m im nt , pe t ly: : ne a i di c di ea e of t ce v ca s ne;
dege r tve s s s
he r i l pi
di be es m elius tla t a;o s t c pa a c t lt
a t
lt ss s hm
be iy; ar l nd ubia ' ls om e Elsa us pos szge i s
unne yndr y 6 t t
t lr r e ;
5D i esm eliusi $a dieas i whi t m et im ofs s i gr l i r duet t
abet
lt s 1 s e n ch he abols
ugar s eaty mpaied
o he
f t se eton ofi uln by t pa e ' See J. Schmi ,Ator sD i i y ofM edi ne,at1 99
auly cr i
ns i
he ncr as.'
E.
dt t ney' ctonar
ci
7-
( 9 )( r ia trû it ofM e ' .
1 99 he en fe r c.
d.)
'
5
hr i oft s ul r U1a de e so .'R.2 He f
os s he ho de s; nd pr s i n ' 0. ound he hype tnson,a i r tux,a
r
re i cd el
nd
hi c e tr t be c r l d a t nots ve e,a he pol ysi ova i n s ome no
gh holse ol o
ontole nd hus
e r nd r yc tc ra yndr
t
sveebec us i di notr ul i a c iains J Hec ude a t t r se t tnone
e r a et d
es t n ny omplc to ..
Z
oncl d t he hid tp ha
ofhe i im e so c
r mpar nt r ombi ton ofi ime sm e orm e cal eq l d t s ve iy ofany
nai
mpar nt t
di ly ua e he e rt
lse i r
itd mpaiment R. 21.
. 20Bas on t e de e bef r hi ,t ALJ de e ne t tM c ila ha t r sdua
ed
he vi nc
o e m he
t nni d ha
M li n d he e i l
fm c i
t tonalc pa iy, hr h t da e l s i lr d,t
a c t t oug he t a t ns ze o:
pef m s de ay wor asdei d i 20 CFR 404. *.She
ror e ntr
k
fne n
1567(
woul have be n a e t lf a ca r u t 1 pounds
d
e bl o it nd ry p o 0
occ sonaly a up t 5 poundsfe nty;sa wal f 3 hour
a i l nd
o
r que l t nd/ k or
s
i a 8- l pe i f r 1houra atm e and stf r6 hour i a 8n n hotr rod o
t i ;
i o
sn n
ho pe i f 2 hour a a tm e.She w o d ha bee a e t us
ur r od or
s t i
ul ve n bl o e
t ha f smpl g a pi al fne m a pulton.She woul
he nds or i e r s ng rd i
ni a i
d
ha nee
ve ded t a d pus ng a puli of n m c r s She
o voi
hi nd lng
r ontol .
woul ha be n lmie t oc asona be ng a s ua tng.She
d ve t i t d o c i l ndi nd q ti
woul ha ne d t a d cr wlng, ci ng, or r c ng
d ve ede o voi a i
lmbi
ea hi
over a She woul ha ne d t a d a 1 e
he d.
d ve ede o voi l xpos e t
m o
t ot c e he g s a m id e
mpr e t d i ht nd l xpos le t m ovi m a hi r a
tr o
ng c ne y nd
drvi a om o l e pm e .La ty,s woul ha be n abl t
i ng ut bie qui nt sl he
d ve e
eo
t de s a c r y ou ,and r m e be s m pl i t u i ;r s
m r t nd, a r t
e m r i e nsr ctons e pond
a opra e y t s r son,co ke s a us lwor st tons
ppr it l o upe vii
wor r , nd ua
k iuai ;
a de wih c nge i ar tnewor s ti
nd al t ha s n ou i
k e tng.
R.22.The ALJ r le on t VE' t tmony t tt sRFC woul a l M c ila t pe f m
ei d
he
s esi
ha hi
d low
M li n o ror
j t te se i sg fc ntnumber i t nai lec
obs ha xitd n iniia
s n he tona onomy,at ug i wo d no ha
lho h t ul t ve
alowe he t pe f m he pas wor R.27- Ac or ngl t ALJc ude M cM ila wa
l d r o ror
r t k.
28. c di y, he
oncl d
li n s
notdia e unde t Ac . 28 29.
s bld
r he t R. Pl ntf r quese Appe s Counci r vi w of t ALJ S de son, R. 1 a a s
ai if e t d
al
l e e
he
' cii
3, nd lo
s
ubmitd addii li o ma i i s
te
tona nf r ton n uppo tof he r ques,i l ng an a tona vocai na
r
r e t ncudi
ddii l
to l
6Capa a d c bia tnn s dr meaec diinsr s tngfo ac mpr si orij r oft e
r l n u t l u el yn o r on to euli r m o e son nu y h
medi ner and t ul ner att el
an ve
he nar ve he bow,r pectvel The can r ul i pai and num bnessi t
es i y. y
es t n n
n he
f ea m ,hands wr s and fnge .Di .ofM ed. a C- C- 1
or r
, it
i rs ct
, t 96, 5 7.
7Arh ossme nsç ie s ofaj nt'M e Dit a A- .
tr i a d s a e
d
oi . d. c . t 551
'
6
e ua i fom A .Bente Ha ns f rng a vo to l o ni bas d on Dr Iic e'
val ton r
l y nki ,ofe i
cai na pi on
e
. tt hi s
c a ii r c me
l rfed e om nded physc lfmc i l lm iai ns a s m e add to lme c e de .
i a t tona i tto , nd o
ii na di al vi nce
The A ppea s Counc ls a e t ti c i e e t a tona e de e but f
l
i t t d ha t ons d r d he ddii l vi nc ,
ound t t i di not
ha t d
r lt t t epei da j dc td b t ALJ wh c e d dwiht ee piain o M c il n' ls
eae o h ro d u iae y he , ih n e t h x rto f M li s a t
a
i lr d da eofDe mbe 31 201 R. TheAppe sCot i t de e Pl ntf sr ques f
nsze t
ce r , 0. 2.
al
mc l hus ni d ai if e t or
r e , 1 r nde i t ALJ Sdecson t fna decson oft Co misone .See20 C. R.
eviw R. , e rng he
'
ii he i l ii
he m s i r
F.
j 40 981 M c ila tmey fld t s Compl n s e ng rviw of t Commisone '
4. . M lin i l ie hi
ait e ki e e
he
si rs
de ii n.
c so
B.
M e c and O t r Evi
di al
he
dence
8
Th me ia r c r s i dc t t t Mc lin s tie ijlis a t r s t o a
e d c l e o d n iae ha Mila usan d n t e s he eul f n
r
a om o l a i t on Se e r 30,2005.R.43.She ha a M llpe f med i No mbe
ut bie ccden
pt mbe
d n t ror
n ve r
2005, whih r veaed m i e pose oc ntal dic pr t son a C4- a mi t lf
c e l
nut
tr e r
s
o nz i
t
C5 nd
nu e e t
pose olt a/or m i l dic pr r son a C5- and C6tr aer lf a na s otu i t
C6
C7,as wel a m i m a f a i l
l s ni l or m na
na r ng a C6- s onda y t t dic pr t u i R. 41 1 The r por de m e t s
rowi t
7, ec
r o he s o r son.
3- 4.
e t e d he e
fndi ,howe r t be iofquesi bl ci c sg fc nt' R.41 1 M c ilan r ceved
i ngs
ve , o
t
tona e lnial i nii a .
'
3- 4. M li e i
c r a i c r a pa tci t d i a las 38 phys c l t r py s sons R.420hiopr ctc a e nd ri pa e n t e t
i a he a
es i ,
439,but
none hels r po td ltl i pr m e t i he a lt t do daiy aci te a lnge i
t e s e re ite m ove n n r biiy o
l tvii s nd i rng
dicomf ti he nec R.420. I De mbe 2005,M c ila was e ua e by Dr J m
s
or n r k.
n ce r
M lin
val t d
. ol
Ca m ody,who di gnos d c r i l a a ce v ca di c pr r i a C4- C5- a C6- R .
r
a
e e v ca gi nd r i l s ot us ons t
5, 6, nd
7.
477.l M a c 2006,Physc a s As itntM a k Da s r f r e M c ila t a s ne s i it
n rh
ii n' ssa
r
vi, e e r d M li n o pi pecals
due t M c ila sc i d c
o M li n' ontnue ompl i sofne k pai sif swih oc sona r c opa hy of
ant
c
n/tfnes t ca i l adiul t
pa n f om ne k t uppe e r m ii . .
i r
c o
r xte tes R 469470.
Dr W ila Br n e l t M c ila on O c ober 31,2006.R .488 8 H e di gnos d
. li m ow va ua ed M li n
t
- 9.
a
e
8M e c le de c fom pro t t pei o ds biiy a is he e( c be a onJ l 22,
dia vi n e r
ir o he rod f ia lt t sue r whih g n uy
2 ,s es p anoe2 i p e e t df rba kvou i or to o y.
008 e u r t ) s r s n e o c
nd nf main nl
7
l tcapa t
ef r l unnel s ome a lf t dy ul paly.R.489.Dr Br
yndr
nd e t ar
nar s
. own pero m e c r
f r d a pal
de omprs i a ul neve de
c e son nd nar r
compr son slg i ,i Nove r 2006 te tsd a
esi t eres n
r
mbe
lf ie) nd
De e r2 0 (ih sd ) R. 18 . c il n h da dto a szg re a wel icudn a
c mbe 0 6 rg t ie . 48 - 7 M M li a d i n l l eis s l, n l ig
a
i
r
l s e occpia ne v bl k fo Dr J m Pore i De e be 2008.R.265- a a t os opi
e s r i t l r e oc r m . ol
tr n c m r
67, nd rhr c c
r aorc fr par s r ilde m pr son,a dit lclvi l e ii oft rg s de
ot t uf e i, ubac om a co es i nd sa a ce xcson he iht houl r
by Dr J Ric ei Jme2009. 28 8
. ohn t hi n t
R. 3- 4.
l J y 2009,M c ila wa i ved i a s cond a om obie a ci nt R.50.An xr
n ul
M li n s nvol
n e
ut
l c de .
ay
t ke o J y 4,2009 r ve e ac om i l c a s pa ai oft rghts ul r R.294.She
a n n ul
e ald r ocaviulr e r ton he i ho de ,
co i
ntnued t a tnd physc t r py s s i .R.329- I No mber 2009,s t r nt
o te
ial he a e sons
38. n ve
he mde we
a t os opy oft lf s de wih s r alde ompr s i n and dit lc a cl e son,a
rhr c
he e t houl r t ubac omi c
e so
sa l vi e xcii
s
we la ope bi e t nodess R.347- On Aprl6,201 M cM ila t d Dr lic et the
l s n c ps e
i.
48.
i
0,
lin ol . tt hi ha r
rg s de w a silunc f ra ebutt ts ha ma pr r s wih t l t R.571 7 I
i ht houl r s tl om o tbl
ha he d de og e s t he ef.
- 2. n
f t s ve alm ont e rir i Febr r 201 s ha ne r f l l f s de r nge ofm o i n
ac , e r
hs a le n
ua y
0, he d a u l e t houl r a
to
wih no i tbiiy,a s wa t ng much be tr' lhough s not t he pan wa wor e
t
nsa lt nd he s ç
doi
te 'a t
he ed hat r i s s
ove he d.R. 5 On Oc obe 6,201 M c ila unde we a s r a de m p e son,
r a
73.
t r
0, M li n
r nt ubac omi l co r s i
di t lcl vi l e s on,a bi e t ndo i oft r g s ul rw ih D r l ic e R . 4- 5.
s a a c e xcii
nd c ps e nes s he i ht ho de t . t t hi . 61 1
The ear no m o e team e r or fo Dr Richi a trOc obe 201 None hees ,i
r e
r r t nt ec ds r m . t e fe t r 0.
t l s n
Se e r 2011 Dr Ric e r ponde t a lte fom Pl i ifs a tr
pt mbe
, . thi ts
d o e tr r
antf
to ney sa i t t he
t tng ha
be ived t tPl ntf wo d m iswor t c am o h duet pa n a m a be t bl t pe f r
le
ha ai if ul s
k wi e
nt
o i nd y ma e o ro m
ove hea lfi o vi ous us of t rg s der R.656.Dr Ric e a s complt d a
r d itng r gor
e
he iht houl .
. t hi lo
ee
t
s ialc pa ii e ua i ' i whih he i c t d t tM c ila c d stf sx ho si
physc a ctes val ton,' n
c
ndi a e ha
M li n oul i or i ur n
a ei thourwor day,a sa a wa k f t eeea h,a t ts c d lf a c ry up t
n gh k
nd t nd nd l or hr
c nd ha he oul it nd a r
o
fvepoundsfe nty a up t t n po
i
r que l nd
o e undsoc asonal R.657. i
c i ly.
He mpos d no r titonson
e
esrc i
sm pl g a pi o fne ma pulton,b opi t tM c ila c d onl occ sonaly be
i e r s ng r i
ni a i
ut ned ha
M lin oul
y a i l nd
8
a s ta c d ne c a , i b,orr a h.R.657.
nd qua nd oul ver r wl clm
ec
9
On t s me dae,Dr Ric e ans r a t et que ton t i ca As es me ofPan'
he n
t
. t hi
we ed hr - si t ni l s s nt
cl
i'
f m ,i cai t tM cM ila s pan wa t es ntt s h a e e as t be dita tng t
or ndi tng ha
li n' i
s t e o uc n xt nt o
pr
sr c i o
a
dequa e pe f r a ofdaiy aci te orwor 'and i whi h he comm e e t tM c ila
t r o m nce
l tvii s
k'
n
c
ntd ha
M lin
ç a s occ i lna co i whi h m a fo tm e t tme be r quied f pe i ofi r a e
ç ke
t
asona r tcs c
y rm i o i
e r or rods nc e s d
pan r quii m isng wo k.' 658.0
i e rng s i
r 'R. 1
l M ay 2011,a r um aol s ,Dr W iln Gr l e l t d M c ila f c
n
he t ogit . lim u m, vaua e
M lin or ompl i s
ant
of nec s der l g,a f t pai and di nos d he wih fbr m ya g a wih ge r lz d
k, houl s e nd oo
n,
ag e r t i o l i t ne ai e
mus l pan.R.623- Dr (1 1) c plt d a ClnialA s e s e of Pai que tonnaie i
ce i
24. . 5- 11 om e e
u
i c
s s m nt
n
si
r n
Se e be 2011 i whih he r s
ptm r
,n
c
e ponde t onl one oft e que tonspos t hi a ofe e
do y
hr e si
ed o m nd f r d
no comment.l hi r pons t t one q si n he a we e he i c t d t tM c ila s
s n s es e o he
ue to
ns r d, ndia e ha
M lin'
pan wa s fcintt be ç sr c i t ade t pe f nna ofda l a tviis o wo k. R.
i
s ufi e o
û ta tng o qua e r o nce
di
iy c i te r r '
'
653.
Afe t ALJhea i M r Hnnks a ce tfe voc i
tr he
rng, .
, riid atonale ua i s cals,evaua e
val ton pe i it l t d
M c ila se pl
M lin' m oymentpot nta . co l
e i l He ncudedt t i f l a i Dr Ric e' opi onsas
ha , f uly doptng . thi s ni
t M c il n' f n to a l tto s a d b s d o h ra q ie j b s il fo h rp e ius
o M li s u cin l i ain , n a e n e c ur d o k ls r m e rvo
a
mi
e pl e a a pa ol c er s c no pe f m t r qui e en s of pos tons t t e s i
m oym nt s
yr l l k, he nn t r or he e r m t
ii
ha xi t n
s gnii a num be si t na i le onom y.See ce r ly R.71 735.
i t c nt
r n he tona c
ne a l
99 P1 i if alo poi s t a Decembe 20, 201l lte f om Dr. Richi t s deem s a
nt o
r
e tr r
a ntf s
t e hat he
fclrfca i ' i whi he pur t y expl ne t t hi pror opi on di not pr ntPl ntf fom
t a ii tony' n
ch
poredl
ai d ha s i
ni
d
eve
ai if r
r achi on an occasonalbass and t t t s r t iton s d dat back t a l t Jul 2009.The
e ng
i
i
ha hi esrc i houl
e
o t eas y
Co sin rc mgan ta telte i n tap r o tea miitaierc r a dta Panif a n t
mmiso e o lis h th etr s o at f h d nsrt e od n h t litf h s o
v
s
hown i was s lt t t Com m is one .The Com m isone f rt r cont ndst tt l t i nota
t
ubm ted o he
si r
s i r ' he
u
e
ha he eter s
clrfca i but a cha
a ii ton,
nge of opi on a t t i a
ni nd ha t ppear t have been aut ed Si an a t
s o
hor 'n
tempt t
o
s
eemi y contadi an A LJ' de son t ti s
ngl
r ct
S ci i ha s uppored by s t ntalevi
t
ubs a i
dence.'ECF No.1 at 1 l
'
4
2. n
any event t ltt i notpar oft r d bef e t Courq and t t Cour doesnotconsi i.
, he e er s
t he ecor
or he
hus he
t
der t
1 A s not d,t Appeal Counci dir ded Dr Richi s Sept
0
s
l segar
e he
.
t e'
ember201l eval i on t
uatons
he
gr un ta t y r ae t t pe i a trt r lv n tmepe id fr e al tng ds biiy ( c
o ds h t he eltd o he rod fe he ee a t i - ro o v uai ia lt whih
e d o De e e 31 201 ,Mc ila sdaeo ls i urd.
nde n c mb r , 0 M lin' t f a t ns e )
9
Att he ng,M c ila t sii d on he own be l.R.43- She e l i d t ts
he mi
M lin e tfe
r
haf
58.
xp ane ha he
so p dwo kn d t t eij re s s san di t S p e e 3 , 0 c ra cd n . 43
tp e r ig ue o h nu is he u ti e n he e tmb r 0 20 5 a c ie t R. .
S me o te e ijliswee ltra g a ae b he s c n c ra cd n o J l 4 2 0 . 5 ,
o f h s nt e r ae g rv td y r e o d a c ie t n u y , 0 9 R. 0
r
54.She t tfe t ts i bot r d by a aci te t ti ve t us ofhe a ms t the
esii d ha he s he e
ny tvii s ha nvol he e
r r , ha r
l and f etac s badl t ts ca ha dl sa R.44,47,a t to a çg
egs
e
he o
y ha he n r y t nd,
nd ha n çood d y' s
a ' he
doe 1a ltl pute i a ound' a t i t do a l d ofl und y.R . On a ba day,s st i
s $ ite t rng r
' nd res o
oa
a r
49.
d
he is n
he r lne a 1day.I Shet sii d t ts ge r ly ha t good daysi a a r ewee I
r eci r l
d.
e tfe ha he ne a l s wo
n n ve ag
k. d.
She a s doe no se p wela ni .She t tted t ts l ke t sr h i et rha t
lo s t l e
l t ght
esii ha he ac d he tengt n ihe nd o
b e k tes a o ami j g o s f d ik b t e R.5 , n as alg ddfiut wi o ehe d
ra h e l f l u r o t rn o t , 0 a d lo le e ifc ly t v r a
k
l
h
r a hi ai r ttvemotonswih he uppe e r m ii s R.
e c ng rd epe ii
i
t r
r xte te . 56.
11
1.
DI
SCU SSI
ON
l he a
n r ppea t t s Cour, M c ila s prma y a gum e i t ALJ e r d i
l o hi
t
M lin' i r r
nt s he
re n
dic i pori ns of Dr Ric e' r por, i t a c
s ountng
to
. thi s e t nse d hoosng t i he r pi k' wha t
i o i ry- c '
c
t o
i po at i o hi RFC.Rea ed y,s cai st ti he had gi n t e iey ofDr Ric e'
ncor r e nt s
lt l he l m ha f
ve he ntr t
. thi s
r por t ea weght't n t r s twoul be asi c t i M r Ha ns r por,t tt r i
e t t t i 'he he e ul
gr
d , ndi aed n . nki ' e t ha he e s
no a lbl wor M c ila c n pe f m a t s i dia e She alo m a st ge r
t vaia e k M li n a ror nd hus he s s bld.
s
ke he ne al
a gume t tt ALJf l t a yzet c
r
nt ha he
aied o nal he umultveefe tofa 1ofhe media pr e s See
ai fc
l
r
c l oblm .
cener l ECF N o.12.
alv
Th Co si n rr s nd t h ra g me t i is ml r j d me tmo in S e
e mmiso e epo s o e r u n s n t mmay u g n to . e
g neal ECF No 1 Fis,i ag e t a t e ALJ r a o a l rj ce t p rin o Dr
e rlv
. 4. rt t r u s h t h
e s n by ee td he o t f .
o
Ric e' pr f t lm iai t t Pl i if c
t hi s ofer d i t tons ha antf ount no pe f m a r ac ng be us a t t l
t ror ny e hi
ca e o a
pr l i a i ta 1r ac ngwasco r r t t m e ca evi nc ofr c d,i l nghi own
ecuson gans 1 e hi
nta y o he di l de e e or ncudi
s
te t ntrcor a he own t tmo Reaedl i ague t tt ALJpr ryrj td Dr
rame e ds nd r
esi ny. lt y, t r s ha he
ope l eece .
Ric e' o ni t Pli if woul mis wor of a l as t da pe mont d t pan,
t hi s pi on hat antf
d s
k
t e t wo ys r
h ue o i
be a et m e ca e de d d no s
c us he di l vi nce i t uppo tt s ve epan des rbe by Dr m t hi Fi ly,
r he e r i
ci d
. c e. nal
t Com misone c e t tt ALJ d ope l dee ned t tPl ntf r t i d t a lt
he
s i r ontnds ha he
t
pr ry tnni
ha ai if ea ne he biiy
t pe f m ot r wor ba e o t M e c lvocai na Gui lne and a i bl Socal
o ror
he
k s d n he di a to l
de i s
pplca e
i
Sec iy Rulngs' ECF No.1 a 2.
urt
i .
'
4 t
A.
TheA LJ' D e er i i oft W e ghtt B e G i n D n R ic e s Te tm ony
S t m naton
he i
o
ve
t hi ' s i
l Support By Subs antalEvi nc
s
ed
t i
de e
Mc ila tk s is e wi te ALJS RFC a d i pa t ua ,h s rj cin o t s
M lin a e su t h
h
'
n , n ri lr i ee to f ho e
c
p rin o DrRi heso iin t t ( )s ec ul n te g g i a y r a hng a d ()ta s e
ot s f
o
t i' pn o ha: 1 h o d o n a e n n e c i ; n 2 h t h
c
woul mi sm o et n t da ofwor pe mont duet pan.An RFC i a a s s nt bas
d s r ha wo ys
k r
h
o i
s n s es me , ed
upon al of t r e
l he elvante de e,of wha a cai
vi nc
t l mantc n sil do de pie he lmia i .20
a tl
s t r i ttons
C. R.jj404.5 41 945.Desrptonsa obsr ai ofa cai ntslmiai by he
F.
1 45, 9.
ci i nd e v tons
l ma ' i ttons
r
a b ot r m us be c i r aong wih medialr cor t as itt Comm isone i
nd y he s
t
onsde ed l
t
c e ds o ss he
si r n
dec di t wha e e a i pa r e ke ps a cl i a f om pe f m i pa tc a w o k
i ng o
t xt nt n m im nt e
a m nt r
r or ng ri ul r r
a tvii .l The ALJ dee mi t f t a r ol s i onsse i s bet e a cai nts
c i tes d.
tr nes he acs nd es ve nc it nc e
we n l ma '
ale d i r nt a he a lt t wor See Smih v.Chatr 99 F. 635,638 ( h Ci.
lge mpaime s nd r biiy o k.
t
e,
3d
4t r
1 ) A r viwi c tgi gratweghtt t ALJ' ase s n ofacama tsc e biiy
996 . e e ng our ves e
i o he
S s sme t
li n ' r di lt
and s d no i e f r wih t t a s s m e whe e t e denc i t r or s ppo t t
houl t nt re e t ha s e s nt
r he vi e n he ec d u rs he
ALJSc n lso s Se S i ey v He klr 7 9 F.d 9 7 9 9 9 ( t Ci.1 8 )(idn t a
' o cu i n . e h v l . c e, 3 2 8 , 8 - 0 4h r 9 4 fn ig h t
be us t ALJha t opporuniy t obs r et de nora t deer ne t c e biiy of
ca e he
d he
t t o e v he mea
nd o t mi he r di lt
t cama ,t ALJSobsr ai c r ngt s que tonsa et begi ngratweg .
he li nt he ' e v tons onceni he e si r o
ve e iht)
The r ul tons pr de t t a teai physc a s medial opi on i e il t
eg a i
ovi ha
r tng
ii n'
c
ni s ntted o
c r lng we gh whe e i i t ls
ontoli
i t
r t s d - uppore by m e cal ac e a e ci c la lbor t y
wtl
td
di ly c pt bl lnia nd a aor
di gnos i t c que a not i ons s e w ih t ot s t t a e de ' of r or 20
a
tc e hni s nd
nc it nt t he her ubsan i l vi nce ' ec d.
C. R.j41 927()2) 20C. R.j40 1 26()2) Ht e v.Suli n,993F. 31,35( hCi.
F.
6. c( ;
F.
4.5 c( ; mtr
lva
3d
4t r
1 .Not ng i t go r ng saut or rgulto ,howe r rquie t tmoe weg
992) hi n he veni tt e e ains
ve, e rs ha r iht
awa be gi n t t opi onsofte tng s ce .Raher 20 CFR.j 41 927( diecst
l ys
ve o he ni
rai our s t ,
6. d) r t he
ALJ t alo c i r whe dee m i ng how muc wei t as i a m e c opi on,t
o s onsde ,
n t r ni
h
ght o sgn
dial ni he
s
uppo tbiiy oft physc a s o ni t c itncy oft opi on wih t r c d,a
ra lt
he
ii n' pi on, he onsse
he ni
t he e or nd
wh t e te p y iin i a s e ils.S e 2 C. R.j 41 .2 ( )3 -5 ;s e as Hie v
eh r h h sca s p cait e 0 F. j 69 7 d ( )( ) e lo n s .
Ba a t45 F.d5 9 5 3( t Ci. 0 6 . us teFo rhCic i h se p an dta t r i
mh r, 3 3 5 , 6 4h r 2 0 ) Th ,h u t rut a x lie h t hee s
no ç ol e'r e t tgr t rwei s d be afo de t a tea i physc a s o ni n a
s ut ' ul ha eae
abs
ght houl
f r d o r tng
ii n' pi o nd
i ed,i m a be g ve l s w ei htti t r i pe s s ve con r r e denc ' Hi s 453 F. a
nde t y
i n e s g tf he e s r ua i
t a y vi t. ne ,
'
3d t
5 3 & n. (uoi Ht e v.S lia 9 3 F.d 31 35 ( t Ci.1 9 :.1,fre mpe t
6
2 q tng mtr u l n, 3 2 , 4h r 9 2 f o xn l, he
v
te tng physca s o ni n i not s ppo td o i ot r s i onssentwih t r co d St
rai
i in' pi o s
u re r s he wie nc it
t he e r t
i
s dbea or sg t ntyl sweght'Cr :v.Cha tr 76F. 585,590( h Ci.1 .
houl
cc ded inika l es i .' ai
re , 3d
4t r 996)
l a ALJ doe notgi co r lng w e g t a t ea i phys c a s opi on,t A LJ m us i ve
f n
s
ve nt oli
i ht o r tng
i i n'
ni he
td
gi
g o r a o s' f r t a d cso S e 2 C. R. j 4 4 1 2 ( )2 ; 41 9 7 d ( )
o d e s n ' o h t e iin. e 0 F. j 0 .5 7 d ( ) 6.2 ( )2 .
Ha ng r vi d t ALJ S r s ng on t s i s a t entr r or t Cour i
vi e ewe he
' ea oni
hi s ue nd he ie ec d, he
ts
c nc d t ts t ntale de es
onvi e ha ubsa i vi nc upporst ALJ' RFC a i pa tculr hi decson nott
t he
S
nd, n ri a , s ii
o
a
doptDr Ric e' pr e lmia i who1 cot Notbl t si nota c ewhe e t ALJ
. t hi s opos d i t tons
e- l h. a y, hi s
as
r he
sm pl f ie t c i r t te tng physcin' o ni To t conta y, t ALJ he e
i y al d o onsde he r a i
i a s pi on.
he
r r he
r
r e d c r f l Dr Ric e' o ni a a s s nts etme e a ni why i wasgi ng
eviwe a e uly . t hi s pi on nd lo pe om i xpli ng
t
vi
g ea we g t m uc ofDr Ric e' opi o a why ce t n a pe t oft topi on we e not
r t i ht o
h
. t hi s ni n, nd
rai s c s ha ni
r
e il t g e twe g . I pari ulr t ALJ e ane t tDr Ric e' a s s me oft
ntted o r a i ht n tc a , he
xpli d ha . t hi s s e s nt he
s vert of pa n a t co plt pr bii o r a ng confit d wih o he e de of
e iy
i nd he m e e ohi ton n e chi
lc e
t t r vi nce
r or a hi own team e no es
ec d nd s
r t nt t :
The o y lm ia i no e tr y s
nl i t ton t n iel uppored i t a da e of a 1
t s he voi nc
l
r c ng.The unde s g no e t tt s i no e i e y s
ea hi
r i ned t s ha hi s t ntr l uppore
td
as(
McMila hasa tedt beng a et wa hhe harwihout
linl
dmit o i bl o s r i t
difc t a t r t fr t t o s de slge i s M or ove ,
fi uly f e he i s w
houl r tr r e .
e r
1
2
team e no e s e ntt t s ge i de
r t nt t s ubs que o he ur res monsr e i r s d
tatd nc ea e
r nge of m o i n wih bia e a s ul r a s
a
to
t lt r l ho de s nd howe mus l
d
ce
s r ngt a i ac .
t e h s nt t
R.26- Thi c uson i s ppored by s t n i le de e i t r or I Ocobe 2009,
27. s oncl i s u
t
ubsa ta vi nc n he ec d. n t r
s ha a f lr nge ofm oton oft l ts de wih no i t lt an t r g s de ç ar
he d ul a
i
he ef houl r t
ns abiiy d he i ht houl r ç
ne
f l pa svef wa d ee ton,' ul i e na r a i a l ke onl t y degr esofe e a
' l s i or r lva i 'f l ntr l ot ton, nd ac d y went
u
e
xt m l
r ai R.58 Addii ly,Pl ntf t d he physc lt r piti De mbe 2009 t t s
ot ton.
0.
tonal ai if ol r
i a he a s n ce r
ha he
co d us bot ar st wa h he hai wihou pr e s R.360.I Ja r 2010,s r pored a
ul e h m o s r r t t oblm .
n nua y
he e t
sxt fve pe c nt i oveme o r l, but had s e sif s a a hi pan. R. 371.
i y-i
r e mpr
nt ve a l
om tfnes nd c ng i
Addii ly,i Aprl201 Pl i ifhad a f lpa sve r nge ofmoton oft rghts de ,
tona l n
i
0, antf
ul s i a
i
he i
houl r
be o e t slge y o he rghts de e n oc ured.
f r he tr r n r i houl r ve c r
Addii ly,Pli ifst si ony a t hea i di no i c t t ts had difc t
tona l a ntf e tm
t he rng d t ndia e ha he
fiuly
w ih a1 m a hi but f us d pr m a iy on ove he d r a hi as di m a of he m e ca
t 1 c ng,
oc e i r l
r a e c ng,
d ny
r di l
r or .R.370,656.M or ove ,he physca t r py e r iesi lt De mbe 2009 i ude
ec ds
e r r
i l he a xe cs n a e ce r
ncl d
s atd puleys c t pr s s and s a e hih r ,R.360,whih alr quier c ng.I s t
e e
l , hes, es e ,
e t d g ows
c l e r ea hi n hor,
t r i s tntale de t s
he e s ubsa i vi nce o uppor t ALJ S dee mi ton t tM c ila s RFC di not
t he
' t r na i ha
M li n'
d
pr cl alr a hi
e ude l e c ng.
As t M c ilan' r l e c e i t t t ALJ f l t consde t c
o
M li s eatd ont nton ha he
aied o
i r he umultve
ai
mediale de ,M c ilan doesnoti ntf i he bre wha s ii a tona e de t t
c vi nce M li
de iy n r i f t pecfc ddii l vi nce ha
t ALJ f ie t c i rhe woul r rhe dia e a t Cour' r vi w oft r or
he
a ld o onsde r
d ende r s bld, nd he
ts e e
he ec d
s s s t nta e de e t s
how ubs a i l vi nc o uppor t ALJ Sde s on.
t he
' ci i
B.
TheALJ Re onabl Rei d on t l pa i Voca i
as
y le
he m rtal
tonalExpe Tesi ony
rt tm
Fr t H e i
om he ar ng
As not M c ila a s a g t tt ALJere i f lng t c e tt r por ofhe
ed, M li n lo r ues ha he
r d n aii o r di he e t
r
VE,M r Hnnki ,a i t d c edii t t tmony oft VE fom t a nita i he rng.
.
ns nd nsea r tng he esi
he
r he dmi sr tve a i
l hi de a l d r por,M r Hn ns de c i s a num be of as e s e t a di nos i t s he
n s t ie e t . nki
s rbe
r
s s m n s nd ag tc ool
us d t e ua e M c ila s voc tonala lte .He alo c e t Dr Ric e' a s s m e of
e o val t
M lin'
ai
biii s
s r dis . t hi s s e s nt
M c ila s a lte ,i udi Ric e' c a ii d opi on, s e s a not 9,t t M c ila
M lin' biii s ncl ng thi s l rfe
ni
e upr
e
ha
M li n
r t i t a lt t r a on a oc aso lbass a t ha e on a fe
e aned he biiy o e ch
n c i na
i nd o ndl
r quen ba i,at
t s s lhough
s c de
he oul ngagt i no ove hea lfi Ba e on t s f nc i l lm iai ,M r Ha ns
n
r d itng. s d
he e u tona i t tons
. nki
o ned t tM c ila s S c to lba e ...woul be e r m ey s l be us t l r
pi
ha
M li n' E upai na s
oc
d
xte l ma l ca e he a ge
mao i o u s ild s d na yo c p to rq r bi n l e trt 'R. 3 . n n t ee s
j rt f n kle , e e tr c u ains e uie ma ua d x eiy. 7 4 He o eh ls
y
'
opi t t s c d pe f nn t pos ton of a s r il nce s t m m o t a a c lned ha he oul r o
he
ii
u ve la - ys e
nior nd
a lour
o r t ,a t tt et postonsa oun f ia
pe a or nd ha hes wo ii
cc t or lbout20, t 22, e o e postons
000 o 000 mpl ym nt ii
i t Unie Stt s a a
n he t d a e nd bout5 t 600 e pl
00 o
m oyme postons i Vigi m' R.734.He t
nt ii n r ni '
hus
c l d t t t f t ti r of f c dee m i s t t M s M c ila i lm ied t t de e
onc ude ha t he re
i
a t t r ne ha
. M li n s i t o he gr e
i c t d by Dr Ric e i i m y voc tona opi on t t s doe no r t i a e s t
ndi a e
. t hi , t s
a i l ni ha he
s t e an cc s o
oc upatonst te s i sgnii a numbe si t r i lo nai na ec
c i ha xit n i tc nt
r n he eg ona r to l onomy. R. 4' 73 35.
'
Fort r as t Cour ha ale y e a ne t ALJ Sdecson nott c e tce ti
he e ons he
t s r ad xpli d, he
'
ii
o r di ra n
a pe t of Dr Ric e' r por a t RFC f md by t ALJ a e s
s cs
. thi s e t nd he
ot
he
r uppore by s t nta
td
ubsa i l
e de e. Thus M r Ha ns opi on,whih utlze a dif r RFC,ne d notbe f l d.
vi nc
, . nki ' ni
c ii s
fe ent
e
olowe
The Com misone a s c r c l no est t e n i M r Ha ns'opi on we ec e t d,
s i r lo ore ty t ha , ve f . nki
ni
r r die
i s o t a t ee a e i fc j b t a e iti sg i n nl e s t tM c il n c ud
t h ws h t h r r n a t o s h t xs n in t t t r ha M li o l
ka
mb
a
pe f m .l pm iulr t Comm iso ri ntfest c est tsa f t pr ii t t
ror n
c a , he
s i ne de ii wo as ha t nd or he oposton ha
5 0t 6 0j bsae asg i a tn mb r S eECF No.1 a 1 ( ing Hik v.Caia ,6 0
0 o 0 o r in ûc n u e . e
4 t 4 ct
i
cs
lfno 0
F.d 1 4 ,1 51n. ( t Ci.1 7 )(W ed n ttik ta t ea p o i tl 1 0j b tsiid
2 0 8 0 2 4h r 9 9 $ o o h n h t h p r xmaey 0 o s e tfe
1
t byt voc tona e tconsiut a i inii n numbe .)a Cr i ev.
o he ai l xper
tt e n nsg fca t
r' nd aui Bowe 835F.
'
n,
2d
5 5 ( d Ci.1 7 (ttn ta 2 0 j b i t e rg o rp e e ta sg i c n n mb r.Th
6, 8 3 r 98 ) sai g h t 0 o s n h e in e r sn in t a t u e) e
i
Co r a r e ta t s c s s s g s te n mb r o j bs a albe p r Mr Ha kis ae
u t g e s h t he e a e ug et h u e f o v ia l, e . n n , r
s f e l numer t tt r i ava lbl wor f M s M c ila
ufkinty
ous ha he e s ia e k or . M lin.
Aspon e o tb t Co sin r mo e v r t e ALJh r dd no j tr l o te
itd u y he mmiso e , r o e, h
e e i t us ey n h
VE' t tmony,but alo l d t t grds a e ane t r s why t a tona
s esi
s ooke o he i nd xpl i d he ea ons
he ddii l
lm iatons i
i t i mpos d by Dr Ric e di no e ode t oc upai lba e f s ntr wor R.
e
. t hi d t r
he c tona s or ede a y k.
28 2 (uoe a ECFNo. 4a 1 1 )
- 9 q td t
1 t 4- 5 .
For a1 of t e r as ,t Cou tconcudes t t s t nta e de e s
1
hes e ons he
r
l
ha ubsa i l vi nc uppore t
td he
ALJS c n l so t a tee a e j bs i sg i n nu es i te r go a a d n to a
' o cu i n h t h r r o n in t t mb r n h e in l n ai n l
ka
ec
onomi s t M cM ila c n peror a t t tt ALJ' fndi of non- s biiy fnds
e hat
li n a
f m nd hus ha he
S i ng
dia lt
s tnta s
ubsa il uppo ti t r co d.
r n he e r
l
V.
CONCLUSI
ON
TheCour ha detr i t tt ALJ' de ii i s
t s e m ned ha he
S c son s uppore by s t ta e de e.
td
ubsan i l vi nc
The e or t Cour G R AN T S t Com m i soner sM oto f r Stm m a y J
r f e, he
t
he
si '
in o z
r udgm e ,ECF N o.
nt
13, DENI t Pl ntf sM oton f Sum ma yJ
and
ES he ai if
i or
r udgm e t ECF N o.11
n,
.
A n a o i t Or rs l i s t sda
ppr pr a e de ha l s ue hi y.
'
,
ENTER: Thi ' a ofM a c 201
s C' y
r h, 4.
J ,?'
,'
? y.'
y
,
' s ,w + y
.
Hon. a e C.Ttr
Jm s
lk
Se orUnied St t Diti tJ
ni
t
aes src udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?