Barbati v. Warden, USP Lee County

Filing 44

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 07/05/2013. (kab)

e pv s OFFI U. , sT. lr
a
CE s Dl m I
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

-.
,,

J !. 2 1
UL 15 93
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTER N DISTW CT O F V I G I A
R M
R O AN O K E DI I O N
V SI
N I O LA S BA R BAT I
CH
,

Jutl C.
A
BY:
DEP

Y,
CLERK

GL
ERK

CA SE N O .7: 3CV 00048
1

Pe i i r,
t tone
M EM O R AN D U M O PI I N
N O

.

VS.

W A RD EN ,U SP L EE CO UN TY ,

By: G l n E.C onrad
e
C hi U nied St es Di tri Judge
ef t
at
s ct

R espondent
.

N ihol sBa ba i af r li t pr e ngpr K ,fl t spe ii f awrtof
c a r t, ede a nma e oce di
o
ied hi tton or
i
.

ha scor , s ntt 28U. C.j2241 a srt t tt cac ai ofhi tnnof
bea pus purua o
S.
, se i ha he lulton
ng
se
c i me byt Btr uofPrs (t 'doe noti l prorc t c e tt wlihhe
onfne nt he lea
ions :
BOP' s ncude i usody r di o lc
)
he e r he our oncl s ha r t a l o t t a t
i e il 1 Upon r viw oft r co d, t c tc ude t tBa ba if ist s a e f c son
s ntted.
e e

whihhei enildt ha asr le t rj2241.
c
s tte o be eif mde
I

A ut r te i V ol i Co y,Fl i ar e t d B a ba ion J y 2,2009,f pos e s on of
ho ii s n
us a unt orda r s e
r t
ul
or s s i

coc ne pos e so ofna c i e pme ,a de i ng s
ai , s s i n
r otc qui nt nd rvi uppor fom pr tt i i Cas No.
tr
osiuton n e

1 Ba b t fldt sj2 p ttoni t Unie SaesDititCou t o t eM idl Dititof
r a i ie hi 241 eii n he td tt src r f r h d e src
Fl i and i wastans e r t t Unied Sàt Diti Cour f t Sout n Diti ofW es
orda,
t
r f r ed o he t
es srct
t or he
her srct
t
V igi a becaus pe ii wasconfne brefy i t tdititwhie i tanst On Febr y 5,2013,t
r ni,
e ttoner
i d i l n ha src
l n r i.
uar
he
cas waskansered t t scourtbe e Bar iwast confned a t Unied St esPe t i y i
e
f r o hi
caus
bat
hen
i
t he t at
nientar n

Le Cou t CC Le Cou t', r ni wihnt sc ur'j idito Thi c ur sbsiue t
e ny USP e ny' Vigi w ti hi o ts urs cin. s o t u tttd he
)
w a den ofUSP Le Count ast r pondentand r r a r pons t Bar t ' petton. Bar iwas
r
e
y he es
equied es e o ba is ii
bat
lt tans ered t USP At t ri Calf ni and i curenty confned t r
a er r f r o
wa e n ior a
s r l
i he e.

Or n rl t peiine ' c nvn c t dini t pr e r po ntt a j22 p tto Se
dia iy,he tto rs u t uso a s he op r es nde o
41 e iin. e

Ru f l v. dil,5 2U. 4 ( 00 .Thewade o USP Le Co t ha n tr ie a obe ton
msed Pa la 4 S. 26 2 4)
r nf
e un y s o as d ny j ci
rgadigj idito a ha fldamoint dimis Mor v rbe a s Babai c fne i t
e r n urs cin nd s ie
to o s s. eo e, c ue r twas oni d n he
W eser Diti ofVigi aatt tm et scour r ved hi pe ii t cour concl t hi
t n srct
r ni he i hi
t ecei
s tton, he
t
udes hat s

s squ n ta frt Caiori ddno dee thic r'j idci t a rs hi j22 cams L=
ube e trnse o lf na i t fa t s ou t ursiton o ddes s 41 li . d.
s
at442443.

1 03361 cFA Es. H e w a r l s d on bond t ts m e day. Count aut ii ar e t d
009
8
2
s e ea e
ha n
y hortes r s e

Ba baia i o Oc obe 15,
r t ga n n t r 2009, elt d t t s me c s andagan,r l s d hi on bond t
r a e o he n
a e,
i eea e m
he

smeda OnAprl20,201 t Vol i CounyCic ts ntnc Babait sxmont ( 0
n
y.
i
0,he usa
t rui e e ed r t o i
hs 18
da )i prs f t sstofc r . Babair c ve t da ofprorc t cedit r
ys n ion or hi e hages3 r t e ei d wo ys i usody r t owad
t ssntnce f J y2a Ocobe 1 2009(heda whe hewa ar tda r e ed)
hi e e , or ul nd t r 5,
t ys n
s rese nd elas .
Vol i Cot y a horte r ese Ba ba ion M a c 1 201 f G
usa mt ut iis
td r t
r h 2, 0, or s
domesi vi e ei
tc olnc n

CaeNo. 01 0 40 0M M AES. M . s Ex. , t 6 Hewa c n itdo t i c a g a d
s
2 0 3 3
' Dim. 1 a ! .
'
s o vce n h s h r e n
s nt nc d o M a 5,201 t 55 da i pr s tw ih c edi f tm e s r d f dom e tc ba t r
e e e n y
0, o
ys n i on, ç t r t or i e ve or
s i te y
i Cas N o. 201 034030M MAES.4 JLa !(.
n
e
, - t k
, I
0
-

Fe a a t ii t r d'Ba ba iunde a wrtofhabe c pusadpr e ndum
der l u hortes t owe ' r t
bor
r
i
as or
os que
on M a 13,
y
2010,s t the coul f ce f de a cha ge i t U nied St t Di t i tCour f t
o ha
d a e r l r s n he t
a es sr c
t or he

M i eDiti ofFl i W hieBa baiwast G l n't f de ala hortes t r ei d
ddl srct
orda.
l r t
hus l oa ' o e r ut ii , hey ec ve
on

2 Thewar haspr de t i or a i s marzed he e r di Bar iscour
den
ovi d he nf m ton um
i
r egar ng bat'
t
pr
oceedi i r i
ngs, n elance on a afi vi fom a corectonalpr amsspeci itw ih t BOP'
n fda t r
r i
ogr
als t he
s

de i ai a s ne ec uttonc n e;Ba b t' Pr sntnc I si to Re or CTS ', ih
sgn ton nd e tnc omp a i e tr r ais e e e e nvetgain p t R' whc
)
hasnotbeen pr ded t t courq and ot s
ovi o he
her upportng docum e aton.W hieBa ba isalegatons
i
nt i
l r t' l i
diput s
s e ome f t fom t ss mar asnot t diput f t a enotmat i t t cour '
ac s r hi um
y,
ed, he s ed ac s r
eral o he
ts
det mi ton t Bar isf t alega i f lt demonsr t i opercal a i ofBa ba ispror
er na i hat bat' acual l tons ai o
t ae mpr
culton
r t' i
cusody cr tby f alofk i s. Ther or t cour fndsno need t expand t r d by r rng
t
edi
eder l al
ef e, he
ti
o
he ecor
equii
t wa de t s i t PSR orany ot a tonaldocum e aton.
he r n o ubm t he
her ddii
nt i
3 A lhough Bar iass rt t the wasa ted oft oft t ee c gest war n des i
t
bat e s ha
cquit
wo he hr har he de
crbes
i t sc e,Bar t doesnotdiput t l h oft s ence i
n hi as
ba i
s e he engt
he ent
mpos ort s enci dat t war
ed he ent ng e he den
pr desf t cas
ovi or he e.
4 Thewar sdoc
den'
umentton i ca est t scas concer a c get Ba ba ihad
a i ndi t hat hi e
ned har hat r t

vi ae p e a r la ec ndii .M . s . 1 Ata h. a 7( No. 4- .Ag i ho ve,
oltd r lil ee s o tons Dim Ex. , tc B, t ECF 3 3) an, we r
Bar idoesnotdi et l ngt oft s e i pos ort s nt ng da et war pr des
bat
sput he e h he ent nce m ed he e enci
t he den ovi
f t case.
or he

2

i or ton i c tng t thi sa es nt nc ha e r on Aug t26, 201 5 OnNovembe
nf ma i ndia i ha s tt e e e d xpied
us
r
0.
30, 0, heDiti tCour i Fl i s nt nc Ba ba it t e co uren t msof48 mont
201 t
src
t n orda e e ed r t o hr e nc r t er
hs
i pr s f c
n i on or onveyi f l e i or a i a hoa flng a f s c a m w ih t I e a Re nue
ng a s nf m ton nd x, ii
al e l i
t he nt m l ve

Se vie, ma ng af s dites c l
r c and ki
ale sr s al.
Acc di t t wa de sevi nce f pu pos ofs nt ncec c ai Ba ba is
or ng o he r n' de , or r es e e
alul ton, r t'
f de a s e c me e on t da ofhi f der ls nt nci N o mbe 30,201 a he
e r l entnce om nc d he y
s e a e e ng, ve r
0, nd
be n s r i t ts nt nc on t tda e I a ton, r c ve 95 daysofprorc t cr di
ga e vng ha e e e ha t . n ddii he e ei d
i usody e t
f tm e s r e fom A ug t27, 0, he da afe hi sa e s nt nc e r d,t tlN ove ber
or i e v d r
us
201 t
y t r s t t e e e xpi e m i
m

29 2 0 t ed ybeo eh sf d rls ne c c mme c d r aisc re t rj ce rla e
, 01 ,h a f r i e ea e tn e o n e .Bab t' u r n p o e td ee s
daei M a 24, 201 6
t s y
4.

Li r lyconsnld, r t' j2241s si asett f l ngovelppi
be al
t e Ba bais
ubmisons s r he olowi
ra ng

g omdsf rr l f ()teBt e uo Prs n (%OP' t a ul c mp tdh ssn e c ; b t
r t o ei : a h l a f io s t ' mlwf ly o u e i e tn e ( ) he
e
r
)
BOP t a ul d ne hm p irc so yce i; n ()t eBOPr v k do r f s dt ce i
mlwf ly e id i ro u t d r dt a d c h
e o e r e t e o r dt
z
hi wih g tme hee ne , ors ul ha e r dt rsa el 7 Ba ba ihasa s tl a
m t ood i
nr d
l o ied
ho d ve n ne mde t t aw. r t

pla igsye a aû to f rsl r u g n . I hi s b si n , r ai s e t ta h
e dn t ld s t in o l
mo
mmayj d me t' n s u miso s Ba b t a s rs h t e
'
i entte t a addii l18 daysofpro c t c edi ag ns hi f de a s t nc bec us
s ild o n
tona 0
i r usody r t ai t s e r l en e e, a e
a1 ofhi s a e a f de als nt nc w e e i pos d t r n co ur e l
1
s t t nd e r e e es r m
e o u nc r nty.Se r t l he as e t
pa a e y,
s rs
5 A s nt e cal aton m e o ata d t t war sm oton i c est tf r ofi al
e enc cul i
m
tche o he den'
i ndiat ha ede al fci s
verfe w ih sat ofi al by t e
iid t t e fci s elphone t tBa ba issa e s ence ended on Augus 26,2010.M .
ha r t' t t ent
t

Dim. 1 Ata h. a 7( No. 5- .
s Ex. , tc D, t ECF 3 2)
I i notcl rfom t r d wha ot f alcrmi s nt
ts
ea r he ecor
t her eder i nal e encesBar t may have f d,i
ba i
ace n
a ton t t t years e ati s he e.
ddii o he woent nce s ue r
7 Thewar n as erst Bar if l t exhaus adm i s r i r
de s t hat bat aied o
t
nitatve emedi ast t good
es o he
conduc cr tas tofhi petton. Ther e f m sa t hed t t petton r l ,however t t
t edi pec
s ii
em dy or tac
o he ii etect
, ha

Bar idi r s t is ofgood conduc tme durng t a i s r i r
bat d aie he s ue
ti
i he dm nitatve emedi pr es Thus, he
es oc s.
t
cour cannotfnd fom t r d t tt war n hasesabls l k ofe us i asa gr
t
i r he ecor ha he de
t ihed ac
xha ton
ound f
or
di mi aloft sas tofBa ba iscl m .
s ss
hi pec
r t' ai
3

t the sgnedpa r k i c tng t thi sa es nt nc e d on M a 13, 1 t day
ha
i
pe wor ndia i ha s tt e e e nde
y 20 0, he
f de a ofk i sboco
e r l t al
wedhi on a wrt a ass h, s dr c vef r c e tfom M a
m
i, nd uc he houl e ei ede al r di r
y
13t Augus 26, 0. I t ale a i , hea gues i hewa sils vi hi sae s nt nce
o
t 201 8 n he t m tve
r ,f
s tl er ng s t t e e

durngt ttm e t rsat l w, wa e il t 60 da ofgood c
i ha i , mde t e a he s ntted o
ys
onduc c edi a i tt
t r t ga ns he
sa etme,whi h wo d ha al d hi t c
tt i
c
ul ve lowe m o ompl t t sa es nt nc s nert Augus 26,
ee he tt e e e oo han
t
9
t
ae
s o s s he tto
2010. The Unied St t s m ove t di m i st pe ii n, and Ba ba ihasr ponded,m aki t
r t
es
ng he

m a trrpe f c i r to
te i or onsde a i n.
11

Thebr des ofBa ba isa gum e t f rprorc t cr di a s t t tbec us t
oa t
r t' r
n s o i usody e t s ers ha
a e he
f r la sa es nt esa e E oncure , hes d r ceve c e ta ns li f r s nt nc
ede a nd t t e enc r t
c
r nt'
' houl e i r di gai t ls ede al e e e

fra1 h j itmeh s r e .Th fcso hi c s , o v r d no s p o thi cam.
o 1t e al i e ev d e a t f s a e h we e , o t u p r t s li
l af de als ntncei i pos d t nm co ure l wih a e si sa es ntnc t
f e r e e
sm e o
nc r nty t n xitng t t e e e,he
BOP m a desg t t tt i m a ewils vehi f de a s nt nc a t sa eprs f iiy
y i nae ha he n t l er
s e r l e e e t he tt ion aclt
whe ehei s r i t sa es ntnc t alowi hi t a c u c e tagans bot s ntnce .
r
s e vng he t t e e e,hus l ng m o c r e r di i t h e e s

S e 1 U. C. 3 21b ;
e 8 S. j 6 ( ) BOP P oga S ae n 5 6 0 Th s cru tnc sddn taiei
r rm ttme t 1 0.5. e e ic msa e i o rs n
Ba baisca e. Hi f r s ntncewa i
r t' s
s ede al e e
s mpos o Nove be 3 201 a trBa ba iha
ed n
m r 0, 0, fe r t d
c plt d hi sa es nt nc a wasno l ri sa ec t y. M or ve , l t f de al
om e e s tt e e es nd
onge n tt usod
eo r whie he e r

j g n idc tsta t efd r l e tn e a et r nc n u rn l t e c oh r i d e n t
ud me t n iae h t h e ea s n e c s r o u o c re ty o a h t e ,t o s o

8 I t adm i sr i r
n he
nitatve emedy f m sata
or
tched t Ba ba ispe ii , he as erst thi sat
o r t' tton
s t ha s t e

s ne ee e onJ e2 201 j2 Pe. tc A, t3.
e tnc nd d un 9, 0. 241 t Ata h. a

9 Babaia s rsi hi mo in frs
r t se t n s to o ummayj dg ntt tbe a s hi o fns c nd tf on of
r u me ha c u e s fe e o uc or e
t sat c geswasaneces r Epal oft ofkns conduc 'f t f alc ge,he s d r ve
he t e har
sa y û ' he l e
t
t' or he eder har
houl ecei
cr tf t sat s e agai tt f der s e
edi or he t e ent nce
ns he e al ent nce.Thi alega i whi i notcl l desgna ed
s l ton, ch s
eary i t

a asq rt cam i Bab t' p tin a p ast a srac aln et tev l i o tefd rl
s e aae li n rais eio , p er o set h l g o h ai t f h e ea
t
e
dy

c cton and/ s enceasi pos Such acl m m us be r s d i a moton t vacat s asdeor
onvi l
or ent
m ed.
ai
t ai e n
i o
e, et i

c re tt s ntn eu e 28U. C. 2 i t s ntn ngc ur, eel r J ne , F.d328 3
o rc he e e c nd r
S. j 255 n he e e ci o ts n e o s 226 3
, 33
(t Ci.000 , n wiln tbea d e sd h r .
4 h r2 ) a d l o
d rse ee
4

i c t t tt f der ls nt nc ar t r n co ure l wih a s nt ncefom a he
ndia e ha he e a e e es e o u nc r nty t ny e e
r
not r

j rs ito Fo t e er a o s t efc ta o eo b t o Bab t' saes ne e wee
u idcin. r h s e s n ,h a t h t n r o h f r ais tt e tnc s r
i
mpos d t r n conc r nty wih ot rs ntnc doe notafe tt caculton ofhi f r l
e o u
ure l t he e e es s
f c he l a i
s ede a
s ence.
ent

Bar t ne a s rst thes d r c vec e ta i thi f de a s nt nc f a1tm e
ba i xt s e t ha
houl e ei r di ga ns s e r l e e e or 1 i
s ve a t M a 1 201 whe f der la hortesi r d'hi t
er d fer y 3, 0, n e a ut ii ç owe ' m mdert a pr e ndlm
bor
he d os que l
wrt l e s nc Ba ba ia lgest tf r lofi i l,i cac ai t lngt ofhi tr of
i. n s e e, r t le ha ede a fc as n lul tng he e h
s em
confne e unde t 1 da s ntnc i pos Aprl20, 0,f l t r ogni t thehad
i m nt
r he 80- y e e e m ed
i 201 aied o ec ze ha

sgne pa r k i c tng hi sae s nt nc wasc m plt asofM a 13,201 I t
i d pe wor ndia i
s tt e e e
o ee
y
0. n he
at m ai he a gue t the s d havebe n c e t d wih good c
le tve, r s ha
houl
e r die t
onduc c e tundersae 1w
t r di
tt a
t r duc t l ngt oft ss nt nc by 1 da f e r 30 da s r e
o e e he e h hi e e e
0 ys or ve y
ys e v d.

To c c aewha ,i a addii lpe i ofprs tme s r edm us be c e t d
alult
t f ny, tona rods
ion i e v
t r die
agans Bar t' f de a prs n s t nc ,t c tm us deer newhen t saer lnquihe
i t ba is e r l io en e e he our
t t mi
he t t ei s d
prmar cusody ofhi . I i wele t bls d t t
i y t
m t s l sa ihe ha

()fd r l e tn ed e no b gnt r n. . e ap io e i saec td i
a e ea s ne c o s t e i o u . wh n rs n r n tt uso y s
pr uc d f pr e uton i f de alc t s ntt a f r lwrtofha as
od e or os c i n e r our pur ua o ede a i
be

c r sa pr s q e dl Rah r t esaerti p i r j rs ito o e t e
opu d o e u n l
m. te ,h tt eans rmay u idcin v r h
prs ne ,a f r lc t c
io r nd ede a usody omm e sonl whe t sae a horte
nce
y
n he t t ut ii s
r lnquiht prs
ei s he ioneron s if c i oft sa eoblgai n. Se Thom a v.
atsa ton he t t
i to
e
s

W hae 962F. 358,361n.3(t Ci.1 2)
ln,
2d
4h r 99 .

Untd Sae v. a , 5 F.d9 8 91 (t Ci.1 9 ) ûA)fd r l i o h b a c r usa
ie tts Ev ns 1 9 3 0 , 2 4h r 9 8 . : e ea m t f a e s op d
(
pr eq ndlm meey l nst prs rt f r a hortes'a doesnottr f ml1asae
os ue l rl oa he ione o edeal ut ii ' nd
t ansor
t
tt
prs ne i oafde a prs r'I (iai o te .
io r nt e r l ione ' d. cttons mitd)

5

Be us s eofi a sr e t d a deai d Ba baio M a ch 1 201 t sa eha
ca e ut fcil
se nd t ne r t n r 2, 0, he t t d

p i t j rs ito o rhm u tlh c mpltdhssges ne e .0 M o e v r a jn a te
rma. u id cin ve i n i e o ee i tt e tnc s1
y
ro e , s o g s h
saertie p i r c so y hec n iu dt s r eh ssaeo lg to s e e wh l s be t o
tt ean d rmay u t d , o tn e o ev i tt bi ai n , v n ie u j c t
t f de ala pr e nd wr t nl afe he co pl t d hi sa e s nt nc a s a e
he e r d os que um i.O y t r
m e e s t t e e es nd t t

a ho ii sr lnq s dprm a y c t on Augus 26,201 di hi ofi i lde e i on t
ut rte ei uihe i r usody
t
0, d s fc a t nton he
f de alc r s be n.
e r ha ge ga
Ba ba ihasno cl i t tBOP ofk i l m i c l ul t hi t r ofc i m e on t
r t
a m ha
t a s s a c a ed s e m
ontne nt he

sa es n e . BOP ofk i sha no r ponsbiiy o a hort f de e m i ngt a o mtof
t t e t nce
t al ve es i lt r ut iy or t r ni he m t
good c
onduc tm eunde s e lw t becr die a ns hi sa es nt e orf rfgtrngout
ti
r ut a o
e t d gai t s t t e enc
o i li
whe hec
n
omplt d hi sa es nt e. Theoblga i t complt s h c l ultonsf lst
e e s tt e enc 11
i ton o
e e uc a c a i a l o

a opraesaeofkil,ba e onr or fo t saec t a t saeprs orj l
ppr it tt t as s d ec ds r m he tt ours nd he tt ions ais
i ved i Ba ba issa ec i na pr ee ngsa c t
nvol n r t' t t rmi l oc di
nd usody. M or ve ,Ba baidoe no r f t
eo r r t s t e u e
t wa de se de ofsa ea ho ii s r por t BOP ofk il t tBaba issae s nt nc
he r n' vi nce t t ut rte ' e t o
t a s ha r t' t t e e e
wasco plt d on Augus 26,201 BOP ofi i sc d rg f l r l on t ss nt e
m ee
t
0.
fcal oul i htuly ey
hi e enc
c
ompl ton da ea r pored t t m by sa ea horte .
ei
t s e t o he
t t ut iis
ThegitofBa ba ispeii n i t tt BOP di notgi hi alt prorc t c edi
s
r t' tto s ha he
d
ve m l he i usody r t
t whih he wase tted. Thef ct hea lges howe r a enots t i ntt de
o c
n il
a s le ,
ve , r
ufk e o monsr t any
tae
micac a i unde t a ia ef r lsaut s
s lul ton
r he pplc bl ede a tt e .
Ca c a i oft prorc t y c e tade e ntm a r cevea i thi f r l
l ulton he i usod r di
f nda
y e i gans s ede a

s ne c i g v m e b j3 8 ( ) whihsae :
e tn e s o e d y 5 5 b , c tts
1 Ba ba ias erst he wasaresed on M ar h 1 , 2010,on bot sat and f r char . The
0 r t s t hat
r t
c 2
h te
ede al ges

po sbii t a h ha c a g sfo bohj rs cinsp ndnga t etmeofhi ar s,h ve , e no
s i lt h t e d h r e r m t u idito e i t h i
y
s re t owe r do s t
change t f tt Vol i Count ofk i sa r t and det ned hi on t dat gi ngt sat
he ac hat usa
y f al r esed
ai
m
hat e, vi he t e

pi r j rs cinov rhi
rmay uidito e m.
1 B a ba iciesno aut iy i s
1 r t t
hort n uppor ofhi vagu ass rton t tBOP of i al s d appl
t
s
e e i ha
fci s houl
y
good conduc tm e aut i unde Fl i 1w agai thi f r t m ofc i
ti
horzed
r orda a
ns s ede al er
onfnement
.
6

(
b)

Cr tf prorcusody.- dee nts l be gi n ce tt r t
edi or i
t -A fnda hal
ve rdi owad he
s r i e of a t r of i prs e f a tm e he ha s nt i of i i
e vc
em
m i onm nt or ny i
s pe n f c al
de e i prort t da e t s nt e co m enc t nton i o he t he e enc m
es

()
1

a a r s t of t ofe e f whih t s nt e was
s eul
he fns or c he e enc
i
mpos d'o
e ,r

()
2

a ars l o a oh rc ag f rwhc ted fn a twa
s e ut f ny te h r e o ih h e e d n s
a r s ed a tr t c m i s on of t of e e f r w li h t
r e t fe he om s i
he f ns o tc he
s t nc wasi
en e e
mpos d;
e

t tha not en c e t d agans a t rs nt nc
ha s be r die
i t nohe e e e.

1 U. C.j 3585. I t s sci t
8 S.
n hi e ton, ç
congrs ma cla t ta dee ntc d notrc ve
e s de e r ha
fnda oul
e ei

d u ec e i f rhi d tni ntme' ie S ae v W is n 5 3U. 3 , 3 ( 9 2 .Th ,
o bl rdt o s ee to i .
'Untd tts . lo , 0 S. 29 3 7 1 9 ) us
by sa ut t BOP c nno gr ntprorc t c edi f tme s r d bef r c
tt e, he
n t a
i usody r t or i e ve
o e omm e me of
nce nt
t de e
he f ndan ' f der l s nt nc , i t prs r ha r e ved c e t f t t c t
t s e a e e e f he i one s ec i
r di or ha us ody t a d
ow r

a t e sn e c .Uni dS ae v Br wn, 7 F.d 5 4,1 9 W L 2 7 7 , t*1( t Ci. 9 2
noh r e tn e
t tts . o 9 7 2 7 9 2
e
3 2 5 a 4h r 1 9 )
( n u ls e )(id n d fn a tma r c iece ia an th sfd r l e tnc f rtmes e ti
u p b ih d fn i g ee d n y e ev r dt g is i e ea s n e e o i p n n
ofi i de e i prort t da e hi s ntnc c
fcal t nton i o he t s e e e omm e es t e s i has be n c edied a ns
nc mls t
e r t gai t

a oh rsn e c )
n t e e tn e.
Bar t' f r ls nt nc co me e on No mbe 30,201 t dae whe i was
bais ede a e e e m nc d
ve r
0, he t
nt

i o e . j3 8 () Un e j3 8 () h c udr c i ce ia ans hsfd r l e tn ef r
mp s d 5 5 a . d r 5 5b , e o l e eve r dt g i t i e ea s ne c o
a pe i ofofk i de e in s r d be or Novembe 30,
ny rod
t al t nto e ve f e
r 2010,f whi h hedi notr ceve
or c
d
e i
sat s nt nc c e t co di t sa eofk i s r por t t BOP,Ba ba idi notco plt
t e e e e r di.Ac r ng o tt t al' e t o he
r t d
m ee
li sae s nt nc untlAugus 26,
ls t t e e es i
t 2010. Se dc ofhi sa es nt esbega upon hi a r s
r e
s tt e enc
n
s ret
a c i d durng t tmebe we n M a 1 a Aug t26, 0,at h f de a ofk i s
nd ontnue
i he i
t e
y 3 nd
us
201 lhoug e r l t al
t n ha physc lc t ofBa ba iunde t wrtofha asc usadpr eque l .Be a e
he d
i a usody
r t
r he i
be om
os ndlm
c us

heha notde onsr t d t thedi no r ceve c edi a ns hi sa es nt nc f t tpe i
s
m ta e ha
d t e i r t gai t s t t e e es or ha rod

7

oftme Ba baiha no de onsr t t thei e il d t r eve prorc t c e tagans hi
i , r t s t m taed ha
s ntte o ec i
i usody r di i t s

fd r l e tn efrt t ro 1 j? g (;
e e a s n e c o ha peid.2 5 5j .
)
Fort r as sa e t c t ncude t tBar t ha notsa e f t on whih he i
he e ons tt d,he our co l s ha
ba i s
tt d ac s
c
s

e ildt rlefunde j2241 The eor,t c t a st wrde smotont dimisand
ntte o ei
r
. r f e he our gr nt he
n' i o s s

d n e Bab t' moin f rs mmm.j g n .Ana p o raeo d rwil n e t sd y
e is r ais to o u
y ud me t
p r p it r e l e tr hi a .
The Clr i die t t s nd co e oft sm e a um opi on a a ompa ng or rt
e k s r ced o e
pis hi mor nd
ni nd cc
nyi
de o
pe ii nera t c elofr co d f t r ponden .
tto
nd o ouns
e r or he es
t

E TR Ti Gp dy f >& 1.
N E : hs d aoJ , 3
:
ChifUnie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge

1 Babaic mpai t tt fd rlsne igj getl hi hewo drc i pirc so y
2 r t o l ns ha he e ea e tncn ud od m
ul eeve ro utd
cr tf tme s ved bet
edi or i er
ween M a 1 a Augus 26,2010.Beca et BOP, and nott dit itcour
y 3 nd
t
us he
he src
q
i gr nt aut iy t cal at t m sofcontnementa prorcusody cr t however aj ge'
s a ed hort o cul e er
i
nd i
t
edi
,
ud s

c mme t a ou s n e c ce tc nn te il Ba b t t r le un rj22 .Uni d S ae v. ilr 8
o n s b t e t n e r di a o ntte r ai o eif de
41
t tt s M le , 71
e
F.d 48 , 9- 0( t Ci.1 9)
2 8 48 9 4h r 98 .
8