Smith v. Owens et al

Filing 28

ORDER adopting Report and Recommendations re 20 ; Smith's objections are OVERRULED; denying 1 Motion for Preliminary Injunction. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 4/5/2013. (tvt)

cLERn OFFI U.S. SQ COUA
CE
DI
AT RoANou ,
vA
FI
LED

AF û5 2 1
R
23
I TH E U NI
N
TED STA TES DI
STR I T C O U RT
C
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRICT OF W RGI A
NI
ROANO KE DI SI
VI ON
BR AN D O N R R O D SM I ,
TH
Pl ntf ,
ai if
V.

OFFI
CER OW ENS e al,
t .
D ef
endant .
s

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

J A
BYULI c.

t RK
.

:

DEP

Ci lA c i N o.7: v00060
vi t on
13c
O R D ER A D O PTIN G R EPO R T

AND RECOM M ENDATI
ON
By:Sam ue G . is
l W l on
U nie St e Di t i tJudge
t d at s s r c

Br ndon J r Smih, Vigni i t pr e ngpr s ,brngst sa ton plrln t
a
e od
t a r i a nma e oce di
/ e i hi c i zslnt o

42U. C.j 1 a i tt e W alnsli Stt Prs core tona ofi as algi t tt
S.
983 gans hre le kdge ae ion rci l fcil, le ng ha he

o t asp y ial a sule hm.S t tldamoin frap ei nayij n to s e iga
fkil h sc ly sa td i mi ie
h
to o rlmi r n u ci n e kn n
or rt pr t c hi fom t de e nt. Thecour t ok Sm ih' moton unde ad s me a
de o o e t m r he f nda s
to
t s i
r vie nt nd
r f r e i t M a sr t J
e e r d t o gita e udgePa ea M ea Sa ge f aRe ta Rec
m l
de r nt or
por nd
omm e ton
nda i

ptrua t 28U. C.j636( ( )B)
ls nt o
S.
b)1( .
TheM a sr t J
gita e udgehel ahea i on t ma tra fld ar por fndi t tSm ih
d
rng he te nd ie e t i ng ha
t
hasf ie t de o tae alkei
a ld o m nsr t i lhood ofir par bl ha m ors e so t m e is a
re a e r
ucc s n he rt , nd

rc mme dn t thec u t e yS t smoinf rij n tv r l f S t ha fld
e o n ig ha t o r d n mi
h' to o nu cie ei mi s ie
e
h
o j cin t t Ma itaeJ d esrp r a rc mme d t n.S t so j ci n s o t a
b e to s o he gsrt u g ' e o t nd e o n ai mi b e to s h w h t
o
h'
he i no l rho edatW a lnsRi Stt Prs butt tt Vigi aDe rm e of
s onge us
le
dge a e ion,
ha he r ni pa t nt
Co r to hasta f redhi t Sus e ISt t Prs e f c i y mootng hi c am f
reci ns
r ns e r
m o s x a e ion, fe tvel
i
s l i or

ij n tv r le.Ha i r ve dt eRe o t n Re o n ain S t so j ci n , n
nu cie eif vng e iwe h p r a d c mme d to , mi b e to s a d
h'
pe tnen por i oft r or t c t e s w ih t M a sr t J
ri t tons he ec d, he our agr e t he gi ta e udge' r om m e ton.
s ec
nda i
Acc di y,i i her by O RD ER ED a AD JUD GED t tt M a s r t J
or ngl t s e
nd
ha he gi ta e udge' Re ta
s por nd

E

Re o n ai ni ADOPTED i ise t ey Smih' o j cin aeOVERRULED, n
c mme d to s
n t ni t , t s b e to s r
r
ad
Smih' mo inf r ei n r ij n tv rle i DENI
t s to o prlmia y nu cie eif s
ED.
EN TER : Apri 5,2013.
l

Z V -V

a,x

Z

.A'

r'
e.

'
..
..
e
.'

.m
-

A

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE