Smith v. Owens et al

Filing 66

ORDER ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS 60 ; Objections 65 are OVERRULED; Objections 61 are OVERRULED; and judgment is in favor of the defendants Officer Owens, Officer Dixon, and Lieutenant Carico, and against the plaintiff Brandon Jerod Smith; this case is ORDERED STRICKEN from the court's docket. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 12/18/2013. (tvt)

CL K' OF I u. olxpnl
ER S FCE s s . I
*

A q A o ,A
z' N l v
o
Fl
r
uso

I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D I
STR I C O U RT
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I O F VI G I A
CT
R NI
R O A N O K E D I SI N
W O

DEC 13 2 1
03
a A .
uul

EM

BY:

B M ND O N JER O D SM ITH ,

C i lA c i N o.7: V00060
vi t on
13C
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
V.

FI
NAL ORDER

O FFI ER O W EN S,e aI,
C
t .

By: Sam ue G .W is
l
l on
U ni e St esD i t i tJudge
t d at
src

D ef
endant
s.

Th sc s wa r fre p s a tt 28U. C. 6 6b ()B)t t eHo o a l Pn l M .
i a e s e erd uru n o
S. j 3 ()1 ( o h n rb e mea
Sa ge , t d Stt sM a sr t J
r nt Unie a e
gita e udge.TheM a sr t J
gita e udgehel a e de i r he rng o
d n vi nta y a i n

S ptmb r1 , 01 a ha fldarpo t e o ndngt a t ec u t n e j d me ti fvo
e e e 9 2 3 nd s ie e r r c mme i h t h o r e tr u g n n a r

o t ed fn a t.Do ke le No. 0. Th os p an if Brn o J r d S t , a o j ce
f h e e d n s ( c t tm
6 ) epr e litf, a d n eo mih h s be td
t t r por , os l r i i i s s ofwines c e biiy t the e t r a es e orha t
o he e t m ty a s ng s ue
t s r di lt ha
ihe ddr s d
d he

o p rt t t a d e sa t h ai g.Do k tle No. ) mihh sas o j ce t te
p o t y o d rs the e rn ( c e tm
mi
65 .S t a lo b e td o h
M a sr t J
gi ta e udge' or r ofN ove be 1 201 t de e Sm ih' pos - a i m oton t
s de
m r 9, 3 hat ni d
t s the rng
i o

r vi r d eyevi ,1de e hi f rh moton f a nt
e ew api
deo ni d s ou t
i or ppoi mentofc ms lza gr nt t
ot e , nd a ed he

d fn n s moi nfrap o e tv o de b ri f rh rds o e y ( c t tm No 61)
ee da t' to o r tcie r r arng u te ic v r .Do ke le
. .
Ha n rv e dterp r,h No e r1 , 01 Or e, mi so j ci n t eeo pet e t
vig e iwe h e o tt e v mbe 9 2 3 d r S t b e to s h rt , ri n
h'
n
1Thedefnda smant nt ypr edt r pi e vi a t Se ember1 , 201 hea i
e nt i ai he oduc he a d ye deo t he pt
9
3 rng.

2S t as rie hi lc o c u e i hi o jcin t teMa itaeJ g ' rp r.Asst u i teMa srt
mi lo asd s ak f o nsln s b eto s o h gsrt ud es e o t e o tn h gitae
h
J d esod rd n n S t sfrt to t a p it o nslDo k tIe No 21, rs n r h v n sauo y
u g ' r e eyig mi is moin o p on c u e ( c e tm . )p io es a e o tttr
h'
rghtt co e i cvi c e I t a t cour ha dic ein ast whet rt r s t a at ne rpr s ta
i o uns l n i l as s. nse d,he
t s s r to
o
he o eque t hat n tor y e e en

p ro u bet afr c t e. 8U. C. 1 l ()l.Th Ma itaeJ g c n iee tefcsa d
es n na l o fo d omsl2 S. j 9 5e() e gsrt ud e o sd rd h a t n
cru tn e o S t sc s a fu iwa n tnteitrs o j siet rq etc u e frS t ( e
ic msa c s f mi ae nd o nd t s o i h neet f utc o e u s o nslo mih.S e
h'
Do k tIe No 21( oigu c mpiae fcu l n lg lsu sa S t sd mo srtda lt t a e u tl
c e tm . n t n o lctd at a a d e a ise nd mi e n tae bi y o d q aey
n
h'
i
rp ee thsitrss. l a dto , rve o t e ie c so t M a itaeJ g wa mo tcrf lnh r
e rsn i neetl) n d i n a e iw fhe vd n e h wshe gsrt ud e s s aeu i e
i

e m i tonoft e ier co d,wasbot pai ta i g w ih Sm ih i gi nghi evey opporuniy t
xa nai
he ntr e r
h ten nd ndulent t
t n vi m
x
t t o
pr s nthi cm e and,at
ee s s,
lhoughnotSmih' advoc t ,wa pe sse i he eforst de o t r or i acaef
ts
a e s r itnt n r f t o velp he ec d n r ul
a appr it ma rs ht tSmih' cli we ea quaeypr s nt See e. ,
nd
oprae nne uc ha
t s ams r de tl e e ed. , a.Bowma v. hie, F.
n W t 388 2d

7 6, 61(t Ci.1 6 )
5 7 4h r 9 8.

pori oft r c ddenov andt r e
tons he e or
o,
he elvantl t c t e wih t M a sr t J
aw,he our agr es t he gita e udge'
s

rc mme d to t e tr u g n i fv ro ted fn a t a dh rNo e r1 , 3
e o n ain o n e j d me tn a o f h ee d ns n e v mbe 9 201
nli .
lngs
Acc di y,i i he e O RDERED a ADJUDGED t :
or ngl t s r by
nd
hat

1 t M a srt J
) he gitae udge' Re t ndRe omme ton( ke Ie No.60 i
s por a
c
ndai Doc t tm
)s
AD O PTED ;

2 Smi sObe to st Re o t n Re o n ain( c e Ie No. 5 a e
) t
h' j ci n o p r a d c mme d to Do k t tm
6) r
O V ERR U LED ;

3 S t sObe to st Ma itaeJ d esOr e ( c t tm No 61 ae
) mi
h' j cin o gsrt u g ' d r Do ke Ie . ) r
O V ERR U LED ;K d

4 j d me ti e trd i fv ro t d fn a t Ofie Owe s Ofie Dio a
) u g n s n ee n a o f he ee d n s fc r n , fc r x n, nd
Liut na Ca i o,andagans t pl ntf Br ndon J r Smih.
e e nt rc
i t he ai if a
e od
t
A1 m a tr ha ng bee r ol t sca e i ORDERED STRI
1 te s vi
n es ved, hi s s
CKEN fom t cou tsdoc t
r he r'
ke .
TheCl r i DI
e k s RECTED t mai a c oft sor rt t pl i if
o l opy hi de o he antf

'
X

s

z'
.
.

E NTER : Thi D e e be 18h 201 .
s cm r t
3

'

V,'
=
UNI
TED STATESDI CT JUDGE
STRI

2