Makdessi v. Fleming et al

Filing 24

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 06/11/2013. (kab)

*

rdFp<; oFF4 J. DI rnlr
c;l B. SK l
ATROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

I TH E U NI
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI T C O UR T
C
FO R T H E W ESTERN DI
STR I T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
ROANOKE DI SI
W ON
A D I ED D I R AM EZ M A K D ESSI
B
E
,

J 1 12 1
UN
23
JUtl C.
A

BK
u,
.
,

DEP

'iLERK
,.
2
CL
ERK

CA SE N O .7: 3CV 00079
1

Pl ntff
ai i ,

M EM O M ND U M O PI O N
NI

HAROLD CLARKE, AL ,
:I

By: Gln E. nr d
e Co a
Chi f Unied St esD i t i Judge
e
t
at
s r ct

Defnda t)
e nts.
Pl ntf Adi Eddi Rn zM a s i pr e ngpr K a t f mapa i i t s
ai if b
e me kdesi s oce di o nd q or
upers n hi

prs ne cvirg sa tont r42U. C.j 1
io r i l iht ci mde
S.
983.Thecour notfe M a s t thi i tal
t iid kdesi ha s nii
compl i f ie t sa ea a tona ec am , c us he di notsae f c sc e ni c
ant al d o tt ny c i bl l i be a e
d
t t a t onc r ng onduc
t
by t i vi lde e nt i vi a i ofhi rght . M a
he ndi dua f nda s n ol ton
si s
kdes ihass i t d a n e d
s
ubm t e n m nde

co pl nt a t co tr ce l die t d t c e k t a t
m ai , nd he ur e nty r c e he l r o tempts r i eofpr e soft tn nde
e vc
oc s
ha me d
c pli on t de e nt na e t r i .1 M a s ihasalo fl dt motonst thesyl
om a nt he f nda s m d he en
kde s
s ie wo
i ha
t es

a t me g n yr q sl)f ro d ro p oe to '( No .1 & 1 ) Afe rviw o te
s û r e c e uets o r e f r tci n'ECF s 4 5 . tr e e f h
e
r c r ,h c u t e e te emoi n f ritro uo yij n tv r l f
e o d te o r d nis h s to s o n el c tr n u cie ei .
e
I hi c pli , a
n s om a nt M kdes ial st ti N ove
s lege ha n
mber201 tle ofi r fom Red Oni n
2, lr e fce s r
o

SaePrs n wh r h sp e iu j1 8 a to aos , r al we t c met t ep o e tv
tt io , ee i r vo s 9 3 cin r e wee lo d o o o h r tcie
c t t twhe ehe i now ho ed a Ke n M ount i Co tona Ce e a i r t iton
usody mi
r
s
us t e
an aeci l nt r nd, n e ala i

f t tpro l ws t we ealowe t ha uf hi be nd hi ba k d pie knowl dge ofhi
or ha i r a ui, r l d o ndc f m hi
s c es t
e
s

s o l e ij r I h sc re t to , a d si se t ta h f asf rh slf a Ke n
h u d r nu y. n i u rn moins M k e s a s rs h t e e r o i ie t e
M ot n,ba e on sa e e sva i ofi i sha m a a
mii s d
tt m nt rous tcal ve de bouthi prorlws tandt sne
s i a ui
hi w
ca e. H e a l gest tOfi rPhilps t d hi s c i y ofi r c d sr p s a c M a s if
s
le
ha tce
li ol m e m t ice s oul ti e r h kde s or
1 Bas on M akdes isom isi ofot def ndant fom t am e d com pl nt t courtwil
ed
s'
s on
her e
s r he
nde
ai , he
l
dim ist acton ast t om it def
s s he i
o he ted endant ,on t pr umpton t M akdes ihassa ed no cl m he
s
he es
i hat
s
tt
ai
w ihest pur ue agai tt .
s o s
ns hem

s ctrt r s ns t tofk er i si a i hi ca m ofs xuala s ta c edhi ofl ng a
e liy ea o ; ha t s nve tg tng s li
e
s aul c us
m
yi nd

t d hi heco d ge outofs gr ga i i he c ng hi so y;a t tt as it wa de
ol m
ul t
e e ton f ha ed s t r nd ha he s sant r n
s d hewoul lmi t nlmbe ofl lm aera sM ak s coul pos e si hi s g e i c l
ai
d i t he ' r ega t il
des i d s s n s e r gaton el.
M akde s a kst c t o is a o de t thebepr ec e fom ha a s e a t ea sa
s i s he our t s ue n r r ha
ot t d r
r s m nt nd hr t nd
t tofi i l pr ec hi lga doc nt a hi a lt t a e st cours
ha fc a s ot t s e l ume s nd s biiy o cc s he
t.

Asap ei n r ij n to tmp rrl af r a e ta r iayrme yp i r otilt e
r l ay nu cin e o aiy fods n x ro dn r e d ro t ra,h
mi
pa t se n tep ei n r ijmcinmu td mo taet t ( )G ei l eyt s c e do
ry e kig h r l a y nt to s e nsrt ha: 1 û s i l o u c e n
mi
h
k

t emeis'( )l ei lk l t s fe i paa l h nni tea s n eo p ei n r rle, ( )
h rt, 2 ç s iey o u fr ae rbe a n h b e c f r lmi ay eif' 3
' h
'
ûh baa eo e ute tpsi h sfv r'a d( )û nij ci ni i t p bi itr s. Se
û e lnc f q i s i n i a o , n 4 ç nun to s n he u lc n ee t' e
t
i
'
a
'
W i e v. t alRe ouresDee eCouncl l ,555U. 7,1 S. .365,374(
ntr Naur s c
fns
i.nc.
S. 29 Ct
2008) A
.
s
howi ofa t tong pos i lt ' hn i i ufi e ,be a et sanda d r quie a s
ng
t'
sr
sbiiy'of nn s ns fcint c us he t r e r s howi
ng
t tha m i tlkel ' I Ea h oft s f f c or m us bes tsi d bef r i e l or
ha r s li y.' d. c
he e our a t s t a ife
o e nt rocut y
ill tver le i wa r nt d- Re Tr t AboutOba a. l c v. EC, 7 F.d 3 2 3 7( t
n'nc i ei f s ra e z al uh
l
m n . F 5 5 3 4 , 4 4h

Ci.
r 2009) va ae bve e nd bv.c r.grnt 1 S.Ct 2371( 0) rafimedi pa t
, c td r ma ed
e t a ed, 30
.
201 , e fr n r.

r ma d db , 0 F.d3 5(t Ci. 01 )
e n e y 6 7 3 5 4h r2 0 .
M a s if l t de
kde s ais o monsr t t twiho i e l ut y r le , i lkel t s f r
ta e ha t ut nt roc or e if he s i y o ufe
ir pa a eha m .He sa esno f c ss
re r bl r
tt
a t uggesi t thehasbee de i d ofa es t hi l ga
tng ha
n prve
cc s o s e l
m a e i sort a e s oft cou t . l e t r co d i ca est the r ce l pa tc pa e i a
t ral
o cc s
he r s nde d, he e r ndi t ha
e nty ri i t d n
t o- y be h t i w ih co ta nt d c m s la s s i hi . M or ove ,M a s if ist
w da nc ral t ur - ppoi e ot e s itng m
e r kde s a l o

demonsr t t t a lge pa ta t ofr t la i t ke a ns hi by Ke n M ount i ofi al
ta e hat he le d s c s ea iton a n gai t m
e
an fci s
have pl e hi ,ora e lke y t pl ce hi , tr s ofir pa a e ha m wihoutc t nt r nto
ac d m
r i l o a
m a i k r e r bl r
t
our i e ve i n.
2 Tempor y r tai ng or sar is onl r el , when t movantpr
der e s ued y ar y
ar esr ni
he
ovest hewils f
hat
l ufer

ijr irle i no ga tdb fr t a ves pat c l ben tfe a ha eo ru t t r po
nuy f eifs t rne eoe he d re ry oud oiid nd v ppotniy o es nd.
See Fed.R.Ci P.65. Such an or woul onl l tuntls h tme asa hearng on a pr i i r
v.
der
d y as i uc i
i
elm na y

ij ci nc l bear n d.Asi i ce rfo t o te t tM a sii n e tte t ap ei n r
nun to oud ra ge
t s la r m he u s tha kde s s ot n ild o r lmia y
ij c in,h c ur fnd noba i u nwhiht grnthm atmp a yr sr i ngo de .
nun to te o t i s
ss po
c o a i e orr e tani r r
2

A ss a e he com pl ns prm arl t tK e n M ount i ofi i sha m a ve ba c m e s
t t d,
ai
i iy ha e
a n t c al ve de r l om nt

a
bouthi l ws t Hedoesnotaleget ta
s a ui.
l ha nyone a Ke n M ount i hasca e ort e t ne
t e
an
us d hr a e d
hi wih a physc hn m. On t s a lga i ,M a s f ist de onsr t a lke i
m t ny
ial r
he e le tons kdes i a l o m ta e ny i lhood
t thewils f ir par bl hn m i t a e e oft r quese r lef An a o it or r
ha
l ufer re a e r n he bs nc
he e t d e i .
ppr pra e de

wilis ett d y d n i ghsmo in fri tro u oyijlcier l f
l su ls a , e y n i to s o ne lc tr nl tv ei .
i
n
e
The Cl r i diece t s nd c e oft sme or ndlm o ni n a a ompa ng
e k s r td o e opi s hi m a l pi o nd cc
nyi
o de t pl i if
r r o a ntf .

ENTER:Ths tl d yo J n , 01
i
a f u e 2 3.
ChifUnie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge