Blocker v. Warden et al

Filing 14

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 04/25/2013. (rkc)

clEM s OFFI U..DI . COURT
CE s ST
AT ROANOG ,V
A
F'
LED

AF 25 2 1
R
23
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRICT CO URT
FO R T H E W E STER N DIST m CT O F V I G I I
R N A
ROANO KE DI SI
VI ON
M ARVI BLO CK ER,
N

J A C.
ULI DUDL CLERK
EY

BK

r

'
N

Ci lA c i No.7: 3c
vi ton
1 v00103

Pl nt f ,
ai i f

M EM ORANDUM OPI
NION

V.

W A R D EN etaI,
.
D efendants
.

By:Sam uelG .W ison
l
Unie St e Dit i tJudge
t d at s s r c

Pl n ifM a v n Bl ker aVigi ai ae pr e ngrr s brng t saci plr ua
aitf r i oc , r ni nm t oc edi
o e, i s hi ton zs nt

t 42U. C.j1 a i tt l e oye o W atnsli Stt Prs Bl ke ha
o
S.
983 gans weve mpl es f le kdge ae ion. oc r s

s p e ne hsic mpeej1 3c mpan-o m wiht n yt pa e o j u n l nre
u plme td i n o lt 98 o li tf r t we t -wo g s f o r a e tis
t tge r l de c i how prs e pl sa econ n i tng hi a r a t s ts a t r f l
ha ne aly s rbe
ion m oyee r
t m na i
s le dy-m a if c o y ood,

se ln h sma a i e a dohe malc lighm o j cin bl n me , ho tn t dsu bhs
taig i g zn s n t r i, aln i be to a e n s s u ig o it r i
se p, r f sng t pr dehi gre nc f nns
l e and e u i o ovi m ' va e o .
i

Under28U. C.j1 A,dit tco ' aerquie t rviw prs rc ant f
S. 915 sdc uts r e rd o e e ione ompli s or
t
c
ompla ewih t bascnzesofpl a ng,a i doi s t c tmus eihe %i ntf
inc t he i l
e di nd n ng o, he our
t t r çde iy
c za e c am sordim ist co pl nt ora pori oft c
ogni bl l i
s s he m ai , ny ton he ompli ,i t c
ant f he ompli ...
ant

fist saeacam u o whc r l f yb g a td' j 1 5 b .A c mp an mu talg
al o tt li p n ih ei ma e rn e . 91 A( ) o lit s le e
e
'
t noug f t t sae ac am t r le t ti plusbl on isf e. Gi ra a v.J on,5
t
e
h ac s o t t l i o e if ha s a i e t ac ' a r t no ohns
'
21

F. 298,302( hCi. )( i BelAt.Co . Two y,55 U. 544,570( )
3d
4t r 2008 quotng l l p v. mbl 0 S.
2007).
The f mii r esofpl a ng a egr a l r a d f pr s pli if ,howeve , nd ltga s
n lar ul
e di r e ty elxe oï o e antfs
r a ii nt
w ih m ert i cl m s s d notbe st i by t
t
iorous ai houl
ym ed
echni requiem ent See B eaudet v.Civ
cal
r
s.
t
t
'Bl ke co pl nst thi m e l ofe i udeol c bba ,under ke br d a c e ,t s al
oc r m ai ha s as tn ncl
d a ge
coo d ea nd ookis oo-m l
pi esofc ke,s piiuss lng cofee si pott s bea andrc t thavebee ûplye wihy a vmio
ec
a us co -meli
f , lmy
oe , ns
ie ha
n t a d t ' nd
'
us
bodiyfui
l l ds.

t
w

o Hn t n 7 5F.d 1 4,1 7 -7 (t Ci. 98 ) Silt rlx to o tepla igr ls
f mp o , 7 2 27 2 7 8 4h r 1 5 . tl,he ea ain f h e dn ue
i notwihoutlmis A cour mus, tam i m um,bea et dic r fom t compl i t
s
t
i t.
t ta
ni
bl o s e n r he
ant he
pa te beng s a t al ge c
ris i ued nd he le d onduc on whih e c cai r t . Though r l xe t
t
c a h l m ess
e a d, he

sa d r si d ma d g n rlc h r n e a di d e no rq iec u t Goc n u eu q e to
tn ad tl e n s e ea o e e c , n t o s t e ur o rs ç o j r p u sins
l
t
ne rs ey pr e t d t t m . I a 1
ve quar l es n e o he ' d. t 278.
'

Hee( wih hi prvi co ait)Bl ke hasalege anumbe ofwr but
r as t s e ous mpl n2 oc r
l d
r
ongs
of e ed s ntf c uals ppor f t ,l r l f l d t co c a pa tc a w r ng t a
f r ca a t u
t or hem a ge y aie o nne t ny r i ul r o o ny

pa tc a def nt ne e t t gr md hi c
riulr enda , gl ced o ot
s ompl n on a consiutonalorsaut y
ait ny
tt i
t t or
pr son,a r quese no s c fcr i f W hiet pladi r l do noti
ovii nd e t d
pe ii ele .
l he e ng ues
mpos a e tng
e n xaci
sa r on Bl ke ,hem us ofe s
t nda d
oc r
t f r omef hol on whih t de enda sca ba ea a we or
oot d
c he f nt n s n ns r

o wh c t ec u t a ba eaj d me t Ac o dngy tec u t imis sBlc e ' c mplit
n ih h o r c n s u g n . c r i l ,h o r d s se o k rs o an

wih u p eudc frfit et saeacam.
t o t rj ie o all o tt li
r
EN TER :A prl25, 3.
i
201

..
):
.:
('
r
1
'po ,'7
V .,'
>
. '

.
y.
'
F ',
'
.
.

7
'
'
z.
..

A

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE

2Se Bl ke v. Vh ni SaeP io Ofkil. . S. , 1 c 0 0 ( . Va Jn r 2 , 01 )
e oc r
xi a tt r,n t as W R. P.7:3 v 0 27 W D. .a uay 4 2 3.