Collier v. Land & Sea Restaurant Company, LLC
Filing
370
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 8/13/15. (eot)
cLERO OFFI U.S. sm X URT
CE
Dl
A R* ou , A
T
V
FI
LED
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R THE W ESTERN DI
STR I OF V I I A
CT
RG NI
RO AN O K E D I I ON
V SI
ROBERT J.
B
COLLI
ER,
Pl i if
a ntf ,
ALC 13 2 1
25
J
.
EM D pRK
a
Ci lA c i N o. 7: CV 001
vi ton
13
04
V.
M EM O M N D U M O PI O N
M
LAND & SEA RESTAURANT
COM PANY,LLC,d/ a FRANKI
b/
E
R OW LAN D ' STEA KH O U SE,e al,
S
t .
By: on. l n E.Com'd
H
Ge
a
Chi fUnied St t DititJ
e
t
aes src udge
De e nt .
f nda s
Sn Ru tSe f o I .û m Rus 'ha mo e t srket ed ma df raj r til
m s ao d,nc (sa
ç
f) s v d o ti h e n o u y ra
m a i t s co a
de n he e nd mende t r pa t compl ntfl by La & SeaResa a Compa
d hid- ry
ai ied
nd
t ur nt
ny,
LLC (t & Se '.Fort r s stf t bel t moi wilbede e
$
Land
a'
)
he ea ons e orh ow,he ton l
nid.
Backeround
Ro r Colirfld t saci agans La & Se on M a c 19,
be t le ie hi ton i t nd
a
r h 2013, l ng t the
alegi ha
s fee sro sij re a ars l o e tn émwh ls mef o 'a Frn i Ro a '
u fr d e iu nu is s e ut f aig ' o e o o d' t a k e wlnd s
t
St khous on A prl1 2011 La & Sea s eque l fl a t r pa t c pl i a i t
ea
e
i 4,
. nd
ubs
nty ied hid- r y om a nt ga ns
Sn Rus a ot re ii . I Cou VI ofiss c a e
m
t nd he nttes n
nt 1 t e ond m ndedt r pa t c pli ,La &
hid- ry om a nt nd
Se s e ade a a i t tSa Rus mus def nd a i mniy i agans Colirscai ,
a e ks clr ton ha m
t t e nd nde f t i t le ' l ms
pur ua t aFoods r cePr t Supple Ag e m e be we n Sa Rus a one ofLa &
s nt o
e vi
oduc s
ir r e nt t e m
t nd
nd
Se ' p i r f o s p les P roma eFo dGr u l .La d & S ad ma dsaj r til
a s rmay o d u pir, e f r nc o o p,nc n
e e n
u y ra
o al fiscams i ldngisd caao yj dg n cam a an tSa Ru t
n lo t li ,ncu i t e lrt r u me t li g is m s.
Sa Rus ha move t srkeLa & Se sde ndfraj ytil Thecour heda
m t s
d o ti nd
a' ma o ur ra.
t l
i
en uly i ed nd s i or
he i on t m oton on M a c 9, 5. Themoton hasbe f l bref a i rpe f
arng
he
i
r h 201
r ew .
evi
Di cus on
s si
Th S v nhAme d n t t eCo siuinp ee v sap ry srg t oaj r tiltin
e e et
n me t o h n ttto r s r e a t' ih t u y ra sl
l
Suis a com m on l w . U . Cons . m e V l . ' sha bee i e pr t d t e end t r g t
t t
a ' S.
'
t a nd. I '
Thi s n nt r e e o xt
he i ht o
aj ytilt a1 s t, t ra c
ur ra o 1 uis whehe t ommon1w ora ii unde f r l sai wheelaa
a
rsng
r edealegilton, r e l
rght aei ved.'Pa i v. r i aBd. Ed . 1 F. 823,828( hCi.1 )
i s r nvol ' ndazdes Vigni of uc, 3 3d
4t r 994
( mp a i i o iia) seas I r Lo k e dMa tnCo p, 0 F.d 3 , 5 (t Ci. 0 7
e h ss n rgn l; e lo n e c h e ri r .5 3 3 51 3 4 4h r 2 0 )
( oigt t h Se e t Ame d n ' g aa teo aj r tilt p iso l t c s sa 1w'
n tn ha t e v n h
n me ts u rn e f u y ra d pl n y o a e ta '
a e
)
(mp a i i o ii l.Be a s a to f rd ca aoyj d me t aen i rlg l o e utb e
e h ss n rgna) c u e cins o e lrtr u g n s r et e a n r q ia l,
he
t erg t oaj r til nad caao yj g n a to d p nd o G eh rt eewo l h ve
h ih t u y ra i e lrt r ud me t cin e e s n i te h r u d a
wh
b e arg tt aj r til dtea to p o e d d wih u t ed caao yj g n ve il .
e n ih o u y ra ha h cin r c e e t o t h e lrt r ud me t hce'
'
Loc edMari 503F. a 355( tngBea n The te sI v. e t r 359U. 500,504
khe
tn,
3d t
cii
co
ars nc. W sove ,
S.
( 959);s ealoGulsra Aer pa eCor v.Maya amasCop .485U. 271 284( 988)
1 ) e s
fte m os c
p.
c
,
S. ,
1
CAcinsf rd caaoyj d me t aen i e lg l o e ui bl, ndc u t h v te eo eh d
i to o e lrtr u g ns r et r e a n r q t e a o rs a e h r fr a
h
a
t l k t t ki ofa ton t twoul havebe n br hthad Co r s no pr dedt
o oo o he nd c i ha
d
e oug
ng e s t ovi he
d caaoyj d me trme y.)
e lrtr u g n e d ' .
'
l t i c s ,ft d ca ao yj dg n r me yh dn t e na albl, n & S a
n h s a e i he e lr tr u me t e d a o b e v i e La d e
a
woul ha br
d ve oughtabr ac ofc r c cai agans Sa Rus,alegi t tSa Rus
e h onta t l m
i t m
t l ng ha m
t
br a he t Foods r i ePr t Supple Agr eme by r f i t def nd and i mniy
e c d he
e v c oduc s
ir e nt e usng o e
nde f
La & Sea aga ns Coli r scl i s Si e c ai s f br ac ofc r c a e t s or c ly
nd
i t le ' a m . nc l m or e h
ont a t r s t i a l
hi
çe a,'La d& S awoudh v b e e ildt aj r tilt s c cam.My r v. ie
1g 1' n
'
e
l a e e n nt e o u y ra m u h li
t
e s Untd
SttsDit Cour, F. 741 744( hCi.1 ;s ealoAtasRoofngCo.l v.
ae s. t620 2d ,
9t r 980) e s l
i
. nc.
Oc upai Saev& He t Re e Comm' 430U. 442, 9 ( )(ssl t f da s
c tonal ft
a1h viw
n,
S. 45 1977 tg uis or mage
2
f rbr a h ofc r t... e e s t a com m on 1 w w ih t i s s o t m a ng o t c r c
o ec
ontac
w r uis t
a
t he s ue f he ki f he ont a t
a disb e c t b d cd db aj r . .' .I f lo t tLa d& Se as h sarg tt aj r
n t r a h o e e ie y u y . .) t o lws ha n
'
a lo a ih o u y
til nisd caao yj d me tcam a ans S m Ru t Se Lo k e dM at 5 3F.da 3 9
ra o t e lrtr u g n li g i t a s. e c h e ri 0 3 t 5 n,
60;s ealo Fiche I ncCor v. n. e Co. 1 F. 11 11 -2 (0t Ci.1
e s s r mazi
n. Ge Elc. , 87 3d 65, 717 1 h r 999)
(oligt th panifwa e ildt aj r tilo isd caao yj dg n cam sn e
h dn ha te litf s nt e o u y ra n t e lr tr u me t li ic ,
t
wih u ç e lrtr u g nt r c d rs'iss i wo dh v i omd e )i c n rc a d
t o tç caaoyj d me p o e u e , t ut ul a e t t gd n o ta t n
d
'
s
so g t lg l eif'; o r eP o . v. c eo GulhRe o' LLC, 7 F. p 2 91 ,
gu h ) e a rle ) M n o r p.LLC Ba h lr c s l
t
3 4 Su p. d 4
9 ( Col 2005 ( di t tt pl ntf ha arg t aj ytilon isde aaor
23 D. o. ) hol ng ha he ai if d iht o ur ra t clrt y
j d me tcam, i et a to ç u dh v h dt p o e da a a to f rb e c o c nr c
u g n li snc he cin k l a e a o r c e s n ci n o ra h f o ta t
wo
wih u t d v c o d ca ao yr l f'.Ac o d n l, m Ru tsmoin t srk tej r
t o the e ie f e lrtr ei ) c r i gy Sa
e
s' t o tie h u y
o
de ndm us bede e
ma
t
ni d.
C oncl on
usi
Fort f e ng r as ,t c t l de Sa Rus ' m oton t srke La & Sea'
he or goi e ons he our wil ny m
ts i o ti
nd
s
d ma dfraj r til Th Clr i drce t sn c pe o ti me r n u o nina d
e n o u y ra . e ek s ie td o e d o is f h s mo a d m pi o n
t a c pa ng or rt a1 cou elofr co d.
he c om nyi
de o 1 ns
e r
S> da ofAugus, 2015.
y
t
Ex TsR:Thi l
s-
Chi fUnied St t sDiti J
e
t
a e srd udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?