Sprinkle v. Ofogh, et al

Filing 16

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 05/21/2013. (kab)

h
r

r3FRK: OFFCE U. DI COURT
I
S, ST.
AT K ANOKEV
VA
F.fO
L

MAt 2 2 2 1
23
I T H E UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STR I T CO UR T
C
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
ROANOKE DI SI N
VI O

DAVI F.SPRI
D
NKLE,

JULt C . - ' $ CL
A ;
l ERK
BK
DEP
GLERK

CASE NO.7: 3CV00107
1

Pl ntf ,
ai if

M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N
N O

BLU E R I G E R EG IO N A L JAIL
D

AUTHORI c K ,
TY,

By:Gln E.Conrad
e
C hi fU nie St t s Di t c Judge
e
t d a e s ri t

Dee nts.
fnda t)
Da d F.Sprnkl ,aVigi ai t pr ee ng pr K ,fld t scvi rght a ton
vi
i e
r ni nma e oc di
o
ie hi i l i s c i

pzs a t o4 U. C. 1 8 , l gn ta t pe iidj i o t ash v de rv dhm o
t u n t 2 S. j 9 3 al ig h t ms cfe al f l a e p ie i f
r
e
ki
a
dequa e m e c tea m e f pr vi l di nos c o c pai f om ki y di ea e tl o s
t di al r t nt or e ous y ag ed, hr ni n r
dne s s , lm r ,

a d ac uhe a kl.S ik eh sc mp idwi terq rme t t p o e d if r
n r s d n e prn l a o le t h e uie n s o r c e n o mapau rs
h
pe i
u d r28U. C.j1 5 b a dh smo e t a n h sc mpli t Be a et mo ina dt e
ne
S.
91 ( ) n a v d o me d i o an . c us he to n h
i ta c pli do notsaeaci na e cai sa ns t named de e nt , hecour de e
nii l om a nt
tt to bl l m gai t he
f nda s t
t ni s
t moton t n e sl a iy dim is st c am sa i tt s de e nt,and g a s
he i o m nd, lmm rl s s e he l i gans he e f nda s
r nt
pl i ifa opporuniy t s i a n e
antf n
t t o ubm t n m nded c
ompli .
ant
Thec ti r q r t dimi sa a ton o ca m fl d by aprs rag ns a
our s e uied o s s ny c i r li ie
ione ai t
gove n e a e iy o ofi e i t cour de e mi st a i o ca m i fi ous malci ,
r m nt l ntt r fc r f he
t t r ne he cton r li s rvol , i ous

orf l t saeacam onwhihr i ma beg a ed.28U. C.j1 5A( ( ) Seci 1
ais o tt li
c elef y r nt
S. 91 b)1. ton 983
li de i d t pr vi a c
Gs sgne o o de ompr hensver m e f t de i ton ofconsiu i na rg s'
e i e dy or he prva i
tt to l i ht .
'

S t v. mp o Tri igSc . o Nt s s 3 0F.d5 7 5 ( t Ci.1 6 ) Tosaeacam
mi Hn t n ann h f r l e , 6 2 7 , 81 4h r 9 6 . tt li
h
r
t rj 1 1 pli ifmus esa iht eeee nt ...:( )t de i to ofarght
mde 983,ç antf
a
t tbls hr lme s
1 he prvain
i

sclrdbyt Consiutonoraf rlsaue;( byape s ()aci unde col ofsae
e ze
he
tt i
edea tt t 2)
r on; 3 tng
r or tt
lw. J nki v.M e or 11 F. 11 11 60( hCi.1 (mpha i a
a ' e ns
'
df d, 9 3d 56, 59- 4t r 997) e
ss dded)
.

l hi i ta co pl ntandm otont a e Sprnkl i ntfesonl t de e nt :
n s niil m ai
i o m nd, i e de ii
y wo f nda s

t Bl Ri J i Aut iy(% RRJ ' a t Ca l Cot yAdul Dee i Ce tr
he ue dge al hort t
A') nd he mpbel mt
t tnton ne

(CCADC' Asalc l al a iiy teCCADC i n taG ro 's be tt s i t e 1 1 8 .
C
t
).
o a j i fcl ,h
t
s o û s n' u j c o ut md r 9 3
pe
Prva v. n 20 F.d8 , 0 0W L 2 5 , t* ( t Ci. a 1 , 0 0 ( n u ls d
e l Re o, 3 3 21 2 0
0 91 a 1 4 h r J n. 3 2 0 ) u p b ihe )
( uoi W ilv. ihi nDe tofStt Polc 491U. 58,71( 989:;M c v. a a
q tng l M c ca p'
ae ie,
S.
1
coy Chespe ke

Co r ci n l ne, 8 F. p 8 0 8 3 9 ( D. . 9 2 (i igct ali n fo
re to a Ce tr 7 8 Su p. 9 , 9 -4 E. Va 1 9 ) f n iyj i mmu e r m
nd
s i a dn tap ro f rp r o e o j 1 8 ) Theeo e S rnkescamsa ans t eCCADC
ut n o es n o u p s s f 9 3 . rf r , p i l' li g i t h
mus besl rl dimis dunde j1 5A( ( )a lgalyfi ous
t lmmaiy s se
r 91 b)1 s e l rvol .

Top o eta ag ve n a e tt , u h a alc l ala to iy i la l f r
r v h t o mme tl n iy s c s o a j i uh rt , s ibe o
co tt i vi ai nsco mitd by ise oye ,pl ntf m us s
nsiutonal ol to
m te
t mpl es ai if t how t tt e iy' polc
ha he ntt s i y
wasthe movi f r eoft c tt i na vi a i ' Pol Cot v v.
t
t
ng o c
he onsiuto l olton.' k mt Dods 454 U. 31
on,
S. 2,

3 6( 98 ) l c l o enngb d e . . a b s e drcl t e j1 8 f rmo eay
2 1 1 . i a g v r i o is . c n e u d ie ty md r 9 3 o n tr ,
Lo
d caao y o ij n tv r l f ee. .h a to t a i alg dt bet o t u in l
e lr tr , r n u cie ei wh r . t e ci n h t s le e o mc nsi to a
e
t
i plm e sore c esa polc sae e , di nce r gul to orde ii ofii ly a e
m e nt
xe ut
i y t tm nt or na , e ai n,
c son fc al dopt d
a pr m ul t d by t tbody' ofk e s' M onel v. w Yor Ciy De .ofSocalSe vce ,
nd o ga e
ha
s t r.
'
l Ne
k t pt
i ri s

436U. 658,690( 978) Be a eSprnkl fist saefcslnki t naur oft me ca
S.
1 . c us i e al o tt a t i ng he t e he di l
c ehehasr ei d t as ii polc orde son t fcaly a e ' t gove ni body
ar
ec ve o pecfc i y
cii t i i l dopt d'by he
of
r ng

o t j i a t o i n i e hi c mp an n rh smoint n n saea ya to bej 1 8
f he al u h rt et r s o lit o i to o me d tt n cina l 9 3
y, h
c pl ntagans t BRRJ
om ai
i t he
A.Ac r ngl t c t l de hi m o i t n e a wil
co di y, he our wil ny s ton o m nd nd l

sl rl d s s wih u p eu iet ecamsa ans t eBRRJ
l
mmai imis t o t rj dc h li g i t h
y
A.
The c rt i ,
ou fnds howe r t tSprnkl sa lga i ,lbe al c tu d, i gi rs
ve , ha
i e' le tons i r ly onsr e m ght ve ie

t aci bl j 1 cai a ns i vi l alofiil ormedialpe s mel Be us
o tona e 983 l ms gai t ndi dua j i fcas
c ror . ca e
Sprnkl i pr ee ngrr s ,t c twilgr ntSprnkl a opporu t t s i a n e d
i e s oc di
o e he our l a
i e n
tniy o ubm t n m nde

2

co pl ntco e i hi cai a
m ai nc m ng s l ms boutt medialc ehehasr e ve a CCAD C. The
he
c ar
ec i d t
ame
nded c
ompl i m us i tf i t hea ng oft docl e ,hei vi st tSprnkl
ant t den iy, n he di
he lm nt t ndi dual ha
i e
i nnmi asdef nda sa sae,i de a ld a nlmbe e pa ag a ,wha aci ea h
s
ng
e nt nd t t n t ie nd l r d r r phs
t tons c
def nda t i vi a i ofS i e' co tt tona rght. Se Rul s8 & 1 Fe r lRul s
e nt ook n olton
prnkl s nsiu i l i s e e
0, de a
e
ofCi lPr dtr The a e d c
vi oce le.
m nde ompli s ul a s sa ef t i s
ant ho d lo tt acs n uppor oft cli ,
t he a ms
i l ng bu notlmie t when Sprnkl a ked f me c lc r wha c ehebeleve he
ncudi
t
i td o
i e s
or di a a e, t ar
i d

s dr c i ,wha r ponst)her eve wha ea hdeenda kne a hi me c l
houl e eve t es e s ec i d, t c f nt w bout s dia

c ndto , a me ia e laina dme ia te t n S rn l r c i d a dwh tijlyhe
o iin wh t dc l vau to n dc l rame t p i ke e eve , n a nt
r
s f r d a ar ul oft de e nt 'aci ns Fi l t n e d c pl ntm us i udet
ufe e s es t he f nda s to . naly, he m nde om ai
t ncl he

a sg e c s nl ra db sg dt e p nat o p ru y.S eRul 1 .
sin d a e l
mbe n e ine md r e l f ej r e e 1
y
Fo ter a o ssae ,h c u t imis swi o t rj d c S rn l ' camsa an tte
r h e s n ttd t e o r d s se t u p eu ie p ik es li g is h
h
BRRJ a dt eCCADC, t s n t j1 5 b ( )a dd nishsmo int a n b tg a t
A n h
pt ua t o 91 A( )1 n e e i to o me d, u r n s
r
hi a opporuniy t s i an n nde c
m n
t t o ubm t me d ompl i . An a o it or rwili s t sda
ant
ppr pra e de l s ue hi y.

ENTER :Thi â l d yo Ma
s R a f y 2013.
,
Chi Unie St t sDititJ
ef t d a e src udge