Obataiye-Allah v. Clarke et al

Filing 4

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 04/16/2013. (kab)

e ppœ: OFFIE U. , ST) URT
d
C S D# M
AT RQANOKE,
V#

#.

I THE I M TED STATES DI
N
J
STRI CO URT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN DISTRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O AN O K E DIV I N
SIO

$1 2r
7! 3' '

A?k 16 2 1
23
Jutl z
à
BY;
D P

, ..

u ,
ay cueRK
CLERK

UH URUSEK O U OBA TM YE- LLA H ,
A

C i lA c i N o.7: 3- vvi ton
1 e 0011
8
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
M EM O M ND U M O PI O N
NI

By:
CL AR K E,ET A L,

Gl E.Conr
en
ad
Chi fU ni e St t D i t i tJudge
e
t d a es s r c

Dee
fndants.
t)

Uh r - e o Ob ti - lh, r e d n p oK , i daç oi nf rIj n to 'wh c
u u s k u aayeAl p oc e i g r fl ç to o n u cin, ih
a
e M
'
t co tc tu a aci lrght c ant purua tt 42U. C.j1
he ur onsr ed s vi i s ompli , s n o
S. 983. Pl nifwas
aitf

a v sdt a t ec u t ul n t du iaelg la dfcu lmatr d suse i hi pla igi
d ie h t h o r wo d o a j dc t e a n a t a tes ic s d n s e dn n
t c tona l fl a ton t i he cle t de i inci not d i t or ren e ed M ar h 25,
he ondii ly ied c i mtl tr d he fce es e n he de t r
c
201 The c tdiec e pl ntf t s
3.
our r t d ai if o ubmi wihi 1 da fom t da eoft or rfna i l
t t n 0 ys r he t
he de i nc a
i onnai n a ve ii d sae e ofe usi ofad i sr tver le .Pl i ifwa a s d
nf
to nd rfe tt m nt xha ton
m l tai e if antf s dvie

t a af i r t c mp ywo l rs l i d s sa o t i a to wi u p eu ie
h t al e o o l ud e ut n imis l f hs cin t t rj dc .
u
ho
M or t n 1 da ha elps d,a pl i ifhasf ie t c
e ha 0 ys ve a e nd antf
a ld o ompl wih t des rbe
y t he c i d
c tonsbe us hehasf ld t pr defna a i or ton a verfe sa e
ondii
ca e
aie o ovi i ncil nf ma i nd ii d t t mentof
e usi ofa i sr tver le .Ac or ngl t c ur dim is t a to wihout
xha ton dm nita i ei f c di y, he o t s s es he c i n t

prj diea srk st c s fo tea tv d c t ftec u t an ifma r fl t cams
eu c nd tie he a e rm h cie o ke o h o r.Plitf y eie he li
i a s pa ae a ton onc pl ntf i pr pa e t c
n e r t ci
e ai if s e r d o ompl wih t no edcondii .
y t he t
tons
The Clr i die t t s nd aco oft sM e andlm Opi o a a ompa ng
e k s r ced o e
py hi mor l
ni n nd cc
nyi
Or rt pl ntf.
de o ai if

ENTER

:T i l N dyo Api 2 1.
hs Q
a f r,03
l
Chi U nied St es D it i Judge
ef t
at
s rct