Adkins v. Robertson
Filing
8
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 04/25/2013. (kab)
m pnrs OFFI U..Dl rnlr '
a
CE s sm - l f
AT Roz ou ,
l
x
vA
FI
CEo
AF 25 2 1
R
23
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI
CT
RGI A
M
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON
MI
CHAEL ANTHO NY ADKI
NS,
JULI C.
A
BY:
DEP
, ERK
CL
CL
ERK
CASE NO.7: 3CV001
1
32
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON
NI
By: Jam e C .
s Turk
Se or U nie St e Di t i Judge
ni
t d at s s r ct
NURSE TM CY ROBERTSON ,
Dee
f ndant
.
M iha Ant
c el hony Adl ,aVigi ai ae pr e ng pr K ,El d t sc v lrg s
dns
r ni nm t oc edi
o
e hi i i i ht
.
a t np ru n t 4 U. C. 1 8 , le igta aj int s d ne hi me tl e l
ci u s a t o 2 S. j 9 3 algn h t al z e e id m na h at
o
r
h
m e c i on one oc ason. Upon r viw oft r c d,t c tfndst tt a ton mus be
diaton
c i
e e
he e or he our i ha he c i
t
sl rl d s se t e 2 U. C. 1 9 ea a fio o .
l
mma i imis d md r 8 S. j 9 7 () s rv lusl
y
1
Adki ,a i t a t Da le Ciy J i, lgest to W e da M a c 20,201
ns n nma e t he nvil t a l ale
ha n dnes y, r h
3,
a
bout9: p. .t de e ntnur edi nothavehi m e c i f bi ardior r a ey,
30 m ,he f nda
s d
s diaton or pol s de , nxit
ls d ha
d i
s g
c i u t e ie l'
a dd p e so 2 Thentr esai t tshewoul brngback hi ni htmediaton, b tt h lld .
n e r sin.
s
'
( mpl2. Asr le i t sa ton,Ad nsseks3. milondola s hi me cain,a a
Co . ) eif n hi ci
ki e
5 li
lr, s di to nd
ta se t a oh r alfcl y be a s h fa st t i lf ma b i d n e .
rn fr o n t e j i a it , c u e e e r ha h s ie y e n a g r
i
Adki hasalofl amoton t a e hi co ai , e ki t add ade a f a
ns
s ied
i o m nd s mpl nt s e ng o
m nd or
tmpo ayrsri igo d rdrcigo t ast ta frl m i d aeyt a ohe ji f clt
e r r etann r e ie tn fkil o rnse l mme itl o n t r al a ii
i
y.
1 Thecourti r r t dim isany ac i orc am fl by a pr s ragai ta govem m e al
s equied o s s
ton
l i ied
ione
ns
nt
entt orofk eri t cour de er i t a i orcl m i f i ous m alci orf l t sat a cl m
iy
f
f he
t t m nes he cton
ai s rvol , i ous, ais o t e ai
onwhih r le ma bera td.28U. C.j 1 5 b ( )
c eif y
ne
S. 9l A( ) 1 .
2 Adki s l t de endantsna et dif entwaysi hi s isi : Robe s and
ns pels he f
' m wo f er
n s ubm s ons
rton
Robi on. Accor ngl t courtwilr f t t def
ns
di y, he
l e er o he endantasçt nur e.'
çhe s '
Ad i a s rst ti i at o ld o itr s'frhi t b d tie a t j iwh r te
kns se t ha t s ç nti f n ee t o m o e ean d the al e e h
c
'
de e n ntr ewor .
f nda t ls
ks
1
1
A j 1 pl ntf mus e t iht ts ha be ndeprve o rght guaanee byt
983 ai if t sabls ha he s e
i d f i s r t d he
Co tt i orl wsoft Unie St e a t t sde i ton r ule f o c
nsiuton a
he t d ats nd hat hi prva i es t d r m onduc
t
c mmitdb ap ro a n t e c l ro saelw.W e t At n , 8 U. 4 ( 9 8 .A
o te y e s n di g md r o o f tt a
s v. kis 4 7 S. 2 1 8 )
prs ofk ilsdelbe at i fe e et a i ae' s rousm e ca ne dsvi aest Ei h
ion t a ' i r e ndif r nc o n nm t s e i
di l e
olt he ght
Ame me t S eEsel v. mbe 4 U.. 7 1 2( 9 6 .A p io ot a i l ei eaey
nd n . e t l Ga l, 29 S 9 , 0 1 7 ) rs n f l s l lb rtl
ç
ki
d
i fe e 'i s t
ndif r nt' f he t
knowsofa dir r a e es i rs t i t he t ors f t ' elt d
nd sega ds n xc sve ik o nma e alh a ey'r a e
t hi s rousm e c lnee a r pondst e ona y t t rs Far rv. e n,511U .
o s ei
di a
ds nd es
mr as bl o he ik. me Br nna
S.
8 , 3 ( 9 4 .Onteoh rh nd acam algngn gie ta to b me ia p ro n l
25 8 7 1 9 )
h te a , li le i e l n cins y dc l e s n e
g
r r ng di gnossa co s ofte t e doe no i i t t Ei h Am e
ega di
a
i nd ur e r am nt s t mplcae he ght
ndme .Esele,
nt t l
429U. a 1 1 W rgh v. lns 766F. 8 8 ( hCi.1 .
S. t 05- 06; i t Coli ,
2d 41, 49 4t r 985)
Adki 'alegai nsf lt s if e t rf e oft delbe at i fer nc sa d.
ns l to ai o atsy ihe ac t he i r e ndif e e t ndar
Fis ,he doesnota l t tm i sng one dos ofhi m e a hea t m e c ton on one oc as on
rt
lege ha s i
e
s nt l lh di a i
c i
pl e hi a any sgnika rs ofhar ort the s f r a ha m ora a i ofhi
ac d m t
i f nt ik
m
ha
ufe ed ny r
ggr vaton
s
c ton asar ul ofm isng o dos Thus hehasnots
ondii
es t
s i ne e.
,
hownt tt ntre' aci
ha he ls s tons
a f c e hi s ro m e ea nee ,a r quiedt sa ea Ei h Ame
fe t d s e i us di l ds s e r o tt n ght
ndme c am . I a ton,
nt l i n ddii
Adki 'alegai nsoferno i cai t tt ntr eknowi y f ie t brnghi media i t
ns l to
f
ndi ton ha he zs
ngl al d o i
s
c ton o
li on M a c 20,201
tm
rh
3.Hi s
s ubmi sonss por,a m os,acli t tt nure a t d
si
up t t t am ha he s c e
ne lg nl o t a o o c so .M een gie c i n ta to a l t e j1 8 .Esel, 29
gi e ty n h t ne c a in r e lg n e s o cin b e md r 9 3 tle 4
U . a 1 06. Be a e Adki 'alegai nsdo notpr deaf t bassf a a tona e
S. t 05c us
ns l to
ovi
acual i or ny c i bl
2
cam a an thed fn a tt c u t ls mma iyd s s t ea to wih u p eu iet e
li g is t ee d n ,he o r wil u rl imis h cin t o t rj d c md r
j 1 5A( ( )aslgal fi ous3
91 b)1 e ly rvol The c talo fndsno g ot o whi h Adki i e il t at mpor y r sr i ng
our s i
r md n
c
ns s ntted o e
ar e ta ni
or r Te
de . mpor y r sr ni or r ar is ed o y r r y,whe t m ovantpr desan
ar e tai ng de s e s u nl a el
n he
ovi
a fd vice rys owig ta h wils fe ij r i r l f sno g a tdb f r tea v rep ry
fi a t lal h n h t e l u fr nu y f ei i t rne eo e h d es a t
e
c d beno ii d a ha a opporuniy t r pond. Se Fede alRul ofCi lPr dur
oul
tfe nd ve n
t t o es
e
r
e
vi oce e
6 ( ) Ad isfist alg a y s e i cfcsc n en n t emn n ri whihh wils fe
5 b . kn al o le e n p ct a t o c r i g h n e n c e l u fr
i
dmme it a dirpaa l ij r 'i t ea e c o terq e tdrle .Ac odigy, s
i dae n re r be n u y'n h bsn e f h e u se eif c r n l hi
i
m oi t n
ton o mendt a adema f at mpo a y r tai ngor rwilb de e
o dd
nd or e r r esr ni
de l e ni d.
An a oprat or wili s t sda The Clr i die t d t s nd copi oft s
ppr i e der l s ue hi y.
ek s rce o e
es hi
m e andum opi o a a ompa ng o de t pli if
mor
ni n nd cc
nyi r r o antf
E rR:ri
x- ' s
s '
h
la o- r,03
ly f i21.
r Apl
S ' Unie St t Ditit udg
t d aes src
e
3 Adki alo adm ison t f ofhi com pl ntt he di notfl any adm i sr i r edi
ns s
t
he ace
s
ai hat
d
ie
nitatve em es
a t j ibeor flngt sa ton, srqurdu r4 U. C. l 97 () Ad nsc mpli t tte
the al f e ii hi ci a e ie nde 2 S. j 9 ea. ki o ansha h
j i'gre n epocdue aen E v ia e't hi b c us al t asdon rtr o a we
als iva c r e rs r otû albl 'o m, e a ejiofkil oteun r ns r
a
gre
ivancesa s
nd ometm est ow t awa Adki adm ison t thedi notate t fl any
i
hr hem
y.
ns'
s i ha
d
tmpt o ie
grevancesc
i
oncer ng t i dentati ue i t scas however i a ale na i v ound f dim i alof
ni he nci
ss n hi e,
, s n t r tve
or s ss
hi l ui.
s aws t
3
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?