Adkins v. Robertson

Filing 8

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 04/25/2013. (kab)

m pnrs OFFI U..Dl rnlr '
a
CE s sm - l f
AT Roz ou ,
l
x
vA
FI
CEo

AF 25 2 1
R
23
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI
CT
RGI A
M
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON
MI
CHAEL ANTHO NY ADKI
NS,

JULI C.
A
BY:
DEP

, ERK
CL
CL
ERK

CASE NO.7: 3CV001
1
32

Pl nt f ,
ai i f

M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON
NI

By: Jam e C .
s Turk
Se or U nie St e Di t i Judge
ni
t d at s s r ct

NURSE TM CY ROBERTSON ,
Dee
f ndant
.

M iha Ant
c el hony Adl ,aVigi ai ae pr e ng pr K ,El d t sc v lrg s
dns
r ni nm t oc edi
o
e hi i i i ht
.

a t np ru n t 4 U. C. 1 8 , le igta aj int s d ne hi me tl e l
ci u s a t o 2 S. j 9 3 algn h t al z e e id m na h at
o
r
h
m e c i on one oc ason. Upon r viw oft r c d,t c tfndst tt a ton mus be
diaton
c i
e e
he e or he our i ha he c i
t

sl rl d s se t e 2 U. C. 1 9 ea a fio o .
l
mma i imis d md r 8 S. j 9 7 () s rv lusl
y
1

Adki ,a i t a t Da le Ciy J i, lgest to W e da M a c 20,201
ns n nma e t he nvil t a l ale
ha n dnes y, r h
3,

a
bout9: p. .t de e ntnur edi nothavehi m e c i f bi ardior r a ey,
30 m ,he f nda
s d
s diaton or pol s de , nxit
ls d ha
d i
s g
c i u t e ie l'
a dd p e so 2 Thentr esai t tshewoul brngback hi ni htmediaton, b tt h lld .
n e r sin.
s
'

( mpl2. Asr le i t sa ton,Ad nsseks3. milondola s hi me cain,a a
Co . ) eif n hi ci
ki e
5 li
lr, s di to nd

ta se t a oh r alfcl y be a s h fa st t i lf ma b i d n e .
rn fr o n t e j i a it , c u e e e r ha h s ie y e n a g r
i
Adki hasalofl amoton t a e hi co ai , e ki t add ade a f a
ns
s ied
i o m nd s mpl nt s e ng o
m nd or

tmpo ayrsri igo d rdrcigo t ast ta frl m i d aeyt a ohe ji f clt
e r r etann r e ie tn fkil o rnse l mme itl o n t r al a ii
i
y.

1 Thecourti r r t dim isany ac i orc am fl by a pr s ragai ta govem m e al
s equied o s s
ton
l i ied
ione
ns
nt

entt orofk eri t cour de er i t a i orcl m i f i ous m alci orf l t sat a cl m
iy
f
f he
t t m nes he cton
ai s rvol , i ous, ais o t e ai

onwhih r le ma bera td.28U. C.j 1 5 b ( )
c eif y
ne
S. 9l A( ) 1 .
2 Adki s l t de endantsna et dif entwaysi hi s isi : Robe s and
ns pels he f
' m wo f er
n s ubm s ons
rton
Robi on. Accor ngl t courtwilr f t t def
ns
di y, he
l e er o he endantasçt nur e.'
çhe s '

Ad i a s rst ti i at o ld o itr s'frhi t b d tie a t j iwh r te
kns se t ha t s ç nti f n ee t o m o e ean d the al e e h
c
'
de e n ntr ewor .
f nda t ls
ks
1
1

A j 1 pl ntf mus e t iht ts ha be ndeprve o rght guaanee byt
983 ai if t sabls ha he s e
i d f i s r t d he
Co tt i orl wsoft Unie St e a t t sde i ton r ule f o c
nsiuton a
he t d ats nd hat hi prva i es t d r m onduc
t

c mmitdb ap ro a n t e c l ro saelw.W e t At n , 8 U. 4 ( 9 8 .A
o te y e s n di g md r o o f tt a
s v. kis 4 7 S. 2 1 8 )
prs ofk ilsdelbe at i fe e et a i ae' s rousm e ca ne dsvi aest Ei h
ion t a ' i r e ndif r nc o n nm t s e i
di l e
olt he ght

Ame me t S eEsel v. mbe 4 U.. 7 1 2( 9 6 .A p io ot a i l ei eaey
nd n . e t l Ga l, 29 S 9 , 0 1 7 ) rs n f l s l lb rtl
ç
ki
d
i fe e 'i s t
ndif r nt' f he t
knowsofa dir r a e es i rs t i t he t ors f t ' elt d
nd sega ds n xc sve ik o nma e alh a ey'r a e
t hi s rousm e c lnee a r pondst e ona y t t rs Far rv. e n,511U .
o s ei
di a
ds nd es
mr as bl o he ik. me Br nna
S.

8 , 3 ( 9 4 .Onteoh rh nd acam algngn gie ta to b me ia p ro n l
25 8 7 1 9 )
h te a , li le i e l n cins y dc l e s n e
g
r r ng di gnossa co s ofte t e doe no i i t t Ei h Am e
ega di
a
i nd ur e r am nt s t mplcae he ght
ndme .Esele,
nt t l

429U. a 1 1 W rgh v. lns 766F. 8 8 ( hCi.1 .
S. t 05- 06; i t Coli ,
2d 41, 49 4t r 985)
Adki 'alegai nsf lt s if e t rf e oft delbe at i fer nc sa d.
ns l to ai o atsy ihe ac t he i r e ndif e e t ndar
Fis ,he doesnota l t tm i sng one dos ofhi m e a hea t m e c ton on one oc as on
rt
lege ha s i
e
s nt l lh di a i
c i

pl e hi a any sgnika rs ofhar ort the s f r a ha m ora a i ofhi
ac d m t
i f nt ik
m
ha
ufe ed ny r
ggr vaton
s
c ton asar ul ofm isng o dos Thus hehasnots
ondii
es t
s i ne e.
,
hownt tt ntre' aci
ha he ls s tons
a f c e hi s ro m e ea nee ,a r quiedt sa ea Ei h Ame
fe t d s e i us di l ds s e r o tt n ght
ndme c am . I a ton,
nt l i n ddii
Adki 'alegai nsoferno i cai t tt ntr eknowi y f ie t brnghi media i t
ns l to
f
ndi ton ha he zs
ngl al d o i
s
c ton o
li on M a c 20,201
tm
rh
3.Hi s
s ubmi sonss por,a m os,acli t tt nure a t d
si
up t t t am ha he s c e

ne lg nl o t a o o c so .M een gie c i n ta to a l t e j1 8 .Esel, 29
gi e ty n h t ne c a in r e lg n e s o cin b e md r 9 3 tle 4
U . a 1 06. Be a e Adki 'alegai nsdo notpr deaf t bassf a a tona e
S. t 05c us
ns l to
ovi
acual i or ny c i bl

2

cam a an thed fn a tt c u t ls mma iyd s s t ea to wih u p eu iet e
li g is t ee d n ,he o r wil u rl imis h cin t o t rj d c md r
j 1 5A( ( )aslgal fi ous3
91 b)1 e ly rvol The c talo fndsno g ot o whi h Adki i e il t at mpor y r sr i ng
our s i
r md n
c
ns s ntted o e
ar e ta ni
or r Te
de . mpor y r sr ni or r ar is ed o y r r y,whe t m ovantpr desan
ar e tai ng de s e s u nl a el
n he
ovi

a fd vice rys owig ta h wils fe ij r i r l f sno g a tdb f r tea v rep ry
fi a t lal h n h t e l u fr nu y f ei i t rne eo e h d es a t
e
c d beno ii d a ha a opporuniy t r pond. Se Fede alRul ofCi lPr dur
oul
tfe nd ve n
t t o es
e
r
e
vi oce e

6 ( ) Ad isfist alg a y s e i cfcsc n en n t emn n ri whihh wils fe
5 b . kn al o le e n p ct a t o c r i g h n e n c e l u fr
i

dmme it a dirpaa l ij r 'i t ea e c o terq e tdrle .Ac odigy, s
i dae n re r be n u y'n h bsn e f h e u se eif c r n l hi
i
m oi t n
ton o mendt a adema f at mpo a y r tai ngor rwilb de e
o dd
nd or e r r esr ni
de l e ni d.
An a oprat or wili s t sda The Clr i die t d t s nd copi oft s
ppr i e der l s ue hi y.
ek s rce o e
es hi
m e andum opi o a a ompa ng o de t pli if
mor
ni n nd cc
nyi r r o antf

E rR:ri
x- ' s
s '
h

la o- r,03
ly f i21.
r Apl
S ' Unie St t Ditit udg
t d aes src
e

3 Adki alo adm ison t f ofhi com pl ntt he di notfl any adm i sr i r edi
ns s
t
he ace
s
ai hat
d
ie
nitatve em es

a t j ibeor flngt sa ton, srqurdu r4 U. C. l 97 () Ad nsc mpli t tte
the al f e ii hi ci a e ie nde 2 S. j 9 ea. ki o ansha h
j i'gre n epocdue aen E v ia e't hi b c us al t asdon rtr o a we
als iva c r e rs r otû albl 'o m, e a ejiofkil oteun r ns r
a
gre
ivancesa s
nd ometm est ow t awa Adki adm ison t thedi notate t fl any
i
hr hem
y.
ns'
s i ha
d
tmpt o ie
grevancesc
i
oncer ng t i dentati ue i t scas however i a ale na i v ound f dim i alof
ni he nci
ss n hi e,
, s n t r tve
or s ss
hi l ui.
s aws t

3