Morgan v. Wells Fargo Bank, National Association

Filing 37

MEMORANDUM OPINION and ORDER granting defendant's Bill of Costs and awarding $3,042.93 in costs to the defendant. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 05/06/2014. (rkc)

r p< s OFFj U.:. DI .COURT
d
CE
sT
ATROANOKE,VA
FIED
L

MAï 25 2 1
29
I TH E U NI
N
TED STATES DISTR I C O U R T
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI O F VI
CT
RGI A
NI
R O AN O K E D I I O N
V SI

J A C.
ULI DUDLEY CLERK

BK

LEJU AN A ALI E M O RG A N ,
C
Pl ntf ,
ai if

Ci lA c i N o.7: 3c 37
vi t on
1 v1

V.

M EM OM NDUM OPI ON &
NI
O R DER
W ELLS FA R G O BA N K ,N ATI N A L
O
ASSO CI O N
ATI

By:Sam ue G.W is
l
lon
U nied St e D i t i tJudge
t
at s s r c

D ef
endant
.

Thi matri b fr tec u t n De e d n W el F r o smoin frBilo Co t (
s te s e o e h o r o fn a t ls a g ' to o l f ss ECF
No.33)puruan t 28U. C.j1 a Fe a Rul ofCi lPr dur 5 d) Pl ntf
s to
S. 920 nd derl e
vi oce e 4( . ai if

Leu naMo g nd e n t b e tt Dee d n ' c lu ain o tx bec ssb to j cso l o
ja
r a o s o o j c o fn a ts ac lto f a a l o t u be t ny n
t g oundst ts c nnotaf dt pa t m.Rul 5 d)c e tsapr umpini fvorof
he r
ha he n
for o y he
e 4( r ae es to n a
a r ng c t t t pr vaii pa t unl s a he sa ut c eaesa e epton ort opposng
wa di oss o he e lng ry e s not r tt e r t n xc i
he
i
pa t s
ry howscr
icumsa e s fcintt ove comet pr s
tnc s ufi e o r
he e umpton.ç
i t
Amongt f c or t t
he a t s ha

j tf d n i a a r of o t a e ()mic n u tb teprv iigp ry;2 t
usiy e yng n wad c ss r : 1 s o d c y h e al a t () he
n
uns ce sulpary' i lt t payt c t;( t e esi ne soft cossi apa tc a
uc sf
t s nabiiy o
he oss 3) he xc sve s he t n riulr
c e;( t lmie val oft prvalngpat svit y;or( t cos ne sa ditculyof
as 4) he i td ue he e ii ry' cor
5) he l e s nd fi t
t is sde i d. Eli v.GrntThor o LLP,434F.App' 232,235( hCi.2011 ( tng
he sue cde ' ls
'
a
ntn
x
4t r
) cii

Ch ryv. n i nI tlCo ,1 6F.d4 2, 46(t Ci. 9 9 )
er Ch mp o n ' p. 8 3 4 4 4 h r 1 9 ).
Alhough Pli ifciest he i biiy t pay,s marhal no e de e i s ppo t A
t
antf t o r na lt o
he s s
vi nc n u r.

j oft sc thasprvi l r edt tShel i pa t stna a rs c me i
udge hi our
e ousy ul ha i osng ry' i ncil e oures rt
t

c n i eain s o l t e eb si in e ie c t ma eafn ig o n bit t y. Arh rv
o sd rto , h ud h r e uhce t vd n e o k
dn fia ly opa ' tu .
i
'

c

Pe Dar , 01 W L 6 8 3 , t* ( . Va De . , 01 )(iig c s s (mp a i a d d ;
t iy 2 3
22 7 2 a 2 W D. . c 2 2 3 ct a e ) e h ss d e )
n
s eCha ma v. Trn p, 2 F.d 1 2( 1hCi. 0 )(1 ad src c u t nd tr nng
e
p n Al a s .2 9 3 01 1 t r 20 0 t f itit o r i ee mii
t
t a o ofc t t aw a d c
he m unt os s o
r hoos t c i rt no pr vaii pa t s fnanc als a us i
es o ons de he n- e lng ry' i i t t , t

s o l r q ies b tn il o u nain o atu i a ii t pa ' , e as M c lv.
h ud e ur u sa ta d c me tto f r e n blt o y.) s e lo Gil
y
''
Fa kne,1 F. 456,459( h Ci.1 (fi ngdititc tsfndi t tpa t f l t
ul r 8 3d
7t r 994) afnni src our' i ng ha ry aied o
e t ih i t r or t thewasi pa eofpa ngt cour-mpos d cossa t pr s
sabls n he ec d ha
nca bl
yi he
ti
e
t t he e ent
tmeori t f t ebec us hi r po et t petton f cossçme el alege wihout
i
n he u ur
a e s es ns o he ii or t ç r y l d, t

doc nt ys r t hewasi ge a t eor hes dno ha t pa coss'
ume ar uppo q hat
ndi nt nd herf e houl t ve o y t.
).
The e or be a ePl i ifm a sonl bl nke as e tonsofhe i biiy t pa a noot r
r f e, c us antf ke
y a t s ri
r na lt o y nd
he
f ct w e ghsi he f vor #t Cour wilgr ntDef ndan , m oton f BilofCoss
a or i n r a , he
t l a
e
ts i or l
t.

Ac or ngl i i he e ORDERED t tDef nda ' m oton f BilofCossi
c di y, t s r by
ha
e nts i or l
t s

GRANTED,a t c ta r $3, 93 i cosst De e nt
nd he our wa ds 042. n t o f nda .
EN TER : M a 6,201
y
4.
'

..
.M
s

e'
.
e
.-'
. ..
..
.
e.
.
' * .' ..'
'
'

zP wz.z
' g' .
zW

.
.sv
..

.N
.

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE

*

Ev nh ds ma s lde ie c , o rsh v k a to e ) h tal i p ry, id g nc o
e a he rhae vd n e c u t a e k uingd t a osng a t s n ie y r
c

a i biiy t pa c t doe nota o a ialy mea t ta c t a r l vid a i tt tpa t
n na lt o y oss s
ut m tc l
n ha oss wa d e e gans ha ry

i i quia e. I r Pa iR. YadPCB Lii ,221F. 449,463( Ci.2000) s eKi v.
s ne tbl ' n e ol R. r
'
tg.
3d
3d r
; e ng
E.Shor W ae.LLC,201 W L 460331 a * ( M d.Aug. 201 ) l t sc e,hec t
e tr
3
6, t 2 D.
27, 3 . n hi as t our
a s fndst tt i s we enotcos a difc t The e i no e de e ofltga i
lo i ha he s ues r
l e nd fi ul. r s
vi nc
ii ton
m ic
s onduc by t pr va lng pa t a t r i no e de t tDe e nts e e e sve
t he e ii
ry, nd he e s vi nce ha f nda e ks xc s i
cos s.
t