Bradley v. Insight Health Corp. et al

Filing 9

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 5/10/2013. (eot)

Download PDF
clp2m ofFf u. . r cg : 7*m çoudk : ATRQANOK'' VA FI LK MA 12 2 1 t 23 I TH E UN I N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI I A CT RG NI R OANOK E DI I N V SIO PA UL I R .M CFA R LA N E , NE J A ULI CY1 C i lA ct t N ..7: 3c * 01 vi im 1 5 46 Pl nt f , ai i f V. I SIG H T H E A LTH C O R P.et##, N . D efendant s. D AN A M A R LEN E BR A D LE Y , C i lA ct on N o.7: 3c vi i 1 v001 47 Pl nt f ai i f, V. I SI H T H EA LT H C O R P. e/a N G Ln D e e nt . f nda s R O BER T EA R L H A R R I JR . S, , Pl ntif, ai f V. I GH T H EALTH CORP.eta1, NSI . Dee f ndant . s Ci lA c i N o.7: v00148 vi t on 13: D EX CL ERK ' ' R A N D O L PH E .SM I H , T Ci lA c i N o.7: vi t on 13cv00149 Pl nt f ai i f, I SI H T H EA LTH C O R P.eta#, N G . De e f ndant . s R I H A R D A .W H I LO W , C T C i lA cton N o.7: 3c vi i 1 v001 50 Pl nt f ai i f, V. I GH T H EALTH CORP.eta1n NSI . D ef endants. BA R BA M J.FI LSO N , Ci lA c i N o.7: v00151 vi t on 13c Pl nt f , ai i f V. I SI H T H E AL TH C O R P.et##, N G . D ef endant . s CH ESTE R T .K A LI O SK I, N Pl nti , ai ff V. I SI H T H E AL TH C O R P. e a1, N G t . D efendants. C i lA c i N o.7: 3c vi t on 1 v00152 JA M ES W I T SM I ,JR . R TH , C i lA ct on N o.7: 3c vi i 1 v001 53 Pl nt f ai i f, V. I SI H T H EA L TH C O R P.et, . N G #, D ef endants. T R U DY R .EPPER LY , C i lA c i N o.7: 3c vi t on 1 v00154 Pl nti , ai ff V. I SIG H T H EA LTH C O R P.etal N n D ef endant s. ZACHARY LUCAS FOUTZ e ,6 t C i lA ct on N o.7: 3c vi i 1 v001 55 Pl nt f , ai i f V. I SIG H T H EA LTH C O R P. e a . N t I, D efendant s. RONNI A .BRO W N, E Pl nti , ai ff V. I SIGHT H EALTH CORP.e a . N t 1, D efendants. C i lA ct on N o.7: 3c vi i 1 v001 56 RO NALD T.COURTNEY, Ci lAc i No.7: *0163 vi ton 13c& Pl nti , ai ff I SI H T H EA LT H C O R P. e a . N G t 1, D ef endant s. JU L I D .H O LB R O O K , AN C i lA ct on N o.7: v00164 vi i 13c Pl nt f , ai if M EM ORANDUM OPI O N NI V. I SIG H T H EA LTH C O R P. e/a1n N . De e f ndant . s By:Sam uelG .W ison l U ni e St e D i t i tJudge t d at s s r c Thepl i if i t et re n s pa ae cvi a tonsorgnal fl t i c am si t antfs n hes hite e r t i l c i i i ly ied her l i n he Cic tCour f t CiyofRoa rui tor he t nokea i tl ihtHeat Cor (çHC' ,HC physca ,a gans nsg lh p. i ' I l ) iins nd l a Gui d Pan M a me . J ta i W i t v.I i H: lh Cor ,7: 3c m ge de i nage nt us s n nMa: nsMht a t p. 1 v001 42 ( . Va May 1 201 ,t pli if 'saec tc ant aleget tt dee nt a t W D. . 0, 3) he antfs tt-our ompli s l ha he fnda s ced ne i n l fa e l a i vi a i oft Vig ni Cons rPr e ton Ac by obt i ng glge ty, r udulnty, nd n olton he r i a ume ot c i t ani c na n tdmeh l e n s ln a eaetnij ca l seod c mmo l u e t te ts lig o tmiae typrd ioo e c tt a n e tb e tr i o ny s d o ra wel n a dp i)fo teNe En ln Co u dn Ce tr(C n an r m h w ga d mpo n ig n e G NECC' a da miitrngi va ' n d n sei t i ) ijcinst tc us dfmg l nngts trt eplitfsfldterc mplit i saec u t n e to ha a e t a me i ii.Afe h an if ie h i o an s n tt o r, 1 r m ove t a tonst f r lc t e on t cl ms'pu poredr lton t NECC' HC e d he c i o ede a our bas d he ai r t ea i o S ongoi Cha e 11 ba ng pt r nknz c i t D i ti tofM as a hus ts Ea h pl ntf ha t l a pt y n he sr c s c e t . c ai i f s i ed moton t r m a hi orhe c us ofaci n t sa ec tta h a g ngt tI Sr mova i o e nd s r a e to o t t our, c r ui ha HC' e l peiinwasuntmel a j iditonal dei int Falngt ,t ague,hec ts d tto i y nd urs ci ly tce . ii hat hey r t our houl a ti fo e ecsn rltdt j rs ito o s o l r ma t ea to o e utbeg o nd . bsan r m x riig eae -o u id cin, r h u d e nd h ci n n q ia l ru s I Scode e HC' f ndant,Dr J M ahi,Dr Robe tO' i n,a I a Gui d Pan M a eme , s . ohn t s . r Bre nd m ge de i nag nt h v j ie i t panif' to .Asi W i aev,n ih He 1 Co p.tec u t sume a e on d n he litfs moins n ng t l sg t at r ,h o r a s s h wih u d cdngt a i h sr ltdt j rs ito o e te ematr, u fn sta t en tc o t o t e ii h tt a eae -o u idci n v r h s te s b t i d h t h o ie f ha i . e r m ova i e h c ewast i y1a r ma t c am son t tbass Se 28 U. C. e l n ac as mtmel nd e nds he l i S. j 1 3 ( )(xe dn fd rl u idcint p o e d n st a a eûeae t 'c s st e Ti e 3 4 a e tn ig e e a j rs ito o r c e i g h t r ç ltd o' a e md r t r l 1 ) j1 5 ( r vd n f rmo a o camsb s do rltd-oj rs it nl Fe . Ba kr P. 1; 4 2 p o ii g or e v l f li a e n eae t u idci ; d R. n . o 9 2 ()3 ( sa ihn t etmi go r mo a) l r Ceo e Co p.1 4F.d61 , 2 (t Ci. 0 7 a( ) e tbls ig h i n f e v l; n e ltx r , 2 3 9 6 9 4h r 1 9 )( t t a t Ba nztyRu e a pyt c s sg o n e o rltd t j rs ito ) I 9 7 noi h the nk p c ls p l o a e r u d d n eae -o u idcin . n ng t at r tve a es e i l f t r as t c tsa e i F i t v.l i htHe t Cor , he lena i , nd s ntaly or he e ons he our tt d n naa e ns R a1h p. t c r a t i fom hea i t s ma tr plr ua t t m a t y a t n i n pr son i he ou t bsans r rng he e te s zs nt o he nda or bse to ovii n 1Se M cFa l ne v. Isg tHe 1 Co , :3 v 01 6(o littldi saec u t n emaldt e ra n ih at p.71 : 0 4 c mpan ie n tt o r a d - ie o h o p sn c t e De e e 2 , 01 ; e ve t fd rl o r Ap i8 2 3 ; a lvv Isg tHe 1 Co . p o ig omsl cmb r 8 2 2 rmo d o e ea c u t rl , 01 )Brde .n ih at p , h 7 1 c 0 4 (o littldi saec ut n emaldt o p sn c u sl c mb r2 2 2;e v dt :3 v 01 7 c mpan ie n tt o ra d - ie o p o ig o n e De e e 8, 01 rmo e o fdea c u t rl , 3 9 ri v lsg t at Cop.7 1 c 0 48(o litfldi saec ut a u l 7 e rl o r Ap i8 201 )Hars .n ih He lh r , 23 v 01 c mpan i n tt o rz n a' , e y 2 3 c mpan emaldt o poigc u slo Jn m' 8 2 3 rmo dt fd rl o r Ap i8 2 3 ; mi v 01 ; o lit - ie o p sn o n e n a u y , 01 ; e ve o e ea c u t rl , 01 ) S t . h l sg t at Co p.7 1 c 0 4 ( o l itfldi sae c u t n e mald t o po i g c u s l a u r 8 2 3 n i h He 1h r , : 3 v 01 9 c mp an i n tt o r a d - i o p sn o n e J n ay , 01 ; e e rmo e t fdea c u t rl8 2 3; hto v lsg tHe 1 Co . :3 v 01 0(o lit i di sae e v d o e rl o r Ap i , 01 4W i w .n ih at p.7 1 c 0 5 c mpan fl n tt l h e c tJ nua y7, 3;co ante- ie t opposngco e on J nua y 8, 3;rmovedt fdealco tAprl8, our a r 201 mpli mald o i uns l a r 201 e o e r ur i 2 3 ; lo v lsg He lhCo n, 1 c 0 5 (o littldi saec u t n emaldt o poigc u sl 01 )Fisn .n iht at r .7:3 v 01 1 c mpan ie n tt o r a d - i o p sn o n e e De e e 28 20 2*e v dt fd r l o r Api 8 2 3; l o k v.nsg tHe l Co .7:3 v 01 2 c mb r , 1 , mo e o e ea c u t rl , 01 ) Kai s i I ih at p , 1 c 0 5 r n h (o litfldi saec u t n emaldt o po igc u s l c mb r28 2 2;e v dt fd rl o r Api c mpan ie n tt o r a d - i o p sn o n e De e e , 01 rmo e o e ea c u t rl e 8 2 3 ; mi v lsg tHe lhCo p, :3 v 01 3(o lit i di saec ut n emaldt o p sn , 01 ) S t .n ih at r .7 l c 0 5 c mpan fl n tt o r a d - ie o p o ig h e c u s l c mb r28 201 *e v dt fd r l o r Ap i8 201) En el v I ih He l Co , 1 c 0 5 o n e De e e , 2, mo e o e ea c u t rl , 3 ; p rv .nsg t at p.7:3 v 014 r h (o litfldi saec u t n emaldt o p igc u sl c mb r28 2 2;e v dt fd r l o rApi c mpan i n tt o r a d - i o p osn o n e De e e , 01 rmo e o e ea c u t rl e e 8 2 3 9 uzv Isg tHe l Cop, :3 v 01 5(o an fldi saec tt a ay2 2 3 c mpan e , 01 )Fo t .n ih at r .71 c 0 5 c mplit i n tt ol Jnu r , 01 9 o lit h e r maldt o p sn c u e Jn r 3 2 3 rmo e t fd rl o r Ap i8 2 3 ; o v I ih He 1 ie o p o ig o nsl a uay , 01 ; e v d o e ea c u t rl , 01 )Brwn .nsg t at h Cop, 1 c 01 6(o an fldi saec u t n emaldt o po i c u s l rh 1 2 3 rmo e t r .7:3 v0 5 c mplit ie n tt o r a d - ie o p sng o n t Mac , 01 4 e v d o fdta c u t rl , 01 ) Co M e v.nsg t at Co p, 1 c 0 6 (o littldi saec u t b u r e rl o r Ap i8 2 3 ; u y l ih Helh r .7:3 v 01 3 c mpan ie n tt o rFe r ay 1 , 01 ; o litemaldt o p igc u slF b u r 1 , 01 rmo e t fd r l o r Api 8 2 3; 5 2 3 c mpan - i o p osn o n e e r ay 8 2 3;e v d o e ea c u t rl , 01 ) e Hobo kv lsg tHe lhCo n, :3 v 01 4(o an fldi saec u t n emaldt o p sn c t e lr o .n ih at r .7 1 c 0 6 c mplit i n tt o r a d - ie o p o ig omsl e F b ur 1 , 01 ;e v dt fd rl o r Ap i8 201 ) e r ay 1 2 3 rmo e o e ea c u t rl , 3. he t e mds ua o 28U. C. 1 3 ()2 2a d as r m andst m on equiabl grot purs ntt 28U S. S. j 3 4 c( ) n 1o e C. . j 1 2( .Ac r ngl t c tgrnt t pli if'motonst rma 45 b) co di y,he our a s he antfs i o e nd. EN TER :M ay 10,2013. # ? ., ' .' . J t .' , UNI TED STATES DI STRI J CT UDGE 2Alidcto saeta tesatc u t ltmeyaj dc t teematr, ln wi Wiz t v l ih ln iain r h t h tt o rwi i l du iae h s tes ao g t n ae .nsg t l h Heat Cor .l a e nt t &c r ti r i no whe eltgai woul movet f t t butwhehe i ca be lh o. n ny ve ,he torec nquiy s t r ii ton d he ases, t rt n t l aj dc tdi saec u t tal'Po rPa t t 'Cai-Re- tn a v Ma a o 4 4B. 2 0 i y du iae n tt o r a l. we ln Enm- - sno -s r Id.LLC . ng n , 8 R. 9 , me ' t o 2 7 ( M d 2 2 .Plitfs c t e r p e e td d rn o a ag me t a t ep risha c n u t daln t y 9 D. . 01 ) an if ' o ms l e r s n e u ig r l r u nt h t h a t d o d ce e g h e c n ee c wi tesaej d ea dh dfr ltdapa i whihtec u t uducWi t a tela c s t o frn e t h tt u g n a o muae ln n c h o r wo l s r e s h e d ae o h ma a e st lgala f t is esandwoul c oldaet r toft c e f dic l Thea davisand ddr s he e nd acual s u d ons i t he es he as s or s ovey. m t ohe tl si te ecs ss o ta tesaepo edig weemovn q ikya dta tesaej d eh dma e t rii n h s ae h w h th tt rc e n s r ng ig uc l n h t h tt u g a d ce rhsitnint mo etec ssfr r a dh de e e trdp ril l r j d me tnan mb ro te la i nv to o v h a e o wad n a v n nee ata sl y u g n i u e f h m. mma I fc,ta p asta teo l t n i e i t l aj dc t no ttmei it i d tt t fd r l o r. n a ti p e r h th ny hig mp dng i y du iai n h rt s hs eot o e ea c u t me o s r

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?