Kalinoski v. Insight Health Corp. et al

Filing 11

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 5/10/2013. (eot)

clp2m ofFf u. .
r cg : 7*m çoudk
:
ATRQANOK''
VA
FI
LK

MA 12 2 1
t
23
I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI I A
CT
RG NI
R OANOK E DI I N
V SIO
PA UL I R .M CFA R LA N E ,
NE

J A
ULI

CY1

C i lA ct t N ..7: 3c * 01
vi
im
1 5 46

Pl nt f ,
ai i f
V.

I SIG H T H E A LTH C O R P.et##,
N
.
D efendant
s.

D AN A M A R LEN E BR A D LE Y ,

C i lA ct on N o.7: 3c
vi
i
1 v001
47

Pl nt f
ai i f,
V.

I SI H T H EA LT H C O R P. e/a
N G
Ln
D e e nt .
f nda s
R O BER T EA R L H A R R I JR .
S, ,
Pl ntif,
ai f
V.

I GH T H EALTH CORP.eta1,
NSI
.
Dee
f ndant .
s

Ci lA c i N o.7: v00148
vi t on
13:

D

EX
CL
ERK

'
'

R A N D O L PH E .SM I H ,
T

Ci lA c i N o.7:
vi t on
13cv00149

Pl nt f
ai i f,

I SI H T H EA LTH C O R P.eta#,
N G
.
De e
f ndant .
s

R I H A R D A .W H I LO W ,
C
T

C i lA cton N o.7: 3c
vi
i
1 v001
50

Pl nt f
ai i f,
V.

I GH T H EALTH CORP.eta1n
NSI
.
D ef
endants.

BA R BA M

J.FI
LSO N ,

Ci lA c i N o.7: v00151
vi t on
13c

Pl nt f ,
ai i f
V.

I SI H T H E AL TH C O R P.et##,
N G
.
D ef
endant .
s
CH ESTE R T .K A LI O SK I,
N
Pl nti ,
ai ff
V.

I SI H T H E AL TH C O R P. e a1,
N G
t .
D efendants.

C i lA c i N o.7: 3c
vi t on
1 v00152

JA M ES W I T SM I ,JR .
R
TH
,

C i lA ct on N o.7: 3c
vi
i
1 v001
53

Pl nt f
ai i f,
V.

I SI H T H EA L TH C O R P.et, .
N G
#,
D ef
endants.

T R U DY R .EPPER LY ,

C i lA c i N o.7: 3c
vi t on
1 v00154

Pl nti ,
ai ff
V.

I SIG H T H EA LTH C O R P.etal
N
n
D ef
endant
s.

ZACHARY LUCAS FOUTZ e ,6
t

C i lA ct on N o.7: 3c
vi
i
1 v001
55

Pl nt f ,
ai i f
V.

I SIG H T H EA LTH C O R P. e a .
N
t I,
D efendant
s.

RONNI A .BRO W N,
E
Pl nti ,
ai ff
V.

I SIGHT H EALTH CORP.e a .
N
t 1,
D efendants.

C i lA ct on N o.7: 3c
vi
i
1 v001
56

RO NALD T.COURTNEY,

Ci lAc i No.7: *0163
vi ton
13c&

Pl nti ,
ai ff

I SI H T H EA LT H C O R P. e a .
N G
t 1,
D ef
endant
s.

JU L I D .H O LB R O O K ,
AN

C i lA ct on N o.7: v00164
vi
i
13c

Pl nt f ,
ai if

M EM ORANDUM OPI O N
NI

V.

I SIG H T H EA LTH C O R P. e/a1n
N
.

De e
f ndant .
s

By:Sam uelG .W ison
l
U ni e St e D i t i tJudge
t d at s s r c

Thepl i if i t et re n s pa ae cvi a tonsorgnal fl t i c am si t
antfs n hes hite e r t i l c i
i i ly ied her l i n he

Cic tCour f t CiyofRoa
rui
tor he t
nokea i tl ihtHeat Cor (çHC' ,HC physca ,a
gans nsg
lh p. i ' I
l )
iins nd
l a Gui d Pan M a me . J ta i W i t v.I i H: lh Cor ,7: 3c
m ge de i nage nt us s n nMa: nsMht a t
p. 1 v001
42

( . Va May 1 201 ,t pli if 'saec tc ant aleget tt dee nt a t
W D. .
0, 3) he antfs tt-our ompli s l ha he fnda s ced
ne i n l fa e l a i vi a i oft Vig ni Cons rPr e ton Ac by obt i ng
glge ty, r udulnty, nd n olton he r i a
ume ot c i
t
ani

c na n tdmeh l e n s ln a eaetnij ca l seod c mmo l u e t te ts lig
o tmiae typrd ioo e c tt a n e tb e tr i o ny s d o ra wel
n
a dp i)fo teNe En ln Co u dn Ce tr(C
n an r m h w ga d mpo n ig n e G
NECC' a da miitrngi va
' n d n sei t i
)
ijcinst tc us dfmg l nngts trt eplitfsfldterc mplit i saec u t
n e to ha a e t a me i ii.Afe h an if ie h i o an s n tt o r,
1 r m ove t a tonst f r lc t e on t cl ms'pu poredr lton t NECC'
HC e
d he c i o ede a our bas d he ai
r t ea i o
S
ongoi Cha e 11 ba
ng
pt r
nknz c i t D i ti tofM as a hus ts Ea h pl ntf ha t l a
pt y n he sr c
s c e t . c ai i f s i ed

moton t r m a hi orhe c us ofaci n t sa ec tta h a g ngt tI Sr mova
i o e nd s
r a e
to o t t our, c r ui ha HC' e
l

peiinwasuntmel a j iditonal dei int Falngt ,t ague,hec ts d
tto
i y nd urs ci ly tce . ii hat hey r t our houl

a ti fo e ecsn rltdt j rs ito o s o l r ma t ea to o e utbeg o nd .
bsan r m x riig eae -o u id cin, r h u d e nd h ci n n q ia l ru s
I Scode e
HC'
f ndant,Dr J M ahi,Dr Robe tO' i n,a I a Gui d Pan M a eme ,
s . ohn t s .
r Bre nd m ge de i
nag nt

h v j ie i t panif' to .Asi W i aev,n ih He 1 Co p.tec u t sume
a e on d n he litfs moins
n ng t l sg t at r ,h o r a s s
h
wih u d cdngt a i h sr ltdt j rs ito o e te ematr, u fn sta t en tc o
t o t e ii h tt a eae -o u idci n v r h s te s b t i d h t h o ie f
ha i . e
r m ova i e h c ewast i y1a r ma t c am son t tbass Se 28 U. C.
e
l n ac as
mtmel nd e nds he l i
S.

j 1 3 ( )(xe dn fd rl u idcint p o e d n st a a eûeae t 'c s st e Ti e
3 4 a e tn ig e e a j rs ito o r c e i g h t r ç ltd o' a e md r t
r
l
1 ) j1 5 ( r vd n f rmo a o camsb s do rltd-oj rs it nl Fe . Ba kr P.
1; 4 2 p o ii g or e v l f li a e n eae t u idci ; d R. n .
o
9 2 ()3 ( sa ihn t etmi go r mo a) l r Ceo e Co p.1 4F.d61 , 2 (t Ci.
0 7 a( ) e tbls ig h i n f e v l; n e ltx r , 2 3 9 6 9 4h r

1 9 )( t t a t Ba nztyRu e a pyt c s sg o n e o rltd t j rs ito ) I
9 7 noi h the nk p c ls p l o a e r u d d n eae -o u idcin . n
ng
t at r tve a es e i l f t r as t c tsa e i F i t v.l i htHe t Cor ,
he lena i , nd s ntaly or he e ons he our tt d n naa e ns R
a1h p.
t c r a t i fom hea i t s ma tr plr ua t t m a t y a t n i n pr son i
he ou t bsans r
rng he e te s zs nt o he nda or bse to ovii n

1Se M cFa l ne v. Isg tHe 1 Co , :3 v 01 6(o littldi saec u t n emaldt
e
ra
n ih at p.71 : 0 4 c mpan ie n tt o r a d - ie o
h

o p sn c t e De e e 2 , 01 ; e ve t fd rl o r Ap i8 2 3 ; a lvv Isg tHe 1 Co .
p o ig omsl cmb r 8 2 2 rmo d o e ea c u t rl , 01 )Brde .n ih at p ,
h
7 1 c 0 4 (o littldi saec ut n emaldt o p sn c u sl c mb r2 2 2;e v dt
:3 v 01 7 c mpan ie n tt o ra d - ie o p o ig o n e De e e 8, 01 rmo e o
fdea c u t rl , 3 9 ri v lsg t at Cop.7 1 c 0 48(o litfldi saec ut a u l 7
e rl o r Ap i8 201 )Hars .n ih He lh r , 23 v 01 c mpan i n tt o rz n a' ,
e
y
2 3 c mpan emaldt o poigc u slo Jn m' 8 2 3 rmo dt fd rl o r Ap i8 2 3 ; mi v
01 ; o lit - ie o p sn o n e n a u y , 01 ; e ve o e ea c u t rl , 01 ) S t .
h
l sg t at Co p.7 1 c 0 4 ( o l itfldi sae c u t n e mald t o po i g c u s l a u r 8 2 3
n i h He 1h r , : 3 v 01 9 c mp an i n tt o r a d - i o p sn o n e J n ay , 01 ;
e
e
rmo e t fdea c u t rl8 2 3; hto v lsg tHe 1 Co . :3 v 01 0(o lit i di sae
e v d o e rl o r Ap i , 01 4W i w .n ih at p.7 1 c 0 5 c mpan fl n tt
l
h
e
c tJ nua y7, 3;co ante- ie t opposngco e on J nua y 8, 3;rmovedt fdealco tAprl8,
our a r 201 mpli mald o
i uns l a r 201 e
o e r ur i

2 3 ; lo v lsg He lhCo n, 1 c 0 5 (o littldi saec u t n emaldt o poigc u sl
01 )Fisn .n iht at r .7:3 v 01 1 c mpan ie n tt o r a d - i o p sn o n e
e
De e e 28 20 2*e v dt fd r l o r Api 8 2 3; l o k v.nsg tHe l Co .7:3 v 01 2
c mb r , 1 , mo e o e ea c u t rl , 01 ) Kai s i I ih at p , 1 c 0 5
r
n
h
(o litfldi saec u t n emaldt o po igc u s l c mb r28 2 2;e v dt fd rl o r Api
c mpan ie n tt o r a d - i o p sn o n e De e e , 01 rmo e o e ea c u t rl
e
8 2 3 ; mi v lsg tHe lhCo p, :3 v 01 3(o lit i di saec ut n emaldt o p sn
, 01 ) S t .n ih at r .7 l c 0 5 c mpan fl n tt o r a d - ie o p o ig
h
e
c u s l c mb r28 201 *e v dt fd r l o r Ap i8 201) En el v I ih He l Co , 1 c 0 5
o n e De e e , 2, mo e o e ea c u t rl , 3 ; p rv .nsg t at p.7:3 v 014
r
h
(o litfldi saec u t n emaldt o p igc u sl c mb r28 2 2;e v dt fd r l o rApi
c mpan i n tt o r a d - i o p osn o n e De e e , 01 rmo e o e ea c u t rl
e
e
8 2 3 9 uzv Isg tHe l Cop, :3 v 01 5(o an fldi saec tt a ay2 2 3 c mpan e
, 01 )Fo t .n ih at r .71 c 0 5 c mplit i n tt ol Jnu r , 01 9 o lit h
e
r
maldt o p sn c u e Jn r 3 2 3 rmo e t fd rl o r Ap i8 2 3 ; o v I ih He 1
ie o p o ig o nsl a uay , 01 ; e v d o e ea c u t rl , 01 )Brwn .nsg t at
h
Cop, 1 c 01 6(o an fldi saec u t n emaldt o po i c u s l rh 1 2 3 rmo e t
r .7:3 v0 5 c mplit ie n tt o r a d - ie o p sng o n t Mac , 01 4 e v d o
fdta c u t rl , 01 ) Co M e v.nsg t at Co p, 1 c 0 6 (o littldi saec u t b u r
e rl o r Ap i8 2 3 ; u y l ih Helh r .7:3 v 01 3 c mpan ie n tt o rFe r ay
1 , 01 ; o litemaldt o p igc u slF b u r 1 , 01 rmo e t fd r l o r Api 8 2 3;
5 2 3 c mpan - i o p osn o n e e r ay 8 2 3;e v d o e ea c u t rl , 01 )
e
Hobo kv lsg tHe lhCo n, :3 v 01 4(o an fldi saec u t n emaldt o p sn c t e
lr o .n ih at r .7 1 c 0 6 c mplit i n tt o r a d - ie o p o ig omsl
e
F b ur 1 , 01 ;e v dt fd rl o r Ap i8 201 )
e r ay 1 2 3 rmo e o e ea c u t rl , 3.

he
t e
mds
ua o
28U. C. 1 3 ()2 2a d as r m andst m on equiabl grot purs ntt 28U S.
S. j 3 4 c( ) n 1o e
C.
.

j 1 2( .Ac r ngl t c tgrnt t pli if'motonst rma
45 b) co di y,he our a s he antfs i o e nd.
EN TER :M ay 10,2013.
#

?
.,

'
.' .

J

t
.'
,

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE

2Alidcto saeta tesatc u t ltmeyaj dc t teematr, ln wi Wiz t v l ih
ln iain r h t h tt o rwi i l du iae h s tes ao g t n ae .nsg t
l
h
Heat Cor .l a e nt t &c r ti r i no whe eltgai woul movet f t t butwhehe i ca be
lh o. n ny ve ,he torec nquiy s t r ii ton
d
he ases,
t rt n

t l aj dc tdi saec u t tal'Po rPa t t 'Cai-Re- tn a v Ma a o 4 4B. 2 0
i y du iae n tt o r a l. we ln Enm- - sno -s r Id.LLC . ng n , 8 R. 9 ,
me
'
t o
2 7 ( M d 2 2 .Plitfs c t e r p e e td d rn o a ag me t a t ep risha c n u t daln t y
9 D. . 01 ) an if ' o ms l e r s n e u ig r l r u nt h t h a t d o d ce e g h
e
c n ee c wi tesaej d ea dh dfr ltdapa i whihtec u t uducWi t a tela c s t
o frn e t h tt u g n a o muae ln n c h o r wo l s r e s h e d ae o
h
ma
a e st lgala f t is esandwoul c oldaet r toft c e f dic l Thea davisand
ddr s he e nd acual s u
d ons i t he es he as s or s ovey.
m
t

ohe tl si te ecs ss o ta tesaepo edig weemovn q ikya dta tesaej d eh dma e
t rii n h s ae h w h th tt rc e n s r
ng
ig uc l n h t h tt u g a d
ce rhsitnint mo etec ssfr r a dh de e e trdp ril l r j d me tnan mb ro te
la i nv to o v h a e o wad n a v n nee ata sl y u g n i u e f h m.
mma
I fc,ta p asta teo l t n i e i t l aj dc t no ttmei it i d tt t fd r l o r.
n a ti p e r h th ny hig mp dng i y du iai n h rt s hs eot o e ea c u t
me
o
s
r