Bender v. Insight Health Corp. et al

Filing 9

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 5/10/2013. (eot)

ctEe s OFFI U..
CE 8 D< rn 1
RT
ATROAROKE, A
V
FI
LED

m t l2 2 1
23
I T H E U N I D STA TE S D I
N
TE
STR I T C O U RT
C
FO R TH E W E ST ER N D I
STR ICT O F V I G I I
R N A
R OANO KE DI SI
VI ON
R O B ER T D A N A BE N D ER ,

J AQ
ULI
BK
D

, JFQ*
P
CL

C i lA ct on N o.7: v00157
vi
i
13c

Pl nt f
ai i f,
V.

I SI H T H EA LT H C O R P.eta .
N G
l,
D ef
endant
s.

O DE SSA M .SH U C K ,

Ci lA c i N o.7: v00158
vi t on
13c

Pl ntf
ai it
V.

I SI T H EALTH CORP.e a .
N GH
t 1,
De e
f ndant .
s

RO SE M .W H I
TE,

Ci lAdi N o.7: v00159
vi
on
13c

Pl nt f ,
ai i f

M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI

V.

I GH T H EALTH CORP.eta1,
NSI
.
De e
f ndant .
s

By:Sam ue G.W is n
l
lo
U nied St es Di tri Judge
t
at
s ct

Thepl i if i t s t e s pa a ec vi a tonso i na l fld t i cli i t
antfs n he e hr e e r t i l c i
rgi ly ie her a ms n he

Cic tCour f t CiyofRoa agans l ihtHe lhCor CtHC' ,HC physca ,
rui
tor he t
noke i t nsg
at p. l ' l
)
iins and
I age Gui Pai M anagem ent. Jus as i W i e v.l ghtH ealh Corp. 7:
m
ded n
t n nMat
nsi
t
, 13cv00142

( . Va.May 1 201 ,hepli if'sae-our c ant al t tt dee nt a td
W D.
0, 3)t antfs tt c t ompli s lege ha he fnda s ce
ne i nty,f a e l a i vi a i oft V ig ni Cons erPr e i A c by ob a ni
glge l r udul nty, nd n ol ton he r i a
um
ot cton t
t i ng

c a naedmehyl e s oneac tt (n ij tbl se oi c
ontmi t
t prdniol
eae a neca e tr d ommonl usdt tea s lng
y e o r t weli
a pan)fom t Ne Enga Compoundi Ce er(C
nd i r he w lnd
ng nt C
NECC' a a nitrngivi
' nd dmi se i t a
)

ij cin t a c u e f n a me i gts Afe t eplitfsfldterc mpansi saec u t
ne to s h t a s d u g l n n ii. tr h an if ie h i o lit n tt o r,
I r movedt a tonst f de a c tba e on t c am s pur td r ai t NECC'
HC t
he ci o e r l our s d
he l i ' pore elton o
S

o i Cha e 11ba pt y i t DititofM asac e t.Ea h pl i tf hasfl d a
ngo ng pt r
nknz c n he src
s hus ts c a n if
ie
m oton t r m a hi orhe c us ofaci n t sa tc t e c a gui t tI Sr mova
i o e nd s
ra e
to o tt our, a h r ng ha HC' e
l

p tto wa j idcin l d fce t Fal gt t t e ag e t ec u t h uda ti fo
ei n s m s ito al e in . ii ha,h y r u ,h o r s o l bsan r m
i
y
n

e rii r ltd- j rs ito o s o l rma dt ea t n o e utbeg o n s I S
xecsng eae t u idcin, r h u d e n h ci n q ia l r u d . HC'
o
o
code e
f ndan s Dr J M ahi, .
t , . ohn t s Dr Robe tO' i n, nd l a Gui d Pan M a ge nt ha
r Bre a m ge de i
na me , ve

j ne i t pl ntfs motons Asi W i at v.nsa Heat Cor ,hecour asume
oi d n he ai if ' i . n na e l iht 1h p.t
t s s

wi o td cdn ta iha r ltd t j rs ito o r h s matr b t e s n ilyfrt e
t u e i ig h t t s eae -o u idcin ve t e e tes u, se tal o h
h
r as t cour sa e i W i a e, hec ta t nsfom he rngt e ma tr purua tt t
e ons he
t tt d n ng t t our bsai r
a i hes te s s n o he
m a t r a t nton pr so i 28 U .S. j1 c ( 1al as r m a t m on e t bl
nda o y bse i
ovii n n
quia e
C. 334()2) rd lo e nds he

g omd p rua tt 28U. C. l 5 ( ) Ac o d n l,h c u t rn steplitfs moi n t
rt s us n o
S. j 4 2 b . c r i gy te o r ga t h an if' to s o
r and.
em

ENTER:M a 10,201
y
3.
zA
-v''-y- '
.

/'
V M
T

.,r
)'
f)
'y

- ., .
' . .
z'
.
.

>

.

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE

1 1n iainsaeta tesaec ut ltmeyaj iaeteematr, ln wi Wig t v I ih
A1idcto r h th tt o rwili l dudc t h s tes ao g t n ae .nsg t
h
Heat Co p.. l a e t t çc r c i r i no whe cltgai wo dmovet fse t butwhehe i ca be
1h r n ny ven ,he tore t nquiy s t r ii ton ul
he a ts,
t rt n
.

t l aj dctdi saec u t t 1. Po rPln Enm'Cai Reo tn .LLC v Ma a o 4 4B. 2 0
i y du iae n tt o r a al' we a t t t sno s r ld.
me
'
. ng n , 8 R. 9 ,
297 ( M d.201 .Pl ntfs'cou elr pr e e durngor lar ntt t pa teshad c
D.
2) ai if
ns e es ntd i a gume hat he ri
onducedalngt
t e hy

c n ee ewihtesaej d ea dh dfr ltdapa i whc tec u t udueW i aea tela c s t
o frnc t h tt u g n a omuae ln n ih h o r wo l s na t s h e d ae o
a e st lgala f t lis a woul c oldaet r s oft c e f dic l The atdavisand
ddr s he e nd acua sues nd
d ons i t he e t he as s or s ovey.
fi t

ohe tl si teec s ss o ta tes ep o e dig weemovn q c ya ta t saej d eh dma e
t rii n h s ae h w h th ot r c e n s r ig uikl nd h the tt u g a d
ng
ce rhsitnint mo etec ssfm ada dha e e e trdp ril u r jd me tnan mb ro te
la i n e t o v h a e o r n d v n nee at s mmay u g n i u e f h m.
o
a
I fc,ta p as+a teo l tigi e i tmeyaj dcto o temei it sd tl t fd rlc u t
n a ti p e r th ny hn mp dng i l du iain n h rt s hi eoz o e ea o r.
s
r
2