Yowel v. Commonwealth of Virginia et al

Filing 19

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 06/20/2013. (kab)

@ FpK:OF Ij>j , 'Y X QRr.
' 9ej(. D1 ,'
,S
.

.

'
.

AT 8OANOKE,
VA
i1..
--:

JL
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI O F VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON
H A BAK K U K E.BEN Y O W EL,

JULI
A
BY; DE

23
1
EX CLERK
CL
ERK

CA SE NO .7:
13CV 00223

Pl nt f ,
ai i f

N.

M EM OM NDUM OPI O N
NI

CO M M O NW EA LTH O F V I G I I ,
R N A

U K ,

By:J me C. k
a s Tur
Se or U nied St e D it i tJudge
ni
t
at s s r c

Dee
fndants.
t)
Habn
kkuk E.Be Yowel aVigi ai t pr e ngpr K ,fld t scvi rg s
n
, r ni nma e oce di
o
ie hi i l i ht

a to pzs a t o4 U. C. 1 8 , le igt tt Co n at a dd z nso h rofc r,
cin l u n t 2 S. 9 9 3 algn ha he mmo we 1 n o e f e fies
r
h
i l ng t gove nora t e ie ge r a s mbl ha vi a e hi co tt tona rght.
nc udi he
r
nd he ntr ne al s e y, ve olt d s nsiu i l i s
The c tg a e Y ow e ' a i a i n t pr e w ihoutpr pa e oft flng f e unde 28
our r nt d
l s pplc t o o oc ed t
e ym nt he ii e
r

U. C.j1 wiht pr viot tt ssauscoul bervo di t c tf t tYowe
S. 915, t he o s ha hi tt
d e ke f he our ound ha
l
ha pr vi l hadt e c e dimi s d asfi ous malci , f f iur t sa ea ca m .
d e ousy
hr e as s s s e
rvol , i ous or or al e o tt li
Upon r e oft c tsr or a t c
eviw
he our ' ec ds nd he ompli ,t c tfndst tYowe doesnot
ant he our i ha
l
qua iy t pr e w ih t sa i wihoutpr pa e oft f e. The e or t cour r voke
lf o oce d t hi cton t
e ym nt he e
r f e, he
te
s

Yo lsi f r pa p rssausu d rj1 5b a ds mma i d s se t a to p ru n
we ' n o ma u e i tt n e 91 ( ) n u rl imis s he cin, u s a t
y
t 28U. C.j1 5( .
o
S. 91 g)
Se ton 1 5( rquie t c tt a s sa ns i ge i tst $ 00flng
ci 91 b) e r s he our o ses gai t ndi nt nmae he 350. ii
f ef a cvi aci n,b a s alowst m t pa t sf et ough i t lm e swihhel fom
e or i l to ut lo l
he o y hi e hr
nsa l nt t d r

t ri t a cou sa t ca epr ese .Seci 1 5( de est i tlme pa nt
hei nmae c nt s he s ogr s s ton 91 g) ni he nsal nt yme
m e hod t t e prs r who ha S hr e sr ke ' - t e pr s ne sw ho ha ha t e
t
o hos i one s
ve ç e ti s ' - hos i o r
t
ve d hr e

pr vi c esora al dimis d asfi ous m a ii ,orf f itr t sa eacli . Eve
e ous as
ppt s s s e
rvol , lcous or a lle o t t
am
n

a pr s r ltga wih t ee s rkesm a qua iy t pr e unde t i t lm e pa entpl n i
i one ii nt t hr t i
y lf o oce d
r he ns a l nt ym
a f

h dsi i n n d n e o sro p ysc l nu y. j 91 ()
e s n mmie t a g r f eius h ia ij r ' 1 5 g .
i
'
Cour r or i ca e t tY ow e ha f l d a l a tt e prorci la tons i f m a
t ec ds ndi t ha
l s ie t e s hr e i vi c i , n or

pa pe i,t twe edim is d asm ai i ,fi ous orf f iur t sa ea cam ; Yowe v.
u rs ha r s s e
lcous rvol , or a l e o t t li
l

J h o No 2:4-v- 47( D. . rl 3 2 0 )( imisda fi lu pzs a to
o ns n, . 0 c 001 E. Va Ap i 2 , 0 4 d s se s rvoo s l u n t
r
Prs rLii tonReor Acl Robi o v.Gimor No. 6663,1 U. App.
ione tgai f m t; ns n
l e, 99999 S.
LEXI
S
296 ( hCi.
42 4t r Nov.1 1 (i i t a a fi ous; i onv.Gimoe, 2: c
0, 999) fndng he ppe l rvol ) Robns
l r No. 99-v0053 ( D. Ma 4,1 ( s se asfi ouspurua t Prs rLii tonReo m
4 E. Va. y 999) dimis d rvol
s nt o ione tgai
fr

Ac) Ro i o v. mmo we lh No 79 -v 0 21 ( . Va M a .1 1 9 )( s s ig
t; bns n Co n at , . :6 c - 0 2 W D. . r , 9 6 dimisn
unde 28U. C.j1 5( )(1 :,af' No.96-387,1 U. App.
r
S. 91 d 996 fd,
6
996 S.
LEXI 1 21 ( h Ci.
S 9 0 4t r
Aug. 1 .Se aloYo v. r ni De rme ofCore tons Ca eNo.7:0-v5, 996) e s wel Vigi a pa t nt
rci , s
1 c 00040

( . Va)(imisn j 1 8 a to wi u p eu ieu e j1 5 g f rtr esrk s.
W D. . d s si g 9 3 cin t t rj dc nd r 91 ( ) o h e tie )l
ho
Theeor t rj1 5( ) hei bardfom flngacviaci i t sc twihoutprpa ng
rf e,mde 91 g , s re r ii
i l ton n hi our t
e yi
t flng f i f lunl s he de
he ii ee n ul e s
monsr t st thei i i i ntda rofphysca hn
ta e ha
s n mm ne
nge
i l nn
r l t d t hi c ains
ea e o s l r .
I hi pr s ntco pl nt Yow e alege û e i r t M a i i D e a ofN e o og c
n s ee
m ai ,
l l s r lbe a e lc ous ni l
ur l i al

M edialCa e a Se vcePr a Pos Sur r ... lbe a eM a ii De a of
c
r nd r i
e nd t ge y De i r t
lc ous ni l

S ii a/ l i u Fre o Beif a tc wih u p n s me t. .a d Deie aeM aii u
p rt l i o s e d m l gr cie t o t u ih n .ln l l rt l o s
u Re g
e
b
c
I lci l jCr lAndUnus lPu s nt Theco antca bes
nfiton of ue
ua nibme .
mpli n ummaiydimis d
rl s s e

u e 2 U. C. 1 5 b ( ) b c u ei fist saea yf csi s p o t ft e ecamso t
nd r 8 S. j 91 A()1 , e a s t al o tt n a t n u p r o h s li r o
de c i c
s rbe onduc by a oft i vi lde e
t ny he ndi dua f ndan si vi a i ofYowelsrg s See
t n olton
' i ht .

Vi daev.Gi ,550F. 926,928( , Ci.977)(i ngt tunde j 1 çibiiywil
nne
bbs
2d
4t r1
h
tndi ha
r 983,ta lt l
l
1 l t opi on dim i i t scas , t courtnot t tYowelpr
n he ni s ssng hi e he
ed ha
oceeded undert s
he ame
i at num be ,#145224,i t eprorcourtpr eedi ,butattm esuse anot name,Barhol e
nm e
r
n hes i
oc ngs
i
d
her
t om w
Robi on.
ns

2

onl 1ewhe ei i af m ai l s
yi
r t s fr tvey hown t tt ofi ilc r d a t d pe s ly i t
ha he fca ha ge c e r ona l n he

d p i ai no tep an itçqrg t' (nena ctto o te ) M o e v r b c u etecams
e rv to f h litfls ih s' i tr l i ins mitd . r o e, e a s h li
)
a
j i mutp ed f n a t i o ec mplit h tp e e t mulpl camsc n en n s p rt lg l
o n lil ee d n s n n o an t a rs n s t e li o c r i g e aae e a
i
que to ,bas d o ditnc eve sa m uli eprs n f clte ,t c
si ns e n si t nt t tpl io a iiis he ompl i i c
ant s omplt l
e ey

c n rr t t er srcinso j i d ro t eae d fn a t a dcamsi Rue 1 a d2
o tay o h e tito n o n e f mrltd ee d n s n li n ls 8 n 0.
M os i pora l how e r Yow e ' co pl n s a esno f c s i ca i t the i i
t m t nty,
ve ,
l s m ai t t t
a t ndi tng ha
sn

i mi ntda rofphysc har r l t t a ofhi cli s Acc di y, he c r fndst t
m ne
nge
ial m e aed o ny
s am .
or ngl t ou t i ha

Yo lsc mplitf i t stsyt eçmmie td n e'e c pint e j1 5 g , a d
we' o an al o aif h i n n a g r' x e to md r 91 ( )2 n
s
i
t r f e,Yow elm a no pr e w ihoutpr pa e oft flng f e a a a plc bl
he e or
y t oc ed t
e ym nt he ii e nd ny p i a e

ad i sr t f es Thec twilr vo isor ral nghi t pr e wihoutpr pa nt
m nita e e .
our l e ke t de lowi
m o oc ed t
e yme .

Fu t r r ,h c u t l ds s ti a to wih u p eu ie p s n t j 1 5 g .
rhemo e t e o r wil imis h s cin t o t rj dc , urua t o 91 ( )
TheCl k i die edt s nd c e oft sm e a
er s r ct o e opi s hi mor ndum opi on a a compa ng
ni nd c
nyi
o dert pl i if
r o a ntf .

ENTER

:T i V% dyo Jn , 0 3
hs
a fu e2 1.
Z
Se
n'

ie St t sDitit dge
t d a e src

2 Y owe1movesse a el f t cour t appoi couns and t or prs of i al t pr de
par t y or he
to
nt
el
o der ion fci s o ovi
c esofuns fed docum ent f eeofchar asnee f Y owelsltgaton.l s
opi
pecii
sr
ge,
ded or
' ii i
n uppor ofhi
t
s
m oton f appoi m entofcouns ,Yow elsa est i M ar orAprl201 he had s ge y i whi
i or
nt
el
t t hat n
ch
i 2,
ur r n ch

S newa c ta y i gi)ne kt e lr t s na c nney i a a tmp t ale aep i fo a
s
bo
s u wa n h s c o n age he pi l ha l' n n te t o lvit an r m
'
pi h dne v i t ta e ofhi b y.( No. - ,a l) I t a t p i a o h rs omsoft
nc e r e n ha r a s od ECF 7 1 t . nse d,he an nd t e ympt
he
pi
nched ne have goten wor e snce t s ger l Oct 201 prson ofi al alegedl
rve
t
s i he ur y. n ober 2, i
fci s l
y
di
scontnue Y owelsneur pai m edi i a ha snce r fus t pr de any m edi car or
i d
'
o- n
catons nd ve i e ed o ovi
cal e
s rvi r aed t hi pi
e ces el t o s nched ne e.
rv
Y oweldoegnoti ca et tt e f w lnesi t ss a e moton f couns ar r eva t hi
ndi t ha hes e i n hi epar t
i or
el e el nt o s

j l 3cli .Eve i t c u t o d I r l c nsr ete ass c t y d no me tt rquie n s
98 ams n f he o r c ul i al o tu h m u h,he o t e he e r me t
be y
ofj 1 1 ( .Gi nt ep s a eo s v r lmonhsb t e t s e n sa t flngo ti a toni
9 5g) ve h a s g f e e a
t e we n he e ve t nd he ii f h s ci n
M ay 201 t y ar i uf i entt suppor a fndi t tY oweli i i i da
3, he e ns fci o
t i ng ha
s n mm nent ngerofphyscalha m
i
r
r at t hi va cl m i t com pl ntt he hasbeen deni uns fed medi car t ough t
el ed o s gue ai n he
ai hat
ed pecii
cal e hr
he
uns fed ac i ofuni ii i vi s
pecii tons
dentfed ndi dual,