Austin v. Colvin
Filing
21
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 07/22/2014. (ssm)
CL S OFFI O. DI COURT
ERK'
CE S. ST.
AT ROANOKE,
VA
Fi
LEO
I THE UNI S
N
TED TATESDI TRI COURT
S CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF V I NI
CT
RGI A
R OAN O KE DI SI
VI ON
J 22 2 1
UL
29
J
UU
:v:
U ('
-6
E
UTY CL
ERK
SHA RON P.AU STI
N
Ci lA c i N o. 7:
vi ton
13CV 00251
Pl i if
a ntf ,
M EM O M N DU M O PI I N
N O
CA ROLY N W . LVI , c i
CO
N A tng
Com m i s one ofSoc alSe urt
si r
i
c iy,
By:
H on. l E.Corr d
G en
ta
Chi fU nie St t s Di t i tJ ge
e
t d a e sr c ud
D e e nt
f nda .
Pli tf ha fl t saci c le ng t fna de ii oft Comm isone ofSoca
a n if s ied hi ton ha lngi he i l c son he
si r
il
Se urt de ngpl i ifsc am f s e àl e urt nc be ft unde t Soc a Se urt
c iy nyi antf l i or upplmen s c iyi ome ne is
r he i l c iy
Ac,asn nde 42U. C.j 1 qts g. J iditon oft sc ti purua t 42 U. C.j
t me d,
S.
381 e. urs ci
hi our s s nt o
S.
1 c( , c i or ae j205( oft SocilSe urt Act42U. C.j405g) Thi c t
383()3)whih nc ports
g) he a c iy , S.
( . s our'
s
r viw i lm ied t a deer na i a t whe he t r i s t nta e de e t s
e e s i t o
t mi ton s o
t r he e s ubsa i l vi nc o uppor t
t he
Com m i s o rsc l i ha pl i iff ie t m ee t c tonsf e il m e tes a i hed by
s i ne ' onc usont t a ntf a l d o
t he ondii or ntte n t bls
a pur ua t t A c .l s h s t nta e de e e s s t fna de s on oft Com m i s one
nd s nt o he t f uc ubsa i l vi nc xi t , he i l ci i
he
si r
mus beafimed.Lawsv.Cee e ze 368 F. 6 (t Ci.1 .Sttdbrel s tnta
t
fr
lbrz ,
2d 40 4h r 966) ae ify, ubsa il
e de ehasbe n de i ass h r e nte denc , onsde i t r c d a a whol ,a m i htbe
vi nc
e fned uc el va vi e c i r ng he e or s
e s g
f
ound a ua et s
deq t o uppor ac ncusonbyar s na em i Riha ds v. r l s 402U . 38
t o l i
ea o bl nd. c r on Pe a e ,
S. 9,
40l( 971.
1 )
Thepl i if Sha o P. us i w a bor on Se e ber1 1
a ntf , r n A tn, s n
pt m
3, 970.W hieM s Aus i she d
l
. tnha l
sverlobsfrveys r pei oftme t Admi srtveLaw J f t ts thasnopa t
e aj o r ho t rods i ,he
nitai
udge ound ha he û
s
r e twor ' ( 22) OnDe e r1 2009, s Ausi flda a iainf s e ntl
elvan k. TR .
'
c mbe 6,
M . tn ie n pplc to or upplme a
s c iy i om e be ft . Pl ntf aleg d t ts bec m e di a e f al f m s of s t nta
e ur t nc
ne is ai if l e ha he a
s bl d or l or
ubs a i l
gai ul m pl e o J r a y 1 200 duet m uli em e a il s s bi ar ood s i , nge
nf e oym nt n a m r , 3
o
tpl nt l lnes e , pol m
w ngs a r
is ,l c off us s ve e de es i hy r c i t pa c a tc ,a ey, c pan,a t ii,
s ues a k oc , e r pr son, pe a tviy, ni ta ks nxit ba k i rhrts
hea c ,a j ntpai Pli ifnow mant nst ts hasrmai d dia edt t pr s n
da hes nd oi n. antf
i ai ha he
e ne sbl o he e e t
tm e
i .
M s Ausi sa ia i
. tn' pplc tonwasde e
ni dupo i ta c i r to a e onsde a i Shet n
n nii l onsde a in ndr c i r ton.
he
r
equese a rc ve aX novohe rnga rviw beor anAdmi sr tveLa J
td nd e ei d
ai nd e e f e
nitai w udge.I a
n n
o ni da e Fe ta y 9,201 t La J
pi on t d brz r
2, he w udge a s de e m i d t tpl ntf i notdi a ed. The
l o t r ne ha ai if s
s bl
Law J
udge f
ound t tM s Ausi s f r fom a hit y ofpol ubsa e a e'a et posha
. tn ufe s r
sor
ys t nc bus , nxi y; t
t a a i sr sdi or r bi a / t ym i dior r pa cdi or r pe s na iydi or r l ba ,
r um tc tes s de ; pol rdys h c s de ; ni s de ; r o lt s de ; um go'
a s de a tlal a.( 1 .Be us oft s i i nt,heLa J r e t tpli if
nd houl r rlr gi TR 4) ca e he e mpanne st w udge uld ha antf
i dia e f a hi m o et n almie r ngeoflg wor aci t
s s bld or nyt ng r ha i t d a
i ht k tviy.The La J e a s s d
w udg s es e
M s A usi sr i ualf tona ca c t a f l s
. tn' es d
unc i l pa iy s olow :
Afe c r f l c i r ton oft en ie r c d,t unde sgne fnds t t t
tr a e' onsde a i
u
he tr e or he
ri d i
ha he
cli a ha t r i f nci c pa t t pe f m lg wo k asde i d i 20
am nt s he esdual u tonal a ciy o ror iht r
fne n
CFR 41 967(9 e e s s d a d ale ur t haz r ma hi r
6. 1 xc pt he houl voi l xpos e o adous c ney,
unpr ec ed he ght , nd c i bi orl dder ,r
ot t
i s a lm ng a
s opesa s a f ds The cl i a i
nd c f ol .
a m nt s
lm ie t sm pl r i , r pe ii uns le w or t s ; pr
i t d o i e, outne and e ttve kil d
k a ks no oduc i r t or
ton a e
pa w or w ih sr c pr ton s a z ;no i e ac i n w ih t publc;a no
ce
k t ti t oduc i t nda ds
nt r to
t he
i nd
m or t n occ s ona i e a to w ih c wor r a s r i or .
e ha
a i l nt r c i n t o- ke s nd upe v s s
( 1 .Gi ns har i lf nci lc pa t a a rc i rngpli ifsa , ai
TR 6) ve uc esdua u tona a ciy, nd he onsdei antf ge educ ton,
a l c ofprorw or e r e e as wel a t tm on f o a voc tona e r , he La J
nd a k
i
k xpe i nc ,
l s esi y ' m
r
a i l xpe t t
w udge
de e m i d t tM s Aus i r ai s f c e f to ca c t t peror s ve als cii lg
t r ne ha
. tn et ns uf i i nt unc i nal pa iy o f m e r pe tc i ht
w o k r e e s i i s g tc tnum be i t na i lec
r ol s xitng n i nii an
r n he tona onom y. Acc di y,t Law J
or ngl he
udge
uli a e y c l ed t tM s A us i i notdi a e a t ts i note il t s e en a
tm t l onc ud ha
. tn s
s bl d, nd ha he s
ntted o uppl m t l
s trt i omebeneks Se ge rly,20 C. R.j41 9 g .TheLa J e' opi o wa
ecziy nc
t . e neal
F.
6.20()
w udg s nin s
adopt ast fnaldeci on oft Com m i i
ed he i
si
he
ss onerby t Soci Secmi y A dm i staton' A ppeal
he
al
t
ni r i s
s
Counc l Ha nge
i. vi xhause a1a ia ea i sr tver medi , s Ausi ha no a a e t
t d 1 va lbl dm nita i e
es M . tn s w ppe l d o
t s court
hi
.
W hie pl i i f m a be di a e f c rai f m s of em pl en , t c uc a f c ual
l a ntf
y
s bl d or e t n or
oym t he r i l a t
d t r i ton i w he her a ntf w a dia e f a l or sofs t tal i ul m pl e .Se
e e m na i s t pl i if s s bl d or l f m
ubsan i ga nf e oym nt e
42U. C.j 1 2c() Theea ef ee nt ofpr whihmus bec i rdi ma ngs h
S.
38 a. r r our lme s oof c
t onsdee n ki uc
ana l i.Thes eeme saes
nayss
e l nt r ummaieda f l :( )ob e tveme c fcsa ci c
rz s olows 1 j ci
dial a t nd lnial
fn i g ;2 teo no a dc n lso so te tn p y iin ;3 s b e tv e ie c o p y ia
id n s ( )h piins n o cu i n fraig h sca s ( ) u j cie vd n e f h sc l
ma ie tt nso i anne t, sd srb dt r u h acama t tsi n a ( t ecama t
nf sai f mp i ns a e ci e h o g li n ' e tmo y; nd 4) h li n '
o
s
s
ed ton, ai hit y,e i ls ls a age Vie v. nc 438F. 11 11 60( h
ucai voc tonal sor rsdua kil, nd . tk Fi h,
2d 57, 59- 4t
Ci.1 ) Unde woodv. biof,298F. 8 851( hCi.1 .
r 971 ; r
Ri c f
2d 50, 4t r 962)
Afera r viw oft r or i t s c e,t co ti c tai d t c ude t t t
t
e e
he ec d n hi as he ur s onsr ne o oncl
ha he
Com m i s one ' fna de i i n i s
s i r s i l c s o s uppore by s t nta e de e. M s Aus i s f r f om a
td
ubs a i l vi nc
. tn uf e s r
c bi ton ofph i la e o i lc tons The c tbe i vest tt m edi alevi nce
om na i
ys ca nd m tona ondii .
our le
ha he
c
de
c e ry s
l a l uppor st Law J
t he
udge s fndi t tpl i i f s s ve e ph i lpr bl m s do notpr ve
' i ng ha a ntf e r ys ca o e
e nt
pe f m a e oflgh e l ve sofwor a tviya H oweve , s A us i se otona pr e s m ood
r or nc
i tr e l
k ci t l
r M . tn' m i l obl m ,
di or r a pe s lt de i i i pr s n a m uc c os r que to A c or ng t pl i if s
s de , nd r ona iy fc enc es e e t
h l e
s i n. c di o a ntf
t tm ony, heha r e vedt e t e f va i e otona s m pt sove ape i ofs ve al a s
es i
s
s ec i r a m nt or rous m i l y om
r r od e r ye r .
She c r i a di nos s of bi a di o der a he doc or ha pr de t e t en f pa c,
a res
ag i
pol r s r , nd r t s ve ovi d r a m t or ni
a e y,a r and de e s on.
nxi t nge ,
pr s i
1l t s r pec , teLa J d erj ce t f dig o tesaea e c p y iin wh c n ld dta Ms
n hi es t h w u g ee td he i n s f h tt g n y h sca s o o cu e h t .
n
Au tn d d n th v s v r p ysc li ar n . ( 2 ) T La J d e h l t a p an ifslmb g s o l e
si i o a e e e e h ia mp ime t TR 0 . he w u g ed h t l itf ' u a o, h u d r
pr e s a a t ii c pli sar s s ver ast pr ve pe f nc ofm e mnandhe wor a tviy, ndt t
oblm , nd rhrtc om ant e o e e o e nt ronna e
di
avy k c i t a ha
t s m epr em slm it r ngeofs ntr ndlg wor a tviyf
he a
obl i the a
ede a ya iht k c i t orwhihplitf soher s physcal ca bl
c anifi t wie
i ly pa e.
Suc fndi a ef l consse w iht medial ec d.
h i ngs r uly
itnt t he
c r or
I c nu to wi t ea j iaino plitf scam f rs p lme tls c rt ic me
n o j nci n t h dudc to f an if li o u pe n a e u i n o
h
y
be tt , he s a e di a lt a nc r f r ed M s Aus i t D r M a vi A .Gar ne ,J . a c i ca
nei s t t t s biiy ge y e e r
. tn o . r n
d r r , lni l
ps
ychol s ,f a consulatve eval i The prm ar diput i t s cas concer t pr
ogi t or
ti
uaton.
i y s e n hi e
ns he oper
i e pr t ton t be gi n t Dr Ga dne ' ps hol c l r por . U li a el t La J
nt r e a i o
ve o . r r s yc ogi a e t
tm t y, he w udge
de e m i d t Dr Ga dne ' a s s me s
t r ne hat . r rs s e s nt upporsa fndng ofr sdua f tona ca ciy f
t i i
e i l unci l pa t or
sm pl , outne a r pe ii uns le w or as no i vi pr uc i n w or i e ac i w ih
i e r i , nd e ttve, kil d
kt ks t nvol ng od t o
k, nt r ton t
t publc orm or t n oc as o li e a ton w ih c w or r a s r s s
he
i,
e ha c i na nt r c i
t o- ke s nd upe vi or .
H a ng r vi w e a lt e de of r cor t c tm us a e t t t La J
vi e e d l he vi nce
e d, he our
t gr e ha he w udge'
s
fndi a enot m r s bl a t tt La J e' a s s m e tofpl i if sr s dual u tonal
i ngs r
l ea ona e, nd ha he w udg s s e s n
a ntf e i f nc i
c pa iy i s
a c t s uppored by t m e c l r co d. A t t a i s r tve he r ng, t La J
t
he di a e r
he dm nit a i
ai
he w udge
pr
opounde ahypot tca quesi t avoc tona e r whih i l edasumptonsba e ont
d
he i l ton o
a i l xpe t c ncud
s
i
s d he
La J
w udge' as e s e ofDr Ga dne ' r por ,a wel as lm ia i as oc a e wih pl i if s
s s s m nt
. r r s e t s l i t tons s i t d t a ntf
ph i lpr e s l r s
ysca obl m . n e pons t voc tona e r i ntfe s ver ls ii lghtw or r e i
e, he a i l xpe t de ii d e a pec f c i
k ol s n
whi h pl i ifco d be e
c a ntf ul
xpec e t pe f m . I ap a st t c tt tt voca i le
t d o r or
t pe r o he our ha he
tona xper'
ts
e ua i oft voc tona f c or , t a s ptons unde w hi t e r de i r t d,a e
val ton he a i l a t s and he s um i
r ch he xpe t lbe a e r
bot r s na e a co i t n w iht e de e ofr cor The c t nc udest t heLa J e
h ea o bl nd ns s e t t he vi nc
e d.
our co l
ha t
w udg
pr pe l r le on t voc tonale r ' i
o ry e i d
he a i
xpe ts nputi as e sng pl i if s c pa iy f r a t m a e w or
n ssi
a ntf a c t o le t
k
a tviis Thus t c tfndst tt r co d s
c i te .
, he our i ha he e r upporst La J
t he w udge' de e mi ton t tM s
s t r na i ha
.
A us i r t i s f c ent f to l c pa t t pe f m s ve a s c fc w or r e e s i i
tn e a ns ufi i
unc i na a ciy o r or e r l pe ii
k ol s xitng n
s gnii a num be i t na i le nom y. I m uc as t c thas c uded t tt La
i f c nt
r n he tona co
nas h
he our
oncl
ha he w
J
udge' opi on i s
s ni s uppor e b s t n i l e de e i f l s t t fnal de s on of t
t d y ubs a t a vi nc , t olow hat he i
cii
he
Com m i si
s onerm us be af i
t
fnned.
4
Asno e a
t d bove, n t c tsvi w , hi c s t r o t w e ght asw e la t e pha e ,
i he our' e t s a e u ns n he i ,
l s he m
ss
t be a co d t Dr Ga d r sps hol ca tndi . On a
o
c r ed o . r ne ' yc ogi l i ngs
ppea , a ntf m a nt i t tt Law
l pl i if i a ns ha he
J g i r p ryrj ce c rano Dr Gad e' fndng , ndt tteLa J g fie t sae
ud e mp o el ee td e ti f . z n rs i i s a ha h w ud e ald o tt
m e ni ulr as i s
a ngf e ons n uppor ofhi as e s e t oft ps hol c lr por . M or s c fc l
t
s s sm n
he yc ogi a e t
e pe i i aly,
pli ifco e t tt La J
antf nt nds ha he w udge f ie t t ke i o ac o tDr Ga d rs o e vai n t t
al d o a nt c un . r ne ' bs r to ha
t l mantsm a ke i im e ofc en r ton woul pr em a ke wo k-elt d i par e
l ai
c
' z d mpar nt onc ta i
d oduc
r d r r a e m im nt
o c nrton, ritnce o pa .'( 269 .Asnoedb pl ntf, . r ras obsr ed
f once tai pesse , r ce' TR )
t y ai if Dr Ga dne lo e v
t a tecama tstu g n i mo eaeyt mak dyi ardi d iylf . ( 2 8 .Fi l
h th li n ' j d me t s d rtl o r e l mp ie n al ie' TR 6 ) nal
'
y,
pl i ifa guest tD r G a dne ' fnd ngsa as e s e t nd t s
a ntf r
ha . r r s i i
nd s s m nt e o uppor t c e biiy ofm uc
t he r di lt
h
ofpl ntf st si ony, ndt tt La J
ai if e tm
a ha he w udgei ope l dic t t tpori oft t si o
mpr ry s oun ed ha ton he e tm ny
s
ugge tng i biiy t pe f m r gul ra s t i d w or a tviy.
s i na lt o ror e a nd us a ne
k ci t
W hie pl i if s a gum e s a e m e ngf ,a no w ihout s e s
l a ntf r
nt r
ani ul nd t t
om uppo ti t m e c
r n he di al
r or t co tmus uli aey c l t tt La J ge' tndi ofr i
ec d, he ur
t tm t l onc ude ha he w ud s i ng
esdualf nc i nal
u to
ca c t f a lm ie r
pa iy or i t d ange ofw or i co i t n w ih t co ula i ps hol c lr por . D r
k s ns s e t t he ns t tve yc ogi a e t .
Ga dne s c/c ly f und t tM s Ausi i ta e t pe f m smpl a r pe ii t s a
r r pe i a l o
ha
. tn s ûbl o ror i e nd e ttve a ks nd
mai ai r gulratnda ei t worplc ' ( 269) TheLa J a e t sfndi a
nt n e a te nc n he k a e.' TR
.
w udge doptd hi i ng nd
i l
nc uded i i t hypo he i alquesi n pos d t t voc tona expe t The La J
t n he
t tc
to
e o he a i l
r.
w udge a s not d
lo e
D r Ga d r s de e m i ton t t pl i i f i a e t d r or w or a tvii s w ihout s i or
. r ne ' t r na i ha a ntf s bl o ' f m
pe
k c i te t
pec al
a t o s r son, a t ts i a e t tc pl t a nor a w or y o w or e k w ihou
ddii nal upe vi i ' nd ha he s bl o t om e e
'
m l kda r kw e t t
i er i r uli fom he ps hiti co to '( 269) .
ntruptons es tng r
r yc arc ndiin' TR
.
A sf pl i if sc e r t o o e s t c ur not t tt r i s er a o t bele
or a ntf onc nt a i npr bl m , he o t es ha he e s om e s n o i ve
t tM s Ausi woul e j abetrl lofpef ma ei pr l te t Att tmeofhi
ha . tn
d noy te eve
ror nc f opery raed. he i
s
e ua i on M a 1 2010, . r rsa e t tM s Ausi i t ure l nott ki a m e a
val ton
y 9,
Dr Ga dne tt d ha . tn s E r nty
c
a ng ny ntl
heat me c tons' ( 264) Fi l t co tbele st ti fndi ar i lf tonal
lh diai . TR
'
. naly, he ur ive ha n i ng esdua unci
ca c t f alm ie r ng oflght ri t La J epr pe l r le on r por sf o t o s a e
pa iy or i t d a e i exe ton, he w udg o ry e i d e t r m w t t
ag y ps hol i t who pe f m e r c d r vi w s a of e ed o ni as pa tof t ea le
enc yc og s s
r or d e or e e
nd f r pi ons
r
he ri r
a j iaino plitf scam frb n ft.Boh saea e yps c o o it c n ld dt a Ms
dudc to f an if li o e e is t tt g nc y h l gss o cu e h t .
Ausi e re esno mor t m ode aelm ia i , nd t ts i no dia e f ra1 f
tn xpe i nc
e han
r t i t tons a ha he s t s bl d o 1 onnsof
wo k. ( 60- a 73- . Bot ps hol ss e plcil consdee and rle upon Dr
r TR 64 nd 77)
h yc ogit x i ty
i rd
eid
.
G a dne ' cons t tver po t n c
r rs
ula i e r i onduc i he rr or r e s Thec t i t tt La J e
tngt i ec d evi w .
our fnds ha he w udg
r a ona yr i d ont s a s s e si det nni ng t t s A us i e a nss fci ntphysca a
e s bl ele
he e s es m nt n e ni ha M . tnr t i uf i e
i l nd
e otona ca ciy t pe f r a lm ie r nge of lg w or a tviy. Gi n D r Gar r s
m i l pa t o r o m
i td a
i ht
k ci t
ve
. dne '
ps hol c las es m e , t r or r vi w spe f m ed by t sa e a nc ps
yc ogi a s s nt and he ec d e e
r or
he t t ge y ychol s s t
ogi t , he
c ta s be i ve t t he e i e de e t s
our l o le s ha t r s vi nc o uppor t La J
t he w udge' dec s on not o f l c e tt t
s ii
t uly r di ha
po ton of pl i i fs t s i ony i w hi h s de crbe i a c t f r gul r a s t ne
ri
a ntf ' e tm
n
c he s i d nc pa iy or e a nd usai d
e pl ym e a i t
m o nt ctviy.
I a fnni t Com m i s one ' fna de son,t c tdoe nots
n f i ng he
s i r s i l ci i he our
s
ugge tt tM s A us i
s ha
. tn
i f ee of a lpa n,or t t s doe no e r e e de e s o a e y,pa c a t ks a m ood
sr
l i
ha he s t xpe i nc pr s i n, nxi t
ni tac , nd
s i . l e t m edi alr c d co im st tpl i ifs f r f o s ve e ph i lpr e s
w ngs nde d, he
c e or nfr ha a ntf uf e s r m e r ysca obl m ,
as wel a bi a di or ra pe s na iy di or r ,whi h ca be e c ed t r ul i phys c
l s pol r s de nd r o lt s de s
c n
xpe t o es t n
i al
lm ia i a
i t tons ndw oni om ee otona m a f s a i ns How e r aso lne a
s
m i l ni e t to .
ve , uti d bove, hec t le s
t our be i ve
t tt La J
ha he w udgepr ry a co t d f pli ifsphysc dit uli i a s sngherr sdua
ope l c un e or antf
i al fk tes n s es i
ei l
f t onalcapaciy f w or M or
unc i
t or k.
eover gi D r.G ar
, ven
dner' ps
s ychol calass m ent,t court
ogi
ess
he
fndst t
i
hat here i evi
s dence t s
o uppor t noton t M s.A us i can per or si pl r i and
t he i hat
tn
f m m e, outne,
6
r pe ii uns le wor t s whi h do no i ve pr duc i r quie nt or s t tal
e ttve kild
k a ks
c
t nvol
o ton e r me s
ubsan i
i e a ton w ih o he pe e I m us be r ogni ed t tt i biiy t do w or wihouta y pai
nt r c i
t t r opl . t t ec z ha he na lt o
k t
n
n
o s b e tv ma ie tto d e no o i efrn e acama t oal d sb e Cri v Ch tr7
r u j cie nf sains o s t f t l e d r li n ttly ia ld. ac . ae,6
s
F. 585,594- ( hCi.1 6) Onc a i i a ast t c tt tt Ad nitai La
3d
95 4t r 99 . e gan,t ppe r o he our ha he mi srtve w
J d eg v ra o a ec n ieaint a1 f h s be tv fco ss p o tdb t eme ia r c r
u g a e e s n bl o sd rto o lo t e u jcie a tr u p re y h dc le o d
i aj dc tn p an ifscam f r n t .Asrg r sh rp y ia p o lms t ec t t le e
n du iai g litf li o be eks
e ad e h sc l r be ,h o l beiv s
r
t tt La J
ha he w udge ga M s A us i t be ftof t doubt i tndi s ve e i pa r e s l
ve . tn he ne i
he
n i ng e r m im nt . t
f l st ta1 f ce s oft Co m i s one ' f na de s on a e s pore by s t nta evi nce
olow ha l a t
he m s i r s i l cii r up t d
ubs a i l de .
A s a ge r nze,r s uto ofconti t i t evi nce i a m a t rw ihi t pr nce of
ne al l e ol i n
l c s n he de
s
te t n he ovi
al
t Co mi so re n i t c t i r s vet c lc sdif r nty.Riha ds m v.Per es,
he m s i ne ve f he our m ght e ol he onfit fe e l
c r f
-
s a Oppe m v. nc 495F. 396( hCi. 974) Fort ras sae t c ti t
upr ;
nhei Fi h,
2d
4t r 1 . he e ons ttd,he our fnds he
Com m i s one ' r ol i oft pe tne c lc s i t r c d i t s ca e t be s
s i rs es uton he r i nt onfi t n he e or n hi s o
uppore by
td
s t n i l vi nce A c or ngl t fna de i i n oft Com m i s one m us be a fr e La s
ubs a t a e de . c di y, he i l c s o
he
s i r t f i m d. w
v. lbrz e s r.Ana r p it j d me ta do d rwil ee tr dt i d y.
Cee e z ,up a
pp o rae u g n n r e lb nee h s a
The C l r i diec e t s nd ce tte c esoft sopi on t al cou elofr cor
ek s r td o e
rii d opi
hi
ni o 1 ns
e d.
ENTER : Thi J%e
s
d yo uy 2014.
a fl l,
f
Chi fUnie St t D i ti tJ
e
t d a es s r c udge
7
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?