Hoglan et al v. Robinson et al
Filing
64
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 09/19/2014. (kab)
cœ nrsoFFl u.. sx p ce s a
A
AT> MUa ,
vA
F D
I THE UNI S
N
TED TATESDI CT COURT
STRI
FO R TH E W E STER N DI
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
RO A N O K E D I SI N
VI O
A
s
J K
DL
x
DO UGLAS A.HOG LAN,
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
M EM ORANDUM OPJ O N
NI
A .D AV I R O BI SO N ,e al,
D
N
t .
D ef
endant
s.
.
Ci lActon No.7: 3- vvi i
1 c 00258
V.
By:H on.Jac on L.K i e
ks
jr
Se or U nied St e Di t i tJudge
ni
t
at s s r c
'
Pli ifDougl A .
antf
as Hogln,aVigi ai aepr e di pr K ,fl ave ii d Co ant
a
r ni nm t oc e ng o
ied
rfe
mpli
a a e e s pur uantt 42 U .S. j1 3, esntngffe n cams1 Pl i ifnn e va i
nd m ndm nt
s
o
C. 98 pr e i ite li . antf m s rous
safoft Vigi aDe rme ofCore tons(ç
tf he r ni pa t nt
rci :
VDOC' asdee nt.Defnda sfldamoin
'
)
fnda s
e nt ie
to
frs mmayj d me t a dPlitf rs o d d ma igtematrrp f rd s sto 2 Aj
o u r u g n, n an if e p n e , kn h te ie o ipo iin. ur
rve n ter c r 1 n Dee d n s moin frs mmayj g n a t cam 7a ddrc
e iwig h e o d, de y fn a t' t o u r ud me t s o li n ie t
o
De e d n st tl amoin frsl r j d me ta o tt t li d n De e d n s mo inf r
fn a t o ie to o l
mmay u g n b u ha cam; e y fn a t' to o
s
ummayj d me t t u p eu iea t Plitf se h use camso rtlaind et t e
r u g n wi t rj dc s o anif x a td li f eaito u o h
ho
p nd n yo cam 7 a d ga tt mo inf rs mma yj g n a t a1 t rcams
e e c f li , n r n he to o u r ud me t s o l ohe li .
1.
On J nua y 30, 2009,Pli ifwa s nt nce t ffy- yea s i prs nm e 3afe hepla d
a r
e de
antf s e e d o it one r ' m i o nt tr
g i yt t c u t o a ul rt d ikt ij r,woc t so a utrt f o ,h e c u t o
u l o wo o n s f d t ae rn o n u e t omt f d leae o d tre o n s f
t
e
aggr va e s xualba tr one c
a td e
te y,
ountofunl wf fl ngpho ogr phy, nd t c sofpos es i of
a ul imi / t a
a wo ount
s son
hid nogr phy.
nweat v. H og a N o.CR080001 CR0800041 CR07000982,
1h
c l por a 4 Comm o
l n,
02,
7,
CR070011 ( rui Ct St fr Cnt )(vaiabl vi Vigi aCic tCour Cael or ton,
01 Cic t . afo d y. a l e a r ni rui
t s nf mai
ht /e o ilc u .tt.au / l e /ic i. p ; e . ..Fe . Evi. 2 ( )2 ;n Re
tpi ws cs .o hssaev .sclsW bcrut s ) se eM, d R. d R. 01b ( ) l
/
j
Karn Ca a Br a h sCo s . tg, 3 F. u p. d 6 5 6 1 3 & n 1 - 5( D. . 0 8 ;
tia n l e c e n olLii.5 3 S p 2 1 , 3 - 3 n.4 1 E. La 2 0 )
1TheCompl n , a e e s andex bist a ne ry 400 pa .
ait m ndm nt,
hi t otl a l
ges
2Themoinfrs mmayj d me tb ifi sp r afd vt, n e hbi ttl e ry30 p g s a dPlitf'
t o u r u g n, re n u poq fia isa d x i t oa n al 0 a e , n anifs
o
s
r s ei m or t n 1 pa s.
e pons s e ha 50 ge
m
M %
j
j
W il msv Lo g 5 5F. u p. d67 , 8 - 8& n4( M d. 0 8 .So ntee fe , litf wa
li . n , 8 S p 2 9 6 6 8
a
. D. 2 0 ) o h ra tr P an if s
t a f r ed t t c t ofV D OC ofk i s
r ns e r o he us ody
t al .
W hl ic re ae a teVDOC' P c h na SaeCo r cina Fa it (TSCC', an if
ie n ac rtd t h
S o a o ts tt re to l cl y ç
i
' Plitf
)
at mpt d t r ei va i books , fye sde c i nude wom e a t l s i o dipl y off mal
te e o ec ve rous
s l r pitng
n nd he a evi us s a
e e
ge t la , com m er i lphot ofnude ors n iy- e s d wo e , a pe i c l7fom s ce
niai 6
os
ca tl dr s e
m n nd rodi a s r our s
ca
ou s de t pr s buts a fw oul i e c tde i r a pr ve Pl i if spos es i oft s iem s
t i he i on,
tf
d nt r ep lve y nd e nt a ntf
s s on he e t
ptr ua t e t rPSCC W a de Young' diec i t tno PSCC i a e m a or rc m e c a
ls nt o ihe
r n
s r tve ha
nm t
y de om r i l
phot r phsors eo herVDOC o PSCC polc Pl n ift ucc s f l pur ue a i sr tve
og a
om t
r
iy. aitf ms e s uly s d dm nitai
r medi wih PSCC a VDOC ofk i l.
e
es t
nd
t as
l De mbe 2011 de e ntBoyd,t Se orPs hol s atPSCC,c e t d a Ca e Pl n
n ce r
, f nda
he ni yc ogit
rae
s a
Ag e me t(te t n p a ' t a,ne ai, r hbi dPlitf Sr m v e n o p se sn a y
re n ir ame t ln' h t itr la p o i t anif t o iwig r o s sig n
l
)
e
f
publc tons ma e i l,orphot whih m a bederm e alt t te t e pln ort tma pr m ot
ia i , t ras
os c
y
ti nt o he r am nt a
ha y o e
8
e a
de a be vi si l ng s ly de a be or .' C as Pl n A gt, ECF N o.47, gei no.
vint ha or ncudi exua l vi nt havi s'
pa d.
.
8 Pl i ifsgne t team e pl n on De embe 16, 1, lt rbele d t ti wasc e e a
20. antf i d he r t nt a
c
r 201 but a e ive ha t
r atd s
r t la i f flnggre nce a
e a iton or ii
i va s bouthi i biiy t r cevenude i
s na lt o e i
mage a books Pli ifs
s nd
. antf
contnue at mpt t r cevepor a cpho os fye s pa phlt , nd booksalege y pr
i d te s o e i
nogr phi
t , l r, m es a
l dl ompt d
e
PSCC saf t r t laeby s r hi hi c l s i ng i a sofc l e and wo e a co ci
t f o e ait
ea c ng s el, ezi m ge
hidr n
m n, nd nvi tng
3Thesaecour s pe d a1butt yyea soft s enc , a Pl ntf willkeyber las dba k i ot
tt
t us nde l
went r he ent e nd ai if l i l
ee e c nt he
communiy whie i hi e l sxtes
t
l n s ary i i .
4Stt c tr or r vea t tt f l ng c r swe enolepr s aûe heplade g ly:t c sofdei r
ae our ec ds e l ha he olowi ha ge r l osed r
e d uit wo ount
lve
a tr td f ei c sofpos esi ofchid por a atmptd r ,a fvecou sofa avae s l
dule ae ood, ght ount
s son
l nogr phy, te e ape nd i
nt
ggr td exua
batr l
te y. d.
5Theboo a eTheGilw iht Dr on Ta t , Pahfnde :Ki M ake -Bl f Bl > TheFlntSaaa andThe
ks r
r t he ae
too t i r na
r ood or ood
i
,
AritsCompl eGui t Fa i Expr sons Alho r ernce i Pl nifsExhi tP, antf doesnotc le
ts'
et
de o cal
es i . t ugh ef e d n aitf
bi Pli if
halnge
t diposton oft book Ba isofBi i Gr k.
he s ii
he
sc
blcal ee
6Pl ntf r e st t ie asdc t ogs' ndStye s' l Defnda sr f t t m as(tye s' Thedc t og'
ai if efr o he tms çaal 'a t r 'whie e nt eer o he
l
çl r . '
taal '
a r t cons s off r y phot aphsofna d w om e e t ri sngl org oup s lpos s on 8 % i h by 1l i h
ppea s o
it o t
ogr
ke
n, ihe n i e r
exua
e,
nc
nc
pa r.Forco itnc Ir f rt t tye sc t ogsa S l r '
pe
nsse y, e e o he l r /aal s l ye s.
f
'
1Thepe i caswer t is ofPl
rodi l
e wo sues
ayboyLi re
nge i.
8Thesatdgoaloft te mentpln wast addr sPl ntf side tuctves xualis s'duei lr pa tohi
te
he r at
a
o
es ai if' t sr i e
s ue '
n a ge r t s
çpr bl'c i i t nki obs r ton,whih i cae alc ofa e a ofr ponsbiiy f hi c i i lc
ç oba e' rm nalhi ng e vai
c ndi ts a k cc ptnce es i lt or s rm na onduc .
t
ECF N o.47,pa i no.8
ge d.
20.
. ..
.
-.
Pl i ifofva i usi tt i i r to f vi a i t t r soft team e pl n.9 Pli if
antf
ro nsiutonal nfaci ns or oltng he e m
he r t nt a
a ntf
be ivest s a t wer unl wf r t ito be a e Pl i ifha be a l d t r eve s h iems
le he e c s e a ul ealai n c us antf d en lowe o ec i uc t
dlrng hi pro t ye r i t VDOC a di nothel Boyd de l t te t ntpln.
zi
s i r wo a s n he
nd d
p
ve op he r a me a
The i tt i lcon c i uli a ey 1 d t Pl ntf sni t da ta f rt t PSCC
nsiutona
vitons tm t l e o ai if ney- y r nse o he
S r cu e Li igUnt(( ' whihi ah usn a sg n ta i mo ec nr le t ng n r l
tu t rd vn i ç
SLU', c s o i g s inme t h t s r o to ld ha e ea
)
p p lto b tls ta s g e ain.Se VDOC Op rtn Pr c d z C$ '8 ..Afe a vn a
o uain u e s h n e r g to
e
eaig o e u e OP' 417 tr ni ig t
)
t SLU on N ove be 6, 2, a ntf no l rha phys c la ce st t PSCC 1 lbr r
he
m r 201 Pl i if onge d
i a c s o he
aw i a y
alhough he c d silc
t
oul tl ommuni t wih t prvae at r as i d t PSCC a coul r ques
cae t he i t to ney sgne o
nd
d e t
s c fc lgalma e i l fom hi t tco el a t i ae lw-i ar cer .Pl i iff ndt s
pe ii e
t ras r
s mi uns or nd he nm t a lbr y l ks antf ou hi
s t m t bel sconve e a e f c i t n i heha physca ac es t t 1 lbr r
yse o es
ni nt nd fe tve ha f
d
i l c s o ht aw i a y.
Pl i ifa guesff e n m ulif ce ed c ai si ve w ih hi i a c r ton a t PSCC,
a ntf r
ite
t- a t l m nvol d t s nc r e a i t he
e e a e 1 asf jows
num r t d 0 o j .
.
Cl i 4. Young,Ga man,A.Robi on,Coli ,Co lnd, Al i vi a e Pli tf Fis
am
r
ns
lns pea and drdge olt d a n ifs rt
A m endm e rghtt r ce ve i or t o i prs a t Four e nt Am e
nt i o e i nf ma i n n i on nd he
te h
ndm e t 1rghtt
n1 i o
due pr es by nota rng t t Sspec tc Crt r a f Publca i n D i a oval' lned
oc s
dhe i o he ç ii ie i or
i to
s ppr ' outi
i O P 803. d nc i Publca i , when pr ntng Pl i if s r c ptoft book The
n
2, s om ng
l
i tons'
'
eve i
a ntf e ei
he
Gi lw ih t D r on Ta t
r t he ag
t oo.
Cli 5. M o d vi aed Pl i ifsFis Am e
am
ul ol t
antf
rt
ndmentrghtt r evepu i tonsi prs a
i o ec i
blcai n ion nd
Foure nt Am e e rghtt duepr es whe M oul s r e a dia ove fye s
te h
ndm nt i o
oc s n
d c e ned nd s ppr d l r
S a g oup'i t d ofea h tyer a Tur r Bi ns a G.
t
as r ' nsea
c l , nd ne , ve , nd Robi on obsr c e
ns
tu td
a i sr tver medi by de ng gre
dm nitai e
es
nyi
ivanc sa
e boutM oul
d.
9Theie s iedasc r band i vi a i oft teame pl i udedapageoff t phot ofsngl wo or
tms ez
onta
n olton he r t nt an ncl
ory
os i e men
gr
oupsofwomeni s xualy-uggesi postonsore
n e ls
tve ii
ngagi i s xualacs apa depitngna d,ve ys l chidr n
ng n e
t; ge
ci ke r mal l e
a t nake br ssoff lsa youngasffee yea sol a e otc sor s eci f m bywhi Plitf wa
nd he
d ea t emae s
it n- r d; n r i t y el ton or
ch an if s
r quesi sore ba e ona s andanala g oups aphot r phy m a zi ;acompa sor f m sf r
e tng t is s d
nal ex
nd r
ex;
og a
ga ne
ny' der or o
maga ne depitngs alpener i a tte d r l Legal'$ Cup, t gBut 'fwveYoung GilPr e s
zi s ci exu
taton nd ild ç ey
Ba
,1
' D- ' ç
' Bi t 's i
l
r es nt
Lai , ec;a or rf m f nontnos' t n de or or
'
nudef m aecee iis'pit es pa fom a a omy bookpubls dby Natonal
e l lbrte cur ; ges r n nat
ihe
i
Ge a c;a a riementt tf t esmuli epitzesofayoung,cl hedgil apa fom Sshutebug'
ogr phi n dve ts
ha eaur
tpl clr
ot
r; ge r i tr 'maga ne
zi
t thast eepi t e ofc ot d c l e i dif r ntpos ;a g a c,de a l d dr ngsofl s a a g oup s
ha
hr
c ur s l he hidr n n f e e
es nd r phi t ie awi
e bi n nd r
ex.
1 ai s 1t ough 3wer fl i t nameofaco- antf, who ha sncebe n s ver fom t sa ton.Icontnue
0Cl m
hr
e ied n he
pli if
si
e e ed r hi c i
i
t us t cai nu be sPli ifa Defndan sus d i t i flng
o e he l m m r antf nd e t e n her ii s.
1 Pl ntf r atdl ar t tt a i bl rghtt d pr es i pr t td byboht Fi a Fo te h
1 ai if epe e y gues ha he pplca e i o ue oc s s oece
t he hh nd ure nt
Am e e s butt Fi Am e m en ' duepr es ca eapplesonl t t fde a govenm e .See e. , tsv.
ndm nt, he Ah
nd ts
oc s lus
i
y o he e r l
r nt
. a.Be t
Brd , 1 U. 4 5 4 2(9 2 .
a y 3 6 S. 5 , 6 1 4 )
Cli 6. W al Rowe et ,a Hi evi aed Pli ifsFis Am e
am
z,
l te nd nkl ol t
antf
rt
ndmen rg t r c ve
t i ht o e ei
publcai i prs a Foure t Ame e rghtt duepr es by dia ovi and
i tons n ion nd
ten h
ndm nt i o
oc s
s ppr ng
r f i t s r n c me calphot a on a t as by- a e' ss
e usng o c ee om r i
ogr phs
s e- c s 'ba i.
c
Cl m 7. You W a z Hi e,Gar n, . ns an Clr vi atd Pl ntf' Fis
ai
ng, l , nkl
ma A Robi on, d a ke ol e ai ifs r t
Am e e rg t r c vepublc tonsi prs a Foure nt Am e e trghtt due
ndm nt i ht o e ei
ia i n ion nd
te h
ndm n i o
pr es by ba ng a1 c me cilpho ogr phs i udi t ewih a tc e , nd G.
oc s
nni 1 om r a
t a , ncl ng hos t dul ont nt a
Robi on obs r c e ad i s r tve r m edi .
ns
t u t d m ni t a i e
es
Cl m 8. Tur ra m e r oft PRC vi ae Pl i ifsFis Ame m e rghtt r c i
ai
ne nd mbe s he
olt d antf
rt
nd nt i o e e ve
publc tonsi prs a Foure nt Am e
ia i n ion nd
te h
ndmentrghtt duepr e sby de ng Pli tf
i o
oc s
nyi
a n if
r ceptofpublc tonsba e on û ol pl ngy' G. bi on obsr t a nitai
e i
iai
s d ç e ayi 'and Ro ns
r
tuced dmi sr tve
rm e e .
e di s
Cl i 9. Ha l Boyd,a Da svi a e Pl n if sFis Ame m e rgh t r c i publc tonsi
am
l,
nd vi olt d aitf
rt
nd nt i t o e e ve
ia i n
prs and Foure nt Am e e rg t duepr es by e c i ate t tpln t t
ion
te h
ndm nt i ht o
oc s
na tng r a men a ha
pr bied hi fom pos es i varouspublcai ns Boyd c e t d t te t ntpln as
ohi t m r
s sng i
i to ,
r a e he r a me a
r t la i a Ttne ,Bi ns a Robi on obsr c e a i sr tve r medi .
e a iton, nd u r ve , nd
ns
tu t d dm nitai e
es
Cl i 1 Ha l Boyd,a Zi e r t laed a i tPli iff flng t slws tby c r ng hi
am 0. l,
nd eglr e ai t ga ns antf or ii hi a ui
ha gi m
wih pos es i ofco r ba Ba a W az s e
t
s son
nta nd. ndy nd l ubs quen l vi a e t Foure nt
ty olt d he
te h
Amendme rghtt duepr s by notc
nt i o
oce s
onduc i af rdicplna yhe rng a by
tng ai s i i r a i nd
afimi t i tt to c ci on a al r pe i y.
fr ng he nsiu i nal onvi ton
ppe , es ctvel
Cl i 11 Ha l Ca t i ,a Sut n r t laed a i tPl i iff flng t sl ws t Ca t i ht
am . l, rwrght nd phi e ai t ga ns antf or ii hi a ui. rwrg
vi a e t Foure nt Ame e rgh t d pr es whe hes i d Pli tf spr ry
olt d he
te h
ndm nt i t o ue oc s n
eze a n if ope t
and di notr tzn i,a Tur r Bi ns W az,a Hil eobsr t d a nita i
d
elr t nd ne , ve , l nd rkl
tuc e dmi sr tve
r me e .
e di s
Cli 1 Boyd c r ed Pli ifwih pos es i ofc r ba asr t la i f flng gre
am 2.
ha g
antf t
s son onta nd e a iton or ii
ivanc a
es nd
t sl ui,vi a e t Fis Ame m e rghtt r c vepublc tonsi prs a
hi aws t olt d he r t
nd nt i o e ei
ia i n ion, nd
vi aedt Fouree h Ame m e rghtt duepr es by s i ng Pli if spe s l
olt he
t nt
nd nt i o
oc s ezi
antf
r ona
pho os Ba a Young vi aed duepr s by notc
t . ndy nd
olt
oce s
onduc i af i dicplna y
tng ar s i i r
he rng a a fnni t i tt i lc c i r peci l a Tur ra Bi ns
a i nd fi ng he nsiutona onviton, es tvey, nd ne nd ve
o t c e a i sr tve r medis
bsnlt d dm nita i e
e.
Cl m 1 Boyd c r ed Pli tf wih pos es i ofc r ba a r t iton f tlng gre
ai 3.
ha g
a n if t
s son onta nd s e ala i or ii
ivanc a
es nd
t sl ui,a Ba y and Yo vi a e t Fo te h Am e
hi aws t nd nd
ung olt d he ure nt
ndme rg t duepr s
nt i ht o
oce s
by no c
t onduc i a f i di c plna y hea i a a tnni t i tt i
tng a r s i i r
rng nd fi ng he ns iutonalc c i
onvi ton,
r s c i y.
e pe tvel
4
Cl i 1 Hn mond,W al Young,Hil e Gar n, .
am 4. m
z,
rkl , ma A Robi on, nd Clr vi a e t f de al
ns a
a ke olt d he e r
rg t ac es c t by c e tng apolc t tca e i de t a es t t prs lw
i ht o c s ours r a i
iy ha us d na qua e cc s o he ion a
lbr r durng Pl i ifsc i
i ay i
antf ontneme i t SLU, c pr c ude Pl ntf fo r ii
nt n he
whi h e l d ai if r m a sng
a t rcl i i t s a ton.1
no he a m n hi c i 2
Cl i 1 Boyd r t it d agans Pl ntf by r c
am 5.
e ala e
i t ai if e omm e ngt tPli ifbehous d i t SLU.
ndi ha antf
e n he
W a z Rowlte,Young,Hi e,Ganna A .
l,
et
nkl
n, Robi on,a Clr vi a e t Fouree h
ns nd a ke olt d he
t nt
Am e
ndme rghtt duepr e sby notpr di ahe rngbe or bei hous d i t
nt i o
oc s
ovi ng
ai
f e ng
e n he
SLU , and Tur robsr ct a nita i r m e e .3
ne
tu ed dmi sr tve e di s1
Cl i 1 . Tu ne ,Bi ns a G.Robi on obsr t d a nita i r m e e .4
am 6
r r ve , nd
ns
tuc e dmi sr tve e dis 1
Cli 1 PRC m e
am 7.
mber vi a e t Fis Am e e rg t r evepublc tonswhiei prs n
s olt d he rt
ndm nt i ht o ec i
iai
l n io
a t Foure nt Am e e rghtt duepr e sby dia ovi Pl ntf sr ceptof
nd he
te h
ndm nt i o
oc s
s ppr ng ai if e i
t Oc o r ove be 201 is ofPlyboy Li re.1
he t bem
m r 2 s ue
a
nge i 5
Cli 1 Bo a Yo vi aedt Fis Ame e rghtt r c vepublc tonsi prs a
am 8. yd nd ung olt he r t
ndm nt i o e ei
ia i n ion nd
Foure nt Am e e trg t duepr sby c ic tng fom Pl i ift prs
te h
ndm n i ht o
oces
onfs a i r
antf he ionlbr r boo TheAritsCo pl eGui t Fac a Exnr s i a vi a i Pli ifs
i ay k
ts ' m et
de o i l
e sons s oltng antf
te t ntpln,a Boyd r t laed a ns Pli ifby c gi hi wih poses i of
r a me a nd
e a it gai t antf
har ng m t
s son
conta nd.
r ba
II.
Dee d n sa g i t i moi nf rs mmayj g n t a t ecamsfrd ma e a s re
f n a t r ue n her to o u r ud me t h t h li o a g s se td
agans t m i t ri vi c pa ii ar ba r by t doc rneofquaiid i muniy.6 A pa t
i t he n hei ndi dual a ctes e red he ti
lfe m
t l
ry
i e tt dt sl r j d me t f h p e dng ,h d so e ya dds l s r mae il o fl, n
s nil o t
e
mmay u g n i t e la i s t e ic v r n ico u e tras n ie a d
a yatd vt s o ta te ei n g n i eds u ea t a ymae ilfc.F d R. v. 5 ()
n fi a is h w h t h r s o e u n ip t s o n tra a t e . Ci P. 6 a.
M a e i lf t a et ene s a y t esa ih t e e t ofapa t sca eofa ton.Ande s v.
t ra ac s r hos ce s r o t bls he l men s
ry' us
ci
r on
Li t Lobby,l .477U. 242, ( 986 .A ge neis ofmae ilfc e ssi,i viwi
bery
nc,
S. 248 1 )
nui sue
tra a t xit f n e ng
1 Plitf c ncd si hir s net temoinfrs mmayj d me th th wa n t rn iga id pe d n
2 anif o e e n s epo s o h to o u r u g n ta e s o b ign n n e n e t
cli agans Young,Ga man,a A.Robi o f alege y vi ai t Fis Ame men rghtt r cevepublcai i
am i t
r
nd
ns n or l dl oltng he r t nd t i o e i
i tons n
prs by de ngPl ntf' r ceptoft Fe ua y/ ar 2011is ofPlybo Li re.
ion
nyi ai ifs e i
he br r M ch
sue
a y nge i
1 anifwi de arltdcam ta Plitf s fee d u l jo ad b ben ta serdt teS ECFn
3Plitf t rw eae li h t anif ufr d o be e p r y y ig rn fre o h LU.
h
o.
57.
1 Pl ntf a
4 ai if cknow l gest tcl m 1 i no ba edon a al d lc ofS e viea ecot s'alhought tis i
ed ha ai 6 s t s
n lege a k d r c bl l he ' t
s
ha sue s
dicus e i t Com pli .Pl' Re p.t M ot Sum m .J a pa i no.91
s s d n he
ant .s s o
.
. t ge d.
5.
1 Pl i ifwihdr ar ltd cl m t tA . Robi onandClr vi aedt Fis Ame
5 antf t ew eae ai ha
ns
a ke olt he rt
ndme by e ci apolc
nt na tng
iy
t tba r Pli iffom a lngale y dia ove pu i to vi t O fende Greva Pr e te ECF no.
ha red antf r ppeai r ad s ppr d blcains a he f r i nce oc dtr .
57.
1 Qualfe i
6
iid mmuniypennisgover ntofii spef mi dic ei r f nctonsi i vi c ciist be
t
t
nme fcal ror ng s r tonay u i n ndi dual apa te o
ïs ededfom la lt f cvi dama si ofrast i c
thil r ibiiy or i l
ge ns a her onduc doesno vi aece l esa ihed saut y or
t
t olt lary tbls tt or
c n tuin l iht o whc arao a ep ro wo dh v k o ' Halw v Ftg rl, 7U. 8 0, 1 (9 2 ;
o si to a rg s f ih e s n bl es n ul a e n wn. ro . iz ead 45 S. 0 8 8 1 8 )
t
'
seBr a tv Muh, 4F.d 1 8 ,1 8 (t Ci.1 9 )(eciigb re s i n ) Dee d nsaep oetdfo
e y n . t 99 2 0 2 0 6 4h r 9 3 d s rbn ud n hhig. fn a t r r tce rm
da gesi t rofii c pa tesbyt Elvent Amend e .Se eg.M t He t Ciy Sc Dit Bd.ofEduc.
ma n hei fcal a cii
he e h
m nt e. . , . alhy t h. s.
v.
Do l, 2 U. 2 4, 0 ( 9 7 .
y e 4 9 S. 7 28 1 7 )
t r cor a a1 r s na e i e e esdr wn t r fom i alg mos f a et t non- o ng
he e d nd l ea o bl nf r nc
a he e r n i ht t avor bl o he
m vi
pat, r a o a l fc-id rc u dr tr av r itf rteno mo a t J Th mo n p ryh st e
ry a e s n be a tfn e o l eu n e dc o h n- v n . Z e vig a t a h
bur n ofs
de
howi - tha i , n i o t t diti co t t tt r i a a e ofe de e t
ng d t s poitng ut o he srct ur - ha he e s n bs nce vi nc o
t
s
uppor t nonmovi pary' c e. CeotxCop . Cart,477U. 31 325( 6) l t
the
ng t s as ' l e
'
v. tet
S. 7, 198 . f he
mova s tsi st sbur n, he t nonnt a ite hi de t n he
mova mus s tf t s cii admisbl f c st t
nt t e orh pe fc,
s i e a t ha
de o taet e se eofa ge ne is off c f ti .1 1 .at322- . A pa t i e ild t
m nsr t he xitnc
nui s ue a t or ral 7 d
23
ry s ntte o
s mmayj d me t f h r c r a awh l c udno la arto a tiro fc t fndi fv ro t
u r u g n i t e e o d s oe o l t e d ain l re f a t o i n a o f he
nonmovan .W ila v. ifn,952F. 8 8 ( hCi.1 )
t lims Grfi
2d 20, 23 4t r 991 .
111.
De e nt a guet tPl i iff ie t e us a ia e a nita i r di sf rcli 5,
f nda s r
ha antf a ld o xha t val bl dmi sr tve eme e o a ms
7, 9 1 , 2, n 1 , srq ie b 4 U. C. 1 9 e a.8 Thee ha ton r quie e i m a t y
, 1 1 a d 7 a e ur d y 2 S. j 9 7 ()1
x usi e r m nt s nda or
a d û p le t a1 n t s isa o tp io lf ( ' Po trv. sl, 3 U. 51 , 2 5 2 (0 2 .
n ' p is o 1 i mae ut b u rs n ie. ' re Nu se 5 4 S. 6 5 4, 3 2 0 )
a
)
t ope e usi de
s
pr r xha ton mandsc
ompla wih a a nc sde i and ot rc ii alpr e al
ince t n ge y' adlnes
he rtc oc dur
r ls' W oodf r v.
ue .'
od Ngo,5 U. 81 90(
48 S. , 2006) W he aprs prvi ara nitai
. n ion o des l dmi srtve
gre ncepr dur ,t i a emus fl a g iva r ii apa tc a cli a ptr uei t ough
i va
oce e he nm t
t ie re nce a sng
riul r am nd ts t hr
a1a alb elveso a p a t û r p rye h us. I .Dio v. c , 91F.d48 4 0 91( t Ci.
l v ia l e l f p e l o ç o e l x a t' d; x n Pa e 2 3 5, 9 - 7h r
p
'
2002) 1( na nitai r dyi notc i r t ha be na ia ei aprs r t oug no
. $A1 dmi srtve eme s onsdeed o ve e valbl f ione ,hr h
f tofhi o wa pr ve e fom a lnghi e fofi. M oor v. nne t,51 F. 71 725
aul
s wn, s e ntd r
vaii
ms l t'
'
e Be te 7 3d 7,
( h Ci. ) çg l nprs ofi i sprve i tsfom usngt a nitai pr e s...
4t r 2008 . iW he ion tcal e nt nmae r
i he dmi srtve oc s ,
t pr s t e sso pa rbec e unaval bl i r alt ' Ka v.St pp,458 F.d 678 68
he oce s hat xit n pe
om s
ia e n e iy.' ba
e
3
, 4
( t Ci.
7h r 2006)
.
1A Panifc n o u ears ns t amoinfrs rmayj d me tt c re t ekince i ac mpan
7 litf a n t s epo e o to o un r u g n o o rc d t e is n o lit
c aln e b ad fn a tsmoinfrs mmayj g n.Cla i e v Mc vt 55 F.d3 4, 36(t Ci. 0 9 .
h le g d y ee d n ' to o u r ud me t o nna r . De it 5 3 2 3 4h r2 0 )
,
1 A defndan hast bur n t pr a i ae, f l et e us a lbl ad i sr tverm edis J
8
e t
he de o ove n nm t s aiur o xha t vaia e m nitai e
e . onesv.Boc
k,
5 U. 1 9, 6 ( 0 7 .
49 S. 9 2l 2 0 )
OP 866.,Sofe
1 t f nderGre nc Pr ed e,' ovi est a i sr tver m e esf i aes
iva e oc ur 'pr d he dm nitai e di or nm t
t r ol c pl i s a ala i sr tvede ii ,a c le epolcesa pr dur .9
o es ve om a nt , ppe dm nita i
c sons nd ha lng
i i nd oce es1
Be or s itng a g i va ,t i t m us makeagood-aih efo tt i or ly r s vet is
f e ubm ti
re nce he nma e
t
f t f r o nf ma l e ol he s ue
by s itng an l or Compli f m,whih i a ia e i housng unis l t is i not
ubm ti
nf mal
ant or
c s va lbl n
i
t . f he sue s
i onna l r s ved, hei t mus fl ar gul gre nc wihi t ry cae rda fo t dae
nf
ly e ol t nma e
t ie e ar iva e t n hit lnda ys r m he t
oft oc re eori i nt2 Regulrg i van sma r e vet eel l ofr vi w . A f ciiy'
he cu r nc
nc de .0
a re ce y ec i hr eve s e e
a lt s
W a de orSupe i e ntc
r n
rnt nde onduc st fr t ç ave 1' e e , nd i t i ei uns tsi d wih t
t he is, s e l 'r viw a f he nmat s a ife t he
t
Le lIde e m i ton, hei a ema a alwihi fveda ofr ceptt Le lI , c i us l
ve
t r na i t nm t y ppe
tn i
ys e i o ve l whi h s ualy
doneby ar gi na om buds a Formos i s s Le l1 i t fnallve ofr vi w,butf t f w
e o l
m n.
t s ue , ve 1 s he i e l e e
or he e
i s sa
s ue ppeaa et Le l11 t i aem a a a t t De y Die t orDie t oft VDOC
lbl o ve 1, he nm t y ppe l o he put r c or
r c or he
wihi fveda ofr c ptoft Le l1 r po e.21
t n i
ys e ei
he ve 1 es ns
A.Cli 5,9,a 1 aebardby j1
ams
nd 2 r re
997e()
a.
Forc am 5,Pli ifaleg t tsa funlw f ly s r e d fyer Ea agr ' nd o t c e
li
antf l es ha t f a u l c e ne l s ss oup'a bsnlt d
a miitai erme is Plitf fldar g lrgiv nc a o ttefir , u iwa rj ce a itk
d n srtv e d e . an if ie e ua re a e b u h le s b t t s ee td t na e
f dns fcinti or to ' Pe OP 8 1 saf r t ne t gre nc a ad s Pli ift the
or t ufi e nf ma i n. r
i
'
66., t f eur d he i va e nd vied antf ha
nee t wata fl a g i va a trt PRC dee nedwhe he t tye ss ul be
ded o i nd ie re nce fe he
tnni
t r he l r ho d
dia ove .2 N ot ng s
s ppr d 2
hi ugge t t tPli tf e use ad i sr tver m e e oncet PRC
s s ha a n if xha t d m nitai e di s
he
d cd dt p o i it efy r.Plitf sp e t r giv n e whihwa rj ce a itk ,sn ta
e i e o r h bt h l es an if rmau e re a c , c s ee td t na e i o
1 lis saegre bl e pta
9Al s ue r iva e xce boutpolcis pr dtr ,a de sonsoft Vigi aPa ol Boad;dici i r
i e , oce les nd cii
he r ni r e r s plnay
he rngpe li and/rpr edzale r s saeandf de a c tde sons lws a r ains a ot mater
a i nates o oc lr ror ; tt
e r l our cii , a , nd egulto ; nd her t s
be
yondt VD OC' contol
he
S r .
2 on1 oneis pe r a gre nc m a bead e s . Re a greva st do no m e tt flngr quie ent
0 y
s ue r egulr iva e y
dr s ed gulr i nce hat
t e he ii e rm s
ofOP 866. a er m r t t i aew ihi t wor ng da fom t dat ofr ceptwih i tuc i ,whe pos i e,
1 r e ned o he nm t t n wo ki
ys r he e e i t nsr tons
n sbl
a how t i t mayr med a defce a ac oft i a decso i kep i t i e' g ivanc fl
bout
he nmae
e y ny iincy, nd opy he ntke iin s t n he nmat s re e ie.
A n i aem a a
nm t y ppeala i a de s on by s ndi t greva a t i a d i i n t ar gi ombuds a wihi
n nt ke cii
e ng he i nce nd he nt ke ec s o o e onal
m n tn
tveda ofr cept butt r i no frt rr e oft i a deciin.
i
ys e i , he e s u he eviw
he ntke
so
2 A Le Ir pons mus be is d wihi t ry da ,andLeve 1 a Le llr s e mus beis d wihi
1
vel cs e t sue t n hit ys
l 1 nd vel l e pons s t s ue t n
t nt da .Expiai oft tmelmiwihoutis eofar po ea a sa oft pr s a omai ly e ils
we y ys
r ton he i i t t
suanc
es ns t ny tge he oce s ut tcal ntte
a i a et a lt t nextl l
n nm t o ppea o he
eve .
2 Pl ntf a aldt it decson t t Re ona Om b m a , whouphel t it de son.
2 ai if ppe e he nake ii o he gi l
uds n
d he nake cii
v l e h u to a dsafsrj cino tep e tr giv n eddn tma a mi itaierme is
ai x a sin, n tf ee to f h rmat e re a c i o ke d nsrtv e d e
d
l
unava lbl
ia e.
Forc am 9,Pli ifaleg t tsa funlw f l e t ateam e pln t tpr bie hi
li
antf l es ha t f a uly naced r t nt a ha ohi t d m
fom pos es i va i publc tonsa r t iton and obsr t a nita i r m e e . The
r
s sng rous
iai
s eala i
tuced dmi sr tve e di s
te t ntpln,whi h pr bied t pos e son ofa rs i ag wasena t d on De e be 1
r a me a
c ohi t he s s i
ny iqué m e,
ce
c m r 6,
2011, antf di notfl t r e ntgreva esuntlM a c 201 a t gre nc we epr ry
Pl i if d
ie he elva
i nc
i r h 2, nd he iva es r ope l
rj ctd a untmey fld.Not ngç
ee e s i l ie
hi ç
beyondPli ifsc r 'prve e Pli iffo tmey
antf' ontol' e ntd antf rm i l
g ivngt ec ndto sd s rb di tete t n p a , n terj cinso t eu tmeyg iv n e
re i h o i n e cie n h rame t ln a d h ee to f h ni l re a c s
i
di notm a admi sr tver m e est a ia e.
d
ke
nitai e di m va lbl
Forcli 1 Pl n ifal ge t tsa funl wf l i t r ptd publcai ,s i e Pl ntf s
am 2, aitf le s ha t f a uly n e ce e
i tons e z d ai if
f miy phot ,obsr c e admi sr tver m e es a c r a c ced Pl i ifofpos es i
n l
os tu t d
nitai e di , nd ha ged nd onvit
antf
s son
ofco r band a r t lai f flng g iva esa t slws t2 Pl i iffld a uns c s u
nta
s e ai ton or ii re nc nd hi a ui. 3 antf ie n uc es f l
r a g iva ea utt c ic t f miy phot ,a Pl ntf di nota a t de son t
egulr re nc bo he onfs a ed a l
os nd ai if d
ppe l he cii o
Le 1. Pli ifsa gum e sa enotpe s i t tsa fm a r m e e una ia ea t
vel I antf r
nt r
r uasve ha tf de e di s va lbl nd hat
s e
ubs quen gr e nce a
t i va s boutBoyd' a l ed r t i ton, hi h a s w e e no a al d, us hi
s leg e ala i w c l o r t ppe e exc e s
f iur t e us t i talgre nc
at e o xha t he nii iva e.
B. Cl ms7,11 a 1 a enotbardbyj 1
ai
, nd 7 r
re
997e()
a.
Forcli 7,Pl ntf al ge t tsa funl wf l bn d c
am
ai if le s ha t f a uly nne omm e cilpho ogr phs i udi
r a
t a , ncl ng
pho ogr phswih a tc en ,a obsnzt d admi sr tver m e es Pl i iffl a uns es f
t a
t dul ont t nd t c e
nitai e di . antf ied n ucc s ul
r gulrgre nc o Aprl5, 2, bo t ba on c
e a iva e n
i 201 a ut he n
omm e c a phot r phs a Pli ifa aed
ril
og a , nd a ntf ppe l
t Le l1de ii t Hi e whouphed t Le l1decson on M a 25, 2.On t Le l1
he ve
c son o nkl ,
l he ve
ii
y 201
he ve 1
r s ns f r Hi e i or e Pli ift thecoul a
e po e o m, nkl nf m d antf ha
d ppea t Le I1by M a 30,201 Pli tf
l o vel 1
y
2. a n if
2 Pl ntf ' co pl nt a
3 ai if s m ai s boutt di ci i r c c i a e notg i vabl vi OP 8 .1
he s plna y onviton r
re e a
66
8
dr td hi a alon J 1 201 an t a a wasalege y notr c ve a Le IIuntlJme
afe s ppe
une 4, 2, d he ppe l
l dl
e ei d t vel 1 i t
27,201 l afe t fve- y a
2, ong tr he i da ppea perod e r d.
l i xpie
Howe ,Pli ifa gue t tt Le l11appe wa tm ey fld bec us hem a ld i on
ver antf r s ha he ve I
al s i l ie
a e
ie t
J 1 201 whih, t bl w a t da afe he al ge yr c ve t Leve 1 r pons l
une 4, 2, c no a y, s he y tr le dl e ei d he
l 1 es e. n
s
uppor oft scai , hee de r veast t i r pons t Pl i ifsi r saf t d hi on J
t hi l m t vi nce e l ha , n es e o antf nquiy, t f ol m
une
6,201 t tHi e' Le 1 r pons ha be n c e t d on M a 28,201 butose i y i hadno
2, ha nkl s vel 1 es e d e r a e
y
2,
tnsbl t
t
y tarve a t ep io b J n 6 2 2 be a s saff rh re p an dt a it i jn tme nta i
e ri d t h rs n y u e , 01 , c u e tf u te x lie h tt d d o a h t t
dl
hasbe pr es e a maied. St f r as ur d Pli ift thet l havea a opra ea mtof
en oc s d nd l ' a f e s e antf ha
'
s l
wi
n ppr it mot
tmet tk wh tv rse . . e dld t tk . .' Co f sn l Tu n rs i i h rr s o s d td
i o a e ae e tps . n e e ) o a e . . n u igy, r e ad n e e p n e ae
'
J 13, 2, ha t a a f t sc am waspe ng a Le 1Ir vi w,de piebo h Pli ifs
une 201 t t he ppe l or hi l i
ndi t vel I e e
s t t antf
cli t the di notm alt appe lun i J 1 201 a Robi on' lte ca mi t Le lII
a m ha
d
i he
a tl une 4, 2, nd
ns s e tr li ng he ve I
a a wasr e ve on J 27 201 I ye a he doc nt Robi on satd t Pli ifs
ppe l
ec i d
une , 2. n t not r ume ,
ns t e hat a ntf'
uns cii d per r 'f t g i va ewa r ceved o J y 2 a 25,201 Duet t dipa iy
pe fed t
pa wo k' or he re nc s e i
n ul nd
2.
o he s rt
oft e de a dic e ncesi t VDOC' own r c ds De e nt pr s nty f lt e t bls
he vi nce nd s r pa i n he
S
e or , f nda s e e l ai o sa ih
t tPli ifdi no tme y tl t Le lI1a alwihi oneda ofr evi t Le 1
ha antf d t i l ie he ve I ppe
t n
y ec i ng he vel 1
r S n e2 Se OP 8 6 1jVlD)5 ( emit ga imaefved y fo t d t o rc it oa p a
ePO S .4 e
6.
( ( ) p r ti n n t i a s r m he ae f e ep t p e l
n
agre nc r s ns .
iva e epo e)
Forcli 11 Pl ntf al ge t tsa funl wf l s z d Pl i ifspr pery,obsr t d
am , ai if le s ha t f a uly eie antf
o t
tuc e
adm i s r tve r m e e , a r t laed when Pli iffld al ws t2 Pl i ifs it d ar ul r
nit a i e di s nd e ai t
antf ie a ui.5 antf ubm te eg a
g iv n ea o ttec l s ac bengr tl to , ihwa rj ce a itk a aS e u s f r
re a c b u h el e r h i eai in whc s ee td t n a e s ç q e t o
a
r
s r i es:2 1c nno fndt t am 1 i bar byj 1
e v c . ,6 n t i ha cli 1 s red
997ea bec us sa fc ede i t i ake
() a e tf onc d n he nt
2 o ue t t e c fz i r or ,D e enda s a e per itd t aga n addr st e usi ofa ia e r
4
o h on tsng ec d f nt r
m te o i
es he xha ton
va l bl emedi sf t s
e or hi
cam i temoinfrsmmayj d me t e u se i P r l
li n h to o u r u g n rq e td n at V.
2 f nt conce t tPl ntf
5Deenda s
de ha ai ifexhausedadmi sr tver disa hi pr ry bei s zeddurng ac l
t
nitai eme e bout s ope t ng ei
i
el
s r h.
ea c
2 A lhough De e t alget tPl ntf di no a lt it kedecson,paget e ofPli ifse bi #AL
6 t
f ndans le ha ai if d t ppea he n a
ii
hr e
antf xhi t
i c t st tPlitf di a landt tt ReginalOm buds a uphedt i a decso
ndia e ha anif d ppea
ha he
o
m n
l he ntke iin.
r s e t tt c
e pons ha he ompl i di notf l wihi t s
ant d
al t n he copeofOP 866. Furhe mor t Reg o l
1. t r e,he i na
Om buds n uphel t i a decson on a
ma
d he nt ke ii
ppea ,a t ,t g i va epr s wa nota lbl
l nd hus he re nc oce s s
vaia e
f t c
or he ompl i a
ant boutr t it y s a c a i i notc e rhow t co pl ntqualfe asaç e s f
eala or e r h s t s
la
he m ai
ii d
' que t or
r
s r i s'
e v ce .
'
Forc ai 1 Pl i ifa l gest tPRC m e be sunl f l di a oved Pl i if s r c i of
l m 7, a ntf le
ha
m r
aw uly s ppr
a ntf ' e e pt
t Oc obe m ove r201 is ofPl yboy Li re. Def nda sar t tt c am i
he t r
mbe
2 s ue
a
nge i
e nt gue ha he l i s
une use be us Pl ntf ne ra a e t PRC' dia o loft publc ton. Howe r t
xha t d ca e ai if ve ppe l d he
S s ppr va he
i ai
ve , he
r l va Notfc ton ofPRC Di a ova s cii lyt dPl i ift tt dee m i ton wa ç
e e nt ii ai
s ppr l pe fca l ol antf ha he tr na i
si
not
s be tt a pe lh o g t Ofe d rGre a c P o e u e' Th s OP 8 6. wa n ta a albe
u jc o p a tr u h he fn e iv n e r c d r . u , 6 1 s o n v ia l
'
r m e f t s c ai .
e dy or hi l m
I .
V
Cli s4,7,8,1 a 18c
am
7, nd
once n Pli ifsFis Am e e rg swhiei a ce a e
r antf
rt
ndm nt i ht
l nc r r t d.
Cl i 7 s il a l c
am pecfc ly once nsa a l d ba on PSCC i t 'r ceptofc
r n lege n
nma es e i
omm e c a phot a ,
r i l ogr phs
i l ng e otcphot .De e nt di nota es t m e isoft sc am i t rmoton f r
ncudi r i
os f nda s d
ddr s he rt
hi l i n hei
i o
s mmayj g n , n tus t e s alfl amo inf rsz r j d me tt ta d e sst emeis
u r ud me t a d h , h y h l ie to o l
mma y u g n ha d r se h rt
ofcli 7.Afe r e ngt ot rFis Am e e cli a De e
am
tr eviwi he he rt
ndm nt a ms nd f ndant'r s es 1c ude
s e pons , oncl
t a De e d n sa ee tte t q lfe i nt a ds mmayj d me t o cams4 8 1 , n 1 .
h t fn a t r n ild o uaiid mmu iy n u r u g n f r li , , 7 a d 8
l tsç lal r t npr eci afode byt Fis Ame nt.' O' v.Esaeof
nmae t e ry eai ot tons fr d he rt ndme ll' Lone
c
tt
S a z , 8 U. 3 2 3 ( 98 ) Ho v r imae ' rt n me trg t mus beb lnc d
h ba z 4 2 S. 4 , 48 1 7 . we e,n ts Fis Ame d n ih s t aa e
wihprs 'i tt i nalne ofs curt dici i a ge r la i sr ton.I a 349.Thus
t ions nsiuto
eds e iy, s plne, nd ne a dm nita i
d. t
,
çaprs r ulton t a i si aes co tt i lrgh si ç ld i i i r as bl r lt d t
$ ion eg a i hat brdge nm t ' nsiutona i t s vai f t s e ona y ea e o
lgii t penol c li e et.' Lovelcev.Lee 472F. 1 1 ( hCi. )( tngTume v.
e tmae
ogia ntr ss''
a
,
3d 74, 99 4t r2006 cii
r
S te , 8 U. 7 , 4( 9 7 W h t e ar g lto i ra o a l rltdd p n o
al y 4 2 S. 8 8 1 8 :. eh r e uain s e s n by eae e e ds n;
( )( l t rt r i aç ld,rto lc ci 'bewe n t prs rgulto or
1 W hehe hee s ç i aina onne ton' t e he ion e ain
va
acton and t i er t as ed by t govem m ent or whe her t s i er t i fs
i
he nt es sert
he
,
t
hi nt es s to
10
rmoea t rnde t polc abirr orirtonal'( wheher( tr tvemea
e t s o e r he iy r ta y rai '; 2) t i enai
al
ns
of e r ii t rght .. r mai ope t prs i aes' a i uiy t t as
xe c sng he i
. e n
n o ion nm t ,' n nq r ha ks
br y whe he i t swe ede i d ofa lf r sofr lgi e r ie orwheher
oadl
t r nma e r prve
1 om
ei ous xe c s
t
t ywee a l t p rii t i o h ro sr a c so t erfih' 3 wh ti a tte
he r be o a t pae n t e b e v n e f h i at , ) a mp c h
c
(
desr a co moda i woul ha on s cziy sa f i aes a t al a i of
ied c m
ton
d ve
e lrt t f , nm t , nd he loc ton
prs r oures a ()whehe t r exita l ous e y atr tves't t
ion es c ; nd 4
t r hee s ny d
obvi , as lenai ' o he
c le d r ul ton or a ton,whi h m a s
ha l nge eg a i
ci
c
y ugge tt ti i ç t r as bl ,bu i
s ha t s s e ona e t s
no
gnse a e gert rs et prs c r .
i tadq n xag aed e pons o ion oncens
1 at200( tngTur r 48 U. a 89- .Theprs rhast bur nt dipr t vai t ofa
d.
cii
ne, 2 S. t 92)
ione
he de o s ove he ldiy
p io r g lto p ru n t t Tu n ra ayss Ov ro v. z et, 3 U. 1 6 1 2( 0 3 .
rs n e uain u s a t o he r e n l i. e tn Ba z ta 5 9 S. 2 , 3 2 0 )
Pr s a i s r t r a e e il d t def r nce i t i m a ge e ofpe lf ciii . Lovel c 472
i on dm nit a o s r ntte o e e
n he r na m nt
na a ltes
a e,
F.d a 1 Fore
3 t 99.
xnmpl c t s d notSs ond- s aprs a nitaorsc cea o
e, ours houl
tec gue s ion dmi sr t ' hoi m ng
aler tvepolc e unls a ale a i e sst twoul m e ni u l e nc a i ae' a lt t
t na i
ii s e s n t m tve xit ha
d a ngf ly nha e n nm t s biiy o
execiehi c tt i lrght.'Ha ev. ug ,993F. 1 1 (t Ci.1 .
r s s onsiutona i s' us Va ht
2d 079, 083 4h r 993)
V DO C polc pe m ism e t lhe lh s af t pr bi a i a e spos es i ofa ie
i y r t n a a t t f o ohi t n nm t '
s s on
n tm
ûde e ne t be derme a t ofe rr ha lt tvee f t'ba ed ont i t sç pe ii
s t nni d o
ti nt l o f nde e biiai fors' s
he nma e' ç c fc
s
c i n g n cf co s' OP 8 32jI O)1-3 .Th imaema a p a ac n ic to b s do s c
rmio e i a t r.
'
0 . V( ( )( ) e n t y p e l o fs ain a e n u h
ade e mi ton t t PRC. ThePRC i r ponsbl f r vi wi pu i tonss itd fom VDOC
t r nai o he
s es i e or e e ng blca i ubm te r
f ciii t deer ne i t publc tonsa ea o it f i aes pos e son. ThePRC r vi ws
a ltes o t mi f he
iai
r ppr pra e or nm t ' s s i
e e
publc tonst e ur t y a ei c pla ewih OP 8 2,snc ng Publc tons'by r vi wi
ia i o ns e he r n om i nc t
03. Sl omi
ia i ,' e e ng
ie sbas d on t c ie i s tf rh i OP 803. s ii al whehercont tpr
tm
e
he rtra e o t n
2, pectc ly
t
en omot sga
e nga fla i t ror vi e e,ofdior r whe he con e vi a essa eorf der ll whehe co e
fiiton, e r , ol nc
s de ' t r t nt olt tt
,
e a aw; t r nt nt
c anss xualy e i tacs i udi s xuala t i vi ai ofsae orf de allw ;o whe he
ont i e l xplci t, ncl ng e
c s n ol ton t t
e r a r t r
c n e t h e tn t es ft a s c rt o tei si to Noa y twl e ap rino ap b iain
o tn t rae s h a ey nd e u iy f h n tt in. tbl,s h n o t f u lc to
u
g
o
i di a oved, he en ie publc ton w ilbe di a ove
s s ppr
t
tr
i ai
l
s ppr d.The e w ilbe no a t m ptt r m o o
r l
te
o e ve r
c ns t dia ovedmaeil' OP 803. jI G)9) Publc tonsdia ove byt PRC ae
e or he s ppr
tra.
'
2 V( ( . iai
s ppr d he
r
c
ompie i o aDia ove Publc tonsLit whi sa fca c ul t de a i t sr c ptofa
l d nt
s ppr d
ia i
s, ch t f n ons t o ny n nma e' e ei
di a oved publca i n wihoutr pe t dl ha ng t s nd t ie t t PRC .
s ppr
i to
t
e a e y vi o e he t m o he
11
Pl i iff ist esabls t tt dia oval oft TheGilwih t Dr gon Ta t
antf a l o t ih ha he s ppr s he
r t he a
too,
TheAritsCo plt Gui t Fa i lExpr s i ,TheFlntSa t Oct r ovembe 201 is
ts' m e e de o c a
e sons
i
ga,he obe m
r 2 s ue
ofi ayboy Li re,' nd Pa hfnde :Ki M ake -Bl f Bl vi atd t Fis Am e
l
pl
nge i 'a
t i r nc
r ood or ood ol e he rt
ndment
.
The Gilwih t Dr gon Tatoo' des rpto ofcrm i ls xua vi e e bewe n awoma a he
r t he a
t s ci in
i na e l olnc t e
n nd r
pr ton of i e s tsi t PR C' r s bl c e nsa
oba i
f c r a i tes he
S ea ona e onc r boutpr ve i m a e i l des r bi il l
e ntng t r a s c i ng lega
s xualbe vi a pr otngvi e ea d s r .
e
ha or nd om i
olnc nd i o der
Boyd, heSe o Ps hol s a PSCC, s ppr ve Pli ifspos es i ofTheArits
t
ni r yc ogit t
dia o d antf
s son
ts '
Com pl t G ui t Fa i Expr s i ns a a vi a i ofhi t e t e pl n. By is l , ac als c s of
e e de o c al
e s o s ol ton
s r a m nt a
t e f f i ket he
young gil s m i uous Howeve ,lbe k fom t r or i t sc e a viw t bo i t
rs ee nnoc
.
r
net r he ec d n hi as nd e he ok n he
con e ofPli if sc i e a be ori prs I wa r a ona ef Boyd t dialow pos es i
t xt
antf rm s nd havi n ion. t s e s bl or
o s l
s son
ofa book t tma pr m ot de a be or by tac ngPl i ifho t dr w yot gil,smia t
ha y o e vint havi s e hi
antf w o a
mg rs i lr o
Pl i if sha dr w n s t he ofyou f m al s e
a ntf
nd- a
ke c s
ng e e ngagi i gr p s x.2 Si lry, hede al of
ng n ou e 7 mia l t
ni s
TheFlntSa i Aprl201 a t Oc o r ove be 201 is ofç a
i
ga n i
2 nd he t bem
m r 2 s ue s yboyLi re' nAprl
pl
nge i'i
i
201 wer r as bl r r e sofwhehe t iemswe e on t PRC' Dia ove Publc ton
3 e e ona e, ega dl s
t r he t
r
he
S s ppr d
iai
Lit i lg oft i hi y-e lco e , her lvantpr bii de crbed i Pli tf ste t nt
s, n i ht he r ghl s xua nt nt t ee
ohi ton s i n a n if r a me
pl , a Pl i if sobs i t r f alt c onn t t t e t e pl n.8
an nd a ntf
tna e e us o onf
o he r a m nt a 2
Pahfnde : ngM a r-Bl f Bl an a lge r e pl ng book t woul c an
t i r Ki
ke
ood or ood, le d ol- ayi
hat
d ont i
nume o ac onym sa combi to ofl te a numbe s wasa d t t PRC' Dia oved
r us r
nd
nai ns e tr nd
r,
dde o he
S s ppr
P bl ainsLitf rb i ( tra wrte o c mmu c tdi c d o wrte i afr in( o u i to s o eng t eil itn r o niae n o e r i n n o eg n n
c
ma
t
Engls lng ot rt n Engls orSpa s ' Coli , fr rPRC c nna avest tt
ih) a uage he ha
ih
nih. lns a o me
'
hai n, r ha he
r g lto p o btn mae il itni c d o i af rin ln ua ei n c sa yb c u ette
e u ain r hiiig tra m te n o e r n o eg a g g s e e s r e a s 'h l
l
2 J tast ublnga derment t hi te men woul bePli ifr lvi hi c i by c a ng hi el e gi
7 us w i nd ti al o s r at t
d
antf e-i ng s rmes l wi ms f nga ng
r
i s xua ac sw ih hi vi tm s
n e l t t s ci .
2Th PRCdtr n dta tePly yisecnan da lato deito o oa sxa ta vj jj s g
8 e
eemie hth abo su o tie tes ne jcin r rle nd ht w rj a a
ju
c ai mae ilt emphaszese li orgr phi de ci ordes rpto ofs xuala s i u ng,butnotlmied
ont ned tra hat
i xplct
a c pitons
ci lns e
ct,ncldi
i t
t bonda s ditc,ma oc si,orot rvi e acsi t cont ofs xualaci t i vi ai ofOP 8 2.Pli if
o,
ge, a si s hitc
he olnt t n he ext e
tviy, n olton
03. antf
tldac p o j s o epitr fom t Ply o ma a ie whc s o an k dwo nwihe po e b e ssa d
se o y fu t n cu e r he a b y g zn , ih h ws a e ma t x sd rat n
ge t la.
nia i
1
2
VDOC doe notha t r s c st ta lt e h publc ton t c ansa f r gn l
s
ve he e our e o r nsa e ac
ia i hat ont i
o ei angua t
ge hat
c e i o af c lt whih co d be
om s nt a iiy c ul come as urt is i t i onnai n c nnotbe ve ii d a
ec iy s ue f he nf
to n
rfe s
a oprae f rt f iiy. Ther gulton i r tonaly r aed t t prs si er s t efi i l
ppr i t o he aclt '
'
e a i s a i l elt o he ion' nt e t o tcenty
alocae s r er s ur e a pr ve unknown,pos i y dinz i m ae il fom dis m i tng i o
l t ca c e o c s nd e nt
sbl s ptve tra s r
s e na i nt
t imaepo lto Se . . , pa l v. lmi g 4 4F. p' 1 0 1 0( t Ci. 01 )
he n t puain. e ec.De oa F e n , 7 Ap x 2 , 2 4h r 2 2
( fi ui dsrc c u ti dngt a t i rg lto a disrto aed n tvo aet eFis
afn ng itit o r fn i h t h s e u ai n n t ain l o o ilt h rt
Amendme ) VDOC ofi asha algii t i ees i mai ai ngs eya or rwihi t
nt.
fcil ve e tmae ntr t n nt ni aft nd de t n he
i tt i Se Hodg v. r ni 8 F. pp.873,876( . Va 1 (i ngt ts urt
nsiuton. e
es Vigi a, 71 Su
W D. . 994) fndi ha ec iy,
d s iln , r e , u i s ft a rh b l ainitrssn e n d fn e ,e do oh rc o n s
icp ie o d r p bl a ey, nd e a ii to ne et e d o ee s ) rv' n t e r u d ,
c
t
M ont l PublCop . Be 80F.d 1 ( hCi.1 .Prs ofi asdonotne dt watf a
cam
.
v. ck, 3 05 4t r 996) ion fcil
e o i or
pari a dir pton t oc urbef et c n t ker s bl me ur t a t i. l t a
tculr s u i o c
or hey a a ea ona e as es o ba e t nse d,
S es i eprs ofi i smus be pe ted t t r as bl se t f e tl s h at ea ,a
ç ponsbl ion fcal
r
t
nnit o ake e ona e tps o or sa l uc hr t nd
t y mus be pe m it d t ac be o et tm ewhe t y c n compiea dos iro t e ofarot'
he
t
r te o t f r he i
n he a
l
se n he ve
i .
'
J n sv. C. io es La o Uno 43 U. 1 9 1 2 3 ( 9 7 .Ev nwi o t c e st t s
o e N. Prs n r ' b r in, 3 S. 1 , 3 - 3 1 7 ) e t u a c s o hi
h
pa tc a r e pl yi boo Pli ifr t i at r i me ofobt i ng a ce st i or ton a
ri ulr ol- a ng k, antf e ans le natve ans
ani c s o nf ma i nd
i ast ough many o he publc i t tt VDOC woul a l hi t r c i Pl n ifdoesnot
de hr
t r
iatons ha he
d low m o e e ve. aitf
expl i a tobvi ,e y ale nai s' t , e titng Pl ntf pos e son ofPa hfnde :Ki
an ny d ous as tr tve'and hus r src i
ai ips s s i
t i r ng
M ake -Bl f Bl doesnotvi a et Fis Am e
r ood or ood
olt he rt
ndmen be us ç e po i e e re d
t ca e l s nsbl, xpe ince
r
a mi srtr h v d tr n d,nt ers u ddic ei n t a s c ( traswrte i c d ) l
d nitao s a e eemie i h i o n sr to ,h t u h maeil itn n o e wil
j o a dz t esc i oftefclt ' Blc v. t ef r , 6 U. 5 6 5 6( 9 4 .
e p r ie h e urt h a ii ' o k Ru h ro d 4 8 S. 7 , 8 1 8 )
y
y.
Alhough t r mai ng ca msa lgevi a i off de a l w, antf f ist et ri ntf
t
he e ni li le
oltons e r l a Pl i if a l o ihe de iy
apr ecedi ers ors fcintysaeacli a tonabl vi 42U. C.j 1 Ac r ngl
ot t nt e t ufi e l tt am ci e a
S.
983. co di y,
De e d n saee tte t q ai e i ni a s mmayj g n fra1rmann cams e c p
fn a t r n ild o u lt d mmu t nd u r ud me t o 1 e iig li , x e t
i
y
f t r t lai n cl ms f t f l ng r s .
or he e aito ai , or he olowi ea ons
Pli ifr pe t dl ct sDe enda s f iur t c
antf e a e y ie f nt ' a l es o ompl wih sae lws pr e es or
y t t t a , oc dur ,
c t s buts h a a us ton f ist sa ea a tona e c am .A cai t tprs n ofii sha
usom ,
uc n cc a i a l o tt n ci bl l i
l m ha io fcal ve
notf l d t i own i pe ntpolcesorpr dtr sdoe notsa ea c tt i na cli . See
olowe her
nde nde
ii
oce ze
s
tt onsiuto l am
UntdS ae v Ca e e , 4 U. 7 , 5 5 ( 9 8 ; c i v. t ofF ifx 9 7F.d 1 5 ,
ie tts . c rs 4 0 S. 41 7 2- 5 1 7 ) Rico Cny. ara , 0 2 4 9
1 6 ( t Ci. 9 0 ( o dn ta i saelw g a t mo ep o e u a rg t t a t Co si to
4 9 4 h r 1 9 ) h l ig h t f tt a r n s r r c d r l ih s h n he n tt in
u
r uies asae' f llet a debyt tlw i notafde a duepr es is )
eq r , tt s aitr o bi
ha a s
e rl
oc s sue.
Pl i ifsc le
antf ha lnged i tt i ldici i r c ci r ule i t l sofr c eai n a
nsiutona s plna y onvi tons es t d n he os
e r to nd
tl
eephoneprviege . Be us t l soft eprvie do noti ia eapr pe t orlbe t
i l s ca e he os
hes i lges
mplc t
o ry i ry
i e e t t Four e nt Am e
nt r s , he
te h
ndm e pr e tons de c i i W ol fv.M c onnel, 8 U . 539,557nt ot c i
s rbed n
f
D
l 41 S.
5 ( 9 4 , r n ti lc tda ter lva t n ttto a h ai g .Tot ee e tPlitf f retd
8 1 7 ) we e o mp iae t h ee n i si in l e rn s
u
h xtn an if o fie
conta nd,t r co d r ve st tPli ifwa a f de a nce wrten notc oft cai d
r ba he e r e al ha antf s for d dva d it
i e he l me
vi ai ns dic os eofa r ee de ;t opport t t calwine s sa pr s ntr lva
olto ' s l ur
,
dve s vi nce he
tmiy o l t s e nd e e ee nt
e de e e e whe de enda Bandy,t i ri he rng ofk e ,f und good c us t e l
vi nc xc pt n f nt
he mpa tal a i
t r o
a e o xcude
ir e nte de e;a am it n sa e ntoft f c sa e de er i upo a t r s nsf
relva vi nc nd
te t t me
he a t nd vi nc eled n nd he ea o or
t dicplna y aci t ke .2 Pli ifsuns
he s i i r ton a n 9 a ntf
uppored c l i n t tBa wa no i pa ta i not
t oncuso ha ndy s t m ri l s
e ildt a a s to oft t Se ec.BelAt.Co . Twombl 55 U. 544,555( )
ntte o n sumpin nzh. es . , l l m v.
y, 0 S.
2007
(e og zi apli ifsba i f rle rquie mor t nl l a concuso ) Eveni iwe e
rc ni ng antf ss or eif e r s e ha abes nd
l ins.
ft r,
ter c r i cu n Plitf so sae n s r v ast a mo eta j s S o e ie c '
h e o d,n ldig anif wn ttme t,e e l h t r h n u t t me v d n e'
s
e t ihe Pl i ifpos es e conta
sabls d antf
s sd
r band a vi a e t t r soft team e pl n. Se se. s
nd olt d he e m
he r t nt a
e g.
2 Event oughno r r d byW olf t VD OC a to ly alowsaprs nera a i sr tvea lf ea h
9
h
t equie
f, he
ddiinal l
io
n dm nitai ppea or c
co c i whi Pl ntf as a l hi el.1not t tPl ntf doe no ale t thedi notr ceveawrten
nviton, ch ai if lo vaied ms f
e ha ai if s t lge ha
d
e i
it
s
ummay oftndi f t Oct r9,201 dicplnar he i orwasde edt asitnceofa adviorort a lt
r i ngs or he obe
2, s i i y arng
ni he ssa
n
s
he biiy
t c lawi e s Am. mpl! l 2 1 , 8 Ex T, .1 5
o al t s. Co . ! 1 - 6 1 0, . p , .
n
1
4
Supe i e nt M a s Cor . ns . H il472U. 445,
rnt nde . s . r l t v. l,
S. 455- ( 985 .Furhemor dici i r
56 1 ) t r e, s plnay
-
pr ee ngst tuli ael t r naed i Pli if sf vorca
oc di ha tm t y e mi t n antf a
nnotco tt eaduepr s vi a i
nsiut
oce s olton.
TheUnie St t Consiuton doe note
td aes
tt i
s
nume a ea f me a prva y rght a t
r t undn nt l i c i , nd he
Supr m e Cou ha ne rpr a m e a S ne a cons iutona rghtt prva ' W hal n v.
e
rt s ve ocl i d ç r l
ge
tt i l i o i cy.'
e Roe,
429
U. 5 9 6 7 0 ( 9 7 ( twa qJ, o c ri ) we e, h Su r meCo r h sh l t a a
S. 8 , 0 - 8 1 7 ) Se r .c n u rng .Ho v r t e p e
u t a ed h t n
i a edoesnotha a e c a i ofprvac i hi prs celbe a eprs a nita o sne t
nm t
ve n xpe t ton
i y n s ion l c us ion dmi sr t r ed o
e s r s c rt wih nt ep io Hu s nv Pame, 6 U. 5 7, 2528(98 ) Ac odngy
n u e e u iy ti h rs n. d o . l r 4 8 S. 1 5 - 1 4 . c r i l,
Pli ifsc ant a prs saf r ae y s rhi hi c l warntnorle vi j1983.
antf ompli s bout ion t f epe tdl eac ng s el ra
eif a
Ale tonst tVigi aprs ofi il i t ntona l orneglge l de i d a i t of
lga i ha r ni ion fca s n e i ly
i nty prve n nma e
pr pe t whiea tng outi t s opeofofi alpolc orc t do no sa ea co tt i l
o ry l c i
sde he c
tci
i y usom
t t t ny nsiutona
cl m bec us t Vigi aTo tCli Ac, r i aCod j8. - 95. i ame ni f posai
a e he r ni r ams tVigni e 01 1 3,s a ng ul t
deprvai rme Huds v.Pame,468U. 51 533(98 ;Pa rt v.Ta or 451U. 527
i ton e dy.
on
l r
S. 7, 1 4) rat yl ,
S.
( 9 )( v m z dt ir lv n p r ) Da il v. ila , 7 U. 3 7, 3 - ( 98 $.Alo,
1 81 o e l q ree a t a t. nes W l ms 4 4 S. 2 3 0 31 1 6
e
.
y
i
s a
pos- prva i n,d pr es he i wa no ne s a y a trPli tf tans e r d t f miy phot t
tde i to ue oc s arng s t ce s r fe a n if r f re he a l
os o
s m e o sdet VDOC be us t sa edi notc ic t t pr ry.
o one ut i he
ca e he t t d
onfs a e he ope t
Alho h Pl i ifc
t ug antf ompli aboutt c tonsofc i
a ns
he ondii
onfneme i t SLU,
nt n he
none oft
he
c tonshe e re ed i a aypi la sg fc ha ds p i r l to t t or na y i de sof
ondii
xpe i nc s n t ca nd i niiant r hi n e ai n o he di r nci nt
prs lf orgi rs t t pr e ton oft Foure nt Am e
ion ie
ve ie o he ot c i
he
te h
ndmen ' Due Pr s Cl us by isown
ts
oce s a e t
f re S e eg, v rt v. mi 1 0F.d5 0 5 2( t Ci.1 9 ) Plitf d e n t a ea
o c . e . ..Be eai S t 2 3 0 , 0 4h r 9 7 . an if o s o h v
h,
c tt i lrghtt bepl c d i as c fcs urt cl sfcai a c t a cas ik ai nsdo not
onsiutona i o
a e n pe ii ec iy as ii ton, nd usodil l st to
ce t amao d su to i ap io rse vr n n .S n i v. n e, 5U. 47 48 - 7( 9 )
r ae j r ir pi n n rs ne ' n io me t a d n Co n r 51 S. 2, 6 8 1 95 .
Plitf as d e n t a af d rlrg t op io p iie e l ap io j b c mmis r ,
anif lo o s o h ve e ea ih t rs n rv lg s i
ke rs n o , o s ay
r
ecreaton,vi iaton,orgeneralpr s pr am m i Seese. ,M adi v.Par ,104 F.3d 765,768
i
st i
i on ogr
ng.
g.
son
ker
( h Ci.1 ,Bulerv.UniedStt Bur uofPrs ,65F. 48,50& n. (t Ci.995)
5t r 997) g
.
t aes ea
ions
3d
3 5h r1 ,
.
15
Stiklrv.W aes 989F. 1 1 1n. (t Ci.1 3) Mp t v. le,438F.Supp.11 11
rc e
tr,
2d 375, 38 7 4h r 99 9 hie Kelr
0, 5
( M d 1 7 ) afd, 8 F.d91 ( t Ci.1 7 )( e c ra .
D. . 9 7 , f 5 8 2 3 4h r 9 8 p r u im)
Pl ntf doe notha aco tt i lrghtt a c sa g i va s t m .Adn sv. c 40
ai if s
ve
nsiutona i o c es re nce yse
m
Rie,
F.d7 , 4( t Ci.1 9 ) Alo ta s p ro ' a trt efc d nil fag iva c ( r ep ns t a
3 2 7 4h r 9 4 . s ,ç ) u e irs fe -h -a t e a o re n e o r s o e o
l
ltejf l frs o t fe tb ihn j1 8 la ii ' De a l v. y No. :2 v 01 9, 01 U.
etr al a h r o sa ls ig 9 3 iblt ' p oa Ra , 7 1 c 0 3 2 3 S.
s
y.
Dit LEXI 11 8 a * 201 W L 4451 a *8( . Va.J y22,201 ( r ntM ...
s.
S 71 2, t 23, 3
236, t W D. ul
3) Sage , J)
Furher e,s vior la lt unde j 1 ma notbeprdiae ont t r ofr s
t mor uper s y ibiiy
r 983 y
e c td he heo y epondea
t
s ror Se M onelv. p' ofSoc.Se vs,436U. 658,663n. ( 978) Fihe v. ahi t
upe i . e
l De t
r .
S.
7 1 ; s r W s ncon
M er Ar Tr iAut .690F. 11 11 43( h Ci.1 .Cons que l Pli ifs
to. ea anst hor,
2d 33, 42- 4t r 982)
e nty, antf
num e ousc am sa uthow De e
r
l i bo
f ndan sr s nde t hi g i va sa a a sa t tDe e nt
t e po d o s re nce nd ppe l nd ha f nda s
fusrt hi a e st OP 866. d notsaeacli a tona evi j 1
r taed s cc s o
1o
tt am ci bl a 983.
Alhough Pl n ifcompl i a
t
aitf
ans boutde e son,abi a condii a s itc- r pan,
pr s i
polr
ton, nd ca i ne ve i he
ac
knowl st te c oft e ma a esi bei a es e vi c ula i wih media pe s nne
edge ha a h hes l di s ng ddr s d a ons t tons t
c l ro l
o d u s Th fc t a t s c n iinsfu taeh sa l y$oply s o t o d mao a tvte 'd s
r r g . e a t h the e o d t r srt i bit % a p rs r o j r ciiis' oe
o
i
no sa ea Ei h Am e
t tt n ght
ndmentcli f c u a t ua punihme a i tDef nda s
a m or r el nd mus l
s nt ga ns
e nt .
I c am 1 Pli ifaleg hi rghtt a ce st c t wasvi aedbe aus apolcy
n l i 4, antf l es s i o c s he ours
olt
c e
i
pr ve e Pl ntf fom physc l r ti vi 1 w lbr r m a e i swhiehous d i t SLU .3
e nt d ai if r
ialy ere ng a i a y t ral
l
e n he
0
l t sha ac tt i lrg t r s bl a e st c t t c le t i c c i or
nma e ve onsiutona iht o ea ona e cc s o ours o ha lnge her onvitons
vi c t t rc tt i lrght.Boundsv.Smih, 0U. 81 838( 977) Howe r i tsdo
ndiae hei onsiutona i s
t 43 S. 7,
1 .
ve ,nmae
notha a f ee t ndi rghtt a 1 w lbr r or l galas it nce Le i v. ey,51 U . 343,351
ve r s a ng i o a i a y e
s s a . w s Cas
8 S.
( 9 6 .I se d prs no fcasmus p o d aG a blt o b i i gc n e ltd g n rvoo s
1 9 ) n ta , io fiil t r vie é pa ii f rngn o tmp ae no fi lu l
c
y
c lnge t s ntnc sorc tonsofco i me befr t c t.'J a 356.TheSuprme
hale s o e e e
ondii
nfne nt oe he ours' . t
z
e
3 I t d ofphysc l a es i t prs lw lbrr , Pl ntf r que t s ver mae i sa atmebywrtng l l
0 nsea
ialy cc sng he ion a i a y ai if e sed e al tral t i
ii ega
ctto on af m t ther mr t aunimana r Thef m wa f wa dedt i t lw-i ay ce kswho rtive
iains
or ha
e ned o
t
ge .
or
s or r o nmae a lbr r lr
ere d
t ie s i pos i e,a ha t matral dei r t t SLU .
he tm , f sbl nd d he e i s lveed o he
16
Cour i Le sdl f)it prs ofi ast dee mi how bes t e ur t ti ts... vea
tn wi telt t o ion tcil o tr ne
t o ns e ha nmae ha
r as bl a
e ona y dequa eopporuniy t fl nonfi ousl lcli sc le ngt i c c i or
t
t t o ie
rvol ega am ha lngi her onvitons
c ndto so c ni e n ll a dn tdta tti ta c pa ii rt e t ntec p bit o tr i
o i n f o fn me t,' n o e h t t s h t a blt ah r ha h a a l y f u nng
i
'
i
y,
i
page i al w lbr r t ti t t hso 'ofaconsiutonalrghtt a ce sc urs
s n a i a y, ha s he ouc t ne'
tt i
i o c s o t.
Pl i ifa
antf cknowl dges a t r or c im s t tPl i ifa e s d nume o prs l
e , nd he ec d onfr , ha antf cc s e
r us ion awlbr r r our e fom i t 1 clr vi t ciai n m ehod a a s co ule wih a lce ed
i a y es c s r nma e aw e ks a he t to
t
nd lo ns t d t i ns
at ne whoasit imae ,purua t Vigni Codej53.- Eve i a tont t a lt t
tor y
sss n ts s nt o r i a
140. n n ddii o he biiy o
r eyac es lw lbrr r o c s Shes r ceoft atr yl a ntdbyt Stt t asit
emotl c s a i ay es ur e ,k evi
t
he to ne ) ppoi e
he ae o ss
p io r c mp idwihter q ie n so Bo n . Al ndv Da s 6 9F.d 1 6, 0 0( t
rs nes o le t h e urme t f u ds' mo . vi, 3 2 08 1 9 4h
'
Ci. 98 ) Co s q e ty Plitf fist etb ihta ad f n a td ne hi r ao a l a c s t
r 1 1 . n e u n l, anif al o sa ls h t e e d n e id m e s n be c e s o
cours.
t
Furhe
t nnor t rgh ofr as na e a c st c t S sa ilr t t unde l ng cli ,
e, he i t e o bl c es o ours t ncla y o he
i
ryi am
wih u wh c apan ifc l th v s fee ij r b b i s u o to c u t,'a daplitf mus
t o t ih litf amo a e u f rd n u y y eng h t u f o rlq' n
an if t
s ii a l i iy anon-rvol uslgalcai t ta de e
pecfc ly dentf
fi o e
l m ha
f ndantsa tonspr ve e hi fo
' ci
e nt d m r m
ltgai Chrsophe v. r uy,536U. 403, 5- 6(
ii tng. it r Habt'
S. 41 1 2002) Thi rquie ntmea t tn t
. s e r me
ns he l mae
i
mus comef wa d wih s ehi mor t n vaguea c l or a lga i ofi nve e or
t
or r t om t ng
e ha
nd oncus y le tons nco nince
deay i hi i tga i orpr e uton ofl ga a tons ...Thef c t ta i aem a notbe a et
l n s nsi ton
os c i
e l ci .
a t ha n nm t y
bl o
l iaei e a t t ema n rh d sr si n ts fiin t d mo srt tea t ln u yee n o a
i g t n x cl h n e e e ie s o u fce t o e n tae h cua ij r lme t f n
t
y
a es t co t cl m v Godf ey v.W as ng on Cnt . a. She i f N o. 06- v- 87,2007 U .
cc s o ur s ai '
'
r
hi t
y. V s r f , 7: c 001
S.
DitLEXI 6051 a * 2007W L 2405728,a *1 ( . Va.
s.
S
9, t 39,
t 3 W D. Aug.17, )( k,J)
2007 Tur ..
Pl n ifcompl i t thi a lged fusr t physc a e st t 1w lbr r durng hi
aitf
ans ha s le
r taed
ial cc s o he a i a y i s
ni t da say i t SLU c us d hi t f f ta c ai t t a i a e t o- a s a ut of
ne y- y t n he
a e m o or ei l m o he pplc bl w ye r t t e
lm ia i . l plci i t ta gtm e i t f c t tt f f ie c a m a c ue m or t n t o ye r
i t tons m i t n ha r l nt s he a t ha he or e t d l i c r d
e ha w
as
be or hefl d t saci Pli ifdoesnota es how Ha mond,W al Young,Hi e,Ga m a
f e ie hi ton. antf
ddr s
m
z,
nkl
r n,
17
A . bi o a Cl r i e f r d wih Pl ntf sa lt t fl s ta
Ro ns n, nd ake nt re e t ai if biiy o ie ui boutt c am d i t t
he l i urng he woyea lm ia i pe i whih r n bot be or and a rPl i ifsni t da sa i t SLU.
r i ttons rod, c a
h f e
he antf
ne y- y t y n he
La ty,Pl i if s Am e
s l a ntf
nded Com pl nta i tD e enda si r pl t w ih a us tonsof
ai ga ns f
nt s e e e t cc a i
r tl to ld frd s osto o Plitf se ha se camso rt l to t i1n a l t a j iae
eai in. ee ip iin f anif x u td li f eai in mtl m be o dudc t
a
a
cai 7.See e. , ms 40F. a 75(e nii rt itonmus ha occ rdwihr r t t
lm
s g.Ada , 3d t rcog zng ealai
t ve ure t egad o he
e ecs o s mec n ttto l p oe tdrg to tertlao ya to is l voltds c arg t.
x r ie f o o si inal r tce ih r h eait r cin tef i ae u h ih)
u
y
V I.
Fo t ef r g igra o , d n De e d n s moin frs mmayj d me ta t cam 7a d
r h o e on e s ns I e y fn a t' to o u r u g n s o li n
die tte t fl amo inf rs mma yj d me t d n Dee d n s moin frsl r j d me t
rc h m o ie to o u r u g n ; e y fn a t' to o l
mmay u g n
wih u prj d c a t P an ifse h use camso rtlaind et t ep n e c o cam 7 a d
t o t eu ie s o litf x a td li f eaito u o h e d n y f li , n
g a t h moin frs mmayj dg n a t al te cams
r n t e to o u r u me t s o l oh r li .
ENTER: hsl c dyo Spe e,04
T i . a f etmbr2 1.
Se o Unie Stt DititJ
ni
td a es src udge
18
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?