Banks v. New River Valley Regional Jail et al

Filing 11

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 08/05/2013. (kab)

* pprs OFFI U'8. ST fc utl
CE
DI z l R '
ATROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON

AUC 2 5 2 1
23
JUL

UD EY, ERK
CL

BY;

PUTYCLERK

CASTRO JEROM E BANK S,

CASE NO .7: 36+ 00264
1

Pl ntf ,
ai if
M EM O M N D UM O PI I N
N O

V.

NE W R I ER V A LLEY R EG I N A L JA I
V
O
L,
CHARLI COCHREN,
E

By: Jam e C .Tur
s
k
Se or U nied St e D i t i Judge
ni
t
at s s r ct

De e
f ndants.
t)
Casr J r
to e omeBa , Vigi ai t pr e ngpr K , ie t scvi rgh sa ton
nks a r ni nma e oce di
o fld hi i l i t c i

pzs a t o4 U. C. 1 8 , l gigta ted fn a t al fkil o g ul c n it dh m
l u n t 2 S. j 9 3 al n h t h ee d n j io t a wr n f l o vce i
r
e
y
ofa dicplna yc r wihou ahe i i vi a i ofduepr s .Upon r viw oft
s i i r ha ge t t arng, n olton
oce s
e e
he
r co d,t c r fndst tt a ton m us b sl ma iy dim is
e r he ou t i ha he c i
te l
m rl s s ed.

Ba ks a imaea t Ne Rie ValyRe i n l al çh j i', le e t ef lo n
n , n n t t he w v r le go a J i(ç e a1) alg s h ol wig
t
'

s q n eofe e t rlv n t h scam .l Ma 2 3 ji o fcasc ag dBa k wi
e ue c v n s ee a t o i li n y 01 ,al fiil h r e n s t
h
va ls ,avi ai oft i t dici i yr gultons W he a ofke a t ed t s r e
ndaim
ol ton he nma e s plnar e a i .
n n f r tempt o e v
Bankswih am 'tn co oft c r on M a 1 201 Ba r f e t sgn i.
t
i e py he ha ge
t
y 6, 3, nks e us d o i t
Bn s isac ofa f m,da e M a 1 201 e ild II ATE VI
nks ubm t opy
or
t d y 6, 3, ntte ENM
OLATI
ON

REPORT/
ADVI E OFY GHTS DI CI NARY DI POS TI ' ( No 2 a 2)
SEM NT
/ S PLI
S I ON. ECF . , t .
'
Thet oft f m saest cr l t nc soft va ls c r e. Be ow t c gei a
op he or tt he iclmsa e
he ndaim ha g
l he har s
s cton entte C DVI
e i
ild W
SEM ENT OF RI
GHTS, whih r ads t ha be n i or
' c e : t ve e nf med oft
'
l
he

c r s agans mea ad s dofmyrg s By sg ngbeow, i caeyoz prfrnc
haget) i t nd vie
iht. ini l you ndi t lr eee e
r ga di t rg si cae W avi yo z rght t ahe rng i t admi son ofg l a
e r ng he i ht ndi td. i ng lr i s o
a i s he
si
uit nd

c n o b a p ae . (d) Beo t spaa rp t ei maemus i iaeo eo t c o c s
n n t e p e ld' I . lw hi rg a h,h n t
'
tndc t n f wo h ie :

ç ai t Ri t aHe i YES NO. W avet 24 hourRequie e prort havi t
l ve he ght o
W
arng;
i he
r m nt i o
ng he

he rngc
ai onduce YES NO.'(d. Ba di notmakYESorNO f et roft e
td:
' I ) nks d
r
or ihe hes
c c .
hoi es

Lae o M a 1 201 ,h j i' h a igo fc r Ch ri Co h e c met s eBn k a
tr n y 6, 3 t e als e rn fie, a l c rn, n o e n s t
e
li c land a ke i he wantd t ha hi hea i a t tme.Banksr f s d,s yi t the
zs el
s df
e o ve s rng t hat i
e u e a ng ha
wa e 24 hotr t pr pa ef t he ng. Coc e s i oka buti caed hedi no
nt d
ts o e r or he mi
hr n a d y,
ndi t
d t

undesa whyBn ne dedmor tme,snc het sar dyguit bec us ( rf e t
rtnd
nks e
e i i e l lea
wa
ly a e he) e usd o

sg ' ( mp . .
in. Co l 2)
'
Thene da Bnnksr e ve aco oft i t vi ai n r por,sai t tCoc e
xt y,
ec i d
py he nma e ol to e t t tng ha
hr n,
a he rng ofke ,ha f md Ba guit oft c r andpe i d hi wih t l sof5
s ai
t r d ot
nks ly he ha ge
nalze m t he os

d y o g o t .Ba ksfldag iv nc , r u n (shed e h r ) h ttec ag p p r r
as f o d i
me n ie re a e ag i g a
o s ee t a h h r e a e wo k
di notputhi onno i t tf iur t sgn t a s me ofrght wa t equi e of
d
m
tce ha al e o i he dvi e nt i s s he
valnt
a ti g l orwavi t rg t bepr e f ahea i on t c r A c pt n uphed
dmitng uit
i ng he i ht o
es nt or
rng he ha ge. a ai
l

t c ci sai ç r Ba yourofe serpor al wiht a s me ofrg s
he onviton, ttng: t . nks
M
fnll e t ong t he dvie nt iht
we egi nt you.Ha you co plt d advie tofrght t r woul no ha be n a
r ve o
d
m ee
s men
i s he e
d t ve e
que tonofyouri e i .W he you r f et c
si
ntntons
n
e us o ooper t wih otrpr edm es wec
ae t l oc
,
anno gues
t
s

wha y uwa t od . ( No 2 a 3) Th r s o s a t en x lv lo rve sae :t u
t o n t o' ECF . , t . e e p n e t h e t e e f e iw ttd t
'
Yo
weea fr e d ep o e sa dy u c o sen t opatcp t.Be a s y uc ll n t o
r fo d d u r c s n o h ll o t riiae c u e o ho se o t
p ii t d e n tme ntec ag wil o beh ad. J a 4. Th sfn i gwa u hedi a
m cpae o s o a h h r e ln t e r ' Z t ) i id n s p l n
'(
t r lv l frv e
hid e e o e iw.Ba k p it o t h t i rtea vie n o rg t f r n rt ji'
n s on s u t a net h d s me t f ih s o m o he als
he
ha
ndbook a s si t t f itr t sg t cha gea a s m e ofrgh sf m
dvie nma es hat a lle o i n he r nd dvie nt i t or
c tm t san a i s o of g l orw ai rofa hemi
onsi e
dm s i n
uit
ve
ng.

2

Ba k fldti j 1 8 a to a an ttej i a d Co h e , le i avo aino h sd e
n s ie h s 9 3 ci n g i s h al n c r n algng ilto f i u
pr e srgh s Asr i , s e û lws tag ns Ofke Coc e f rvi ai m y rght t
oc s i t .
elef he e ks t a ui ai t t r hr n o ol tng
a
i so

d ep o e s a dt h vehm frdfo t ej ia ah ai go t r b c u eIm sleoh r
u r c s , n o a i ie r m h al s e rn f , e a s ' t t e
ke
r
i t hal ha t sdonebyhi ... (
nmaes vel d hi
m ' Compl3.
'
.)
11

Thec r i r quie t dim isa a ton orcai fl by aprs ra i ta
ou t s e r d o s s ny c i
l m ied
ione gans
gove n en a e iy orofi e i t c tde e m i t a ton orcl i i f i ous m a i i ,
r m t l ntt
t c r f he our t r nes he c i
a m s rvol , lc ous

orfist saeacam onwhihrle ma begrntd.28U. C.j 1 5A( () I or rt
al o tt li
c eif y
a e
S.
91 b)1 . n de o

saeacam i a y fd r l i l cin,h panifst ta t a alg to smu t ee o g t
tt li n n e ea cvia to t e litf tl cu l l ain s b n u , o
l
e
h
r iearghtt r le a
as i o ei f bove t s c a i l ve , t onet ti G a i e o isf ce'r t r
he pe ultve e l' o
'
ha s t usbl n t a ,' a he
pl

t nmeel ç nc i e. BelAt. p. Twombl 550U. 5 570( )
ha r y l evabl ' l lCor v.
co
'
v,
S. 44, 2007 .
The onl f r ofr i f Bnnks s eksi br ngi tls l w s ti t ha Coc e
y om
ele
e
n i ng li a ui s o ve
hr n

tr i t d asahe rngofk e . Thec tc t est sde nd a a r ques f pr pe tve
e m na e
ai
t r
our onsnz hi ma s e t or os c i

rle, ri oh rwo d , p r n n ijmcino d rn j io fcast b iCo h e fo
eif o n t e r s a ema e t nt to r e ig al fiil o a c rn r m
pr s di ove di c plnar pr e di .
e i ng r s i i y oc e ngs

A l ia tlc sa dn t pzs eijmcier l f s do ap s e e tG bs n ar a
i g n a ks tn ig o t u n t tv ei ba e n a t v n û e t e l
t
r
e
a
a i medit t e t' ha hewilbehn med i t s wa i t f t e.Br ntv. ne
nd m
a e hr a 't t
l
r
n he ame y n he u ur
ya
Che y,

9 4F. 5 5 5 9(t Ci. 9 )(p yn Civo Lo Ana lsv. ns 461U.. 5( 9 3 )
2 2d 2 , 2 4 h r 1 91 a plig t f s ee Lvo ,
S 9 1 8 ).
Ba m a sno s h s i H i own e de e i c t st ti he i e rc r d w ih
nks ke
uc how ng. s
vi nc ndi a e ha f s ve ha ge t

a ohe ds i ia yifa to a tej i, ec ne u et t er c ie ahe rngbeo eb ig
n t r icpl r n rcin t h alh a ns r ha h e ev s ai f r en
n
f
ound g ly- by c
uit
ompltng t a s men ofrg ss c i oft c r f m a cic i
e i he dvie t i ht e ton he ha ge or nd r lng
G O ' i r pons t bo h quesi i t ss c i oft f nn.
t ' n es
N
eo t
tons n hi e ton he o

Be a s i i ce rfo Ba ks alg to ta h i no e tte t t eijmcierle
c u e t s la rm n ' l ains h t e s t nild o h n t tv eif
e

hes e si t i cvia to t ec u t imis stea to wih u p eu ie p ru n t
e k n hs i l cin,h o r ds se h cin to t rj dc , u s a t o
j 1 5 b ( ) Th Clr i drce t sndc pe o t sme rn d o no a d
91 A( ) 1. e ek s ie td o e o is f hi mo a dl piin n
m
a co pa ng o de t pl i if
c m nyi r r o a ntf
EN TER : Ihi
s

J- w a o Au u t2013.
Y d y f g s,
*e - 4 J
v,
Se orUnied St t Ditl tJ
nl
t
aes sr udge