Fry v. New River Valley Regional Jail

Filing 10

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 07/24/2013. (kab)

el < 8 QF I l, 5lT * Ur .
W
FX J:. # !
,
ATfQASIKk#
I II VA
FICD
L'

I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D I
STR I C O U R T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
ROANOKE DI I O N
V SI
R O BER T D .
FRY ,

)
)
Pl ntf ,
ai if
)
)
)
)
NEW RI
VER VALLEY REGI
ONAL JAI )
L,
)
Dee
fndant
.
)

J 1i 2 1
Ut
23
JULA
I
BK

L Y.
.
E

w *.

cksE No. : 3 0 0
7 1 CV: 3 8
M EM O R AN D U M O PI I N
N O

By: G l n E.C onrad
e
C hi fU nie St t sD i t c Judge
e
t d a e s ri t

Robe t . y,a V igi a i a e pr ee ng pr K ,t l d t s c vi r g s a ton ptr ua
r D Fr
r ni nm t oc di
o
s e hi i l i ht c i
zs nt

t 4 U. C. 1 8 , le i t a I n me alo fcash v r f s dt p o d hm wi c ran
o 2 S. j 9 3 algng h tl a dj i fiil a e eu e o r vie i t e ti
n
h
media i Upon r vi w oft r or t c tfndst tt a ton mus besl a iy
c ton.
e e
he ec d, he our i ha he c i
t lmm rl
di r s e
sni s d.
I

F y i a imaea t Ne Rie ValyRe in lJ i Ct ej i' . h nh frte tr d
r s n n t the w v r le go a al l al' W e e is ne e
h
)
t ej i, eb o g t d c to fo h me a p r nl s p le t h m tr ug hi Veea '
h al h r u h me iai n r m o , p ae ty u pid o i h o h s tr n s
be ft . OnceFr e used t ss y,howe r t medialsa fr f e t pr det
ne is
y xha t hi uppl
ve , he
c tf e us d o ovi he

me iain b c u eF yrf s dt pa f ri a r q ie b j i p lc F yalg st t eha
dc to , e a s r e u e o y o t s e ur d y al oiy. r le e ha h s

fldrq e t t s etej i d co a dt rc i me iain, u h sg nef rt we ks
ie e u ss o e h al o tr n o e eve dc to b t a o o wo e
wihouthi me cne.
t
s di i

F yb i g t i a to a ans t ej i.Asrle, esae ta h wa t t rc iehs
r rn s hs cin g i t h al
eif h tts h t e n s o e ev i
medii a t bec
cne nd o
ompe ae f pan a s f rng.
ns td or i nd ufe i
11

The c ti r uie t di m i sa a ton orcl i fl d by a pr s
our s eq r d o s s ny c i
a m ie
i onera ns a
gai t
gove n en ale iy orofk e i t co tde enni t a ton o c a m i f i ous m alci ,
r m t ntt
t r f he ur t nes he c i r l i s rvol , i ous

RK

i
#
.

orfist saeacli onwhihr i ma beg a ed.28U. C.j1 5A( ( ) To saea
al o tt am
c elef y r nt
S. 91 b)1. tt
ca eofa tonunde j1 apli ifmus esa iht theha bee de i dofrg s
us ci
r 983, antf t tbls ha
s n prve iht
guar nted by t Co tt ton orl oft Unie St esa t ttlsde i to r s t
a e
he nsiu i
aws he td at nd ha ii prva in e uled
fo c
r m onduc c m it d by a pe s a tng t de col ofs a e l w . W e tv. t ns 487 U .
t om te
r on c i m r or t t a
s A ki s
S.

4 ( 9 8 . Th j i, st eo yd fn a t yha n me i t sa to ,sn t G es n' u j c
2 1 8 ) e al a h nl ee d n Fr s a d n hi cin i o a û ro 's b e t
p
t s i u d r1 1 8 .P e a v Re o 2 3F.d 8 , 0 W L 20 1 a * ( t Ci. a .1 ,
o ut n e 9 3 r v l . n , 0 3 21 20 0
59 , t 1 4h r J n 3
2 0 )( n u ls e )(uoi W i v. c ia De 'o S aeP lc , 91U. 5 , ( 9 9
0 0 u p bih d q tng l Mih g n pt f tt o ie 4
l
S. 8 71 1 8 :;
Mc yv Ch s p a çCo r cin l n e s 8 F. p 8 0 8 3 9 ( D. .1 9 )( dng
co . e a e k re t a Ce tr 7 8 Su p. 9 , 9 - 4 E. Va 9 2 sn i
o
ct al mmu efo s i a dn t pes nf rpupo e o j 1 8 )
iyj ii n rm ut n o a ro o r s s f 9 3 .

Be a s Fr c nn tp e aln aj1 8 cam a ans t ej i,h c u t imis sFr s
c u e y n o rv ii
9 3 li g i t h alt e o r d s se y'
c mpan wih u p eu ie p rl n t j1 1 A( )1, slg lyfio o .TheClr i
o lit t o t rj dc , u sl t o 9 5 b ( ) a e al rv lus1
n
ek s
di e t d t s nd co esoft sm e o and t opi on a a om pa ng or rt pl ntf .
rce o e
pi
hi m r lm
ni nd cc
nyi
de o ai if

ENTER: Thi
s

%4 R
d

a ofJ y,201
y ul
3.

Chi fUnie St t D i ti tJ
e
t d a es sr c udge

1 Thecour al o fndst Fr scur e alegatonsf lt sat aconsiutonaly sgnii
t s i hat y' r nt l i ai o t e
tt i l i fcant

cam a i ta on a teji.Fr do sno i iaeta h h a ysro me c ln e frme c to
li gans ny e t h al y e tndc t h t e as n eius dia e d o diain
ort th h ss frda yil fet fo n trc i ngi.l as a e r fom hi sbmison t tal
ha e a ufee n lefcs rm o e evi t t lo py as r s u si s haj i
ofk il a ewiln t pr vi hi wihme iai i hec iswlht ai' me c lu tp o e r s
t as r lig o o de m t dc ton f omple t hej ls dia ni r c du e .
Se Esel v. mbl, 29U. 9 1 2( 9 )(idigt tp ion rmus s w d i rt i if rnc
e t le Ga e 4
S. 7, 0 1 76 fn n ha rs e
t ho el ae nd fee e
be
t hi s'o me ia n e t p o c tt ton vilto me en glg nc i no s fce ) W rg tv.
o s e ius dc l e d o r ve onsiu i al oain; r e ie e s t ufiint; ih
r
Colns 7 F.d 8 ,8 ( h Ci.1 )(idigmeedia r e ntb t e i t a d me c l
li , 66 2 41 49 4t r 985 fn n r s g e me e we n nmae n dia
pe s nn lo rc reo te t n d sn i iaec tt ton lrg t)
r o e ve ou s f rame t oe ot mplc t onsiu i a ih s.
2