Martin v. Britton

Filing 10

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 08/08/2013. (kab)

CLERKS OFFI t. . 8T. COURT
CE ls Dl
ATROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I RI CO U R T
ST CT
FO R TH E W ESTER N D I
STR I T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O A N O K E D I SI N
VI O

Ak û 8 2 1
C
23
JUL

DU LEM CL
ERK

BY;
E t' CL
lY ERK
f

JOHN PHI P M ARTI
LLI
N

CASE NO.7:3CV00 3
1
31

Pl ntf ,
ai if

V.

M EM O M N D U M O PI I N
N O

STAN LEY BR I TO N,JR .
T
,

By: Jam esC .Tur
k
Se or Uni e St esD i t i tJudge
ni
t d at
src

Dee
fndants.
t)
J Philp M a t aVigi a i t pr e ng pr K ,fl t sci lrght ac i
ohn li
ri
n, r ni nma e oce di
o
ied hi vi i s ton
.

purua t 42U. C.j1 3.M a tn' compl ntr dsa f lws vebai :
s nt o
S. 98
ri s
ai ea s olo , r tm
Upon 1 23/ 1 Hw y 360 W es H alf x Coun y,V igi a. St nl y Brton, r
0/ 201
t ia
t
r ni
a e it J .

pef me sej eupon Shel matnsRe seedVe ce.W ili Cour
ror d lizur
ia ri gitr
hil
tln
t
ta cit / 2 1 tsiidh h dn r a o f rsel u e Ev k d6h
rns rp 2 2 /2 etfe e a o e s n o liz r . o e t
Ame m e Spee ti l2/ / 3,5/ 1 6/ 13Alo c ofVA 1 2- nd nt
dy ra 20 1 9/ 3, 3/
s ode
9. 243
Cour Da es tf r10 9t 1 h,111201 Upon 1 23 2011on Rt61
t t e o / h, 0t t
3
0/ /
3

trys i RdStnlyBrtonJ ra di ove cea sel dJ m Philp
er brdge
a e it r e che nt hil nd lize ol li
M a tn' G pe s'orlc e outof1 p dtrng t r y s op. The M a e J
r i s t r ' i ens
pa
a li e r t
n c d ohn
Philp M a tn
li
ri

( mpl 1) Asr l fM a t se mo ea yd ma e a dG ma cp to o c re tc n iim'
Co . .
ei , ri e ks n tr a g s n l n iain f u rn o dto '
e
n
e
(d Thec tfndst tt a tonmus besl rl dimis df f ltet saef t
L=)
our
ha he ci
t lmmaiy s se or aitr o tt acs
s t e t pr e apl i ecai f rlefunderj 1
ufkint o esnt ausbl l m or ei
983.
Thec ti r quie t r viw prs rc pli sf c
our s e r d o e e ione om a nt or omplanc wiht ba i nle of
i e t he sc l s
pl a ng a eihe çde iy c i a ecli so dimist compl nt ora pori oft
e di nd t r l ntf ogn z bl am r s s he
i
ai , ny ton he

c mp an (h t fist saeacam u nwh c rle c nb g a td. 2 U. C.
o lit t al al o tt li po ih eif a e r ne ' 8 S.
'
Martin v. Britton

Doc. 10

j 1 5 b ( ) A c mplitmu t l g t n ug fcst saeacam t rle t a i pa i e
91 A( )1 . o an s al e t o h a t o tt li o eif h t s lusbl
e e
o isfce' Gi r tnov. ohns 5 F. 298,302( hCi.2008)( i BelAt. p.
n t a .' aram
J on, 21 3d
4t r
quotng l lCor v.

Two v,550U. 544,570(
mbl
S.
2007:.Coursmus lbeal co tuepl di fldbypr s
t t i rly nsr ea ngs ie
oe
pli if t e ur t tm e etcl ca r zr m e sdo notf ecos pot nta l me iorous
antf s o ns e ha r e mi l eqlie nt
or l e e ily rt i

Dockets.Justia.com

cams Be u et Civo Hn tn, 7 F.d 1 7 ,1 7 - 8( t Ci.1 8 ) Ne e tee s t
li . a d t v. t f mp o 7 5 2 2 4 2 7 7 4h r 9 5 . v rh ls ,he
c tmus bea et dic m f o t c
our
t bl o s e r m he ompl ntt pa tesbeng s t al ge conduc on
ai he ri i ued, he le d
t

whc e c cam rss a dt en t eo t ij r t b c mpe s td Ev n ap os p an ifs
ih a h li e t, n h aur f he nu y o e o n ae . e r e litf
û ta ta alg t nsmus b e o g t r iearg t or l fa o et es e ultv lv l'oo e
tl cu l le ai
g
o
t e n u h o as ih t ei b v h p c aie e e, t n
e
'
t ti û a i eon isf e, r t rt m e ey l onceva e. BelAt. p. Twom bl
ha s t usbl
pl
t ac ' ahe h%
'
rl i
c
i bl ' l l Cor v.
'
v,

5 0U. 5 4 5 0( 0 7 .
5 S. 4 , 7 2 0 )
Tosaeac us o a to u d r5 9 3, p an ifmu te tb ihta h h sb e
tt a e f cin n e 1 8 a litf s sa ls h t e a e n
de i d ofr g s g r nt e by t Cons iuton orl w soft Unied St t a t tt s
pr ve
i ht ua a e d
he
tt i
a
he t
a es nd ha hi

de i ton r s t fom co
prva i e uled r
nduc co mitd by ape s a tng t
t m te
r on c i mderc orofsae lw .W es
ol
tt a
t

v. k n , 7U.. 2( 9 8 . Ma t sc mpli t o sn t r vies fkin fcst saea y
Ati s 48 S 4 1 8 ) ri o an d e o p o d u t e t a t o tt n
n'
plusbl cai aci bl unde j1
a i e l m tona e
r 983.Fr m t s s deal hepr des t c tc nnot
o he pare tis
ovi ,he our n

d tr n wh ted fnd n i, yhei s b e tt s i u d rj1 3 o Wh r t fn hi t
eemie o h ee a t s wh
s u jc o ut n e 98 , r ee o id m o
s w epr e so hi .Theco ai alo o r sno i cai oft m n ri whih t
e
oc s n m
mpl nt s fer
ndi ton he nne n c he
i ht .
def nda ' a tonsm a ha vi a e pl i if s c tm tonalr g s l Thus t c pl i f is
e nt s c i
y ve ol t d a ntf ons i i
a nt a l
, he om

t saea a tona ej 1 cai f mo tr dnmag agans Brto
o tt ny ci bl 938 l m or neay
es i t itn.
Theco tc tu M a tn' de nd f rt m a i to ofc e c ton't bea
ur onsr es ri s ma o t ncpai n
e
= nt ondii ' o
r que tf r e e fo i r e ai n. W he a deai e c le
e s or elas r m nca c r to
n
t ne ha lngest f tordtr ton ofhi
he ac
la i
s
dee i a cvi rght compl nti no t pr
tnton, i l i s
ai s t he operlgalr m e Pr ie v. Rodrmue 411U.
e e dy. e s r
i z,
S.

4 5( 9 3 ; d v. s evle 71 F.d7 ( t Ci.1 8 ) d ti ema ries h
7 1 7 ) To d Ba k r il, 2 2 0 4h r 9 3 .A eane y as uc
c l ng t li de en i n onl by flng a pe ii f a w rtofha msco pus f l i
hale es o ts t t o
y
ii
tton or
i
be
r , olow ng

1 To t ext t M ari s
he ent hat
tn eeksdnm agesbas on a t yt tBrton' actonsconti ed i
ed
heor ha it s i
rbut n

s
ome wa t hi unl ulares orde e i he i her advi t tcl m soft snat e ar not
y o s awf r t
t nton, s eby
sed ha ai
hi ur e

a ton bl u rj1 3u e st r s tngc n ci sha b e ov ru ne o s ta i .Se . g.
ci a e nde 98 nls he e uli o viton ve e n e tr d r e sde e e.
He kv. mp e 51 U. 477 486 8 ( 9 4) Hei as a vie t tcamsun rj 1 3mus
c Hu hry, 2 S. , - 7 1 9 . s lo d s d ha li de 98
t

ge eal b fldwihi t yer oft asetdijr Se Va Cod An j8. -43a;Owe v.
n rl e ie t n wo as he sre nuy. e . e n. 012 () ns
y
Ok e 48sU. 23 23 - (98 .
ur,
S. 5, 940 1 9)
2

e usi ofa ia es ec trmedi .J .seas 28U. C.j22544 (e r ng
xha ton valbl ut our e es #=; e lo
S.
b) r gadi

e h usi nrq ie n )2 Th s M a t c n o saeacam u e j 1 8 f rr la efo
x a to e ur me t.
u , ri n n t tt li nd r 9 3 o ee s r m
n
confnem ent
i
.

F rt er a o sae t c u t s se Ma t sc mplitwi u p eu ie p rua t
o h e s ns ttd,he o r dimis s ri o an t t rj dc , u s n
n'
ho
t j 1 5 b ( ) f rfiu et saeacam.Th Clr i dr ce t s n c piso t s
o 91 A( )1, o alr o tt li
e ek s ie td o e d o e f hi
me or ndlm o ni n and a co pa ng o de t pli if
m a l pi o
c m nyi r r o antf.
EN TER ; 'hi F s

ay ofA ugus,201
t
3.

J
Se Unie Stt sDititJ
ni
t d a e src udg

2 A sM a tn' submi i i cat t hi crm i pr
ri s
ssons ndi e hat s i nal oceedi a e cur enty pendi , t cour
ngs r
r l
ng he
t
i s ifed t the hass e cour r
s ats i ha
ut
t emedi yetavaiabl t hi . Ass
es
l eo m
uch,he hasnotye s ts i t
t a ifed he

e usi r q rme un rj22 49.Ac o di y, h c ur wil tc nsr ehi s bmiso a a
xha ton e uie nt de
54 1
c r ngl t e o t l no o tu s u s in s
ha a peiin u e j2 4.
be s tto nd r 25
3