Scottsdale Insurance Company v. C.E.S. et al

Filing 52

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 7/29/14. (eot)

M anges e pl
' m oyert pre
o ventt ac sofsexuala e. Specii ly,M anges a Thom as f f
he t
bus
fcal
nd
ace our

c u t i t u eliglws i Co nt -Batr ( n e) Co nt 1-Batr ( h ma, e o da
o n s n he nd r n a ut u l tey Ma g s; u 1
y
:
tey F o s rj n et
p
JJ:/8; u tI1-Ne l nc ( ma)Co n I - Ne l e ePe S C h ma)
v rp Co n 1
gke e Tho s; u t V
gi nc t e f o s.
g
Thom as s it a cli on A ptl22,2013 t Scotsdae r
ubm ted am
i
o
t l equesi i ur
tng ns ance cover of
age

t saec ta don.Sc tdaede e t cam a fldt i tntde lrt yj gme a don,
he tt our c
ots l nid he li nd te he nsa caaor ud nt c
nam i M anges,Thom as,and M i ,M ot r,and Fat rD oe asdef
ng
not
he
he
endant . Scots l cont
s
t da e
ends

t t polcy lngua does notcovert al
hat he i a ge
he legadonsse f t i t D oes s a e cour com pli .
t orh n he
' tt
t
ant
Scotsdal al a guest Thom asand M angesf ied t com pl wih t nodce r r ent oft
t e so r
hat
al o
y t he
equiem s he
polcy,and t ,di nots if a condi pr
i
hus d
ats y
éon ecedentt cover oft underyi l ui. O n
o
age he
l ng aws t

Au t1 2 ,Doea he pa e sa wee a fldac ecqm f de lrt yj me ,
gus 4, 013
nd r rnt ns rd nd te ountrli or caaor udg nt
s ng t esabls t t undetyi com pl ntdoesi f iw oke cover oft polcy.
eeki o t ih hat he
l ng
ai
n act t
age he i
Thom as' a weri uded a sm ia count cl m r
s ns
ncl
i lr
er ai eques i a decar i ofcover unde t
tng
l aton
age
r he

i ur
ns ance cont act Scots e s it an ans ert t D oes'count cli on Sept ber5,
r .
t dal ubm ted
w o he
er am
em
2013 a res
nd ponded t Thom as count r m on O ct
o
'
e cbi
obet 8,2013. M angeshasnotfl any
ted

pl a ngsorm a a a a a e i t s a don a no pa t ha r que t t tt c e k e e
e di
de ny ppe r nc n hi c
nd
ry s e sed ha he l t nt r
def ta ns li .
aul gai t am

OnMa c 1 2014 Sc tdaes te t i tntmodonf j
rh 7, , ots l ubmitd he nsa
orudgme ont pla ngs
nt he e di ,
t yi on isar ent t t polcy l
el ng t gum s hat he i anguage doesnotprovi covet ge oft cli sadvanced
de
a
he am
i t underyi com pl nt The cour hel a m otonshearng on M a 22,2014 r di
n he
l ng
ai .
t d
i
i
y
egar ng

Sc tdaesmotonf j gme on t pla ngsa wela Sc tdae'mot t srkejz
ots l' i or ud nt he e di s l s ots l s bn o ti uy
dem and. M eanwhie,Scots e,Thom as,and t D oesha each s it m otonsf s m ar
l
tdal
he
ve
ubm ted
i
or um
y

j me t tdiput is softmeynotc c eni Thoma ' l oft i urnc cam a
udg nt ha s e sue i l ie onc r ng
s fi
ng he ns a e li nd
Scots l s de aloft cli . Thos Rul 56 m otonsa e notcur enty bef e t cour .
t da e' ni
he am
e e
i
r
t l
or he
t

lI.

The fts i ue t i cur enty bef t colr i whet t cour s d exer s
l t ss hat s r l
ore he zt s
her he
t houl
cie

j ididonove t smatrz Unde t Delrt yl gme Ac, dititc zti ac s or
urs c
t hi te.
r he caaor ud nt ta stc olr n ae
c r ryot r s wihi isj ididon,Q ydelr t rght a ot rlga rldonsofa
ontoves hewie t n t urs c
z
mq cae he i s nd he e l ea
ny

itr se pat s e igs c d caain' 2 U.. j2 0 (mp ssa d d . Ac o dn l,h
n eetd ry ekn u h e lr t . 8 SC, 2 1 e hai d e lS c r igy t e
o '
c ttsj ididono rt satoni dice r .Na lusI .Co. W i hettHome.nc,1
otr' urs c
ve hi ci s srdonay utl ns v. nc se
'
sI . 5

F.d3 1 3 5(t Ci. 9 4 .Delrt r jd me tsus l a p o raewh nt er q se
3 7 , 7 4h t 1 9 ) caao y u g n i ual p r p it e h e uetd
y
decl aton f ilse a us ulpurpos i cl i yng and s ti t lgalrel
ar i < l rve ef
w
e n arf i
etlng he e
adonsi is and . .
n s ue,
.
whe i w tlt m i e and af or r i fom t uncet ni y,i ecurt and cont ovet y gi ng ts
n t ' er nat
t
f d elef r
he
t nt ns iy,
t s vi ie

t t pr e di ' Aer Ca. Sur Co. Quals 9 F. 321 3 ( hCi.1 7 .Howe r
o he oc e ng. tm s& . v. re, 2 2d , 25 4t t 93 )
'
ve,
wheet de lrtr j me a toni die tyas itdwihape ngsaelwsttt c tt
t he caao y udg nt ci s rcl socae t
ndi tt a ti,he otr

mus as tkei oa c d onsdea offdeaim,ehce y a c t i de ii
t lo a nt c ount f i r dons e rls f inc , nd omif'n cdng
c

wheh rt e trant st.Na tu , 5F.da 3 6(iigMi h s nv Hars 9 5F.d2 5
te o n eti he tt ui s 1 3 t 7 ct
i
l
n t eo . ri, 5 2 3 ,
c
2 74 (t Ci. 9 2) o tfco sadi ti b ln igts:
3 - 1 4h z 1 9 ).F u a t t i n hs aa cn et
( t srnghoft saesi e eti ha ngt is srie i t
i he te t he tt' ntr s n vi he sue asd n he
)
f a decl at acdon deci i t st ecolrt
eder l ar ory
ded n he at z s;

$)wheh rteis e rie i t fd rl c o c nmo ee f inl
te h su s as d n he e ea a d n a r fi e t
c y
be r ol i t courti w li t s a e acton i pendi
es ved n he
n lch he t t i s
ng;

ti whehe pemitngt fdea a i t g f wadwoul r s t
ii t r t ti he e rl cton o o or r
l
d eul
i unneces ry fent e ent'bet
n
sa t angl m ' ween t f al a sat cotr
he edet nd t e tt
s em s beca e of t pres
yst ,
us
he
ence of fovera ng is of f ot
f lppi s ues
act
lw ';and
a 7

( )wheh rted caao yjd me t cin i b igusdmeeya a
i
v
te h e lrtr u g n a t s en e rl s
o
devi f fprocedur f ng'- t i ,Tt pr de anot f z
ce or i
al enci ' hat s fo ovi
her ortm
i a t f rsyùdiat 'or tt ac eve a f alhearng i a case
n ace ot e
c a'
fo hi
eder
i n
ot wi e notr ovabl '
her s
em
e.'

2 nop ryh sobetdt t c ut jrs ié no e ti a t n t c t rie t s c n e sajot.
As at a jce o he o r' u idc o v r hs ci ,he out asshee o cms u p ne
s
o
3 e alblyi ue fe ad caao yjd me t cina ansisn le a datidp rywi atr c m aan t
Wh n i it nsrrt s elrtr u g n a t g i ttisz d n hr at t o t bi gis
a i
l
o
r
h
t i ur d a s e t e tbhs t tt unde l ng ca m i notc r d by t diput d pol y, < c e ofa tz l
he ns e nd e ks o sa h ha he
ryi li s
ove e
he s e
i Ta as
c
c ta

c n r v ry'sp ee .S eMaya d Ca . . . c Co l Oi Co, 1 U.. 7 , 7 (9 1.Ad io l ,
o to e s 'i r snt e r ln s Co v Pa . a & l .3 2 S 2 0 2 3 1 4 ) dd nal
y
ac rigt t c mpan frd caao yjd me tS otd l i a Ohoc r rd nwihispi ia paeof
c odn o he o lit o elrtr u g n, c tsae s n i opoa o t t r p l lc
nc
busne si Sc tdae Arz ,a ea h oft de e nt i a ctze oft Com m onwe lh ofVig ri. Bec us t
i s n ots l , i ona nd c
he f nda s s ii n he
at
r ila
a e he

p r e aec mpeeydv re a dtea t i c nrv rye ce s$ 50 0 tec utsuidc o o e timatri
aé s r o ltl ies,n h momtn o to es x ed 7 ,0 ,h o r'jrsié n v r hs te s
pop rp rua t 8U... 1 3 .
r e us n 2 SC j 3 2

I at377.
d.
4

l a yigt s g dei st t cs a ba,t c tf t te riil j sl do
n ppl n hee ui lne o he a e t r he our mds ha xecstg t cc n
ui i
overt sdecl at acton i appr i e.Fi s , igm l si er i ha ng t pa i zatis
hi
ar ory i s
oprat
r t V t ' ' nt est n vi he rtcll s ues
a'
r sed i t sacdon deci i' sat colt i nots fci l com pelng t f vorabsendon. A fer
ai n hi
ded t t e z t s
l
ufi enty
li o a
t
t

t oughl re ewi t ar e s,t courtdoesnotbeleve t t pat 'diput pr ent
hor
y vi ng he gum nt he
i hat he des s es es

unstldorovel c mplxque donsofsaelw.Se i a 3 (e rlc uts da ti t y
ete
ty o e s
tt a
e i t 78 fdea ot houl bsnn f
onl
whe t q tonsofsae1w ivove aedifc tc e oruns tld' .
n he uesi
tt a n l d r fiul, omplx,
ete '
)

S c j ca e onomyweghsonfvorofe t ii j iditonove t sdelrtr
e ond,udiil c
i
a
xecsng urs ci
t hi caao y
a
cdon. I e l tng e l i nc co e ns t cou tprm a l f us son ' he he t que donsi
n vaua i fk e y nc r , he r i rl oc e
'
y
f t r he s
w
n
cont
rovet y bet n t par t t f alstt..can beterbe s ted i t pt
s
wee he des o he eder ti .
t
etl n he oceedi t a
ngs hat re

ara pe lngi t saec z '1 ( i Brlbatv. e sI . ofAm.316U. 491
ledy nfi n he tt out' d.quotng il r Exc s ns Co.
,
S. ,
4 (9 ).Hee Sc tdaei notapat t t saec tlwstta i i unceri is
95 1 42) r , ots l s
ry o he tt our a ti nd t s la ft
i er
nt vendon i t acton i possbl att ssage. Even i i erventon w e pos i e,t cont act
n hat i s
i e hi t
f nt
i
re sbl he
t
diput atcent s a i t scour ar i dent lt t t tcl m sadvanced i s at cour . W hie
s es
er t ge n hi
t e nci a o he or ai
n te
t
l
r at t tvo diput r s se tat ques i of1w and f tand cons i i t acdonsi o
el ed, he a
s es aie pa e
tons a
ac
oldatng he
nt
one woul notai efi entres uton ofeiherm ater
d
d fci
ol i
t
t .

Thid,e a e ntoflga a fcua quesi bewe nt t lwstt i notofmao
r ntnglme
e l nd a t l tons t e he wo a tis s
jr
concer Thebul ofScots e' com pl ntr sesques
n.
k
t dal s
ai ai
dons oflw r di cont act
a egar ng
t

itmr tt n.S eAESCo . . ta fs l s Co, 8 Va 6 9 6 6 1 , 2 SE.d5 2 5 5 (0 2
ne eai e
o
m v Se d at n . .2 3 . 0 , 1 -7 7 5 . 2 3 , 3 2 1 )
rg nl t alg donsi t c anta t pr ii oft i urnc polc aet be
tq y he le a
n he ompli nd he ovsons he ns a e iy t o
cons de ed i decci w het t e i a dut on t par oft i ur t def and i
i r n ilng
her her s
y
he t he ns er o end
ndem niy
f

4 teFo rhCicz h sn td,flesc o o Na tusn ovn tea p l t sa d r so rve wa o er ldby
Ash ut rlt a oe fth e é n f ui iv lig h p el e tn ad f e iw s v rue
i
l
l
a
teS p e Co ri Wio v S v nF l Co.5 5U,. 7 1 5SCt2 3 , 3 L.d2 2 4(9 5.Ho v rte
h u rme utn l n . e e al , 1 S 27 , 1 . . 1 7 1 2 E .d 1 1 9) we e,h
t
s
fcor aécltdwhc g ietecsrc c ut e ecs o dsrt ni ad caao jd me t c nrman
a t s r uae ih ad h l t t o r' x rie f icei n elrtc u g n ado e i
ii
s
o
a pia l. si La esMu.n . . . o el Te So t Kru LLP, 5 F. px6 8 6 9(0 9.
p l be' lt
c ' m.
r tI sCo v Antn l r tu & a s
i
3 5 Ap ' 9 , 9 2 0 )

t i urd'.W hae tis soffc t tma berie byt pate' ieagu nt ae
he ns e '
)
tve sue a t ha y as d he risnotc r me s t
unlkel t ha a s t ilefecton t unde l ' g l ui.
i y o ve ubsanta f
he
rym aws t
Las l not ng i cat t Scots e fl ttsszti t guie of<procedlr f ng.'
ty, hi ndi es hat
t dal ted li li n he s
t
zal enci '

D iput bet
s es ween an i ur and isi ur overt ext oft i ur scover at ofe
ns er
t ns ed
he ent he ns ed'
age e t n
s ted i decl at y actonsbecaus t ar pari a l appropra e f eaty r udon,s
etl n
ar or i
e hey e tculty
i t or l esol
ee
N autl .15 F. at380,and s i t stz i here. The a ence ofpr
ius
3d
uch s he iaaton
bs
ocedur gam es ans p i
al
m hi s

f t rsppore byt fc t nopat ha objce t t c tsjtiditonove t smatr
urhe u td he a that
ry s e td o he our' trs ci
r hi te.
Fort e r ons t cour w ilnotabs nl fom hearng t scas
hes eas , he
t l
t' r
n
i hi e.
11
1,

Thec tno t nst Sc tdaesmotonf j
our w ut o ots l' i orudgme ont pla n .Rul 1 c
nt he e digs e 2()
pr de t ttafe t pla ngsaecosd bute zye hnott dea til apa t ma
ovi s ha d jtr he e li r l e
l
al noug
o ly ra
ry y

mo efrjd me t n tepe dn s'Fe . Ci P. 2c.Hee t pla ig aen t ls d
v o u g n o h la ig . d R. v. 1 () r,he e dn s t o co e
'
be a e de e ntM a sha notfl d a a we t S ot s l ' c pli a no pa t ha
c us f nda
nge s
te n ns t o c t da es om a nt nd
ry s

rquese t tdefulj me bee ee a i thi Theeor,atme unde Rul 1 c i not
e td ha a tudg nt ntrd gans m. rf e e dy t e 2() s
a ia e.Se Doev. lt Sae , 9F.d 1 58,1 ( h Ci. )(t 'motonf
valbl e
Uried tts 41 3 0 061 9t t2005 f s i or
Doe
j
udgme ont pla i wa fldbeor t govenme flda a we. codi y, '
nt he e dngs s te f e he r nt le n ns r Ac r ngl Does
motonwa prmaur a s ul ha be ndele ';
i
s e t e nd ho d ve e tid.) Dunn- s v.PM ora ChaeBa
'
Maon .
I
g n s nk

Na. sn 1 - 1 4 9 2 3W L 4 8 6 6 a + ( D. c Au . 3 2 1 )(e yn 1 ()
tAs', 1CV- 3 1 , 01
0 4 7 , t 1 E. Mih. g 1 , 0 3 d n ig 2c
motonwheeoneoftvodee nt ha notye fldar ponsvepla ng ; z lv.S r Le
i
r
a fnda s d
t te es i e di ) Miel aa e

Lp -CI A.2: CV12 2 WL 1 05 a * ( D. .('nt sc s,t dee ntha y t
zp. V. 05
,
9, 005
668 6, t 2 E. Va) tI hi ae he fnda s e
t fl a a we t t pbi ifsc anta t r fr t pla ngsaenotcos d.) ald,158
o le n ns t o he ntf ompli , nd heeo e he e di r
l e ', f'
'
F. x424( hCi. 05 ; a Ove Bulv. eu ofI a Afar, F.S 36 367
App'
4t r20 ) Stnds r l Bura
ndin fis 442 upp. 0,

(3. o .19 )( r mul edee nt ha notf da west pli fsc antt c ur
1 M nt 77 whee dpl fnda s d ze ns t o andf ompli he o t
de e a1 c modona prmaut) s eas 5 ChalsAlnW rg & ArhurR. le, dea
nid 2()
s e t e; e lo C re a iht t
Milr Fe rl

Prciea Pr d ej1 (de 20 )(fl pr tc us f t pli fi ac ei
a tc nd oce ur 367 3 d. 04 trlhe ope ot e or he andf n as n
whih t defnda fist a we i t mo f adea tj gme unde Rul 55rt rt n
c he e nt al o ns r s o ve or ful ud nt r e ahe ha
se aj
e k udgme ont plalngs'.
nt he e ti .)
'
Gi n t pr d a pos't oft c s, e1 c doe notpr dea a nuef t
ve he oce url t e he ae Rul 2() s
u
ovi n ve or he
courtt reac t m e isoft diput A ss
o
h he tt
he s e.
uch,t cour wileval e aloft a gum ent r s
he
t l
uat l
he r
s aied

i c n e t nwiht Rue1 c mo na t es mmayjd me tsa e
n o n ci t he l 2() éo t h u r u g n tg .
o
I .
V

Fott s r aons Sc tdaesmodonf j me ont pla ngsi DEN I
he e e s , ots l'
oz udg nt he e di s
ED.
A n appt i e O r wilbe e er
oprat der l
nt ed.

E te: L' -u- - fj
ne d s- pq t
r
l

4/- -2.,
. #/
,
Mi
chaelF.U t ki
bans

Unie SttsDitit udge
td ae src l