Rojas v. Colvin

Filing 22

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 09/29/2014. (ssm)

CLERK' OFFI U. DI COURT
S
CE S. ST.
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

I THE UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI O F V I
CT
RGW I
A
ROA N OK E D I I ON
V SI

SEF 29 2 1
29
J I c DU
ULA

B
Y:

J
ESSI PA GA N S R OJ S,
E
A

. F
c! k
k

' 6J
f

ceKj
uR

Ci lA c i N o. 7: 3CV 00353
vi ton
1

Pl n if
aitf,

M EM O RANDUM O PI ON
NI
CA RO LY N W .COLV I ,Actng
N
i
Co m i s onerofSoc a Se urt
m si
i l c iy,

By:

.

H o Gl n E.Conr d
n. e
a
Chi U nied St t D i t i tJ e
ef t
a es sr c udg

Def nda .
e nt

Pli ifha fl t sa ton c le ng t fnalde son oft Com misone ofSoc a
a ntf s ied hi c i hal ngi he i
cii
he
si r
il
Se urt de ng pl ntf scai f rape i ofdia lt and di a lt i ur ebe ft unde
c iy nyi ai if l m o
rod
s biiy
s biiy ns anc ne is
r

t SocilSec iy Ac,asa nde 42 U. C.jj41 i and423. J iditon oft sc ti
he
a urt t me d,
S.
6()
urs ci
hi our s

purua t j205()ofheAc, U. C. 405( .Thi co t rviw i lmie t adeenni to
s nto
g t t42 S. j g) s ur' e e s i td o t nain
s
ast whe he t r i s t nta e d et s
o
t r he e s ubsa il vi enc o uppor t Comm isone ' concuso t tpl ntf
t he
s i rs
l i n ha ai if
f iedt mee t r quieme sf e ilmen obe ft unde heAc .I s hs t nta e de
al o
the e r nt or ntte tt neis
rt
t f uc ubsa i l vi nce
e ss t fna de son oft Comm isone m us beafi med.Lawsv. e ez e, F. 640
xit, he i l cii
he
si r t
tr
Celbr z 368 2d

(t Ci.1 . Sttd brel s tnta e de ehasbe n dei a s h rlva e de ,
4h r 966) ae ify, ubsa il vi nc
e tned s uc ee nt vi nce
c i rng t r c d as a whol a m i be f und a qua e t s
onsde i he e or
e, s ght
o
de t o uppor a c uson by a
t oncl i

ras bl mi Ii r onv.Peaes 40 U. 389,401( 971.
e ona e nd. tchads
rl , 2 S.
1 )

Thep an if J si Pa a Ro a , sb r o F br ay5 1 4 W hl M r . j sdi n t
litf,e se g ns j s wa o n n e u r , 98 . ie sRoa d o
co plt hi s hool s l trea ne aGED.Pli ifha wor prma iy a a a i sr tve
m e e gh c , he ae r d
antf s ked i rl s n dm nita i
as i t nt f a door m a a t e . The A dm i sr tve La J
s s a or
nuf c ur r
ni ta i
w udge not d t t as pe f m ed by
e ha ,
r or

pli ift swor r es tmesr rdme um e ri ( 21.Appae l M r. j sls
antf,hi k ol omei equie di xe ton. TR )
rnty, sRoa at
w or
ked o a r gul a s t i d bas s i 2009. On D e em be 1 2009,pl i if fl d a
n e ar nd us a ne
i n
c
r 4,
a nt f ie n

a p iainf rap ro o ds b lya ds blt is rn eb n ft.Mr . j salg dt a s e
p lc to o e id f ia ii nd ia ii n u a c e eis s Ro a le e h t h
t
y
be m e di a ed f a l f nns of s t nta ga nf em pl ym e on Fe ua y 9,2009,due t
ca
s bl or 1 o
ubs a i l i ul
o nt
br r
o

fbr
i omya g a, nxit
l i a e ypani a t c , nda tlii.Shenow m ant i t ts ha r m ane dia e
c ta ks a rlrts
i a ns ha he s e i d s bl d

t teprs n tme Th r c r rv ast t r. j sme tei u e sausr q ie n so t e
o h e e t i . e e o d e e l ha M s Roa t h ns rd tt e urme t f h
Ac tr u htes c n q a tro 2 0 b t t h ra tr Se g n r l , 2U. C. j41 ()a d
t h o g h e o d u re f 01 , u no t ee fe . e e eal 4 S. j 6 i n
y
423() Cons nty, antf i e il t apei ofdia lt a dia lt i ur nc be t
a.
eque l pli if s ntted o rod
sbiiy nd sbiiy ns a e neks
onl i s hasesa ihedt ts bec m edia e f a l or sofs t ta gai ule oy e ,
y f he
t bls ha he a
s bl d or l f m
ubsan i l nf mpl m nt

wihi t mea ngoft Actonorbe oeJ 30,201 Seege r ly, U. C.jj423( .
t n he ni
he ,
f r une
0.
ne al 42 S.
a)
Pli ifs c am wa de ed upon i talc i er ton a r onsde ai
antf l i
s ni
nii onsd ai nd ec i r ton. She t n
he

r se a rceveda7qnovohe rngandrviw befr a Admi sr i La J
eque td nd e i
ai
ee
oe n
nitatve w udge.l a
n n

o no d tdAp i2 , 01 ,h La J g as d tr n dt a Mr . j swa n t ia ld Th
piin ae rl 6 2 2 t e w ud e lo eemie h t sRoa s o ds b e . e
La l
w ùdgef
oundt t ai ifs f r fo s ve ei ime s i l ngl ba s nepa sdef t
ha pl ntf ufe ed r m e r mpar nt,nc udi um r pi r ec,

fbr li he dac ,l ttoc ntrc burii,se p dit ba e,a a ey. ( 1 .
i omyaga, a hes ef r ha ei sts le sur nc nd nxit TR 5)
Ne rhel s t La J
ve t es , he w udge nze t t a a 1r l va tm e ,pl ntf r t i r i lf tona
ld ha , t l e e nt i s ai if e aned esdua unc i l

c pa iyt p ro al tdrn eo lg t x rin l ciiy Th La J d ea s se M r. j s
a ct o e fnn i e a g fih e e t a a tvt . e w u g se s d s Ro a '
mi
o
r i
esdualf nc i lc pa iy as f l s
u tona a c t
olow :

Afe ca e ulconsde a i oft e ier c d,he unde sgne fndst t t oug
tr r f
i r ton he ntr e or t
r i d i ha , hr h
t da e l s i ur d,t cl i a ha t r s dua f ncto lc pa iy t pe f m
he t a t ns e he a m nt d he e i l u i na a c t o r or

lghtwor a dei di 20CFR 404.567( ,wiht f l ng e e ins The
i
k s fne n
1 b) t he olowi xc pto .
cli ntr quiedt optont at r t postonbewe nsti a sandi a las
a ma e r he i o le na e ii
t e itng nd t ng t e t
eve y30 mi es Shec d notha e
r
nut .
oul
ve xpos et haz r .Shec d onl pe f
ur o a ds
oul y ronn
oc sonalci ng,balnc ng,soopi c ouc ng,cr wlng a kneei She
ca i
lmbi
a i t ng, r hi
a i nd
lng.
nee d t a d c en r t d e
de o voi onc ta e xpos et e s i noie a e e svevi a i
ur o xce sve s nd xc s i br ton.
Shec dnotpe f compl xt s , pe f pr ton r t orpa wor wih
oul
ronn
e a ks or ronn oduc i a e
ce k t
sti pr
rct oducton s andar Due t anxi t w ih pani atacks she needed t avoi
i t
ds.
o
ey t
c t ,
o
d
cr ds.
ow

( 1 - 9 . Gie s c a rsd a f ci n lc p ct,a d a trc n i ei tsi n fo a
TR 8 1 ) v n u h e iu l t to a a a i n fe o sd rng e tmo y r m
m
y
voc tona e l t Law J
a i l xpet he
udgede e m i dt tpl i ifr t i d s fcen f tona ca ciyt
t r ne ha antf e ane ufi i t unc i l pa t o
r um t he pa tr e
et
o r s elvantwor as a a nita i as it . Acc di y,t La J
k
n dmi sr tve ssant
or ngl he w udge

utmaeyc n ld dta Mr . j swa n td sbldo o b f r J n 3 , 01 , ndta s ei
li tl o cu e h t s Roa s o ia e n r e o e u e 0 2 0 a h t h s

n t n ildt apeido d sbit o d s bl yisza c b neis Se 20C. R. 4 4.5 0 9.
o e tte o ro f ia l y r ia ii n t n e e tt. e
i
t r
F. j 0 1 2 4
The Law J
udge' o ni w a ado e as t fnalde i i of t Com m i s one by t Soci l
s pi on s pt d
he i
c s on
he
si r
he
a

Se urt Adm i sr ton' Appe s Co mcl Ha ng e use al val bl a i sr tve
c iy
nita i s
al t i.
vi xha t d 1a ia e dm nita i

r me e , s Ro a ha n w a pe ldt t sc u t
e dis Mr . j s s o p ae o hi o r.
W hie pli if ma be dia e f r c ran f ms of e o e ,t c u al f t
l antf
y
s bld o e ti or
mpl ym nt he r ci acual
deer i toni whe he pl i ifwa dia e f a1f r sofs t nta ganf e oy e .See
t m na i s t r antf s s bl d or 1 o m
ubsa i l i ul mpl m nt

4 U. C. 4 3 d ( ) Th r aef u ee n so p o f ihmu t ec n iee i ma i gs c
2 S. j 2 ( )2 . ee r o r lme t f r o whc s b o sd r d n k n u h
a a ayss Th s ee nsa es mmaie a flo : ()o j ci eme ia fcsa d ciia
n n l i. e e lme t r u rz d s o lws 1 be tv dc l a t n lnc l

fn i s ( )h o i o sa dc n l ins fr ai gp y iin ;3 s b e tv e ie eo p y ia
i dng ;2 t e pnin n o cuso o te tn h sca s ( ) u j cie vd nc f h sc l
maniesainsofi ime s asde ci dtzoughacama ' t tmony'a ( t cli nts
f tto
mpar nt, s rbe lr
li nts esi , nd 4) he ama '
e ton, tona hit y,esdua s ls a a Vie v. nc 438F. 11 11 60( h
ducai vocai l sor r i l kil, nd ge. tk Fi h,
2d 57, 59- 4t
Ci.1 ) Unde woodv.Ri c f 298F. 850,851( hCi.1 .
r 971;
r
biof,
2d
4t r 962)
Afer a r e oft r c d i t s c e,t c ti c ta ne t c l t tt
t
eviw
he e or n hi as he our s onsr i d o oncude ha he

Co sine' fna d cso i s p o tdb s b tnil v d n e M r. j sh ss fe e fo
mmiso rs i l e iin s u p re y u sa ta e i e c . s Ro a a u fr d r m
a ba k pr e f ma y r . I 2008,a x-a was s i t r vea fr t de e f wa d
c oblm or ny ea s n
n ry
ad o e l is gr e or r
diplce tof15 on S1 wih pr bl pa s de e t ofL5. She hasalo be n teaed f l f
s a men
.
,
t oba e r f c s
s e r t or e t
t oc nt rc bur ii . W hie t s c
r ha e i
s ts
l he e ondii nsha c us d pl i ifm uc di c f t t m e c
to
ve a e a ntf
h s om or , he di al

r c d c im st tt s m us ul ke eal fiuli di no c tt eorc rbut t a ove al
e or ontr ha he e
c os l t difc tes d t onsiut
onti e o n r l

ds blt Ho v rM r. j sas s fee fo fb o aga a wel s eae h a a h s se p
ia ii
y. we e, sRoa lo u frd r m i r my li, s la rltd e d c e ,le
dsu b n e a d a xey Mr . j sh sb e te tdf rti c n ii nb Dr J s p Le r a
it r a c , n n it . s Ro a a e n r ae o h s o d to y . o e h mme ,
r um a ol s ,w ho di nos tbr ya gi f t tr ttm e o M a 13,
he t ogit
ag ed i om l a or he i s i n y
2009. Dr Le m e has
. m r

s e M r. j so s v rlo c so sn et eiiil ig oss M ac 2 20 2, . mme
e n s Ro a n e ea c a ins ic h nta da n i.On rh 2, 1 Dr Le r
s
ubmit an as es me of pli ifs physca a lt t do wo k-ea e aci te . St t
ted
s s nt
antf
i l biiy o
r r lt d tvii s
aed

s c i cl,her e mao o itp o u e fn i g whihidiaeta Mr . j si tt l dia ld
u cn ty t h u tl gs r d c d id n s c n c t h t s Ro a s oal s be
y
duet pana ftgue.( 646- .Dr Le rs ciialyi c tdt tpl ntf sc ton
o i nd ai
TR
49) . mme pe fc l ndiae ha ai if ondii
ha e se a t s me lve ofs ve iy snc a l s Fe u y 9,2009,t pli if salege
d xit d t he a e l e rt i e t ea t br ar
he antf
l d

dia lt ons tdae.( 649)
s biiy e t TR
.
The Adm i sr tve La J
nita i
w udge de e mi d t ac or Dr Lemm e ' m e c la s s t
t r ne o c d .
r s di a s es men

diteweg t' ( 2 ) Th La J g n tdt tDr Le ro l s w M r. jso afw
ttl i h . TR 0 . e w ud e o e ha . mme ny a s Roa n e
l
'
oc aso prort t t nni ton o i ur d saus TheLa J e o e ve t tDr Le me '
c i ns i o he e na i f ns e tt .
w udg bs r d ha . m r s
ci ca not si hee ri rte t e s sonsdono e l c s ve ea de lttngs
lni l e nt a le r am nt es i
tr fe t e r nd biiai ympt s M or
om . e
t li y, heLa J
e lngl t
w udge c r d l not t tphys c lexa i tonsco pl t by e e ge y r
or e y ed ha
ia
m na i
m e ed
m r nc oom

p y iins u t eo ea di daeyatrJ n 3 , 01 ,e e ldu rmrk b eciia Gn i s
h sca j s b f r n mme itl fe u e 0 2 0 rv ae n e a l l c l dng
n
a s pt m a ol
nd ym o t ogy.

Thecour mus a r t t heLa J
t t g ee ha t
w udge' a s s m e i co itnt
s s e s nt s nsse whht m edial vi e
he
c e denc
i t sea e.Ot rt n f rDr Le me ' c yptc c
n hi s
he ha o . m r s r i omm e t i t lt rmedi las e s e , t r
n s n he a e
ca s s m nt he e

i smpyn e ie c whc s p o t ten to t a M r. j sha be o t tl d sbldo o
s i l o vd n e ih u p rs h oi n h t s Ro a d c me o al ia e n r
y
be or J 30,201
f e une
0.
I den ng pl ntf sa i ton, he La J e al o r i d on t s i ony fom avoca i l
n yi
ai if pplca i t
w udg s ele
e tm
r
tona
e r .TheLa J
xpe t
w udgepos d a hypo he i al
e
t tc quesi whi h i l
ton c nc uded t c bi t on ofe r i l
he om na i
xe tona

a nonexe tona i panne s r te t d i t La J e' fndi as t r i ua f tonal
nd
ri l m i nt el c e n he w udg s i ngs o esd l unc i
ca ciy.I r s ns t voc tonal xpe t es ii t tpl ntf c d ha be n e
pa t n e po e, he a i e r t tted ha ai if oul ve e xpec e t w or
td o
k

i h rp sj ba a a miitaiea ssa te e a s migta s rq ie at i sa do to .
n e a t o s n d n srtv sitn , v n su n h t he e u rd k t tn p in'
s/
'
( 5153) TheAdmi srtveLaw J r ogni dt tpl ntf st tmonys
TR - .
nitai
udge ec ze ha ai if esi
uggese t t
td ha
s meofhe pas wor r quie medi exe ton.( 52) l r pons t voc tonal xpe t t
o
r t k e rd
um ri TR . n es e,he ai e r noed

ta s meo fc j b d n t e ur tes melve o p y ia a tvi , n t a p an ifc udh v
h t o fie o s o o r q ie h a e l f h sc l ci t a d h t litf o l a e
y
be e cedt pef m s hwor onas ti ba i.( 5 53) I a a st t c tha
en xpe t o ror uc
k
usaned ss TR 2- . t ppe r o he our t t
t e r' e l ton oft voca i lf c or ,a t a s
he xpe ts vaua i
he
tona a t s nd he s umpto unde whih t e r
i ns
r c he xpe t
delber t a ebot r s bl a c it ntwiht e de ei t c e. Thec tc ude
i aed, r h ea ona e nd onsse
t he vi nc n he as
our oncl s
t tt La J
ha he w udge pr ry r le on t voc tonale r ' t s i ony i de e m i ng t M r .
ope l e i d
he a i
xpe ts e tm
n t r ni hat s

Roa rtie s fi in f n to a c p ct t pef r p s r lv n wo ka al i sp irt t e
j s ean d u tce t u cin l a a iy o ro m a t ee a t r t ltme ro o h
t r na i ofi ur sa usl I f l t tt Law J
e mi ton
ns ed t t . t olows ha he
udge' opi on denyi entte e i
s ni
ng ilm nt s
s
uppo td by s t nta e de e. Ac or ngl t tna de son oft Comm isone mus be
re
ubsa i l vi nc
c di y, he i l cii
he
si r
t
a fr e
f im d.

On a alt t sco t pl i ife
ppe o hi ur, antf mpha i e t tDr Le me s cik a l de e mi d t t
sz s ha . m r pe t ly t r ne ha
pli ifsfbr
a ntf i omya g aha r a hedadi a i ofs ve iym i t t tr nai n ofi ur saus
li d e c
s blng e rt or o he e mi to
ns ed t t .

Mr . jsn ts ha DrLe r sab adc riidr e maoo it omo ie rg lr dc l
sRo a o e t t . mme i o r etfe h u t lg swh vd d e u a me ia
te t nt t e t ngt weg t be a c de t hi o ni unde 20 C. R.j404. 27.
r ame , hus nhawi he iht o c or d o s pi on
r
F.
15
Howe ,a outi d a
ver s lne bove,t cou tbei vest tt La J
he r le
ha he w udge s r s ng as r ga ds Dr
' ea oni
e r
.
Le e ' opi oni f l c it wiht me c lr c d.Si y sae durnghi ofk eviis
mm rs ni s uly onssent t he di a e or
mpl t td, i s t
st

1l i now wel stldt t i det r i ng whe heracl i tca pe f m pas r l va w o k a t f urh se
ts
l e te ha , n e m ni
t
a man n r or
t e e nt r t he o t t p

o tesq e ta dsblya l i,tsa po raet c nsd rh rq ie nso te o a ii g n r l p rome
fh e u nil ia ii nayss ii p rp it o o ie te e urme t fh j b s ts e eal efr d
t
y
i ten to a e o o , rh ata rq le nso tep riuaj bwhc h cama t r vo sypef n d. o il
n h aln lc n my o te cu le urme t fh atc lro ihte li n p e iu l ro ne S ca
S c rt Rui 8 - ; a sv. ae 6 F.d 1 0 ,1 0 (t Ci.1 9 )
e u i l 261 P s Ch tr 5 3 2 0 2 7 4h r 9 5 .
v nz

wihMr . j si M a , uy a dNo e e o 2 0 , . mme d dn trp r a y sg iia t
t s Roa n y J l, n v mb r f 0 9 Dr Le r i o e o t n infc n
phys c l i ia i , pienotngt nde
i a lm t tons des t i e rpoi t co i t nt ih t br ya gi s nd o e.Att i e
n s ns s e w t i om l a y r m
hetm

oft e m i ton on J y 1 2009,Dr Le e r l t t tpl ntf sc ton wasi pr d.
he xa na i
ul 4,
. mm r e aed ha ai if ondii
m ove

( 297) W hiepl nifsc ant ha wore dbyt tmeofe mi tononNove r1
TR
. l aitf ompli s d s ne he i
xa nai
mbe 6,

2 0 DrLe rflt a M r. j smih b n f fo srthige e cs s ( 2 4 .Ont a
0 9, . mme et h t s Ro a g t e ei r m tec n x r ie . TR 9 )
t
ht
smed y ter u t lg s n tdt a plitf d cie tn e pon ij ci n . TR 2 4 .
a a ,h he maoo it oe h t anif e l d e d r it ne to s ( 9 )
n
l t scon e , he c t s be i vest tt Adm i sr tve La J
n hi
t xt t our al o le
ha he
ni t a i
w udge r as bl r le
e ona y e i d

o h ptle r e c r o rpo t h twee c mp ee j s f r a d i daey a tr
n os ia meg n y o m e rst a r o ltd u tbeo e n mme it l fe
tr n to o is rd sau .Fo e a l, e te t g M r. j sf rfu-i es mp o o
emiain f n u e tt s r x mpe wh n rai
n s Roa o l lk y t ms n
M a c 5,201 Dr Ka lH.Klt i s ii a l not t tpli ifwa C gai f myal as
rh
0, . r
e zng pectc ly ed ha antf s l tve or
ne
gi ,

n c p i, a kpan,o n p i a d fls' ( 3 2 . M r. j sas s u h e r e c r o
e k an b c i j i t an, n al. TR 3 ) s Ro a lo o g t meg n y o m
'
team e on Se e be 28,201 On t toc son,s wa f
r t nt
ptm r
0.
ha ca i he s ound t pos e sanonna r ngeof
o ss
la

motonwih none ol ials oms ( 375)
i t
ur ogc ympt . TR
.
The c tge r ly be ives t tr pors fom teai m e ca s c a it ,s h as Dr
our ne al le
ha e t r
r tng di l pe i lss uc
.
Le m e , e ve y c pe lng. How e r i t sc e,Dr Le m e ' c uc alopi on w a r nde ed
m r ar r om li
ve , n hi as
. m rs r i
ni
se r

m a mont afe t t r i tonofpl ntf si tr d sa us W hiet Adm i sr tveLa l
ny
hs tr he e m na i
ai if nsle tt .
l he
nita i
w udge

ce ryrc nie t a s c a o i o c udr lt b c ot epeidi wh c pan if tle j y d
la l e og z d h t u h n pnin o l eae a kt h ro n ih litf sil no e
i ur dsaus seJ hns v.Ba nha q43 F. 650( h Ci. ) W ool i ev.Bowen,81
ns e tt , e o on
r r 4 3d
4t r 2005 '
,
drdc
6
F. 1 1 ( h Ci.1 7) a M ooev.Fi h,41 F. 1 1 ( hCi.1 4t La
2d 57, 60 4t r 98 ; nd r
nc 8 2d 224, 226 4t r 969) he w
J
udge r i on e e nt fom Dr Le e ' ea le r pors a we la obs r a i by ot r
eled
l me s r
. mm rs ri r e t, s l s e v tons
he

e mi ng physca ,i c l ng t tMr.Ro a f l t me tt bur n i etbls ng
xa ni
iins n oncudi ha s j s aied o e he de n sa ihi
di a lt o o be or J 30, 0. A lho h t co tm i ha r ol d t c l c i t
s biiy n r f e une 201
t ug he ur ght ve es ve he ont i t n he

e de dif r l t c 'm us c l t tt ei s t nta e de et s ppo tt La
vi nce fe enty, he oul
t t onc ude ha her s ubsa i l vi nc o u r he w
J e' diposton.
udg s s ii

M r. j sas c n e d ta t eLa J d efi dt a c r p o rweg tt pan ifs
s Ro a lo o tn s h t h w u g al o c o d r pe ih o litf
e
t tm ony,a sa e e sgi n by he hus nd,a r ga ds he c pa t f s t nta ganf
esi
nd tt m nt ve
r ba
s e r
r a ciy or ubsa i l i ul
aci t W iho quesi pl i ifst si
tviy. t ut
ton, antf e tmonya t a i sr tvehe rng, nd sa e
t he dm nita i
a i a t t ment gi n
s ve

b h r s a di a a utt id p r f n to rp r,ndc t t a M r. j si s v r l i ard.
y e hu b n n n d l,hr - a t u ci n e o ti iae h t s Ro a s e eey mp ie
Ho v r imu t g i b n tdt a t erpo tfo t ee r e c r o p ysca , e e ae j s
we e ,t s a an e o e h th e rs r m h meg n y o m h iinsg n rtd u t
b f r a d a trtr n to o is rd saus s g e tt a M r.Roa dd no e p re c a y
eo e n fe emi ai n f n u e tt , u g s h t s j s i t x ein e n
s gnii a m us ul ke e al di t e s The e m e ca o e va i obvi l t k pl ntf s
i f c nt
c os l t
sr s .
s
di l bs r tons
ousy oo
ai if

s be t c mplit it a c u t Fo t a matrtec u t le e ta p an ifstsi n , n
u j ci o ans n o c o n . r h t te ,h o rbeiv s h t litf e tmo y a d
ve
he hus nd' sa e e s a e i ons sen wih t c
r ba s tt m nt, r nc it t t he ompl i sgi t Dr Le e a t tm eof
ant ven o . mm r t he i

h ro fc viis M o e v r a n tdb Dr Le r Mr . j sdd n t h o et p ru a1h
e fie st. ro e , s o e y . mme, s Roa i o c o s o u s e l te
r m e a m ea ur sof e e by t r um a ol s a t tm e oft N ove be 2009 of i e vi i. l
e di l s e f r d he he t ogi t t he i
he
m r
fc s t n
s t t c tf nds s t i e de e t s
hor , he our i
ubsantal vi nc o uppor t La J
t he w udge' r ol i oft c e biiy
s es uton he r di lt
i s i pl i i f sc e.
s ues n a nt f as

l afi ng t tnalde son oft Comm isone ,t c tdoesnots es t tM r .
n tnni he i
cii
he
s i r he our
ugg t ha s

Roa i fe o al i ds o o ta xit, ndse p e s e s l e d,h me ia r c r c nfnns
j s s re f lpan, ic mfr, n ey a le lsn s. nd e t e dc le o d o i
t tpl i ifs f r fom a s rouscondii w hi h c n bee
ha a ntf uf e s r
ei
ton c a
xpec e t pr
t d o oduc s g tc tphys ca
e i nii an
i l

a emotona c ans l ed,ta r t tM r. j sma now s f rfom adia i lve
nd
i l omplit. nde i ppeas ha sRoa y
ufe r
s blng e l
offbr
i omya g a.Howe r a t t pe i pro t tr na i ofi ur d saus t c t le s
li
ve , s o he rod i r o e mi ton ns e t t , he our be ive
t t t m e c l r co d doe not doc e t e s e e o ph i a pr e s w hi h co d be
ha he di a e r
s
um nt he xit ne f ys c l obl m
c
ul
e
xpeded t pr
o oduc t a l di a i phys c a e o i
e ot ly s blng
i al nd m tonaldi c f r .l i w e ls t l d t tt
s om o t t s l e te ha he

ia lt t d wo kwih u a ys b e v ds o o t o sn to is l r n e acama tttl
n bii o o r t o t n u j die ic mf r d e o f tef e d r li n o al
y
y
dia e Cr gv.Chae,76F. 585,594- ( h Ci.1 .l a r t t cour t tt
s bld. ai
tr
3d
95 4t r 996) t ppeas o he tha he

Ad n srtv La l d ec n ie e a1 fhes be tv fco se s n bl s p o tdb h rc r
miitaie w u g o sd r d lo t u j ci e a tr ra o a y u p re yt e e o d
i tea j d c to o p an ifscam frb n f .Id e ,hec u t eive t t h La J d e
n h du iain f litf li o e ehs n e d t o r b le s ha t e w u g

g v Mr . j stebe eh o t d u ti fn i gt a s er q ie astsa do to p irt te
a e s Ro a h n f f he o b n id n h t h e urd i tn p in ro o h
/
t r i ton of i ur d s a us I f l s t t a lf e s oft Com m i s one ' fnalde s on a e
e m na i
ns e t t . t olow ha l ac t
he
s i rs i
ci i r
s
uppor e by s t nta e de
td
ubs a i l vi nce.
A sa ge r lr e, e ol i ofc l c si t e de e i a m a t w ihi t pr nce of
ne a ul r s uton
ont i t n he vi nc s
ter t n he ovi

t Com mi sonere n i t c tmi htr s vet c lc sdif e l
he
si
ve f he our g e ol he onfit fer nty.Riha ds n v.Pe aes
c r o
rl ,

s pr;Oppel i v. nc 495F. 396( hCi.1 .Fort r s nssaed,heco ti t
u a
rhem Fi h,
2d
4t r 974)
he ea o tt t urfnds he
Com m i s one ' r s u i oft pe tne c l c s i t r c d i t s e e t be s
s i rs e ol t on
he r i nt ont i t n he e or n hi as o
uppor e by
td
s t nta e de e.A c di y, he fna de s on oft Com m i s one m us be a tnne La s
ubs a i l vi nc
cor ngl t i l cii
he
si r
t fi d. w

v. lb e z , u r .An a p o it j g n a d od rwi bee trdt sd y
Cee r z e s p a
p rprae ud me t n r e l n ee hi a .
l
TheCl r i diecedt s nd c rii d c esoft sopi ont a 1couns ofr cor
e k s r t o e e tfe opi
hi ni o 1
el e d.

DATED:Ths 41
i

dyo S pe e, 01
a f e tmb r 2 4.
I
Chi U nie St esD i ti tJ
ef t d at
sr c udge

8