Branham v. Lynchburg Adult Detention Center
Filing
8
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 09/30/2013. (kab)
D >*e: OFFI U,S. SX COURT
CE
DI
AT ROANOKE, !/
kA
FI l:
tè 1
.i
I TH E U NI
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI T C O UR T
C
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O AN O K E D I SI N
VI O
M I O N BR ANH AM ,
LT
SEPp3' : :
29 3
c
a
J A C 'ï
ULI .,
BK
DE
''
c ,.
'
....t k
Z
LER1
. <
CLERK
C A SE N O .7: 3C V 00430
1
Pl ntff
ai i ,
M EM O R AN D U M O PI I N
N O
LY N CH BUR G A D ULT D ETEN TI N
O
CEN TER ,
By: G l n E.C onr
e
ad
C hi U nied St es D i ri Judge
ef t
at
st ct
D efendant
.
M it Br n m , a V igila i a e pr ee ng pr K , t l d tls c vi rght ac i n
lon a hn
r ri nm t oc di
o
i e li i l i s to
p ls a tt 4 U. C.j 1 8 ,algng t tji o t asu e e c si f r e a ans hm a d
t u n o 2 S.
r
9 3 le i ha al fkil s d x e sve o c g i t i n
hous d hi unde haz r
e m
r a dousco tons i vi ai n ofhi c tmtona rg s Upon r vi w of
ndii , n ol to
s onsi i l i ht .
e e
t r cor t co ttndst t a ton mus be sl a iy dimis d.
he e d, he ur i hat he c i
t lmm rl s s e
Backeround
l hi c pl i a o he s i sons Br nbn a l ge t f l i s que
n s om a nt nd t r ubm s i , a m le s he olow ng e nce of
e nt on whi h he ba e hi c am s On Aug t 28,201 Br nhn was a i a e a t
ve s
c
s s s li .
us
3, n m
n nm t t he
Ly h u g Ad l Dee to Ce tr(t ej i' . Two o t esrmo d Br n a fo hsc l
nc b r ut tnin n e th al)
t
'
f r e ve a h m r m i el
k
a plc hi i Gs ain.' ( No.4,a 2. W he Br m bega ki ng hi door t
nd a ed m n û olto ' ECF
i
t )
n nnhn
n cki s ,he
ofkesor r hi t gi t m hi s s Het dt m,G - you,c a ge t m.'(d.
t r deed m o ve he s hoe . ol he t Fome nd t he ' 1 )
Theofi e st n e e e t cela s a Br nha wih mac Hesilr us d t gi t m
fc r he nt r d he l nd pr yed a m t
e.
tl ef e o ve he
hi s s A fe be ng cl e i t c a i t d c lf ha f a hot Br nhn bega t ha
s hoe . t r i
os d n he ont m na e el or l n m n m
n o ve
t o e br t ng a ki d t door a i Thi t m i es l t r a ofk e cn e t t door
r ubl ea hi nd cke he
ga n.
ry nut a e , n t r m o he
.
Br nhn tle t ned t kilhi s l . Of i e s r m ove hi f om t c l pu hi i t s pwe ,
n m lr a e
o l m e f fc r e
d m r he el, t m n he h r
a t n pl ed hi i a dif r ntc lon s ci w a c
nd he ac
m n
f e e el
ui de t h.
Ea l on Augus 28,2013,ofi e s t d Br nha t t t y ne ded t m ove hi a
ry
t
tc r ol n m ha he
e
o
m nd
pl e hi i a dif r ntc l t rs c de wa c Fi m i t lt r t y as plce a he
ac d m n
fe e e l mde uii
t h. ve nu es a e , he lo a d not r
s cde wac i ae i t c lwih Br nhn . Br nhn t eaene t kilt o he i t bu
ui i
th nm t n he el t n m
n m hr t d o l he t r nma e, t
t ofk e s l t a
he t r ef nywa The t i a e r m ane i t cel t t r al t t da a
y.
wo nm t s e i d n he l oge he l ha y nd
ove i ht na d,w ih no nm ni w a e . A r m d noo on Augus 30,201 m e a he lh s a f
m g , ke
t
ng t r
ot
n
t
3, nt l a t t f
me wih Br m a t hi of s c dewa c Hewa al d a hers
t t anha nd ook m f uii
t h.
s lowe not howe a r blne
r nd e r d
t hi housng uni.
o s
i
t
Di cussi
s
on
The co ti r qui e t di m i sany a ton orc ai fl by aprs raga ns a
ur s e r d o s s
ci
l m ied
i one
i t
g r e a e iy orofk e i t c t t r i t a ton orcl i i f i o , a i i ,
ove nm nt l ntt
t r f he our de e m nes he c i
a m s rvol us m lc ous
o fist saeacam o wh c rle ma b g a td 2 U. C. 1 5 b ( ) Tos ea
r al o tt li n ih eif y e rn e . 8 S. j 91 A()1 . kt
c us ofacin t r51 apli ifmus esa iht theha bee de i dofrghs
a e to mde 983, antf t tbls ha
s n prve i t
g r nt d by t Consiuton orl wsoft Unie St t a t tt sde i ton r s t d
ua a ee
he
tt i
a
he td aes nd ha hi prvai e ule
fo c
r m onduc c
t omm il d by ape s n a tng unde col ofsae lw .W es v. ki ,48 U.
te
ro ci
r or t t a
t At ns 7 S.
42( 9 8 . Th j i,h o l d fn a tBrn a h sn me a ad f n a t oti a to , sn t
1 8 ) e alt e n y ee d n n h m a a d s e e d n t h s cin i o
ai e s n' u j c t s t n e 1 1 8 .Prv l Re o,20 F.d8 , 0 0W L 2 5 , t*1
t ro 's b e t o uiu d r 9 3 e a v. n
p
3 3 21 2 0
0 91 a
( hCi. a 13, 00)(
4t r J n. 20 unpubls d)( i W ilv.M ihia Dep'ofStt Polc ,491U.
ihe quotng l
c an
t ae ie
S.
5 , ( 9 9 M c vv. e a e k Co cin l n e, 8 F. u p. 9 , 9 - 4( D. .
8 71 1 8 :; co Ch sp a e ae t a Ce tr 7 8 S p 8 0 8 3 9 E. Va
o
1 9 )(i dn ct ali n fo s i a dn tapes nf rp r o e o j1 3 .
9 2 fn ig i i mmu e r m ut n o
yj
ro o u p s s f 98 )
2
Be a s Brn a c n o prv i i aj 1 8 cam a ans t j i,h c u t imis sh s
c u e n h m n n t e aln
9 3 li g i the alt e o r d s se i
c mplitwi o tp eu ie pls a tt j 1 5 b ( ) a lg ly fi lu . An a p o rae
o an t u rj d c , t u n o 91 A()1 , s e al rvoo s1
h
r
p r p it
or rwilis t sda
de l s ue hi y.
The Clr i die t d t s nd c esof tls m e an l opi o a a ompanyi
ek s rce o e
opi
li
mor dtm
ni n nd cc
ng
or rt pl n if
de o aitf.
ENTER:Thi $ 0 da ofSe embe ,201
s
y
pt r 3.
Chi fUnied St t DititJ e
e
t
aes src udg
1 The c alo fndst tBr m ' c r alegatonsf lt s e a consiu i l sgnii
ourt s i ha anha s urent l i ai o tt
tt tonaly i tcant
cai a is a on a t j l Frm te cru tnc sBrnh m decie ,ot r usd ony t t
l m gant ny e t he ai. o h ic msa e a n srb s fkes e l ha
m eas e of f c neces ar t mai ai or i t f of Br
ur
or e
sy o
nt n der n he ace
anhnm ' adm it m ibehavi . See
s
ted s
or
W hily v.Ale s 47 U. 31 ,31 ( 98 CGnl t e un c sa y a wa o i lcin ofpan o
te
b r, 5 S. 2 9 1 6) o y h ne e s r nd ntn nfito
i n
prs ne s c nsiues cue a u s a p s me ' i vilton oft Eiht Ame dme )(n ena
io r o ttt r l nd nu u l unih nt' n oai
he g h
n nt it r l
q oain o te ) Smi ry b c u eBrn a d e n talg s feij a y sg i c n ijr a a
u tt s mitd. i l l, e a s a h m o s o l e ufr n int a t nuy s
o
a
e
n
i
r ul ofbei hous wih t ot s ci w ach i ef t da t sl dentdoesnotgi rs t
es t
ng
ed t he her ui de t nmat or wo ys, hi nci
ve ie o
a y c nsiuina cam r gadig p io c ndii s Se Sha a v.Smih,71 F. 1 , 1 6 ( t
n o ttto l li e r n rs n o ton . e kk
t
3d 62 6 4h
Ci.9 ) (ttng ta cam o u o ttto lprs c ndiins rquie R vie e o a s rous o
r1 95 sai h t li f nc nsiuina ion o to e r s e d nc f e i r
sr iia p ysclo e ina ij yr utngfo t c le e c ndtons'.
i tcnt h ia r moto lnur esli rm he halng d o ii '
)
3
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?