Adams v. McDonnell et al

Filing 9

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 10/30/2013. (tvt)

a p-

I THE UNI S
N
TED TATESDI CT COURT
STRI
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI I A
CT
RG M
R O A N O K E D I SI
VI ON
JERRY L.
ADAM S,
Pl ntf
ai if,

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

G OV.BOB M CDONNELL,e al,
t .

Dee
fndants.
t)

oFFI u. . l - cE : D sm
ATRoANoe ,
vA
FIED
L

02T 32 2 1
23
JULA C.
I D
BY;
DE

,

C i lA c i N o.7: 3- v- 37
vi ton
1 c 004
M EM O R AN DU M O PI O N
NI
By: Sam ue G .W is
l
l on
Unied St e Dit i Judge
t
at s s rct

J r y L. dnm s pr ee ng pr K , ie a c vi r g s c pl i , s ntt 42 U . C .
er A
, oc di
o f l d i l i ht om a nt pur ua o
S.
.

9 98 By Or e e tr dSe e e 2 , 01 ,hec u t ie tdp an ift s b t ti 1
1 3.
d r n e e ptmb r 3 2 3 t o r drce litf o u mi wi n 0
h
da fom t da eoft Or ra i t a ot f r ,a a c riid c ofpl n ifstts
ys r he t
he de n nma e cc mt o m nd e tfe opy
aitf rzt
f nd a ountsaeme f rt m ont ofM a c 201 i e a ey pr c di t flng oft
u cc
t t nt o he
h
rh
3 mm dit l e e ng he ii
he
c pl nt obt i fo t a oprae p ion ofi i lofea h prs a whih pl i ifi or
om ai , aned r m he ppr i t rs
tc a
c ion t c antf s
wa c i dtrng t tm ont
s onfned li ha
h.Pl ntf wasadvied t taf iur t c
ai if
s ha a l e o ompl woul r s ti
y
d e ul n

d s sa o t sa to wi u p eu c .Plitf s n t c u t lte fldOco e 2 2 3
imis l f hi cin t t rj die an if e t he o r a e tr e t b r , 01 ,
ho
r r ng t di sc t obt ni t i o m a i r quied a r ue t d t tt c t s nd
ega di he f uly ai ng he nf r ton e r nd eq s e ha he our e

a t e i maea c t fr dr cl t tesafa tej i ise do teplitf. Clr
noh r n t c omt o m ie t o h tf t h aln ta f h an if The ek
y
r pondedt t lte on t s
es
o he e tr he mne dae by e osng aco oft co tonal fl o dera
t
ncl i
py he ndii ly ied r
nd
poi e outt s c i on t fr tpa r m i ngpli ifofhi r ponsbiiy t obti
nt d
he e ton
he is ge e ndi
antf
s es i lt o a n
r uie doc e ai On Oc obe 3, 3 t co t e ei d a i omplt i ae a c mt
eq r d um nt ton.
t r 201 he ur r c ve n nc
e e nm t c ot
I
XPO/.
M or t n amont ha e a e a pl i ifhasf ie t c
e ha
h s l ps d, nd antf
a ld o ompl wih t de c i d
y t he s rbe

c n iins Ac od n l t ec u t imis stea to wi o tp eu iea dsrk stec s
o dto . c r i gy,h o r ds se h cin t u rj d c n tie h a e
h
fom t a tvedoc toft c t Pl i ifma r fl t cai si a s pa ae a ton onc
r he c i
ke
he our. antf y e ie he l m n e r t c i
e
pl ntf i pr pa ed t compl wih t not d c to .
ai if s e r o
y t he e ondii ns

The Clr i die t d t s ac oft sM e a lm Opi on a a co pa ng
e k s r c e o end opy hi mor ndz
ni nd c m nyi
Or rt pl i if
de o a ntf .

E ER:T i j5
NT hs .
s

dyo Ocoe 2013.
a f tbr
,

.Z
'
'
''

Unt S ae Ditit u g
id tt s src J d e