Via v. Clarke

Filing 22

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 6/12/2014. (tvt)

CL S OFFI U. . SI COUA
ERK
CE S DI
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W EST ERN DISTR I T O F V IR G I IA
C
N
R O AN O K E DI I O N
V SI

JUN 12 2 1
09

B; AC
tU )
U
D

BARRY L. A,a k/ Zayd AbdulM uham m ad,
VI / a
Ci lActon No.7: v51
vi
i
13c 3
Pet toner,
ii

M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
H A R O LD W .CLA R K E,

By:Sam ue G .W is
l
l on
U nie St e Di t c Judge
t d at s s ri t

R espondent
.

Bar L. a ak/ Za AbdulM uha d,(( a',fldt speii f ha a c pus
ry Vi, / a yd
mma t ' e hi tton or be s or
Vi )
purua t 28U. C.j225 cli ngt tRes
s nt o
S.
4, ami ha ponden wa hol nghi a Re Oni Stt
t s di m t d on ae
Prs pa thi t tor r d'r e eda ei vi ai n oft Ei h and Fourc nt
ion s s ç
cour de e ' elas t n olto
he ght
te h
Am e e s Se r we ksa trVi fld hi peii howe r t Vigi aDe rmen of
ndm nt . ve al e fe a ie s tton,
ve , he r ni pa t t

Core tons(S
rci ç
VDOC')r l s dhi Dic mi noc iui c ltrlc e nce ,he
' eea e m. s e ng ontn ng olaea ons que s t
c tc l st tVi sc am sa enow m oota dim is st m .
our onc ude ha a' l i r
nd s s e he

Vi i af me i eoft Re Oni St ePrs i Vigi a. W hie i ar e atd,
a s or r nmat he d on at ion n r ni
l nc c r e
V i fl d num e ousprs greva escl m i t V D OC w a f c ng hi t s r a s nt e
a ie
r
i on i nc
ai ng he
s or i
m o e ve e enc

l e t n wha t c t i na l i pos
ong r ha
t he our orgi ly m ed.Acc di t V i,t VDOC wa r quie t
or ng o a he
s e rd o

r e ehi by a l s Augus 6,201
elas m
t ea t
t
3.Vi c c a e t sda ebas upon a a s y memo
a alult d hi t
ed
n dvior
s ntt V i by t VD O C on Fe ua y 1 201 Tha m e o es i a ed V i s ç
e o a he
br r 4, 3.
t m
tm t
a' t
good tm e '
i '

r e edaewoul beAugus 6,201 buti ore ty sae Vi stt s tnce.Pe'' Ex.
elas t
d
t
4 nc rcl ttd a' oal ene ( trs H,

ECFNo.13) W he t VDOC fnal c rce Vi stt s ne byr uci i by 1
n he
i ly ore td a' oal e tnce ed ng t 2

CE
L

d i wie e
s tood i 'r l as t y he n
mot .
m ont 1Vi bei ve i woul lke s r ducehi tg tm e' e e e dae b t s m en mt
hs, a le d t
H o ve ,t advior me o fom t VDOC t Vi saed adif r ntgood tm er l a eda eof
we r he
s y m r he
o a tt
fee
i ee s t

Novembe 1 2013,Pe '' Ex.,ECFNo.13)whihVi cli t VDOC i e i ly
r 9,
( trs 1
- , c a ams he
ntntonal
micac aed.( No.12a 6) TheVDOC de e Vi sc ait a ex ai dt ti ha
s lult ECF
- t
nid a' ompl n s nd pl ne ha t d
pr pe l ca cul t d hi good tm e r l s da e.2
o ry l a e s
i e ea e t
A fe e us i t prs s gre
t r xha tng he i on' i vanc pr dur ,V i fl d a s a e ha spe ii
e oce es a ie
t t bea tton,

cl mi t VDOC vi a e hi Ei t a Foure nt Am e
ai ng he
olt d s gh h nd
te h
ndme rght by f ci hi t
nt i s or ng m o
s vetmeno or r d by t co t On Se e be 30,201 t Vigi a Supr me Cour
er i
t de e
he ur.
pt m r
3, he r ni
e
t

d ne Vi ' pdiina u tmeyu d rVa Co ej8. - 5 ( () Vi te peiin dt i
e id as to s n i l n e . d
016 4 A)2 . a h n t o e h s
t
c u to awrto h be sc r u , u s n t 2 U. C.j2 5 , se t gt esmecams Vi
o r f r i f a a o p s p rua to 8 S. 2 4 a s ri h a li . a
n
a kst co tt i i t t e es pori ofhi s nt nc a diec hi i e aer e e.
s he ur o nvaldae he xc s ton
s e e e nd r t s mm dit elas

( No.1a 1 Appr mael t eewee ltr onNove
ECF
t 4)
oxi t y hr
ks ae ,
mber1 201 t VDOC rl s d
9, 3,he
eea e
Vi.
a

Re ponde t n fld a moton t dim is a g ngt tVi sc am shad be om emoot
s
nt he ie
i o s s , r ui ha a' l i
c
.
Be or r i on Res
f e ulng
ponde ' moton,t c tdie t t pa test a es t a i a lt
nts i he our r ced he ri o ddr s he pplc biiy

a dra o i go To e v. a vs 5 7F.d5 3(t Ci. 0 9 , ihf u dta a i maes
n e s n n f wn s J r i, 7 3 4 4h r 2 0 )wh c o n h t n n t '
r l s on pa ol di no ne s arl r rhi ha
eea e
r e d t ce s iy ende s beaspe ii moot
tton
.
1o n M ar h 31 2011 Vi pld guit t a s ul a bat r ofaVDOC ofi e . TheW ie
c ,
ly o s a t nd te y
fc r
, a e
s
Cot y Cic tCour i Vig ni i
mt r ui
t n r i a mpos d a 1 m ont s nt nc t ti i e
e
2
h e e e ha t nt ndedt nm c ur e
o
onc r nt

t Vi sot rs nt et) butt s ntncngodermitke y satdt tiwast r n
o a' he e enc s, he e e i r
sa nl t e ha t o u
c n e uiet t oh rsn e c t)
o s c tv o he t e e tn es.
2Th VDOC t l Vi twl e ane (e tn i g o c r whc rs t i t erc lulto o a
e
od a s h n w sn e cn ) c u s ih euls n h e ac ain f n
g
o fn e ' tmec mp tto ,h prvo syp oe tdrla ed t i n lng rv ld. ( trs
fe d rs i o u ain te e iu l rj ce ee s ae s o o e ai ' Pe''
'
Ex. ECF No 13 Ea ha v s r me o Se a u ae'as sae t a çth p oe td
0,
. - ) c d io y mo, r t g l pd t, lo tts h tt l e rj ce
l
'
l
dat ar bas on t ass pton t t of enderw ilcontnue t ear good tm e att pr ent
es e ed
he um i hat he f
l
i
o n
i
he es
e ni lve and wilno ha e r goo tm et n fom t ofe ra ar s tof
ar ng e l
l t ve a ned d i ake r he f nde s e ul
m i beha or Los ofea ne good tm e,a c ng i good tm e e r i l vel ora ot re nt
s
vi .
s
r d
i
ha e n
i n n ng e , ny he ve

ta i a t t es r ieo t ttlsn e c ma c u etep o e tdd tst c n e'( e''
h t mp cs h e vc f he o a e tn e y a s h rj ce ae o ha g . P trs
'
Ex.H-,ECFNo.13)
l
-

1
l.

The c t w f ndst tbec us V i poi st no e de e ofc i ng c l t r l
our no i
ha
a e a nt o
vi nc
ontnui ola e a

c eq nc ca e by Res
ons ue es us d
ponde ' al ge m ic l ultonsa bec us Vi ha r c ve t
nts le d s a c a i
nd a e a s e ei d he
r le hei ta l s
e if niily ought Vi ' cli sa em oo .Ac r ngl t c twilg a Res
, a s am z
t co di y, he our l r nt ponde '
nts
m o i t di m i s
ton o s s .

Ge r ly,ac ebe om e mootwhe t hei s pr e e a eno l erlveo t
ne al
as c s
n t s ues es nt d r
t
ong i r he

pa tesl c a l aly cogni bl i e es i t outom e. Powe lv.M ç m a k,395 U. 48
ri a k eg l
za e ntr t n he c
'
'
l
cor c
S. 6,

496( 969) Eve i aca ewa lvea isi pton,a a t lc r ves mus e s dl i a1
1 . n f s s i t t nce i n cua onto ry t xit z ng 1
r

sa e o l iain ll sme n t a,h o g u t l iain,h Eeiine)ç t a e
tg s f i g to . st
-hi a s h tt r u ho t he i g to te p tto r mus h v
t

s fee , rb tr ae dwih a a t a ij r ta e bet t ed fn a ta lk l t b
u fr d o e h e tne t , n cu l nu y r c a l o h ee d n nd iey o e
rd e sdb afv rbl j dca de iin.' p n e v. mn ,5 3U. 1 7( 9 8 (uoig
e r se y a o a e u iil cso ' S e c r Ke a 2 S. , 1 9 ) q tn
'
Lewi v.ContnentlBa Cor , U. 472, 78( 990 ) W heet peii rss ntnc
s
i a nk o.494 S. 477- 1 ). r he ttone ' e e e

h se pie t eemu tb ç o c n r t a dc n iun ij r oh rta t en w-n e
a x rd,h r s e ç me o c ee n o tn ig nu y te h n h o e d d
s
i a ce a i orpa ol - s e E ola e a co eq nc oft co c i
nc r r ton
r e om c l t r l ns ue e' he nvi ton- m us e s i t s t
t xi t f he ui

i t bem ant i 'l TheSupr me Cour ha pr s
so
i aned. d.
'
e
t s e umedt tawr ulc i i c ci n
ha
ongf rm nal onvi to

ha c i ngc ltrlc e nc s L a 8.Bu t Supr Cour ha rf s dt e e a
s ontnui olaea ons que e . ês t
t he
eme
t s e u e o xtnd
pr s m pto ofc l tr lc eque est ot rar as s h a pa ol r a i I a l Thus
e u in
olae a ons nc o he e , uc s r e evoc ton. d. t 4.
,

wh r ap tto e d e n tc alng hso h ru d ryn c n cin s,h s i' s b itn e
ee eiin r o s o h le e i r e n e lig o vito t)t e uts u sse c
t cal rquiest tcontnui c ltrlc e nce bepr d.Se L.a 8.
ypi ly e r ha
i ng olaea ons que s
ove e d t
Be aus Vi doesnotcha lngehi underyi conki i ,t hem us de
c e a
le
s
l ng
ctons hen,
t monsr t
ta e
c i ng c l t r lc e nc s c us d by R e ponde ' a l ed m i ca c a i . Unlke t
ontnui ola e a ons que e a e
s
nt s leg
s l ul tons
i he
pettoneri Townesv.Jarvi w ho m ai ai t ,even afert VD O C r eas hi ,t
ii
n
s,
nt ned hat
t he
el ed m he

Vigi aPa ol Boa d' e rirconduc co i
r ni r e
r s a le
t ntnued t afec t l ng h ofhi pa ol,5 F. a
o f t he e t
s r e 77 3d t

3

5 , apon st noc ni igh r 3 Vi h src ie t eo j c o hsp tto : ee s .
47 Vi it o o t n a m. a a e ev d h b e t f i ei n rla e
nu
i
W ihno c i ng cola e alc e nc s Vi sha sca m sm. m oot a t c twil
t
ontnui
lt r ons que e , a' bea li
e
, nd he our l
g a Res
r nt ponde ' moton t dim is4
nts i o s s .
11
1.

Fo ter a o ssae ,h c u t rn sRepo e tsmo iny d s s.
r h e s n ttd te o r g a t s nd n ' to o imis
EN TER :June 12,2014.

I I S
X TED TATES DI CT J
STRI UDGE

3I alo a
t s ppea st tVi wa notacua l hel be
r ha a s
t ly d yond hi cour or r d r l s da ea he
s
t de e eea e t s
c pl ns Vi se bisi c t t thewa fr tr m a
om ai . a' xhi t ndi ae ha
s is e ndedt c t on Jme 1 1 and,
o usody
t 5, 990

ac or ngt t VDOC,wa sr ngattlsntnc of4 yeas 6mont ,a 32da . (
c di o he
s e vi oa e e e :
23 r,
hs nd
ys' ECF
'
No.13) TheVDOC rla e Vi onNove r19,
ee s d a
mbe 2013, afe ha ngs r e 23veas 5
or tr vi e v d
r.
m ont ,a 4 da .
hs nd
ys
4Thi i nott s t tRe po
ss
o ay ha s ndentsa lge i e i nalmicaculton ofhi çg tme'
' le d ntnto
s l ai
s çood i '

r la ed t i n c sa i i uae fo rv e t e 4 U. C. 1 8 . e Sld v. mp o
ee s ae s e e srl ns lt d r m e iw md r 2 S. j 9 3 S e a e Hn t n
y
Roa Reg' J i,407F. 243,248- ( hCi.2005 ( di t tf me deaneesr quet
ds l al
3d
49 4t r
) hol ng ha or r ti ' e s
f rij n tv r l fu d r4 U. C. 1 8 wa mo tb t st e u s f rmo eayrle ( s
o nu cie ei n e 2 S. j 9 3 s o, u hi t q e t o n tr eif wa q
e
r
notmoote nt h ( )g lbe nr e e fom J i'.
ve houg he had e elasd r a1'
)
4