Dotson v. The Commonwealth of Virginia et al

Filing 55

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 3/30/2017. (tvt)

CLERK:AT DA t.& DI 'GOURT
DFFI J m ,
GE
NVI E,
LL VA
RL
ED

I THE UXI
N
TED S
TATES DI
STRI COURT
PT

MA2 3û 2 7
2

FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON

JULA
I
D
CL
BK
D P
LER

K EW N TER R Y D O T SO N ,
Pett oner,
ii

C i lA cton N o.
vi
i
Ci lA c i n N o.7: 3 - vvi t o
1 c 00529

V.

M E M O M N D UM O PI I N
N O

W A RD EN O F K M CC ,
R e ponde .
s
nt

By:

H on. t on L.K i er
Jacls
s
Se or U ni e St e D i t i tJudge
ni
t d at s s r c

Ke n Te Doton,aVigi ai t pr ee ngpr K ,r e l tl d am o i of
vi ny
s
r ni nma e oc di
o
ec nty ie
ton

ç rnscfa upon t c t' n cvi a ton 7: 3- vl i i r ud
ext
he our'i i l c i
1 c 00529. I t ta ton, had g a t d
n ha c i I
r ne
r ponde ' m oton t dim isa dimi s d Peii ne ' pe ii f awrtofha asco pus
es
nts i o s s nd s s e tto rs tton or
i
be
r

fldpurua t 28U. C.j2254.
e s nt o
S.
Thei t ntGe rnscfa tpo t c t' i doe no a lge de ecsi t
nsa çxti i r ud i n he our'moton s t le
f t n he
r ol i n ofhi frtha a peii n a i tad a tc t lga iyofhi sae c i né
es uto
s is be s tto nd nse ta ks he e lt
s t t rmi l

j d me tb s do f cse si b f r h fldh sfrt b a p tto .Ac o dn l 1c n tu
u g n a e n a t xitng e o e e ie i is ha e s ei n c r igy, o sr e
i
t i t ntm oton a a s c ors ce svepe ii f a w rtofha s c pus c le ng t
he ns a
i s e ond
uc s i
tton or
i
bea or
ha l ngi he

smesaec u tu me tar a yc alng di cvla to 7 1 -v 0 5 9.
a tt o r j dg n le d h l e n i i cin :3 c - 0 2
e
P ru n t 28U. C. 2 4 49, fd r l ititc u t yc n ie as c n o
u sa t o
S. j 2 4 1 a e e a d src o r ma o sd r e o d r
s c e sv j22 4pei o o yu ns cfcc ri to fo aUntdSttsColt fAp as
u c sie 5 tt n nl po pe ii ett in r m
i
ka
ie ae t o pe l
r
t tcai si t s e ntpe ii n m e tc ran crt ra.Bec us Pe ii ne ha nots
ha l m n he ubs que
tto
e e ti ie i
a e tto r s
ubmit
ted
a e de t theha ob a ne s h c rik ai fom t Cour ofAppe l f t Fo t
ny vi nce ha
s t i d uc e tt ton r he
t
a s or he m'
h

Cic i, mu tds s t epei o wih u p eu iea s c e sv .Ba e u nt efn igt a
r ut I s imis h tt n t o t rj dc s u c s ie s d po h i dn h t
i
Pe ii rha notm a t r ui ie s t ntals i ofa de alofa cons i tona r ghtas
ttone s
de he eq s t ubs a i how ng
ni
tm i l i

rquie by28U. C.j2253()a Slc v. c nil529U. 473, 4 ( ) ac rii t
e rd
S.
c nd a k M Da e,
S. 48 2000 , e tfcae
of a a a lt i de ed.
ppe l biiy s ni
EN TER : TI
W

'
e- da o M a c 201
y f r h, 7.
I
M
N

t
I

s

.-v
.

e o U nie St t D it i J
ni r t d a es s rct udge