Wells v. Itsihnar

Filing 5

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 11/14/2013. (tvt)

CLERK' OFFI U. .DI COURT
S
CE S ST.
ATROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L

I TH E UM TED STATES DI
N
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI
CT
RGI A
NI
ROANO KE DI SI
VI ON
LESTER CHALRES W ELLS,

N 1i 2 1
0V
03
J
ULI
BY;

CASE NO .7:
13CV00538

D DL ,
CLERK
PUW CL
ERK

Pl ntf,
ai if
V.

M EM OR ANDUM O PI ON
NI

DA W D I H N A R ,
TSI

By: Jam esC .Tur
k
Se or U ni e St t sD i t c Judge
ni
t d a e s ri t

Def nda .
e nt

Le tr Cha l s W els a Vigi a i t pr e i pr K ,Gl t s c vi rght a ton
se
re
l,
r l nma e oc edng o
ed hi i l i s c i

puruan t 42 U. C.j1
s to
S.
983.W el'e tr c antsaest twhiehewasi aceae a
ls nie ompli tt ha l
nc r rtd t
Buc ng
ki hnm Core tonalCe e i AprlorM a of2008,t de e nt Da d Isl r tc m e
rci
nt r n
i
y
he f nda , vi t ima ,tut

o my fnlela d lf awo n o my fn g r. Co . ) Th c u t o cu e fo rviw
n
i g r n et u d n
i l el' mpl2. e o r c n ld s r m e e
'(
o ter c r t tW el' o lit s b sl rl ds se t e 2 U. C. 1 1 A( )1
f h e o d ha ls c mpan mu t e l
mmaiy imis d md r 8 S. j 9 5 b ( )
a l galy f i ous
s e l r vol .

The cour i r quied t dim is a a ton or c am fl d by a prs ne agans a
t s e r o s s ny ci
l i ie
io r i t
gove mentle iy orofi e i t c tde e ne t aci n orcai i fi ous m ai i us
m
a ntt
fc r f he our t nni s he to
l m s rvol , lc o ,

o fist sae acam o whc rle ma beg a td 28 U. C.j 1 5 b ( ) W h n i i
r al o tt li n ih eif y
rn e .
S.
91 A( )1. e t s
ce rfo t f c o aj1 3c mp an t a panifscam i b re b t a p ia l saue
la r m he a e f 98 o lit h t litf li s ar d y he p lc be ttt

o l tto ,te c u tma s mmaiy d s s t c mp an wih u p eu ie a lg l
f i ains h o r y u rl imis he o lit t o t rj dc s e al
mi
y
fi lu . N%i v.W ade M d Ho s o Co rcin,6 F.d 9 ,9 6 (t Ci.1 9 )(n
rvoo s
m
r m . u e f re to 4 3 51 5 4h r 9 5 e
b n)
a c.
A j 1 cam bas on e nt t tocc re i Vigi mus be br
983 li
ed
ve s ha u rd n r ia t
oughtwihi t
t n wo
yeasfo t tme whe t acin ac r eso i i bard by Va.Code Ann.j8. 243()
r r m he i
n he to c u r t s re
01- a,

Vigna ssa efrg n r lpes n lij r cams S eOwe v. tr , 8U. 2 5 2 9 4
r ii' tmt o e ea, ro a nu y li . e
ns Ok te 48 S. 3 , 3 - 0

( 9 9 . A cam u d rj 1 8 a c e wh nplitf k o e o g a u tehnm d n t hi
18 )
li n e 9 3 c nzs e an if n ws n u h bo t h r o e o m
t brnghi lws t Nasm ,64 F. at95 l i ce rfom t f e ofW els'co pl n t the
o i
s a ui.
i
3d
5. t s la r he ac
l m ait ha
knew i AprlorM a of2008t ha m t tlshna al ge y i lc e o hi . Ye ,he di no
n
i
y
he r ha ti r le dl nfit d n m
t
d t

fl t sa ton untlNo mbe of201 mor t n fveye r ltr Thus a j1 3 cli he
ie hi ci
i ve r
3, e ha i as ae.
, ny 98 am

ma h v h da ans Ish a i b re u d rj8. - 4 9 a d mus b s mmaiy ds se
y a e a g i t ti n r s a rd n e 012 3 $, n
t e u rl imis d
wih u p eu ieu d rj 1 5 b ( )a lg lyfi oo s1 Ana p o raeo d rwilis et i
t o t rj dc n e 91 A( )1 s e al rv lu .
p r p it r e l su h s
day.
The Cl r i dieced t s nd c es of t s m e o a lm opi on a a ompa ng
e k s r t o e opi
hi m r nd l
ni nd cc
nyi
o de t pl ntf.
r r o ai if

ENTER:Ths /
i V

a o No mb r201 .
y f ve e, 3
Se o Unie Stt sDiti
m r t d a e src

dge

1 The cour not t W els compl ntalo f l t demonsr e t the e
t es hat l '
ai s ais o
tat ha
xhaused a i s r i
t dm nitatve

r me e b f r flngt sa tona rqur d u e 4 U. C.j l e a ort tlshn rsa ton c ul
e dis e o e ii hi ci s e ie nd r 2 S. 997 () ha ti a ' ci s o d
pos i y qualf asa vi aton ofW els'rght unde t Ei h Am e e s ast be actonabl unde
s bl
iy
ol i
l i s
r he ght
ndm nt o o
i
e
r

j 1 3. To t e tn t tW el mihti e d t b ig s cam un rsae1w a ai tIsh s h
98
he xe t ha ls g ntn o rn ome li de tt a g ns tinr, uc
cams ae no ide e e ty a ton bl u e j 1 83 a d t c td cie t e r ie s plme t l
li r t n p nd n l c i a e nd r 9 , n he our e ln s o xe cs up e n a

jrs cino rsc cams Se 28U. C.j1 7() Li Wel'fdea cai ,a ysaelw cli
uidito ve u h li . e
S. 36 c. ke ls e rl l ms n tt a ams
wil ds se wih tpeudc
lbe imisd tou rj ie.