Reed v. Department of Corrections/ Commonwealth of Virginia

Filing 59

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/7/2014. (ssm)

CLERK' OFFCE U. . DI .
S
I
S ST COURT
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

h0k 27 2 1
2j
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI O F V I m I
CT
RG A
ROA N OK E D I I ON
V SI

J A C.
ULI DUDL CLiqf
EY, il t:
k

B:d ,
v

DEPUT CL T
M ER!

KR I E ST.CLA I REED ,
STI
R

Ci lA c i N o.7: 3- vi ton
1 CV 00543
Pl i i f
a ntf ,
M EM O M ND U M O PIN I N
O

D EPA RTM EN T O F COR RECTI S /
ON
COM M ON W EA LTH OF V I I A ,
RG NI

By:H on.G l E.Conr
en
ad
Chi U nie St t D it i tJ
ef t d a es s r c udge

Def nda .
e nt

On Se e r23,201 aj yf f t pli if Krsi StCli Ree onhe
ptmbe
4, ur ound or he antf, ite . ar d,
r

rtlain cam b o h p ru n t Til Vl o teCii Rih sAc o 1 6 (-i eV1' , 2
eaito li r ug t u s a t o te I f h vl g t t f 9 4 tlt I) 4
ç-l '
U. C.j2000ee s Re dha no tldaPeii f Ba kPa a Fr tPa (she
S.
t eg. e s w ie
tton or c y nd on y l
t
peii ', ke No.53,s e nge tbl r le purua tt t tsaut Thedeenda ,
tton' Doc t
)
e ki quia e eif s n o ha tt e.
f nt
Vigi aDe t ntofCor tons($
r ni parme
reci $VDOC',hasr ponde t t peii Doc tNo.56.
'
)
es
d o he tton, ke
The m a t ri now r pe f r e .
te s
i or evi w
B ackaround

The f c soft s c e a e outi i de ai i t c ts m e or ndum o ni n g a tng
at
hi as r
lned n t l n he our ' m a
pi o r n i

i p r a dd n n i p r VDOC' mo inf rs mma yj d me t Do k t . 5 Th s o l a
n a t n e yig n a t
S to o u r u g n , c e No 3 . u , ny
brefsunm a y f l sher
i t
r olow
e.

Re dwo k da as n o c re to l fie a Bln Cor ci n lCe tr($ 'i
e r e s e i r o r cina o fc r t a d re to a n e é
BCC' n
)
Blnd, r ni fom 2007untls wast nni t i 201 Prort hert r i ton, d
a Vigi a r
i he
e naed n 2. i o
e m na i Ree

e r d $31746. a
a ne
, 00 nnual i t tposton. Se Pe ii n Ex.A,Doc tNo. 1.Ree wa
ly n ha ii
e tto
ke
53d s
sexualy har ed by a BCC cow or
l
ass
ker. She r t t shar m entt B CC m anagem enton
epored hi ass
o
A prl9,201 and w ast m i ed f om herposii on M ay 18,2012. Reed s equenty
i
2,
er nat r
ton
ubs
l

br
oughtt s a ton a ns VD O C o N ove be l 201 ale ng i par t tV D OC
hi c i gai t
n
m r 5, 3, l gi n t ha

t mi e he i r a iton f r pori s xualha as me i vi a i ofTil V1.
er natd r n etla i or e tng e
r s nt n olton
te 1

F lo n tel blt p a eo abf r ae til aj r fu f rRe d o he rtlain
o lwig h i ii h s f iuc td ra, u y o nd o e n r eaito
a y
cam, c tNo 4 .Afe t ej r r tr e t i v r it Re da dVDOC a r e t f rg t
li Do ke . 6 tr h u y et n d hs ed c, e n
l
g e d o o e o he
da a s phas oft t i l l t a t pa tess i a ed t t a ountofc pe a or
m ge
e he r a . ns e d, he r i tpul t o he m
om ns t y

da a t bea r i t sc s Doc tN o.41 a s itd t is ofe t bl r le
m ges o
wa ded n hi a e, ke
, nd ubm te he s ues quia e e if
a a t r s f e t t co tf de s on. Se D oc tN o.
nd to ney' e s o he ur or ci i
e
ke
48. Re d t n s it d t s
e he ubm te hi

p tto , nwh c s s e $ 2, 2.0i ba kp y, u p eu g n itr s, n $ ,4 0
eiin i ih he e ks 3 25 0 n c a pls rj d me t ne et a d 415 4.0
i f ontpa I
n r
y. d.
Di
scuss on
i

Z LegalSt
andard

Til V I i a r m e als a ut des g d i pa tt m a t vi tm s ofdi c i i ton
te 1 s e di t t e i ne n r o ke he c i
s rm na i
w hol A s a ge r lr e, di ti tco tha i oad equia e di c e i t a d ba k pa f ont
e.
ne a ul a s r c ur s l
br
t bl s r ton o war c y, r

pa andi ee tt efct t (he e rme ali e i . For v. gi y Ra tr .nc.984F.
y, ntrs o fe uae t s l e di ntntons' d Ri dpl fe s I ,
'

S p 3 6 38 ( M d 1 9 ) s eFrn v. wma Trn p Co, 2 U. 7 , 6 - 4( 9 6 ;
u p. 8 , 9 D. . 9 7 ; e n ks Bo n a s . .4 4 S. 47 7 3 6 1 7 )
Ale rePa e Co v Mo d 4 2U.. 0 , 6 1 ( 9 5 .é Til VI p an ifwh i
b mal p r . . o y, 2 S 4 5 41 - 7 1 7 ) $ te l litf o s
A
una et fnd co pa abl wor i e ild t ba k pa û a ma trofc s unl s t
bl o i
m r e k s ntte o c y as
te
our e' e s he

defnda pr ese de et t(he pl ntf di nötus r s bl ef t t mii t
e nt oduc vi nc ha t l ai if d
e eaona e fors o tgae
da
mage . For 984F.Supp.a 38 ( i M atnv.Ca le Hot Cop .48F. 1
s' d,
'
t 9 quotng ri
vair el
, 3d 343,
1 (t Ci.l ).l artlaor dic r ca elket so ,abac pa a r ne sa iy
358 4h r 995 ) n eait y s hage s i hi ne
k y wad ce srl

amount t t ddifr ebet enwha t g antf woul ha e r dhadt wr ul
s o he s feenc we
t he pli io
d ve ane
he ongf

gemiain n to c re fo t p ro o tr n to t j d me t a dt (litf s a t l
tr n to l o c u r d r m he eid f emiain o u g n , n he panif j cua
e r ngs d i t tpe i ' 1 The s a a de i w ihi t ti lc tsdi c e i n. M a tn,
n ni
ur ng ha r od.' d.
um w r d s t n he r a our ' s r t o
ri

2

48 F. a 1
3d t 358.
Fr pa i t o y a a de f l tc pe a i durng t pe i be w e
ont y s û ne w r d or os om ns ton i he r od t en
m

j d me ta dr isae n o i l uo ri ttme t'Polr v. 1 d Po tNe u s&
u g n n en ttme t r n i f ensae n . l d E.. u n mo r
e
' a
Co.532U. 8 8 ( ) I S ompe aeg)vitmsofdici nainf rt co i ng
,
S. 43, 46 2001. t k
c
ns t s ci
srmi to o he ntnui
f ur ef e t ofdi c i i ton untlt vi i c n be m a w hol ' Pr ft v. e m a N o.
ut e f c s
s rm na i
i he ctm a
de
e. of it V ne n,
'

5: - 00067,
0lCV2002U. Dit LEXI 21 a *4( . Va.
S. s.
S 906, t W D. Nov.6,2002) Sf ea r of
. l' wad
-h
fontpa r sss ua e y wihi t dititc tsdic e i whi m us be Ce r d'by She
r
y e t q r l t n he src our' s r ton, ch
t t mpe e
t

potnta f wi al't t pl nif' d.(uoi Ni sv.As a Hos Cor ,251F.d
e il or ndf l o he aitf.
'1 q tng chol
hlnd p. p.
3

4 6, 0 (t Ci. 0 ). ec u tte eo e é s j d co l sr tn z t rc r t
9 5 4 4 h r 20 1) Th o r,h r f r,G t u iiusy cu iie he e o d o
mu

d tr n wh t e f t r e n saes fiin l p e itbet j tf s ha a r . Fo d
eemie eh r uu e ve t r u fce ty r dca l o usiy uc n wa d' r ,
'
98 F.Supp. t392;s e Eva v. r hm o Ba itChur h I a Ca e Ct . l ,956 F.
4
a
e
ns La c nt pts
c nf nt r r . nc.

Supp. 695,708( D.Va 201 ( clni t a r fontpa whe doi s woul r quie
2d
E. . 3) de i ng o wad r
y n ng o
de r
f s i c ranunkno 'andd d (herf e beund ys c ai a
d umgngq e ti
as
wns' s
woul t eorl
ul pe ultve nd

i ppr prae'.
na o it'
)
W ih t slgalfa e k i m i t c twilnow deer ne t a
t hi e r m wor n nd, he our l
t mi he mountofba k
c
pa a f ontpay,i a t whi h Ree i e il d i t s c e.
y nd r
f ny, o
c
d s ntte n hi as
I Back Pay
I.

Asas ce sulTil VI pl ntf,Re d i e ild t ba k pay C am at rofcolre.'
uc s f te I ai if e s ntte o c
'
as
te
zs '
M a tn,48F. a 1
ri
3d t 358.VDOC ha a s re s ve a a g e s howe ,s esi t tt
s s e td e r l r um nt ,
ver ugg tng ha he
bac pa a r s d be lm ied i t sca e.Fis,VDOC as e t t tRee sa r s d be
k y wa d houl
i t n hi s
rt
s rs ha
d' wa d houl
r uc d by t a ountofune pl e be ft s r eve f l ng he t nni ton.
ed e
he m
m oym nt neis he ec i d olowi
r e nai
Se nd,VD O C c e t tRe f ie t m ii t herda a . The c t ilc i re h
co
ont nds ha ed a l d o tga e
m ges
our w l ons de ac
argum enti t n.
n ur

3

VDOC ur st c 't de tune oy e be isfom Re d' ba pa awa d.
ge he oul o duc
t
mpl m nt neft r
e s ck y
r
Re wasunem pl
ed
oyed,a r e ve une pl entbe isf om t V igi a Em pl e
nd ec i d m oym
neft r he r ni
oym nt

Commison(C ',f aperodoft nt eghtwee f l nghert mi to SeeRe
si tVEC' or i
)
we y-i
ks olowi
er nain.
ed
De . 6, ttonEx. Docke No.53- Shewoul ha e r $1 094i s r i d
cl! Peii
B,
t
2.
d ve aned 7, f he emane
e oye by VDOC durngt spe i VDOC a gue ,howe r t ta ba pa a r d t
mpl d
i hi rod.
r s
ve , ha ny ck y wa de o

Re mus be ofs tby t une oymen be ft t ts r ceved,be us t VEC a
ed
t
fe
he mpl
t ne is ha he e i
ca e he
nd

VDOC aeb t saea e ce .VDOC ra o sta, to ts c a o fe, e wo l e j ya
r oh tt g n is
e s n h t wi u u h n fs tRe d ud n o
h
doubl r co r a t e ns ofV i g ni t xpa s The c ta ee .
e e ve y t he xpe e
r i a a yer .
our gr s

I c s i vi prva ee oye s c t ofe de i t r duceapl i ifsba k pa
n a es nvol ng i t mpl r , ours tn clne o e
antf
c y
a a d by be ft r e ve f om a t r s ce lke s a e une pl e be i s Sl v. SX
w r
ne i s ec i d r
no he our , i t t
m oym nt nett . oas C

Trns .I ,61 F. 380,389( hCi.201 )(ttngt tt c ltr s urenlepr des
a p. nc. 6 3d
4t r 0 sai ha he olaeal o c l ovi
t tç ompe ai fom ac ltr s ces ul bedir r di a s sngt tdama ')
ha s
c
nston r
olaeal our ho d
segade n sesi or
ges';

s eCri v.Y&Y Snac sl ,721F. 77,8185( Ci.1 (fimi de sonnott
e ac
ks nc.
2d
- 3d r 983) afr ng cii
o
de beneisi aTil VI c e .Thec ltrls cer ema a ye nwhe apli if
duct ft n te 1 as)
olaea our ul y ppl ve
n antf
r e ve a be i f om t pr va e e pl ris l , a e Swhe he a gi be fti de i d
ec i s
neft r he i t m oye t e f bec us û t r ven ne i s r ve

fom ac ltr s ur û pe s .. t e c naur oft compe ai r eve 'rt r
r
olaeal o ce de ndll.upon he xa t t e he
nston ec i d''ahe
t n t s c oft tc
ha he our e ha ompens to al
ai n one. Sl , 6 F. a 390. l Sl ,t Fourh Cic t
oas 61 3d t
n oas he
t r ui

sae t a ab n ft r vie b ad fn a tt p cfc l t c mpe s t (h plitf f rh r
ttd h t e e ip o d d y ee d n d e iial o o n ae te anit o e
s
y
l
ij r 'wa n tfo ac lae a s u c , n tuss o l b ofe fo t p an ifsba kpa
nu y' s o r m o ltrl o r e a d h h ud e fst r m he litf c y
a r J Ont ohe ha i t prvaeempl ha pr de t benei t t pli iff
wad. .
Z
he t r nd, f he i t
oyer d ovi d he
ft o he antf or
s eot r a on,ha benei wo d bec lt r la s d notr duc t pli ifsr co y.
om her e s t t
tt ul
ola e a nd houl
e e he antf ' e ver
1
d.

4

The Sl Cou tnot howeve ,t tc t havea i t sc lt r ls r r l mor
oas r ed,
r ha ours
ppled hi ola e a ou ce u e e

naw wl i ca e wheet defnda i agovenme e iy.Seej.at389n. l s hca e ,
l y n s s r he e nt s
r nt ntt
;a
9. n uc s s
c t m a c i rS he s c oft be ft , wihoutm o e t de e m i whe he t y a e
our s y ons de t our e he ne is' t
t
'
r , o t r ne
t r he r

colatr .Philpsv.W .Co.ofN. ,95 F. 923,931( h Ci.1 ,s eSze oc v.
l eal li
Am. 3 2d
5t r 992) e dl k
.
Te t 61F. x 88,89- (t Ci. )(
ne,
App'
90 4h r 2003 unpubls d)(fimi dititco tsofstof
ihe afr ng src ur' fe
fde a beneisfom fde a e oyee' ba kpa a r unde t Re biiainAc) Smihv.
e r l tt r e r l mpl s c y wad
r he ha ltto t; t
OfieofPes melM gmt,778F. 258,263(t Ci.1 )(a i ADEA c e) Her,
fc
rol
.
2d
5h r 985 sme n
as . e
Re d' unempl m e be ft a enotc lt r l be a e k h t be isa t ba pa
e s
oy nt ne is r
ola e a , c us k
bot he neft nd he ck y

c mefo tes mes u c - te(tt)g v r me t' S e lc 61F. p' a 8 - 0.Th
o r m h n o re h sae o en n . z do k,
'
Ap x t 9 9
e
cour co l , t r or ,t tt ebene iss d beofs tfom Re d' bac pa a r 1
t ncudes he ef e ha hos
ft houl
fe r
e s k y wa d.
VD O C a s as e t t tR e d f l t s f c e l m ii t he dam a asr quie by
l o s r s ha e aied o ufi i nty tga e r
ges e r d
Til V I . Ree be n w or ng a a pa ttm e s c iy of i e f Ca ii n N ew R i rV a l y
te 1
d ga
ki s
r -i e ur t f c r or r lo
ve le

M e c Ce e (l rlon' on Dec mbe 3,201 Re Dec. 6.Shee ne $1 49pe ho
dial ntr scaii '
)
e r
2. ed l!
ar d 2. r ur
f a a r ofni t e hour pe we k f t ne t nt fvewe ks untls r c i d a
or n ve age
ne e n
s r e or he xt we y-i
e , i he e eve

nni
une, 3. # t
'
f ltmeofe fom Caii a 'hebegi ngofJ 201 '2 J s a !7.Shewor df ltme
ul-i fr r
rlon t'
t
ke ul i
-

a Caiinu tl h d t o j d me t e r i g$1 .5pe h u f rafry f u h u wo kwe k.
t rl n it e ae f u g n , an n 32 r o r o o t-o r o r r e
o
1 N one he es , D OC a gue t tRe d ha f ie t f l m ii t herda a s be us s
d.
t l sV
r s ha e s a l d o uly tga e
m ge , ca e he

ea ne l s i t epostonst n s woul ha e r d a BCC.Asar ul,
r d e s n hes
ii ha he
d ve a ne t
es t VDOC a g
r ues
t tRe d s dnotr ceveba k pa f t perod oftme a trs bega wor ng a Ca ii
ha e houl
e i
c y or he i
i fe he
n
ki t rlon.
The c tdi ag e s
our s r e .

1Ther c dlcksevi nc s w i t a oun ofune pl e be ist tRee a m aly r ei .
e or a
de e ho ng he m t
m oym nt nett ha
d c l ec ved
Thecour beleve t tt pa tess dbeabl t r diydeer i t sa ounta deduc i fom t bac pa
t i s ha he ri houl
e o ea l t m ne hi m
nd
t t r he k y

a r llhowe ,t pa te ar una et a eeonana opra ea t ,he ma pr e evi ncet t c t
wad. t
ver he ris e bl o gr
ppr it momt t y y es nt de o he our
f decso
or iin.
2Be us Ree doesnoti c t t e c daeonwhi s ta ii
ca e d
ndia e he xa t t
ch he r nstonedt f ltm eempl e i t
o ul-i
oym nt n he
pe iin,hecou w ila s et ts bega wor ng f ltm eonJu 1 201
tto t
rt l s um ha he
n ki ul i
ne , 3.

5

Unde 42U. C.j2000e- g)1,aTil V1 cli ntmus mii t he da ges whih
r
S.
5( ( ) te l ama
t tgae r ma , c
r quiest c am a t bet ea ona y dii nti s ki and a ce i ne e oymen
e r he l i nt o ' s bl lge n ee ng
r
c ptng w mpl
t

s t i l e valntt t tfom whih (l wa dic r ' Br vv.Thurt M ot
ubsantaly qui e o ha r
c she s s haged. ad
'
son or
Li s I .753F. 1 1 ( h Ci.1 (ii For M oorCo.v.
ne .nc,
2d 269, 273 4t r 985) ctng d t
EEOC, U. 21
458 S. 9,
232( 982).A pli ifc nnotrc vebac pa f apei durngwhih s di notf tlhe
1 )
antf n
e ei
k y or rod i
c he d ulil r
dut t m ii t l tFaitr t m ii t i a a fr a i de e e f whi h t em pl
y o tga e. d. t lte o tga e s n f im tve f ns or c he
oyerbe r
as

t bur nofpr . W ag rv. ladDe .St es l ,1 F. x 1 153( hCi. )
he de
oof'
' ne Dilr pt or snc. 7 App' 41, 4t r 2001 .
A n e pl ror na iy m us c e f wa d w ih e denc t tc pa a e wor i ava l bl ,
m oye di r l
t om or r t vi e ha om r bl
k s ia e
unl s t e pl r c n de ons r t t tt pl i i f' ade no r as
e s he m oye a m ta e ha he a ntf k
m
e onabl a t m ptt fnd
e te
o i

wor ' l a 15 5 (A pli ifwhormansi ei t dofs e nge oymen f f t ( r
k. d. t 3- 4. i antf
'
e i dl nsea
e ki mpl
t oreis hej
rgh t ba kpayf t pei durngwhih ghe di no s e e oyme .l a 15 ( tng
i to c
or he rod i
c s ) d t e k mpl nt d. t 3 cii
Br 753F. a 1 .Ho ve,dg bti ngapa ttmej .s tsi Pl ntf soblgai
adv,
2d t 273) we r kol ani
r-i ob..aifes ai if i ton
t mii t da sa e as wi by ghede e nt t tt sa i wasnoti goodfih.
o tgae mage bs nt ho ng t f nda q ha hi cton
n
at '
'

Fo d, 4F. p a 3 0( igDo n lyv. l w F ec tS .1 c, 7 F.d40 41 (t
r 98 Su p. t 9 dtn n el Yel r ih vs.n .8 4 2 2, 1 7h
o
Ci. 98 ).
r 1 9)
I t sca e Re obt ne pa ttm e- a lt rf ltm e- e pl e i asm ia
n hi s , ed ai d r-i
nd a e ul-i
m oym nt n i lr
te d f l ng he tnni ton.
i l olowi
r e nai VDOC ha notpr edany e de s
s
oduc
vi nce uggesi t tRe s
tng ha ed'
a ce anc ofem pl m e a Ca ii w a i ba f t ort m o e c pa a e w or w a
c pt e
oy nt t rlon s n d aih hat r om r bl
k s

r a l a ia e. Thecour c udest tRee a uael mii t he dn a by
e diy val bl
t oncl
ha
d deq t y tgaed r m ges
ob ani c pa a eempl e f l nghe t r i ton.Shei en ild,he e or t
t i ng om r bl
oym nt olowi
r e m na i
s tte t r f e, o
rc
e overt dif r e be w e w ha s a t ly e r a Ca ii pr o t t da e of
he f e enc t en
t he c ua l a ned t rlon i r o he t

j me a wha s woul ha ea a BCC dtrngt ts mepei
udg nt nd t he
d ve nwd t
ti ha a
rod.

6

Re dse sp eu me titrs o h rb c p ya r .dlteVl a to ie
e e k rj dg n ne e t n e a k a wa d t-l 1 uh rz s
-i
p eu g n itrs a pa t ft b c pa rme y' Loefe v F q k 4 6U. 5 , 5 - 8
rj d me tn ee t s r o he a k y e d .
' flr . r n , 8 S. 49 5 7 5
( 9 8 .Th c u t l a p yVigna ssxp re tsau o yj d me t aet ti a r S e
1 8 ) e o r wi p l r ii' i e c n ttt r u g n rt o h s wad. e
l
Va.Codej6. 302; E. C. Li t & M ves l ,690F. 1 1 ( h Ci.1 2)
02- E. O. v. cce'
t
rs nc.
2d 072, 074 4t r 98
(ttngt tadititc t y,n isdicei c et a y a i ees rt pr vi df by
sai ha src our ma i t srton, hoos o ppl n ntr t ae o de or
saelw) Pr ft,2002U. Dit LEXI 21 a *1 11(ppl ngt Vigi asaut yrt
tt a ; ofit
S. s.
S 906, t 0- a yi he r ni tt or ae

t aTil VI j
o te l udgme ) si ees wilas bec
nt.Thi ntr t l lo ompou dt r l ctt f onomi ralt '
nde o ete he û
ec
c e iy'

t a çgl tfr(
h tsb u o VDOC')c nd t g e lwo l h v h da c s t t smo e d rn teba k
S o uc,Re d ud a e a c e s o hi n y u i g h c
pa pe i a w oul have be n a e t e n i e e tnoto y on t pr nc pa am ount , a s
y r od nd
d
e bl o ar nt r s
nl
he i i l
s but l o

o a c ae i e et' Hvlndv.Xer Cor ,749F.Supp. 3 351( M d.201 ,
n c umultd ntr s.' i
ox p.
2d 40, D.
0)

rv re o oh rg o n b 48 F. p' 81 (t Ci. 01 )
e e s d n t e r u ds y 1 Ap x 9 4h r 2 2 .
111. FrontPay

Re a s s e f ontpa i t sc e. Spe fca l Re d a s r st t be aus s
ed l o e ks r
y n hi as
cii ly, e s e t ha , c e he

l
s
hopedt c i he e oyme twih (
o ontnue r mpl n t VDOC)untlhe rtrme , t cour s dawa d
i r eie nt' he t houl r
'
he t dif e e bewee wha s ea nsi he cure poston a wha s woul ha
r he fer nc t n
t he r n r r nt ii nd
t he
d ve

eane atBCC f ea hye rbewe nnow a whe s r c agesxt tve.Peii a !
r d
or c a t e
nd n he ea hes
i y-i
tton t !

2 , 6 Th c u th we e , a n t u tf afo tp ya r b s do t rc r b f r i.
3 2 . e o r, o v r c n o j siy r n a wa d a e n he e o d eo e t
Alhough Re e r si l l s no t n when s wasempl ye by VDOC,he ei no
t
ed a ns lghty e s w ha
he
o d
t r s
e denc s
vi e ugges i t tt s dipa iy w ilcon i f t ne t ry- i yea s l e a
tng ha hi s rt l tnue or he xt hit s x r . nde d,

c o a ear
ol r bl gume c n bem a t tRee may uli t l ea n mor i t prva es c ort i
nt a
de ha
d
tma ey r
e n he i t e t han f
h d he em i d m oyed by VD O C untls r i e 3 Se D ef' Res at5,D ocketN o.
i he etr d. e
s e ha s r a ne e pl
. s
p.
56. The recor sm pl l
d i y acks it essentalda a necessar t cal at a reas
éhe
i t
y o cul e
onabl cert n f ont
y
ai r

3Thecour alo c
t s annots y wihce tit t tRe w oul hav r m ai empl
a t rany ha ed
d e e ned
oyedbyVD OC untlhe
i r
r tr m e . Re d' prordi ci i r r or f e mpl ,s s st tVDOC m a ha ha a l gii er as n t
e ie nt e s i s plna y ec d, or xa e ugge t ha
y ve d e tmat e o o

pa a r ' Bnzov. tdAilne .I ,239F. 848,862( hCi.2001 .Awa di Re
y wad.
' s Unie ri s nc.
3d
7t r
)
r ng ed
fontpa he ek dr quiet s( our t astnecet nunknowns' Eva ,956F.
r
y r l
woul e r hi cl to su rai
.
' ns
Supp.2d
a 708. The co tde i t do s
t
ur clnes o
o.
C oncl i
us on
Fort r as s a ed, t c twila r Re ba k pa i t a ountof$28321. ,
he e ons t t he our l wa d ed c y n he m
, 254

l s t a ountofsa eune pl ym e be t t tRee r ceved f l wi he t mi to
e s he m
tt
m o nt neks ha
d e i
olo ng r er nai n.

Prj d me titrs wil ea d dt t etna b c p ya u t Re di as e t ldt
eu g n n ee t l b d e o h i l a k a mo n . e s lo ni e o
t
com pe a or da a i a co da e wih t pa te 'pr vi s i a i D oc tN o. The
ns t y m ges n c r nc t he ri s e ous tpul ton, ke
41.

pa te a edie t d t c e r r ngt a o ofune pl e be ft t beded t
ri s r r c e o onf r ega di he m unt
m oym nt ne is o
uced

fo Re d sba kp ya r , n t p e e tap o o e fn lu g n c nanngt i a re r m e ' c a wad a d o rs n r p s d ia j d me t o t ii hs g e d
u o a u tt t ec u t Th ra tr t c u t le trfn lu me ti t smatr
p n mo n o h o r. e e fe,he o r wil n e ia j dg n n hi te .
The Cl r i die t d t s nd c r ii d c esoft sm em or ndum opi on a t
e k s r c e o e e tf e opi
hi
a
ni nd he
a om pa ng or t a 1co elofr cor
cc
nyi
der o 1 uns
e d.

Ex rsR : Thi
s

- N dayofxove r 2014.
f
mbe ,
I
Chi U nied St t D i ti tJ
ef t
a es sr c udge

t r na e hera s e poi t a e a r t it r m otve. See M e .Op.a 5,Docke N o.35.
e mi t
t om
n , bs nt ny e ala o y i
m
t
t

4Th c u t ac lt st i s m b a digt g t r hef lo n a u t : l t $1 0 4.0t a Re d
e o r c lu ae h s u y d n o ehe t o l wig mo n s ( ) he 7 9 0 h t e
wo l ha ee re a BCC d rn h rt nyeg twe k o u e ly n; 2 t $93 9.5dfee c b t e
ud v an d t
uig e we t-ih e s f n mpo me t( )he ,2 7 ifrn e ewen
wha Ree e neddurng he t y-i wee ofpa ti ee pl e a Ca ii a w ha s w oul have
t d ar
i
r went fve ks
r tm m oym nt t rlon nd
t he
d

e re a BCC d rngta smep ro ; nd()te$18 .0di ee c b t e wh t e er e dtigh r
an d t
u i h t a eid a 3 h ,975 f rn e ewen a Re d an d t n e
f
r
sxt ni w e ksoff l tm ee pl e a Ca ii a wha s woul ha eaned a BCC durngt tpe i
i y- ne e
ul i m oym nt t rlon nd
t he
d ve r
t
i ha rod.

8