Sun v. Virginia Parole Board Chairman et al

Filing 21

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 6/5/2014. (tvt)

CL S OFFI U. . ST. URT
ERK'
CE S DI O
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI ED
L

I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
RO ANOK E DI SI
VI ON

J 25 2 1
LN
2j
J I
ULA
BY;
D

L ,C RK
CL
E

I M A N I SUN ,
G

Pl ntf ,
ai if

Ci lAc i n No.7: v569
vi to
13c
M EM OR ANDUM O PI ON
NI

VI GI A PAROLE BOARD CH AI AN,
R NI
RM
ET A L .

By:Sam ue G .W is
l
l on
U ni e St esD i t i tJudge
t d at
sr c

Defendant
s.

Thi i apr s a tonpurua t 42U. C.j 1 byKa niSun, / aJme Clnt
s s o e ci
s nt o
S.
983
ma
ak/ n s i on

F r n( r ia tr: u ', e kigd caao ya dij n tv r l f o iiigteVigna
o ma heen fe $ n' s e n e lrt r n n u cie ei pr hbtn h r ii
S )
e
P r l Boad(Bo r ' fo d n n hsrla e ic a la t2 1 t eBo r ha n n al
a oe r $ ad' r m e yig i ee s .Sn e t e s 01 ,h a d s n u ly
i
)
r vi d St ' elgi lt f pa ol a on ea h occ son,de e m i d t par ewa no
e ewe m s i biiy or r e nd,
c
ai
t r ne hat ol s t
wa r nt f rva i usr s . Sun cli st r as nsf hi 201 a 201 de al a e
ra ed o ro ea ons
am he e o or s 2 nd
3 ni s r

a bir r a c prcousa t r f evi a ehi co tt i rghtt duepr es .The Boa d
r ta y nd a i i
nd he e or olt s nsiutonal i o
oc s
r
ha move t dimis.Thec tfndst tSun f ist sa eacli f whih r le c n be
s
d o s s
our i ha
a l o tt
a m or c ei f a
gr nt d a dim is hi c
a e nd s s es s ompl i .
ant

l 1
n 989,Sun pld g ly t br a ng a e e i wih t i en t commi r pe a r pe.
e uit o e ki nd nt rng t he nt t o
t a nd a
The Cic tCour f t Ciy ofLync
r ui
t or he t
hbur Vi g ni s nt nc hi t lf pl t n ye r .
g, r i a e e ed m o i e us e a s

Be us t ofe e we ecommit be or J nuar 1 1
ca e he f ns s r
ted f e a y , 995,Sun i pa ol elgi e.Se Va.
s r e i bl e

Code53.- ( ihi dic ei r paol f ofe esonl a rs ddae.'heBo d
1 136 abols ng sr tonay r e or fns
y he ai t) r
ar
r vi we Sun' c s f pa ol i Nove r2011.Afe co i rngva i f c or , heBoa d
e e d
s a e or r e n
mbe
tr nsde i
rous a t s t
r
notfe Sun t ti ha decde nott gr nthi pa ol TheBoa dexpl ne t tt prm a y
iid
ha t d i d
o a m r e.
r
ai d ha he i r

ras weebe us of ( )Su srs t t c
e ons r ca e : 1 n' ik o he ommuniy;( t s i nalea
t 2) he erous tz nd
r
cr tncesoft ofe e;()t nee t s r emor oft sntnceprort r l s ;a (
icumsa
he fns 3 he d o e v
e he e e
i o eea e nd 4)
t naur oft c i comm itd. I Nove be 201 t Boa dagan r viwe Sun' c ef
he t e he rmes
te n
m r 2, he r
i e e d
s as or
pa ol,a agan t Boa d denid hi pa ol Thi tm e t Boa d e ane t tpa ol was
r e nd i he
r
e s r e. s i , he
r xpli d ha r e

nota o it be us of( )t srousnauea cr umsa e oft ofe ea be us
ppr prae ca e 1 he e i
tr nd ic tnc s he fns nd ca e
( rl s a t tmewoul di nih t s rous s oft c i
2) eea e t hat i
d mi s he ei ne s he rme.
Su r quesedr c i e ai oft Boa d' decson and c
n e t e onsd r ton he r s ii
ompli dt thedi not
ane ha
d
know wha i t kest bede m e ls t bl f r l as ' Sun ciedno e r so ne o dif r nt
tta
o
e d tuia e or e e e.
'
t
ror r w r ft e
i or ai n t twoul wa r ntr onsde a i unde t Boa d' polc e b none hees a ke
nf m to ha
d r a ec i r ton
r he r s ii s ut
t l ss d
t Boa d t r consde hi pa ol sncei wasde e s ey on t ba i oft s rous s ofhi
he
r o e
i r s r e i t
nid ol l
he ss he e i ne s
s
c ci ns Sun a s as t Boa dt de i f hi t m e ni ofi uiabl 's hewoul
onvito .
lo ked he r o fne or m he a ng i t e, o
s
'
d
know wha mor hene t dot a e pa ol TheBoa d s e
t e
eds o o chive r e.
r ubs qutn l de e hi r ue t
ty nid s eq s
f r onsde a i butdi i or hi t tis t biiy i dee mi whe 3 o 4 Boa d
or ec i r ton
d nf m m ha éuia lt s t r ned
n r
r

me e s- i ( ijc s 3- d cd t a g jn ln e p e s at ra t t tc mmu i '(
mb r - n hs a e - e ie h t he o o g r os l) h e t o h o nt ' ECF
y.
No.1 1a 5 Be a et Boa dddnoti l a aba i f is201 de a ofpaol t the
- t ) c us he r i
ncude s ss or t 2 nil
r e ha
pos d at e tt t c muniy,Sun fld t pr e a ton,a gui t themus t r f ebe
e hr a o he om
t
ie he es nt c i r ng ha
t he e or

s ia l, n a yd n a o paoewa wi u j tf to a v oae h sc n ttto a rg t
utbe a d n e il f r l s t t usikain nd i ltd i o si in l ihs
ho
u
t d pr es
o ue oc s.
Sun fld hi co a n on De e be 5, 3.A s ttmet r fe , heBoa d agan
it s mpli t
c m r 201
hor i he ta tr t
r
i
notfed Sun t ti hadr viwe hi ca ef pa ol on No mbe 22,201 a a tr
ii
ha t
e e d s s or r e
ve r
3 nd, fe
co i rng va i f c or , i f
nsde i
rous a t s agan ound Sun uns t bl f r e e.The Boa d e ane is
uia e or elas
r xpl i d t
r s i a D e e be 11, 13 l te .A c or ng t t tl te , he Boar de e pa ol be a e
ea ons n
e m r 20 e t r
c di o ha e tr t
d ni d r e c us

of ( )Sun' rs t t co
:1
s ik o he mmuniy;( t srousnalr a crumsa e ofhi ofe e ;a
t 2) ht e i
tze nd ic tnc s
s fns s nd

2

( )isc n l i nt a S n s o l sr emo eof h s ne c b f r h srla e ( No. - a
3 t o cuso h t u h u d e v r t e e tn e e o e i ee s . ECF 7 1 t
1 Bec us t Boadoncea nc i r dSunt bears t t c
) a e he r
gai onsde e
o
ik o he ommuniy,Sunn nde
t
me d
hi compl nta no a gue t tt Boa d' fndi a ei onsse a dii enuous
s
ai nd w r s ha he r s i ngs r nc it nt nd sng
.

Ac o dn l, eman an t a t ed n a o hi paoewa wi o ta e uaej siiaina d
c r igy h iti s h t h e il f s r l s t u d q t u tfc to n
h
fmdn e al unf i.
t m nt ly ar
I.
I

Toprvalonaj 1 3 cam t tsaeofi asvi ae a i t sduepr s rg s
e i
98 li ha tt fcil oltd n nmae'
oce s iht,
t c am a m us pr t thehad apr e t lbe t i e es t twasad r ey afe t d
he l i nt t ove ha
ot ced i ry nt r t ha
ve s l f c e
wiho t pr t c i gua an ee by t Fouree h Am e
t ut he o e tons r t d he
t nt
ndme .Slza v. t, F. 590,
nt e k Eva t 21 3d

5 3 9 (t Ci. 9 4 .Net e Vigni 1w no teCo siui nce tsap oe tdlb ry
9 - 4 4h r 1 9 ) ih r r i a a r h n t to r ae r tce i e t
t
i t r ti t e c a i ofe r y r e e o pa ol Se Hilv. a o 64 F. d 1 1 71
n e es n he xpe t ton
a l el as n r e. e l J cks n,
3 63, 70-

( h Ci.1 ( r ni lw) Gr nholzv.nmat ofNe as Pe & Cor Co e 442
4t r 995) Vigi a a ; ee t l es
br ka nal
r. mplx,

U. 1 7( 9 9 ( n tt t n .Vigna1w d e , o v r ce t al ry itr s f rc ran
S. , 1 7 ) Co siui ) r ii a o s h we e, r ae i t nee t o e ti
o
be
i t i par eco de aton.SeeHil 64F. a 1 ,Va.
nmaes n ol nsi r i
l, 3d t 70* Codej53.- 51 Ha ng
1 1 . vi
i e t dqalbe t i ees,heDuePr es Clus r uiesfi pr e esfrisvi c ton.'
eraeg i ry ntr tt
oc s a e eq r ar oc dur o t ndiai ''

Bu n tev Fa e ,6 7F.d 1 ,1 ( t Ci. 01 )(iigSwa to t Co ke 1 S. . 5 ,
r et . h y 8 3 71 81 4h r 2 2 ctn
rh u v. o , 31 Ct 8 9
8 2( 01 )( rc ra ) dac u tç lrviw tea piai no (u h c nsiu in ly
6 2 1 pe u iml.An o r $ l e e h p lc to f s c l o ttto al
wi
r quiedpr e es' Swa t t 1 S.Ct a 862.Bu ,i t pa ol c e ,t r r d
e r
oc dur .
' rhou , 31
.t
t n he r e ont xt he equie
pr e esa ei i m a .' d. ç m os,... r e a hortesmus it i h t t prs ra
oc dur r ç ni l'1 t
m
At t pa ol ut ii
t fmzs o he ione

sae n o isra o f rd n a o paoe' Va nv Anc ln , 3F.d 5 9, 2 ( t Ci.
ttme t f t e s ns o e il f r l.' n . eo e 7 3 1 5 2 4h r
'
1 9 )(uoigFrn lnv. hed , 6 F.d78 ,8 ( t Ci.1 7 )(nb n l.
9 6 q tn a k i S ils 5 9 2 4 01 4h r 9 8 e a c l
A sa i he e t r i not ng t s
ppled r , he e s hi o ugge tt tt Boa d de e St t c tt i na l
s ha he
r ni d m he ons iuto ly

r quiedpr e es TheBoa d c i r d Sun' c e f pa ol annua l but afe r viwi
e r
oc dur .
r onsde e
s as or r e
ly , tr e e ng

varousf t s f
i ac or , ound ea h tm et tSun wasnot( uia e'f r l s lI e r i tnc , t
c i ha
f tbl' or eea e. n ve y nsa e he
s

Boa d e ane t Sun t r onsf risde a .Alho h Sun cli st er as we e
r xpl i d o
he eas
o t ni l t ug
am hos e ons r
a bir r a t tt Boar m us pr
r t a y nd ha he
d
t oduc s e e de e ofç ur e ' ortc i ng be vi '
e om vi nc
ç r nt' ç ontnui
c
ha or'

t j tf isr ao i g ( No 1a 4 ,1a Vign aimae. . o sno h v ad ep o e s
o usiy t e s n n , ECF . t ) $ J r ii n t . d e t a e u r c s
(

rg t o u iil d fw o hev ldt o ter a o gv n. Ro i o v. h v, 6 F. u p.
ih t j d ca r ve ft a ii f h e s n ie ' bns n Fa e 3 6 S p 2d
y
'
3 8 3 - 2( D. . 0 ) afr dRo is nv. a y 1 4F. p' 7 7 7 8(t Ci.
6 , 717 E. Va 2 05, fime bn o F he , 7 Ap x 5 , 5 4 h r
2006)(mpha i i orgi l (ntr lciai omit ) d-'efdealc t donotprvi a
e
ss n i na) i ena ttons ted . s h e r ours
f
o de
f um t r vi t di c eto r de i i ofs a e pa ol ofi i l ;r t r f er lr ew of
or o e ew he s r i na y c s ons t t r e fc a s a he , ed a evi

saep r l d cso si lmie t p o e u a fa . Viu v. sa, 4 F.d7 ( t Ci.
tt ao e e iin s i td o r c d rl lws' g e Va s r 8 6 2 5 4h r
'
di y t
1 ) (ntr lcttonsomitd)2 Accor ngl , wihnoe de eofpr e aler ,Sunfis
988) i ena iai
te .
vi nc
oc dur ror
al
t sae acai f rwhi h r i ca begr t d,a t cour wilgr ntt Boa d' m o i t
o tt l m o
c elef n
an e nd he
t l a he r s ton o
dimi s3
s s.
1Sun doesnotque ton t tt Boa d acualy r e d hi ca e; at r he c le est
si ha he r t l eviwe s s r he ,
ha lng he

Boad sb s sfrd n igh m p r l .Se ECFNo. )(il o e5b adme e sd srb me
r ' a e o e yn i ao e ( e
7 f- s o r mb r e ci e
llh
asctrntyposngatikt t communiy. l t si s t i i i umbe ( lw)t tt
tre l i rs o he
t ' f hi s o,hen t s nc
nt by a ha he
p r l bo r p o u es mee i e c o c re to c ni igb h vo t j siyt i ra o i g
a oe a d r d c o v d n e f u rn r o t n e a ir o u tf her e s n n .
nu
Fo wi o ts he i e c t s p o th i sae n , u p o e si c mp o s d' (mp ss
r t u uc v d n e o u p r ter ttme td e r c s s o r mie .) e ha i
h
'
i orgi )
n i nal.
2Thecou ta s not st tt Boa d i notlmie t consde i t tc
r lo e ha he
r s
i td o
i rng ç - omm ime , prs
pos
t nt ionr lt d'f cor i d e ni whe he Sun i ls t bl 'f r l as Goodm a v.M us 201
ea e ' a t s n etnni ng
t r
s tuia e' or e e e.
n
e, 3

W L 5 2 1 ( t Ci. p . 0 2 3 ( e c rn ( n u ls e ) (x liigt t h Vign a
4 28 5 4h r Se t3 , 01 ) p r u im) u p bih d e pann ha t e r ii
paol sat e,Va.
r e t ut
Codej53.-1 r r c i rtonofpr-ommimen a non- ion
1 55,equies onsdeai
ec
t t nd prs
r a e f c or ,i l ng t gr viy oft ofe e i de e m i ngwhe he r l as on pa ol i
elt d a t s nc udi he a t
he f ns , n t r ni
t r ee e
r es

a pr p it f rb t s ceya dt p io r.
p o rae o oh o it n he rs ne)
3S nas rq e t ah ai a da k t ec u tor l t a teBo r h sn jl s ito t
u 1o e u ss e rng n s s h o r t ue h t h a d a o t id ci n o
r
decde hi prol or i t at m a i t a n a i pe ntove s g c
i s
e , n he le tve, o ppoi t n nde nde
r i ht omm itet
te o
detr i wha a ho iy t pa ol boa d has Bec us t c t s is shi c
e m ne
t ut rt he r e r
. a e he our dim s e s ompli f
ant or
f iur t sa ea cai f whih r le c n begr nt d,t c td esSun' r quess I
al e o tt l m or c e if a
a e he our eni
s e t. n

addii t c tnotst tt Boar sa hort i gove byVa.Code j53. e s .and
ton,he our e ha he
d' ut iy s
nwd
1 t eq,
S oursa e no feet r ie lgiltvee t e s'Unie St t v.Shia 253 F. 7 8
t t r t r o ewrt e sai nacm nt.' t d aes
c
r h,
2d 98, 00

(t Ci.1 )( tngCr v.Har lon,282U. 55,5 ( 930:.
4h r 958 cii ooks
res
S. 9 1
4

11
1.

Fort r as sa e t c tgr t t Boa d' m oto t dimi puruantt Rul
he e ons t t d, he our an s he r s i n o s
s
o e
,
'

1 b)6)
2( ( .

zz'

zr
#

7

c
..

ENTER : t 5, 4.
Jme 201

z
.
'

UNIYD STA ESDI CT J
X
STRI UDGE

5