Foster v. Zych

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION & ORDER DENYING request to transfer this case to California. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 12/27/2013. (tvt)

nlFRKS OFFI t.:. SX X Ur
CE J DI
AT ROANOKE,VA
CIED
I
-

DEC 27 2 1
23
TH E UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI I A
CT
RG NI
ROANOK E DI SI
VI ON
BENJAM I SHANE FO STER,
N
Pett oner,
ii
V.

CH R I O PH ER ZY C H ,
ST
R espondent
.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

Jw .
BY.k .. t.. ..

;
.,

' g c ERX
F'
'

P

Ci lA c i N o.7: : 00596
vi ton
13- v-

M EM OM NDUM O PI ON
NI
A N D O R DER
By:Sam ue G .W is
l
l on
Unied St e D i t i Judge
t
at s s r ct

Pei o e, n a nS a eFo tr b o g t hsh b a c musp tto os u d r2
tt n r Be j mi h n se, r u h t i a e s o
i
eiinpr e n e 8
U. C.j2241 a i trs
S.
, gans e ponde ,Chrsophe Zyc wade a t Unie Stt Pe tntayi
nt it r h, r n t he td aes nie ir n

Le Co n y(t Le Co mt '.Fo trcamst eFe ea Bl e u o P io C%OP' fie t
e ut I
USP e t yl se li h d r l z a f rs ns
r
' ald o
)
a co f tmehe s r d pro t BOP c t dy i t Albn aprs s t m .Fose fl d t s
c unt or i
e ve i r o
uso n he a m
ion yse
t r e hi

j2241peii i t Unie SttsDititCour f t M i eDititofAlbn whiehe
tton n he td ae src
t or he ddl src
a ma l
wasi a ce a e a USP LeeCount whih i l atd wihi t W eser DititofVigi a.
nc r r t d t
y, c s oc e t n he
t n src
r ni
On De m be 1 201 t DititCour f t M i eDiti tofAl ba ta f red
ce r 9, 3, he src
t or he ddl src
a ma r nse r
Fose ' peii t t sco tba e on hi c i me a U SP Le Co y.W hie Fose '
t rs tton o hi ur s d
s ontne nt t
e unt
l
tr s

pe ii n waspe ng,BOP ta f re hi t Fe r lCoreci na I tt i n, rong,whi h i
tto
ndi
r ns e r d m o de a
r to l nsiuto He l
c s
l a e i t Ea t r DititofCaio i Fose hasr ue t d t tt sc t r ns e hi c e
oc t d n he se n src
lf m a. t r
eq se ha hi our ta f r s as
t t Ease DititofCa iom i
o he tm src
lf a.
A f de alprs rm a c lenget m n rofe c i n ofhi s nt nc by flng a
e r ione y hal
he nne
xe uto
se e e
i
'

peiinf rwrto ha e sc mu t e 2 U. C. 2 41 ie S ae v Milr 8 F.d48 ,
tt o i f b a o s md r 8 S. j 2 .Untd tts . l , 71 2 8
o
e
490( hCi.1 )(< cl m f c e tagans as ne eatckst c
4t r 989 <A ai or r di i t e tnc ta he ompuutona exe uton
i nd c i
oft s ntnc rt rt nt s ne eis l.) Or narl j22 r quiest tapettone s k
he e e e ahe ha he e tnc tef' . di iy 41 e r ha
'
ii r ee
r le i t diti tcou toft diti twhe ehi c t a i l a e Rlm se d v.Pa la 542
ei f n he src r he src
r s usodin s oc t d. z f l
dil ,

U. 426,442(
S.
2004)(ntr ei j2241t rquiet hi moet nt tt c tis ngt
i eprtng
o e r t ng r ha ha he our sui he
not

wrt v jzidcino e t ec so i
iha e l s ito v r h u td mf).Ho v r t Fo rhCic t ssae t t
r
we e ,he u t ruiha ttd ha
t u idcini d tr n d a tetmea a to i fld s b e u n ta se so prs n r
t rs it s eemie th i n ci n s ie ; u s q e t rn fr f io es
gj
o
o ti etejzidcin i wh c te tlda to sd e n td f a p ro a jl s ito . Uni d
u sd h l s it n ih h y ie cin o s o ee t e s n lt idcin' t
r
o
r
' e
Sae v Ed r s 2 F.d5 4(t Ci.1 9 (e czim)(ii Frn i v Rio ,8 4F.d
tt s . wad , 7 3 6 4h r 9 4) p r l a ctng a cs . s n 9 2
r
353,35 ( t Ci.1 ) s as Cha yv.O' in, 7: - 21 2007W L 11
4 9h r 990); ee lo ne
Bre No. 07001 ,
89641a *1
t

( . Va 2 07 (idigj rs cino e j2 41p tto e i d tr n da tetmeo fln ,
W D. . 0 ) fn n u idito v r 2 eiin r s eemi e t h i f i g
i
a dno dv se b hss b e u n ta se t ll oi)
n t ie td y i u s q e t rn fr o li s.
n
Ac o dn l t c u t id ta Fo trss b e u n ta se t Caio nad e n i
c r igy,he o r fn s h t se' u s q e t r n fr o lf r i o s o

dv s ti c u t f t id ci nt a d e stej2 41p t int a h flda an t h wad no
ie t h s o r o jl s ito o d r s h 2 ei o h t e ie g i s t e r e f
r
t
U SP LeeCount a whie i a ce a e wihi t W e t m Diti tofVigi a. I i t r f r
y nd l nc r x t d t n he se
src
r ni t s he e p e
.

ORDERED a ADJUDGED t tpe ii rsr ques t ta f rhîxas i DENI .
nd
ha ttone ' e t o r nse j e s
ED
ZzrW
('
e
f
EN TER
z
.. .
-œ

.'
e

: s27hda ofDe e r201
Thi t y
c mbe 3.

V. '
,'
.
z

Z

y
z.f
.A
..
.'

.

UNI s ATESDI CT J
YED
STRI UDGE

2