Ferrara v. Sisson et al

Filing 10

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 1/27/2014. (tvt)

.
*

CLERK' OFFI U. .DI COURT
S
CE s ST.
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STR I C O U RT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTE RN D I
STRI O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
R O A N O K E D I SI N
VI O
FR AN K PA U L FER R AR A,
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
V.

LO RIB.SI
SSON,e al,
t .
D ef
endants
.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

J 2? 2 1
AN
29
aUL
BY:

, U EY;
CLERK
EPU: CL
Y ERK

Ci lA cton N o.7: cv-00602
vi
i
13-

M EM OM NDUM O PI ON
NI
By:

Hon.M i hae F.Ur
c l
bans
ki
Uni e St e D i t i Judge
t d at s s r ct

Fr PaulFe r r ,aVigi ai a epr ee ng pr K ,fl d aCompli ptrua tt 42
nnk
ra a
r ni nm t oc di
o
ie
ant ts n o

U. C.j1 3a Vigni lw.Pli ifal est tdefnda sLor B.Sis a DinaD.
S. 98 nd r i a a
antf leg ha e nt i son nd a
M oor who ar t sa epr ton ofi r ,f ie t e ur Pl i ifsr ha lt to a r quie
e,
e wo t t oba i
tce s al d o ns e antf e biiai n s e r d
by sae a f de a l ws Afe r vi ngPl i ifss
t t nd e r l a . tr e ewi
antf ubmi sons t c t s is a1 cli s
s i ,he our dim s es l am

wih u p eu ie
t o t rj dc .
Def nda Si s be m e Pl i if spr to of i e once Pl i i fwa r e e f om
e nt s on ca
a ntf ' oba i n fc r
a ntf s el as d r

i a c r ton a i o t co muniy ofW i he t r Vig ni Pl ntf bei vest tSis had
nc r e a i nd nt he m
t
nc se , r i a. ai if le ha s on
a l ga d y,pur ua t s a e a f de a l w s t e u e hi r ha lt ton,whi h w a be t
e l ut
s nt o t t nd e r l a , o ns r s e biia i
c
s s
a com pls d by ta f r i hi s r i i t R i hm ond, i g ni w he e he c d r c i
c
ihe
r ns e rng s upe v s on o c
V r i a, r
oul e e ve

mor s
e uppor a a ve e a oft a med s r ies Pl ntf f t rbe ive t tSi s br a d
t s t r n he r
e vc . ai if urhe le s ha s on e che
t tdu y by kee ng hi i W i hese ,whe ehewasf lel a us d ofi e e ur a
ha t
pi m n nc t r
r
a s y cc e
ndec nt xpos e nd
r -nca c aed. Pl i ifs e da a fom Sis n a he s r ior Dine D. oor
e i r er t
antf e ks m ges r
s o nd r upe v s , a
M e.
Pl i ifca tpr ee i t sa ton a ns D e e nt f r Si s salege br ac of
a ntf nno oc d n hi c i gai t f nda s o s on' l d e h

t dutesasPli tf spr ton ofi rbe us acli ofne i nc doe no sa eavi ai
he i
a n if oba i
fce ca e am
glge e s t t t
ol ton
oft Fourt h A m e
he
t ent
ndm e ' eq lpr e ton ordue pr es c a e. Se D a e sv. ila s
nt s ua ot c i
oc s l us
e ni l W li m ,

474U. 327,328( 986)(ttngduepr ce si no vi at bynegi nta t ofsat ofi il
S.
1
sai
o s s t ol ed
lge cs t e tcas

t a c u eu i tn e ls o ij r ) M o s nv. ra hy, 3 F.d6 , 4( 0 )(ttn
h t a s n ne d d o s r nu y ; nio Gar g t 2 9 3 48 65 2 01 saig

4

a e u l r tcincam rq ie çn e to l rp r o e u'ds rmiain .F rh r r ,
n q a p oe to li e u rs d tnina o u p s f l ici n to ) u temo e
i
'
Plitf c mzt r c e vaj1 3a ans M o r me eyb c u eM o r i S so ss p r io .
anif a o p o e d i 98 g i t o e rl e a s o e s is n' u e vs r
Se M onelv. p' ofSo Sevs, U. 658,663n. ( 978 (ttngr s
e
l De t
c. r .436 S.
7 1 ) sai epondea s rori
t upei s
nota tona evi j 1 .Acc di y, antf sf rlcai aedimis dwihout
ci bl a 983)
or ngl Pli if edea l ms r s se t

p eu ief rfii t saeacam u o wh c rle ma beg a td pzs a t o2 U..
rj dc o al o tt li p n ih eif y rn e , l u n t 8 SC.
ng
r

j1 5 b ( ) Th c u t e l st e e cs s ppe na j rs ito o e a ysae1w cam
91 A( )1. e o r d ci o x r ie u lme tlu id ci n v r n tt a li
ne
r ae t t algai i t Compli spurua tt 28U. C.j 1 c.
eltd o he le tons n he
ant s n o
S.
367()
EN TER : Thi
s

V.
3

d yo J nu r , 2014.
a f a ay

#/

r l'r .*n - 2
' #
r
Unie Stt sDiti tJ
t d a e src udge

2