Green v. Colvin
Filing
17
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/14/2014. (lab)
cœ RK' OFFI U . DI . COtRT
s
CE s. ST Z J
AT G OKE,
VA
FtEB
L
I THEUNI STATESDITRI COURT
N
TED
S CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROA NO KE DI I ON
V SI
0CT 1j 2 1
24
JULW , l
D a
BY'
V I I BRJ EGA R G REEN ,
V AN
N
Ci lAc i N o. 7: 4CV 00039
vi ton
1
Pl ntf ,
ai i f
M EM O R AND U M O PI I N
N O
CA RO LYN W .C OLV W ,A ctng
i
Com m i s one ofSoc al
si r
i
Se ur t
c iy,
By:
Hon. e E.Comud
Gln
ChifUnied St t sDititJ ge
e
t
a e src ud
De e
f ndant
.
Pl ntf ha fl d t s a ton c lngi t fna de ii oft Commi sone of Soc a
ai if s ie hi ci hale ng he i l c son
he
si r
il
Se rt de ng pl ntf scli f ape i ofdia lt a dia lt i ur nc bene isunde t
cu iy nyi ai if am or rod
s biiy nd s biiy ns a e
ft
r he
Soca Se urt Ac, sa nded, U. C.jj41 i a 423.J iditonoft sco ti purua t
il c iy ta me
42 S.
6() nd
urs ci
hi ur s s nto
j g)oft Ac, U. C. 405() Asr lce byt me a a agume s te byt
205(
he t42 S. j g . efe td he mornda nd r nt ubmitd he
pa tes t is sbef e t scou ta e whehert Comm isone ' fna de ii n i s ppo td by
ri , he s ue
or hi
r r
t he
s i rs i l c so s u re
s t nta e de e, nd i i i not whe he pl i ifhasm e t bur n ofpr a pr c i d by a
ubs a i l vi nc a f t s , t r a ntf
t he de
oof s es r be
nd
pur ua t t Act St t d br e l s t ntale d e hasbe n de i d a s h r l va e de ,
s nt o he
. a e i fy, ubs a i vi enc
e fne s uc e e nt vi nce
c i rngt r c d a awhol a m i bef
onsde i he e or s
e, s ght ound a quaet s
de t o uppor aco usonby ar a ona e
t ncl i
e s bl
mi Rihads nv. r e ,402U. 389,401(1 71.
nd. c r o Peals
S.
9 )
The pl i if V i a Brneg r G r e was bor on D e e be 1 1
a ntf , vi n i a
e n,
n
c m r 8, 957, a eve ualy
nd
nt l
c ee he hih shoole ai Mr Gr e as c eed oneye rofc lge. ( 44)
ompltd r g c
duc ton. s. e n lo omplt
a
ole
TR .
Pl n ifha bee e pl d asar s r t r t r pi t de i or r a s m bl lnew o ke , ndw at es
ai tf s n m oye
e pia o y he a s , l w ke , s e y i
r ra
ir s.
Appae l M r.Gr nl twor donar ulra s ti dba i i 2009.( 233- .
rnty, s ee as ke
eg a nd usane ss n
TR
34)
l s e st tpl i iffrtfl da i tonsf diabiiyi ur ncebe ft and s eme a
t e m ha antf is ie pplcai or s lt ns a
ne is
uppl nt l
s t iy i om e be tt on M a 24,2007. Thes cl i sw e e de ed upon i talc i r ton a
ec t t nc
r
ne i s
y
e am
r ni
nii ons de a i nd
r onsdeai
ec i rton. She t n rquese a rc i d a X novo he zng and r e beor a
he e td nd e eve
ai
eviw f e n
Admi sr tveLa J
nita i
w udge.I a opi onda e Nove r4,
n n ni
td
mbe 2009,heLa J
t
w udgea s de e m i dt t
lo t r ne ha
M r Gr e wa notdia e The La J
s. e n s
s bl d.
w udge' o ni wa a ed a t tna d ii n oft
s pi on s dopt s he i l ec so
he
Co mi so rby t Soc a Sec rt Admi sr to sAp a sCounc l M r .Gr e a ald t
m s i ne
he i l u iy
nitai n' pe l
i.
s e n ppe e he
adve s de i i t t Unie St t DititCour f t Ea t l DititofVigi a.Howeve , he
r e c son o he t d aes src
t or he sem src
r ni
rt
dit i tc t tm a el a tr ed t Com m i s one ' fnalde i i
s rc our uli t y fi m
he
s i rs i
c s on.
On Oc obe 21 201 pl ntf fl d ne a ia i f d s biiy i ur e be ft a
t r , 0, ai if ie w pplc tons or ia lt ns anc ne is nd
s e nt l e urt i om ebe ft .Sheal edt ts
uppl me a s c iy nc
ne is
leg ha hebe media e oral or sofs t nta
cn
s bl df 1f m
ubsa i l
ga nf e pl
i ul m oyme on Ocobe 1 2009 due t s na se i,de ne ai dic diea e bipolr
nt
t r ,
o pi l tnoss ge r tve s s s , - a
dior r de e so a pos-r uma i sr s dior r She now m ant i t ts ha r mai d
s de , pr s i n, nd tta tc te s s de .
i ans ha he s e ne
di a e t t pr s nttm e A st he ap i to f dia lt i ur nc be ks t r co dr ve l
s bld o he e e i .
o r plcai n or s biiy ns a e net , he e r e a s
t tM r . e nm e t i ur sausr quie nt oft Ac t oug t fr tq trof201 butno
ha s Gr e
t he ns ed t t e r me s he t hr h he is uare
0,
t
t ra tr Seece r l 42U. C. 41 ia 423() Cons ue l pli ifse tte odia lt
hee fe .
nealv
S. jj 6() nd a . eq nty, antfi nildt s biiy
i ur nc be iso yi s hase t bls d t ts wasdia e f a 1f r ofs t nta g nf
ns a e neft nl f he
sa ihe ha he
s bl d or 1 o ms ubsa il ai ul
e ly n o o b f r M ac 31 2 0 S eg n r l , 2U. C. 4 3 a.
mpo me t n r eo e rh , 01 . e e eal 4 S. j 2 ()
y
As t he cai f r s pplme a s urt i ome be ft ,i wa de e m i d u
o r l m o u e nt l ec iy nc
ne is t s t r ne pon i ta
nii l
c i r ton t tM r .Gr n wasdi a e f ral f m sofs t nta ga nf e pl ym e a oft
ons de a i ha s ee
s bl d o l or
ubs a i l i ul m o nt s he
d t o he a pl ain f
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?