Clark v. Clarke
Filing
30
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 2/28/2017. (slt)
CLERKS OFFI U.S. ST COURT
CE
DI .
AT ROANOG ,
VA
FL
JED
MA2 û1 2 1
27
I TH E U N I D STATE S D I
N
TE
STRI CO U RT
CT
FOR THE W ES
TERN DI TRJ OFW RGI A
S CT
NI
ROAN O K E D I SI N
W O
JU
BY:
EY CLERK
CL
E
BM NDON J ES CIARK,
AM
,
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
Pet t oner
ii
,
H ARO LD W .CL ARI ,
G
Res
pondent
.
CASE N O .7:
14CV00042
M EM O RAN D U M O PI ION
N
By:H on.M i
chaelF.Ur
bansd
l
Ulie St t Diti tJ
zt d a es src udge
Br n J m e Clr ,aVigni i t p oc e i pc . ,f e t spei f r a
a don a s a k
ri a nmae r e dng -q K û d hi t
don o
wzt of ha a c r s p s a t 28 U.. j 2 5 c le g n t v lct of hi
i
be s o pu , uru nt o
SC. 2 4, haln i g he aiiy
l
s
c nfne nto a jd me b t Cic tCou toft Ciy ofW a neboz Repond nt
o i me n u g nt y he z ui r he t
y s o. s e
fld a mod t cil s Clr sj 2 5 pei ,a Clr r s e ,m a ig t e matz
le
on o l nis ak' 2 4 t
s
éon nd a k epond d kn h te
rpe f diposton. Afe r viw oft r oz t c tconcudest tClr s c nm ha
i or s ii
tr e e
he ec d, he our
l
ha a k' l i
s
no m e i,r quii t m oton t dimi st begr nt
rt e tng he i o s s o
a ed.
1.
Backgr
ound
Clr w a c ct d of one c
ak
s onvi e
ount of bur l r wih a w e pon, t c
gay t
a
wo ount of
s
a a t m aii woundi t c
ggr va ed lcous
ng, wo ount ofus ofa f a m whie c
s
e
ue r
l omm idng a f l
t
e ony,
a onec un o sre g n pat i do ivovngajv ni . Afe Clr sdie ta pe l
nd
o t f tet a g zi pa n n li u e l tz ak' tc p a
c
e
a sa e ha as pe ii w e e uns c sul he fl t pr e f a ha as pe ii
nd t t be
tton r
uc es f ,
ied he es nt eder l be
tton
pu s ntt 2 U. C.j 2 41 Th dstc c zti tal de e rle be a e Clr h d
rua o 8 S.
2 . e itit ok niil nid eif c us ak a
r
y
f ie t e us sa e r m edi , a
a ld o xha t t t e
es nd t c ut a s deni Clt s m odon f
he ot
lo
ed
a k'
or
z onsde a i
ec i r ton. H owe r t Fotr h Cic t Cour of Appe l r m a d f f t r
ve , he
zt t ui
t
a s e nde or ut he
pr e ngs The f ct .nd pr edur l hit y pe tnent t Clr s ha as cni a e a
oc edi .
a sa
oc
a sor r i
o a k' be l m t s
f l s
olow .
O n t ni ofN ove be 25,2006,Cl k w e t AprlTuz rsaparm e a 216
he ght
m r
at nt o
i
ne '
t nt t
Sout W i
h nchese Ave ,i W a nes o. Fi pe e we e i i t a t e :Tur z
tr
nue n y bor
ve opl r nsde he parm nt
ne ,
Tur rsf - e zod da g e , jve l n me JP.f tre n y a - d K. .a eg e nne' i y a - l u htr a u ni a d . , o zt e - e rol W , nd ihte
ve
e
) a-l J me Go d n O' in (lok wna f B. o < a 't sa tr fraCrps
r rod a s r o Bre as no s f ' r f b, he lng em o
e
O. ' Cr 7
i
g ng me r. Clr a f l w Blodsg ng me r W . Ra ha W a hng o a
a
mbe) a k nd el
o o
a
mbe sS. , s me s i t n, nd
J da S tcda a r c d t e a rme twih r d ba a sc v rn t etfc sl SW .
or n til nd pp oa he h pat n t e nd na o e ig h i a e . .
knoc
ked on Ttr rs door butTur r r us d t l t m i sa
zne '
,
ne ef e o et he n, t dng, r o not com e i
ç
D
n.
D on' brng t st m y hous ' H 'g Tz. .2,5.
t i hi o
e.' r
vol
S. .pus d Tur r ba kwa ds and S. . W as ngt Sti a a Clr br
W
he
ne c r
W ,
hi on, tcklnd, nd a k oke
i o t a tm e . S. . s ood ove Tut r whie W a hngt Sti klnd, a Clr
nt he pa t nt
W t
r
ne
l
s
on, tc a
nd a k
pr e
oc eded t a bedr
o
oom whe e t y s K . .onc i t lg,a as s O ' in f r
r he hot W
e n he e nd lo hot Bre ou.
orfve tm es The bule t tsnz k K . .l
i i .
lt ha t c W odged i he t gh a s had a sg fc nts a .
n r hi nd he
imii a c r
O ' i n l ti e nalor nsa ha s na c d da a ,wih abuletr m ni ng l d ne
Bte os nt r
ga nd d pi l or m ge t
l e ni odge xt
t hi s ne He a s ha acol t y a a ieos om y.
o s pi .
lo d
osom nd n l t
Clt fe t s ene,a w a l t a r t d i N e
a k l d he c
nd s aer r ese n wpor N e on D e m be 1 2006.
t ws
ce r ,
Upon a r s ,polc f
r e t i e ound a . c lbe ha
3z- ai r ndpm izCl r spos es i a t bule si t t
r a k'
s son, nd he lt n ha
ha
ndgun m at he a s l f
c d hel ound i Tur rs pa l l . Cl z conf s t t he s a
n
ne ' rdng ot
ak
es ed ha
hot t
O ' i a sa ed t thewi hed O ' i n had di
Bren, nd t t ha
s
Bre
ed.
1 efu c d fndntweeme eso t NieTryG r n Teh a dGrn d s's be o teBlo s
Th o r o ee a s r mb r fhe n e Wie c s n e a e' u st f h o d
)
g n ,a ec h d amo v frteatc :1 Walngo wa u stwizhss o -ob se itr K. .frd t g
a g nd ah a
d e o h tak () si tn s p e t i o nt-e tpsse, W ,o ai
n
l
n
JP.whowa afitdwihteCr ,2 Src ln f a ab e ' t O're b cu eO' inwa sp o e t gv
.,
s fl e t h i () t ka d f d e f wi B in ea s Bre s u p sd o ie
la
ps
i
h
.
h
Srclndapso, u h dn t ()a dalo tec d fn a t weea r wihO' in atrdso eiga dBlo s
tika
itlb t a o, 3 n l f h o ee d ns z ngy t Br fe ic v z n - o d
e
n
gaf:(Blo Kie' o amal xo ti tea rme t
rfi f o d 1 r' n i
ç
1)
bo usde h pat n.
2
O n M a 2,2007,Clr ent r d a A lor guit p1a i t Cic tCour oft Ciy
y
a k e e n f d ly e 2 n he t ui
t he t
ofW a s o,a w a c ct of bur ar wih a we pon,t c
yne bor nd s onvi ed
gl y t
.
a
wo ount of a a t d
s
ggr va e
m aii w oundi t count ofus of a f t i c m ison of a f l
lc ous
ng, wo
s
e
aeq. n om s i
m
eony,a s r et
nd te
ga gpatcpa ni oligajve i .
n rii ùo nv vn u nl
e
A t hi s e i he rng,Clr t tfed t t he ha r m aned outi durng t
s ent nc ng a i
a k esii ha
d e i
sde i he
s
hootng,a as S. . W a hi on,a Sti klnd r n f om t s ne one of t
i
nd
W , s ngt
nd rc a
a r
he ce ,
hem ha
d
gve hi t 32- ai rw e pon.H e he r guns sfom t pa l l ,butdi notknow
i n m he c lbe a
ad
hot r he tdng ot
d
who ha fr d t m .Al o,Cl r cam ed t theha fr d t s l f
d le he
s
a k li
ha
d le he hel ound a t s nea da
t he ce
y
pror t t s
i o he hootngs Clr c am e t t hi ea le c e sons we e les t pr ec t
i . a k l i d ha s rir onf s i
r i o ot t he
younge pa tcpant .
r rii s
Thej g sntncd Clr t a a t tr off t-hzey asi
ud e e e e ak o n ci em
ve
oryt e e r n
Prs 3
ionClr s c
a k' odef ndant ,W a hi on a St l nd,pladed gtit a we e c ct d
e
s
s ngt nd dcda
e
zly nd r onvi e
oft s m e sx ofe e asClr W as ngt and Sti a ci note e Alor plas
he a
i f ns s
a k.
hi on
rcklnd ld
nt r f d e .
Clr ptr ue diec a
a k zs d r t ppeas a gu ng t tt tilc ute r i notf t rr ducng
l, r i ha he ra ot r ed n
urhe e i
li s nt
ns e ence due t mi i e dence pr
o dgaton vi
oduc a s nt ncng. Clr cnm ed t t t
ed t e e i
a k li
ha he
nltgaton e de e de onsr ed t the wa ac al i
ii i vi nc m
tat ha
s m ly nnoc ntor onl nnni al i ol d
e
y i m ly t ve
w
i t ctm es The Cour ofAppeasofVigi a a ft
n he i .
t
l
r ni fi- hi c
med s onvi ton,hollng t tft e
ci
ci ha fher
i s t nta e denc a i tt def ndanti t i m a t r...s fc e f ahndi ofguit
s ubsa il vi e gans he e
n l s te
a
uf i nt or
ng
l
on a lsx c r s' a t t t s e i pos waswihi t r nge pr s tbed by lw .
l i ha ge , nd ha he entnce m
'
ed
t n he a
e ci
a
2No t Caoi v Alod 4 0U..2 (9 0 (eo nzn ta d fn a tma pedg 'ywhl manqnn
rh rlm . f r, 0 S 5 1 7 ) rc g iig h t ee d n y la ut i itiig
r
l
t e
in cnc)
n o e e.
3 Clr ' i c m e c r i d a pot nda m a i
a k s ndit nt a re
e l x mum s nt nc of t e lf fm e pl eght en ye z . 'he
e e e
hr e ie i s us i e
as F
Com monwe lh a gu d f a a dve s nt nc of f t eg ye r ;Clr s a t he a gue t t c ts ul o y
a t r e or n c
e e e ory- iht a s a k' tor y r d hat he our ho d nl
i
mpos t mi m lm m a t y s nt nc s ''e s e i g dei sr c mende ar ng be we n t n y r a fve
e he ni l
nda or e e e . Ih ent ncng ui lne e om
d a e t e e ea s nd i
m ont t > e p t e ye r a t m ont , t am i i ofni t e ye r and f m . ont .
hs o nt hr e a s nd wo
hs wih
dpo nt ne e n a s
o m hs
3
Clr v.Co
ak
mmon at 2 08Va Ap LEXI 2 4 2 0 WJ 2 9 6 ,a * n. ( y1 ,
welh, 0
. p.
S 3 , 0 8 = 01 5 1 t 1 4 Ma 3
2 08.TheS pr meCo tofVigni r f s dt v e Clr tmeyfld ape in f awrt
0 )
u e
ur
r i a e u e e iw. a k i l l
e
dto or i
ofha as c us i t Cic tCott of t Ciy ofW a s o,r sng fve c nm s4 O n
be om
n he r ui
zt he t
yne bor aii i l i .
O ct7,2009,t cr tc tdeni habea r lef a Cl r di notpt ue a ha a a
he icui our
ed
s ei , nd a k d
us
be s ppea
l
t t Supr m e Cour ofVigi a.
o he
e
t
r ni
On J n r 31 2 4,Clr f d a peion f r a wrtofha e s c r i fde a
a ua y , 01 ak ie
tt o
i
i
b a o pus n e r l
cititc r. Hi j 2 5 peiin a s rs a sn l 5 h Ame me cnm:Tra c uns l
l rc ou t s 2 4 tto s e t ige 1t
s
nd nt li il o e
'
(
r
ende e i f tve as it nc by a sng and al wi Clz t ent r i o a Alor guit
r d nefec i
ss a e
dvii
lo ng a k o e nt n f d ly
pla whe c
e
n ouns ldi not beive Clr w a guit of t c i es he wa ad sng hi t
e d
le
a k s ly
he rm
s vii
m o
plad guit t a whih Clr di notcom nnt I s
e
ly o, nd c a k d
i. n uppor ofhi pe
t
s édon,Clr s nis a
a k ubr t
2011 unexe ut d a fda ta s ve a lte sfom one oft vi tm s O ' i n,a l te fom
c e fi vi nd e r l e t r r
he c i , Bre
et r r
a pts rna e f el Boyy a a s a 201 a fda tfom c
ione m d Y la
' nd l o
'
3 fi vi r
odef nda W as ngt The
e nt
hi on.
m a e i l s a e t t Clr di not s
t ras t t ha a k d
hoot O ' i n,a t Cl r was out i i t sr t
Bre nd hat a k
sde n he tee
when t s
he hootng oc uted.
i
c r
Clr ha notr ie tas c am i any Vigi a c t t ,hi cni i pr dut l
ak s
as d li l i n
r ni our; hus s l m s oce al
y
bar dbyCoe n v. m s n,5 1U. 7 2 ( 9 1 .Alo li cnm i Hmebar d u e
re
lma Tho o 0 S. 2 1 9 ) s ,as li s - re nd r
Va Cod j8016 4( ()a 28U. C. 2 4 .Clr ag e ta u e S hl v. l,
. e . - 5 A)2 nd
S. j 2 4$) ak r u s h t nd r c u Deo
5 3 U. 2 ( 9 ) a M c ignv. tcns 1 3S. .1 2 ( 1 ) hi a t a i noc nc
1 S. 98 1 95, nd oug i Pel , 3 Ct 9 4 20 3 , s c u l n e e
i
of t c i e e us t pr edur ldef ul a tm e- r unde a s a t oflnzt tons
he rm s xc es he oc
a
a t nd i ba
r ny t m e
i ia i .
Thediti tcour i tal dir s e Cl k' f r lha a pe i f f iur t e us sat
src
t nii l snis d ar s ede a be s tdon or a l e o xha t t e
y
4Clr' E esaeha escqmsweea fl ws ()Clr wa d ne hsz tt aprl n r h aip ()
aks v tt b a li
r s ol : a ak s e id i kh o ei ay ezz b
o
mi
t
Clr'pe wa iv l aya iwa c ec da ma eu d rd rs;c Clr 'mud l c n d nsvoae hir
aks la s n ol t s t s o re nd d n e ues () aks lpe o dc o iltd s kht
mt
t b fe fo d u l jo ad ;d c u sl siefcvea ta a do a pela ()teeie c wa is h int
o e re rm o be e p r y () o n e wa n fe d tr l n n p a; nd e h vd n e s nufce
i
ts
o uppor t c i éons
t he onv c .
4
r me is Clr v.Clz , 7:4 c - 00 2 ( . Va Fe 1 ,2 4 ( No. ) Clt
e de . ak
ake No. 1 -v 0 4 W D. . b. 0 01 ) ECF
3 . ak
s
oughtr consde a
e
i r éon of t dimi s ,whih was de e Clr v.Clt ,N o.7:4- vhe s s al
c
nid. a k
a ke
1 c
0 4 ( . Va Apr 1 , 01 )( No. )
00 2 W D. . . 0 2 4 ECF 7.
Clr a ald t t Fourh Ciczt Cour of Appe l, a t Cour of Appeas
a k ppe e o he
t r ti
t
a s nd he
t
l
r ve s d t dimi s la r a
e r e he s s a nd em nded t t diti tc t diec i t c tt t e tCl s
o he s rc our, r tng he our o r a rk'
cli a e us e a de aule unde S a t v.D ie t D e ' of Cor eci ,439 F.
nm s xha t d nd f t d
r r ow
r c or
t
r tons
S p. 5 4 ( D. . 0 6 .TheCoztofAp ash l t tt dsdc c ur s u dha e
up 2d 8 E. Va 2 0 )
lr
pe l ed ha he it t o t ho l v
dee mi e ()wh t r Clr ' a ma i c nc cnm e c e t pr c d a dea ta d
tr n d 1 ehe a ks c l nno e e li x us s he o e url ful n
un i l s ofhi j2 5 p é i ,a d ()i Clr ' a ma i c nc d se c eh sd uby
tmei s s 2 4 e ton n 2 f aks c lnno e e oe x us i o l
ne
de a t d pe ii whet r t unde li i f ctve asi tnce ofcouns lcqm hasm ert
f ule
tton,
he he
ry ng nefe i
ssa
e li
i.
Clz v. a k , 1 - 1 ( t Ci. y1 , 01 )( No. 3 .
ak Clr e No. 4 66 5 4 h r Ma 1 2 6 ECF 1 )
I
I.
A c ualI
t
nnocence
A. St
andar ofRevi
d
ew
The Ant e r im a Efe tv De t Pe at Ac of1 6 (
i rors nd fci e ah n l t
t
y
99 AEDPA) s v tl
e e ey
r s rct f de alha asr le a f de t sa e prs r . fG e r ly,a f de alcolt m a not
e ti s e r
be ei f for d o tt ione s f ne al
e r
zt y
consde cqm st a pe ii r f ied t r ie a t tm e and i t m a rt quied unde
i r li hat
ttone al o a s t he i
n he nne e r
r
saelm ' Tee uzv.Zoo 8 6F. 8 3 8 7 (t Ci.2 5 (iai o te ) fAn
tt a ' l
k, 0 3d 0 , 0 4h t 01 ) ctt mitd. f j
on
g
e e i i m ade f c s i wl c a com pelng s
xc pton s
or a es n a h
i
li howi of a ua i
ng
ct l nnoc
ence e bl s a
na e
f a cour t consde t m elt ofa pe i
eder l
to
i r he i s
tdone ' ot wie def uled c m s' I For a
rs her s
a t bi . d.
'
peiine t czm a t a i c nc ,fn w)e i e c mus e tbls s fkin do bta tg
tto r o li c u lnno e e t e v d n e t sa ih u f e t u bou a
g
peiine 'jgul t j tf t c ncuson t a hi g a c r to jwo l bea M s ara of
tto zs i o usiy he o l i h t s i r e ain u d
t
nc
c rige
j tc u l s li c n ci wa t pr d t of a fi til' Sc l ,5 3 U..a 3 6
usie ne zs o viton s he o uc
s
ar ra.
' hu 1 S t 1
5
(mp ss i o ii a) Ac u li c nc f oe no y isl p o i e a ba i f r r l f
e ha i n rg n l. t a nno e e f s tb tef r v d
d
ss o ei .
e
I ta ,Fhepei ne ')cnm f rr le d pe ciial on t vai t ofli (r c d al
nse d
t rs li o eif e nds rtc l
do
y he l y as p o e url
di
y
d futd camq' S hl ,5 3 U. a 31 (i g He r r v.Col ,5 6 U. 3 0 40
e a le li . c u 1 S. t 5 cén rea
'
li 0 S. 9 , 3
ns
( 9 3)
1 9 ).
f -qbe s c muspei t a a va e a s bsa ilczm ofa t a i c nc a e
f la a o
r
téons h t d nc u tnta li
c u l nno e e r
e r m ey r r .: I a 322. To sa e s h a c nm ,t pe ii r m us s ts y a frgor '
xte l a e' d. t
t t uc
l i he ttone
t a if fi ous'
bu d n by < up ti qhsalg to ofc s ui na e r rwih ne r l bl e i nc re
f porg i le ai ns on ét to l ro t w ei e vde e
s
ng
a
whe he i be e ul t y s i ii e dence tus wor hy e wine s ac ount ,or c iia
t rt
xc pa or centfc vi
, r t t ye t s c
s
rtc l
ph sc le i nc t a wa no p e e td a til' I .a 3 4 Fu t r Tg v n be n
y ia vde e h t s t r s n e t ra. d t 2 . rhe , fja i g e
'
l
c vc e . .pe ine)no l g rha t ebe ftoft pr s i ofi c n e To t
on itd . g dto r on e s h nei he eumpt
on nno e c . he
c ntay g ti r c me beo et ha a c u twihasrng a i tev s mao iy
o rr,peionej o s fr he be s o r t to - nd n h at jrt
t
oft c esc l i - pr s pton ofgt't' 1 a 326 n.
he as oncusve
e um i
ul.' d. t
42.
The diti t c t m us e t ne al e dence a m a a holsi t e hol
src our
t xani
1 vi
nd
ke
itc hr s d
det r na i a
erni ton bout t pe i
he tdone ' cai of i
rs l m
nnoce e s pa a e f om is i ur i o t
nc e r t r
t nqt'y nt he
fine sofhst l Tee u v. a s ,6 9F.d 3 2 33 ( t Ci. 01 ) Th dititc u t
ar s i da. l z Pe ron 8 3 2 , 0 4h t 2 2 . e src o r
ma c nsd r t na t eofe i nc ,Ho ev. l 5 7 U. 5 8 5 7 ( 0 ) t t n of
y o i e : he tz
r v de e us Bel 4 S. 1 , 3 20 6 , he i g
,
mi
s nison ,Mc g 1 3S Ct a 1 2 ,tecel ii o win se,Hou e 5 7U. a
ub lsi s oui/n, 3 . . t 9 8 h rcblt f te ss
i y
s, 4 S. t
537,552,a t pr tve f ce oft ne y s e ent r or H ous ,547 U. a
nd he oba i or
he wl upplm ed ec d.
e
S. t
5 8 S e v.Bel 5 3 F.d 3 2 3 1 ( . Ci.2 0 .Afe pe f znig t sa lss t e
3 9 ha
l, 9 3 7 , 8 4t r 01 ) tr ro r n hi nay i, l
h
a
dsdc c l tmus dee mi whehe Tti mor l l t a nott tn r a o b e jr r
it t oz
r
t t t ne t r f s e i y h n
i
ke
ha o e s na l l o
z
woul ha f
d ve ound pe ii rglit beyond ar s bl doubt' Sc u ,51 U . a 328.
ttone zly
ea ona e
. hl
'
3 S. t
6
I addi
n
éon, t r vi wi c t has sgnii nt l i de t m a c elbiiy
he e e ng our
i fca atm
o
ke r ci lt
a s s ent i a ua i
s es m s n ct l nnoc
ence c es Se e.. U nied St t s v.Connol ,504 F. 206,
as . e
, t
ae
l
3d
2 3 1 (s Ci.2 0 )( a peln f aeg)mo toflse ai u n ( c -eons
1 -4 1t r 0 7 The p la t f c d s n mph ss po a o fl 'j
pl
i
ji us r c nt:o ... we r g c -eon' tsi y dd noto c i ava ul ...
al e e a a n ho ve, t o fl s e tmon i
ho
he
)
c ur n c z
m
muc ofhi tsi nyr c i d s bsa da cr u tn lc robo ain. ;Unie S ae v.
h
s e tmo e eve u tn l ic msa da o r r to '
) td tt s
Go ae - nz lz 2 F.d 1 ,2 (s Ci.20 1 ( lig e de e ofpejr i wek
nzlzGo ae , 58 3 6 2 1t r 0 ) hodn vi nc
ru y s a
whe i de nde on t c e bit oft o c nvce fl ) s eas M c a v. s i de ,
n t pe d he r di l y ' o itd eons; e lo cr Va b n r
i
w
4 9 F.d 5 8 5 4 (t Ci. 0 7 ( wine si ntfe t a pelnta t emur rra til
9 3 6 , 7 6 h r 2 0 ) A t s de i d he p la s h
i
dee t ra,
but sat t t he c d not i iy t pe eta or a a l e e denta y he rng.
t ed ha
oul
dentf he m t t
t
atr vi ir
ai
fkaon bejr r n do btc ul q sin t ce blyo t sa utfc fo a t r
f e s a l t o s o u o d ueto he rdiit f hi bo a e r m nohe
l
z
i
i at a r tonal c d dic
nm e nd a i l oul s ounthi t s i ony asnot ng m or t n a ate ptt ke p
y
s e tm
hi
e ha n tm
o e
fo beng f g e a ar t' . A d src c u tma h veg e tzdifc t deem i n t
r m i pe g d s a.)
'
itit o r y a t a e fiuly tr nig he
c e biiy of e de e on a T d r c dy but t Fourh Ciczt Cour of Appeas ha
r di lt
vi nc
<
col e or '
'
he
t r ti
t
l s
al e t diti tcour t conçude t tt e de i i de t orunr ibl e
low d he src
to
l
ha he vi nce s na qua e
ela e nough t
o
dimi st pe i wihouta e denta yhe rng. Se Tee z 689 F. a 331.
s s he éton t
n vi ir a i
e l ,
3d t
B. Guit Pl
ly eas
Pl di /11 doe notentr l pr cude ape ii r fom c nm i a ua i e e
ea ng 11
s
iey e l
ttone r
l i ng ct l nnoc nc
a ha s pr ee ngs howe ,g 11 plas a pa ta conf sons çs rousy unde- i '
t bea oc di ;
ver 411 e nd ri l
esi
Te i l
t ne'
m
t e cam . S eChe tn v. io,5 2 Fe App' 38 , 0 (t Ci.2 1 )( oli t tf h
h li e
sa
S s 2 d. x 9 39 9 h r 0 3 h dng ha f e
t
e i e e ... so r l ng' s d on t pe i rsc nf si a g ut pe ) Bue
v d nc
wa ve whemi 'ba e
he dt ' o e son nd t' y la; i
one
l
v.M c o ,3 F.d 6 3,6 ( h Ci.2 0 )rfj i ha d t s e ho o who h s
Ad
41 3 2 26 7t r 0 3 g t s r o e w ne
l
a
c e s d c n a sr a t a i e e7 I Unie S ae v.Br c ,t S p e Cou tof
onfs e a se t c u l nnoc nc . n td tts
).
o e he u r me r
7
t Unie Sttshed t a by pla ig galy f he a c s d i notsmpy sa ng t a g
he td a e l h t
e dn i , f c u e s
t t
i l td h t t
he
a c e )di t edic eea t d s rbe i t i it nt l a c e ji al i ig g i ofa
c us d d h s rt c s e c i d n he ndcme ; t c usd s c t n al
he
m t
t
s bsa i ci . 4 8 U. 5 3 5 ( 9 9 . The Fou t Cicl Cou to App as h s
u tnt rme' 8 S. 6 , 70 1 8 )
ve
'
th r tt r f e l a
i
e n i tuc e diti tcotr st ge r l dinls petions t tc r ctt pla c l
ve ns r t d src zt o ne al s is i
y
ha ontadi he e oloquy.
Se St es v. Le a t , 403 F.
e at
m ser
3d
2 - 2 (t Ci.2 0 ) tfq t a e e
212 4h r 0 5 fln he bsnc
g
e r or na y cr um s a es t t u h ofs n satm e sm ade durng a Rul 11 c l
xta di r ic t nc , he r t
wor t e nt
i
e
oloquy
i concusvey esabls d, and a ditit c t s d, wihout hol ng a e de
s
l i l t ihe
stc our houl
t
di
n vi ndar
y
he dng d sns a j 2 5 m o n t tne e s rl r le on alg t t tc ta itt
a , ir is ny 2 5 do ha c s ai eis l ai ha on r dc he
y
e ons
s r sae nt.
wo n ttme s'
).
A ddii ly, guit pl s gve rs t s ve a i s
tonal
ly ea i ie o e r l s ues unde Scll : t r i no
r au he e s
fcfnde j g o j y fn l g t r c r i not l a r va e , t e sae dd no
a t r ud e r url i c n , he e o d s mal bb e it d h tt i t
i
y
T es nt'e de e i t t ca f snon t e t bls guitbe
d e ' vi nc n he ypi l a l
pr
i o s a ih l yond a r s bl doubt a
ea ona e
, nd
t pe ii r has c lm e li gtl i a pl coloquy. Se Bouse v.U nie St t ,523
he ttone
onft d as z t n
i
ea l
e
l
t d a es
U..6 4 6 -2 (99 )(c l ,J,dse tn )rglo i t c r t d tr n fcu l
S 1 , 313 1 8 S ai . isnig f- w s he ou t o eemie ata
a
ll
i
nnoc nc upon ourr m and ...whe e convi don w a bas upon a a ison ofgt't'
e e'
e
r
c
s ed
n dm si
ul?'
J s eSc l c ndnu d:f e u by t d fnda wilntod ee i e c g th dd no
u dc ai o e t s ma l he e e nt li r uc v d n e t e i t
a
pr
ha
c mmi t ci j...a t e Go r me ...wi ha t fnd a pr uc win se
o t he rme
nd h ve n nt
l ve o i nd od e t e s s
l
syn t a he di go r tt ci e. ThsS e ; t n C nO t r n e y a n c rig Of
aig h t
d c m ni he rm j i e n s o ; t o e A d Ys a ra e
j t e b t p od e o .) S at v.Bad n 5 0 F. 1 2 ,1 4 n. (t Ci.20 7
usi , ut o r uc ne'; n ih
c
'
lwi , 1 3d 1 7 1 0 9 9. r 0 )
h
r e ae a r of a po e li c ng at be we n t e pu o e of t a t a i oc nc
V r wa e
tnda n o r iy t e h m s
he cu l nn e e
g twa a u e i Sc l a is a pl a n t c s si vovn guly (z no c nts)
ae y nno nc d n h u nd t p i ùo o a e n lig i o
c
t
o et
pla .) Rui v. z lz 2 0 N =3 3 5 , 00 U. Dit LEXI 96 6 , t* n. ( D .
e s' ; z Gon ae , 0 9 V1 23 5 8 2 9 S. s.
'
S 6 8 a 8 5 C.
8
Ca.Oc.2 2 0 )( ll g ta te h be sc r f tc sde p tdo rsg lyplai
l t , 0 9 hocn h t h a a ou t f
i
mus oni r ei ne' ui e n
t
deez nn wh t rpeiine c nm e tt Sc l sa a d).
trniig ehe t o r a e he h u tnd r '
t
C. Schl Gat w ay
up
e
I poranty,t s ni T ct li
m
t l he er nal ' - nnoc nce:ca e r led on c peli e de e of
a ua
e ' s s ei
om lng vi nc
a ta i oc nc . Se Bou l ,5 U. a 6 Sodn t tça tzli e e me n
cu l nn e e e se 23 S. t 23 lig ha f caa nnocnc ' a s
d
fc u li c nc ,no me e lg li ufiinc . I S hl ,a p io s vel n e v d o
a t a nno e e t z e a ns fce y' n c u
).
rs n ut ia c i e
l
s
howed t peddone i t di ng halsxt -i s onds be or gu r r ponde t t
he
r n he ni
l i y fve ec
f e a ds es
d o he
mur rh wa c r e wih.Th peiine i cu d afda ist a ()pr f se Sc l '
de e s hag d t
e tto z n lde fi vt h t 1 o e s d hup s
ino e e ()ie iida h ri t a t asi n,()sae t tt peiine c ud
n c nc ,2 d ntfe note nmae s he sal t 3 ttd ha he t o r o l
a
t
notha t a l fom t dilng halt t m ur r s ne i t known ea e Hm e,a
ve r veed r
he ri
l o he
de ce n he
lps d
nd
()r v ae t tt e peiine ha b e u urid,c rany no a i hewa rzhig a y
4 e e ld ha h tto r d e n nh re e til t s f
s ts n wa
fom a m ur r s ene Sc u , 513 U . a 335 40. l H ous t pe i r pr e ed
r
de c . hl
S. t n
e, he téone es nt
t tm ony t tt vi tm ' hus nd had al it t s ve a pe e t the ha m ur r d hi
esi
ha he c i s ba
cm ted o e r l opl ha
d
de e s
wie,a a s c led i o quesi t pr ec i s c nta f e i pr . 547 U . at55
f nd lo al nt
ton he os uton' e r l or nsc oof
S.
4
( Co thed t a f h is g s co e'
The ur l h t r e sue wa j l s .
t
).
I pr ng a tz i
n ovi caal nnoc
ence fec ntng a hda t a e awa viw e wih Txt e e
,ft a i f vis r l ys e d t e r m
s pcon.'Wil msv.Co l,26 F.d 6 4 7 8 (t Ci.20 1 (uo gUrie Sae v.
usii ' la
'
i
e 0 3 8 , 0 61 r 0 ) q :n z d tts
n
t
Ch mbe ,9 4 F.d 1 3 1 4 ( t Ci.1 9 ) (u e s de i â to ot r r und b
- a t 4 2 25 , 26 6h t 9 1 s re d n r n he o s
U... j 2 15()) Ge r l , TW j r a m o in f r a ne til i ba e u
SSG. D . a). ne al f hee
y g
to o
w ra s s d pon
r ca aton oft tm ony gve a t t l s
e nt i
esi
i n t he da, uch t dm ony i T
es
sl
ooke upon wih t u% os
d
t he
t
s p con,'Unt d Sttsv. oh o 48 F.d 1 7 ,1 79 ( h Ci.1 7 )(uo g Un td
us ii r ie ae J ns n, 7 2 2 8 2 4t r 9 3 q dn ie
Sttsv. wi,3 F.d 1 7 1 9 ( t Ci.1 6 ),as e im t to yi c e s sa t e
ae Le s 38 2 3 , 3 6. r 9 4) k pdcs ha nl n r a e s i
h
m
9
pass S eKo aev. rema 2 6Fe . x2 0 2 2(t Ci. 0 )Sodngt t
se . e molf Quatr n, 4 d App' 7 , 7 5h r 20 7 li ha
t c e biiy ofa r a a
he r di lt
ec nt don afi vi wa r éga e whe i wasnots it d un1 eght
fda t s ni t d
n t
ubnate
i
y a sa tra c v cin) c r.d nid 5 2 U. 1 6 ( 0 9) Furhe c urs ç ve l te
e r fe on ito , e t e e , 5 S. 1 8 2 0 ). t r o t f
ha i l
t
c nfde e i g c e e a ts p te e i t t e pe nc b c us he h d no ûng
o nc n a od fnd n ') ossntncng ruh x de e e a e
a d
whatoe r t l e by i i i tng hi s l afe r c i ng a 60- t s e . D r w v.
s ve o os
ncrm na i
m ef t r e evi
yea ent nce'
?
e
Sc t 2 F.d 46 ,4 3 (t Ci.1 9 ) (ii Dr w v.S ae 7 3S. .d 2 7 2 8 ( x
ot, 8 3 0 6 5 h r 9 4 ctng e
t t, 4 W 2 0 , 2 fe .
Ctm. p.1 8 ).
i Ap 9 7)
1 1 E vi
1.
dence
A. l
ncul or Evi
pat y
dence
Clr s pl a coloquy a li sat e s t polce a a s nt ncng a e sgni ant
a k' e
l
nd ls t em nt o i nd t e e i r i ûc
e dence ofhi gtit D urng hi pl coloquy,Clz t tfe t he a hi a t ne ha
vi
s zl.
i
s ea l
a k esii d hat
nd s tor y d
dic s d t c r , t ee e s of t c r , a wha t Com m onwe lh was
s us e he ha ges he lm nt
he ha ges nd
t he
at
r quied t pr bef e he c d be f
e r o ove or
oul
ound 5 11 H e s a e t he ha ha a qua e tm e
11.
t t d hat
d d de t i
t m e t and conf r wih hi a ne r ga di t c e a a def ns he ha t t
o
e
e t s tor y e r ng he as nd ny
e es
d o he
c r . Folowi t Comm onweat s pt s a i ofa s m a y oft e de e,Cl r
ha ges
l ng he
lh' e ent ton
um r
he vi nc
ak
satd t he had f e l a vol a iy de i t plad guit ,be us he di notwa t
t e hat
r ey nd unt rl c ded o e
ly ca e
d
nt o
rs a l e ji s ntnc fo beng f nd gét a til E e as t l t c r t a he
ik ong r al e e e z m i ou tly t ra. l lo od he ou t h t
unde sood t tby pl adi gait ,he wa w avi s ve a ofhi rght ,i l ng hi rghtt
rt
ha
e ng ly
s i ng e r l
s i s ncudi
si o
a tilbyj y a li rg t pr s nte i e ea c fo h sa c e s Het sxe t a
ra ur nd ls iht o e e v d nc nd on r nt i c usr .
et d h t
no one ha c r e li i o pl di guit ,a t he wass fed wih t s r e of
d oe c d nm nt ea ng ly nd hat
aés i
t he e dc s
.
li a t ne
ns tor y.
10
A ts nt i t Com m onw e lh t nde ed fa s t néalpr f roft e de e ...
e encng, he
at e r < ubs a
ofe
he vi nc
i s ppo toft e g i y pla'b p e e tng e i nc t tClr c nf se t () fb g hs
n u t h ul e ' y r s n i vde e ha a k o e s d o: 1 s n i
t
t
3 - ai rp sol n bu nn on ofO' in' bl ba a s( i ga g c o s i fo of
z c l it a d r ig e
be
Bre s ue nd na Crps n olr) n r nt
.
Tur rs a rm e t da be or t s i i r a iton f Hva Crpsl a r O ' in
ne ' pa t nt he y f e he hootng n etla i or l i e de Bre
wrtn f oodI l zii g aiti Tune' a r e palngl ,()gvn W ahngo a
iig f
Bl oie' n rfiin r rs par nt rd ot 2 iig s i tn
l
gu ()s tn a K. . nd O' in wih a.z-ai rwe pon ()ftngt pit lo ea
n, 3 hoo ig t W a
Bre t 3 c l
be a , 4 ti he so nc t
O' in beo e lsg jmme ,()fei t a rme beo ehe wa a l t fx hs
Bze fr n un a d 5 leng he pat nt fr
i
s be o l i
jmme wepon,()wihig ta O' in ha did bea eClr wa g ig t sr etme
a d a
6 s n h t Bre d e cus ak s on o ev i
a y yf rt e s tn ,a ()sa g t tK. .dd no d sr et bes ot S eClr v.
n wa o h hoo igs nd 7 tdn ha W i t e e v o h . e ak
Com m onweat 2008 W L 2019561 2008 Va.
lh,
,
App.LEXI 234,at*1 n. H rg Tr vol 2,4S
4; ' . .
20,80- Furhe ,t Com m onwe 1h i t
82.
t r he
at ntoduc e de e t t polce had dicove ed a
ed vi nc ha
i
s r
s l c i at t c i e s e pa ki l t t m at
hel asng
he rm c n: r ng ot ha
ched s ls c aned i a . cai r
hel ont i
n 3z- lbe
wea
pon f
ound on Clt whe hewasa r t i N e
ak
n
r esed n wpor N e son D ec m ber1 2006.
t w
e
,
The Com m onw e 1h ac
at knowldge t Clr s s a e ent t polc about hi own
e d hat a k' t t m s o
ie
s
i ve e we e i
nvol m nt r nconssent but e r m ey i ul or Re r ng t . cai pit
it ,
xte l nc pat y. ga di he 32- 1bet sol
t t polce r cove ed on Clr durng hi a r s ,Cl k intal i or e N e
ha
i e r
ak
i
s r e t ar tiily nf m d wpor N e s
t w
O fi rSny t t the sol t we pon f om li unce,butt n l t rs i t the boughti
fce
de ha
t e he a
r ls l
he a e ad ha
t
of t s t t of Cha l t vil Clr t d a com plt l dif r nt s or t W a nes o
f he tee s
rotes le. a k ol
e ey fe e t y o
y bor
O fi r Luza r sa
fce
de , t dng t W a li on ha yel d t t O ' i was r ac ng f a gun
hat slngt
d le ha Bren
e hi or
wlie Cl r a Stikl nd we e s l outi t a r e . U pon he rng W as ngt
ll a k nd rc a
r dl
sde he pa % nt
ai
hi on
s , Clr s i t t he r n i o t a rm e a gr bbed t gun fom a dz we t
hout a k ad ha
a nt he pa t nt nd a
he
r
a r hat
O' in wa r a higi o,a s a O' in w11 t pso .Thegu jmme a Clr
Bre s e c n nt nd hot t Bre t he it l
:
n a d, nd ak
l tt apa t e . W hie e éng t f ontdoor he ate pt d t fr a he s ove hi
ef he rm nt
l xi
he r
,
t m e o te not r hot r s
he dba ki ot ea rme , uttepso jmme a an o rmnne jmme
a c nt l pat ntb h itla d g i r e i d a d.
n
I a i e ve j ta fw h zsltz Clr t l o fc r t talf rc dee da s
n n ntr iw us e ot ae , a k o d fie s ha l ou o f n nt
r
entr t a rm e bec us t y c d hea O ' i n i i ,wih Clr sa i a t y
e ed he pa t nt a e he oul
r Bre nsde t a k t tng s he
ent r d,< el i he w on' c e out t us we wilgo i ' H rg Tr vol 2,15. Clr as
e e < l) f
W
t om
o ,
l
n.' ' . .
a k lo
t d polce t t Sti a s O ' i fve tm e , a t t Sti l
ol
i ha rcklnd hot Bren i i s nd ha zcdand r ceved t .
e i
he 45cai rpit fom W a hi on,who wasgve t g by Clr
lbe sol t
s ngt
i n he un
a k.D urng quesi ng,Clr
i
toni
ak
i or ed ofi e s t t he had gi W as ngt t gu t hol be a e Cl r f s goi
nf m
fc r ha
ven
hi on he n o d c us a k t
wa
ng
go t a rme qt fsfg O. ' I . t1
t he pat nt o itiht B. d a 4.
'
Ft t r t Co
z he , he mmon at o l e sae n s fo K. . JP,a S. .a t
r
we 1h ut n d ttme t r m W , . nd W t he
i
s nt ncng hea i K . .t d polce t tW as ngt s he ,a t tf hr e i vi l
e e i
rng. W ol
i ha
hi on hot r nd ha f e ndi dua s
t
c mei g t be r ml' whl S. .so o e Tur r I .a 6 . t l of c r t t
a n t he d oo , ie W t od v r ne . d t .jP. o d h e s ha
o
'
T ak h d a g ve y bi hartl,t twa a unq hat tl, a at ug JP.di not
f r a
cl
r g isye ha s iue isye' nd l h . d
'
ho
know Clr he wa a e t i ntf li by t har t l a one oft tue m e wea i z
a k,
s bl o de iy nm
he isye s
he l e n
rng ed
ba
ndanast br i o Tut rsa rm ent J S. .jaedt tClr a Sti a s
hat oke nt
ne ' pa t . Z W tt ha ak nd rcklnd hot
.
O ' in a K . .I
Bre nd W d.
La ty,Clr f l a it hi i vem e a m e be snp i t Bl
s l a k uly dnated s nvol
nt nd m z li n he oods Afe li
. t z zs
a r t Clr m ade gang sgns whie beng phot r phe dmi pr s i a r f e a
r es, a k
i
l i
og a d
ng oce sng nd e us d n
ofi rsofe ofBur rl ng durng quesi lng bec us t i éasoft z t uz nt :81 '
fce ' f z
ge ii
i
tori
a e he ni l
he esa a , C 4,'
a s s ood f f ood l le .' Atli s nt ncng,Clr t d t cour t thi t too K O B'
lo t
or f
Bl
G lr'
zs e e i
a k ol he
t ha s a t K
M
'
m ea f e be ofBl
nt f m r
M
oods' a li fna s a e entwas To ne t ng a
y' nd ls i l t t m
:f
hi boutBl
ood,you l
ook
f
orwa d t t de l H e' s
r o he vi.
s uppos t beyour f t r' I at128,146.
ed o
a he .' d.
12
B.E xc pat y Evi
ul or
dence
A ts nt ncng,Clr ccm e t the wa ac ual i
e e i
a k li d ha
s t ly nnoc nt of t c r ,a w a
e
he ha ges nd s
pl di guit i f a of convitons a ti lt tw otl lad t sgnii a l l r prs
ea ng ly n e r
ci
t ra ha
zd e o i fc nty onge ion
sntncs Clr tsie t th arve a Tlne' a rme t fsf O' in,b ta
e e e. ak etf d ha e ri d t z rs pat nt o itkht Bre ut h t
i
r
he ne r e e e t a rm ent I t ad,he sa d be nd i t pa l 1 wlie hi
ve nt r d he pa t
. nse
t ye
hi n he rdng ot al s
c
odef ndant w e upsar a s O ' i and K . . Clr cni e t t he ha gi
e
s nt t is nd hot Bren
W
a k l m d ha
d ven
W ahigt hs.z cl rpitlt hod du n Clr' pa ne fsf wih O' in,a
s n on i 3 -ai so o l ti g aks ln d itkht t Bre nd
be
a t rt s
fe he hooéng,s e ga li bac t gun asal t ga m e be sfe
om one ve nm
k he
l he ng m t l d.
M or ove ,c
e r ouns lde onsr e t tt s l c i t tm a c d t s l i t
e m
tat d ha he hel asng ha
t he he hels n he
w e pon r cove e by N e
a
e
rd
wpor N e spolcedurng Clr sa r s ca e fom t pa ki l ,
t w
i
i
a k' r e t m r
he r ng ot
notTur rs apa t e . Clr e ane t he ha fr t tbuletpror t t ni of
ne '
rm nt a k xpii d hat
d led ha
l i o he ght
t s
he hootng,t r ait a i tt Crpsm em bert thad a hoz a Bl
i o et la e gans he i
ha
ut ed né- oodsgr ft i
afii n
Tur rspa l l .
ne ' rdng ot
Addi ly, couns l hi i e s e i onsse i s an ongs t e e t s e '
donal
e ghlght d om nc i tnc e a
t he y vé ne s s
t tm ony r ga di Clr s pr ence i t a rm e durng t s i A prlTut r
esi
e r ng a k' es
n he pa t nt i he hootng.
i
ne
o y i e tf d W a hig on SW . a d Stil nd a me t r of t s dn ,JP.
nl d n ii
e
s n t , . , n rcda spe eao s he hoo g . '
S
wrten sat e onl r e s t W a li on a S. . a i K . .S sa em e s t polc
it t em nt y ef r o
slngt nd W , nd n W ' t t nt o
ie,
s ne rs a e t t s s w Clr i i t a rm e . 1 a 57- Atone poi ,K . .
he ve t t d ha he a
a k nsde he pa t nt d. t 60.
nt W
e
ven t d polce t s w a one hundr d pe c nts e t the br he ,W as ngt ha
ol
i hat he s e
r e ur ha t ot r
hi on, d
s he ,e n t
hot r ve hough S. .ha i plc ed Sti kl nd a Clr a t s e s J . a 59.
W
d m iat tc a nd a k s he hoot r . da t
-
C. Cl k' N e Evi
ar s w
dence
Clr of e s t ca e i ofne e de e i s
a k f r wo t gores
w vi nc n uppor ofli a t ali
t as c u nnoce e c lm :
nc l i
() a fd vt fo c de e a W a lng o a d vci O' in sa ng t t Clr i
1 fi a is r m o f nd nt st t n n it
i
m Bre té ha ak s
i noc nt a ()lte sfo vci O' in a f l Bo 't a e upae Clr fo t
n e ; nd 2 etr r m it Bre nd Yel y' h t xc l t ak r m he
m
a
s
hootng ofO ' i n.
i
Bre
I W a hi on' N ove be
n
s ngt s
m r
201 afi vi, he sa ed t t he had pe s l
3 fda t
t t ha
z ona
knowldge of t s
e
he hootng of O ' i n and K . . a t Cl k w a outi i t st t
i
Bze
W , nd hat ar
s sde n he tee
w he t s
n he hooéng ha ne a wasuni ve when t s
ppe d, nd
nvol d
he hootng oc ur e W a li on
i
c r d. snngt
as m ant i d hi i
lo i ane s nnoc nc O ' in,i a une c ed O c obe 17,2011 a fda t sa e
e e. Bre n n
xe ut
t r
fi vi, t t d
t Clr di notc m i t c i e ,a s d ber l a e
hat a k d
om t he rm s nd houl
e e s d.
Clr as s it d f lte s fom O ' in. l t & s lte ,O ' in cli e
a k lo ubnate our e t r r
Bre 5 n he t e t r Bre nm d
t he ha notwrten t Com m onweat 6 a t he ne r i plc e Clr i t
hat
d
it he
lhy nd hat
ve m iat d a k n he
s ooé ,a t a hek w Clz dd nots othi S eLetrNo 1 fo J me O' in
h ng nd h t ne a k i
ho m. e te . r m a s Bre
t Br nd Clr 1 - 1( No.1 Ata h.1 . I li s c nd lte ,O' in i or d
o a on ak, 0 1 ECF
, tc ) n ls e o etr Bre nf me
Cl k t t he woul hep Clr be a e t y had no T ef' but t t O ' in wa e t
ar ha
d l a k c us he
d ,:
be
ha Bre
nt d o
f n o J r e gtika ) gil7 Le trNo.2 fo J me O' in t Brndo Clr ,9
f g n o d n s rc lnd sc. te
ba
'
r m a s Bre o a n a k
( N o 1 Ata h.1. I O' in' t idlte,O' in a lgz d f zt afda i tki
ECF . , tc ) n Bre s h r etr Bre poo ie o he fi vt a ng
s lngb cus hewa tyngt g ti noaie e LetrNo.3fom J me O' in t
o o ea e
s ri o e t trz d.S e te
r n s Bre o
Br n Clr ( t 2 2 11, ( No 1 Ata h.1. l O' in' f urhlte,O' in
a don a k Oc. 3, 0 ) 4 ECF . , tc ) n Bre s o t etr Bre
5One lte wasdaed Ocober23, 2011 a he wasNove r 1 2011 a t ot r. lter wer
e tr
t
t
, not r
mbe 6,
, nd he he t et s e
wo
undae
td.
6 O ' in was r f encng t Or on M ot t M odiy Sentnce Com monw e t v. Clr No.
Bre
eer i he der
.
o
f
e ,
alh
a k,
CR0 0 1 7 1 2 a 1 ( .Ci.Ct Oc.3 2 0 ) ta sae ta O' in ha wrte te Co n at,
8 00 0 - 1 , t Va r . t , 0 7 , h t ttd h t Bre d itn h mmo we 1
h
i omigteprsc tr $ )ta E Bre )wa ben c ec da dtr ae e b Mr Clr whi b t me wee
nfr n h o e uo:t h t o' in s ig o re n he tn d y . ak l oh n r
1
e
ic reae a MideRie Re in l al2)ta Mr Clr wa sil fiae wi c rang n s a d3 ta te
n acrtd t d l v r go a Ji; h t . ak s tlafl td t eti a g ; n ) h t h
i
h
c e so t lte ss it t t Cour by M r Clr we efle.
ontnt f he etr ubm ted o he
t
. ak r as '
'
s a e t he kne t Clr had nots hi ,butt tSti kl ha bee t s
t t d hat
w hat a k
hot m
ha zc and d
n he hootr
e,
a O ' in wo l tsiy t t a f c. Se LetrN o.4 fom J me O' in t Bt ndo
nd Bre u d e tf o h t a t e te
r a s Bre o a n
Clr ( v.1 ,2 1,5 6 ( No.1 Ata h.1 . O' in a k wld d t tt r wee
a k No 6 01 ) - ECF
, tc ) Bre c no e ge ha he e z
no ha d f elngsbe we O ' i n a Clr I a 6.
r e i
t en Bre nd a k. d. t
Yel Boy' unda e lte dicus e a c
la
s
t d e t r s s d onve s ton t tYel Boy a O ' in ha
r a i ha la
nd Bre d
ha a ou Clr . Yel Bo wr e Tg Bre js i h k ws ( tClr cd n s othmj
d b t a k l y ot:fo' in ad e no t
a
ha a k l ot ho i
i
c u e ( Bre a d Clr ha )tle a we e s pposd t f ht.. wh n t a sltwe
a s O' in n ak d ak d nd r u e o i
g
e h t li nt
do g ak h dal ewha t fc lokon Iilfc a j trn. Letrfo Yel Bo
wn clrl a i
k
t he u k o
l s ae nd us a ' te r m l y
1
'
a
t Brndo Clr , - ( No. , t c 1.
o a n a k 7 8 ECF
1 Ata h. )
l
V.
Anal i
ys s
H e e t e dence ofer d by Clz does not rs t t lve r t d by Sc u .
r , he vi
f e
ak
ie o he e l equie
hl
Clr ha not s nit com pelng e de e t r ie s f e doubt a
ak s
ubr ted
li vi nc o as ufkint
bouthi gutt a
s ' nd
l
unde m i confdencei li convitons
r ne
i
n 's
l
ci .
Fis ,Clr s s it d a fda t l k c elbiiy a do notofe a com pelng cnm
r t a k' ubnate fi vis ac r ci lt nd
fr
li li
of a t li
c ua nnoc
ence Bot O ' i n a W as ngt a e f l and f m ergang m e be s
.
h Bre nd
hi on r eons
or
m r.
Futhe , O ' in wa Clr s c l
t r
Bre
s a k' hidhood find bef e t y bec m e ga rva s a
re
or he
a
ng i l, nd
W a hi on i a c
s ngt s odef nda t tcai e t m anti bi i
e nt ha l m d o i an s nnoc e die ty c z di
enc , t c l onta céng
W a li on' pl a c l
slngt s e oloquy wih hi afi vi. The afi vis a e a s i r di y s t l k
t s fda t
fda t t lo nc e bl hor, ac
a s c fc de al t woul bolt r t i beiva lt a we e wtten s ver lye r afer
ny pe ii t is hat
d se her le biiy, nd r it e a a s t
t s
he hootngs Telngl
i . li y,Cl r does not ofe a fda t fom a of t ot r vi i s or
ak
f r fi vis r
ny
he he ctm
eyes t es.
vi ness
15
Sec
ond,t lte s do notofe any ne c
he e t r
fr
w ompeli e de e ofClr si
lng vi nc
a k' nnoce e;
nc
i ta t ltesmeeyrieaehi g nea fitkht'te r:t thewa notprsnti
nse d,he etr rl etrt s e zlfsf ' h o y ha
f
s
ee n
t a rm e dutng t s i be us he w a watng f O ' i n i t pa ki l .
he pa t nt i he hootng ca e
s ii or Bre n he r ng ot
M or
eover Yel Boy ci note ha pe s lkno e oft s
, la
ld
ven ve r ona
wl dge he hooéngs he s ntal te
; e
etr
t Clr pa aphr i O ' in' s a e ent about Clr s lck of i ve e . A lo, t
o a k r asng Bre s t t m
a k' a
nvol m nt
s he
c e ofYelaBpy' sa e e a
ontxt
l
s t t m nt boutClr ss
a k' uppos r a i i pr em a i f he t
ed e cton s obl tc: v n hat
s twe d wn y ha a l e wha t f k l o y u fc a d j tr n' J. a 8
hi nt o ou d i
k
t he uc ook n o r a e n us a . - t .
' I
L
O ' in c d notha t d Yel Boy aboutCl r sr a i consde i O ' in wasi t
Bre oul
ve ol la
a k' e cton
i rng Bre
n he
pr s ofbeng s a Clr wasa t nty i t pa ki l .Clr ha notc nm e t
oce s
i hot nd a k
ppa e l n he t ng ot a k s
l i d hat
Y el Boy ha i or aton fom ot rwines esor pa tcpa soft s
la
d nf m i r
he t s
rii nt
he hoodngs or t he
, hat
w a pr e a t s ne t ga
s es nt t he ce o uge Cl t s r c i
a k' ea ton. Cl a l Yela Boy' c m e s a e
e ty, l
s om nt t
nas i s e cont xt lnk,bec us Yela Boy woul notknow wha Cl k' f ce l
isng om
e ual i
a e l
d
t ar s a ooke
d
lke unl s ,ofc s Clr wa t li Yel Boy wha t s yi t lte .
i , es
our e, a k s elng la
t o a n he e t r
Thid, e
r ven wih s e i onssency i t Com m onweat s e de , Cl r s
t om nc it
.
n he
lh' vi nce a k'
e a ton of hi a i on t ni of N ove be 25,2006 doe notm a s ns .
xplna i
s ctons
he ght
m r
s
ke e e
cni s t ha be n i t pa ki 1 i or t fsfght O' i n,butt cout c nnot
l m o ve e n he r ng ot n der o iti
Bre
he
' a
t
c rhe ho Clz c udho sl beiv t tafsf wa g igt o cz a hi pat
omp e nd w ak o l net l e ha itkht s on o c t s s ry
y e
r
a oac d t a r m e ofknown Crpsaftit s ar e wih a l s t ha
ppr he he pa t nt
i - fla e m d t t ea t wo ndgunsa
nd
wi. r ba nas cove i t i f c . The cour fnds i i r l unbei va e t t
t ed nda
h
rng her a es
t i
t nhe enty
le bl ha
a e e m y ga m embe s who had s ve a r c nt vi ent c r a
vow d ne
ng
r
e zl ee
ol
onfont dons woul put
;
d
1Be i sClr s i i t a rmen par ng 1 a bt ng O' in' bl banda , s ve a heae
sde ak hootng n he pa t t ki ot nd rni
Bre s ue
na e r l td
gang-eaed i i nt had r e l oc ure i ol ng Clr hi codeenda s a t vitms O' in ha t d
r lt ncde s
ec nty c r d nv vi
ak, s
f nt, nd he ci . Bre d ol
Clr d rngap o ec lta ç ed n'k o E ak;h n v rk e E ak a . . wh nh d s e( ak ,
ak u i
h n alh t t o t n w clrj e e e n w clr q nd . And e e o e C1r)
h
h ' g igt s o t( ak i (i)fc o sg t'Src a d t d Clr ta h h d fu h O' in p irt te
es on o h o Clr j n hs a e n ihy tikln ol ak h t e a o g t Bre ro o h
'
16
a i t i we pons a m e ey obs r e a Cl r a O ' i enga d i a fsfght The
sde her a
nd r l
e v s a k nd Bren
ge n iti .
c t as Ends Cl r s sa e e t t he ha no i a a
our lo
a k' t t m nt ha
d
de bout t t' i enéons of
he t nt
ue
W ahn t ,Src lnd,a S. .a te fre t i wa i o Tur rsa rme t be
s jon tika nd W s h y oc d her y nt
ne' pat nt o
e t ey unlkey, es i ly c i rng W a hi on' ups de e
xtem l
i l
pecal onsde i
s ngt s
et m anor a pror
nd i
c r aton ofK . . aswela Stikl a S. . prorsat m e sr ga di O ' i
onfont i
W ,
l s tc and nd W ' i t e nt e r ng Bren.
S
Fourh, Cl k' e a éon f hi m ul e i
t
at s xpl na
oz s
dpl nconsse s a e e s a blt nt
it nt t t m nt nd a a
f brca
a i donsi unbeiva e Clr cni st the conf s e t polc i or r t pr ec t
s
le bl. a k l m ha
e s d o ie n de o ot t he
y
ounge pa tcpa s s c fcal t c rf W a l on. H rg Tr vol 2,11 H o e r i
r rii nt, pe ii l o ove or sùngt
y
' . .
8. w ve , n
Clr sconf s i ,he e iil i i t salofhi code e nt i b0t t s
a k'
e sons
xplcty mplca e l
s
f nda s n
h he hoodngsa
nd
t bur a y a e t r prncpasori t s c
he glr s ihe i i l
n he e ond- g ee Clr a s sngld W as ngt out
de r . a k lo i e
hi on
i satng t tClr ha gi n W a hi on a handgun bef e t s
n t i ha a k d ve
s ngt
or he hootngs I i f e oni ;
i . ' s f as ng'
I r
f l ng t a horte de i l c how e r Clr sa ndonm e ofhi conf son i or r
or yi o ut ii s fes ogi;
ve , a k' ba
nt
s
es i n de
t cnm inocnc a a i a ln ty ji sne e wa muc mor rtona,abet
o li n e e nd vod e gh al e tnc s h
e ai l l i
cihones.
ls
t
Fit unde a Schl a l i,t f c inde woul silha t det r i w het rt
fh,
r
up nayss he a ti r
d tl ve o e m ne
he o
beive Clr s d iti 7 ve son of e s bolt e by a fda t a lte s a hor d by
le
a k' f s fght' r i
f
vent
ser d
fi vis nd e tr ut e
f l ,orf l hi i ta c e son t the s O ' i n a wihe t the ha di d,t
e ons
olow s niil onf s i ha
hot Bre nd s d ha
d e he
e wines ac ount ofClr i t a rm ent t sr c t um sa ile de ofge tng
ye t s c
s
a k n he pa t
, he tong ic tnta vi nce
ti
a r s e w lie i pos e son ofone oft w e ponsus i t s
r e t d zl n
s si
he a
ed n he hootng,a wel as Clr s
i
s l
a k'
a knowl m e of hi guit i ii pl coloquy. The c t fnds t t Clr s clm i
c
edge nt
s l n ks ea l
our i
ha a k' li s
Nove r25 s igs,W as ngt ha ha a atr ai wih hi s t besepsse K. . who wasdatng
mbe
hootn
hi on d d n le c ton t s oon-o- -t itr W ,
i
Crp -fiae j v ni JP.a d S. . a c le te me ç bu c o sae ngg r'frno rtlaig a ans
isafl td u e l . , n W h d ald h n f n h f crd i es' o t eait g i t
i
e
a
n
O' e HrgTr vol2,85- 99-1 2.
Brin. ' . .
90, 0
net rcr bl nor com pelng,a e n wih s e unc r ant a t t pr c s i ndte
ihe edi e
li nd ve t om
e t i y s o he e ie de is
oft s
he hoot r ,lga i ufii nc i note
e s e l ns fc e y s
nough t pr ac u li
o ove t a nnoc
enceunde Sc u .
r hl
I s m a y t c ztfndst tClr hasnots
n um r , he otr i
ha a k
hown t the i a m a l i
ha
s c ly nnoc ntof
e
t bur a y ofTur rs a rm entor t s
he glr
ne ' pa t
he hooùngs of O ' i n a K . . Ba e upon a
Bre nd W
sd
c i r ton ofa lof t ne e de e com bi d wih pror i ul t y a e ul or
onsde a i
l
he w vi nc
ne t i nc pa or nd xc pat y
e i e c ,t c u tfndst ti i no l ey t ta y r a on bl jr r wo d h ve ha a
v d n e he o r i ha t s t i l ha n e s a e u o ul a
k
d
r s bl doubta t Clr sguit
ea ona e
s o a k' l.
I f i Ass s ance Cl m
nefectve
it
ai
Re r e s of whet r Cl t s e de e m e s t de a ng Schl sa r hi
ga dls
he a k' vi nc
et he m ndi
u t nda d, s
unde li Si h Am e
ry ng xt
ndm enti f ctve asi t
nefe i
ssance ofc
ouns lc nm fist s rctSti ll
e l i al he ti rctand
v.W a hi t t t To s a e a c tm tona cni f i fec i a ss a e,Clr m us
s n on es.
tt
onsi i l l m or ne f tve s it nc
ak
t
sdsy t t - o Src ln ts b s wi () çha c nsl pefr n e wa
a f he wopr ng tika d et y ho ng 1 f t ou e' roma c s
t
s
deiint:a ()T h tt d fce pe f r nc p eudc d t e de e e' 4 6 U..6 ,
fce , nd 2 f a he eiint ro ma e r j ie h fns . 6 S 68
'
t
'
68 - 8 ( 9 4 . A pe io rmu to e c < sr g p e u i ' t a c unslstc c l
66 7 1 8 )
tt ne s v r ome f ton r s mpton' h t o e' a é a
i
a
deii d ig terptsntto weezao bl c mpee ,a d t c ur ma a jdg
csons urn h e ee ain r es na y o tnt n he o t y du e
couns ls pe f m a e de ii ntonl whe a pettone de ons r t t tTt lghtofa lt
e' ror nc fc e
y
n
ii r m
ta es ha f' i
il
l he
c t um sa s t i ntfed a s oromi sonsw e e outi t wi r
ic t nce , he de ii ct
si
r
sde he de ange ofpr es i ly
of sonal
c pe e asi tnce' 1 a 689 9 8
om t nt ssa .' d. t - 0.
Clr ' j 2 4 peiin a s rs a sn l cnm :f ll a c uns lr nd r d i fe d
a ks 25 tto se t i ge li f r il o e e e e ne fc ve
rr
a ssa by ad sng a pe nlti Clr t e e t Alor pl ase n t
s it nce
vii nd r itng a k o ntr he f d e ve hough t lwy r
he a e
bele
ived,ba e on a m as ofe ul t y e de ,t tClr wasnotglit oft ofe e
sd
s
xc pa or vi nce ha a k
zly
he f ns s
8'-eSxhAme d nt u rn esrao a l c mpee c, tp reta v cc jd e wihteb nei o
<' it
'h
l
n me g aa te es n be o tn e no efc d o ay u g d t h e l f
t
hn sg . Yab r u hv Ge , 4 U.. , (0 3.
id iht' ro o . n 5 0 S 1 8 2 0 )
'
18
c ag d. Pe'' Br 1 ,Clr v.Clr e No.71
h t e ' t s . 6 ak
' t
ak ,
:4CV0 0 2 ( No.1. Alho g Clz
0 4 ECF
) t u h ak
ne r r ie t i pz i e is i e ri pr ee ngs cnm d ofli sat ha aspr ee ng
ve as d l s ecs s ue n a ler oc di , li
a
as t e be
oc di
s a e a sm ia cnm :Clr ale d t ha c
t t d i lr li
a k lge hat d ouns li ot ed hi oft l k ofe de e i
e nf m
m
he ac
vi nc n
t Com m onwe lh' pos es i he woul ha i it d on goi t til a t e de e
he
a t s s son,
d ve nss e
ng o ra, nd he vi nc
couns lpr s nt d on hi be l ats encng coul ha be n us t def hi c e.
e ee e
s haf ent i
d ve e ed o end s as
Asde al i hi pl a coloquy,Clr wasc e ned t thi ga a i t woul not
t ied n s e
l
ak
onc r
ha s ng ctviy
d
T ly wel wih a '1
f a l' t l T.Clt ' c unslwane t ti t e j y t jce Clt ' t si y
P
' . u
aks o e t d ha f h ur ee td aks e tmon ,
Cl r woul f e a sgnii a l hi r s nt nc Couns lad s d Clr t t e e i a
ak
d ac
i fc nty ghe e e e.
e vie a k ha nt rng n
Alo d gzt pla a te c n n ig a j g of Clr' i c nc a ni ma
fr tly e nd h n o vicn
i
ud e
aks nno e e nd ani l
ivove nt wa t be t sr tg , be a e t e j g c u d c nsd r t sntncng
n l me
s he s ta e y c us h ud e o l o i e he e e i
gadei s wh n j is do not Clr de i d t pu s e a Alor p e i s ie of t
il
ne e ure
. a k cde o ru n f d la n pt
he
Com m onweat s ove whem i e dence Clr kne oft pot i f a s nt
lh'
r l ng vi
; ak w
he ental ot e ence a
bove
t gui i . La ty,Clr coul ha wihdr wn hi g ly pla pror t s nt ncng,a
he delnes
sl ak
d ve t a
s uit e i o e e i
nd
couns l sat i a afi vi t t couns lwas pr pa ed t t ke t ca e t tili Clr
e t ed n n fda t ha
e
e r o a he s o ra f a k
wihed,butClr deci d t do s
s
a k lne o
o.
The sat ha scour f
t e bea
t ound t tClr speéton f ied t s ts y et rpr
ha a k'
i al o a if ihe ong oft
he
Sti a t tbeca e he çf ie t s a e avai r as why he s d notbe bound by hi
rcklnd es
us
fald o t t
ld e on
houl
s
s a e ent a ti l c e ni li knowl dge of t Com m onw e lh' e de e a t
t t m s t l a onc r ng ls
e
he
at s vi nc nd he
a q c ofhsc ns l' Clr v. o on No.(L0 0 3 8 0 ,a 9 1 ( .Ci.Ct Oc.
de ua y i ou e. a k J hns ,
'
2 9 00 5 - 0 t - 0 Va r . t
7 2 0 ) The Cic i Co t o t Ciy o W a n s r c ntn d:The e i e c a lns
, 0 9.
r ut u t f he t f y e bo o o iue f v d n e g i t
t
Clr wasove whel i a he f ist de onst t t ar as bl def ntwoul ha
ak
r
m ng nd
al o m
ta e hat e ona e enda
d ve
i it d on pl di notgait gone t ti la t out om e of t c e w oul ha be n
nsse
ea ng
ly,
o ra nd he c
he as
d ve e
dif r nt ..
fe e
1 a 1 The sa e ha as cotr f t r expl ned Cl r s f iur unde
d. t 0.
t t be
zt urhe
ai
a k' al e
r
Sti a
rcklnd:
I l htofg ak' sae ntt poie t na t e oft ofe s s a g ng
ni
g
clr s ttme o l , he tr
q
c
z
he f n e , a r ltd ho i vai n a s tn ,t i t e s ti d b t vc ms t e
eae me n so nd hoo ig he nj s usane y he ié , h
ui
pr s nc ofay un cnl . .n t ho ,g a k smpl c nn d mo tae
ee e
o g l d . i he me clrj i y a ot e nsr t
i
t ta r s bl def ndantwoul ha pladed notguit ,i i t on goi
ha ea ona e e
d ve e
ly nssed
ng
t ti la t out e oft pz e ng woul ha bee dif r ntor t
o ra nd he com
he oce di
d ve n fe e
he
s nt nc w oul ha be l s
e e e
d ve en es .
I at 10- . Addii ly, on diec a
d.
11
tonal
r t ppea, t Colr of Appe l of Vigila hed;
l he
zt
as
r ri l
Tg.t g Clr i t uc d e de ea sntncngt d n o n i mi elsivove n i
Thl hou h ak ntod e vi nc t e e i o e y r nni z l n l me t n
.l
i
t c i es t Com m onweat ofe ed a s t il pr fr of t e de e,i l ng
he rm , he
lh f r
ubsanta ofe
he vi nc ncudi
Clr s c nf si ,i s po toft g i y p e gj' Clr v.Co on at ,20 8 W L
a k' o e son n up r
he ul las. ak
t
'
mm we lh 0
2019561, 2008 Va. App. LEX I 234, a *1 n. The a lat cout c
S
t
4.
ppel e
' ondnued: t
t
he
Co
mmon at ' f u tn le i e e ...g s s ûce f r a fn n ofg i o alsx
we lhs f bsa éa v d nc
s
waj uf int o tdig ul n l i
t
c r s' 1
ha ge .? d.
The cour a r s wih t s a e cour s fndi . Clr ha not ove com e t
t g ee
t he t t
t' i ngs
ak s
r
he
de er ncegi t t f ctfnci oft s a e c t unde t AED PA a Sti kl wih
f e
ven o he a -i lng
he t t ours
r he
nd rc and t
()a fd visfo c v ce flns ()ltesfo c v ce flns a d ()o he e i e e
1 fia t z m on itd eo , 2 etr r m on itd eo , n 3 t r v d nc
t gener ly c r
hat
al or obor t s s e of Clr s s a e e s but die ty conta c s Clr s
a e om
a k' t t m nt,
t cl
t dit a k'
c e son, pl a coloquy, a t Comm onw e lh' fove whem i ' e de . The e
onf s i
e
l
nd he
at s f r l ng' vi nce
s
fndi a e nota unr s bl a i ton off der l1w oran unr s bl detr ana i
i ngs r
n ea ona e pplca i
e a a
ea ona e e n i ton
off t .The ef e t c tgr nt t m oton t dimi s
ac s
r or , he our a s he
i o s s.
W .
20
For t r as satd,t cour GR AN T S t m oton t dimi s Clr ha f ied
he e ons t e he
t
he
i o s s . a k s al
t pr s nts fce l r la e e de e t sat a s t nta c qm of a tz li
o e e ufi inty eibl vi nc o t e ubsa i l l i
ca a nnoc
ence t t
ha
wo l e c ehi pr e u a dea ta tmeba u e S hl a M c g i M o e ve ,
u d x us s oc d r l ful nd i - r nd r c u nd ouign. r o r
Clr s unde li i f ctve a ss a e ofcouns lcli i wihoutm e i. A n a oprat
a k'
ry ng nefe i s it nc
e lm s t
rt
ppr i e
ot rwilent zt sda
de l e hi y.
The Clr i diec e t s nd c esoft sm e or ndum opi on a a com pa i
e k s r t d o e opi
hi m a
ni nd c
nyng
oz z t Tet yand t couns lofz cor f Res
de o
r
o
e
e d or ponde . Futhe ,fndi t tpe i rha
nt
t z i ng ha étone s
f ied t m a a s t ndals
al o ke ubsa
howi oft dela ofa cons itéona rghtasr quie by 28
ng
he
l
ttz
li
e rd
U. C. 2 5 ()1,ac r iaeo a aa l yi DENJ
S. j 2 3 c() eéfc t f ppe lbit s
i
ED.
EN TE R:'hi J
r s
d yofFe r ay 2017.
a
bur
,
4/
A .M Y'*
''
V
Ur td S ae Ditit u ge
z e tts stc l d
i
'
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?