Johnson v. Mathena

Filing 2

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 02/27/2014. (kab)

*7
'

e F*m:Alyj b,:, :4 > I
d
r /.
%
r
TROANOKE,VA
FIED
L

FEa 2 7 2 ,
gj
I TH E U NI
N
TED STATES DISTRI T C O UR T
C
FO R TH E W ESTERN DISTR I T O F V IR G I IA
C
N
R O AN O K E DI I O N
V SI
LAR R Y R AY JO H N SO N ,

JULA c. . # '
I
)
t
'
.
BK
u j cu
j j uaK
DE

CLERK

CA SE N O .7: 4CV 00079
1

Pe ii r
tt one ,
V.

M EM O M ND U M O PI I N
N O

RANDALL C.M A THENA, ARDEN,
W

By: H on.Gln E.Conr
e
ad
Chi fU nied St e D i t i Judge
e
t
at s s r ct

R e ponde .
s
nt

La r Ra J on,a Vigi a i ae pr e di pr K ,fl t spe ii n f a wrtof
r y y ohns
r ni nm t oc e ng o
ied hi tto or
i
.

ha ascopus plrln t 28U. C.j2254.Upon rviw oft peii t co tc udes
be r , zslnt o
S.
e e
he tton, he ur oncl

ta i mus b sl rl d s se wih u prj d c ,b c us J h o ha sae n rg tt
htt t e l
mmaiy imisd t o t eu ie e a e o ns n s ttd o i h o
r l ft e j2 4.
ei md r 25 1
e
Ha asco puspe ii a e ge r ly r s r e f r a tc on t f c ordtr ton oft
be
r
ttons r ne a l e e v d o ta ks
he a t
la i
he

peiiners c i me . Se Prie v.Rodra , 411 U. 475, 500 ( 973 . J on
tto ' onfne nt
e esr
iuez
S.
1 ) ohns
e es l saest the i notc le ng hi sae orf de a convitonsors ntnc ,howe r
xpr sy t t ha
s
hal ngi
s tt
e rl
ci
e e es
ve .

Rahe ,he ase t t t t c ts a i ton of Prs Lii ton Refr Ac (TLlA'
tr
s rs ha he our' pplcai
ion tgai
om t 1 t '
)
pr sons ha t
ovii
s t
undul i ie 'hi c tm to l rght t due pr es a t a e s t
y mpar d' s onsi i na i s o
oc s nd o cc s he

c u t. S e 2 U. C. j 1 5 a, () a d ( ) 2 U. C. j1 5 b ( ) 4 U. C.
o rs e 8 S.
91 () d , n g ; 8 S.
91 A( )1 ; 2 S.

1 Un e Rul 4b o te Rue Go enn j2 4 Cae, tec utma s mmai ds s a j22 4
d r e () f h ls v rig 25 s s h o r y u rl imis
y
5
p tto çifiplil a per fo tep tto a da yatc e e hbi ta tep tto e i n te tte t rl f
ei n çq t any p as rm h ei n n n t h d x i t h t h ei n r s o n i d o ei
i l
i
a
s
i
l
e
i t dikitcout'
n he s c l '

:

i
j1997 c( . A srlef i t s habeas acton, J o a kst co tt alow hi t 5l i
e()2)2
ei n hi
ohns n s he ur o l
m o en

f r pau rscv l iht a to , oo d rhi rmo lto aj ds ito wiha c s t al tt
o ma pe i ii rg s cins t r e s e va t u dcin t c e s o l sae
t
& fd r l o rs'o t o d rh m it ûe e a c t d i daey. 3( No 1 a 1 .
e e a c u t, r o r e i n o l d r l uso y mme itl ' ECF . , t 9)
'
f
'
The c tc
our nnnotfnd t tJo on ha sae a gr
i ha hns
s ttd ny ound f t rle t rj 225
or he eif mde
4.
J ms s co tt i lc lnge t t PLRA r titons on hi a lt t fl cvi a tons
ol on' nsiutona hale s o he
esrc i
s biiy o ie i l ci
w ihoutpr pa e of t flng f e ha no bemi w ha s ve on t f c or dur ton of hi
t
e ym nt he ii e ve
ng
t oe r
he a t
ai
s

c n ie n . Th ,te d no p e e ta y c g ia l j2 5 h b a cam. Net e d
o fn me t4 us h y o t r s n n o nz be 2 4 a e s li
ih r o

J h o sc ncus r alg to s a o toh r s be tmatrhe ma wih t rie i a cv l
o ns n' o l o y l ai n b u te u j c te
e
y s o as n ii
a ton, c e i e es i f c m e ca c e a m a l pr e s a dit uli s ge tng
ci
onc m ng xc sve or e, di l ar nd i obl m , nd fk te
ti

pa r k fom prs ofi i l t fl ci l aci . Suc chal nge t c tons of
pe wor r
ion tc as o ie vi tons
h
le s o ondii

c v n me tfl welo tie tec r o ha e sc r u s b e tmatra mu tb r ie ,i a
o e n al l u sd h o e f b a o p s u j c te nd s e as d f t
a 1 i a c vi a ton unde f de alo sae 1w a ns t r s i e prs of i l . Se e. ,
1, n i l c i
r e r r tt a gai t he e ponsbl ion fc a s e, g.

Nelo v.Cn
sn
mpbel,5 U. 637,643( 4)
l 41 S.
200 .
Be a e J
c us ohns s cli s do no ,i a r s c ,c le t f tor dtr ton ofhi
on' am
t n ny e pe t hal nge he ac
la i
s

c i nt he has sae no Found fr r i unde j2254. Theef e,t c twil
onfneme ,
ttd
o elef
r
r or he our l
s m a iy di m i shi pe ii A n a opra e or rw ili s t sda
um r l s s s tton.
ppr i t de l s ue hi y.

2 Seto 1 5a a d()rq iep io e lt a t t b as se tef lfl gfefr:1 gacvj a ton,
cin 91 () n b e ur rs n r ii ns o e ses d h ul ii e o j
g
n
n j l ci

b t l w te t q aiyt p ytru hisal nsfo terimaetuta c u t.S cin 1 5 e, 1 5 b
u al h m o u l o a ho g ntl t rm h i n t r s c o n s e t 91 () j 91 A( ,
o
f
me
o
a d l 97 ()2 alw smmayds sa o a imae' q aiyn cvlato i i i gioo ,maiiu , rfi
n 9 ec() lo u r imisl f n n t s u l ig ii cin f ts v lus lco s o al
f
s
t saeacam.Un e j1 5g , n ea imaeh sa q rdtrep irRtie'(ae ds se a fioo ,
o tt li
d r 91 () o c n n t a c uie he ro srk s' c ss imis d s rv lus
maiiu ,o frfi r t saeacam) h c n o p o e d wi a yne cvlato u ls ( )hepa stefl
lco s r o al e o tt li , e a n t r c e t n w ii cin nes 1
u
h
y h ul
flngf orhes
ii ee
howshei tt ri ne da
s lmde mmi nt ngerofphysca har ' Thes r ti i ,
i l m.'
e esrctons howe r do no ap y t
ve ,
t pl o

h b a c ru peiin .S eCas nv.o n o ,1 2F.d8 8 8 0(t Ci.1 9 )
a e s op s tt s e ro J h s n 1 3 1 , 2 5h r 9 7 .
o

3Re odsidiaeta i J l 2 3 Jh o wa c n ce o fd rlci na c ag sa dsne c dt a
c r n c t h tn uy 01 , o nsn s o vitd n e ea rmi l h r e n e tn e o
to lof240m ont i prs Se Unle Stt v.J on,Ca eN o.2:2CR0001 Hi a ali pe ng.
o
hs n ion. e td aes ohns
s
1
5. s ppe s ndi

I ac rlte ,J on me i t tt PLRA ha pr ntd hi 9om flng a ci lrght a ton t
n ove e tr ohns
ntons ha he
s eve e m
ii
vi i s ci o
c lnge sae ofk i s'aleged f iur t c cult co r ty hi good co
hale
tt f al l
al e o al ae recl s
nducttm e. W hie a cam c m i
i
l
li once ng
de i to ofcedi f r e r g d cond ttm e agans a i a e' sae s nt e m i be aci bl l der
prvain
r t o a ned oo
uc i
i t n nm t s tt e enc ght
tona e m

j2 5 Jh s nma e n s c cam i hsc retp tto
2 4, o n o k s o u h li n i urn eiin.

The Clr i dieced t s nd c e oft s me or ndlm opi on a a c pa ng
e k s r t o e opi s
hi m a l
ni nd c om nyi
or rt pe ii r
de o ttone .

ENTER:ThsJ 9 d yo Fe ray 201
i
a f b ur , 4.
ChifUnie St t sDititJ e
e
t d a e src udg

3