Garner v. Steger et al
Filing
24
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/09/2014. (ssm)
CL
ERK' OFFI U S. SX COUKF
S
CE
DI
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED
02- 8 2 1
1
2j
I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI CO URT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF V I GI I
CT
R N A
RO AN O KE DI I ON
V SI
HA RO LD GA RN ER,
Pl n if
ai t f ,
J I
OLA
BY:
L ,CL
E UW CL
ERK
Ca eN o. 7: 4- vs
: 1 c 00081 G EC
-
M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
CH A RLES STEG ER , R .
J ,
M A RK M C A M EE,
N
R OBERTS W A LTERS,
DEN N I DEAN ,a
S
nd
TI OTHY D .SAN D S,
M
De e nt .
f nda s
By: Gl n E.
e
Conr
ad
ChifUnie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge
Pe ngbef et c ti de e nt 'm oton t dimist frta e d compl i ,
ndi
or he our s f nda s
i o s s he is m nde
ant
Dkt No.3,whih s eksdim is lofpl i ifsnme
.
c e
s sa
antf
ndedcompl nti ise iet Pl ntf ha
ai n t ntr y. ai if s
fld ar s e i opposton,Dkt N o.1 a de e nt havefld a r pl Dkt No.1 The
ie e pons n
ii
.
2, nd f nda s
ie e y, .
3.
co the d or la g e on t m oto a i i now rpe f di poston. t r as s t
ur ar a r um nt he
i n nd t s
i or s ii For he e ons e
f t beow,t moton t dim isi g an e i pa ta denid i pa t
orh l he
i o s s s r t d n r nd
e n r.
1.
Background
A.
G ener Fac ualBac ound and Par i
al t
kgr
tes
A c e i t w e lpl f c si t fr tnm e
c ptng he l- ed a t n he i s
nded c pl i a t u a t sco tm us
om a nt s r e, s hi ur
t
whe r i onamoi t dimis s eGiraa v. ohns n,521F.d298,3 (t Ci.
n ulng
ton o s s, e artno J o
3
02 4h r
2008) t fcsofca eaea f l
,he a t
s r s olows:
Pl ntf Har dGane (ç r r'i curenty e o da apr esora Vigi a
ai if ol r r $ ne') s r l mplye s of s t r ni
Ga
P l e h cl siuea dS aeUniest (vign aTe h'o teS ie st ' Gane wa
oytc ni n tt t n tt v ri s r ii c ' r h t v riy). r r s
y i
un
hie i Oc obe 2009 t be t Exec i Di e t oft V igi a Bi nf m a i s l tt e
rd n t r
o he
utve r c or he r ni oi or tc ns iut
(ç ' .nM ac 201 Gane ' postonwa c ngedt t ofDiecoroft M e c l
û ' l rh 2, r rs ii
VBl)
s ha
o hat
r t
he dia
l or i ald SysemsDi so atVBI1Ga e br htt sa ton agans Cha l St r
nf matcs a
t
vii n
i t res ege
.
m r oug hi c i
(û e r),f me Pr i ntofVigi aTe h; akM c me (t cNa ',Pr tof
û ge ' or r esde
st
r ni c M r Na e (
M mee' ovos
)
Vigi aTec Robe tW ales(ç atr',Vi Pr sde f rRes ac a Vigi aTe h;a
r ni h; r tr $W 1es' ce ei nt o e rh t r ni c nd
)
De sDe n (; n' ,c rntDie t ofVBI i t i ofi ila i vi lca ciis The
nni a 1Dea ' ure r cor
)
,n her tca nd ndi dua pa te .
c t e en l alowe pl i ift s tt e Ti ohy D. nds t c r ntPr sde ofVigi a
our r c ty l d antf o ubsiut m t
Sa , he ure
e i nt
r ni
Te h,i plceofSt era t cli as e td a ns St e i hi ofii lca iy.Dkt No.1
c n a
eg s o a ms s re gai t eg r n s fc a pact
.
7.
Gane ' c antc anst e damsbr
r rs ompli onti hre i oughtpurua t 42U. C.j 1 A1t e alege
s nt o
S.
983. lhr e l
t thi c
ha s hangei poston co tt e ade a ofduepr e si vi ai n oft Unie St t
n ii
nsiut d
ni l
oc s n olto
he t d aes
Consiuton.DktNo. ! 19.
tt i
. 2, ! B.
O r gi H i i and Subs que Audi
i nal r ng
e nt
t
Ga ne wa hie ast Exe utveDie t ofVBli Oc obe 2009.I adocume tted
r r s r d he c i
r c or
n t r
n
nt il
t é-e m sofFa uly Ofe ' a sgne by Ga ne a by St ge on beha fofVigi aTec t
he t-r
l
c t f r' nd i d
r r nd
e r
l
r ni
h, he
onl mone a y compe a i r f r nc wasGa ne ' s l y abas s a y of$ 000pl a
y
tr
ns ton e e e ed
r r s aar e alr
250,
us
$60, amuala nita i s e nt SeeDkt No.3- a 1- l a lte s ntt Ga ner
000 l
dmi sr tve uppl me .
.
1 t 3. n et r e o r
e osng t tdoc e ,St ge a s r e r d t û he m at r r l td t hi a nt e as
ncl i ha
um nt e r lo ef re o i r te s e ae o s ppoi m nt
ot
Ex c tv Die t ro t ( 1'Dk . . - a 4 6. a lte sae a dto a tr ta
e u ie rco f he VB1. tNo 3 1 t - Th t e tr ttd d iin l ems h t
'
we enoti t sgne t-e' sofFa t Ofe 'docume .Specfc ly,t l t pr dedt t
r
n he i d l-l
l m
culy f r'
nt
ii a l he eter ovi ha
Ga nerwoul bepr ded wih a sa tup pa ka t twoul i l aone-i ee pme
r
d
ovi
t t rc ge ha
d ncude
tm qui nt
expe t eof$300, t $500, a we las$1000, i al ua s l re t hie lbor t y
ndiur
000 o
000, s l
, 000 n m l a a i s o r a aor
i
he
ai , 00 000 ha
sa fa ke r s r he s J a 5.A sdescrbedby t com pl nt $5 , oft twasf
t f nd y e ea c r . Z t 2
or
..
1Thetuenaur oft sc ngei poston, a whet i wasade oton,s ton,orsmpl a
r
t e hi ha
n ii nd
her t
m i anci
i y
r s i e ,i vi r l con et dby t pa tesa a t hea toft m oto t dim is
ea sgnm nt s go ousy t se
he ri nd t he r he in o s s .
'
2Th lt ridiae ta tersac fc l ( o es lre ac u tdfr$ 0 >0 o te$10 0'0 0
e et n c ts h th ee rh a ut wh s aais c o ne o 5 00 0 f h 7 0 0 )
e
y
wo l bee p ce ,tafe a a p o raesatu p ro , çob yo t s b tnil oto o terp sto s
ud x e td t ltr n p r pit tr-p eid' i u u a u sa ta p rin f h i o iins o
g
't
fmds c n be f e f rot rpur e ' Dk . o.3- a 5.
t
a
r ed o he
pos s. t N
'
1 t
l bor t y f ndi a wasti leu ofa e
a aor u ng nd
ln i
n ndowe c r' t ot r$500, oft ta l
d hai'and he he
000 ha nnua
e ndiur wasdesg ' o lunc a gr a ne me c li or tcsdi so f rVBl'
xpe t e
i ned l a h nd ow
t
w di a nf ma i vii n o
.
'
Dk * 25 1 3 Gan rsr e a teEx c tv Die t ro VBlwi o ticd n u tlAug t
tNo. ! 3. r e e v d s h e u ie rco f
t u n i e t ni us
h
2011.
I A ugus 2011 W aler i o d G a ne t the a V B1woul be audied.Dkt N o.2,
n
t
, t s nf nne
r r ha
nd
d
t
.
!23.Ga c
nwr oopertdwihUni st ofi asdurngt a ta t audio si e ve d
ae t veriy fcil i he udi, nd he tr ntr iwe
Ga onDe embe 15, 1 L.!26.On Fe uay29,201 t a t ssntGane ad atof
nwr
c r 201 .ds
u
br r
2,he udior e
r r rf
t rr por a asur d Ga ne t thewoul ha a opporuniy t r vi t r por f f t
hei e t nd s e
r r ha
d ve n
t t o e ew he e t or acual
ac urcya r pondt isdrf fndi .J. !27. r rr e dt rpor a snta
c a nd es
o t a ti ngs .,
ds
Gane eviwe he e t nd e
r pons t t a t son M a c 5, 2, opyi W at r ,M c a ,a Uni r iy Gene a
es e o he udior
r h 201 c ng le s N mee nd ve st
rl
Co ns l yHed rd r Lu!28 Tha s med y Gan rme wihW atr , c me , n t
u e Ka ib e e . d
. . t a a , r e t t l s M Na e a d wo
s
e
a t r i o dert r vi w t d a tr por a Ga ne ' r s e.Jl !29. t
udio s n r o e e he r f e t nd r rs e pons t
a
Alhought drf
he a t
.
r por c ane i or a i a
e t ont i d nf m ton boute r sr l t t VBIa co i no o pr e a t
ror e aed o
c untng, ne es nt t he
me tng i c t d t tGa ne woul ber m o d a t die t rofVBIo o he wiebe
e i ndia e ha r r
d e ve s he r c o
r t r s
dicplned.I !!30- Thea t st nditi edt i fna r por onM ach8,201
s i i d.
31.
udior he srbut her i l e t
r
2.
l. 3 .
d! 3
C .G ar ' C hange i Pos t on
ner s
n
ii
O n M a c 8 201 W a t r m e wih G a ne i W a t r 'ofi e a ga G a ne a l te
r h , 2, le s t t
r r n le s tc nd ve r r e t r
i o mi hi t thi poston wa bei c nge t t tofDie t oft M e c ll onna i
nf r ng m ha s ii
s ng ha d o ha
r c or he di a nf
tcs
andSyse (1 l ' di sonofVBI Jz!34. lte saedt tGane ' sl ywo dnot
tms t S' vii
M )
.#. The etr tt ha r rs aar ul
ber edasar s toft sposton c nge. Dkt N o. 3. I f rhe e ane t thewas
educ
e ul hi
ii ha 4 . 3- t u t r xpli d ha
3Thesaementt ta po i oft f ngwasi le ofa e
tt
ha ny rton he undi
n iu n ndowedchai doesnota ari t
r
ppe n he
doc e sr feci t tr sofhi e pl e ofe .
um nt e l tng he e m
s m oym nt fr
4A c r ngt t m otont dim is pl ntf scu r ts a yhasacual i r s d si l fom
co di o he i o s s , ai if' ren alr
t ly nc ea e lghty r
$325, t $3 645.
000, o 42, 00.
b igta se rdt C lo ( mjt f c smo ef lyo te( I JDiiin, pr g n ta ha
en r n fre o l lw hi o o u r ul n h M S v so a o rm h t s
a
sgnii a po e ilf gr h t ough isco rbutonst r s a ch a t i e f e ofm e cne
i fc nt t nta or owt hr
t nti i o e e r t he ntrac
di i ,
molc a bi ogy a i o m a i .' d.
e ulr ol
nd nf r tcs'l Addii l W at r i onned Gar rt he,
tonaly, le s nf
ne hat
M c m e ,and St ge had una mousy de i d t r m oveGa ne fo hi poston asDiecor
Nn e
e r
ni
l c de o e
r r r m s ii
r t
ofVBI DktNo. !3
. . 2, 4.
D .Faculy H andbook
t
AsExe utveDiecorofVBI pli ifwa a ça nita i ofi i l'a c e by
c i
r t
, a ntf s n sdmi sr tve tc a' nd over d
Se ton7oft Vigi aTec Fa ulyHa
ci
he r ni h c t ndbook(theHa book' Se ton 7. oft
C
t nd
). ci 6 he
Ha
ndbook pr de t tof a smay ber m o d f f l r as :non-ea nt
ovi s ha fcil
e ve or otr e ons
r ppoi ment
,
r a sg me t a o i o o p iin, rrmo a f r us c us . ls a t ot etr o t eM ac
e si n n , b l in f osto o e v l o j t a e Pt u n t h e ms f h rh
t
r
8,201 lte i o mi hi oft c nge i poston, r i aTe h consde ed Gar rsc nge
2 et r nf r ng m
he ha
n ii Vigni c
i r
ne ' ha
i poston aS ea sgmne 'a t usco e t tt dec son wasgove ne by Se ton 7. 3,
n ii
û si
r
nt' nd h
nt nds ha he ii
r d
c i 6.
whi h sa e .
c t t s'
The uni r iy m a r s i n adm i s r tve a pr es i l
ve s t
y ea s g
ni t a i nd of sona
fc t m e
a uly mber a a tme.Rea sgnme m a i ve c ngei
s t ny i
si
nt y nvol ha
n
a i sr tve tteors r ior r s
dm nita i il
upe v s y e ponsbiii s r a sgnm e t
i lte , e s i
nt o
a he poston orde rme , r ns e t a sa fposton,a or
not r ii
pa t nt ta f r o t f
ii nd/
r duc i i s l r c m e ur t w ih r duc r po i lte .
e ton n a a y om ns a e t e ed es nsbiii s
N e t rnotc ofnon-ea nt e norr m ovalf c us i
ihe
ie
r ppoi m nt
e
or a e s
r qui e t ef e ta r as i nm e .
e r d o f c e s g nt The uni r iy' r s ns biiy
ve st s e po i lt
t derr a s gnm e i t m a a iabl a s tt epos ton or
m
esi
nt s o ke va l e ubsiut
ii
dute r as bl c me ur t wih t pe s n' e a i
is e ona y om ns ae t he r o s duc ton,
e renc a pe f m a e.
xpe i e, nd r or nc
D kt N o. 2 a 8.
. 3- t
Ga nerdiput t Uni r iy' c r c e i to a i t d a lgest tt c ngei
r
s es he ve st s ha a t rzai n nd nsea le ha he ha
n
poston w asa çs e sancton,'perSecton 7. 5:
ii
tever
i '
i
6.
A s ve e s nc i n ge r l i ve a s gnik a l s orpe ly t
e r a to ne aly nvol s i t nt os
na t o
a f c t m em be s h a , notlm ie t a r duc i i tte,
a uly
r uc s but
i t d o, e ton n il
r s ns biii s a s l r ors pe i w iho pa f a pe i
e po i lte , nd a a y; us ns on t ut y or
rod
nott e e oneyea i
o xce d
r mpos f unac e a ec
ed or
c pt bl onducta / a
nd or
s r o br c ofuni r iy polc
e i us ea h
ve s t
i y.
l a 9(mpha i a d) W ihr r t s ve es tons ût smepr edtr asdimis f
d. t e
ss dde . t egad o e r anci ,she a
oc les s sal or
c us a et be f l d. 1
a e r o
olowe ' d.
'
Se ton 7. 4 c ai t pr dur a l ng t uni r iy t r m ove a i s r tve
ci
6. ont ns he oce es lowi he ve s t o e
dm ni t a i
a dp o e so a fc t f r u tc us (ndas fras v r snci n S ci n765 , n
n r f sin l a ul o j s a e a lo o e ee a to , e to ..) a d
y
p o ie frc ranp o e u a s fg ads F re a l,t lmo a f r u tc u ei p e e e b
r vd s o e ti r c d rl a e u r . o x mp e kre v l o j s a s s rc d d y
l
am e tng oft s vs a ane -e lad i sr t wih t f culy me be t r vi t
ei
he uper ior nd
xtl ve m nitaor t he a t m r o e ew he
r a o f t r i ton,w hi h a e pr s nt d i w rtng t t e pl e. A ddii ly,u
e s ns or e m na i
c r e e e n ii o he m oye '
'
tona l pon
n tfc to o ter a o sf r emiain lth fc lyme e i g v namii m of h e
oiiain f h e s n o tr n to ,t le a ut mb r s i e
g
nmu t re
wor ng da t r pond t t r s . Tha d e po e i m a t t s vior who t n
ki
ys o es
o he ea ons' t t s ns s de o he uper s ,
'
r
he
ma a fna de son a co muni aesi t t f c t m e r Thef culy me be m a
kes i l cii nd m
c t t o he a uly mbe .
a t m r y
i
nvoke t a i abl gr e nce pr ed e ' 1 a 8,Se ton 7. 4.
he pplc e i va
oc ur .' d. t
ci
6.
E.ProceduralB ackground
Gm e orgi ly fl d s ti t Cic tCo tf M ont m e y Count Bec us al of
r i na l ie ui n he r ui ur or
go r
y. a e l
t c si hi c anta sre cli under42U. C.j1 dee nt tmel rmove
he ount n s ompli se td ams
S.
983, fnda s i y e
d
t a to t fd rlc u tiv kngt sc u tsfd r l u sinj rs it n u d r2 U. C.
he cin o e ea o r,n o i hi o r' e ea q e to u idci n e 8 S.
o
j1 Pl ntf same
331. ai if
ndedc antc ai tz ecou s e c ofwhihi ca i dlDe a
ompli ont ns h e nt, a h
c s ptone s nil
o Du Pr c s i Vilto o t eUntdS ae Co t ui na d4 U. C. 1 8 .
f e o e s n o ain f h ie tts nsi to n 2 S. j 9 3'
t
'
Thefr tco i br
is unt s oughta i tdef nda sSa ,M c
gans e nt nds Name a W at r i t i
e, nd le s n her
o t a c pa iis l alg sta Gan rc ul o l b rmo e fo hsp sto f r u tc u e
fkil a cte .t le e h t r e o d ny e e v d r m i o i n o j s a s
i
a t the t ha a pr ry i e e ti hi pos ton.l f t r a l gest the w a r oved
nd ha
hus d
ope t nt r s n s ii t urhe le
ha
s em
w ih no no i e oft pos i e de oton a no o r uniy t c e thi r m ova ,i vi a i of
t
tc
he sbl m i nd
ppo t t o ont s s e
l n ol ton
hi duepr es rght . . 2 a 1 1
s
oc s i s Dkt No. t 3- 4.
Count1 as e t t s me cai s buti br
1 s rs he a
lm ,
s oughtagans def nda sSt r M c m e
i t e nt ege , Nn e,
a W a t r i t i i vi lc pa ii . kt N o.2 a 1 l a l gest the has s f e va i
nd le s n he r ndi dua a c tes D .
t 4. t le
ha
uf er d r ous
dn gesasa r s toft a t a omi sonsoft def nda sa t tt ac i tken by
ma
e ul he c s nd
si
he e nt nd ha he tons a
de e nt c er ng hi r m o lwe em otva edby e lm o i o i e a i ve r c e s
f nda s onc ni
s e va r
i t
vi tve r ntnt nd nvol d e kls
orc l i fe e t hi duepr e srgh s l a 15.
alous ndif r nce o s
oc s i t . d. t
Countl Innm e a 1def nda si t i i vi
I
s 1 e nt n he r ndi duala of i a c pac tes 5 I a s r st t
nd fci l a ii . t s e t ha
Ga ne ' r m ova fo hi poston a die t ofVBI coupld wih de e nt 'tsi tzi
r rs e
l r m s ii s r c or
,
e t f nda s dtgma i ng
sa e
tt ment i c tng t tGa hadengag i pr e sona m ic
s ndi a i ha nwr
ed n of s i l s onduc a wa be ng
t nd s i
rmove asExe utveDie t a ars toff lngt a t,'i iaehi duepr es rght
e d
c i r cor s e ul aii he udilq'mplc t s
oc s i s
pr m i ed on hi lbery i e es .I a 1 H e a l gest tt de e
e s
s i t nt r t d. t 6.
le
ha he f ndant m ade t e s a e e s
s
hes t t m nt
publcl t t kne t e sae e swe ef s when ma a t t i ac i wer
i y, hat hey w hes t tm nt r ale
de, nd hat her tons e
û tv tdb e l tv o itn a div ve rc e so c lo sid fe e c t (litf s
û iae y vimoie r ne t n n ol d e kls r alu n ifr n e o p an if l
mo
f de aly pr e t d r g s ' 1 a 1 H e al o c ai st t i addii n t t ha' t hi
e r l ot c e i ht . d. t 8.
'
s l m ha , n
to o he l o s
m
r put i he ha be n dn
e aton,
s e mage be us at
d ca e, lhough hi s a y hasco i
s alr
ntnued,hedoesnotr ceve
e i
ce t n ot ras t off ng be a e he i no l rt diec orofV BI Thes i ude a
rai he pec s undi
c us
s onge he r t
.
e ncl
tave budge a t a
r l
t nd he nnua l bor t r fmdi f rr s a c sa sa f He s eks$11m ilo i
l a a o y t ng o e e r her nd t f . e
li n n
da a s
m ge .
Il.
A nal s
ysi
A.
Le St
gal andar Gover ngRul 1 b)6)M oi t Dimis
ds
ni
e 2( (
tons o s s
To s vi a m oton t di m i s pl i if sale tonsm us E t t a cl i t r le t ti
ur ve
i o s s , a ntf
l ga i
t d a e a m o e i f ha s
s
plusbl onisfce'As r t l ,556U. 662,678(
a i e t a .' hcof v.qbal
S.
2009)( ttonomild) Thi
ciai
te . s
5AS not ,Sa w a r ce l s tm td f St ronl ast t ofi a c pa t cam s Thus
ed nds s e nty ubsi e or ege y o he fcil a ciy li .
,
M c mee, a x , ndDe n a ena i bot c pa iisi Count11 Sa i name o y i bi ofk il
Na
W he s a
a x med n b a cte n
1, nds s
d nl n s i a
c ciy,a St ri na e o y i hi i vi lca iy.
apa t nd ege s m d nl n s ndi dua pact
6
sa r ( equie t pli ift a tc at f ct,when a ce e a tu t tthow't t
t nda d û r s he a ntf o ri ul e a s
r
c ptd s r e, ha s
hat he
pli ifhassatd a cai e ilnghi t r i ,ie.t ç a i lt ofe il m e t r le '
a ntf
te
l m ntti
m o elef . , he plusbiiy ntte nt o ei f''
Frn i v. a o l , 8 F.d 1 6 1 3( t Ci. 0 9 ( u tnglb l5 U. a 6 8 . e
a cs Gic mel 5 8 3 8 , 9 4h r 2 0 ) q oi q a, 56 S. t 7 ) Th
i
pl i lt sa d r quie m or t n û s rpos i lt t ta de e ntha a t d
ausbiiy tndar e r s e ha $ hee
a
sbiiy ha
f nda
s ce
u a uly. As r tv.l l 556U. 662,678(
nlwf l ' hcof qba,
'
S.
2009)Furhe e,osaeac us ofaci
. t nnor t tt a e
ton
unde j1 k plitf mus alget vi ain ofarghtsc e byt Consiutona
r 983,t anif t le he olto
a
i e urd he
tt i nd
lw soft Unie Stt s, nd m us s
a
he t d a e a
t how t tt al ge de i ton wascomm it d by ape s n
ha he le d prvai
te
ro
a tngunde c orofsaelw. W etv. ki ,487U. 42,48( 988)
ci
r ol
tt a ' s At ns
'
S.
1 .
I t i m o i n t dimis de e nt a s r s ve ala gum e s Fis,t c e t t
n her to o s s , f nda s s e t e r r
nt. rt hey ont nd ha
pl i tf s c a m saga ns def nda si t i of i i lc pa ii s d be di m i s d ptr ua t
a n if l i
i t e nt n he r fc a a c tes houl
s s e ls nt o
Rul 1 b)1 bec us defnda sa enott s 'i t i ofiilca iisf pur e of42
e 2( ( ) a e e nt r
û ons'n her fca pacte or pos s
per
U. C.j1 a ha Elve hAme nti
S.
983 nd ve e nt
ndme mmuniyfom s t Se nd,t ypostt ta1
t r ui. co he i ha 1
t e c t s dbedimis dptrua t Rul 1 b)6)be a e,a amal roflw, antf
hre oun s houl
s se zs nt o e 2( ( c us s te a pli if
di notha apr t i e es o lbe t i e e ti hi poston asdie t ofVBI Thid,
d
ve opery nt r t r i ry ntr s n s ii
r cor
. r
defnda sa g t y ar e ild t q lfe i uniybec us t y di no vi a epl i ifs
e nt r ue he e ntte o uaii d mm t
a e he d t olt antf'
cla l e t bls d rg s Fourh a fna l- a i t ale a i --de e nt a g t te
e ry sa ihe i ht .
t nd i ly nd n he tm tve - f nda s r ue ha ven
i t co pl ntdoes s tf t f c s s f c en t es a i h a pr t orlbe t i er s ,t
f he m ai
e orh a t uf i i t o t bls
opery i ry nt e t he
c pl n s d s ilbe di m i s d be aus pl i ifr e ved due pr s .
om ai t houl t l
s s e c e a ntf ec i
oce s
B.
E l vent A m e
e
h
ndm entI m uniy
m
t
Deenda srl onW ilv. ihi nDe tofStt Pot 491U. 58( 989)t ague
f nt ey
l M e ga p'
ae ke,
S. 1
or
t a t i e u t sn s b e t te j rs cin o rtecamsa an td f n a t i t er
h t h s o r ha o u j c matr u idito ve h li g i s ee d n s n h i
ofk i lc pa t e .l pa tc a ,W ilhe d t tt ihe a St t noris ofi i l ac i i t r
t a a cii s n ri ul r l l ha s t r a e
ne
t fc a s tng n hei
ofkilca ciisaed s ns unde j1 'I a 71. nW ilho ver rc niedt
t a pa te r pero ' r 983. d. t Eve l, we , e og z he
'
e c p in stfrhi Expat Yo ng 2 9U. 1 3 ( 9 ) r l du o b plitf hee 491
x e to e o t n
re u , 0 S. 2 1 08, ei p n y anif r .
e
U . at71 n. 0. c fc l Ex pa t Younc a l sof i i c pa iy c a m s u rSe ton 198
S.
1 Spe i i aly,
re
low
fc al a c t l i nde c i
3
t b a s re a ans saeofcaswheeap an ifs e so l p o p cie ij nci rle .
o e s etd g i t tt fiil r litf e k ny r s e tv ,nu t eif
ve
Seej seas Grvv.
- e lo a Laws 51F. 426,430(t Ci.1 )($ saeandisofke saenot
4;
, 3d
4h r 995 1 tt
A
t t r r
e il d t Elve h Am e e pr e ton,howeve ,whe eapl i ifs ekso y pr pe tve,
ntte o e nt
ndm nt ot c i
r
r
antf e
nl os c i
ij nci erle ' .
n u tv eif '
)
Hee t eo fca c pa iycamss e o l p os e tv ij nci erle a dtusfl
r ,h fiil a ct li e k n y r p cie nu tv eif n h al
wihi t Ex pa t Yo e e i .6Specii ly,Co 1oft a e
t n he
re ung xc pton
fcal
unt
he m nded c
ompli ts e onl
a n e ks y
a c s ton ofwr f a t a r i t t m e t t Exe utve D ie t s p ofV Bla t i
es a i
ong ul c s nd e ns a e nt o he
c i
r c or hi
nd hus s
notbar Si lry,Co 1I( ough ag ns dee nt i bot t i i vi la ofi a
red. mial unt I br t ai t fnda s n h her ndi dua nd fcil
c p cte )s e mo ea yd ma e b tas s e sij n t erle Cnt ef r o ahe rngo
a a iis e ks n tr a g s u lo e k nu ci eif l h o m f ai r
v
i
ot ro runiyt c e rhi na e. Thus de e nt 'm otont dim iswilbedeni t t
he ppo t t o l a s m '
'
, f nda s
i o s s l
ed o he
e tn i s e d s sa o o t a c p ct camsse n p o p cie ij n tv r le .
x e t t e ks imis l f f l a a i li e kig r s e tv ,n u cie eif
ki
y
C.
D ue Process Cl m s
ai
De enda sne c end t tGa ne di nothaveapr ry orlbe t i er s i hi
f nt xt ont ha r r d
ope t
i ry nt e t n s
contnued e oy e wih t f nci ltteofExec i Die t ofVBla t hi cli s
i
mpl m nt t he u tona il
utve r c or
nd hus s am
aes be t ods sa. fnd nsas c n e dta te aee tte t q aiidi nt a
r u j c t imis lDee a t lo o tn h t h y r n ild o u lfe mmu i s
y
t bot cli s Thecour t nst qualfe i muniyfrt snc t fr tpr oft ta yss
o h am .
t ur o
iid m
t is, i e he is ong ha nal i
r qui e a de e m i ton ofw he he G a ne hass fci nty pl d a c tt i lvi a i n.
e rs
t r na i
t r r r
uf i e l e
ons iutona ol to
Quaiidi
lfe mmuniyt otcsgove n ntofki sfom la lt f ci lda ges
t t et
pr
r me f al r ibiiy or vi ma
i of rast i conduc doesnotvi a e cl ary e t bls d s a u or orc tt i
ns a
he r
t
ol t e l s a i he t t t y
ons iutonalrght of
i s
whih aras bl pe s woul ha known. Smihv. lhrs,7 F. 30 307( hCi.
c e ona e ron
d ve
' t Gic it 49 3d 2, 4t r
'
6Tot e t ntt co pl nti unce a t whihr lefi bei s
he x e he m ai s lar s o c ei s ng oughtfom defnda si whih
r
e nt n c
ca ii ,pli ifexpli t thei nots ki m onea y d
pactes antf
ans ha
s
ee ng
tr amagesfo t deenda si t i ofi a ca ii .
r m he f nt n her fcil pactes
Dkt N o.1 a 1 n.
.
2 t 3 3.
8
2 4 ( u t g Sa o v. i , U. ,1 4 S. . , ( 1 )( e c ra ) tl eb r n o
01 ) q oi tntn Sms
n
S. 3 Ct 3 4 20 3 p r u iml.d- u de f
-h
pr a pe s i w ih r pec t a de e e ofqualf e i m uniy r s s on t of i i l
oof nd r uas on t es t o
f ns
ii d m
t et
he fc a
a srigt a d fns . Du h m v. o e , 3 F.d 2 1 29 ( t Ci. 01 ) tl p e al n e
se t h t ee e' r a J n s 7 7 3 9 , 9 4 h r 2 3 .t' rv iu d r
n
'
'o
q ai e i nt , d fnd n sh v ) os w et e ta t r wa n c nsiu in l oain o
u lt d mmu iy ( ee a t a e t ho ih r h t hee s o o t to a vilto r
i
t
t tt rghtvi aedwa no ce ryesa ihed.'d.(iai omitd)
ha he i olt
s t lal tbls 'l cttons te .
1.Propert Int
y erest
The c t
our addr s es Ga ne ' pr t i e e tc a m fr t A st t s c a m ,t tr tpr
es
r r s opery nt r s l i is . o hi l i he i s ong
oft qua ii d i m uniy a l i r qui e t c t o de e m i whe herGa ne hasade t l
he lfe m
t na ys s e r s he our t t r ne
t
r r
qua e y
al ge aconsiutonalvi ai n ba e on de i ton ofapr pe t i e es wihoutduepr es .
le d
tt i
ol to s d
prva i
o ry nt r t t
oc s
çr h veap o e t itr s s be t opr c d rld ep o e sp oe to a i iiua mu tb
io a
'
r p ry n ee t u j c t o e u a u r c s r tcin, n ndvd l s e
e il t abe ftc e t d a de i by as ur i pende oft Consiuton,s h as
ntted o
ne i r a e nd fned
o ce nde
nt he
tt i uc
saelw.' ncv. ofGovenor,902F. 11 4,11 ( hCi.1 .dnt cone of
tt a 'Hua
Bd.
r s
2d 3 41 4t r 990) tl he txt
e pl e i publc e a i t i pe nts ur f t pr ry i e es ha be s d t
m oym nt n
i duc ton, he nde nde o ce or he ope t nt r t s en ai o
be a c r tw hi h pr de f c i d e pl e ,a w hi h c n be t r i t d onl f
ontac
c ovi s or ontnue m oym nt nd
c a
e m na e
y or
good c e.Thus onl whe et e pl eha al tm ae e il me t con i d
aus
, y
r he m oye s egii t ntte nt o tnue
e pl
m oymen do t r quie nt ofduepr es a tc 'Royse v.Bd.ofTr .772 F. 61
t he e r me s
oc s ta h.
'
tr
s,
2d 8,
620- ( hCi.1 (iai omit ;Loga v. mmema Br hCo.4557. 422,430
21 4t r 985) cttons ted)
n Zi r n us , 1 5.
(1 2)(t' halmakofpr ry...i a i vi le tte ntgoundedi saelw,whih
98 i-he l r
f
ope t
s n ndi dua nilme r
n tt a
c
ca bermovede ptçorca e' (iai o te ;s as Hua 902F. a 11
nnot e
xce f us '' cttons mitd) ee lo nc,
)
2d t 41
(tpl nifs postona at e pr eso i i s a yapr ryrghte ildt
Cg aitf j ii s enurd of s r s ndiputbl ope t i ntte o
pr e alduepr s pr e ton.)
oc dur
oce s otci ' .
'
D ef nt cie t a num be ofc est s
enda s t o
r as o uppor t i c a m t tG a ne ha no
t he r l i ha r r d
c tt i l pr ec e pr r y i e e ti hi tte o i hi c i d em pl ym e a
ons iutonaly ot t d ope t nt r s n s il r n s ontnue
o nt s
9
Ex c t Die tro VBI r li h a iyo tefcst a: 1 h r man e o e a a
e ui rco f , eyng e v l n h a t h t ( ) e e is mply d s
ve
tnur dfc t me r a ( hi sl ywa notrduc d.I t frtoft ec s s Hua
e e a uly mbe ; nd 2) s aar s e e n he is hes a e ngat nur d pr es oras e t t thi ta f rfom o de rm e t a he vi a e hi due
e e of s s red ha s r nse r
ne pa t nt o not r olt d s
pr c s rg t. 0 F.da 1 3 - 7. ec u tee tdh scam i p r b c u eh r man da
o e s ihs 9 2 3 t 1 6 3 Th o r rj ce i li n a t e a s e e ie
tnur d f lpr e s a t s m eore f c i l gr trs a y. d. t11 Thec t e s d,
e e ul of s or t he a
f e tvey eae alr l a 41.
our r a one
(W eaec n ic dta a yc nsi to al p oe tdp o e t itrs gn e l y eh s a a
t z o vn e h t n o tt in ly r tce r p ry ne e t a mp o e a ) s
ç
u
r ul ofhi e oyme c r c (s stsidbypay ntoft f l c
es t s mpl nt onta t il aife
me
he ul ompe ai dueunder
ns ton
t c nr c.' 1 . t1 4 (u tngRo se , 7 F.da 6 ) Ac o dngy, n sitr
he o ta t' d a 1 2 q o i
'
y tr 7 4 2 t 21. c r i l Hua g' ne de m e a tanse di notr ul i a i rnge e ofac tt i ly pr t c edpr pe t
pm nt l r fr d
es t n n nfi m nt
onsiutonal o e t
o ry
i ers.Se aloi ( l c tnoi t tisnzi wa c itntwih:( )t 1w i t
nt et e s d.Huam our tng ha t lng s onsse t 1 he a n he
El nt Cic tt tthe ta f roft nur d pr es or fom o de t e t a he ,wihout
eve h r ui ha û r ns e
t
e e of s s r
ne parm nt o not r t
l s ofr rk orpa doesnoti plc t a pr r y i e e tpr ec ed by t Due Pr s
os
al
y,
m i a e ny ope t nt r s ot t
he
oces
Clus';a 2)r lng t t Fit a Si hCic t, c ha hel t tcet ni ra e' nd ui s k he fh nd xt ruis whih ve d ha rai nta
of
d p me tld mo in d n ti lc t p o et itr sss be tt p oc d r l u p o e s
e m n a e to s o o mpiae r p ry n ee t u j c o r e u a d e r c s
pr eci ' Ga vi v. a ks 8 F. 647(t Ci.1988 ( antf,whoha l thi
ot ton.); r e J c on, 45 2d
6h r
) pli if
d os s
poston ast hea ofhi de rm e butc i dt bee pl
ii
he d
s pa t nt
ontnue o
m oyedbyt uni r iy a af l
he ve st s ul-
tmetnur pr e s a f ls lr di no s fra de i to ofapr t i ees)
i e ed ofsor t ul aay, d t ufe ny prvain
opery ntr t;
Kelhe v.Flwn,761F. 1 1 (t Ci.1 (e tonofga t sude ' ta hi
le r a
2d 079, 087 5h r 985) rduci
rduae t nts e c ng
dutesi notde alofapr e tdpr ryi eesl.
i s
ni
otce ope t ntr t)
Def nt alor y on t Fo t Cic tsde ii n i Royse , F. 618.The
enda s s el
he urh r ui' c so n
t r 774 2d
Roys e ,c tc l d t ta s hools i e ntha apr ry i t r t pr m i e on hi
t r our onc ude ha c
upernt nde
d
ope t n e es , e s d
s
c r t t ough t end ofhi c r c .
ontac , hr
he
s ont a t The Cour hel t the w asnotde i d oft si e es
t d ha
prve
hi nt r t
whe hewa dim is d a m le d ofa lofhi d i sx m ont e ry,butsilr ei d hi
n
s s s e nd ive
l
s utes i
hs a l
tl ec ve s
f ls a y a be ft t oug t end oft c r c pe i 77 F. a 620.The Cour
ul alr nd ne is hr h he
he onta t rod. 4 2d t
t
concuded,atrd a eulconsdeai , ...t t( antf'lc rc af de hi onl t
l
fe t r f
c
i rtonll ha pli ifs onta t for d m y he
rgh t be f l compe a e a nott rg t oc pyt ofk eofs rntnde . l a
i t o uly
ns t d, nd
he i ht o cu he t
upe i e nt' d. t
'
6 ; e as F edsv Duhn 9 9F.d9 , 8(t Ci. 9 0 (x ann ta t p o e t
21 s e lo il . r m, 0 2 4 9 4h r 1 9 ) e pli ig h t he r p ry
itrs i e ly n do sno e tn t terg t op s s a drti apatc lr o o t
n ee tn mpo me t e t x e d o h ih t ose s n ean riua j b r o
pe f pari a s r i esa r yi on Royse t hol t no de i ton e sss l a
ronn tculr e v c nd el ng
tr o d hat
prva i xi t o ong s
t e oye r c i û me oft f l c
he mpl e e eves d
pay nt he ul ompe ai dueunde t c r c )( i
nston
r he onta f' quotng
Rovse ,77 F. a 621.
tr 4 2d t )
Pl i ifa t m pt t di tnguih e c oft s c eson f t gr
a ntf te s o s i s a h he e as
ac ual ounds See D kt N o.1 a
.
.
2 t
1 20.Fo e m pl Pl ntf a gue t tG a vi i i ppos t be a e i t tc e, he f c t
8r xa e, ai i f r s ha r e s na
ie c us n ha as t a uly
ha
ndbook w a l e rt tno t nur s t m a i st de r m e he ds'a t e w a no
s s a ha
cl
e e ys e pple o pa t nt a ' nd her s
pr s fom t t ve st t tahe ds p woul bet nni t o y f ca e. r i 845
omie r he mi r iy ha
a hi
d e naed nl or us Ga ve,
F.da 6 . c n rs, h h n b o h r e p e sys b e t açe uci ni tte
2 t 51 By o ta tt e a d o k ee x r sl u j cs l d to n i ,
r
l
r s o sb l is a ds lr t t ep o e to sa dp o e u e o j t a s .
e p n iii e , n aaf'o h r tci n n r c d r s f us c u e
t
Si ia l pl ntf c endst tt de i i n i Hua doe notcon r be aus t
m l ry, ai i f ont
ha he c s o n
ng s
t ol c e he
hol ng t r w a sm pl t tû he t a f roft nur pr e s s f om one de r m e t a t r
di he e s i y ha i r ns e
t
e ed of s or r
pa t nt o no he ,
w ihoutl s ofr nk orpay,doe no i plca e a y pr pe t i e es . 902 F. a 11 .Her ,
t
os
a
s t m i t n o ry nt r t'
'
2d t 41
e
Ganersae heha i s a yalege bohal sofrnk( se c i die t s pt a
r tts
s ndiputbl l d t os a hi xe utve rcorhi o
posto s di et t exe utvedie tr andal sofohe mo tr be ft,s ha t
iin ubor nat o he c i rco)
os t r neay neis uc s he
l bo a or s i
a r t y ubs dy.
The c ur hasc i r d t s c s a ag e st t a tr tgl nce t br d l nguage
o t
ons de e he e a es nd r e ha - t i s a - he oa a
a t r s ti m os oft s c es pari ul ry R o t r a Hua s
nd he e ul n
t he e as , tc a l vse nd
nR, ugges t tt ac i
t ha he tons
t ken he edo noti i t a pr pe t i t r t I pa tculr i Rovse t de enda was
a
r
mplcae o ry n e es. n ri a ,n
t r he f nt
e s nta l srpped ofa1dute , tbe us hewa pad wha hewa d undert con r t t
s e ily ti
1 is bu ca e
s i
t
s ue
he tac, he
c t nc uded he r t i t o y pr pe t i e es he pos es e M or over t ca es
our co l
e a ned he nl o ry nt r t
s s d. e
, he s
ge r ly r f rt apr pe t i e e ti ûc i
ne al e e o o ry ntr s n dontnued e o e . He e, cour e Ga e
mplym nt' r of
'
s, m r
r m anse oye and hi ba es l r ha no be n r duc d.
e i mpl d
s s aay s t e e e
N one he es ,whie t s ca e a e i t u i t s e deg ee, he s ope oft pr r y
t l s
l he e s s r nsr d ve o om
r t c
he ope t
i e eti afcti e i i r t tt nsont tnnsoft c r c ( lw)ceai t
ntr s s a -ntnsve nquiy ha ur
he e
he onta t or a r tng he
pr pe t i e es. si s be aus apr ry it r texit i a be ftonl whe et ei a
o ry nt r t Thi s o c e ope t n e es ss n
ne i y
r her s
c nr cu l ih n tobed p i do ta b n ftwi o tg o c u eo j tc us . v tr 7 4
o ta ta rg t o t
e rve f h t e ei t u o d a s r us a e Ro se, 7
h
F.da 6 0 21 Th ,hec u t s lo t wh t sp o e tdb tej s c us p o iin o
2 t 2 - . us t o r mu t o k o a wa r tce y h u t a e r v so s f
t Handbookt deemi t c o sofGane ' pr ry itr t Se j.Sofn
he
o tr ne he ontur
r rs ope t nees. e .. r med,he
ys
t
quesi be om e whe he t aci n t ke a i tGa ne , . ,hi c ngei poston a
ton c s t r he to a n gans r r ie. s ha
n ii nd
a tnda cic sa es s h ast l sofr r a c ran be tt butwih r t nton ofhi
te nt r um t nc , uc
he os
al nd e ti neis
k
t ee i
s
b s s lr , o do l b tk nwihg o c us o j tc us . s i tr r q ie a
a e aay c ul ny e a e t o d a e r us a e Thi,n t n,e ur s n
l
applca i oft H a
i ton he ndboo t t a l ge f c s i t sc e
k o he le d a t n hi as .
Thec ii lc i r ton t rt tnnsoft Ha
rtca onsde a i mde he e
he ndbook i wheherGar r sc
s t
ne ' hangei
n
posto wasadr as i
ii n
ûe sgnment'o i t a a ç eve e s nc i ' l i tul wa ar s i nme ,t
' r nse d i r a ton. f t r y s ea sg nt he
s
'
pli lnguageoft Handbookpr dest ttg eihe notc ofnon-e ppoi me no
an a
he
ovi ha tnl t r ie
ra nt nt r
r movalf ca e i r quied t efed ar as i
e
or us s e r o f
e sgnme .'
nt'Thus no pr ry i e e ti i ia e
,
ope t nt r s s mplc t d
f a r s i nm e .1 , e r i w asa S eve e s nc i ' t n G n n r wasen il t t s m e
or ea s g nt f how ve , t
ç r a ton, he
s
'
re
tted o he n
duepr s pr e tonst tar m ova f ca ewo d ha en ild hi t
oce s ot c i ha e
l or us ul ve tte m o.
The H a boo s a est ta r as i e û a i ve c nge i ad i s r tve tte or
nd k t t ha e s gnm nt t y nvol ha
m
n m ni t a i il
s r i or r s
upe v s y e pons biii s r as i e t a t rpos ton orde r m e , r ns e t a s a f
i lte , e s gnm nt o no he
ii
pa t nt t a f r o t f
poston,a orr uci i s lr c
ii nd/ ed ton n a ay omm e ur t wih r due d r ponsbiii s. A C e r
ns ae t e e es i lte ' t ve e
' s
12
s nc i 'on t ot ha Sg r l i ve asgnii a l sorpe ly t af c t
a ton,' he her nd, tene aly nvol s i fc nt os
nat o a uly
m e be s h as butnotlm ie t a r duc i i tte, e ponsbiii , s a y;ors pe i n
m r uc ,
i t d o, e ton n il r s
i ltes and al r
us ns o
wihoutpa f ape i nott e ee oneye i
t
y or rod
o xc d
ar mpos d f una e a ec
e or cc pt bl onduc a ora
t nd/
s r o br ac ofuni s t polc ' D kt N o. 2 a 9.
e i us e h
ver iy i y.
' . 3- t
The c t le t q s i n ofw hi h oft s t o c t gor e Gar r s c
our be i ves he ue to
c
he e w a e i s ne ' hange i
n
poston f l i a ve y cl e one. a ng c i r t f c spl d i t ca e, e ,t c t
ii als s
r os
H vi ons de ed he a t e n he s how ver he our
i c tane t co l t tpli ifhasade t y pl apl usbl cl m ,s e l l t tt
s onsr i d o ncude ha a ntf
quael ed a i e ai e qba , ha he
c ng i poston he ewasaSs ve e s nc i ' ha coul onl be madef c us The
ha e n ii
r
ûe r a ton't t d y
or a e.
c
ompl n des rbe t ac i a ade o i andt tal gai i c ranl s
ait c i s he ton s m ton,
ha le ton s e ti y uppore byt
td
he
f tt t c ngei ude bot ar duc i i ttea r ponsbiii . ti ,Ga nerwas
ac hat he ha
ncl d h e ton n il nd es i ltes Tha s r
pr vi l e pl d ast e utve diec orofV Bla i now i a poston t tr pors t t
e ous y m oye
he xec i r t
nd s
n
ii ha e t o he
exe utve di e t r Putdif r ty,t s c nge w asnota l t r lm ove.
c i
rco .
f e en l hi ha
aea
Addii ly,t c
tona l he ompl i al ge t t at h hi ba es lr w a no r duce Ga e
ant le s ha , lhoug s s aa y s t e
d, m r
r c i d ar ton i t r sofot rm onear be tt a pr si e,s c fca l t l sofa
e e ve educ i n e m
he
t y neis nd e tg pe ii ly he os
$500, a
000 nnuallbor or s i a t a lt t c tolt f ng f a tonal
a at y ubsdy nd he biiy o on r he undi or ddii
r s a che s I t r uc i c tt e a r
e e r r . f he ed tons ons iut educ i i s l r t n i a
ton n a a y, he t ppea st poston cha
r he ii
nge
woul c tt e ar duc i n i S il ,r s i ltes a s l r ' woul f l s r l wihi
d onsiut e to n t te e ponsbiii , nd a a y'and
t
d a l qua e y t n
t t e r s nci n'c t or M or ove ,Ga ne a lge t tt sl soff ng,i pm iul r
he t ve e a to ' a eg y. e r r r le s ha hi os
s
undi n
c a,
hasû a i i pos i e ornea l i pos i e f hi t s c e nee d pe s
d de t m
m
s bl
ry m
sbl or m o e ur
de r onne , e ea c
lr s rh
p rn r, n f n i frter s ac p o e t o whc h sc re a ap o e s ra d sinii
a te s a d u dng o h e e rh rj cs n ih i ae r s r f so n ce tfc
r eac rde nds'DktNo. a !!5 56.
es rhe pe .' . 2 t 4,
Bas o t ef ds i i a la tpl usbl t tGa ne ha apr pe t i t r ti hi
ed n hes a , t s t e s a i e ha r r d
o ry n e es n s
poston asExe utve D iec orofV BI W hie uli a e y di c r m a s
ii
c i
r t
.
l tm t l s ove y y how t tt cha e i
ha he ng n
posto wasi f c ar as i e , tt m oton t dim issa t a
ii n
n a t e sgnm nt a he i o s s t ge, he bove f c sr nde i
at e r t
pl us bl t tGn ne ha a pr pe t i e es i plc t d by t c nge i pos ton. Thus t
a i e ha r r d
o ry nt r t m i a e
he ha
n ii 7
, he
c twilnotdim ist scai outi a concudest tGa nerha s tcen l al ge a
our l
s s hi l m
rght nd
l
ha r
s ufi i ty le d
c tt i
ons iutonalvi a i
ol ton.
The c tne t nst t s c pr ofqua ii i uniy- whe he t
our xt ur o he e ond ong
lted mm t
t r he
e pl
m oymen a ton he evi a e Gar rscea l esabls rg s Fort s m er s t t
t ci
r olt d ne ' l ry t ihed i ht .
he a ea ons ha
t c tha e ai d t tt pr rcha a t r z ton oft sc nge i post on i a di fc t
he our s xpl ne ha he ope
rceiai
hi ha
n
ii s fi ul
que to t c tc l st tdee nt a ee ildt q iidi
sin,he our oncude ha fnda s r ntte o ualfe mmuniy.Quiesmpl i
t
t i y,t
wa no û e l e tbls d't tt e pl e a ton her vi aed apr e t d pr ry
s t t ary sa ihe ' ha he m oym nt c i
cl
e ol t
ot c e ope t
i e es . é r gh i c e r y e t bls d i t c our oft rghtar s fc e l c e r s t ta
nt r t t i t s l a l s a i he f he ont s he i
A
e uf i i nty l a o ha
r s eg fcalwoul ha t rt unde t cr tnc a ha t thi be vir
eaonabl ofiil
d ve mdesood, r he icumsa es t nd, ha s ha o
vi ae t rgh . Cn
oltd he i t' mpbelv.Gal v,483F.d258, ( hCi. .not rwor ,
'
l
lowa
3
271 4t r2007) I he ds
ie si pr ce ntm us ha plce t sau or orco tt i lq si 'e r e by t
lxitng e de
t ve a d he t t t y
nsiutona ue ton' onfont d he
ofiilt yondde t 'As r t alKi 1 S.Ct 2074,208 ( )
fca d
be
bae. hcof v. - dd, 31
'
.
3 2011 .
l t sca e, he e i much lgii edebae a tt naur oft sc nge i poston
n hi s t r s
e tmat
t bou he t e hi ha
n ii
a whehe i c tt ed al e r s ton'e ilng Gane t pr dur pr e tons I e
nd
t r t onsiut
k ve e anci ' ntti
s
r r o oce al ot c i . nde d,
i t Uni r iy' co e ha bee r vi wi t c s sa l ng a t l
f he ve st s uns l d n e e ng he a e nd ooki t he anguag a
e nd
hol ngsi Rovse a Hua i i ea yt unde sa t tco elwoul ha be ive t
di n
t r nd
ng, t s s o
r tnd ha uns
d ve le d he
cha i posto her woul notvi a et Ha boo pari ulry snc Gar rsbas s l r
nge n ii n e
d
olt he nd k, tc a l i e ne ' e a a y
wasco i
ntnued. co tt co l st tde e nt a e e il t qua i i uniy o
The ur hus ncude ha f nda s r ntted o lled mm t n
1 Theco tnots howeve ,ha t r ul c dwelbedifr nta trdic y, t tt r ae fc s
ur e ,
r t t he es t oul
l
fe e fe s over and ha he e r a t
t a s p o t o hc aa trz to s Co tay f css p o t gd fnd n s po ii na et a : l t c a g s e t
h t u p r b t h r ce iai n . n r r a t u p ri e e a t' sto r h t ( ) he h n e e ms o
n
f lwihi t r as i m e c egor be us i i vesac
al t n he e sgn nt at y ca e t nvol
hangei a i sr tvettea s r s y
n dm nitai il nd upe vior
rso iiie, c ic aatrz da arasg me ta d2 agu bytec a g i n tat iniia tl so
ep nsbliswhih s h rceie s e sin n' n ) r a l h h n e s o ç a fc n os r
t
,
s
p n l 'a d e n tn ld ard cini tte rs o sbite , n s lr (i tee a l o asv r sn t n
e at ' nd o s o icu e e u to n i ,e p n i l is a d aay l h x mpe f e ee a ci )
y
l
i
ke
o
sncehi s a y wa no r ed.Addii l t lte t Gar rnotf nghi oft decsondes rbed i a a
i
s alr s t educ
tonaly, he etr o ne iyi m he ii
ci t s
r a sg me t at o g t a c a a trz to i n t s o iieh r . e Frncs 5 8F. da 2 0 ( e r l g o a
e s i n n , lh u h h t h r ce iai n s o dip st e e S e a i, 8 3 t 0 9 wh n ui n
v
n
moint ds s,h c u t s a c p tealg to si tec mplita tu )
to o imis te o r mut c e t h le ain n h o an s r e.
t sc am be us t y ha s
hi l i ca e he ve hown t tt rghtwasnotclary esa ihe Acc di l a
ha he i
e l tbls d. or ng y, ny
c am f rm one da ag bas on avi aton ofGa ne ' pr ry i e e twilbe dimis d.
li o
y m es ed
ol i
r r s ope t nt r s l
s se
2.
Li y lnt
bert
erest
The c t ur ne t t alega i n t tdef nda svi a e G a ne ' lbe t i e e t
our t ns xt o he l to ha
e nt ol t d r r s i r y nt r s .
Fort r as s tf t he e n, he e tc
he e ons e orh r i t our ondude Ga rha f ie t s a e a s tc e d a m
s nw
s a l d o t t ufi i nt i
ofac tt i lvi a i on t tis a t t tt scli mus bedimi s asama tr
onsiutona olton ha s ue nd hus ha hi a m
t
s s ed
te
ofl w .
a
The U nie St t Cour ofA ppe l f t Fo t Cic taddr s ed t lbe t i e es
t d a es
t
a s or he urh r ui
e s he i r y nt r t
i plca ed by s a e e sm a durng t t m i ton ofa publc e pl e i Sci i v. t of
m i t
t t m nt de i he er na i
i m oye n olno Ciy
Ne tNe , F. 6 ( h Ci.
wpor ws 480 3d 42 4t r 2007) Thee,heco thedt tapublcemplyee(ve
. r t ur l ha
i
o e n
onewihoutac r tortnur)hasalbe t i ers tmplc tdbypublca
t
ontac e e
i ry nt et û iae
i
i nnounce ntof
me
r ao f ra e l y e sd sh r e'48 F.da 6 - 6( i to o te )
e s ns o n mp o e ' ic a g . 0 3 t 454 ct in mi d .
'
a
t
Sdolno' c a m a os f om t e bi to oft ditnd rght pr e e by t
i s l i r e r he om ùa i n wo s i i s ot d d
he
Fouree hAmendme : 1 t lberyt e gei a oft common oc upai oflf a
t nt
nt ( ) he i t o nga n ny he
c tons ie; nd
( t rghtt duepr s lwhe eaperon' goodna rputton, r o i e iyi a
2) he i o
oce s t r
s s
me, e ai hono , r ntgrt s t
sa bec us ofwha t gover nti doi t hi .' 0 F. a 6 To sa et st of
t ke a e
t he
nme s ng o m '48 3d t 46. t t hi ype
lbery i e es cli unde t DuePr es Clus ,apli ifmus al get tt alegai nsor
i t nt r t am
r he
oc s a e
antf
t le ha he l to
s a e e s oft e pl r:
t t m nt
he m oye
( )pl e asi onhi r putton;
1 ac d tgma
s e ai
( weema publcbyt e oye il
2) r de i he mpl ri
B
( )weema ei c n u to wihhstr n to o d moin; n
3 r d n o j ncin t i emiain r e to a d
( weef s
4) r ale.
8I tnnsoft r quie e t tt s e e .sbemadepublcl apl ntf mus alegealkei
ne
he e rm nt ha he Gtm nt
i y, ai if t l
i lhoodt t
ha
pr pe tvee pl r ort pu i a lr ew ilhavea es t t f s sae ensoft e o r I a 650.
os c i m oye s he blc t a g l
cc s o he ale ttm t he mplye . d. t
15
1 a 6 6(ii So ev Un v o M d M e S s Co p 8 5F.d 1 7, 7 n.)( hCi. 9 8
d. t 4 ct tn . i . f . d. y . r . 5 2 6 1 2 5 4t r 1 8 :.
ng
Thi i s tm e r f re t asatsi pl ' cai .
s s ome i s e e r d o
dtgma us' l m
Ga ne pont t t e sa e t i s
r r i s o hr e t t men s n uppo tofhi lbe t i e es cai . r t hea lges
r
s i ry nt r t l m Fis, le
t tVie Pr i ntW at r s am e s get çalVBlsude s f uly a sa f f lel
ha c esde
le s ent
s a o sl
t nt , ac t nd t f, a s y
i o m i t m t tPr es o G a ne w a û e i s ng t dutesoft Exee i D ie or ''
nf r ng he ha of s r r r s r lnqui hi he i
he
utve r d .'
DktNo. a !44.Se nd,hecamswhe Dee ntDe ntok o rasi ei dieco of
. 2t
co
li
n fnda a o ve ntrm r tr
VBI he he d a m e tng w ih V B ls ude s f c t a s f , he e he a
,
l
ei
t
t nt , a uly, nd G f w r
nnounc d t tG a e
e ha m r
ha be rmo da ar ul offii t a t I !46. r hecamst tasae ntlke
d en e ve s es t alng he udi. d.( Thid, li ha ttme i
D e n' w a m a a oxi a el s ve m o hs l t by Dr St phe Bi i &a c ula f t
a s s de ppr m t y e n nt a er
. e n er, t ons t nt or he
U ni r iy who ha pa tc pa ed i t hii ofPr e s G a ner' t a m e be ofV BI s
ve st
d r i i t n he rng
of s or r , o
'
m r
'
Sce ii Advior Boad. co di t t c anta tl n i or tona beif Dr
intfc
s y r Ac r ng o he ompli nd kol nf mai nd le, .
Bi r madet ssae e upont a horzai a ova a ordieci ofoneorm or oft
ei
hi t tm nt
he ut i ton, ppr l nd/ r ton
e he
Dee nt.'d. 47.
fnda s'I !
Theco ti a es i t scai on am oton t dimis a t m us c e tt
ur s ddr sng hi l m
i o s s , nd hus t r di he
c
ompl i ' alegai a t r s bl i e e st r r m i Ga nersf vor Unde t t
ants l tons nd he ea ona e nf r nce he efo n r ' a .
r ha
sa r t c twila s ewihoutde i ngt theha s tc e l pld t fr t s ond,
t nda d, he our l s um
t
cdi ha
s ufi i nty e he is, ec
a f t ee e soft si pl t t asdicus e brel be ow.Be aus heca
nd ourh lm nt he tgma us es,
s s d i ty l
c e
nnot
esa i h t tt s a e e sw e e m ade i c m ec i n w ih a de oto o t nni ton ast
t bls ha he t t m nt r
n ol to t
m i n r e na i
he
Fo t Cicui defne i,howe r t c t s is t cai .
urh r t i s t
ve , he our dim s es he l m
Fis, t t Ssi ' e e t t Fourh Cic tha t si s d sa e e st t
r t as o he ttgma'elm n , he
t r ui s û tnguihe tt m nt ha
di
i y...s rousc r ce de e nt (uc a dihone t ori
mpl
ei ha a tr f nda s s h s s sy mmor iylfom sae nt t t
alt r ttme s ha
smpl al etnc
i y leg i ompee e.'Ri t v.Bd.ofGovenor M as l Uni ,447F. 292( h
tnc '' dpah
r s rhal v.
3d
4t
Ci.2006) Ga damst tt flea e ai hee,. ,t thetfie t a t's
r
. mer i ha he as e ustons r ie. ha tald he udi, ugges
'
t
16
hei dihone t Thec tdoe notbe ivet si ne es a iy s a t ta e ly pl usbl
s s s.
our
s
le hi s c s rl o, nd ha n qua l a i e
i e r t i n i t the s m pl wa c e es ori m pe e i hi fna a boo e ng.Se .
nt m e ato s ha
i y s ar l s nco t nt n s i nci l kke pi
e
ec.Zarliv. t ofNorol 201 W L 2860295( D. J 23,201 ( a i motont
. , rel Civ
f k, 4
E. Va. une
4) grntng i o
dim iswhe e al ge y si i ng sa e nt we et tpli tf empl yeewa notf l ng
s s
r le dl tgmatzi t t me s r ha a n if
o
s
olowi
c ranofkepolcesbe a et ydi notstsyt si ts fom Ri t ; s Coxv.
e ti t
ii c us he d
aif he tgma et r
dpah) but ee
N. Trns Comm' 551F. 555( hCi.1 (ttme st t pl ntf wa frdafe
Va. a .
n,
2d
4t r 976) sae nt hathe ai if s ie tr
a a ts
n udi howed fna alir ulrtesi t a e ofe ns ac ountpr ed e wer
i nci reg a ii n he r a xpe e c
oc ur s e
s fce l si i ng)Nonehel s a t motont dimissage t c t lasumet t
ufiinty tgmatzi .
t es, the i o s s t ,he our wil s
ha
he has s fci nty a l ged a s i m a i i sa e e .Se Co s a.
uf i e l le
tg tz ng t t m nt e x, upr
The c ta s as tm est tG n n rhass fc e l pl d t tt s a e e sw e e m a
our l o s z
ha r e
uf i i nty e ha he t t m nt r
de
publc y.He c am st tbot W at r 'a De n' saeme swe e ma t a1 VBIf uly,
il
l i ha h le s nd a s t t nt r de o l
ac t
su ns a dsa fDk . 2a ! 4 - , n te ei a la t q eto a t wh te s h
tde t, n tf, tNo. t ! 446 a d h r s t e s a u sin s o eh r uc
di cl lr c tt e û i ' di cl ur He f r he aleg t tW a t r 'm es age w a
s osz e ons iut s ç
publc ' s os e.
u t r l es ha
le s
s
s
û ubs ue l f r a de t o houtt U ni st a lke y beyond' a t tt s t nc of
s eq nty o w r d hr ug
s
he ver iy nd i l
' nd ha he ubs a e
Dea ssae e ç ca known t pe s nst o houtt ac de i c
n' t tm nt s me
be
o r o hr ug
he a m c omm t t i udi on
miy, ncl ng,
if r to a db le,hela e so oh risi to so hih rlan n . I a ! 4 , 6.
n o main n eif t e d r f te n tt in f g e e r i g' d. t ! 5 4 A
u
'
sa e nti s fc e l publcy dis mi td i t pl i ifa lgesa lkei
t t me s ufi i nty
i l s e nae f he antf le
i lhood ofa t l
c ua
di cl tr t pr pe tve e pl ye s Sci i 480 F. a 65
s os le o os c i m o r . olno,
3d t 0.
Ski ng f rt tmebeng t t r elm e a t ni t t f t t saeme st t
ppi o he i
i he hid e nt nd ur ng o he ourh, he t t nt ha
he û ei s d hi poston'a t the k a ld hi a t'a e a las a cor ng t t
t lnquihe s ii ' nd ha
r
l ie s udi' r , t e t c di o he
f
alegai nsoft c
l to
he ompli ,f le.Ga ne c am st tt a tpr e sis l wa i onsse
a nt a s
r r l i ha he udi oc s te f s nc it nt
wiht Uni riy' sa r f i ena a t.d. t! 3 Hef t rcamst ttgl wo s,
t he ve st s tndads or ntr l udis 1 a 2. urhe li ha tat rt
t Re ti ntfesa ha ulofm i m i t ke t twe e m a i g f ih,wer qui kl a
he por de ii
ndf
nor s a s ha r
de n ood a t
e c y nd
ea iy co r c e a l d t noha m'a t tk r t Re ts
sl r e t d, nd e o
r ' nd ha l e he por uggessm ic
whe
t s onduc ofa s t
t ny or
byPr es orGar r t Re ta t t tt c
of s
ne , he por dmis ha he onducta is wasf ly c it ntwih
t s ue
' l onsse
u
t
a ia eUni riypolc '1 a !31. i whiet r i s mequesi ast whehe t
pplc bl ve st iy. d. t
'
Agan, l he e s o
ton o t r he
sa e ntt thetf l d t a t'i f le, hec t l a s hec d e t ih t f t
t t me ha
laie he udi' s a s t our wil s ume
oul sabls he ourh
el ent
em .
Re ur ngt t t r elm e ,t c tc udest tpl ntf ha nots tce l
t ni o he hid e nt he our oncl
ha ai if s
ufi inty
sae acam t a t e esae n sweema ei c nu cinwi asg iia td mo ino
ttd li h t h s ttme t r d n o j n to t infc n e to r
h
t nni ton. dpat r le upon by pl i if c a nsa i t u i di c s on oft
e na i Ri h, e i d
a ntf , ont i n nsr ctve s us i
he
cr u tn e u d rwhc aj br a sg me tc nc nsiu eal in fc n d mo in'o a
ic msa c s n e ih o e sin n a o ttt t g iia t e to 'f r
s
cl i a l gi a lbe t i e es unde t s ca l l t g a pl ' t t I Ri pa h, he pl i if
a m le ng i ry nt r t
r he o- led i i m
s
us ' es . n d t t
a ntf
w a hied as a a s s a a hl tc diec or w a gi n t tte ofN CA A i
s r
n s it nt t e i r t , s ve he il
t planc D i e t r '
com i e r c o ,'
and w asi cha ge ofe urng t uni r iy a hl tc de rm e ' co pla w ih N CA A nle .
n r
ns i he ve st t e i pa t nt s m i nce t
ls
l a 300. i c pl i a l ge t thi c e ca e rw asi û nt r olegi t a hl tcs
d. t
H s om a nt le d ha s hos n r e
n ç ec l ae t ei
i
admi sr ton,pa tc a l i t a e ofove s ei c
nita i
riul ry n he r a
r e ng ompla ewihN CAA r es'I
inc t
ul . d.
'
Acc di t hi c pl i ,he w a wihoutf ul, us a a s a
or ng o s om a nt
s t
a t but ed s c pegoa by t uni r iy w he
t he ve s t
n
heunc r d c ra nvi ai nsofNCAA r l by ot r .Hewases e ily f c t t ke
ove e e ti ol to
ues
he s
s nta l or ed o a
a he pos to ou s de hi c en fel a hi ta f rw asl l d a a ûc r c i a ton' b
not r ii n t i
s hos i d, nd s r ns e
abe e s ç or e tve c i ' y
t uni r iy i isr po tt t N CA A a
he ve s t n t e r o he
boutt i r ctons The pl ntf c a m e t the had
he nfa i .
ai i f l i d ha
no opport t t diput t slbela t ti waspr ven i hi fom obti ng ot r
tmiy o s e hi a
nd ha t
e tng m r
a ni he
e pl e i hi c e fed. e on t s f c s t Fourh Cic ta e t thehad
m oym nt n s hos n i l Bas d
he e a t , he
t r ui gr ed ha
s t inty sa e acl m t thehadbe n de i d ofalbe t i e e twihou duepr e s See
ufk e l t t d ai ha
e prve
i ry ntr s t t
oc s .
c r ly Ri h,447 F. 292;s e a s Hal v.Civ ofN e
ene a l dpat
3d
e lo l
t
wpor N e s 469 F. pp' 25 263
t w ,
A x 9,
( hCi. 2)(
4t r 201 unpubls d)
ihe .
18
I Ha lt co tde e ne t t pli tf hadpld s fcintf c st s w t thi
n l, he ur t nni d hat he a n if
e ufi e a t o ho ha s
de oto qua ii d asûs gnii nt'
m in
lte
ti fca ' unde Ri t wher he w a es e i ly de o e f om a
r dpa h
e
s s nta l m t d r
c riid l w e or me ofi rwih t polcepowe t m a sops is s
e tfe a nf ce nt fce t he i
r o ke t , s ue umm onsa
nd
wa r nt,a m a are t,a i t a as i d t acvii nposton a Csrppe ... hi
r a s nd ke r ss nd nse d sgne o i la
ii nd kti d of s
lw e or men powe sa sa usa apolceofi r'469 F.App' a 261,262.Hi lbe t
a nf ce t
r nd t t s
i tce .'
x t
s i ry
i e es w ast r f e i plc t d. d.
nt r t
he e or m i a e 1
Bot R i t and Hal no e t t i plc t a lbe t i e e t a dem oton m us be
h dpa h
l t d hat o m i a e i ry nt r s ,
i
t
s gnik a ,s h a r as i e ofa em pl
i t nt uc s e s gnm nt n
oyee C o a pos ton out i hi fe d ofc c '
û
t
ii
s de s i l
hoi e.
'
Ri t 447 F. a 309.Thus notany de i wils t e;nse d, hede oton or
dpah,
3d t
,
moton l ufk i t a t
m i
r a sg me tmu t et é o frb ne t t eo e( an it h d, eeb ig s d mo e i t
e si n n s b o t b a e ah h n plitfl a wh r en o e td s o
aj
be a e f tvel e l
s feci y xcuded fo one' tadeo c li asby bei t own outo t sr e .
rm
sr
r a lng
ng hr
n he te t'
'
Rip t 4 7F.da 31 ( u tdi Hal Ci o Ne o t ws 46 F. p' 25 26 ( t
d ah, 4 3 t 4 q o e n lv. t f wp rNe , 9 Ap x 9, 2 4 h
y
Ci. 2).TheRi t c t ai d:
r 201 )
dpah our expl ne
Ri t w a no s m pl t a f r e fom o pos ton t a s i l
dpa h s t i y r ns e r d r
ne ii o lghty
l s desr bl ore n a be trone ...Ra he ,i a dr a i cha
es
ia e ve
te
t r n
am tc nge
ofs a useq va e t o rghtdi cha ge, w asoused f om t
tt
ui l nt o ut i
s r he
t r he
Uni r iy' De rmen ofAt ei a complt y e ude
ve st s pa t t
hltcs nd
e el xcl d
f om hi c en te d ofi er olegi t a hl tcsa i s r ton.
r
s hos i l
nt c l a e t e i dm ni t a i
447F. a 311 Seeas i a 311n.9 ( si s ngt f e ngcic tnce fom
3d t .
lo d. t
1 ditnguihi he orgoi rumsa s r
de inst ti ve ûnoc ngei lneofwor '.
moto ha nvol d t ha n i
k')
The ea e sg t a f t ditnci be we n t f c si Ri t a Hal, t
r r i nik nt acual si tons t e he a t n dpa h nd l on he
one ha a t f c she e, t ot .Thos ditnci l a t c t o c udet t
nd, nd he a t r on he her
e si tons e d he our t oncl ha
Ga ne ' lbe t i e e tw a no vi a ed he e.Se D kt N o.1 a 3- l pa tc a , hie t
r r s i r y nt r s s t ol t
r
e
.
3 t 5. n r i ul r w l he
pl i if i t eca e we eefeci l pr ve ed fo wor ng i t i chos n fel ,Ganwr
antfs n hos s s r f tvey e nt r m
ki n her
e i ds
r a nsem pl
em i
oyed i t s e f e d.Ga rr m ai e pl yed i ac dem i a a hi l velof
n he am i l
nw e ns m o
n a
a t gh e
mana m e a ha ma nt ne hi f ls lr Thus hi d moton,'e n as um i i
ge nt nd s i ai d s ul aa y.
, st
de i ' ve s ng t
i ia e apr t i e es ba ed ont Ha
mplc t d opery nt r t s
he ndbook' pr t to , snots t i ntt i i t
s o eci ns i
ufk e o mplcae
albery i e es.Ther ton i tte a l si lbor t y f ng, tndi a one, esmpl
i t nt r t
educi n il nd os n a a or undi sa ng l ar i y
i uf i e t s
ns fci nt o uppor G a ne ' a l ga i t the ha bee l l
t r r s le ton ha
s n k uded ...f om hi t a o
exc
r
s r de r
c lng a apr es o ,s e ii r s a che ,a i sr t ,a diecorofas i ii i tt e.
ali s of s r cintfc e e r r dm nita or nd r t
centfc nsiut '
'
D kt N o.1 a 24. e Ri t s a; a l s a. si pa tc a l t ue w he e he i c r nty
.
2 t Se dpa h, upr H l , upr Thi s r i ul ry r
r
s ur e l
pef nn n d te ( leto l apo t no t e t th wa o ii al hie t p ro b hs
ro i g u is ab i ny ri f h m) ha e s rg n ly rd o ef nn, y i
o
own a si Se Am.Compl! 1 Tha i,heha be n gi naposton a die t ofM I
dmison. e
. 7. t s
s e ve
ii s rcor
S,
a i tt ewihi VBIa a en iyt thewasorgi ly hiedt esabls Se i Thus no
n nsiut t n
nd n tt ha
i na l r o t ih. e d.
,
pl i e lbe t i e e tcli a ieson t f c soft sca e.
ausbl i ry ntr s am rs
he a t hi s g
D.
W hether G arner R ecei D ue Proces
ved
s
D e enda sa g i t a t r tve, ha i t co pl ntes a ihe a c tt i lyf
nt r ue, n he le na i t t f he m ai t bls s ons iutona l
pr t c e m ope t orlbe t i e es ,Ga e r ce ve al t pr es he w asdue pr ort hi
oe td
r y i ry nt r t m r e i d l he oc s
i o s
r as i e ,i t f ofw rte no i e a
e s gnm nt n he onn
it n tc boutt r as i e a t oppo t t t m e t
he e s gnm nt nd he
r uniy o e
wih def nda W at r t dic si. M o eo r de e
t
e nt le s o s us t r ve , f ndant not t ta Loude l1 je rjg
s e ha
nnil0 j a ja
( t isba i rquie nt ofnotc a a opporuniyt behe r i r r beor a
wih t sc e rme s
ie nd n
t t o
ad) s equied f e
t r nai n, Ga ne r m anse pl
e mi to but r r e i m oyed t tf 1 s l y a atnur d pr es or'Dkt No. a
û u 1 aar s e e of s .
a
' . 4 t
1 D e e nt f t poi ou t G a ne r ce ved a c ofa d a t ta r ponde i
4. f nda s urher nt t hat r r e i
opy
r f audi nd es
d n
w rtng,t the r c ve w rte notc oft r as i nm e , nd t thi c pl i alege he m e
ii ha
e ei d it n i e he e s g nt a ha s om a nt l s
t
br e l w ih W aler t di c st m a t rprort r a s g e .Addii na l de e nt
ify t
t s o s us he t e i o e s i nm nt
t o ly, f nda s
9Fort s m e r s , defnda t woul alo bee il t q iid i m uniy on t scai ,snc t y
he a ea ons e n s
d s
ntted o ualfe m
t
hi l m i e he
ha s
ve hown t tpl ntf di nota
ha ai if d
dequael algeac tt i vi a i Dur m ,737F. a 299;Seeas
t y le
onsiutonal olton. ha
3d t
lo
Gave 8 5F.da 6 2( eepanifh dbenrmo e a ad pat n h a b t o tnu da atnue
r i, 4 2 t 5 wh r litf a e e v d s e rme t e d u c ni e s e rd
pr e s wiho ac
ofs or t ut hangei s lr t deenda swer enildt qualfe i uniybe us t r wa no
n aa y, he f nt
e tte o
iid mm t ca e he e s
v o ai no p an ifsce ry e tbl h d l e t rg t.
i lto f l itf' la l sa i e i ry ih )
s b
1 cjvel Bd. o Ed c v Lo emil47 U. 5 2(9 5 .
0 e and
f u . . ud r l 0 S. 3 1 8 )
5
e
mpha iet tpl i ifdi no a i hi s l oft g iva em oee sf lowi t
sz ha antf d t va l m ef he re nc
s o l ng he
r as i nm e .
e s g nt Thus def nda s s
, e nt ugges he r ce ve al pr s he w asdue.
t e i d l oce s
A tt m oton t dim i s s a ,t cour i nott s d w ih t na l r s vi pl i i f s
he
i o s s t ge he
ts
a ke t i ly e ol ng a ntf
ca ms butonl wih de e m i ng whehe heha sa e aS a i e c am t r i 'i hi
li ,
y t t r ni
t r
s t t d t usbl l i o elef n s
pl
c
ompl i .Seel l s a. s d on t al ga i i t c
ant
qba , upr Bm e
he le tons n he ompl i , hecour c udest t
ant t
t oncl
ha
Ga ne hasa
r r
dequael a l d t thedi no r c vet pr es due. or ngt t pli
t y lege ha
d t e ei he oc s
Acc di o he an
a l a i oft c pl i ,t f r tnotce he w a gi n ofr s i e w a i t ve y br e
leg tons he om a nt he is i
s ve
ea s gnm nt s n he r i f
m e tng w ih W a t r . tt ttm e, a t r t d hi t the c d no di c s i a l ngt
ei
t
le s A ha i W le s ol m ha
oul t s us t t e h
bec us W at r wasnotf e i wel a t twast e ofa C s us i 'Ac or ngt t
a e le s
e lng l, nd ha
he nd
ny t c son. c di o he
di
'
c pl i , he e w asno w a i ofpos i e r as i entprort hi r ce vi t l te and
om a nt t r
m ng
sbl e s gnm
i o s e i ng he e t r
t Ga ne w a no gi t m i m um oft ee w o ki da t r pond t t r a ons f
hus r r s t ven ç ni
a
hr
r ng ys o es
o he e s
or
t r i ton,' s tf r h i t ha
e m na i ' as e o t n he ndbook a Se ton 7. 4.Pl i ife ai i s e de ai w hy
t ci
6. a ntf xpl ns n om
t l
d pr es wa no s tsi d he e a t ta yssi s fcinty pe s i t wihsa a
ue oc s s t a ife r nd ha nal i s ufi e l r uasve o t t nd
moton t dim is Se e. ,Dk . o.1 a 28 32. us t c t l notdimi shi cli so
i o s s . e. :. t N
2 t - Th ,he our wil
s s s am n
t sbas s
hi
i.
1 1 C onc us on
1.
l i
Fort f e ng r s , e nt 'm oton t dim i sw ilbe g a ed i par a
he or goi ea ons def nda s
i o s s l
r nt n t nd
de e i pa tI s
nid n r. n umm a y,t t e e t c
r o he xt nt he ompli i unc e r t onl r i t tpl ntf
ant s l a , he y elef ha ai if
c ns e a ans d fn a t i tero fca c p cte i p o p ci ij n tv r l fTote
a e k g i t e e d n s n h i fiil a a i s s r s e t n u cie ei . h
i
ve
e
e en hi c pli co d bei e r t d t s e ot rr le a i tdef nda si t i ofi i
xt t s om a nt ul
nt p e e o e k he e if gans e nt n her fcal
c pact t e c am sa edimi s d. c t ncudest tpl i ifha nots fc e ty pl d a
a iy,hos l i r s s e The our eo l
ha antf s
ufi i n l e
de i ton ofa pr e t d lbe t i e e ta t w ildi m i st tc a m i is e i e y.The
prva i
ot c e i r y nt r s nd hus l s s ha l i n t ntr t
cour f t c ude t tde e nt a e e il t qua ii d i
t urher oncl s ha f nda s r ntted o lfe mmuniy on pli ifsc am ofa
t
antf l i
due pr e svi a i wih r ga dt hi pr ry i e es a t wildimispl i ifsca m
oc s olton t e r o s ope t nt r t nd hus l s s antf li
f rm one ar da a s a ns de e nt ast t tcl i .Pl i if s c a m f rpr pe tve
o
t y m ge gai t f nda s o ha a m a ntf l i o os c i
ij n tv rle a t h sp o e t itrs cam ma g fr r a t stme
nu cie eif s o i r p ry n ee t li y o o wad t hi i .
ENTER:Thi 9h da ofOcobe , 4.
s t y
t r 201
c t
u
' - /.
r- .
tJ
f
Chi Unie Stt sDiti J
ef t d a e srct udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?