Garner v. Steger et al
Filing
72
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 07/17/2015. (bw)
n pRo OF I t.. STGOUR
FCE ? DI .
S
T
AT R* OG ,
VA
FI
LED
I THE UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI O F V I I I
CT
RG N A
R OAN OK E D I ISI
V ON
JUL 17 2 1
25
#
H AR OLD G ARN ER ,
Pl i if
a ntf ,
DEP
L
E
Ci lA c i n N o. 1 CV vi to
7: 4- 00081
M EM O R AND U M O PINIO N
M A RK M CN A M EE,etal,
.
By:H on.Gl E.Conr
en
ad
Chi fU nie St t s Di t i tJ e
e
t d a e s rc udg
D ef
endant
s.
Pl i i fHar d G a ne f l d t s c vi a i a i ts ve a V i g ni Te h a i s r t r
a ntf
ol r r ie hi i l cton ga ns e r l r i a c dm nit a o s
a t rhe w asr m ove f om hi pos ton a Exe utve D i e t oft V igi a Bi nf m a i
fe
e
d r
s ii s c i
r c or he r ni oi or tcs
l tt e(û 'ort tnsiut ' a t Uni riy.Thec s i pr e l befr t c ton
nsiut 1VBl' he i tt e' t he ve st
l
)
a e s esnty oe he our
c os- oi frs
r sm tons o ummayj me fldbyt pate . c uset co tfndst tmaeil
r udg nt ie
he ris Be a he ur i ha tra
fcua dipuesprcl j
a t l s t e ude udgme a amatroflw,hec 'wilde bot motons
nt s te a t oul l ny h i .
t
Stat entof Fact
em
s
The c t s s m a i e t f c s oft sca e i de a lon t o proroc s ons Se M o .
our ha um r z d he a t
hi s n t i
w
i
ca i . e t
D i m i M em .Op.at 1- DocketN o.24,M ot Sum m .J.M em .Op.a 1- D ocketN o.54.l t
s ss
6,
. .
t 4,
t hus
outi onl t ti or ai n r lva t ispr s ntde ii n he e.
lnes y ha nf m to ee nt o t e e
c so r
Gar sAppoi me asExe ieDie oro VBI:
ner'
nt nt
cutv r ct f
G ar s ved as Executve D iect ofV B1f om N ovem ber 2009 untlhi r ovalon
ner er
i
r or
r
i s em
M ac 8, 2. postonofChare St r(t e De 'a 9.I t sposton,Gane wa
rh 201 De ii
ls ege û ger p' t n hi ii
st
)
r r s
c r d w ih o r e i t e ie I tt e i udi t e s i ntfc di s ons a s af of
ha ge t ve s e ng he ntr ns iut , ncl ng hr e c e i i vi i , t f
a oxi a e y 240 per onne , nd a c bi d ope a i and e r m ur lr s a c budge ofo r
ppr m t l
s
la
om ne
r tng
xt a a e e r h
t ve
$27 m ilon. eDe ii ofKi ry Lynn Byr (û r De ' a 1 1 20,33.Ganl rs
li Se poston
mbe l
d tBy d p.) t 4- 5,
'
e'
e oymentag e me consse oft eedoc nt:( t l-emsofFa ulyOfe'dae
mpl
r e nt itd hr
ume s 1) he t-r
l
c t fr' td
Ocobe 6,2009;( t Vigi aTec Fa ulyHa
t r
2) he r ni h c t ndbook' ( t tstge Letr'whihwas
, 3) he û e r te,' c
and
e poston
d a td o Oc obe 6,2009 a wasr vi e a t na i e o Oc obe 20,2009.Se De ii of
r fe n t r
nd
e s d nd i lz d n t r
-
Chal St r(û ege De ' a 43.PlsExs 9- 1.nt TemsofFa t Ofe ,Gane wa
res ege tst r p.) t , ' . 1 l he r
'
culy fr r r s
g ve t S
i n he d tona Til ' ofExe tve Di e t r ofVBI asw e la a t nur pr es or hi i
Func i l te '
cu i
r co
,
l s e ed of s s p n
t De rme ofBi ogi lScenc . .sEx. Her ceved abas s l r of$250, a a
he pa t nt
ol ca i es Pl'
9. e i
e aay
000 nd n
ad i sr tves e e of$60, f rasa tng s lr of$3l 000.l
m nitai upplm nt
000, o t ri aa y
0,
d.
The St rLe t r s tf t addii lt r sf G a ne ' e pl e Se Pl' Ex.11.
ege te e orh
tona e m or r r s m oym nt e .s
Spe fcal t Stge Letrpr de f ()albwihi VB1f Ga ne ' c i dr e c
cii ly,he e r te ovi d or 1 a t n
or r rs ontnue esarh,
i l ng m ovi e ns s a one r
nc udi
ng xpe e nd
ound-rp on t uni r iy pl ne f ta por i DN A
ti
he ve st a or r ns tng
smpl fom Gane' Te lb;a ( at t tuppa ka 'i l ng()a( tme'
a es r
r rs xas a nd 2) t ar- c ge, ncudi a i i '
s
'
onee pme al ai of$5 000,a ia ef t e ye r fom Gane' satdae;( $5 000
qui nt loc ton
00,
valbl or hre as r
r rs tr t b) 00,
ta ly't f s aisfrlbort ysa f a ()$500, û nnual 'of nds lre f
ûnnual 'o und alre o a aor tf' nd c
,
000 s
a ly't u aa is or
k r s ac r.'d.TheStge Letrpr dest tkgltra a opraesa tuppei t s
s e e rhes'I
key
e r te ovi ha 'afe n ppr it tr- rod,hee
f culy woul be e c edt buy outa s tnta pori oft i postonss f
a t
d
xpe t o
ubsa il ton he r ii
o undsc n befee
a
r d
f ot rpur e . 1 AsExe utveDiecor Ga ne wasa s a f de a $50, a lta l
or he pos s' d.
'
c i
r t , r r
l o for d
000 mma r ve
budge a a $100, annua dic e i r f
t nd
000
l s r tona y und,a we last e utveas itnt . lr ton
s l wo xec i s sa s Deca a i
ofHaol Gane (ûlr rDec.' a ! 1 .De ii ofLa i Cobl (û eDe ' a 3 56r d r z t ane
f
l' t 6, poston
)
ure e k
cobl p.' t 2,
)
57,68. ne oft e e utve a s s a sde t d a o m a e y 40% ofhe tm e t G a ne '
O
hes xec i s it nt vo e ppr xi t l
r i o r rs
pe s lr s a c e a s Co eDe a 57;Byr De a 1 1
r ona e e r h nde vor . bl p. t
d p. t 8- 9.
A sExecutve D iect G ar w ascons der an Adm i sra i and Pr es onalf t
i
r or, ner
i ed
ni t tve
of si
aculy
m e be ,w hi h m e nst thi e pl e w a gove ned by Sec i 7 oft V i gi a Te h
m r
c
a ha s m oym nt s
r
ton
he r ni c
Fac t Ha book.De iin ofRo r W atr (s atr De ')a 79- 0;Stge De a 44,
uly nd
posto
be t les G le s p. t 8 e r p. t
W
'
48- s ePl' Ex.1 j 7. q s q. Ha
49; e .s
0 6 t e The ndbook pr de t tf c t me be smayr c i a
ovi s ha a uly m r
e e ve
Csever s i ' w hi Sgener l i vesa s gnii l orpenaly t a f t m em ber
s
e ancton,' ch i
aly nvol
i fcant oss
t o aculy
s a , notlm ied t a r ucton i tte,r s
uch s but
i t o, ed i n il e pons biii s a s a y;ors pe i w iho
i lt e , nd al r
us nson t ut
pa f a pe i no t e e o ye r i pos d f t c pt bl c
y or
rod t o xc ed ne a m e or mac e a e onduc a ora s rous br ac
t nd/
ei
e h
ofUni riypolc 'l j7. 5.ndi duasr evi as ve es nci aee ttedt t sme
vest iy,'d. 6. l vi l ec i ng e r a ton r nil o he a
pr de i i pr
e- prvaton ocedur as t
es hose applcabl t di m i al for cause,i udi pr or wrten
i e o s ss s
ncl ng i
it
notc a a i pes me tnga o runiyt r pondt t c r salge l jj7. 4,
ie nd n n- ron ei nd ppo t t o es
o he ha ge le d.d. 6.
7. 5. c t m em be sm a a s be k e s g ' whi h i vesû ha i a i s r tve tte
6. Fa uly
r
y l o d as i ned,' c nvol û nge n dm nit a i il
r
c
ors pe vi or r s
u r s y e pons biii ,r as i e tt a he poston orde rm e , r ns e t a s a f
i ltes e sgnm n o not r ii
pa t nt t a f r o t f
poston,a orr ucin i s lr c
ii nd/ ed to n aay omme ur t wihrduce r ponsbiii .'d.j7. 3.The
ns ae t e d es i ltes'1
6.
U ni r iy ne d notpr vi no i orot rdue pr es pr t t o bef r r as i ng a f c t
ve s t e
o de tce
he
- oc s o ec i ns o e e s gni
a uly
membe .Z
rJ
I .,udio VBI
I 4 tf :
l A ugus 2011,a t r ques ofD e e ntR o tW a t r , he U ni r iy' V i e
n
t
t he e
t
f nda
ber
le s t
ve st s c
Pr i ntf Res r h,V igi a Te h pe f r e an ' dvi or s r c r ew' of VBI G a e
es de or ea c
r ni c r o m d
t s y e vi e evi '
a
. nz r
Dec. 1 ,W ale sDe a l , .sEx.23.Suc a t occ rgulrya t Uni riy.Se
l! 9. tr p. t 69. '
Pl
h udis ur e al t he vest e
Co eDe a 42;De n De a 41 42.St ge De a 91. ale ss cii lyr que t t tt
bl p. t
a
p. t - , e r p. t W tr pe fcal e sed ha he
audior c i rwhehe ç l c ofl e es/
t s onsde
t rt
conti t nt r tconfitofComm im e m at r a ebeng
lc
t nt te s r i
ha e a o itl wihi t I tt e'a
ndld ppr praey t n he nsiut' mong ohe obeci s Pl' Ex.23.Gane
t r j tve . .s
r r
cooper ed f ly i t audi,partci i i a l hy i ervi w ih t audior and r pondi
at ' l n he
u
t
i patng n engt nt ew t he
t s
es
ng
t t rrque t f i or ton.Gane De l !1 .De ii o ShaonKurk, r t of
o hei e ss or nf mai
r r c. 9, poston f r
e Diecor
Vigi aTe hDe rmentofl e na Audi (t e De ' a 44- Gane dr ce VBIfc t
r ni c pa t
ntr l t C k p.' t 46. r r ie td
Kur
)
a uly
and saf t cooper ew ih t audior asw el.1
t fo
at t he
t s
l d.
On Febr r 21 201 t a t sm e wih W ale s D e e
ua y , 2, he udior t t
t r , f ndantM a k M c a e ,
r
N m e
V igi a Tech' Seni V i Pr dentand Pr
r ni
s
or ce esi
ovos ,and U ni iy Gener CounselK ay
t
verst
al
H e dbr de t dic sa dr f ve s o oft a tr po t Kur k D e a 1 So t r afe ,t
i e r o s us
a t r i n he udi e r . e
p. t 37. on he e t r he
audior s G ar a copy oft dr ,whi al ed hi f t frs tm e t t audiorshad
t s ent ner
hat aft
ch ert m or he i t i hat he
t
c ude t the ha vi a e c r a n c lc ofi t r tnze ,1and t tt y w e e
oncl d ha
d ol t d e t i onfi t n e es l s
ha he
r
rcommendi hebedicplnedo r poredt saea horte a ars t Gar rDe . 20,
e
ng
s i i r e t o tt ut iis s e ul. ne cl! .
K ur D ep.160- 173- 191- .P1' Ex.26.Garnerr ponded i w rtng,poi i out
ek
62,
75,
92, .s
es
n ii
ntng
s vealfcua er sa c le ngt a t s c l ins GanerDec. 20- .Klrk
e r a t l ror nd halngi he udior' oncuso . r
l!! 22, ze
D e a 1 1 G a ne al o di c s t r por w ih W a t r ,M c nm e a t a t r
p. t 44- 46. r r s s us ed he e t t
le s N
e, nd he udio s
durng a a te tc e e e o M a c 5,201 K ur k D e a 1 47. o o i ca ed t t
i n udi xi onf r nc n r h
2. e
p. t 46- N ne ndi t ha
G a ne m i be r m oved a Exec i D ie t r oro he w i e pe lz d as a r s toft a ta
r r ght e
s
utve r c o
t r s na i e
e ul he udi t
t a t . r e De l!2 . r kDe a 1 8 1 0.
h t i Gan r c.) 2 Ku e p. t 4 - 5
me
,
Hl
iGat er' Change i Posii
m s
n
ton:
Thr e da l t r on M a c 8,201 W a t r m e w ih Ga ne a ga hi a l te s a i
e ys a e ,
rh
2, le s t t r r nd ve m e t r t tng
t the w a be ng r m oved a Exe utve Di e t r ofVB1a r a s gne t D ie t ofV B1 s
ha
s i e
s c i
r co
nd e s i d o r c or
'
M e ia l f r tc a d S tms(d 1 ' dv so Gan rDe l!2 , atr De a 21 - 8
dc l n o mais n yse C S' iiin. r e c. 3. les p. t 7 1 .
M )
W
,
PlsEx.27.Thelte s cfedt tClj r wilbenos lr r duci a s itdwiht s
'
etr pe ii ha tthe e l
aay e ton s ocae t hi
reas gnm ent' Pl sEx.27.l di not how ever pr de any r on f t change.1 A ccor ng
si
.' '
t d ,
, ovi
eas or he
d.
di
t G a ne ,W a t r t d hi t the,M c a e a St e ha una m ous y dec de t r m o
o r r
le s ol m ha
N m e, nd eg r d ni
l
i d o e ve
Gane duet a t pe fe rs 'Gane De . !24- W ale s howe r doe notr al
r r
o n t ciid ikv' r r cl! 25. tr ,
uns
ve, s ec l
l2
t
pr vi nga pa tc a usiiai f Gane ' rmova. W alersD ep a 21 20.OnM ac
o di ny riulrj tfc ton or r rs e
t 9rh
.
1 201 t def nda s s it d pa r or t V i g ni Te h H um a Re our esefec ua i
0, 2, he e nt ubm t e pe w k o r i a c
n s c
f t tng
Ga ne ' c nge i pos to P1' Ex.69 a 2- Spe fca l t y r
r r s ha
n ii n. .s
t 3. cii ly, he eque t d t tGa ne stte be
s e ha r r' il
'Durng t pe i c edbyt a t M c a e w a i t pr s ofr t uc urng t Uni r iy'
i he rod over
he udi, N m e s n he oce s esr t i he ve st s
c nlc o itrs p lc a di rpot ga drve p o es De o iino Jc Fine (Fi e De ' a 2 -3 4 o fit fneet oiy n t e ri n e iw r c s. p sto f ak n y ç nn y p.) t 02 , 0
s
n
s
'
41.Thene polc w a tnalzed a i em e e i Augus 201 ni m on hsa t t a tc l d. d.a 5 53.
w iy s ' i
i
nd mpl nt d n
t 2, ne
t fer he udi onc ude l t 0-
Kur k a t t tVigi aTe h di notpr bi c t n c
e dmis ha r ni c d
ohi t erai onduc a e s d byt a tprort i e e t to oft s
t ddr s e
he udi i o mplm n ain hi
new polc K u e De a 1 1 1 l 62. le f t rsaedt tt t i a we s' os eoft c r
iy. r k p. t 0 - 02, 60- Ktr k urhe tt ha he t ght ns r 't om
r
he ental
ques i cove e by t a td r n' al
tons
r d he udi û e t wayscl r' l a l0 03.
a
ea . d. t 2-1
'
2Alhough W a t r doesnotr ca lpr vi ng Ga nerwih a pa tcul re a to ,het tfed t t
t
le s
e l o di
r
t ny r i a xpl na i n
es ii ha
M c a ee St r a he a ee t r m o Ga ne a Exe tveDi e t i o de t e f t t ç r amm a i '
N m , ege , nd
gr d o e ve r r s cu i
r c or n r r o fec ua e û ogr
p
tc'
c nges i udi s fi VB1 sf
ha , ncl ng hitng
' ocusawa fom bi nf nna i s. a t r D e a 200- .
y r
oi o tc W le s p. t 201
c nge fom k
ha d r d utveDie or' o d r c or M e c ll onna isa Syse sDi so 'i
Exec i
r ct 't c e t , di a nf
Di
tc nd t m
vii n' n
or t (beteralgn Garner' appoi m entwih deparm ent expect i ' l
der o C t i
s
nt
t
t
al
atons.' d.
The f l w i da D e e ntD e s D e n, he ne l a
olo ng y, f nda
nni a t
w y- ppoi ed i erm die t ofVBI
nt nt i r c or
,
'
hel a m e tng wih V Bl s f c t s a f a sude s D e n D e a 66- . a nerdi nota t nd
d
ei
t
' a uly, t f , nd t nt . a
p. t 71 G r
d
te
t sm e tng,t ug D ea i t d hi t do s 1 a 62.Dea t tfed t the he d t sm ee i
hi e i ho h
n nvie m o
o. d. t
n es ii ha
l hi
tng
i pa tt o s t l dow n r or ' a utt c nge i l de s p a t I tt e.Se i a 6
n r d e te
t
um s' bo he ha
n ea r hi t he ns iut
e d. t 2
(ttngt thebeive i wa tmpo tntt t( lriet poitt tt r wa a a tbut
sai ha
le d t s t ra ha he as he n ha hee s n udi
i
t ewa nowr
her s
ongdoi .' . codi t De n,hi rmaksweed r ludaor a
ng..' Ac r ng o a s e r
)
r ç y a t y bout
ve
( r r,' ndt thefs dnos lcousc
Ganej'a ha 'ai
aa i omme sa thi g hi de gai a thi
nt bou m, not ngj nirtng bou m
wha s ve ' durng t sm e tng. d. t71. c r ng t G a ne , w e ,D e n t d V B1
t oe r' i hi e i l a
A co di o r r ho ver a ol
pes lt tGane ha bee rmo df kaii 'hea t Gane De . 26. r ' wie,
ronne ha r r d n e ve or t lng't udi. r r cl! Ganers f
f
K i M e e ,a s t tfed t t s r l afe t sm e tng,D e n t d he a G a ne t tt ha
m
ni r l o es ii ha , ho ty t r hi e i
a ol r nd r r ha t
he d
puledt t rt safofL )t tlt m t tg r r hadbe nde edbe a eheha
l ogehe he tf VBI o el he ha Ganel
e mot c us
d
fie a a t'De iin ofKi M e e (t e e De ' a 9- 0.
ald n udi. posto
'
m nir k nir p.' t 1
M
)
On M a ch 9, 2,V igi a Tec i s d a pr s r l a e s a i t tG a nerha ç t ppe
r
201
r ni
h s ue
es e e s t tng ha r
d de d
s
down'a Exec tveDie t ofVB1i or rt Cea t ( SIdi son..ndf usonhi
's
ui rcor
n de o t d he MI vii .a oc
l
s
s ho a l r s a ch.' e .s Ex. I t s s a em e ,W a t r des r be t c nge a ç ogr s i
c l ry e e r 'D f'
E. n hi t t nt
le s c i s he ha
sd
pr e s ve
...
f VB1a f Gane,'gve t ttg e ca i or tcshasbe meciialyi tnti t
or
nd or r r' i n ha tmldi l nf mai
co rtc l mpora n he
pa t 1 m ont t t s e ii c m uniy a t V B1' l Tha s m e da G a ne w r e t VB l
s 2
hs o he ci ntfc om
t nd o
. d. t a
'
y, r r ot o
saf sai t tS ha tke onne dieci a i onane tae t y,aveypostveone..
tf, ttng ha I
VBI s a n
w r tons nd s
w rjcor
r ii
.
Goi f wad, wilbedoi wha 1dobes,c i ngt b l a la ( Sj'Pl' Ex.
ng or r 1 l
ng t
t ontnui o uid nd e d MI . .s 28.
'
Gar al o w r e t W alersand M cN a eew ihi daysoft change,s atng t the w as(ver
ner s
ot o
t
m
t n
he
t i ha
d y
e husa tca t f ur ofg 1 'a co imi t tt r s t oft audiwoul behedi
nt isi bout he ut e M S)' nd nfr ng ha he euls he t
d
l n
confdence.D ef ' Ex.F.Sever m ont l er,however G ar s l counselsentU ni iy
i
.s
al
hs at
, ner' egal
verst
Le a Co n e alte f r lyo jci t hi û e to 'De.sEx H. r rh sn tn ke
g l u s l etr o mal b e tng o s d moin. f' . Gane a o ivo d
d
'
t pos - pr va i gre nc pr e esouti i t Ha boo a a tm e.
he t de i ton i va e oc dur
lned n he nd k t ny i
U pon hi r m o lasExe utve D i e t ,Ga ne l tco r oft di c e i r a ta l
s e va
c i
r c or r r os nt ol he s r tona y nd r ve
f
undsa f ded t hi i t tposton,w hi h heha pr vi us y us t s
f or
o m n ha
ii
c
d e o l ed o uppor hi ow n w o k a
t s
r s
wela t tofot rVB1pes
l s ha
he
ronnelCobl De a 33,68,71 De nDe a 1 ,Gane Dec. 30.
. e p. t
; a p. t 06. r r l!
G a ne a s l tt a d oft o f ltm e e utve as it nt , ho ha pr vi l a s s e w ih hi
r r l o os he i
w ul- i xec i
ssa s w
d e ous y s it d t s
dutesasExec i D ie ora al o wih hi ow n r s a c e f t .
i
utve r ct nd s t s
e e r h f or s Cobl D e a 56- ,G a ne
e p. t 60. r r
De l!30. r rno r eve a ssa fom oneno e c i lve a ssa ,whos tmemus
c.
Gane w ec i s sitnce r
n-xe utve e l s itnt
ei
t
be s i a o alM 1 f uly. 4.Gane as l tt a hort t de i t VB1f t s r
plt m ng l S ac t J- r r lo os he ut iy o sgnae
unds o uppo t
-
hi own lbor t y. çDe n De a 158s
a a or Se a
p. t
61.
O n N ove be 6, 2,Ga ne s gne a Cl r s o Fac t Of e :Re ppoi m e , w hi h
m r 201
r r i d t - m f uly f r a
-e
nt nt' c
'
l ea nt ' a ne t hi ne pos ton a Di e t r ofM 1 f a pe i oft e yea s untl
t ppoi ed' G r r o s w
r
ii s r c o
S or
rod hr e r , i
O c obe 2015. tdoc enti c t d t tG a ne ' bas s a y a adm i s r tve s i nd w o d
t r
Tha
um
ndi a e ha r r s e al r nd
ni ta i tpe
ul
notc ngeasar s tofhi r a nt nt3i as pr de t tt Sl e a tr a
ha
eul
s e ppoi me ' t lo ovi d ha he ûglnerl ems nd
,
c tonsofg r rs a nmen asouti di ( s i ta TemsofFac t Ofe dae
ondii
Gane 'j ppoit t
lne n hij niil r
uly fr td
Ocobe 6,
t r 2009 a a e e on Ocobe 1 2009 r m an va i 'J. Thi doc e doesnot
nd cc pt d
t r 2,
e i ld. -, s um nt
' ds
m e i t St ge Le t rort fna i t r s c ai d t r i
nton he e r te
he i nc al e m ont ne he e n.
Ga r s f ng w a no r duc d i m e a e y f l i hi r m o lasExe utve D ie t
nw ' undi
s t e e m di t l olow ng s e va
c i
r c or
i M a 201 ora t rhi S e ppoi m e ' asD iec orofM I i N o m be 201 l f c ,i Apr l
n y
2
f e s i a nt nt'
r
r t
S n ve r 2. n a t n
i
201 a oxi a el one yea afe he w asr m o d asExe utve D ie t ,G a ne , ih Dea s
3, ppr m t y
r tr
e ve
c i
r c or r r w t
n'
a ova , e t t r s a c r' undsouti i t St ge Le t rt e e t a nt e s
ppr l us d he t
key e e r he ' f
lned n he e r t e o xt nd he ppoi m nt
oft o M l K ey Researchersf anot t
w
S
or
her hree year D ean D e at154- Byr D ep.at64- 72;
s.
p.
55; d
66,
3I f c , Gane hasr ceve ar s snc hesgne t sdoc nt Henow eansaba es l yof$288, 1
n at r r
e i d aie i e i d hi ume .
r
s aar
21
a r ceve an a nita i si nd of$63, f at ala ls ll of$35l211 SeeDe .sM o .Summ . at8
nd e i s dmi srtve tpe
000, or ot nnua aa'
y
, .
f' t
J.
n. Doc tN o.59.
3, ke
6
PlsEx.75( i 8, 3e- i fom Gane t By d,aki t f ngfrt s r e c r be
'
Aprl 201 mal r
r r o r s ng hat undi o he e esarhe s
r we usngihe$500k/ a pr dedt mef M l f uly'.
ene d i t
t
ye r ovi o or S ac t '
)
l ea l A ugus 201 how ev r D ea m etw ih M c n e W a t r ,Uni r iy Couns l a
n ry
t 3,
e, n
t
N nn e, le s
ve s t
e , nd
J k Fim e t Uni r iy' V i Pr tf Fac t Af ais t di c s G a ne ' f ng. e n
ac r y, he ve s t s ce ovos or uly f r , o s us r r s undi D a
Dep.a 1 - 133- 36,1 40.De t tted t the i ta e t sm e tng afe G a ne r ue t d
t 21 22,
1
38an es ii ha
nii t d hi e i
t r r r eq s e
t na e ofhi is a tup' f be c nge t tG a ne Sus a ni Fund. 1 a 1 Att sm ee i
he m
s ût r - ' und
ha d o s r r t i ng
' d. t 36. hi
'
tng,
t gr decdedt t mi t t $500, i a llbor t y f ng t thad be n pr dedt
he oup i o er nae he
000 n nnua a a or undi ha
e ovi o
G a ne s nc he w a hied a Exe tve D ie t r ofVB1i 2009.Dea D e a 1 1 .Ga ne
r ri e
s r s cu i
rco
n
n p. t 40- 41 r r
recei a l t f om Fim ey on Augus 14,2013,whi expl ned t hi l
ved eter r
z
t
ch
ai
hat s aborat y f ng
or undi
w oul e on J 30,201 t e oft ts a ye r Fi y e a ned t tt stsa tup f ng'
d nd
une
4, he nd he i c l a . nne xpl i
ha hi ût r - undi '
h db e S so itdwi ( r e')a p it n a Die tro g q'a dta i ith sa t p
a e n t s cae t Gan rs p onme t s r co f VBl, n h t ts l e tr u
a
h
'
g
pac ger ee e i (heStge Letr wa desgne t a ss i t i tai ofr s r e r h
ka efrnc d n t e r tej s i d o sit n he niiton hij esa c
pr
ogram atVi gi a Teeh and notaspennanentbase s
r ni
upport'f hi l at y.P1' Ex.29.
' or s abor or
.s
l accordance w ih Fi
n
t nney' l t ,Gar s l
s eter
ner' aborat y f ng w asw ihdraw n i J
or undi
t
n une
201 GanerDe l!39. S yr e rhe 'f ng, aloi tal outi di t St er
4. r
c.
The s es ac r' undi was s niily lne n he eg
ke
Letr ha c i duni er ptd.d. 37. ar ul oft wihdrwa i f ng, me '
te, s ontnue ntru e l ! As es t he t a l n undi Ga rs
l bor t y i s a f w ih f w e i vi ua st n w he he w asExe utve D i e t .See Ga ne D e l
a a or s t f ed t e r ndi d l ha
n
c i
r c or
r r c.
!41. a Afi vi! 11. c di t Gane ,hef ngwihdrwa ha ha ( de sai
,De n fda t
Ac or ng o r r t undi t a l s d C va ttng
a
e fc o g s a lt t e
fe t n hil biiy o ngagei r eac t manti a a nc g s postona rputtona
n es rh o i an nd dva e hi) ii nd e ai s
as e itt atac ga f ndi t s
cints,o tr t rnt u ng o uppor g s lboaor i pe nty,a t maiti ( s
t hij a rt y nde nde l nd o nan hil
a de ccae .'d. 40.
ca mi rer'I !
ProcvduralH i oa
st
Gane fl t slws tunde 42U. C.j 1 algi t thepose s albe t a
r r ied hi a ui
r
S.
983, le ng ha
ssed i ry nd
pr r y i e e ti hi pos ton a Exe utve D i e t r ofV BI a t tt def nda svi a e hi
ope t nt r s n s ii s c i
r co
, nd ha he e nt ol t d s
co tt i lrght w he t y de i d hi oft tposton w ihou due pr s . n O c obe 9,
ns iutona i s
n he prve m
ha
ii
t t
oce s O
t r
201 t c tdi m i s d m uc ofGar r sc pl i .Se D oc tN o. The co the d t t
4, he our s s e
h
ne ' om a nt e
ke
24.
ur l ha
G a ne ' lbe t i e e tc a m f ie be us t e pl ym e a ton a l d di notc tt e a
r r s i ry nt r s l i a l d, ca e he m o nt c i lege d
ons iut
s g fc ntr as i e S o a poston out i hi fel ofc c ' I a 1 The c ta s he d
i nii a e sgnm nt ç
t
ii
s de s i d
hoi e. d. t 9.
'
our l o l
t t de e nt ,i t i i vi ua c pa ii s w e e e il d t qua ii d i m uniy on Ga ner s
hat he f nda s n he r ndi d l a c t e , r ntt e o lf e m
t
r '
pr r y i e e tcl i f da a ,bec us i w a no S e r y esa i he ' ha t e pl ym e
ope t nt r s a m or m ges
a e t s t s a l t bls d't t he m o nt
cl
a ton a i s ha vi a e a pr t c e pr ry i e es . d. t 1 G a ne ' onl r a ni cl i ,
c i t s ue d ol t d
o e t d ope t nt r t l a 4. r r s y em i ng a m
t eor i hi pr peryitr tcam f rpr pe tveij tver le a i tt dee nt i
herf e,s s o t nees li o os ci nunci eif gans he fnda s n
t rof i a c pac tes
hei fci l a ii .
I isO c obe 9,201 opi on,t c te pha i d t tt d r tca co i r ton' w ih
nt t r
4 ni he our m
s ze ha he t ii l ns de a i ' t
c
r s c t t s c ai i w he he ,unde t t r s oft Ha book,Ga r s c nge i pos ton
e pe t o hi l m s
t r
r he e m
he nd
nw ' ha
n ii
c tt e a û e r s nc i ' w hi h r quied t the be af o de t s e duepr es a
ons iut d û ve e a ton,' c e r ha
s
f r d he am
oc s s
r m o lf ca e ora C e s gnm en , w hi h di not 1 a 1 U nde t t nns oft
e va or us ,
d as i
r
t'
' c d . d. t 2.
r he e
he
Ha
ndbook,û C e r s nc i . . r ly i ve a s gni i a l s o pe ly. .s h as but
$ s ve e a ton, .gene a l nvol s i fc nt os r na t . uc ,
a
notlmie t arduci i tte,rs nsbiiis ands ay..'1 a 1 1 (ii Ha boo j
i td o, e ton n il epo i lte , alr .'' d. t 2- 3 ctng nd k
7. 5) Thec tf
6. .
our oundt tGanerha a uaeyal edC h ar duci i tteand
ha r
d deq tl leg c
bot e ton n il
rs i lte .'d.a 1 Thus drj t r ucinsgn moneaybe is c tt earduci
eponsbiiis'1 t 3. ,tif he ed to i
tr nett) onsiut e ton
i s l r t n i a a s t c nge i pos to woul c tt e a r duc i i til
n a a y, he t ppe r he ha
n ii n
d ons iut e ton n tte,
r po i lt a slr gali s eywihi t keveesnci caego y.'d.
es nsbiiy, nd aay' f lngj quarl t n he s r a ton' t r 'I
On Febr y 6,2015,bef e di
uar
or scover w as com pl ed,t def
y
et he endant fl a m oton f
s ied
i or
s mmayj g n o t i is e a g n ta Gan rsc a ei p sto c nsiue a
u r ud me t n h s su , r uig h t r e ' h ng n o iin o tttd
Cr i ent'as a m at erofl becaus hi s ar w asnotr
teass gnm '
t
aw
e s al y
educed asa res t O n M ay 5,2015,
ul .
t coutde e t smoto fndi t tt rc da t ttmeCel te t tt pa te
he t' nid hi in, i ng ha he e or tha i t fecgd) ha he ris
r
contnue t diput t scope and nat oft benett conf ed on Gar by hi i tal
i
o s e he
ure he
is
en'
ner
s nii
8
conta tw ih t U ni r iy. D oc tN o.54 a 7.The c ta s not t ttd r duc i i tt e
r c t he ve st '
' ke
t
our l o ed ha da e ton n il ,
r s i lte ,a s lr i sm pl one e mpl oft sg fca tl sorpe t .i pos f
e ponsbiii s nd aa y' s i y
xa e a i nii n os
naly..m ed or
una ce a e conduc a or a s r ousbr a h ofuni r iy polcy'c tt i a s ve e s nc i '
c pt bl
t nd/
ei
ec
ve st
i
ons iutng e r a ton.
'
l a 8.Thustwj t rGane ' r movala Exec i Die t c tt edas veesncton
d. t
i hehe r rs e
g
s
utve rcor onsiut
e r a i
e ilnghi t duepr s pr tci ( t nsonanumbe ofdipue f cs i udi butno
ntti m o
oce s oe tons 1 ur
r s td a t,ncl ng,
t
lm ied t w het G amer' sal y wasreduced as a r ul.'l
i t o,
her l s ar
es t' d.
Th p ristldco smoinsf rs mmayj d me to M a 1 , 01 Theemoi n
e a te ie r s- to o u r u g n n y 5 2 5. s to s
ha be n f ly b i f d,a t c t a d a g e o e c m oto o J 23,201 The
ve e u l r e e nd he our he r r um nt n a h
i n n une
5.
m otons a e now r pe f r vi .
i
r
i or e ew
St
andard ofRevi
ew
Summayj me i a opraeo ywhe ûhepl di ,t dic r a dicos e
r udg nt s ppr it nl
n t ea ngs he s ovey nd s l ur
t
m a e i son fl a a af i vis s
t ral
ie, nd ny fda t how t tt e i no ge ne i s ast a m a e i lf ta t
ha her s
nui s ue o ny t r a ac rd
t a t emo n i e tte t j d me t samatro lw. F d R. v. 5 () i h ncosh t h va t s n ild o u g n a
te f a ' e . Ci P. 6 a .s e r s
'
W
moto f s
ins or ummayj me ar s te t adititc tea hmoi mus bec i r d
r udg nt e ubmitd o src our, c ton t onsde e
i vi l and t f s r evantt each m us be vi ed i t lghtm os f
ndi dualy,
he act el
o
t
ew n he i
t avorabl t t
e o he
no mo a t'M elnv Bt ic 3 7F.d 3 5 3 3(t Ci. 0 3 . tes mmayj d me t
n v n . le . mtn , 2 3 5 , 6 4 h r 2 0 ) At h u r u g n
'
sa ,t c tc nnotk i jt e de o a s s r t winese cedi lt 'De sv.
tge he our a
é ghr he vi nce r s e sj he t s s' r biiy. nni
we
'
Col aColeonM e Ct.I .290F. 639,645(t Ci. 2) I t d,hec lt t
umbi lt
d. rsnc,
3d
4h r 200 .nsea t otr mus
co i ronl w he he a r a ona e t i roff c C d r t r a ve di f t non- ovi pa t '
ns de
y
t r e s bl r e
att
coul e u n
r ct or he
m ng r y.
'
Ande s v. be' Lo l ,477U. 242,248( 986 .
ron Li ly bby. nc.
t
S.
1 )
D i si
scus on
A st cour hasst ed on pr ous occas ons,t crtcali r i t s cas Ci w het
he
t
at
evi
i
he ii nquiy n hi
e çs
her
G ar exper enced a t
ner
i
severe s i 'entti hi t due pr
ancton, ilng m o
ocesspr ectons,orw het he
ot i
her
e r e e a d e sgnm e w hi h di not' Doc tN o.54 a 8,s e alo Doc tN o.24 a 1
xpe i nc d r as i
nt' c d .
' ke
t 'e s
ke
t 2.
Agan, ( eve e s ton'i $ sgnii a l sorpe t t af uly m e rs h a ,butnot
i a t r anci ' s 1 i fc nt os
s
a
naly o ac t mbe uc s
lm ie t a r duc i i tte, es
i t d o, e ton n il r pons biii s a s l r ,ors pens o wihoutpa f a pe i
i lte , nd a a y' us i n t
y or r od
no t e e one yea i pos f runac pt bl conduc a / a s r o br a h ofU ni st
t o xc ed
r m ed o
ce a e
t nd or e i us e c
ver iy
polc 'Pl' Ex.1 j7. 5. (ea sgnme ,' t ot rha i 1 c ngei a nitai
iy.' .s
0 6. A d s i nt'on he he nd,s û ha n dmi srtve
r
a
tte or s vi y res
il
uper sor pons biii reassi entt anot posii ordepart ent tans ert a
i ltes,
gnm
o
her
ton
m ,r f o
sa fposton,a o r ton i s l r c
tf
ii nd/ r educ i n a a y omm e ur t wih r uc d r ponsbiii , whi i no
ns a e t ed e es i ltes' ch s t
'
i e dasape lyf wr
ntnde
nat or ongdoi J.j7. 3.
ng..s 6. Uponrviwi t r c d,t c tfndst ta
/
e e ng he e or he our i ha
n
umbe ofmae ilfcua diputsprcl s
r
tra a t l s e e ude ummayj
r udgme ont sis .
nt hi sue
Fore m pl ,t pa te di put w he he G a ne ' c nge i poston w a V m pos d f
xa e he r i s s e
t r r r s ha
n ii
sd
i
e or
una ce a e co uc a or a s r ousbr a h ofUni r iy polc ' na e y,w he herhe w a
c pt bl nd t nd/
ei
ec
ve s t
i y' - m l
t
s
r oved a r ul oft a t A tt out e ,t c tnot st tGa ne ' r m ovaloc ur e onl
em
es t he udi. he s t he our e ha r r s e
c rd y
t e da afe V i gi a Te h of i i l m e t di c st r s t oft VB 1a t w hi h c l d
hr e ys t r r ni c fc a s t o s us he e uls he
udi, c onc ude
t tGa me ha vi a e c lc ofi e e tr e .Thi tm i ce ti y s
ha l r d ol t d onf i t nt r s ul s
s i ng ra nl ugges st tt t o e nt
t ha he w ve s
w e e r l t d.
r e a e The def nda sm a nt i ho e r t tt c nge i l de s p w asnoti e
e nt i a n, w ve , ha he ha
n ea r hi
nt nded a a
s
ûdi ci i y acton.'W aler Dep.at2 17.I t t def
ç s plnar
i '
t s
nsead, he endant i s t iW alersr si
s nsi t hat l t eas gned
Ga neri or rt c nge V Bl spr r mm a i diec i n a m ove a a f om bi nf m a i .
r n de o ha
' og a
t c r to nd
w y r
oi or tcs'
'
D ef' M o .
.s t Sum m .J a 4,D oc tN o.59.s W a t r D e a 1 201.
.t
ke
, ee le s p. t 97,
The c t i t s
our t nds hi
e a ton di fc tt s r wih t Uni r iy' publc sa e e s i m e a el f l w i
xpl na i
f i ul o qua e t he ve s t s
i t t m nt m di t y olo ng
G ar sr oval whi des be bi nf
ner' em
, ch cri
oi onnatcsasScrtcaly i port ' t VBI.See Def' Ex.E.
i
û ii l m
ant' o
.s
M or ove ,Ga ne m ai ai t tW ale st d hi t the w a be ng r m ove due t i i k. Ga ner
e r r r nt ns ha
t r ol m ha
s i e
d
o ds ' r
r '
De l!!24- Gar rhasas pr uc de de s esi t tDe nt dot rVB1pes
c.
25. ne
lo od e vi nce ugg tng ha a ol he
ronnel
t theha be n r moved f rt a lng't a t SeeGa ne De l j 26, e e De a 9- 0.Dea
ha
d e e
o t ii ' he udi.
f
r r c . g . nir p. t 1
M
n,
on t ot rha ha t tfed t the t d VBlpe s
he he nd, s es ii ha
ol
r onnelt tt r i asa a tbutt r wasno
ha he e t
w
n udi
he e
wr
ongdoi ' D e Dep.a 62.W ihoutco i r ng t c e biiy oft e w ines e orot r i e
ng.' an
t
t
nsde i he r di lt
hes t s s
he w s
10
w ei ng t evi
ghi he dence,t courtsi pl cannotdeci whet Gar srem ovalw as a ts e
he
m y
de
her ner'
dever
s t on' i ended aspuni hm entSf unaccept e conductand/ a s i br
anc i ' nt
s
çor
abl
or er ous each ofU ni iy
verst
Polcy-'
i '
The pa tesal o diput w he he G a ne e r e e ça r duc i n i tte, e po i ltes
ri s s e
t r r r xpe i nc d ( e t o n il r s ns biii ,
a s a y' fti s ua el w ihi t H a
nd al r ' itng q r y t n he ndbook' de i to ofa ( e e s nc i ' Se Pl' Ex.
s f nii n
' ver a ton. e .s
s
'
1 j7. 5. pa tesagret tGn n rsttea r ponsbiii c nge whe hewasrmove
0 6. The ri
e ha r e ' il nd es i ltes ha d n
e
d
f om t poston ofExe utve D ie or t y al o a e t thi s l r di notc nge asa r ul of
r he ii
c i
r ct ; he s gr e ha s a a y d
ha
es t
t sc nge.The pa te di a e ho e r a t w he he G a ne ' l s ofl bo a or f ndi w as
hi ha
ri s s gr e, w ve , s o
t r r r s os
a r t y u ng
c
onne t d t hi dem oton,whi h m a s
ce o s
i
c
y ugge tt i wasa s ve e s nc i
s hat t
e r a ton.
The de e nt a gue t tt l bor t r f ndi pr de f r i t St ge Le t rw a no
f nda s r
ha he a a o y u ng ovi d o n he e r te s t
i e
nt nded t s
o uppor G a ne ' l bo a or i fnie y.A c or ng t t de e nt ,Vi g ni Te h,
t r r s a r t y nde i t l
c di o he f nda s r i a c
lkeot runi rii ,i t t d ai ofaltsa tup'pa kage .SeeDe nAf. 9'Fine De
i he ve stes lmis he urton
lttr- ' c s
a f ! , n y p.
a 98;M c a
t
N meeDe a 35. de e nt c endt tGa ne kne ors d ha known t s
p. t The f nda s ont ha r r w
houl ve
he e
f
unds w o d be lm ie i dur ton,be aus he hasnego i t d num er t t r - 'pa ka ove
ul
i td n ai
c e
ta e
ous t a tup' c ges r
s
t c s ofhi ca e r See G a ne D e a 98 1 The de e n st m ai ai t tt dec son
he our e
s re .
r r p. t - 00.
f nda t hus nt n ha he i i
t t r i t Gal r s l bo a or f ng oc ur ed a a m a t r o c s ,a w ase ie y unr l t d
o e m na e me ' a r t y undi
c r s
te f our e nd
ntr l
ea e
t t ea lerde s on t r m ove G a ne a Exe utve Di e t r The def nda st a gue t tt
o he z i
cii o e
r r s c i
r co .
e nt hus r
ha he
r m o lofG a ner sl bor t y f ng i 201 ca m ott a f m hi 201 r s i nm e i o a
e va
r ' a a or undi n
3 r
r ns or s 2 ea s g nt nt
s e sancton.
ever
i
The def nda s poston i no w ihoutm e i . e t ,howeve ,i G a ne ' . c r ng t
e nt ' ii s t t
rt N iher
r s r r s A co di o
G a ne ,t l bor or f ng s tf ' i t St rLe t rw asi e
r r he a at y undi e olh n he ege te
t
nt nded t pr de o
o ovi ngoi
ng
s
uppo tf hi pe s lr s a c SeeGa ne De . l Ga nere
r or s r ona e e r h.
r r cl ! 0. r
mphasz t tt St ge Let r
i es ha he e r te
is fdoesnotexplcil lm i t dur i oft e f ,even t
t el
i ty i t he aton hos unds
hough ot tnanci t
her i
al enusi t
n hat
l t ar so lm ied.See Pl' Ex.11.W hen G ar w asr oved as Executve D iect ,he l tt
eter e i t
.s
ner
em
i
r or
os he
11
a lt t de i t V B1f
biiy o s gna e
undst s
o uppo thi own l bor t r es e t a l pe m itng t def nda s
r s
a a o y, s n i ly r t i he e nt
t r m ove hi f ng a t i l i ur Thus G a ne c t nds he e r e ed a s ve e s nc i a
o e
s undi t he r e s e.
, r r on e , xpe i nc
e r a ton t
t tm e ofhi de oton,des t t f c t tt de e nt di no f l t ough by wihdr w i
he i
s m i
pie he a t ha he f nda s d t olow hr
t a ng
hi f ng f overa year.
s undi or
l s e de ei t s
n um, vi nc n he ummayj
r udgme r or s rsbohpa tes postons The
nt ec d uppo t t ri ' ii .
c tt c motco l t tet ri e ildt j me a amatroflw.
our hus ar
ncude ha ihe s ntte o udg nt s te a
C oncl i
us on
Fo tera o ssae ,h pa t s moinsf rs mmayj d me ta ed n e Thi matr
r h e s n ttd t e ri ' to o u r u g n r e id. s te
e
wilbestdownf abe htil a whi t eoul i e t ma us ofa a s yj y.
l e
or nc ra, t eh he ' ntnds o ke e n dvior ur The
t
Cl r i diec ed t s nd ce tf e co e oft sm e or ndum o ni n a t a c pa ng or r
ek s r t o e
ri i d pi s hi m a
pi o nd he c om nyi
de
t a lc
o l ouns lofr or
e
ec d.
EN TER : Thi
s
l'
a
day ofJul , 2015.
y
Chi U nied St es Di t ctJ
ef t
at
sri udge
12
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?