Horton v. Clarke

Filing 6

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 04/18/2014. (kab)

e FQKS OFFI U, DI COURT
CE S. SX
AT 9. .V' E VA
31 f. .

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O AN O K E D I I O N
V SI
ROGER L.H ORTON,
Pett oner,
ii
V.

CLARKE,
R espondent
.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

AP0 2 2 1
.
,
oj
c
JULI c. . ' wuiiK
A
- , zr
g'
t
BY;
' '
DEP
CLERK

Ci lAc i No.7: c 001
vi ton
14- v- 29
M EM OM NDUM O PI ON
NI
By:

H on.H on.Jam es C.Turk
Seni Unie St t Dit i tJudge
or t d a es s r c

Roge L.Ho t aVigi ai a epr ee ng pr K , ie ape ii f wrtofha as
r
ron, r ni nm t oc di
o fld
tton or i
be

c mu , t s a t o2 U. C. 2 4.Peiin rc aln e t ev l iyo h sc n i e n
o s pt u n t 8 S. j 25
r
tto e h l g s h ai t f i o fn me t
e
d
p rua t ot eM a 7 20 7 j d me to teCic i Co r o RuselComt .Afe rviwig
u s n t h y , 0 ,u g n f h rut u t f s l t y tr e e n
t peii t co ttndst ti s d bedimi s d sl a iy ptr uan t Rul 4 oft Rul s
he tton, he ur i ha t houl
s s e lmm rl ls t o e
he e

Go r ng j225 Cas s1
veni
4 e.
A fdealc tma notg a aj2254ha aspeii t e st peiine e usedt
e r our y
r nt
be tton mls he tto r xha t he
r m e esa ia e i t c t oft sa ei whih peii rwasco c e 28 U. C.
e di va lbl n he ours he t t n c ttone
nvit d.
S.

j2 5 (9; es rv Ro rc e , 1U. 4 ( 97 ) S a tnv. mih 4 4U. 5 ( 9 1 .
2 4 1 Prie . d iu z 41 S. 75 1 3 ; lvo S t , 0 S. 3 1 7 )
The e usi r quie e i s tsi d by s e ngr viw oft cai i t hi s sa ec t
xha ton e r m nt s aife
e ki e e
he l m n he ghe t tt our

wi j rs ito t c n ie tecam.O' ulv nv. e c e, 2 U. 8 ( 9 9 .l
t u idcin o o sd r h li
h
S lia Bo r k l 5 6 S. 38 1 9 ) n
Vigi a anon- ah r c c c n e us sa er m e esi o oft eewa ,de ndi on
r ni,
de t ow onvit a xha t tt e di n ne hr
ys pe ng
t naur oft cai sr i e Fis,t c nvitc n fl adie ta
he t e he l m a s d. rt he o c a ie r c ppea t t Vigi aCour of
l o he r ni
t
Appe swih as e nta alt t Su e Cour ofVigi ai t Cour ofAppe sr e
al t ubs que ppe o he pr me
t
r ni f he
t
al uls

agans t c c.VA.CODE j1 1411 Sec t c c c atc t c cin
i the onvit
7.- . ond,he onvit an ta k he onvito
c lt r l by flng a sa eha aspe ii wih t cr ui c t r t co c was
ola e aly
ii
t t be
tton t he ic t our whe e he nvit

c ce a t na lnga a rede iin t t SuprmeCour ofVigi a.l j8. onvitd nd he ppeai n dves cso o he
e
t
r ni d. 01
lA pe ii ma bedimis d puruan t Rul 4i i i cl rfom t peii t tapeii ri note ildt
tton y
s se
s t o e f t s ea r he tton ha
ttone s
ntte o
r le .
eif

6 4 A) 1; . u Ct R. 9a .Fnal t ec n itc ne ha s rme isb fl gasae
5 ( () Va S p. . 5:() i l h o vc a x u t e de y ii tt
y,
n
ha e sp tto dr cl wi teS p e Co r o Vigna
b a eiin ie ty t h u r me u t f r ii.VA. DE j8016 4 A)1.
h
CO
. -5 ( ()
W hi he rr ei t n,t c c uli ae y mus pr e t ca mst t Supr m eCour of
c ve out s ake he onvi t tm tl
t es nt he li o he
e
t
Vigi a a r evear lng fom t tcou tbe or af de a dititc r ca c i rt
r ni nd ec i
u i r ha
r f e e r l src ou t n onsde he
cai s A ha aspe ii rhasnote used sa er medi i t pe ii rhast rghtt r
lm .
be
ttone
xha t t t e
es f he ttone
he i mde
sae 1w t r s t q si pr s ntd byany a ia epr dur a f l t do s 28U. C.
t t a o aie he ue ton e e e
va lbl oce e nd ais o
o.
S.

j2254/)
.
Thepe ii c e ry s
tton l a l howst tPeii rha no pr s nt cai st t Supr me Co t
ha ttone s t e e ed l m o he
e
ur

ofV igi a.2 Pettonersf ltet e
r ni
ii ' aitr o xhaus sae r medisma t sl a y dimis loft
t tt e
e ndaes lmm r s s a
he
pe ii n.3 Ba e upon t fndi t tPe ii rhasnotm a t r quiie s t ntals
tto
sd
he i ng ha ttone
de he e st ubsa i howi
ng

ofde alofaco tt i rghtasr quiedb 28U. C.j2253() ace tfc eof
ni
nsiutonal i
e r y
S.
c, riiat
a albiiy i de ed.
ppe a lt s ni
ENTER: Thi
s

l
j

,

dyoApi2 1.
a f r,04
l
-

f.

Se orUnie St t sDit'tJ e
ni
t d a e sr udg

2Peii rac
ttone knowl si t peii t hthasno pr s nt t i tntha scamst t Su e Co tof
edge n he tton hat
t e e ed he nsa bea li o he pr me ur
Vigi a eihe vi asaeha asc puspeii ora a l9om t Cou tofAppe l ofV igi aorCic tCou t
r ni, t r a tt be or
tton n ppea
he r
as
r ni
r ui
r
ofRus el Count Pe ii re ai t tcot e o diec appe r r d i f tvea ssa eby deauli
sl
y. ttone xpl ns ha ms l n r t al ende e nefeci s itnc
f tng
t a al Alhoug Peii r s t cai i t habea pe ii hee anst c dnota
hat ppe . t h ttoner aied he l m n he
s tton, xpli hat oul
ppealt
he

ds sa ofh h bespeiinb c u eo hsI o 6 a dlc o imaelg l sitn e Co sq e t , n
imisl te a a tt e a s f i Q f 5 n a k fn t e a assa c . n e u nl o e
o
y
o i f Peii rt tyt e us sa ec t e di woul bet fl anoi ofappea wih t Cic tCo t
pton or ttone o r o xha t tt our r me es
d o ie tce
l t he r ui ur
ofRus elCount a t n t fl apetton f a lwiht Su e eCour ofV igi at te anst r s
sl
y nd he o ie
ii or ppea t he pr m
t
r ni ha xpli he ea ons
f t de a a al hi ba esf a tz li
or he l yed ppe , s s or c ta nnoce e,a t r s why he be i vest Cicui Cou tofRus el
nc nd he ea ons
le
he r t r
s l
Count er d bydim isngt sa ehabe peiin.
y re
s si he tt
as tto

3Peii rma r iehi f r ha aspeii i heuns es f l pr e st cai t t Supr Cour of
ttone y efl s edeal be tton f
ucc suly es nt he l ms o he
eme
t
Vigi at oughoneoft t eer e des rbed.Peii i a s d,howeve ,hathi tmet fl sat and
r ni hr
he hr outs c i
ttoner s dvie
rt
s i o ie t e

fd r l a e sp tin i l td.S e2 U. C. 2 4 4 VA. E j80165 A)2 .
e ea h b a eio s s i e e 8 S. j 2 4 *; COD . - 4( ()
t
mi
2