Dawson v. Fleming et al
Filing
9
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 06/17/2014. (kab)
D O œs OFFI U..DI CouRr
CE S SX
AT ROANOKE.
VA
c !?j
tl il
q'
q7
JUN 1S 2 1
29
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI I A
CT
RG NI
ROANOK E DI SI
VI ON
JO H N N Y D O R AN ZO D AW SO N ,
Pl ntf
ai if,
V.
W ARDEN L.J.FLEM I ,e aI,
NG t .
D ef
endant
s.
JULA C. i L$ CLERK
I
j
BY:
DEP
LERK
C i lA c i N o.7: c 001
vi ton
14- v- 62
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
M EM O M ND U M O PINIO N
By:
H on.Jam e C . urk
s T
Se or U ni e St e D i t c Judge
ni
t d at s s ri t
J
ohnny Do a Da on,aVigni prs rpr e ng pr K ,fld aci lrght
r nzo ws
r i a ione oc edi
o
ie
vi i s
Compli ,ptrua t 42U. C.j1 3.Pl ntf mesasdefnda sW ade L.J Flmi
ant ls nt o
S. 98 ai ifnn
e nt r n . e ng,
Asitn W ad nR. ay Ca ti Le , panFil s M ao Kel Ofie Rie Of r
ssa t r e Clr , p an e Ca ti ed , j r l fc r f, t
y,
ke
Bosi ,Se ge ntCoope ,Se ge ntM ic l a Li u e n Da ds a1 ofwhom a e
tc r a
r r a
t hel, nd e t na t vi on, 1
r
empl soft Vigi a De rm e ofCoreci .Pl i ifa lgest tt de e nt wer
oyee
he r ni pa t nt
r tons antf le ha he f nda s e
delber t y i fe e t a s t i rs ofhn m,i vi a i oft Ei hAm e
i ael ndif r nt o ubsantal ik
r n olton he ght
ndme oft
nt he
U nie St t Cons iuto Thi m al ri be or t c rtf r s r e ng, ls n t 28 U . C.
t d a es
tt i n. s t e s f e he ou o c e ni ptr ua t o
S.
j 1 5 Afe rve n ter c r t ec u t imis st eCo lit t u p eudc f r
91 A. tr e iwi g h e o d,h o r ds se h mpan wi t rj ie o
ho
f lng t sa ea cai upo whi h r le m a begr nt d.
aii o tt l m
n
c e if y
a e
1.
Pl i ifa lgest f l ng f c s OnN ove
antf le
he olowi a t .
mber4,201 Pli ifwa tanse r d
3, antf s r f r e
fo Ke nM ount nCorecina Ce e (t CC' t li rNorhCoreci lCe tr
rm e
ai r to l ntr I
KM ' o kve t r tona ne
)
(1
$
RNCC' vi af z- l busrde.Pli ifstdowni t buswhiewe rngha ufs a
' a olrhotr i
)
antf a
n he
l a i ndc f,
w aitc i , a l g s c e ,a a uns ii d pe s pu Pl i ifsprs n-s ue t l son1
s ha n nd e ha kls nd n pecfe r on t antf
i o i s d eevii
on t ofPl i if s ha uf e m i t . So e t d Pl n ift the w a r quie t c r y hi
op
a ntf ' ndc f d s s m one ol ai t f ha
s e rd o ar s
t l s on i hi a m sf t e i e f l hourbus rde,a t w e gh oft t e s o c us d t
e evi i n s r or he ntr otr
i nd he i t he el vi i n a e he
1Thet evi on al dl wei appr maeyt 't poundsa me t e 1 i he x 1 i sx 1
el si lege y ghed
oxi tl hl y
r
nd asl d 2 nc s 2 nche 4
r
i hes
nc .
handc f t di i o Pl ntf sm is s Bec us Pl i ifw or r sr i sw ihoutha ng a s a
uf s o g nt ai i f
t.
a e a ntf
e e t a nt t
vi
et
bet hesr i d hi wrs swhie hol ng t t e son a tyi no t f lo oft s t
l, ta ne s it
l di he elvi i nd r ng t o al ut he ea,
wh c c u e S xc cai gpan'i h swrss ams lg , n b c Plitf alg st tt l i
ih a s d ç nzitn i 'n i it, r ,e s a d a k. an if le e ha çth s
e
l
Wa O d rdb Ca tLe , p . eds M a. l Lt Da i o , tCo p r S . ic el
S r ee y p . e Ca t Fil , j Kel . vds n Sg . p e , gtM th l,
y,
Of Bosi,(nd)Of Rie whowe ea1i ag e me wih or r fo W ade ( Flmi a
c. tc a
c. f,
r l n r e nt t des rm r n 1 e ng nd
Asitn W ad n ( Clr t ma ea1 fe esc ryt i tlvso so tpo t i h n c fd
ssa t r e ) ay o k 1o fnd r ar her ee iin n o f her a d ufe
wrssa a mst e ieti ' Compl 3.
it nd r he ntr rp.
'
.
Pli tf tidt if nn teofc r o teb sa o tt p i b tGth mu i wa b i
anif re o n o h fie s n h u b u he an, u G j e sc s eng
l
pl ye s l t ti ... e n edt ofi e sfom hea i m ec
a d o oud ha t pr ve t he fc r r
rng
ompli ng oft e nz a i
ani
he xc citng
pa n Iwas s f r ng,e t
i
uf e i
ven hough lye l d t t ofi e f hel ' 1 4. Pl i if sha
le o he t c r or p. d.
'
a ntf
nds
bec m enumb by t tmehea rve a RNCC f hour lt r a hehasaleg y s t i
n
he i
ri d t
our
s a e , nd
l edl usaned
pe m a ntne v da age.
r ne
re m
Il.
Thec tmus dim isa a ton orcli fl d by a i a ei t c td e mi st t
our
t s s ny c i
am ie
n nm t f he our etr ne ha
t aci n orcli i fi ousorf ist s eac am on whi h r i m a be g ant See28
he to
am s rvol
al o ut l i
c elef y
r ed.
U; C. j1 5 e( ) 1 5 b ( ) 4 U. C. 1 9 ec .Th frtsa d r i ld scams
S. j 91 ()2 , 91 A( )1 ; 2 S. j 9 7 () e is tn ad ncu e li
bas upon ç n i s abl m e il s l ga t or ' ç l i sofi r nge e ofa l li e e t
ed
t ndi put y r te s e l he y, t a m
a
'c
nf i m nt
ega nt r s
whi h cea l doesnote s,' c am swhe et çf cua contntonsa e cea l bas l s .
c l ry
xit'or l i
r he ta t l e i
r l ry e e s'
'
Netkev.W iln ,490U. 31 3 ( 989 .Thes c sandadi t fmiirsa r f
iz
lims
S. 9, 27 1 )
e ond t r s he n la tndad or
amotont dimisunde Fedea Rul ofCi lPr edle1 b)6) a e i apli ifs
i o s s
r rl e
vi oc tr 2( ( , cc ptng antf'
f c ualal ga i astu
a t le tons r e.A c
ompl i nee t s ta pl n sa e toft cai s
ant ds ( hor nd ai t t men
a
he l m howi
ng
t tt plade i e ildt rle ' nds t e çlla t al ai ...or s arg t
ha he e r s ntte o eif a ufkint çt cual leg tons t aie iht o
2
rle a vetes e u ai lve. .' Bel lCo p. Two y 5 0U. 5 4 5 5( 0 7
eif bo h p c ltve e l . . lAt. r v. mbl, 5 S. 4 , 5 2 0 )
'
(ntr lquottonmar o te .A pl ntf sbai f r i te rsmor t nlbesa
i ena
ai
ks mitd)
ai if ss or eleft quie
r
e ha a l nd
c us ons ....' I The e or a pl i ifm us ç l f c s s fc e t s a e a lt el m e s
oncl i
' d.
r f e, a ntf
t ç ege a t uf i nt o t t l he e nt
al
o Eh jcam.z Ba sv. 1Du o ld Ne u s& Co.3 4F.d7 , 65( t Ci. 0 3 .
f t e li ' s E.. p n e mo r
'
, 2 3 61 7 4h r 2 0 )
Tosaeacam unde j198 apli ifmus algeChevi ai ofarghts c edby
tt li
r
3, antf t le ç olton
t
i e ur
t Consiuton a l w soft Unie St t , nd m us s
he
tt i nd a
he t d a es a
t how t tt a l d de i t o w a
ha he lege prva i n s
commitdbyape s aci t rc orofsaelw. W es v. ki , U. 42,48( 988)
te
ron tng mde ol
tt a '
' t At ns 487 S.
1 .
Tobela evi j 1 frac ton ofconfne ntt tvi aest Eiht Ame
ibl a 983 o ondii
i me ha olt he g h
ndmen,a
t
saea trmu th v b e d lb rtl i ifrn t t es b tn il ik o ij r c u e b te
tt co s a e e n eie aey ndfee t o h u sa ta rs f nu y a s d y h
c ton.Stikl v.W aes 989F. 1375,1379(t Ci.1 ) Tobedei rtl
ondii
rc er
tr,
2d
4h r 993 .
lbeaey
i fer nt aprs ofi a l tbo h bea z off c sfom whih t i e e e c dbe
ndif e , ion fcil t
mus t
wa e a t r
c he nf r nc oul
d a t tas t nta rs ofs rousha e ss a hem us a s dr w t i e e e.'
r wn ha ubsa il ik e i
nn xit, nd
t lo a he nf r nc '
Fa rv.Br nna 511U. 825,835( 994) A prs ofi a i notla ei hei w t
nne
e n,
S.
1 .
ion fcil s ibl f t
kne he
undel ngfcsbutbeive (l it oundl t tt rs t whiht fcsg vers was
ryi a t
le d abet ms
y) ha he ik o c he a t a ie
i u sa ta o n n x se t'I . t8 4; e R- hv Br c , 2 F.d3 6, 8( t Ci. 9 7
ns b tn il r o e itn . d a 4 s e i . u e 1 9 3 3 33 4h r 1 9 )
'
c
( di t tprs ofi a wasnotdei rtl i fee be us hedi nota ualydrw t
hol ng ha ion fcil
lbeaey ndifrnt ca e
d
ct l a he
if rn et a t ep io rwa e p s dt as e ii rs o h nn)
n e e c h t h rs ne s x o e o p cfc ik f a .
2Dee mi ng wheherac
tr ni
t
ompli saesaplusbl cam f rr le i (ac e -pecik t kt tr quiest
ant tt
a i e li o eif s ( ontxts t as ha e r he
rve n c u toda o is u iil x ein ea dc mmo sn e' As r Av lba, 5 U.. 6 6 87
e iwig o r t rw n tj dca e p re c n o n e s . hco .g l5 6 S 6 2, 7 -9
'
(0 9 .Th s ac u t ce nn ac mpan u e Rul 1 ( ()c nie tf pe dn sta aen te tldt a
2 0 ) u , o r sre ig o lit nd r e 2b)6 a d niy la ig h t r o nie o n
t
as
s umpton oftuh bec us t co itofno mo et n lbel a concusons l Alhought co tlbealy
i
rt
a e hey nss
r ha a s nd
l i . d. t
he ur i r l
c n tu sp oK c mpans Han sv. re, 0 U.. 9 5 021(9 2 ,h c ut o sn t c a a imaes
o sr e r o lit, ie Ken r 4 4 S 51 , 2 - 1 7 )te o r d e o a t s n n t'
a
dvoca e,s s e de o ng s a ut r a c tt i lc a m snotc e r y r i e i a co pl i . Se Br v.
t ua pont vel pi t t o y nd ons iutona l i
la l as d n
m a nt e ock
Car l 1 7F.d2 , 43(t Ci. 9 7 ( ti J, o c ni g ; a d t v Civo Ha tn, 7 F.d 1 7
rol 0 3 41 2 4h r 1 9 ) Lut .c n u n )Be u et . t f mpo 7 5 2 2 4,
,
p
1 8( hCi.1 8 ) seas God nv Lek , 7 F.d1 47 151(t Ci. 9 )(e o nzn ta adsrc
27 4t r 9 5 ,e lo ro . e e 5 4 2 1 , 1 4h r 1 78 rc g iig h t itit
.
c u tsn t x ce t as met r l o a v c t frapr K panig.
o r i o e petd o su he oe f d o ae o o litf
3
Pli iff ist i ntf al def ntsdelbe ae i fe e et t f c t t l son
a ntf al o de iy ry enda ' i r t ndifr nc o he a t he eevii
be ng plce on Pl ntf swa s c i a m s a orwrssf f hour c e t as bsa i l
i
a d
ai if
it han, r , nd/
it or our
s r aed u t nta
rs ofû xc c a i pan. Pli tf doesnotal get ta de e ntwaspr s nton t bus
ik ' nzi tng i ' a n if
e
'
le ha ny f nda
ee
he
dur ng hi or a orha a know l dge a uthow at e son w oul be pl e ac os Pl i i f s
i
s de l
d ny
e
bo
el vi i
d
ac d r s a ntf '
m i t Eve i Pli tf alege adef nda ha bee o t bus Pl ntf a knowldg t t
ss. n f a n if l d
e nt d n n he , ai if c
e es ha
noneoft sa fo t bushea d hi compl ni abou t pan o we eot wie a r of
he tf n he
r m
ai ng
t he i r r her s wa e
hi e re ngpan. Furhe
m xpe inci
i
t nnor Pli ifsuns ppo td concuson t tDe e nt kne
e, antf
u re
l i ha f nda s w
i a e o t ta f rbuswo d ha t hol t i t lvii , c i note tte t a
nm t s n he r ns e
ul ve o d her ee sons whi h s
n ild o n
as umpton oftuh,i no s fcintt de c i knowldge ofas t nta rs ofhn m.
s
i
r t s t ufi e o s rbe
e
ubsa i l ik
r
Ac r ngl t c ttndst tPli iff l t alegeadef nda ' dei r t i f e e e,
co di y, he our i ha antf ais o l
e nts lbe a e ndif r nc
a dt eCo li t sd s se wih u p eu ie
n h mpan i imis d t o t rj dc .
1
11.
Fo tef rg i r a o s t ec u t imis steCo lit t o t rj dc frf iig
r h o e ong e s n ,h o r ds se h mpan wih u p eu ie o aln
t saeacam u nwh c r l f yb g a td pzs a tt 28U. C.j1 5 b ()
o tt li po ih ei ma e r ne , l u n o
e
r
S.
91 A()1 .
ENTER:Ths d
i '
7
d yo Jne 2 4
a f u , 01 .
,.
-
-,
,'
%
A-;
y- ;
;
p
.
-:
-j
-)
. .. . .
. .-
.
Se ' rUnied St t Diti tJ
t
aes src udge
4
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?