Dawson v. Fleming et al

Filing 9

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 06/17/2014. (kab)

D O œs OFFI U..DI CouRr
CE S SX
AT ROANOKE.
VA
c !?j
tl il
q'
q7

JUN 1S 2 1
29
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI I A
CT
RG NI
ROANOK E DI SI
VI ON
JO H N N Y D O R AN ZO D AW SO N ,
Pl ntf
ai if,
V.

W ARDEN L.J.FLEM I ,e aI,
NG t .
D ef
endant
s.

JULA C. i L$ CLERK
I
j
BY:
DEP
LERK

C i lA c i N o.7: c 001
vi ton
14- v- 62

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

M EM O M ND U M O PINIO N

By:

H on.Jam e C . urk
s T
Se or U ni e St e D i t c Judge
ni
t d at s s ri t

J
ohnny Do a Da on,aVigni prs rpr e ng pr K ,fld aci lrght
r nzo ws
r i a ione oc edi
o
ie
vi i s

Compli ,ptrua t 42U. C.j1 3.Pl ntf mesasdefnda sW ade L.J Flmi
ant ls nt o
S. 98 ai ifnn
e nt r n . e ng,

Asitn W ad nR. ay Ca ti Le , panFil s M ao Kel Ofie Rie Of r
ssa t r e Clr , p an e Ca ti ed , j r l fc r f, t
y,
ke
Bosi ,Se ge ntCoope ,Se ge ntM ic l a Li u e n Da ds a1 ofwhom a e
tc r a
r r a
t hel, nd e t na t vi on, 1
r
empl soft Vigi a De rm e ofCoreci .Pl i ifa lgest tt de e nt wer
oyee
he r ni pa t nt
r tons antf le ha he f nda s e
delber t y i fe e t a s t i rs ofhn m,i vi a i oft Ei hAm e
i ael ndif r nt o ubsantal ik
r n olton he ght
ndme oft
nt he
U nie St t Cons iuto Thi m al ri be or t c rtf r s r e ng, ls n t 28 U . C.
t d a es
tt i n. s t e s f e he ou o c e ni ptr ua t o
S.

j 1 5 Afe rve n ter c r t ec u t imis st eCo lit t u p eudc f r
91 A. tr e iwi g h e o d,h o r ds se h mpan wi t rj ie o
ho
f lng t sa ea cai upo whi h r le m a begr nt d.
aii o tt l m
n
c e if y
a e
1.

Pl i ifa lgest f l ng f c s OnN ove
antf le
he olowi a t .
mber4,201 Pli ifwa tanse r d
3, antf s r f r e

fo Ke nM ount nCorecina Ce e (t CC' t li rNorhCoreci lCe tr
rm e
ai r to l ntr I
KM ' o kve t r tona ne
)
(1
$
RNCC' vi af z- l busrde.Pli ifstdowni t buswhiewe rngha ufs a
' a olrhotr i
)
antf a
n he
l a i ndc f,
w aitc i , a l g s c e ,a a uns ii d pe s pu Pl i ifsprs n-s ue t l son1
s ha n nd e ha kls nd n pecfe r on t antf
i o i s d eevii
on t ofPl i if s ha uf e m i t . So e t d Pl n ift the w a r quie t c r y hi
op
a ntf ' ndc f d s s m one ol ai t f ha
s e rd o ar s
t l s on i hi a m sf t e i e f l hourbus rde,a t w e gh oft t e s o c us d t
e evi i n s r or he ntr otr
i nd he i t he el vi i n a e he
1Thet evi on al dl wei appr maeyt 't poundsa me t e 1 i he x 1 i sx 1
el si lege y ghed
oxi tl hl y
r
nd asl d 2 nc s 2 nche 4
r
i hes
nc .

handc f t di i o Pl ntf sm is s Bec us Pl i ifw or r sr i sw ihoutha ng a s a
uf s o g nt ai i f
t.
a e a ntf
e e t a nt t
vi
et

bet hesr i d hi wrs swhie hol ng t t e son a tyi no t f lo oft s t
l, ta ne s it
l di he elvi i nd r ng t o al ut he ea,

wh c c u e S xc cai gpan'i h swrss ams lg , n b c Plitf alg st tt l i
ih a s d ç nzitn i 'n i it, r ,e s a d a k. an if le e ha çth s
e
l
Wa O d rdb Ca tLe , p . eds M a. l Lt Da i o , tCo p r S . ic el
S r ee y p . e Ca t Fil , j Kel . vds n Sg . p e , gtM th l,
y,
Of Bosi,(nd)Of Rie whowe ea1i ag e me wih or r fo W ade ( Flmi a
c. tc a
c. f,
r l n r e nt t des rm r n 1 e ng nd

Asitn W ad n ( Clr t ma ea1 fe esc ryt i tlvso so tpo t i h n c fd
ssa t r e ) ay o k 1o fnd r ar her ee iin n o f her a d ufe
wrssa a mst e ieti ' Compl 3.
it nd r he ntr rp.
'
.

Pli tf tidt if nn teofc r o teb sa o tt p i b tGth mu i wa b i
anif re o n o h fie s n h u b u he an, u G j e sc s eng
l
pl ye s l t ti ... e n edt ofi e sfom hea i m ec
a d o oud ha t pr ve t he fc r r
rng
ompli ng oft e nz a i
ani
he xc citng
pa n Iwas s f r ng,e t
i
uf e i
ven hough lye l d t t ofi e f hel ' 1 4. Pl i if sha
le o he t c r or p. d.
'
a ntf
nds

bec m enumb by t tmehea rve a RNCC f hour lt r a hehasaleg y s t i
n
he i
ri d t
our
s a e , nd
l edl usaned
pe m a ntne v da age.
r ne
re m
Il.

Thec tmus dim isa a ton orcli fl d by a i a ei t c td e mi st t
our
t s s ny c i
am ie
n nm t f he our etr ne ha
t aci n orcli i fi ousorf ist s eac am on whi h r i m a be g ant See28
he to
am s rvol
al o ut l i
c elef y
r ed.

U; C. j1 5 e( ) 1 5 b ( ) 4 U. C. 1 9 ec .Th frtsa d r i ld scams
S. j 91 ()2 , 91 A( )1 ; 2 S. j 9 7 () e is tn ad ncu e li
bas upon ç n i s abl m e il s l ga t or ' ç l i sofi r nge e ofa l li e e t
ed
t ndi put y r te s e l he y, t a m
a
'c
nf i m nt
ega nt r s

whi h cea l doesnote s,' c am swhe et çf cua contntonsa e cea l bas l s .
c l ry
xit'or l i
r he ta t l e i
r l ry e e s'
'

Netkev.W iln ,490U. 31 3 ( 989 .Thes c sandadi t fmiirsa r f
iz
lims
S. 9, 27 1 )
e ond t r s he n la tndad or
amotont dimisunde Fedea Rul ofCi lPr edle1 b)6) a e i apli ifs
i o s s
r rl e
vi oc tr 2( ( , cc ptng antf'
f c ualal ga i astu
a t le tons r e.A c
ompl i nee t s ta pl n sa e toft cai s
ant ds ( hor nd ai t t men
a
he l m howi
ng

t tt plade i e ildt rle ' nds t e çlla t al ai ...or s arg t
ha he e r s ntte o eif a ufkint çt cual leg tons t aie iht o
2

rle a vetes e u ai lve. .' Bel lCo p. Two y 5 0U. 5 4 5 5( 0 7
eif bo h p c ltve e l . . lAt. r v. mbl, 5 S. 4 , 5 2 0 )
'
(ntr lquottonmar o te .A pl ntf sbai f r i te rsmor t nlbesa
i ena
ai
ks mitd)
ai if ss or eleft quie
r
e ha a l nd
c us ons ....' I The e or a pl i ifm us ç l f c s s fc e t s a e a lt el m e s
oncl i
' d.
r f e, a ntf
t ç ege a t uf i nt o t t l he e nt
al

o Eh jcam.z Ba sv. 1Du o ld Ne u s& Co.3 4F.d7 , 65( t Ci. 0 3 .
f t e li ' s E.. p n e mo r
'
, 2 3 61 7 4h r 2 0 )
Tosaeacam unde j198 apli ifmus algeChevi ai ofarghts c edby
tt li
r
3, antf t le ç olton
t
i e ur
t Consiuton a l w soft Unie St t , nd m us s
he
tt i nd a
he t d a es a
t how t tt a l d de i t o w a
ha he lege prva i n s

commitdbyape s aci t rc orofsaelw. W es v. ki , U. 42,48( 988)
te
ron tng mde ol
tt a '
' t At ns 487 S.
1 .
Tobela evi j 1 frac ton ofconfne ntt tvi aest Eiht Ame
ibl a 983 o ondii
i me ha olt he g h
ndmen,a
t

saea trmu th v b e d lb rtl i ifrn t t es b tn il ik o ij r c u e b te
tt co s a e e n eie aey ndfee t o h u sa ta rs f nu y a s d y h
c ton.Stikl v.W aes 989F. 1375,1379(t Ci.1 ) Tobedei rtl
ondii
rc er
tr,
2d
4h r 993 .
lbeaey
i fer nt aprs ofi a l tbo h bea z off c sfom whih t i e e e c dbe
ndif e , ion fcil t
mus t
wa e a t r
c he nf r nc oul
d a t tas t nta rs ofs rousha e ss a hem us a s dr w t i e e e.'
r wn ha ubsa il ik e i
nn xit, nd
t lo a he nf r nc '

Fa rv.Br nna 511U. 825,835( 994) A prs ofi a i notla ei hei w t
nne
e n,
S.
1 .
ion fcil s ibl f t
kne he

undel ngfcsbutbeive (l it oundl t tt rs t whiht fcsg vers was
ryi a t
le d abet ms
y) ha he ik o c he a t a ie

i u sa ta o n n x se t'I . t8 4; e R- hv Br c , 2 F.d3 6, 8( t Ci. 9 7
ns b tn il r o e itn . d a 4 s e i . u e 1 9 3 3 33 4h r 1 9 )
'
c
( di t tprs ofi a wasnotdei rtl i fee be us hedi nota ualydrw t
hol ng ha ion fcil
lbeaey ndifrnt ca e
d
ct l a he

if rn et a t ep io rwa e p s dt as e ii rs o h nn)
n e e c h t h rs ne s x o e o p cfc ik f a .

2Dee mi ng wheherac
tr ni
t
ompli saesaplusbl cam f rr le i (ac e -pecik t kt tr quiest
ant tt
a i e li o eif s ( ontxts t as ha e r he

rve n c u toda o is u iil x ein ea dc mmo sn e' As r Av lba, 5 U.. 6 6 87
e iwig o r t rw n tj dca e p re c n o n e s . hco .g l5 6 S 6 2, 7 -9
'
(0 9 .Th s ac u t ce nn ac mpan u e Rul 1 ( ()c nie tf pe dn sta aen te tldt a
2 0 ) u , o r sre ig o lit nd r e 2b)6 a d niy la ig h t r o nie o n
t
as
s umpton oftuh bec us t co itofno mo et n lbel a concusons l Alhought co tlbealy
i
rt
a e hey nss
r ha a s nd
l i . d. t
he ur i r l

c n tu sp oK c mpans Han sv. re, 0 U.. 9 5 021(9 2 ,h c ut o sn t c a a imaes
o sr e r o lit, ie Ken r 4 4 S 51 , 2 - 1 7 )te o r d e o a t s n n t'
a
dvoca e,s s e de o ng s a ut r a c tt i lc a m snotc e r y r i e i a co pl i . Se Br v.
t ua pont vel pi t t o y nd ons iutona l i
la l as d n
m a nt e ock

Car l 1 7F.d2 , 43(t Ci. 9 7 ( ti J, o c ni g ; a d t v Civo Ha tn, 7 F.d 1 7
rol 0 3 41 2 4h r 1 9 ) Lut .c n u n )Be u et . t f mpo 7 5 2 2 4,
,
p
1 8( hCi.1 8 ) seas God nv Lek , 7 F.d1 47 151(t Ci. 9 )(e o nzn ta adsrc
27 4t r 9 5 ,e lo ro . e e 5 4 2 1 , 1 4h r 1 78 rc g iig h t itit
.
c u tsn t x ce t as met r l o a v c t frapr K panig.
o r i o e petd o su he oe f d o ae o o litf
3

Pli iff ist i ntf al def ntsdelbe ae i fe e et t f c t t l son
a ntf al o de iy ry enda ' i r t ndifr nc o he a t he eevii
be ng plce on Pl ntf swa s c i a m s a orwrssf f hour c e t as bsa i l
i
a d
ai if
it han, r , nd/
it or our
s r aed u t nta
rs ofû xc c a i pan. Pli tf doesnotal get ta de e ntwaspr s nton t bus
ik ' nzi tng i ' a n if
e
'
le ha ny f nda
ee
he
dur ng hi or a orha a know l dge a uthow at e son w oul be pl e ac os Pl i i f s
i
s de l
d ny
e
bo
el vi i
d
ac d r s a ntf '

m i t Eve i Pli tf alege adef nda ha bee o t bus Pl ntf a knowldg t t
ss. n f a n if l d
e nt d n n he , ai if c
e es ha
noneoft sa fo t bushea d hi compl ni abou t pan o we eot wie a r of
he tf n he
r m
ai ng
t he i r r her s wa e
hi e re ngpan. Furhe
m xpe inci
i
t nnor Pli ifsuns ppo td concuson t tDe e nt kne
e, antf
u re
l i ha f nda s w
i a e o t ta f rbuswo d ha t hol t i t lvii , c i note tte t a
nm t s n he r ns e
ul ve o d her ee sons whi h s
n ild o n
as umpton oftuh,i no s fcintt de c i knowldge ofas t nta rs ofhn m.
s
i
r t s t ufi e o s rbe
e
ubsa i l ik
r

Ac r ngl t c ttndst tPli iff l t alegeadef nda ' dei r t i f e e e,
co di y, he our i ha antf ais o l
e nts lbe a e ndif r nc

a dt eCo li t sd s se wih u p eu ie
n h mpan i imis d t o t rj dc .
1
11.

Fo tef rg i r a o s t ec u t imis steCo lit t o t rj dc frf iig
r h o e ong e s n ,h o r ds se h mpan wih u p eu ie o aln
t saeacam u nwh c r l f yb g a td pzs a tt 28U. C.j1 5 b ()
o tt li po ih ei ma e r ne , l u n o
e
r
S.
91 A()1 .

ENTER:Ths d
i '
7

d yo Jne 2 4
a f u , 01 .
,.
-

-,
,'
%

A-;
y- ;
;
p
.

-:
-j
-)

. .. . .
. .-

.

Se ' rUnied St t Diti tJ
t
aes src udge

4