Smith v. Ely et al

Filing 137

ORDER ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS 131 , with additional findings and conclusions as noted ; Objections 132 are OVERRULED; dismissing as moot 125 Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law; Judgment is entered for Defendants Ely, Fannon, Carico, Combs, Fields, Tate and Mathena and this action is stricken from the active docket of the court. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 1/26/2016. (tvt)

cl k s oFFl u. . s',
- K'
EE
c8 s oi r cour
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

J 2s 2 1
Ad
26
I TH E UM TED STATES DI
N
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STR I T O F W R G I I
C
N A
R O A N O K E DI SI N
W O
COREY SM I ,
TH

J
U
BY:

.

, ElF
C R
R

CASE NO.7:
146+ 001
68
Pl ntf ,
ai if

V.

FI A L O R DER
N

ELY, AL ,
c

By: Gln E. n a
e Co r d
Chi fUnied St e Di t i t Judge
e
t
at s s r c

De e a t)
f nd nts.
l ac or nc wih t ac ompa ngm e o a
n c da e t he c
nyi
m r ndum opi on,i i he e
ni t s r by
ADIUDGED AND ORDERED

t ta trX novo rviw oft e de e a a7:no dee nai oft e porinsoft
ha fe
e e
he vi nc nd . vo tnni ton hos
.
to
he
r por or s i d pr e fndi orr c
e t pecfe opos d i ngs e omm e tonst whih pl n ifha made s c t
nda i o
c aitf s
pe ik

o j cin pt s n t 2 U.. j 6 6b () panifs o j cins (
b e to , l ua t o 8 SC. 3 ()1, li t
r
f b e to ECF No. 1 2 ae
3) r
OVERRULED,a d te Re o ta d Re o nd to ( No 1 1 i ADOPTED,wi
n h p r n c mme ain ECF . 3 ) s
t
h

a dto lfn n sa c n l insa n td;t e d fnd ns o a moinsf rj dg n a .
d i na idig nd o cuso s oe h eç a t' rl to o u me t sa
i
matro 1w (e , ..ECF No 1 )a eDI M I SED a mo t a d b sd o t Re o t nd
te f a s e eg,
. 25 r S S
s o; n a e n he p r a

t e a dto a fn ig a d c n l so o te c u t i rs n e t plitf o j ci n ,
h d iin l i dn s n o cu ins f h o r n epo s o an ifs b e to s
JUDGM ENT i e e ed f rDef nda sEl Fa
s nt r o
e nt y, nnon,Ca i o,Combs Fil ,Ta e a M a he
rc
, e ds t , nd t na,
andt sa ton i src n fom t a tvedoc toft c t
hi c i s ti ke ' he c i
r
ke he our.
>
ENTER:Th s 1$ d yo a u r , 2016.
i
a rl n a y

ChifUnie St t sDiti tJ
e
t d a e src udge