Smith v. Ely et al

Filing 68

ORDER OVERRULING Objections 65 filed by Corey Smith and AFFIRMING the May 6, 2015 order 62 on the grounds stated by the magistrate judge. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/22/2015. (slt)

:

*

r pRr s oFfl (,s. sx COURT
a
rcs J oj
AT ROANOKE,VA
FI
LED

I THE UNI STATESDI TRI COURT
N
TED
S CT

FO R TH E W E STERN D I
STR I O F W R G I A
CT
NI
R O A N O K E DI SI N
W O

couF, S I
Y M TH
Plitf,
anif
v.

ELY, AL.
ET ,
Dee a ts.
fnd nt)

gAy 2 2 aj
g
J
UL

BY;

)
) Ca eNo. 1
s
7:4CV0 68
01
)
)
) ORDER
)
)
) By:Ho . e E. n a
n Gln Co rd
) Cl è Untd Sae Ditit u g
l f ie tts src J d e
i
)
)

, L Y CL
DU E ERK
PUTY CL
ERK

Th jmatri b fr te c u to p an ifso j cinst teM a 6 2 5 o d ro t
i te s e o e h o r n litf b e to o h y , 01 r e f he
ma itaej d e d n i plitf smoin fr a p it n o c t e t a ss hm i hs
gsrt u g , e yng an if
to o p on me t f oms l o sit i n i
upco i hea i be or he . Pl i if bele t t a nt nt of c t el i wa r nt d
m ng
rng f e r
antf
ives ha ppoi me
o ms s ra e

bec us t f l a is a e c
a e he acs t s ue r ompl x ( as d o t nlmbe of cai sand de e nt a hi
e ' e n he l r l m
b
f nda s nd s

p r o td ne d t prs n e p r me ia tsi n ) plitf si ac rto c mpiaè hs
u p re e o e e t x e t dc l etmo y ; anif nc r eain o lc ts i
a lt t l a e a i e ve pot nta wine s ,bo h i aesand prs saf,a t gahe
biiy o oc t nd nt r iw
e i l t s es t nm t
ion t f nd o t r
a utlzer c ds pl ntf t tmony i i diec c lc wih t t si ony o t def nda
nd ii e or ; ai ifs esi
s n r t onti t t he e tm
f he e nt
ofi e s a m e c l saf;pl n if has no l ga tani a def nda s ha c el and
lc r nd di a t f aitf
e l r i ng nd
e nt ve ouns ;
pl i i sca ehasmert
antY
s
i.

I t eM a 6 o d rt whc plitf o j cs t ma itaej g c re ty n td t t
n h y r e o ih anif b e t,he gsrt ud e or cl o e ha
pl i ifhasno sa t r rghtt com s li t s cvi a ton a t tc t r ques c ms lt
antf
tm o y i o t e n hi i l ci nd ha ours e t ot e o

rpr s nti g cvi ltga so yi e e ina crumsa s See28U. C.j1915()1;
e e e ndient i l ii nt nl n xc pto l ic tnce .
S.
e( )
Uzie Stt v.$27. 00,865F.Supp 33 340 ( D. . 1 (G hehe t r quets h
ltd aes
000.
9,
S. W V. 994) t t r o e s uc
W
as it nc f a cvi ltga i a prviege whi h r ss i t s t dic e i of t diti t
ss a e or i l ii nt s
i l
c e t n he o md s r ton
he src

c u t'. Ev n wh r plitf ha a c lrbl cam wi s me mei,o ti n c t e fr
o r.) e ee an if s oo a e li t o
'
h
rt b anig omsl o

.

pli tf i wa r nt d onl whe e t co t i is dic ei n,dee mi s t t t i e ess o
a n if s ra e
y
r he ur, n t s r to
tr ne ha he nt r t f

j sie s r q r,i lg to te c mpe t o te f cu l a d lg lis e a d p an i s
u tc o e uie n ih f h o lxi f h a ta n e a su s n litY
y
c pa lt t pr e hi owh c s I a 340a biiy o es nt s
a e. d. t
41.

Afe rviw o t erc r , h c u ta re wihtema itaej g t a teitr sso
tr e e f h e o d t e o r g e s t h gsT t ud e h t h n ee t f
j sied n t e ur fn i c t e f r an if' tema itaej d enoe t ef c l n
u tc o o r q ie i dng omsl o plitf.As h gsrt u g td,h a ma a d
lgalis s a e no c
e
s ue r t omplcaed a pl i if Ghr
i t nd antf, t ough hi flngs wih t c tt dae,has
t
s ii
t he our o t

d mo tae hi a iiyt a e u tl r p e e thsitrssi t i c s . ( No 6 ! 1) I
e nsrtd s b l o d q aey e rs n i n eet n h s a e' ECF . 2 . n
t
'
a dto , an ifwiln tb p ee tn li c s t aj r .M o e ve,ûin cvlc s swheeno
d iin plitf l o e r sn ig l a e o u y r o r t l i i a e
s
l
r
l s o lbe t i a sa t Supr m e Co tha c e t a r buta e ç esl pton a i tt
os f i ry s t t ke, he
e
ur s r a ed e tbl G lm i gans he
pr
rghtt a n e c ms l' Las ierv.De rm e ofSoc a Se v c sofDlr m Cot y. t
i o ppoi t d ot e .
' st
pa t nt
il r ie
lhn
mt Norh
-

-

Caoi a 4 2 U. 1 ,31( 9 ) Assae i t eM a 6 o d r plitf smpy h sn tsae
r ln , 5 S. 8
1 81. ttd n h y r e, anif i l a o tt d
f c sove c ngt tpr sl ptonhe e.
at
r omi ha e lm i
r
Fort r as saed,i i no
he e ons t t t s w
O RD ERED

ta p an ifso j cin t teM a 6 2 5 o d ro tema itaej d eae OVERRULED,
h t litf b e to s o h y , 01 , r e f h gsrt u g r
a dt c u t ul AFFI St a o d ro t eg omd sae b t ema itaej d e
n he o r f ly
RM h t r e n h r t s ttd y h g sr t u g .
The Clr i die t t s nd a c py oft sor rt t pli ifa t couns ofr c d
e k s r ced o e
o
hi de o he antf nd o
el e or
f t de e nt .
or he f nda s

E
NTER:

T i 35 dyo Ma, 0 5
hs
a f y2 1.
/

=/

Che UntdSae Dit c Jjg
if ie tts st t u e
i