Springs v. Mathena et al

Filing 11

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 05/08/2014. (kab)

e O œ8 OFFI U. Dl r I
CE S. :m A r
AT ROANC E,
M VA
Fli7
f. '
-7
:

I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
RO AN O K E DI I O N
V SI
M A LC O LM SPRI G S,
N
Pl ntff
ai i ,
V.

R.M ATH ENA,eta .
l,
De e
f ndant .
s

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

MAt 2 8 2 1
99
JULA C DL CL
I
EY, ERK
BY;
t
D
CLERK

Ci lA c i N o.7: 4- v- 69
vi ton
1 c 001

M EM O RANDUM OPI O N
NI
By:

H on.Jam es C .Turk
Se orUnie St esDit i tJudge
ni
t d at
src

M ac m Sprngs aVig ni i t pr ee ngpr K ,fld ac vi rg sa ton puruant
lol
i , r i a nma e oc di
o
ie
i l i ht c i
s

t 4 U. C. 1 8 n migsafa teRe OninStt Prs n(I
o 2 S. j 9 3 a n tf th d o ae io <
ROSP' a dwi t eVigna
' n t h r ii
)
h
De rm e ofCo r c i asde e nt Thi m a tri be o et c tf rs r ni plr ua
pa t nt
r e tons
f nda s. s te s f r he our o c ee ng, zs nt

t 28U. C.j1 5A.Afe rviwi Pli ifss si ,hec tdimis st
o
S. 91
tr e e ng antf' ubmisons t our s se he

Co an wi o tp eu ief rf i n t saeacam u o whc r le ma b g a td.
mplit t u rj d c o al g o tt li p n ih eif y e rn e
h
i

Pl i ifdoe nottyt des rbea a t lcli i t Compli butm e ty r ie f c s
antf
s
r o c i n cua a m n he
ant
r l ect s a t
a
bouthi ho i a sgnme s t i tmtonalc ge ,a tanse sfom ROSP f me c l
s usng s i
nt , wo nsi i
har s nd r f r r
or di a
c r Pl i ifalege t tSgt M il rc r ed Pl i ifw ih t o i tt t o li r to on
a e. a ntf l s ha
. le ha g
a ntf t w ns iu i na nfac i ns

J nua y 23,201 f alege y t e t ni bodiy hn m a s ti on ac r c i ofi r
a r
3, or l dl hr a e ng
l r nd pitng
ore tonal fce ,
and Pli ifwasmov t ad i sr tves gr gaton. Thene da ROSP saf plc Pli if
a ntf
ed o m nitai e e i
xt y,
t f a ed antf

on s cde wa c dtrng whih Pl ntf wass r d wih t i tt i lcha ge . Pli ifwa
ui i
t h, li
c ai if
e ve t he nsiutona
r s antf s
notpr e a t i tt i ldicplna yhea i onFe u y 1 201 a t he ng ofker
es nt t he nsiutona s i i r
rng
br ar 5, 3, nd he mi
t

convit d Pl ntf guit on bot c r a i
c e ai if ly
h ha ges nd mpos d a $12.00 fnef each conviton.
e
i or
ci 1
Pl i ifsa nita i a al oft co c i wer uns ce s u .
antf dmi sr tve ppe s he nvitons e uc s f l

1Pli ifwasnotpr s ntbe aus algedl aROSP c r ci ofk e t dhi bef et heai t ti ha
antf
e e c e le y
ore tonal t r ol m or he rng ha t d
be n co i d t a herdae.
e ntnue o not
t

Il.

Thec tmus dim isa a ton orc am fl dby a i t i t co tde e mi t t
our
t s s ny c i
l i ie
n nma e f he ur t r nes ha

t a i orcl m i fi ousorf ist sae acli on whih r i m ay begr nt d. Se 28
he cton
ai s rvol
al o t t
am
c elef
a e
e

U. C. j 1 5 e( ) 1 5 b ( ) 4 U.. j1 9 ec .Th frtsa d r icud scams
S. j 91 ()2 , 91 A( )1; 2 SC. 9 7 ( ) e is tn a d n l e li
bas u ç n i s a y m e ils l alt y,'t am sofi rnge ntofal ga i e e t
ed pon s ndiput bl rte s eg heor 'û i
a
cl
nfi me
e l ntr s

whi h c e ry doe note s,'o cam swhe et t acua c e i ar c e l ba e e s'
c lal
s
xit' r li
r he i t l ont ntons e l ary s l s .
f
'

Netk v. il ms 49 U. 31 , 2 ( 9 9 .Th s c n sa dadi tefmiirsa d r f r
i e W li , 0 S. 9 3 7 1 8 ) e e o d tn r s h n la tn ad o
z
a
amoint d s s t e Fe rl eo Ci l o e t e1 ( )6 , c e tngaplitf s
to o imis md r dea Rul f viPr c dl 2 b ( ) a c p i
r
an if
f c ua alega i a tu A co pl ntne dst s t pl n sa e e oft cai s
a t l l tons s r e.
m ai e i hor and ai tt m nt he l m howi
a
ng

t tt pe d ri e tte t rle ' n s fce ttta t a alg to s. .oriearg t o
ha he la e s nild o eif a d ufiin & l cu l le ai n . t as ih t
g
r l fa o et es e ultv lv l . . Bel l Co p v. mby 5 0U. 5 4 5 5( 0 7
ei b v h p c aie e e. .' l At. r . Two l, 5 S. 4 , 5 2 0 )
e
'
(n en lq oainmak o t d .A p an ifsb ssf rrle çe ur smo eta lb l a d
itr a u tt
o r s mit ) litf a i o eif û q ie r h n a es n
e
r
c usons .... I The ef r ,apl i ifmus t le f c ss fcintt sa ea lt eeme s
oncl i
' d. r o e
'
antf
t t lge a t ufi e o tt l he l nt
a
'
s
o gh )cam.2 Ba sv. . DupontdeN em our & Co., 3 4F.d76 , 6 (t Ci. 0 3 .
f t e li ' s E I
.
2 3 1 7 5 4h r2 0 )

Tosaeacli unde j 1 apl ntf mus alegeShevi ain ofarg s urdby
tt am
r 983, ai if t l i olto
t
iht ec e
t Consiuton a l wsoft Unied St t , mus s
he
tt i nd a
he t
aes and
t how t tt alege de i ton was
ha he l d prva i

c mmitdb ap r o a tn u d rc lro saelw. W e t At is 4 7U. 4 , ( 98 )
o te y e s n cig n e oo f tt a ' s v. kn , 8 S. 2 48 1 8 .
'
Pl i ifme ey s yst the fl t sa ton t c r c ç pr es vi ai t rt 1 h
antf r l a ha
ied hi c i o ore t ç
due oc s ol tons mde he 4t
Am e
ndme ,e
nt qualpr ec i unde t 1 h Amendme ,c u la t ua pt s nt
ot ton
r he 4t
nt r e nd mus l mihme ,
delber t i fe e ,s pe or i fe e unde t 1 tAme
i ae ndif r nce u nis y ndif r nce
r he s
ndme a sa e1 w cai
nt nd tt a l ms
2Dee mi ngwhehe acompl ntsatsaplusbl cl m f r le i iacon e -pect ts t r quiest
t r ni
t r
ai t e
a i e ai or eif s & t xts ik a k hat e r he

rve n c u toda o i j diil x re ea c mmo sn e' Asco v Ib l5 6U. 6 2, 7 -9
e iwig o r t rw n t u ca e peinc nd o n e s . h rh .p a, 5 S. 6 6 87
.
s
'
( 0 9 .Th s ac u t ce nigac mpan u e Rue1 ()6 c nie t ype dng ta aen te tldt a
2 0 ) u , o r sre n o lit nd r l 2b () a d ni la i s h t r o nie o n
f
t
as u i oftuh be us t y c itofno mo et n l l andconcuso .1 Alhought co tlbe al
s mpton r t ca e he onss
r ha abes
l ins d. t
he ur i r ly

c ntu spoi c mplit, ie v Ken r 4 4U. 51 , 2 - (9 2 ,h c ut o sn t c a a imaes
o sr e r q o ans Han s . r e, 0 S. 9 5 021 1 7 )te o r d e o a t s n n t'

advoc e s s t devel ng saut ya consiutonalcam snotcla l r s i ac pli . Se Br k v.
at, ua pone
opi tt or nd
tt i
li
e ry aied n om ant e oc

Carl,1 7F.d2 , 4 (t Ci. 9 7 ( ti, .c n u rn ) Be u et Ciyo Ha tn, 7 F.d 1 4
rol 0 3 41 2 3 4h r 1 9 ) Lu t J, o c rig; a d tv. t f mp o 7 5 2 27 ,
g
1 8(t Ci. 9 5. e as God nv. e e 5 4F. l 4 ,l 51(t Ci.1 78 (e o nzngta adsrc
27 4h r 1 8 ) se lo r o Lek , 7 2d 1 7 l 4h r 9 ) rc g ii h t itit
,
cour i no e cedt as um et r eofa
t s t xpe t o s
he ol
dvocaef apr K panig.
t or o litf
.

2

o ne lg n e y a u eo p o e s, a itnina ifito o e to l ite s' ( mpl 1)
f gi e c l) b s f r c s l nd n e to ln lcin f moina d sr s . Co . .
)
'
Pl i ifsr la e o t e lbel a c usonsi i ufi i ntt sa es c am s Twombl
antf' ei nc n hes a s nd oncl i s ns tc e o t t uch l i .
y,

550U . a 555. W hiet c tlbe al c t espr K pl di ,t c tdoe no i nt
S. t
l he our i r ly onsnz o
ea ngs he our
s t nve
ca msa a g e son Pl i ifsbe l.Pl i ifdoe notha aconsiutona rghtt a
li nd r um nt
antf' ha f antf
s
ve
tt i l i o n
a a spr e sf ri tt i na dici i r c ci , ndt , heco twilnotc eae a
ppe l oc s o nsiuto l s plna y onvi tons a hus t
ur l
r t

consiu i cli a de l a g e son Pl ntf sbehafs s e fom a a a
tt tonal am nd veop r um nt
ai if
l ua pont r n ppe l
pr s t tt Consiuton doe notr r Ac di y, hec tdimis st Com pli
oce s ha he
tt i
s
equie. cor ngl t our s s e he
a nt

wi u meudc , n Plitf ma r fl i a t tmeh c nt ug tul d srb a
t t j ie a d anif y eie t t he i e a ho h f l e cie n
ho
y

a to b ecam wih u r ligo lb l a dc n lso s s b e tt tea pia l sa eo
cina l li t o t eyn n a es n o cu i n , u j c o h p lc b e tmt f
lm ia i .
i t tons
11
1.

Fo tefr g igr ao ,h Co an i ds se wi u p eu iefrfi n t
r h o e on e s ns t e mplit s imis d t t rj dc o al g o
ho
i
sa eacli upon whih r le ma begr nt d,pur ua t 28 U. C . j1 A( ( )
tt
am
c ei f y
a e
s nt o
S.
915 b)1.

ENTER: hs
T if

dyo Ma,04
a f y2 1.
Se ' . t d St t sDititJ
o Unie a e src u