Davies v. Virginia CVS Pharmacy, LLC et al

Filing 64

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/17/2014. (ssm)

CU
FRVS OFFI U S. ST,
CY
Di COURT
AT RO/NOVZ, A
' . V
$ Fl 2D
L1
1

I THE UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI C OU RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI O F V I I A
CT
RG NI
ROAN O KE DI I ON
V SI

j .jy u j
uj
j
w J
ULZ C

BY:
-

VI
CTO RI D AV I a A dm i s r t r o
A
ES, s
ni ta o f
t Esa eofLn r na Kama a,Dec as d,
he t t
m a
r
e e
Pl i t f ,
a n if

wx. o
k
t
,
s
Cas N 0.7: 4- v- 75
e
1 c 001

uLy' uùk x
- c '

c

M EM O M N DU M O PI O N
NI

V I GW I CV S PHA RM A CY ,LLC ,
R
A
eta1,
.
D ef
endant
s.

Ho Gl n E.
n. e Conr d
a
Chi Unie Stt sDititJ e
ef t d a e src udg

Dee nt Vigi aCVS Pha c LLC (1 ' a OneBe conAmeiaI ur nc
fnda s r ni
nna y,
'
CVS' nd
)
a
rc ns a e
(k
ûoneBe con' pr ousyfl moto t dimispli ifsco ai , c weeague a a
a ' evi l ied ins o s s antf' mpl ntwhih r r d t
)
Se e r2,201 he rng.Afe t the i t cou tgr nt dpli ifsmoton t ame a
pt mbe
4 ai
tr ha arng, he r a e antf
i o
nd nd
alowe pl i ift tl an a nd c
l d antf o ie
me ed ompl i .Thec tas ga ea h def ntaddii l
ant
our lo ve c
enda
tona
tmet e t rfl a r s i pl di fl a a e d moton t dim is ort i or t
i o ihe ie e ponsve ea ng, ie n m nde
i o s s , o nf m he
co tt ti wihe t r ne isprormotont dimis Bo h de e nt ha now r ponde
ur ha t s d o e w t i
i o s s . t f nda s ve
es
d,
CV S hassmpl r - r d isorgi lm o i t dim is Dkt No.22,notngt tt
i y e u ge t i na ton o s s , .
i ha he
a e
m nded c
ompl i di notc nget a lga i a i ti.Dkt No.51 One c hasfld a
ant d
ha
he le tons gans t
.
. Bea on
ie
s pa aem otont dim ist a nded c
e rt
i o s s he me
ompl nt Dk . 52. t r as s tf t her i
ai . t No. For he e ons e orh en,
bot motonst dimi swilbeg a t d.
h i o s s l
r ne
Fact and ProceduralBackzround
ual

Thi m a t rw a orgi l fl d i t Cic tCour f t Ciy ofRoa ke l
s te s i naly ie n he r ui
t or he t
no . nvoki
ng

t i c u tsdv riyj rs ito CVSrmo e tea to t ti c u tS eDk . .1 No ie
h s o r' iest u idcin,
e v d h ci n o h s o r. e tNo , tc
ofRe
movala !!3- OneBe c j ne i a c e edt t rmova.l a !2'DktNo.1
t 5.
a on oi d n nd ons nt o he e
l d. t , .
3.
Acceptng t wel- ed f s i t am ended com pl ntast ast scour m us w hen
i he lpl act n he
ai
rue, hi
t t

r i onamotont dimis s eGiraa v. o on,521F.d 298,302(t Ci. ) t
ulng
i o s s, e artno J hns
3
4h r 2008,he

f c sa easf l vs
at r
oloN :
Pl i t f V i t i Davi s i t a m i sr t oft e t t ofLa r K a ar K a a a
a n i f c or a
e s he d nit a or he s a e
m ana m a. m r

wa iv le i ac ra cd n o o a o t v mb r2 , 01 t t a e hm t s fe ij re ,
s n ov d n a c ie t n r b u No e e 8 2 2 ha c us d i o u fr nu is
i udi abr ke l DktNo. a !!2,5. a
ncl ng o n eg. . 49, t
The mende c antf t ralege t t a t
d ompli urhe l s ha, the
tm eoft a ci t Ka r waswor ng wihi t s opeofhi e oym e a t tç s
i
he c den , ma a
ki
t n he c
s mpl
nt nd ha s
hi

e o e p o i dwo k r c mp n ain c v r g t r u hOn g e c n a do On Be c n
mply r r vde r e s o e s to o ea e h o g e Bqa o n /r e a o
prvie d rc is rn ec v rgef r' i l . t! 1 ,1 .
o d d ie t n u a c o ea o 'hm. d a ! 0 1
Afert a ci nt Ka a awasa it dt Ca ii Roa
t he c de , m r
dm te o rlon
nokeM e ora Hos t l whe e
m il pia , r
he unde we s ge i sa r ceved o he me c te t nt Hi m e ca pr de sdee ne
r nt ur re nd e i
t r di al r a me . s di l ovi r tnni d

h wo l ne d a tc a u ainte t n i o d rt p e e tfrh rijty a dh wa p e c ie
e u d e nio g lto rame t n r e o rv n ' te n t , n e s rs rb d
u
r
Love a Coum a n upo hi di c z The hos t l spha m ac w a una e t pr de t
nox nd
di
n s s ha ge.
pia '
r y s bl o ovi he
pr c i i , o a r ng e sw e e m a t l a e a pha m a y t tco d pr de t m .The
es rptons s r a em nt r
de o oc t
r c ha ul ovi he

a e d compl i al ge ,'
m nde
ant le s t
upon i onnai n a bei , t tt hos t lwoul no ha
nf
to nd lef' ha he pia
'
d t ve
di c r d K a a a i i w e e notc r a n t the woul r e ve t pr c i i nspr pty. d. t
s ha ge
m r ft r
e t i ha
d ec i he es r pto
om l l a

T 68
T -.
A CVS e oyeet dDa e t tCV Sha t m e cne a ia ea woul pr de
mpl
ol vis ha
d he dii s va lbl nd
d ovi
t . hen Davi a rve a t pha m a y,
hem W
es ri d t he r c howe r s wa i o
ve , he s nf nnedt tt r wa a
ha he e s
pr e wih t media i beng a oved f rpa e , t tt y woul be a ia e
oblm t he
c tons i ppr
o ym nt and ha he
d
va lbl

a tras r tme.d. t!9. t hDa e wasa et obti ot rdic r pr s rpto
fe ho t i 1 a
Alhoug vis
bl o an he s hage e ci ins
f o CVS,hea e d co pli a lgest tCVS r f e t f1 t a i gulton
rm
t m nde m a nt le ha
e us d o i1 he ntcoa a i

pr c i i ,a t tdee ntOneBe c ( is damedialri s me polc
esrptons nd ha fnda
a on who sue
c embure nt iy
alge ycovei Ka a rf edt pa f t m.Ka r ne rrcevedt a ioagulton
le dl
rng mar) eus o y or he
maa ve e i he ntc
ai
pr cr pt onsand Cs equenty di f om com plcatonsdue t nott ng t
es i i
çubs
l ed r
i i
o
aki hose m edi tons
ca i ,

s v r l a ltr'Dk. . 9a ! 1
e ea d ys ae , tNo 4 t 4.
'
The a ende c pl nta l ge t ti a di e ta pr xi a e r ul ofK a a a'
m
d om ai le s ha '
as r c nd o m t es t
m r s

ij re a deah,hesaut ybe iire ha bee c us dt s fra i ur' rous
n u is nd t t tt or nefcais ve n a e o ufe nd nc 'vai
dn a .
m ges Thes i l d or ow ,g i f m e a a
e nc ude d r
s
r e , nt l ngui h a s f r ng,a t l sof s ac ,
s nd uf e i
nd he os
ol e

i udi s i t c pa o hi c m f tgui nc ,ki y ofi es a advie ofLa a
ncl ng oc ey, om ni ns p, o or da e ndl fc , nd
c
mr na
Ka a a,' s w e la t l sofhi i m e a s r ce ,a e ns s f hi c r ,tea m e t
m r 'a
l s he os
s nco
nd e vi s nd xpe e or s a e r t n ,

ho pi lz to a df n rls r ie .d. t 1
s t iain n u ea e vc s I a ! 5.
a
Thenme d c
nde ompl i a s rsonl t co s Countonea lgesneglge
ant s e t y wo unt .
le
i nt
pe f r a eofa as um e dut a ns bo h de e nt .Countt al ge t ta s c a
r o m nc
n s d y gai t t f nda s
wo le s ha pe i l
r a i hi e s e be w e n One ac a K a a a be a e OneBea on w a C s i tr r
el tons p xit d t e
Be on nd m r c us
c
s i ns te
hi

a / wo ker c
nd or r s ompe a i ca re ' a be us OneBe c hadbe un pa ng f hi hos t l
ns ton rir' nd ca e
a on
g
yi or s pia
te t e a pr s rpton m e cai a t ha adut t c us te t e t bepr de f
r am nt nd e c i i
di tons nd hus d
y o a e r am nt o
ovi d or
hi ,t i a1i ur nc a / wo ke sc
m d n 1 ns a e nd or r r ompe ai c s s whe t m e ca te t nti
as
ns ton a e , n he di l r a me s

p o i e tr u hd co sa dp ama iss lce b t ei u a c c rir'I a ! 1 - 0 l
r v d d h o g o t r n h r ce ee td y h ns rn e a re . d. t ! 8 2 . t
'
f t r a l ge t tO ne ac neg i nty f ie t a ho i e paym e f rt a i agul ton
urhe le s ha
Be on lge l a l d o ut r z
nt o he ntco a i

m e c ton a f ie t c us t m e cai n t bepr de bot o t da eofdic r a
dia i nd al d o a e he di to o
ovi d h n he t
s ha ge nd
s r lda t r a tr pr m ael c usng Ka a a sdeah.
eve a ys he e fe , oxi t y a i
m r'
t Thus bot oft c sa s r
, h he ount s e t
ne i nc c a m s a do no al get br a h ofa c r ct ldu y.
glge e l i , nd
t le he e c
ny onta ua t 1
St
andard ofR evi
ew

To s vi a m o i t di m i s pl ntf s a l tonsm us C t t a c a m t r i t ti
ur ve
ton o s s , ai i f lega i
t d a e l i o elef ha s
s

plusbl on is fce. As of v.l l 5 U. 66 678 ( 09 (iai omitd) Thi
a ie
t a ' hcr t qba, 56 S. 2,
'
20 ) ctton te . s
'Theorgi c pli co ai at r coun whih wasabr a h ofc r tcam bu t tcoun was
i nal om ant nt ned hid
t c
ec
ontac li
t ha
t
om itd f om t a e
te r he m nded compl nt Pl i tf ' c e cl rfed a aN ove be 7,201 he rng t tt a ende
ai . a n ifs ouns l a ii t
m r
4 a i ha he m
d
co pl ntw a i ende t s redet o i nalc pli a t cou t e - t br ac ofconr ctcl m - was
m ai
s nt d o upe s he rgi om ant nd hat nt hr e he e h
ta ai
pur ef l om itd.
pos uly te

sa r ' e r t pli if t a tc a e f c s whe a ce e as tue,t t çhow't tt
t nda d t quies he antf o riult a t , n c ptd
r
r ha s
ha he
pl ntf has s a e a c ai e ilng hi t r le ,ie. t ' a i lt ofen il m e t r le .'
ai i f
t t d l m ntti
m o e i f . , he pl usbiiy
tte nt o e i f ''

Frncsv.Gicomel,588F. 1 1 ( h Ci.2009 ( i I l 55 U. a 678) The
a i
a
li
3d 86, 93 4t r
) quotng qba, 6 S. t .
plusbiiy sa r r quie mor t n $ s e pos i lt t t a def nt ha aced
a i lt t nda d e r s
e ha t he r
a
sbiiy ha
enda
s t

unlwf ly. As of v.qba,556U. 662,678(
a ul ' hcr t I l
'
S.
2009)
.
D i si
scus on

Choi e ofLaw
c

W h n, si ti c s , f d rlc u tsj rs ito i b sd o dv riy imu ta pyt e
e a n h s a e a e ea o r' u idcin s a e n iest ,t s p l h
f m s a e' s t ntve l w ,i udi is c c of 1 w r l s Er e R .Co.v.To pki , 3
onz t t s ubs a i a ncl ng t hoi e
a ue . i
m ns 04

U. 6 ,7 ( 9 8 ;Klx n Co. S e trElc Mf Co,31 U. 4 7 4 6 ( 9 ) Fo t l
S. 4 8 1 3 ) a o
v. tno e . c. . 3 S. 8 , 9 1 41 . r o'
t
cl i s Vi gi a a i s t nle of l x l de i t,J
a m , r ni pple he l
e oci lc i ones v. R. J s & A s oc . l , 431
S. one
s s s nc.

S. 2d 3 3 ( l ) whih die t t tt c r a yt lw oft saewheet ls
E. 3, 4 Va. 993 , c rcs ha he ou t ppl he a
he tt
r he at
e
ventnec s r t ma a acorla e tke plc Ouiln v.l ' Plvt x.l ,789 F. 1 ,
es a y o ke n t i bl a s a e. le
ntl a e nc.
2d 041

1 4 ( t Ci.1 8 ) l an g ie c a to , h ls e e ti t alg d ij r t teplitf,
0 4 4h r 9 6 . n e lg n e cin t e a t v n s he le e n u y o h an if
whih oc ured i t s c s i Vigi a.Se Sa a .I v.Le Staus & Co. 674 F. 269,
c c r n hi a e n r ni e nt na nc.
vi r s
,
2d

272 ( h Ci.1 .Acc di y- a asbot t patesagee i pr r t c ur a is
4t r 982) or ngl nd
h he ri r s ope- he o t pple
V igi a' s t tve 1 w t pl i if scl i s
r ni s ubsan i a o a ntf ' a m .
C VS' M oton t D i i
S
i o sm ss

l ism o i t dim is CVS a gue t ti i e il d t dimi s lofc
n t ton o s s ,
r s ha t s ntte o s s a
ountone t s e
he ol
c
ountagans i on s ve a gr
i tt
e r l ounds Prm a iy, S c t ndst tboie down t ises e e,
. i rl CV on e
ha l d
o t s nc
pl i if s c ai i t tCV S s ul be he d r ponsbl f Ka a a' de t be us i d d not
a ntf ' l m s ha
ho d
l es
i e or m r s a h ca e t i
gi D avi t m edi i she w ant even t
ve
es he
catons
ed
hough she di notpay f t .Dkt N o.23 at2.
d
or hem
.
l ar
t gues t t
hat here i dno dut on t partofa r ai st e t gi cust er t ngsf f ee' and
si
y
he
et l or o ve
om s hi
or r '

t i û e ti y woul ha s dt m e cai t Da e i s ha pa d f i. 1
hat t d ra nl
c
d ve ol he di ton o vi s f he d i or t' d.
'
Rel t dl CV S a gue t tbe aus pl i if s c a m a ns CV S s
a e y,
r s ha c e a ntf l i gai t
ounds i ne i nc i
n glge t, t

r quie t tt de e ntowepli ifadut a t n br ac t tdut
e r s ha he f nda
antf
y nd he e h ha y.CVS c endst ti
ont
ha t
di no ha adut t pr vi m e c ton unl s i waspa d f r a t ame
d t ve
y o o de dia i
est
i o , nd he
nded c
ompl i
ant
e t bls s i wasno .CV S ciest a num be ofc e t tdi c st du i s ofc r ow e by a
s a i he t
t
t o
r as s ha s us he t e
ae
d
pha m ac w hi h ar t fl pr s rpto c r ty a t di pe e t c r tm ed c ton. kt
r y, c e o il e c i i ns or ec l nd o s ns he or ec
iai D .

No.23a 4. tcontndst tbe us pl ntf sc am de ndson adut t tdoesnote s a a
t l
e
ha ca e ai if l i pe
y ha
xit s
m at rofl w, rc am a ns CVS mus bedimi s d.
te
a he l i gai t
t
s se
Pli ifc e ,howeve ,t tCV S ne i n l pe f m e a ( s e dut ' Thi
antf ont nds
r ha
glge ty ror d n i um d y.
as
' s
t or pos t t tw he e a de e nta s e t a t e n t
he y is ha
r
f nda s um s o c , ve houg gr t t l he m ay be om e
h a uiousy,
c

s b e t oted t t a c rf ly i h a t a alBu n v. g o 7 7 S. 2 6 4, 4 ( .
u j c t h uy o d aeu l,f e cs t l. r s Ga n n, 2 E.d 3 6 3 Va
201 . t st or t a y,a a fnnai ac byt dee nti r quied.Se i.Plitf
2) For hi he y o ppl n fi tve t he fnda s e r
c 4 anif
a gue t tt t or i a i bl asag ns CVS be aus i as umeda dut t a twhe is
r s ha he he y s pplca e
ai t
c et s
yo c
nt
e pl
m oyee t d D a es ort d Ca ii t tCV S w o d pr de t mli oa a i n m e c ne.
ol
vi , ol rlon, ha
ul ovi he tc gul to
di i
Thi a ton,a or ng t pl i if i
s c i cc di o a ntf, nduc d Ca ii t di c r Kam a a a a l e hi t
e
rlon o s ha ge
r nd low d m o

l a t hos t l a t r nde sCV S r s i ef t c eque es W he CVS r f edt
e ve he pia , nd hus e r
e ponsbl or he ons nc .
n
e us o
fl t pr s rptons be us no o woul pa f t m ,a t t o y goe ,CV S br ac d t
il he e c i i
ca e
ne
d y or he s he he r
s
e he he

asume d y.SeeDk . 24a 6;DktNo. a !9(le ngCVSt dDa est ywo d
s d ut
t No. t
. 49 t algi
ol vi he ul
pr det pr c i in)
ovi he esrpto .
The c t ncudest t on t f t asa lge pli ifha no sa e apl usbl cai
our co l
ha, he ac s le d, antf s t tt d a i e l m
t tCV S as um e a dut t ac . ot bl CV S di notunde t ke t a tg at t l a t
ha
s d
y o t N a y,
d
r a o c r uious y nd he
a ende c pl i doesnota l t ti di Tha i ,now he e i t c pl ntdoesi a l ge
m
d om a nt
lege ha t d. t s
r n he om ai
t le
t tCV S t d t pl i if
ha
ol he a ntf--or a
nyone t ti w oul pr det m e ca i f r f e ,a i w a
- ha t
d ovi he di ton o r e nd t s

unde nolga o i tont dos Se Str ns I .v.Selc 58 F. 11 11 ( h Ci.
r e l blgai o o. e oma -nc
e ky, 6 3d 09, 35 9t r
2009)(nco e ofa esi c tttonalc le t sae1w t trquie phamacest
i ntxt ddr sng onsiui
halnge o tt a ha e r d r i o
de i rl uly pr c i d FDA- ppr
lve awf l es rbe
a ovedm e cai wih lm ie e ptons sa i
di tons t i t d xce i , ttng

ir o yc ds rousy q to arf a t tl aprs rpto be aus t cuso rdi no
ûnj bod oul ei l uesin eus l o il e ci in c e he tme d t

p yf ri' ; f Asrp v Ec e dCo .2 0W L 1 7 9 2 a * ( D. . rl 9 2 0
a o t' c. to . k r p , 01
)
7 9 9 , t 4 E. Va Ap i 2 , 01 )

( imisngwihp eu ieacam a an tad u so ewh r tepanifalg dta te
d s si t rj d c li g is r g tr ee h li t l e h t h
f e
ph r c fie t h v h sme iai n i so kwh nh wa tdt m)
ama y ald o a e i dc to s n tc e e n e he .
Alhough pl ntf ha ct d t anum be ofc s sc e ni d s d dutes'pl i if
t
ai if s ie o
r a e onc r ng t ume
as
i ,' antf
ha no cie t a c e hol ng-- s si t t by tli apo e ilc t ri woul
s t t d o ny as
di or ugge tng ha, e lng
t nta usome t
d
pr de m e ca i t t c t e , pha m a a s esa l ga du y t pr de t tm edi a i
ovi
di ton o he us om r a r cy s um
e l t o ovi ha
c ton

feeofc gea wihouta
r
har nd t
nyonepayi f i. nsea ar t i pha mac lkeCVS
ng or t l t d, e al r y i
unde sa bl r quiespay e f m e cai nsi dipe e . .St m a ,l . 586 F. a
r t nda y e r
m nt or di to t s ns s Cf or ns nc,
3d t
11 B e a e t c tc ude t tt f c she e do notpl us bl a l ge t tCV S as um e
35. c us he our oncl s ha he a t r
a i y le ha
s d
a du y t pl i iforK a a a pl i i f scl i ofne i enc f is a a m a t rofl w .
ny t o a ntf
m r , a ntf ' a m
glg e a l s
te
a
A cc di y, he c tw ilg a CV S' m oton t di m i s
or ngl t our l r nt
S i o s s.
O neBeacon' M oton t D i i
s
i o sm ss

Asnot d,t a e d c
e he m nde ompli a s rst cli s a i tOne c bot ofwhih
ant s e t wo am gans
Bea on, h
c
a e ne i nce cai s
r glge
l m .The fr tas e t t t One c a s e a dut t pay f Ka a a'
is s rs ha
Bea on s um d
y o
or m r s
m e c tonswhen i be n payi f s
dia i
t ga
ng or ome ofhi medialte t nta a r ul oft a i nt
s
c r a me s es t he ccde .
The s c
e ond s ks t i
ee o mpos a dut o OneBe c by vit of is is ci r ai ns p' t
e
y n
a on
rue
t ipe al elto hi ' o
Ka a a.I is m o i t di m i s OneBe c a gue t t t a e
m r n t
ton o s s ,
a on r s ha he m nded c pl ntalege onl
om ai l s y
t t One e c br c d is fna i l oblga i t pa f , or a horz pa e f , t
ha
B a on ea he t i nc a
i ton o y or
ut i e ym nt or he
m edi i Thus,i cl m st i di notow e any com m on 1 dut t Kam ar orhi s vor
catons.
t ai hat t d
aw
y o
a
s urvi s
and t is sol dutes are gover by t contactand notby any Sass ed dut 'or is al
hat t e i
ned
he
r
t um
y' speci
6

r a i hi ' l s t i c e t tt onl cai agans i s nd i c ta t no t t a
eltons p. n hor, t ont nds ha he y l ms i t t ou n on r c , t or, nd
'
t bot c
hus h ount a l gi neglge e s d be dim i s d. St t di f r nty, OneBe co s
s le ng
i nc houl
s s e 2 a ed f e e l
a n'
pr m a y a gum ent i t t a du y ow e t a he pa t t t a i es s e y f o a c r c ua
i r r
s ha
t
d o not r ry ha r s ol l r m
ont a t l

oblgai i notacina ei t tDkt No.1 a 5 ( tng Rihmond Mer Aut v.M c vit
i ton s
to bl n or. .
5 t cii c
to. h.
De t

S . vi.n .5 7S. 2 3 4 3 - ( . 9 8 )
tBo s lc, 0 E.d 4 , 4647 Va 1 9 ).
Pl i i fc t r w ih s ve a a g e s She c a m s t tt r i no Vi gi a c e t t
a ntf oun e s t e r l r um nt .
l i ha he e s
r ni as ha
a es e t i s ofa as u e dut orûs i lr l tons p' i t con e ofa i ur r
ddr s s he s ue
n s m d y çpec a e a i hi ' n he t xt n ns e -

i ur d r a i hi buta gue t taû pe i lr ai hi 'c n ars unde wha wasi tal a
ns e eltons p,
r s ha i c a eltons p' a ie
s
r t
nii ly
c r c ua r a i hi a t tt 4 la lt c n a t c e n i t tc e . poi s i
ont a t l el tons p nd ha ol i biiy a ta h ve n ha ont xt She nt , n
pa tc ar t t a e d co pl nts a l ga i t O ne a n ha pr vi l pa d or
ri ul , o he m nde m ai ' le tons hat Be co d e ous y i

pr m iedt pa f Ka a a' r lt d team e ,t tS rlon woul notha di c r d
o s o y or m r s ea e r t nt ha û ii
ca
d
ve s ha ge

Kama ai t ywer notc rai hewoul ha r evedlt aoes i (ntc g a j
r f he
e
et n
d ve ec i l he fr ad a ioa ulnt
pr s rptonspr pty,' nd t t(CV S r le i pa t n t a tonsa as ur nce o
e ci i
om l ' a ha '
e i d n r upo he c i
nd s a s f

On g e c n' e ly e . . e a r engt p o ie'hep e cito s Dk . 1 a 5.
eBla o s mpo e s . wh n g e i o r vd 't rs rp in . tNo. 7 t
B a e on t e f c s pl i ifa l gesOneBe con k w K a a a f e i m i
sd
hes a t , a ntf le
a
ne
m r ac d m nentha m when i
r
t

c et de o wihhol pay e .
hos o ny r t d m nt
The cou tha c r f ly cons de e t a gum e soft pa te ,bu c udest tbot
r s a e ul
i r d he r
nt
he ri s t oncl
ha
h

ofpli if sne i ncec am sf i asamateroflw.I s tVigi al w a a i d he e
antf
glge
li al
t
a n hor, r ni a s pple r
woul no a l as pa a et tcai agans OneBe con, c us t onl dut al ge y
d t low e r t or l m
i t
a
be a e he y y le dl
br c i t s me dut i pos by One a on' c r c ,ie.t dut t pa f c ra n
ea hed s he a
y m ed
Be c s onta t . , he y o y or e ti

2Alhoug t a e d c
t h he m nde ompl nti s
ai s omewha v
t agueont naur oft c r t loblgai ,
he t e he ontacua i ton
OneBea n notst t polc r f e e i t a e
co
e hat he iy eernc d n he m ndedc
ompli i notaw or rsc
ant s
ke ' ompe ai polc
ns ton iy.

lse d ii açembusme t' l yta p o ie s e iidb n ft t a l srdPesnwh s san a ijr
n ta ,t s ç i re n 'poi h t r vd s p cfe e ei o n nu e ro o u tis n nuy
r
c
s
durngt cou s ofhi orhe wor l pa tc a,OneBe cona e t pa f pr c i i m e ci sordr gs
i he r e
s
r k. n riulr
a
gr es o y or es rpton di ne
u
t ihi 30 da u t Compa sr ceptofduea stsacor wrtenpr oft l s'Polc a l 1
t tn
w
ys pon he
ny' e i
nd a if t y it oof he os . iy t 5, 9.
'

7

co r d m e ca te t nt Theco ttndsno me i i pli if sas e to t tt r wasa
ve e
di l r a me .
ur i
rt n a ntf
s ri n ha he e
n
ka s e dut 'o û pe i lr a i hi ' r atng t r la lt
' s um d y' r l c a el tons p' c e i o t i biiy.
s

Thec eofAugusaM utl .Co.v.Mas J.6 S. 2d29O( 2007,sae wel
as
t
,ns
on. r, 45 E.
Va. ) tts l
t ge r lprnc pl s u rV igi a l w a t ra i a i .
he ne a i i e nde r ni a nd hei pplc ton.
A tt out e ,we ac
he s t
know l dge t ta sng e a toroc ur e e c n,
e
ha i l c
c r nc a
i c ran c r um sanc s s ppo tc us sofaci n bot f br ac
n e ti ic t e , u r a e
to
h or e h
ofc r c a f br ac ofa dut a i i i t t For i n M i son
ont a t nd or e h
y r s ng n or . e c
si

Bd. W a ,242Va 234,241 409S. 2d 1 1 ( 991 (ii
v. de
.
,
E. 44, 48 1 ) ctng
Kn a Cop .v.Hae 224 Va.
ml r
ly,
699,705,299 S. 2d 51 51
E.
4, 7

( 98 ) Toa dt ni e r bra hofco rc i oat t
1 3). voi ur ng vey e c
nta t nt or,
how e r w e ha e
ve ,
ve nunc a ed t r l t t i o de t r o ri
i t he u e ha , n r r o ec ve n
t t Shedut t tousy o ne i e l br ac d mus bea
or,i
t
y ori l r glg nty e he
t
c m on l w dut no one e s i be w e n t pa te s e y by
om
a
y, t
xi tng t e he ri s ol l

vit oft c rc.'d.ctngSpe ev. f k& W .R.
rue he onta t'1 (ii
nc Norol
R.
Co, 2Va 1 2 1 6 2 S. 8 5 8 8( 8 5 )
.9 . 0 , 1 , 2 E. 1 , 1 1 9 ).
6 S. 2d a 293.The A ugus a M u .I . de s on a s di c s a l ngt Ri hm ond M e r
45 E. t
t
t ns Co. ci i l o s us es t e h c
to.
A ut ,507 S. 2d 344, t pr m a y c e c t d by One e c - e a ni t tû he
h.
E.
- he i r as ie
B a on- - xpl i ng ha t
t
de e m i ton w he he a c us ofa ton s
t r na i
t r a e c i oundsi c t a tort tde
n on r c
or pends o t s c oft
n he our e he

dut vi aed.'..(ii RihmondM er Aut ,507S. 2da 3 )
y olt 'J. ctng c
/a
to. h.
E. t 47 .
A sa i d i t R i hm o M e r A ut c e, he t l c ai s w e e pr r y di m i s d
pple n he c nd to. h. as t o4 l m
r ope l s s e

be a et de e ntsm ir pr s nttonsi t tc edo y br a he dute a s e by
c us he f nda ' s e e e a i n ha as dnl e c d i s s um d
co r c a ... hi de onsr td t br a ofa dut t twa s pa ae a i e nde
nta t nd not ng m tae he e ch ny y ha s e r t nd nd pe nt

fom t co r t'1 ( tngRil
r he ntac.'d.cii cunondM er Aut 5 S. 2da 346) Asf t rr ctdby
to, h. 07 E. t . urhe e ie
t Aug t Mut I .Co.Cou till t ca eofco antbef a ac ofomisonornonhe usa .ns
r,sif he us
mpli
or n t
si
f as nc w hi h,wihoutpr fofa con r c t do wha w a l f undone,w oul notgi rs t
e a e
c
t
oo
ta t o
t s et
d
ve i e o

a ca eofa to ( a enodut a r fom conta tt dowha i co ane ofe ss t n
ny us
cin bec us
y pa tr
rc o
t s mpli d xit) he
t acton i f
he i s ounded upon cont act and notupon t .'645 S. 2d a 295.
r ,
ort'
E. t

Tha i pr ciel t s t ton he e.The oblg ton t pa f m e ca te t ent i i
t s e s y he iua i
r
i a i o y or di l r a m , f t
8

e ssa al aie onl bec us oft co rc (her mbure ntpolc ) The ei smpl no
xit t l, rss y a e he nta t t ei s me
iy . r s i y
co m on 1 w du y i pos on OneBe c t pa f rm e ca t e t e pr vi d t Ka a a.
m
a
t m ed
a on o y o
di l r a m nt o de o m r

Pa ng s eofwha i owe t risc ta tdoe no gi rs t a as umed d yt pa f
yi om
t s d mde t on r c
s t ve i e o n s
ut o y or
ri
e mbur e e f al e ns scli d by Ka r .Theco mon l w doesnoti
s m nt or 1 xpe e a me
ma a
m
a
mpos s h a
e uc
dut and pl ntf doe notct t a y c s s hol ng.To t e e t da
y
ai if s
ie o n a e o di
he xtnt he mage s
s oughther i
en
c n bea s red a i tOneBe co a a l t n, he c n be o ane onl t oug a b e c o
a
s e t gans
a n t l, he t y a
bt i d y hr h r a h f

c rc cai nott oughat or ofne i nc basd o a a s dduy.Cf j ;s eas
onta t l m, hr
he y
glge e e n n sume t 3 .4, e lo
.

Tuelv.HerzEgui Rena Com.5 F.App' 21 21 20( hCi. 3)( rc im)
t
p. tl l , 08
x 2, 9- 4t r 201 pe ura
(ur ngVigi alw conc r ngasumptonofd y,a c udi t tSvigni c t
s veyi r ni a
eni s i
ut nd oncl ng ha ç r i a ours
a a t bem os r c ptvet tndi g apa' as ume a d y i t t i t pe f r nceofa
ppe r o
t ee i o i n
ly s d ut n or durng he ro ma
t

c nrc wh r t eij rdpat ( ) safr s e b etidp ry n ti p ii t t ec nrc;
o ta t ee h nu e ry 1 wa o ee a l hr a t, o n rvt o h o ta t
y
a ( )s fee s mep ysc lij r , ah rt a meee o o cl s, sar s l o tea trs
nd 2 u f rd o h ia n u y rte h n r c n mi o s a e ut f h co '
neglg tpe fr nce'; a e' J wee s l v.
ien roma ' Je nni s e lr .nc. ADT Sec Se vies I ,201 W L 1
l
. r c .nc. 2
86931
9

( D. . a 2 , 01 )( imisn n gi e c cam b o e o b r lrz dj wer so e
E. Va M y 2 2 2 ds s ig e lg n e li y wn r f u gaie e ly t r
pr s d on de e ntsf l et pr dea f to ngalr s t m wher t E i to t
emie
f nda ' aiur o ovi
unc i ni a m yse
e he i gai n o
obl
i t l as c iy s t m a os s ey by wa ofc r t' nd the ei no c
nsa l e urt yse r e ol l
y ontac'a d r s
t
omm o lw dut t
n a
y o

pr deaar s r c s';Bos t v.VonadoRe lyL. ,83Va.Ci.549,201 W L 8 38
ovi l m evie '
) worh
r
at P.
r
0
9258 ,
a *8( Ci. . c.20,201 ( lni t tnd d end S s
t Va. r CtDe
0) deci ng o i ef ants umeddut 'oprvi
as
y't o de
s c iy m ea ur s a m a lwhe e i ale ha a c r t loblgato t do s a notng t t
e urt
s e t l
r t r ady d ontac ua
i in o
o, nd i ha

t ia s in ofduy'ca e ar at row st' c s sunde Vigi al .
he isumpto
t ' s s e k r e'of a e
na
r r ni aw)

3W hiepl ntf i taly a s redabr a ofc r tcl m a ns O ne ac , isa e d c
l ai if nii l s e t
e ch ontac ai gai t Be on t m nde ompl n
ait
doe notc ai s acli .Se s anot 1 Ac di y,heco tne notdeem i whehera oft
s
ont n uch am e unr e . cor ngl t
ur ed
tr ne t ny he
damagess tbypl ntf i he a e d c
ough
ai if n r m nde ompl ntwoul ber ove a ei ac r tcli a c eq ntal
ai
d ec r bl n ontac am s ons ue i
damages Se e. ,R ih n Me . u pyCo v Clfo , 6 SE.d4 7, 0 ( .1 8 )(ic sigtwobo d
. e. g. c mo d d S p l . . itn 3 9 . 2 0 4 9 Va 9 8 dsu sn t
t ra
-

c tg re 'o d ma e i c nr c , ie ta dc n e u n i l a g s .
ae o is' f a g s n o ta t dr c n o s q e ta d ma e )
9

Si ia l t a gume t taç pe i lr l tons p' e ssgi ngrs t a du y by One
m l ry, he r
nt ha i c a e ai hi ' xit vi ie o
s
t
Be on i t c e oft sc e i nots
ac n he ont xt hi as s
uppore by V igi a l w . e m pl i Holesv.
td
r ni a For xa e, n
l

Sunrs Te r e,I .509S. 2d494( 1999 ,heSuprmeCour ofVigni afr t
ie rac nc,
E.
Va. ) t
e
t r i a fimed he

til o r' nzig stiga i eaj r v r iti plitf sfv ro an g ie ecam. ee
ra c u ts l etn sd u y e dc n an if a o n e lg nc li Th r,
n
t pli ifsde de lved i as ni r i talc nt r a s wa r pe a r bbed a he
he antf
ce nt i n e or esden i e e , nd he s a d nd o
t r
a rm e a t a i r rgane a ce st t fontofhe a rm e tt o h a o he wie
pa t nt fer n ntude i d c s o he r
r pa t n hr ug n t r s l ke doora a he i vi llf t pr mies The de e ntpr vi d f a
oc d
s not r ndi dua e4 he e s .
f nda
o de ood nd
ma
nage nts r ce t t c nt rpurua tt a c ta twih t Co y,a isc r c
me e vi s o he e e
s n o on r c t he unt nd t onta t

i cud dc ran o iainsrltdt s c rt Thej r a r e d ma e o t n g ie c
n l e e ti bl to eae o e u i
g
y. u y wad d a g s n he e lg n e
coun ,butt t i lc ts ta i t ve di . tco l d t tt m a ge e co pa w a
t
he r a our c s de hat r ct I nc ude ha he na m nt m ny s

neihert owne oft pr ryno t de ede ' l ndl d a t ha no s c a r a i hi
t he
r he ope t r he c nts a or nd hus d
pe i l eltons p
w ih t dec den nora c m on l w dut t p o e the f om t f e e a e c i i lac s of
t he e t
ny om
a
y o r t c r r he or s e bl r m na t
t r pa tes 509 S. 2d a 497hid r i .
E. t
98.

l afi m i t sr i Supr m eCour ofVigi asaed'klo e t bls ac us o a ton
n tr ng hi ulng,
e
t
r ni t t . d- sa ih a e f ci
'
f neglge
or
i nce, hedut al dt ha bee t tousy b e c mus bea c
t
y lege o ve n ori l r a hed
t
omm on 1w dut
a
y,

n tad t a iigb t e tepat ss ll b vru o ac nrc. I a 4 7 I rj ce a y
o uy rsn ewe n h ri oey y ite f o ta t'd. t 9 . t ee td n
e
'
cl i t ta s ci lr l tons p e s e be we t r i nta t de e n û a e t e
a m ha pe a e a i hi xi t d t en he esde nd he f nda t i us her
bec

wa norghtofpr e ton i e ti t i r l tons p s pa aeand a r fom a dute
s i
ot c i nher n n her e ai hi e r t
pa t r
ny is
i pos by Sunr s sconta wih t Cou y.' d.a 498.
m ed
i e'
r ct t he
nt ' 1 t
Thus t ne i nce c a m w as
, he glge
li
pr ry di m i s d.1
ope l s s e d,
The ca e r i d upon by pl i t f do nots
s s ele
a n if
uppor hi a gum en s r ga di a Ss ci l
t sr
t e r ng kpe a
r l tons ps'a a i d he e. s a i talm a t r m o toft m i l t que ton o w he he
e a i hi ' s pple r A n nii
te , s
he nvo ve he s i f
t r
t de e nthad t d y t eihe w a n orpr t tt pl i iff om t i e i lt r s or
he f nda
he ut o t r r
o ec he a ntf r he nt ntona o t

10

c i na a ofat r pa t I t tc t xt t ge r r e i t tas i lr a i hi gi ng
rmi l ds
hid ry. n ha on e , he ne al ul s ha pec a eltons p vi
rs t s h a d y ma bef
i e o uc
ut y
oundwhe t defnda tkne ofa û mmi ntpr biiy ofha m'
n he e n
w
nt
i ne oba lt
r '

t t eplitf. eYu e o k v. tJ h ' W o dAps, 4 S. 2 1 4 1 0 41( . 0 1 .n
o h an if Se z fvs y S . o n s o t.5 0 E.d 3 , 4 - Va 2 0 ) I
Y uze o ky,f rexa pl t c tas um e butdi no de i ,t tt pl i tf co d e t bls
f vs
o
m e, he our s d,
d t c de ha he a n if ul s a ih

a s ci r l i hi bewe n t lnd or a at na , no t l s hel t tt lndl r
pe al eatons p t e he a l d nd e nt but ne he e s d ha he a o d
ha nodut t wa n a orpr e tt t na a i tt da rofha m fom t c i i l
d
y o r nd/ otc he c nt gans he nge
r r he rm na

c
onduc ofat r pa t Si lry,nA. v. ki m Pub.495S. 2d482,48 ( 1 )
t
hid ry. mial i H. Roc ngha
,
E.
6 Va. 998 ,
t Supr m eCour o Vigi a a fr d t tilc tsde e m i tont tane pa rhadno
he
e
t f r ni f me he ra our' t r nai ha
ws pe
dut t war o ofisca re soft da rofa a t k by at r pa t
yo
n ne t r i r
he nge
n tac
hid r y.

Thomps v.SkaeAm.540S. 2d l ( 2001,whihas i ve c i na
on
t
,
E. 23 Va. ) c lo nvol d rmi l
c
onduc by at r pa t i il tatve a t when s h a S pecalr l tons p'ha be n
t
hid ry, s lusr i s o
uc s i e ai hi ' s e
s
s f c e l alege l Thom ps t Cour he d t tt c pl i s f c e l a l ed t tt
uf i i nty l d. n
on, he
t l ha he om a nt uf i i nty lcg ha he

o e o as t rn h d ad t t p oe t n o isivte , owa ij r db at r
wn r f kae ik a uy o r tc o e f t n ie s wh s nu e y hid
pe s scrm i la s ul . n t tc e, he c pl i a l ge t tt a t ke had t a ed
r on' i na s a t I ha as t om a nt le d ha he tac r
û us
c
dit ba s ar e s a fght ' a t s t rnk on û e r pr o occ s o ,' ha he w asç
s ur nce , gum nt nd i s ' t he ka e i
t ve al i r a i ns' t t
s
é
a

k o to bl ma e'wh h dp e o l be nee tdfo terr b ise ly e , n t a
n wn r u e k r' o a rviusy e j ce r m h ik y t mpo e s a d h t
l
he i d bee ba d f om r e r t t r nk on t da e oft atac ' 1 a 1 l lg of
d
ha
n nne r
e nt y o he i
he t
he t k. d. t 25. n i ht
'

t e s cfcf c sr ga di t tpa tc a as al nt t c tc ude t tacai bas o a
hos pe ii a t e r ng ha riul r s ia , he our oncl d ha l m
ed n
is ci lr l t o hi 'c d s v ve di m i s l The f t i Thom ps a e a f r c y f om t
çpe a e a i ns p' oul ur i
s s a.
ac s n
on r a r r he
i t ntca e whi h alege t tOne e c w asr quesed t pr de pa e f a pr s rpton
ns a
s , c l ha
B a on
e
t o ovi
ym nt or e c i i
m edi a i pe t t m sofisc r c , e e e ed i w o d do s a t n r us t pa f
c ton r he er
t ont a t r pr s nt t ul
o, nd he ef ed o y or

i.Cf Di t v.Stehlr 55 S. 2d42,49( 2001 ( c i ngThomps n, H.a ot r
t . dao
r e , 4 E.
Va. ) desrbi
o A. , nd he

ca e a fli C t nt a tofourj ipr de goveni s ca r ai hi ...
s s s alng t hi he mbi
wi
urs u nce r ng pe il eltons ps

be a et er lto hi gvers t a d y ofpr t c i fom c i na a t c
c us hos e ai ns ps i ie o ut
o e ton r rmi l c s omm it d by
te
t r pari ' a c udi t y û ve no a i to ' o t i s ofw he he pa e s ofa
hid tes' nd oncl ng he t
ha
pplca i n' t he s ue
t r r nt

pai ntwe e owe adut t wa n by medialpr de swho al dl f l t a s t m of
te
r
d
y o r
c ovi r
lege y aied o dvie he

t cor c r s t oft rda erssc ec lts)
he re t euls hei ught ' ikl el et.
Pl i ifa kno l dge t tVi gi a cou t have notco i r d t st or çi t
a ntf c w e s ha r ni
rs
ns de e hi he y û he
n

contxtofi ur ri ur d, Dkt No.1 a 8,b nonehels a g st tOne a n s d ha
e
ns e -ns e ' .
'
7 t ut
t e s r ue ha
Be co houl ve
bee a r ofi i ntda rt Ka a awhe i r c i d t r q sst fl t
n wa e mm ne
nge o m r
n t e eve he e ue t o il he
a i gulton m e c to a t tt sf c c dgi rs t t r quiies c a r a i hi
ntcoa a i
dia i n nd ha hi a t oul ve ie o he e st pe i l eltons p.
The c t s e .l pa tc a ,t U nie St t sCour ofA ppe l f rt Fo t Cic tha
our diagr es n r i ul r he t d a e
t
a s o he ur h r ui s

e es l hel t t t rVigi alw ,her ca benor c r i t t orar f a i bad f ih
xpr sy d ha , mde r ni a t e n
e ove y n or f
e us l n
at
t honora f r t pa t i ur nc c a m .Se A & E Sunnl Co. N a i i M ut Fie I .Co.
o
i s - ry ns a e l i
e
y
v. tonw de
. r ns
,

798F. 669, ( hCi.1 6) I t tc e,hedee nti ur nc c
2d
676 4t r 98 . n ha as t fnda ns a e ompa ha r f e t
ny d eus d o
pa a f r l s on t g ound t tt fr had be n s tby t i ur d.The i ur d s d,
y ie os
he r
ha he ie
e e
he ns e
ns e ue
c e ng t is c a m had be n de e i ba f ih,a i s ghta w a a r d punii
ont ndi hat t l i
e ni d n d a t nd t ou
nd s wa de
tve

d ma e b aj r Ona pe lt eFo rhCic i r ldt t li frafit et p ya is e
a g s y u y. p a, h u t rut ue ha cams o all o a n n urd
r
die ty ar e ua e unde c r c prncpls nott t i i e , t no punii dn a s
r c l e val t d
r onta t i i e , or prncpl s and hus
tve m ge

coul bea r d. eà Subsque de sonsfom t sc ta ot r ha r e l afr d
d wade Se 4, e nt cii r hi our nd hes ve ec nty fime
t tpr nc pl .Se e. ,M o e d v.St t Fa m Fie & Cas Co. 1 F.Supp. 1 04,1 ha i i e e- :. or hea
ae r r
. , 23
2d 0
005

1 ( . Va.
006 W D. 2000)
.
The c t sco tanedt c l e t tA & E Suppl Co.a t ohe a horte
our i nsr i o onc ud ha
v
nd he t r ut iis
hi i t d a
ghlgh e bove c pe t c us on t tOneBe c ow e no dut t Ka a a out i ofis
om l he oncl i ha
a on
d
y o m r
s de t
conta t dute .Butf t c r ctorpolc t r w oul be no d y a no oblga i on t
r c ual i s
or he onta
i y, he e
d
ut nd
i ton
he
pa tofO ne c t pa f Ka a a' m e c nes The m e e f c t tOneBe co s a ed i w oul
r
Bea on o y or m r s di i .
r a t ha
a n tt t
d

a deby isc r c ua d i t Ka a aa t n f ie t do s doe notr nde i la ei t r.
bi
t onta t l utes o m r nd he al d o
o s
e r t ibl n o t
C oncl on
usi

Fort f e i r s ns t de e a s r s c i motonst dimiswilbe g a ed.
he or go ng ea o , he f nd nt ' e pe tve
i o s s l
r nt
Theclr i die t t s nd c esoft sm e a um o ni n a t ac ompanyi or rt
e k s r ced o e opi
hi mor nd
pi o nd he c
ng de o
a1 couns ofr co d.
1
el e r
EN TER t s t da ofN ove be , 2014.
hi Q y
m r

Chi fU nied St t D it i J
e
t
a es s rct udge