Mills v. CCL et al

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION, ORDER regarding MOTION for Leave to Proceed in forma pauperis 1 filed by Vickie G. Mills. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 5/7/14. (mka)

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES DI RI CO U R T
ST CT
FO R TH E W ESTER N DISTRIC T O F V IRG I IA
N
ROANOK E DI SI
VI ON

VI I G.M I
CK E
LLS,
Pl i if
a nt f
V.

CCL,e aI,
t .
Def
endant
s.

ç.
A .> qyu:v ; ( ou
'- lloû nITc r
ve A
q
.

F M n* .
l
F
YC ? 2 1
24
Jtkl C UD
lA

B l
K

,

CEK
LR

DE TYCL RX
'U
E

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

C i lA c i N o.7: - v- 226
vi ton
14 c 00
By:

H o M i hae F.Urbans
n. c l
ki
Unie St t Dit i tJudge
t d a es s r c

M FM O RANDUM O PI ON
NI
Pr e ngpr K ,pl ntf Vi ki G.M il fld t i t ntco pl ntagans va i
oce di
o
ai if c e
ls ie he nsa
m ai
i t rous
m e c lpr de s t SocilSec iy Adm i sr to a t Unie Stt sTr as y.M il
di a ovi r , he
a
urt
nitai n nd he t d a e e ur
ls

move t pr e j f mapau rs purua t 28U. C.j1 ()1 .Thec t lgrnt
s o oce d - or
q
pei, s nt o
S. 915a ()
our wil a
M il motont pr e L f mapa rs Howe r a t r viwi t c antt c t
ls' i o oce d q or
upei.
ve, fer e e ng he ompli ,he our
co l dest tt a ton m us bedim is d f rf ilr t sa eacli ,ptr ua t 28 U. C.
nc u
ha he c i
t
s s e o alze o t t
am ls nt o
S.

j 1 5 e( )B)i o t eFe e a Rulso Cii P o e u e
91 ()2 ( (i f h d rl e f v l r c d r .
)
Under28U. C.j1 5,dititc t ha aduyt s e ni ta flngsa dimisa
S. 91 src ours ve t o cre niil ii nd s s
c antfldt f mapa rsç ta tmei t c tdeer ne t t.t acin..s
ompli ie q or
upei s ny i f he our t mi s ha ..he to .i
a

fi ousormalci .( lfist saeacli onwhihr ifma beg a td..'28U. C.
rvol
i ous..or al o tt am
c ele y r ne .'
S.
j 1 ( ( ( ()(i;s eas ErlneCo.S. v. ohns 440F. 648, 6( h Ci.2006)
915e)2)B)i-i) e lo ii
A. J on,
3d
65 4t r

(nen l u tto o te )Css cin 1 5p r t d src c u t t id p n e tya s s t e
itr a q oains mi d l e to l 91 e mis itit o rs o n e e d n l se s h
t
mert ofL f mapa rsco ai s a t excud s t t tha noa gua eba i i lw or
is q or
upei mpl nt, nd o l e uis ha ve r bl ss n a

fc .)
a t' .
'
The c tc t ue pr K c pl i s lbe a l i pos ng Gl s sr nge s a r t n
our ons r s o
om a nt i r ly, m i <e s t i nt t nda ds ha

f
onnalpl di drfe bylwy s' Ercks n v.Par ,551U. 89,94(
ea ngs a td a er.' i o
dus
S.
2007)( i
quotng

Eselev.Ga e 429U. 97,1 4-5 (976 Howe r 1ac antmus c nti s fce
tl
mbl,
S. 0 0 1 :.
ve,$ ompli
t o an ufiint
f c ua m a t r a c pt d a t u t û t t a c a m ofr le t ti pl usbl on is f c '' A s r t
a t l te , c e e s r e, o s a e l i
e i f ha s a i e t a e.' hc of
1

v.gba,556U. 662,678(
I l
S.
2009)( i BelAt. p. Twombl 550U. 5 57
quotng l lCor v.
v,
S. 44, 0
(
2007).M il'c antfist saeal lcli uponwhihr i ma beg a t
) ls ompli al o tt ega am
c elef y r ned.
M il'al gai a euni t li bl a gi no per e i e cai f f r lr le .
ls le tons r
n e lgi e nd ve
c ptbl l m or ede a ei f
l ed,i i note n clart t c twha M il i cli i i t ss t s sat onl t ts
nde t s
ve e o he our
t ls s am ng n hi ui; he t es y ha he

i s e ngaS our or rf me cainsnee d'a wa t t çljxa omai pr ci i
s e ki t t de or di to
c
de ' nd n s o ûfa ut tc esrptons
i opha ma t be dei r d orm al d t hom eadd es .'W hiet pla ngr e a e ls
nt
r cy o
lve e
ie o
r s'
l he e di uls r e s
s rnge f pr K pl ntfs M il silmus ofe s
t i nt or o
ai if , ls tl
t f r ome f t don whi h de e nt c d
oo hol
c f nda s oul
.

b s a a s r o o whihtec u t o db s aj d me t Theei n s c f oh dh r .
a e n n we , r n c h o r c ul a e u g n . r s o u h o tol ee
Sf e r qui e e oflbe alc t c i doe notm e n t tt c tc n i no e a cl arf iur i
t ' e r m nt i r ons m ton s
-h
a ha he our a g r
e al e n

t pladi t ale f c swhih s tf t ac am c r nty c ni bl i a f de alditit
he e ng o l ge a t
c e orh l i ure l og za e n e r src

c t t'Ro h se v U. Go .No 20 - 2 ot . c e tr . S. v, . :7 4 7 HMH- C, 0 8W L 61 7 2 a * ( S. M a .
r'
RS 2 0
8 9 , t 2 D. C. r
3,2008)( tngW elrv. pa t ntofSoca Se vce ,901F. 387( hCi.99 )
cii
le De rme
il r i s
2d
4t r1 0).
Ft t r M il ha e tbls dnobassf fderl trs ci
t he , ls s sa ihe
r
i or e a jliditon.Ge r ly,ac eca be
ne al as n

o ii l fldi af d r l itit o r i t r i f d rl u sinj rs ito u d r2 U. C.
rgnal ie n e ea dsrc c u tf hee s e ea q e to u idcin n e 8 S.
y
j1 3lo dv riyo ctz n hpj rs ito u d r2 U. C. 1 3 S eKo k n n v
3 r ie st f iie s i u idcin n e 8 S. j 3 2. e k o e .
Guadin Liel . ofAm.511U. 375,377( 994)(iai omitd)(i-' fde a
r a f ns Co.
,
S.
1
cttons te çg he e r l
l

c u tlp s s o l t a p wt a to ie b (h UntdS ae )Co ttto o asaue whc
o rs ose s n y h t o r uh rz d y t e ie tts nsi in r ttt , ih
u

i n t obee pa d db j d ca d ce .I i t b p e u dta ac u ele o tiet i l td
s o t x n e y u iil e re t s o e r s me h t a s is u sd hs i e
mi
j s ito a dteb r e o e tb ihn t c nr r rssu ntep rya s ri
mi d cin n h u d n f sa ls ig he o tay et po h a t se t
ng
j rs ito '
u idcin.
).
Ac o dngy t ec ur wil imisM i s c mpan wi u p eu iepls a tt 2
c r i l ,h o t l d s s l ' o lit t t rj dc t u n o 8
l
ho
r
U. C. 1 5 e( )B)i)f rfiu et saeacam.
S. j 91 ()2 ( (i o alr o tt li
Theco tnot t tt si t s ven h lw s tfl by M il i t pas t we ksa
ur es ha hi s he e t a ui ied
ls n he t wo e nd

dimis dplrua t 28U. C.j1 ( ( ( (i.Se Cas No. 1 v0018 (ie Apr 21
s se zs nt o
S.
915e)2)B)i) e e 7:4c
3 fld . ,
2

201 ;Cas No. 1 v001 (ie Apr 22,201 ;Cas No. 1
4) e 7:4c 98 tld .
4) e 7:4cv00203(ie Apr 28,
tld .
201 ;Cas No.7:4c
4) e
1 v00204(ie Apr 28,201 4Cas No. 1
fld .
4) e 7:4cv00205(ie Apr 28,
fld .
201 ;Cas No.7:4c
4) e
1 v00206.ByOr re ee i c s ml r7:4cv00206onMay2, 4,
de ntrd n a e mbe 1
201
M il wasnotfedt tf rhe flng offi ouslws t ma r s ti t i poston of
ls
ii ha u t r ii
rvol a uis y e ul n he m ii
s nc i . Be a e M il m a no ha r c ve t tOr rbe or s fld t i t c
a tons c us ls y t ve e ei d ha de f e he ie he nsmnt ompli
ant
on M a 5,201 t c twil outofa a
y
4, he our l,
n bunda eofc uto wa nM il onc agan t t
nc
a i n, r
ls e i ha
FU R TH ER FI N G O F FR I O LO U S LAW SU I S I TH I C O U RT M AY R ESU LT I
LI
V
T N
S
N

THE I POSI ON O F SANCTI NS,I
M
TI
O
NCLUDI I
NG SSUANCE OF A PRE- LI
FI NG
I JU N CTI N .
N
O

The Clr i die t d t s nd copi oft sM e or ndum Opi on a t a co pa ng
ek s rce o e
es hi m a
ni nd he c m nyi
Or rt pl i if
de o a ntf .

E trd Maz,04
nee: y 2 1

/
+/

- 2. # .
' v
r
M i ha F. r ns
c el U ba ki
Unie Stt sDititJ
t d a e src udge

3

'