Lamonaca v. Tread Corporation
Filing
71
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/22/2015. (lab)
- = - OFFI
CE
t.S. SI COU
J DI
A N FIED E,VA
T LOK
I THE UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI GI I
CT
R N A
ROAN OKE DI I ON
V SI
J 22 2 1
UN
25
> 'e -
14I =. D
1 A
.
.
DE
j RK
CLERK 'L
V ALARI LA M ON AC A ,
E
Ci lA c i N o.7: 4CV 002
vi ton
1
49
Pl ntf ,
ai i f
M EM O M ND UM O PIN IO N
TREA D CO RPOM TI ,
ON
RT
Hon. l n E.Co a
Ge
nr d
Chi fUnied St t Diti tJ
e
t
aes src udge
D e e nt
f nda .
V a a i La ona fl d t sa ton ag ns he f m ere pl r Tr d Cor a i
l re M
ca ie hi c i
ai t r or
m oye , ea
por ton
( e d) al i vi ainsoft Fa l a Media Le veActof1 (
Tr a , legng olto
he miy nd
cl a
993 FMLA) 29U. C.jj
,
S.
2 012 5 Th c s i p e e tyb f r t ec u to T e d' moi nfrs mmayj d me t
6 - 6 4. e a e s r sn l eo e h o r n r a s to o u r u g n .
The c t d a he rng o t m oton on J 1 20 1 Fort r as s a e durng t
our hel
a i n he
i
une 7, 5.
he e ons t t d i he
h a iga d frt o estf rhb lw,h mo inf rs mmayj d me t lb de id.
e rn n o h s e o t eo t e to o u r u g n wil e ne
Fact Backeround
ual
The f l ngf t a eeiheru s t d or whe ediput ar pr e e i t lght
olowi acs r t ndipu e , r s ed, e es nt d n he i
mo tfv rbet tepanif Se To a v Cotn, 3 S. . 8 ,1 6 ( 01 )(mp szn
s a o a l o h li tf. e ln . t 1 4 Ct 1 61 8 6 2 4 e ha ii g
o
t tc u t mu tve t e ie c o s mmayj d me tnt elg t s fv rb et te
ha o rs s iw he vd n e n u r u g n i h ih mo t a o a l o h
nonmovi pat .
ng ry)
La ona bega wor ng f Tr a i 2009. A fe i ta l s r ng a a e utve
M
ca
n
ki or e d n
t r nii ly e vi s n xec i
asitntt Trad' f merc e exe utveofi e (
ssa o e s or hif c i tc r CEO)Bil c a La ona wa a ntd
, lM clne, M ca s ppoi e
t s r ast i ei humanr o ce ( diecoronAug t26, 2. OnMa c 1 201
o eve he ntrm
es ur s HR) r t
us 201
r h 0, 3,
t cur entCEO ,B ar y Russ l of i aly prom ot LaM onaca t HR di or. She r ai i
he r
r
el, fci l
ed
o
rect
em ned n
t tposii unt lApr lof2014,when t event gi ng r s t t sacton occur ed.
ha
t on i
i
he
s vi i e o hi i
r
.
I Aprlof201 La onac sr ede otonal afe bei e
n i
4, M
a tuggl m i ly tr ng xpos d t he g e d
e o i ht ne
l l ofsrs a homea a wor Herhus ndha l thi j whiere r tngfo ope
eves te s t
nd t k.
ba
d os s ob l e upe ai r m n
h a t u g r a d t u , e j bwa t efmiy' s l s u c o ic mea d is r n ebe eis
e r s r e y n , h s h r o s h a l s o e o re f n o n n u a c n ft.
Addii ly,
tona l LaM onac sr ltons pwih Rus el ha gr i e i y sr i d. Ones zc
a' ea i hi t
s l d own ncr asngl tane
olr e
oft i bewe t m wasa lws tTr adha fl d i sa ec tagans La o c sf mer
enson t en he
a ui e
d ie n t t our i t M na a' or
bos , l M c a andt compa sf m e c e tna a of e , r M il r
s Bil clne,
he
ny' or r hi f i ncil fc r Ca l le .
O n t afe noon ofFrda A prl 11 201 La onac m d w ih Rus e lt di e s i s
he t r
i y, i , 4, M
a
t
s l o s us s ues
r aedt t l ui agans M c anea M ilr Thepa esdiput wha ta pie durng t
elt o he aws t i t cl
nd le .
/i s e
t r ns r d i he
m e tng. W hie Tr ad m a n a nst tLa ona r s gne durng t m ee i La ona a
ei
l e
i t i ha M
ca e i d i he
tng, M
c
c e t ts me ey i o m e Rus e lt ts wasc i rng r sgni a t the
ont nds ha he r l nf r d
s l ha he
onsde i e i ng, nd ha
s
ugge t d t ts t kes
se ha he a ometme t t nk abou t de son. Durnghe de ii La ona
i o hi
t he cii
i
r poston, M
ca
t tfedt tRuselol he t ts se dC te s dout't tS di nott r t tghejs d
esii ha s lt d r ha he e me d rs e n ha d d hil ha s houl
s
' he
k
r s gn,' t the woul wa he t s i a w rte r i ton i s uli a e y de de t do
e i ' and ha
d nt r o ubm t
it n es gna i f he tm t l ci d o
s LaM onaca D ep.Tr 72o.
. 73.
La ona r t ne t herof i e al rt m e tng, A ppr m a e y t e y m i t l t r
M
ca e ur d o
fc fe he e i
oxi t l w nt nu es a e ,
Rus e lr om m e d t s l ve e l be aus he wasco e ne a
s l ec
nde hat he ea ary, c e
nc r d bouthe çs a e ofm i '
r dt t
nd.
'
Rus el D e Tr 60s l p. . 61. La onac w a o e ve c yi w he s pa s d K i be l Bu l r t
M
a s bs r d r ng
n he s e m r y t e , he
HR a s s a , t way outoft buidi
s i t nt on he
he l ng.
La e t tni ,Rus el s ntLaM onac t t xtmes ag as ngi s pl d t s i
t r ha ght
s le
a wo e
s es ki f he anne o ubm t
a w rte r s g t o LaM onac di notr s
it n e i na i n.
a d
e pond t t m es a t tni ht
o he
s ges ha g .
On t m o ni ofSa ur y,Apr l 1 201 LaM ona s dul a a
he r ng
t da
i 2, 4,
ca che ed n ppoi m e t s e
nt nt o e
herphysi an,Dr.N i Sweeney,t f l i M onda Apr l14,2014. A ft schedulng t
ci
na
he olow ng
y, i
er
i he
appoi m ent LaM onaca sentButeran em ai i catng t s w as Ssuf erng f om
nt
,
l
l ndi i hat he
i f i r
ps hol c dites duet pr ong e
yc ogial sr s
o ol ed xpos r t hi l vesofsr s'a t ts had
u e o gh e l
tes ,' nd ha he
s hedul d t s he phys ci n on M onda a l noon. D e .sEx.P. La ona a a ked Bu l rt
e
e o ee r
ia
y fer
f'
M
c s
te o
s nd he t com pa s FM LA f
e
r he
ny'
onus t t ke w ih he t t a nt e t
o a
t r o he ppoi m n .
On Su y,Aprl1 201 a 1 47 p. .Rus el s ntLaM onac a he s re oft xt
nda
i 3, 4 t 2: m , s l e
a not r e i s e
m e s swhi h pr ded a f l :
s age
c ovi
s olows
Va a i - yourf l et r s
l re
aiuz o e pond t my l s t que tonsi c t t tyou ha
o
a t wo si ndi aes ha
ve
dec ded t di c i youre pl e a Tr d i m e a el l t s i
i
o s ontnue
m oym nt t ea m di t y. f hi s
i or e ,pl s r s
nc r d ea e e pond i m e a e y. Ot r ie,Iw ila s e t r i ton
m di t l
he w s
l s um he es gna i
you ver lyt nde e on Frd i e f c i i
ba l e r d
i ay s fe tve mmedit l a lwila r
a ey nd
l rangeon
M onday t di
o scontnue yourpay and beneft
i
is.
De sEx. .
f'
Q
La ona a r s
M
c e ponde a hourlt rasf l
d n
ae
olows:
Ba y, donot hi t tt si a a opra em e um t ha t scon r a i
n' I
t nk ha hi s n ppr it di o ve hi ve s ton. I
w aspr pa i t di c sw ih you on M onda H oweve ,s nc yo de a m y
e rng o s us t
y.
r i e u m nd
i m edi t r s
m
a e e pons no 1do notpl n t t nde m y r s gna i
e,
a oe r
e i ton. 1w ils nd a l r
l e
onge
e a ton i e l
xplna i n mai.
1s
d
.-
At2: lp. .ha a t r
0 m t t fe noon,La ona s tRus e la e alr ie a i t ts ha
M
ca en
s l n m i et r tng ha he d
de dednott r i n fom Tr d. I t s m ee a l La ona a s d Rus e lt ts wa
ei
o esg r
ea n he a m i, M
ea dvie
s l ha he s
r si a me c lla ofa e e,a t ts had s he e a a nt ntwih he
eque tng
di a e ve bs nc nd ha he
c duld n ppoi me
t r
physi an:
ci
. . . A syo r c
u e ogni d,e n be o e m e Ia s f rng f om t a r e e f c s of
ze ve f r
, m uf e i r he dve s f e t
pr ong e
ol ed xpos r t s r s . On Frda yo s a e t tpe ha t ve y difc t
u e o te s
i y, u t t d ha r ps he r f i ul
r s pr es ha s tntaly i r as d my sr slvel A ltl bi ofditnce
aie oc s s ubsa i l nc e e
tes e . ite t
sa
f om t s t to ha gi n m e m or pe s c i a 1r ogni t tlha
r he iua i n s ve
e r pe tve nd ec ze ha
ve
be e i r asngl e otona l di t e s d a wor Bo h you a m y c or r
eom nc e i y m i ly sr s e t k. t
nd
ow ke s
ha obs r d t s o m uli e r e occ s ons de ons r t d by m y i biiy t
ve e ve hi n
tpl ec nt a i
m ta e
na lt o
m ai ai m y com posure duri sress ulst i ,cr ng atw or and i lt t
nt n
ng t f iuatons yi
k,
nabiiy o
a tc a e m ys l c ea l Ibe i vet tt si t r ul ofpr onged e
r i ul t
e f l r y.
le ha hi s he es t
ol
xpos et
ur o
hi l sofstes and lam seeki m edi t eat entf t s condii
gh evel
r s
ng
cal r m
or hi
ton. 1have
an appoi m entw ih m y phys ci on M onday,A prl 1 201 and 1wil1 you
nt
t
i an
i 4, 4
l et
know t out e oft appoi m e on Tues
he com
he
nt nt
day.
3
l teme n i , a r q e tn t tKi g teqsn met ea p o raeFM LA
n h a tme 1 m e u si g ha m Bulr e d h p r p it
a Sho tTe Dia lt pa r k i tme f m et tket m y a nt nton
nd r nn s biiy pe wor n i or
o a o
ppoi me
M onda a t r on.
y fe no
De ,sEx. l ar pl e a ls ntt nt m i t lt r Rus eldie t d La o c t k t y
f'
R. n e y m i e we y nu es ae , s l r c e M na a o i a
s
a y fom t ofi a of ofTr a pr ry untlf t rno ie.' l
wa r he fce nd f
e d ope t i urhe tc ' d.
On t m or ng ofM o y, i 1 201 Bute r lyedt Rus el La ona a' r ques
he ni
nda Aprl 4, 4, l r ea
o
s l M
c se t
f FM LA f m s N e t rRus e lno Bute f w a de t f m st LaM onac
or
or . ihe
s l r l r or r d he or o
a.
At3: p. . ha at r
30 m t t fe noon,La onac wa e mi d by Dr Swe ne aboa d c rii
M
a s xn ne
. e y,
r e tfed
f miyp a tto e . Dr S e yda n s dLa n c a h vnga a j t n dio d rwih
a l rciin r . we ne ig o e Mo a a s a i n dusme t s r e t
a ousm ood. Shea s d La ona t t a30- ym ed c ll veofabs nc a s he eda
nxi
dvie M
ca o ake
da
i a ea
e e nd c dul
f l - e ua i f M a 1 201
olow up val ton or y 2, 4.
La o c c am st ts wa t r naedby e i lt rt tda At5: p. . Rus el
M na a l i ha he s e mi t
ma l a e ha y.
35 m , s l
s ntLa ona a a e a la s ng he t the e pl e had e
e
M
c n m i dvi i
r ha r m oym nt
nded t pr vi Frday,a t t
he e ous i
nd ha
he ha i t c e Bu l rt s nd he i o m a i n r ar ng he a r e l ve a COBR A benei s
d ns nl t d t e o e
r nf r to eg di
r ec u d ea nd
tt .
O n A pr l22, 4, M ona s ntRus el a c o t w or e us t ts ha r c ve
i
201 La
ca e
s l opy f he
k xc e ha he d e ei d
f om Dr Swee y a a ke t the r ons de t de i i t t nni t he e pl en . l
r
.
ne nd s d ha
ec i r he c son o e na e r m oym t n
r pons ,Rus el a s d LaM onac t the em pl e e d on A prl 11 201 whe he
es
e
s l dvi e
a ha r
oym nt nde
i , 4
n
ça ce edg r rsgnai 'a t ,ha t r wa none df he physca t c eea
tc pt he) e i ton,' nd,hus t thee s
e or r iin o omplt ny
FM LA pa r or D ef' Ex.1 .
pe w k.
s
l
ProceduralH i orv
st
-
LaM ona a f l d t i t nta to a i tTr d o M a 15 201 La ona , c a m st t
c ie he ns a c i n ga ns ea n y , 4. M
ca l i ha
Tr ad i e f r w ih he rght unde t FM LA by t r i tng he i t ad ofgi ng he m e c
e nt r e ed t r i s
r he
e m na i
r ns e
vi
r di al
l
eave,and t Tr t m i ed heri r alaton f reques i FM LA l
hat ead er nat
n et i i or
tng
eave.
OnM a 2 , 01 , e dmo e frs mma yj d me t Th c u t l ah ai o t e
y 2 2 5 Tra v d o u r u g n . e o r hed e rng n h
m oton on J
i
une 1 2015. The m oto hasbee f l br e e a i rpe f r vi w .
7,
in
n uly i f d nd s i or e e
St
andard ofR evi
ew
Ana r o s mmayj d me ti a p o raedftemo n s o t a t eei n
wad f u r u g n s p r p it c h va t h ws h t h r s o
i
g n i ed s u ea t a ymae il a t ndt emo a ti e t ldt j d me ta amatro lw.
e u n ip t s o n tra f c a h v n s ni e o u g n s te f a '
t
'
Fe R. v P. 6a . ; dip t i g n iei i ra o a l j r c u drtr av r it o te
d. Ci . 5 () ' s u e s e un f a e s n b e u y o l eu n ed c f r h
A
n mno igp ry'' Lie tra Pa t o Va v. u d 71 F.d 3 8 31 ( t Ci. 01 )( u tn
o vn a t.' b rain ry f . J d , 8 3 0 , 3 4h r 2 3 q oig
Dulne v. c ngCop . Am.673F. 323,330( hCi. 1 ) ; fc i maei i i
a v Pa kagi
of ,
3d
4t r 20 2). $ a t s tral ft
A
S ghtaf tt outomeoft s tunde t go r ng1w.' J ( i Andes v. bely
mi fec he c
he ui
rhe ve ni a '' #= quotng
ron Li '
t
LobbysI .477U. 242, ( 98 )
nc,
S. 248 1 6).
l c nsd rn ame inf rs mmayj d me t tec u t s ve ter c r i tel h
n o ie ig
to o u r u g n ,h o r mu t iw h e o d n h i t
g
mo tfv rb et t n n v n p ry. Toa ,1 4 S Ct a 1 6 . C u r u g n c n o
s a o a l o he o mo i g a t
ln 3 . . t 8 6 k mmayj d me t a n t
s
be g a t m e el be aus t cour be i vest tt m ova w ilpr va li t ac i i t i d on
r n ed r y c e he
t le
ha he
nt l e i f he ton s re
t meis' J c v. C.
he rt.' a obs N. Admi Ofi eoft Co t,78 F. 562,568( hCi. 5
n. tc he urs 0 3d
4t r 201 )
(ntmalcttona quottonmakso te . il e tt r fr ca weg t e de e
ie
iai nd ai
r mitd) k' our he eo e nnot ih he vi nc
-he
orm a c e biiy detr i tons' l
ke r di lt e m na i .' d.
Di
scussi
on
1.
Int erence Cl m
erf
ai
The FM LA conf r s ver lrg s o elgi e e pl es i l ng t r g t t ke up t
e s e a i ht n i bl m oye , nc udi he i ht o a
o
t l we ksofl vedg e aus o asroushe t c to t tma t e o euna et
weve e
ea tblc e f e i
alh ondiin ha kes he mplye bl o
pe f m t f to 'ofhe poston. 29U. C.j261 a( )D) TheFM LA aloma si
ror he uncins' r ii
S.
2()1( .
s ke t
tunl f f any em pl
t aw ul or
oyert i er er w ih,r t ai ordeny t exerci ofort atem ptt
o nt f e t es r n,
he
se
he t
o
e rie'a e oye sFM LA rght. 29U. C.j2615() ) Toprvalonacam of
xecs ' n mpl e'
i s
S.
a(l.
e i
li
5
unlwf i erec e a emplyeemus pr ( )t ts wase ildt a FM LA be i;(
a ulnt frnc , n
o
t ove 1 ha he
ntte o n
neft 2)
t the e oye itre e wiht pr so oft tbe ft a ( t tt i efr nc c us d
ha r mpl r nefr d t he oviin ha nei; nd 3) ha he ntre e e a e
ham. SeeDownsv.W i hetrM e Ct.21F.Supp. 61 ,6l ( . Va. 4) seas
r
nc se d. r,
3d 5 7 W D. 201 ; e lo
Ada v.
ms AnneAr lCny.Pub.Sc ,No.1 1 2015U. App.
unde t
h.
4- 608,
S.
LEXI 1 ,a *7( h
S 0031 t 4t
Ci.J 15, )
r une 2015 .
I movi f s
n
ng or ummayj me onLa
r udg nt
Mona scai t tTr a i efr dwihhe
ca' l m ha e d ntre e t r
rg t FM LA la Tr ad c e t tLa ona scl m f isa t fr telm e .
i ht o
e ve, e ontnds ha M
ca' ai a l t he is e nt
Spe ii lys e dar st tLa o c wasnotenildt FM LA la be us ( )s
cfcal Tr a gue ha M na a
tte o
e ve ca e 1 he
r inedbeor r que tngla ( s di notpr des fcintnoi ofhe nee f FM LA
esg
f e e si e ve; 2) he d
ovi ufi e tce
r d or
la a ( s di notha asroushe lhcondii t tpr ve edhe fom pe fr ngt
e ve; nd 3) he d
ve e i
at
ton ha e nt r r
romi he
e s nta f tonsofhe ob. Thec t l c i re hagume i t n.
s e il unci
rj
our wil onsde ac r ntn ur
Tr a frt r u sta La o a av u trl rsg e fo h r o d rngt eme t
e d is a g e h t M n c olnaiy e in d ' m e j b u i h ei
r
ng
w ih Rus e lon Apr l11 201 a t ,t ts wa no l re pl
t
sl
i , 4, nd, hus ha he s onge m oyed a t tm e s
t he i hc
rq e tdFMLA la e Fo t er ao sae d rn tes mmayj d me t e rn , o v r
e u se
e v . r h e s ns ttd u ig h u r u g n h a ig h we e,
t cou tr m ansc nc d t twheherLa ona ar i d durng t me i wih Rus el on
he r e i onvi e ha
t
M
c esgne
i he etng t
s l
Aprl1 , 01 i aq eto o f c ta mu t er s l e b aj r W h l Tra h sp o frd
i 1 2 4 s u sin f a th t s b e o v d y u y. ie e d a r fee
e i e c fo whihaj r c udd sr dt M o c ' v rino tee e t,hec u tsn t
v d n e r m c u y o l ic e iLa na as eso f h v n s t o r i o
pemie t weg t ee d n eo ma ec e iii d tr nainso s mmayj d me t
r t d o ih h vie c r k rdb ly eemi to n u r u g n .
t
t
J obs 780F. a 5 s as Gr yv. l n, F. 90, ( hCi.1 )(l i not
gç ,
3d t 68) ee lo a Spil 925 2d 96 4t r 991 ;t s our
ma
1
-
j t wei t e de ,t c how ma afda t fvort pli ifa ho manyo e
ob o gh he vi nce o ount
ny fi vis a he antf nd w
ppos
hi o t dirgad so ist ts m hadt bei
m, r o se r tre ha ee r o leve. Thos ts aef t j y.)
e a ks r or he ur ' .
'
Tr nextar
ead
guest LaM onaca' r
hat
s eques f FM LA l
t or
eave wasi ufi ent To i
ns fci .
nvoke
rght unde t FM LA ,a e pl e i r uie t pr de notc t he e pl rofhe nee f r
i s
r he
n m oye s eq r d o ovi
i e o r m oye
r d o
6
la Rhoadsv.Fe De iI . p.257F, 373,38 ( hCi. ) W hent ne f
e ve.
d. post ns Cor ,
3d
2 4t r 2001 .
he ed or
l a i unf es a e l e o mus pr de no i t t e oye ass a pr c ia e
e ve s or ee bl, i mpl yee
an
t ovi
tce o he mpl r oon s a tc bl
unde t f t a cr umsa esoft pariulrcae.* 29C. R.j825. $. iW he a
r he acs nd ic tnc
he tc a s '
'
F.
3034 s n n
e pl e s eks l ve f t tr ttm e f a FM LA - iyi r s n, he em pl
m oye e
ea or he i s i or
qualf ng ea o t
oyee ne no
ed t
e e syase trg sunde t FM LA ore nme in t FMLA. 29 C. R.j8 303*)
xpr sl s r iht
r he
ve nto he
'
'
F. 25.
.
Ra he ,t e pl e m us m e el pr de Ss fci nti or a i f a e pl ye t r s bl
t r he m oye
t r y ovi luf i e nf m ton or n m o r o ea ona y
deemi whehe t FM LA ma a yt t l ver quet' L (mpha i adde . Asc t
tr ne t r he
y ppl o he ea e s. i e
'
ss d)
ours
ha pr vi usy not d,d hi i no af malsi orsrnge sanda d,'a e oye sne no
ve e o l
e t s s t or itc ti nt t r ' nd mpl e ed t
t
' o de e y de ai nec s r f t e pl rt ve iy i t FM LA a i . Li ht ns e n v.
û vi ver t l es a y or he m oye o rf f he
pr
pples' c e t i
'
Uni ofPitbur hM ed.Ct.691F. 294,303( Ci. 2)(ii caes.
v. ts g
r,
3d
3d r 201 ctng s )
Onc t e pl
e he m oyeei or st e oye t ts ne la f ramedialr as i he
nf m he mpl r ha he eds e ve o
c e on, '
t
bur n t n s fst t e pl rt g t raddii i or ai and de em i i t FM LA i
de he hit o he m oye o a he
tonal nf m ton
t r ne f he
s
a t lyi i td. Kr kev. exa i M ot Ca s l ,28 F. x629,632(t Ci.
cual mplcae ' ens Al ndra or r. nc. 9 App'
'
4h r
2008) ûft e oye fndst e oye srquetf la va ori ufiintt
. s he mpl r i he mpl e' e s or e ve gue ns fce ,he
l
e pl rs d as t e pl e t pr de t ne es a y de a l t oug a tona
m oye houl k he m oye o ovi he c s r t is hr h ddii l
doc nttona i or ton. l ;s eas 29C. R.j825. b)(i hee oye wilbe
ume ai nd nf mai ' d. e lo
'
F.
303( ûf mpl r l
e ctdt obt na a to lrquiedi or tont oughi or lme ns')
xpe e o ai ny ddiina e r nf mai hr
nf ma a . .
'
Cons que l ihei rtca t s'i no whe he t e o ga e r ne es a y de alt
e nty, d c ii l e t s t t r he mplyee ve ve y c s r t i o
t
de e nei t FM LA a is bu C t i or ton c
t nni f he
pple , t how he nf ma i onvey t t e oye i r as bl
ed o he mpl r s e ona y
i eprt '' Lihtnsei 691F. a 303( i Sanows v. rBr
ntr eed.' c e t n,
3d t
quotng r ki Ai ookeLi i l ,
mousne.nc.
51 F, 398, ( Ci.2007). Ther s uton o t sq toni ge al aque to offc
0 3d
402 3d r
)
eol i f hi uesi s nerly
sin a t
*TheFM LA r a i tea f e eeabl a unf e eea e l dif enty. I t scas ,t r i no
egultons r t or s
e nd or s bl eave fer l n hi e he e s
s s i fom eiherpary t tLa onaca' ne f l wasf es eabl
ugge ton r
t
t ha M
s ed or eave
or e e.
f rtej r . I , e as Rv esv. i ims 6 0F.d 1 8 , 1 6( t Ci. 01 )(t c s s
o h u y d.s e lo nd r W l a , 5 3 l 8 1 9 8h r 2 1 ' a e
'
l
our
i t uc t tt a uac ofa e pl yee snotc r quiesc i a i n o t t t lt oft
ns r t ha he deq y
n m o '
i e e r ons der to f he o a iy he
cic tnc a i t cal aj yque to '
rumsa es nd s ypi ly ur sin.
).
V i w i t e de i a lghtm os f r bl t La ona ,t cour bele t ta
e ng he vi nce n i
t avo a e o M
ca he
t i ves ha
ge ne i s ofm a e i lf c e s s a t whe he Tr d r c ve s fci ntnotce ofhe ne f
nui s ue
t r a a t xit s o
t r ea e ei d uf i e
i
r ed or
la
e ve. I as c son ofe a l
n uc es i
m i communi a i be nni onAprl1 201 La onac notfe
c tons gi ng
i 2, 4, M
a ii d
Bute a Rus e lt ts wass f rng fom t a r eefe t ofpr o d e
lr nd s l ha he
ufe i r he dve s f c s
ol nge xpos et sr s
ur o te s
a t ts m a ne t t kea m e ca l ve ofabs nc La ona a t d Bute a Rus e l ha
nd ha he y ed o a
di l ea
e e. M
c ol
l r nd
slt t
s had s he ed t s e he phys c a on t a tr n ofA prl1 201 and r quesed t tt
he
c dul o e r
i in
he fe noo
i 4, 4,
e
t ha he
co pa pr de he w ih t a opr a e FM LA f m s l he e a lt Rus el o A prl 1
m ny ovi
r t he ppr i t
or . n r m i o
s ln
i 4,
201 La ona a s cii a l r que t C media la ofa e e fo Tr ad.' Def' Ex.R.
4, M
c pe fc ly e sed (
a
c l e ve bs nc r m e '
s
l s ppor ofhe r que t LaM ona a pr de s cii e m pl s ofhe e o i
n u
t
r e s,
c ovi d pe fc xa e
r m tonali t biiy a
ns a lt t
w or
k:
. . . lha
ve be om ei e sngl e otonaly dites e a wor Bot yo a my
c
ncr a i y m i l sr s d t k.
h u nd
c or r ha obs ve t son m uli e r c ntoc as o de ons r t d by m y
ow ke s ve er d hi
tpl e e
c i ns m t a e
i lt t m ai ai m y com pos e dur ng sr s uls t tons c yi a w or al
nabiiy o
nt n
ur
i tes f iua i , r ng t k, ld
i biiy t ari ul t m ys l cl ary. Ibele t tt si t r s tofpr onge
na lt o tc a e
ef e l
i ve ha hi s he e ul
ol d
e
xpos e t hi l ve s ofs r s a la s e ng m e ca t e t e f t s
ur o gh e l
t e s nd m e ki
di l r a m nt or hi
c ton.
ondii
D e pie Tr ad' a g e st t c r r t m e e f c t tLa ona ha notye
s t e s r um nt o he ont a y, he r a t ha M
ca d
t
r ce ve m e c lt e t e a t tm e s r es e l ave i no f t t hercl i s nori t f c
e i d di a r a m nt t he i he equ t d e
s t a al o
am ,
s he a t
t tt e a l pr ded no i ca i ofhow l t r ue t d a e w oul be. Cours ha
ha he m is ovi
ndi ton
ong he eq s e bs nee
d
t ve
madece rt ttgl r i nor quie ti t sauet ta e oye bedignos wiha
la ha tthee s e rmen n he ttt ha n mpl e
a ed t
s i he lh condii n be or be m i elgi e f FM LA l ve ' St of v.St J m ' M e cv
erous a t
to f e co ng i bl or
ea ,' ekl f
. ol s r
He lhSys,218F. 858,863(t Ci.
at
.
3d
8h r 2000) a t td mpl esma pr de
, nd ha t oye
e
y ovi
8
FM LA - ua iyi notc bef r k
q lf ng i e o e nowi t e c da e ord a i n o t l a t y w ilt ke.'
ng he xa t t s ur to f he e ve he l a '
Sa now s ,51 F. a 40 s a s Cln ca e v. . r s ofN ew H ope,701 F. 825 8
r
ki 0 3d t 2; ee l o i ks l St The e e
3d
, 29
( hCi. 2)(' . rs ma smuc oft f tt tClnks aeha ... pr vi l be n
8t r 201 ;StThee a ke
h he ac ha i c l d not e ousy e
di gnos d wih a anxi t di o de . .. hiet s a gu e m ay uli a e y bc ron a f c fnde '
a
e t n
e y s r r . W l hi r m nt
tm t l a
a ti r s
c i r ton oft notc r r m e t i < ie c i r bl pole e er Na
onsde ai
he i. equie n ,t as s onsde a e i y oni ns. mdy,he
e
t
FM LA ca
nnotr as bl be r a t pr vi r i fonl f ve e a cl i a sw hos e pl r
e ona y
e d o o de ele
y or t r n a m nt
e m oye s
m a a i i t t ne f m e c ll a
y ntc pa e he ed or di a e ve. The A c is fc e pl t c r um sa e i whi h
t t el ont m a es i c t nc s n
c
t ne d f qualf ng l vea iesune
he e or
iyi ea rs
xpecedl Thus t as ume a e oye spr vi usy
t y.
,o s
n mpl e' e o l
c e rm e ca hi t r pr l esa s e ntFM LA c a m w he hernee f m edi a l a a i es
la
di l s o y ec ud
ubs que
li
n
d or
c l e ve r s
une cedl i pae l unra ona ea c r r t t pupos oft Ac.)
xpe t y s tnty e s bl nd ontay o he
e he t' .
'
Li w i e t c tf ndsunpe s s ve Tr a s r la e o t f tt ti di notr c i
ke s , he our i
r ua i
e d' e i nc n he ac ha t d
e e ve
t doc o ' not e usng La o c fom wor untlAprl22,201 e g da a trhe
he t rs e xc i
M na a r
k i
i
4, i ht ys fe r
e ly n wi Tr a e e . Ase pan da o e ar a o bej r c u dfn t t
mpo me t t e d nd d
h
x lie b v , e s na l u y o l id ha
La ona se l t Bu l and Rus e lpr vi d s fc e i onnai t r quiet e o
M
ca' mais o ter
s l o de ufii nt nf
ton o e r he mplyer
t i r f t i ot bassf he l ver ues,a t tRus e li me ael t r i t d he
o nquie urher nt he i or r ea eq t nd ha
s l m di t y e m na e r
e oyme be or s ha ar s bl opporuniyt pr deaddii na docu e ai n fo
mpl
nt f e he d ea ona e
t t o ovi
to l
m nt to r m
he phys ci n. I s c r m s a es a e pl rbea st r s t ta em pl yee' e il m e
r
ia
n uch icu t nc , n m oye
r he i k ha n
o s ntt e nt
t FM LA l a will e beesa ihe a c nnota dla lt bypr mptve yt m i tngt
o
e ve l atr
t bls d, nd a
voi ibiiy
ee i l er na i he
e oye Se Clnks ae 701F.da 828(ûA) e o doe no a dlabiiyby
mpl e. e i c l,
3 t
ûg n mplyer s t voi i lt
di c r ng a e pl e who t ke l ave i or rt s e te t e f a condii t ti l t r
s ha gi n m oye
a se
n de o e k r a m nt or
ton ha s a e
he d t be c r d by t FM LA . The e pl erwho pr i t l fr a e pl ,whe t
l o
ove e
he
m oy
ec pious y ies n m oyee
n he
l te cl i st be isofl ve unde t FM LA ,be r t rs t tt hea t c ton i
a t r a m he neft
ea
r he
a s he ik ha he lh ondii n
q si lt de lpsi oas roushe lhco ton.)(ntr cttonomit l s as
ueton aer veo nt ei
at ndii ' i enal iai
'
ted ; ee lo
c ton. Att ssag oft pr e ngs howeve ,t c tc udest tLa onac has
ondii
hi t e he oce di ,
r he our oncl
ha M
a
pr e ed s fc e e de t c ea e a ge ne dipu e on t s is
es nt uf i i nt vi nce o r t
nui
s t
hi s ue. Upo e m i ng
n xa ni
La ona on Aprl l 201 Dr Swe y a s he t t ke a m e c l ve ofabs e f om
M
ca
i 4, 4, . ene dvi ed r o a
di al ea
enc r
Tr ad u i M ay 1 201 Durng he de ii D r Sw e ney t s i i d t tLa o c w as
e ntl
3, 4.
i
r poston, . e
e tfe ha M na a
t r ul s ky,a unus ly a tt d durngt exa nai a t ts wa oft opi ont t
ea f , ha
nd
ua l giae
i he mi ton, nd ha he s he ni ha
La ona sa eywa s s veet tLa onac wasuna et pe f m he o Se 29C. R.
M ca' nxit s o e r ha M
a
bl o ror rj b. e
F.
j825.23()(i e oye i u bl t pef t f to oft posto wheet heat
1 a $ mpl e s na e o ronn he uncins he iin r he lh
An
c r pr d t ndst tt e pl e i t a e t wor a a lori una et per o m a one oft
a e ovi er i
ha he m oye s m bl o
k t l s bl o f r ny
he
e s i f tonsoft e o ' poston.. .) Tot extntTrads kst dicediDr
sental unci
he mplyees ii .' .
'
he e e ee o sr t .
S e e stsi n b a g n t a Dr Swe n y' i yrle o ( Mo a as s l-ev n
we n y' e tmo y y r uig h t . e e t mpl eid n La n c 'l efsr i g
s
a s rint a s ewa u a l t p ro m h r o , t ec u t o ld st ts c a g me t ae
se t h t h s n b e o ef r e j b' h o r c ncu e ha u h r u n s r
o
'
b te s td frtilh n s mmayj d me t S eJ c b , 8 F.da 5 8; e as W ila v
etr ui o ra ta u r u g n . e a o s 7 0 3 t 6 se lo l ms .
e
i
Stpl ,l ,37 F. 662, 667( hCi.
a es nc. 2 3d
4t r 2004)(mphaii t tt c tç yno ma
e
szng ha he our t
ma t ke
c e i l yd tr n to 'i rve n t erc r o s mmayj d me t.
rdbit eemiains'n e iwig h e o d n u r u g n)
i
Ad iin l ,h c u t oe t a teme ef c t a La o a aa pidf roh r o sd rng
dto al t e o r n ts h th r a th t M n c p l o t e j b u i
y
e
t pe i ofl a pr c i dby Dr Swee ydoesno pr l he fo esa ihi t s wa
he rod e ve es rbe
.
ne
t ecude r r m t bls ng hat he s
i a cttdf pur esof29C. R. 825. 1 ort ts wa t
nc pa iae or pos
F. j 1 5, ha he s d et pef m t f tons
unabl o ror he unci
ofg lposto 'a rquiedby29U. C.j261 a)1( . Asot rc t ha pr vi l
her iin, s e r
'
S.
2( ( )D)
he ours ve e ousy
e ai d,$ de nsrto t na e oye i u bl t wor i hi o he c rntj duet a
xpl ne (a mo tain ha n mpl e s na e o k n s r z ure ob
o
sro sh at c n iini e o g t s o ta t ee ly ei ic pa iae , v nit to i te
e iu e l o dto s n u h o h w h t h mpo e s n a cttd e e fhaj b s h
h
onl one t tt e pl e i una e t per o m .' St kl f 218 F. a 8 . Li i e û he
y
ha he m oye s bl o f r ' e of ,
3d t 61
kew s , i
t
i r i owhehe a e oye i abl t pef m t e sntalf tonsofhe obs df us
nquiy nt
t r n mpl r s e o ror he se i unci
rj houl oc
on he a lt t pe f m t e f to i herc r nte r e . I a 86 A c or ng y,
r biiy o r or hos unc i ns n
ur e nvi onm nt' d. t 2. c di l
'
a e o e' l vei pr e e by t FM LA ke n i s wasc i
n mpl ye s ea s otctd he
%ve f he
ontnuousy a et wor .. . f
l bl o k
or
s ot remplye .' J .s aloHurbe tSt May' He lhCaeSys,I , F. 1
ome he
o r' #a ee s
;
l r . r s at r a nq.439 3d 286,
1 6 ( 1h Ci. 0 6 (ee tn tee ly rscam t a, samatro lw, ne o e c ul
29 1 t r 2 0 ) rj cig h mpo e ' li h ta
te f a a mply e o d
notha e re c a i biiy t wor wihi t mea ng oft FM LA r ulto snc he
ve xpe inc d n na lt o k t n he
ni
he
eg ai ns i e
co i t pef m smia dute f a he e oyel Eli tv. lns No.
ntnued o ror i lr is or not r mpl r; lot Roli ,
5:1- 693- 2013U. DitLEXI 1
1 CV- FL,
S. s.
S 40926,t*28( D. . Se .1 2013 ($ f tt t
a
E. N C. pt 3, ) 6 ac ha
The
Pl ntf c dpe fr s meot r obwhiepr nanti notr e nt' .
ai if oul rom o
he j
l eg
s elva .)
'
V i w i t r cor i t lg m os f vor bl t La ona , nc udi t t s i o ofD r
e ng he e d n he i ht t a a e o M
ca i l ng he e tm ny
.
Swe ne t co tfndst tage nedipu eofma e i lf c e ssast whe he La onac
e y,he ur i ha
nui s t
t ra a t xit
o
t r M
a
s f r d fom a s rousm e c c ton t tpr c ude he f om per o m i t e s ntal
uf e e r
ei
di al ondii ha e l d r r
f r ng he s e i
f n to so h rp sto . Ac o digy Tr a ' mo inf rs mmayj d me to La o a as
u cin f e o iin
c r n l, e d s to o u r u g n n M n c '
i e f r nc cl i w ilbe de e
nt r e e e a m l
ni d.
ll.
R et i i Cl m
alaton ai
La onac a s cli st tTr dt r i t he i r t la i f rr que tngFM LA la
M
a lo am ha ea e m naed r n e a iton o e si
e ve.
Se 2 U. C. 2 5 a,seas 2 C.. j8 52 0 c (' e (M LA')p o iiina an t
e 9 S. j 61 () e lo 9 FR. 2 .2 () ' F
'
Th
S r hbto g is
i er e e pr bis a e pl rf om di c i i tng orr t la i a i ta e pl e ... or
nt f r nce ohi t n m oye r
s r m na i
e a i tng ga ns n m oye
f
ha ngexecie oral mptdt e rieFM LA rg s'.
vi
r s d te e o xecs
iht.)
'
S LA r t la i cl i sa e a ogo t di c i i to c a m sbr
C
FM
e a i t on a m r nal us o s rm na i n l i
oughtunde Til V l .
r te l'
'
Langv.Fed.Exprs Cor ,703F.d71 71 ( hCi. 3) Ac di y, ealai cams
i
e s p.
3 3, 7 4t r 20l . cor ngl r t iton li
ba e on c r um sa i e de e a e e ua e u rt btr s fi f a e o k s f t i
sd
i c t ntal vi nc r val t d nde he lden- hi tng r m w r et orh n
McDonnelDouMl Cor v. e n, 1U. 79 (973) Se t Unde t sfa wok,he
l
as p. Gre 41 S. 2 1 . e da
r hi rme r t
pli ifû tfrtma aprmaf i s ngt t(hele ge i pr ecedaci t t tt
antf s
mus is ke i ace howi ha s nga d n ot t tviy, ha he
empl t a s a tonag i t( r,a t tt adves a tonwasc alyco ce t
oyer ook dvere ci ans hel nd ha he
re ci
aus l nne td o
t pli ifspr e tda tviy. Ya he v. ra sN. Ca i Co.446F. 541 551( h
he antf' otce ci t ' s nko Harh' C. sno ,
'
3d , 4t
Ci. )(nenalcttona quotto maksomitd) l t pli ifpusf t s tcint
r 2006 itr iai nd
ain r
te . f he antf t orh ufs e
e de e t esa i h a prm a f ci ca e ofr t i ton, nd t e pl rof e sa non- e a i t y
vi nc o t bls
i a e s
e ala i a he m oye f r
r t la or
r as f t a r e a ton,t pl i if( ar t bu d n ofe t bls ng t tt e pl r s
e on or he dve s c i he a ntf t s he r e
be
s a i hi ha he m oye '
pr fr e a toni prtxtf FM LA rt iton. l (ntr lottona quoai maks
ofeed xplnai s ee or
ealai ' d.i ena iai nd tton r
'
omit .
ted)
Att ssa oft pr ce i ,he c ti oft opi on t tLa o c ha pr f r d
hi t ge he o ed ngs t our s he ni ha M na a s ofe e
s fc e e de t es a i h t s e
uf i i nt vi nce o t bls hat he ngag i pr e t d a i t by r ue tng FM LA l a
ed n ot c e ctviy
eq s i
e ve;
t Tr d s bs
hat ea u eque l t r i t d he e pl e ;a t tt e w a a c us lc
nty e m na e r m oym nt nd ha her s a a onnec i
ton
be wee t l ve r que ta t a r e e pl e a ton. See W rchtv. ut e tA ilnes
t n he ea e s nd he dve s m oym nt c i
i
So hw s r i ,
31 F.App' 23 233( hCi.
9
x 2, 4t r 2009)( tngt tt frtt ee nt oft prmafci cae
noi ha he is wo lme s he i a e s
w e e cl a l e t bls d w he e a e pl ye k eque t d ...l ve unde t FM LA a he
r e r y s a i he
r n m o es
r
se
ea
r he
nd r
e oy ntwastr nae ';seas Fose v. v. M ayl Ease Sho e No.1 1
mpl me
emi td' e lo tr Uni of r and- tnz r ,
l
4-073,
201 U. App.LEXI 8384,a * 21( hCi.Ma 21 201 ( di t tt ca ato
5 S.
S
t 20- 4t r y , 5) hol ng ha he us in
ee e wa s
lm nt s upporedbyt t mpor pr miybe wee t pl i ifspr ecedaci t a her
t
he e
al oxi t t n he antf ' ot t
tviy nd
tr nai .
emi ton)
W hie Tr a c i
l e d ontnuest m a nt i t La ona a vol arl r s g d a t , ha s
o i a n hat M
c
unt iy e i ne nd, hus t t he
di nots f ra a r e e oymenta to t c t e ansc nc d t twhehe
d
ufe n dve s mpl
c i n,he our r m i onvi e ha
t r
La o a ase o me t n e v l naiyo iv lna i mu t ed cd dbyaj r Lie s ,
M n c ' mply n e d d o u trl r n ou trl s b e ie
y
u y, k wie
t r or a a w hol w he t ke i t lg m os f vo a e t La ona ,pr s nt a ques i of
he ec d s
e, n a n n he i ht t a r bl o M
ca e e s
ton
f c r r ng w he he Tr d' as e t d bele t tLa onac vol a iy r s gne w a pr t xtf
a t ega di
t r ea s s r e
i f ha M
a unt r l e i d s e e or
r t iton. Se Re sv.Sa ronPlmbi Pr .l , U. 1 l (
ealai
e eve
ndes u nc odss nc.530 S. 33, 48 2000)(iA1
d
(
pl i if spr m a f c e c s c bi d w ih s f c e e de e t fnd t tt e pl ye ' as e t d
a ntf
i a i a e, om ne t uf i i nt vi nc o i ha he m o r s s re
j ttc to i f le ma pemit etiro fc t c n ld ta tee ly ru lwf ly
usi ain s as , y r t h re f a t o o cu e h t h mp o e na ul
q
dici nae ' ;s as Buro v. l lxI ,7 F. 41 430( Ci.201 ( di t t
s rmi td.' ee lo tn Teefe nc. 07 3d 7, 3d r 3) hol ng ha
)
t pl ntf ' e d e c e t d a g nui diput off c r ga di t cr di lt oft e pl ye '
he ai i f s vi enc r a e
e ne s e a t e r ng he e biiy he m o r s
pr frdr a o frhe dic r e,a t t$ ras na efctfnde c dfndt gmpl rs
ofee e s n o r sha g nd ha d e o bl a i r oul i he e oye 'l
a
cam t t(hepli if rsgne t beu t ofc e nc '(ntr lciain a quoai
li ha t antfj e i d o nworhy r de e' i ena tto nd tton
)
maksomitd) Caset v. msCount TrnstAut ,No.106- 1 2008U. Dit
r
te ; rtter Ada
v a i h.
: CV- 993,
S. s.
LEXI 51 a *30( . Pa.J y8, 08 (c he W iei or dCa setrt ts
S 874, t M D. ul 20 ) sW n s nf me rtte ha he
i e pr t hi a ton a a r s g i he i m e a e y a t d t c r c t m i unde s a ng,
nt r e ed s c i s e i naton, m di t l c e o or e t he s
r t ndi but
W iemanan dta h h dv u trl e d dh se o me t He c , u' c udc ncu e
s i ti e h t e a oln aiy n e i mply n . n e aj l o l o ld
y
t tW i e' as e t be i ft tCa s e t rha vol a iy r s gne w a a pr t xtf FM LA
ha
s s s red le ha r t te d unt r l e i d s e e or
rtlai '. Acc di y, e i note il t s
eaiton.)
'
or ngl Trad s ntted o ummayj
r udgme onLa ona srtlain
nt
M ca' eaito
c am .
li
Concl on
usi
F rtera o sae ,h c u t l d n Tra smo inf rsl r j g n .
o h e s ns ttd te o r wi e y e d' to o t
l
mma y ud me t
The Cl r i di e t d t s nd c r ii c esoft sm e or ndum o ni a t
e k s r c e o e e tfed opi
hi m a
pi on nd he
a eo pa ng or rt al co elofr or
e m nyi
de o l uns
ec d.
ENTER:Thi QQ da ofJ ,201
s
y une 5.
Chi fU nied St t D i ti tJ
e
t
a es sr c udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?