Wilburn v. City Of Roanoke
Filing
79
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 8/27/15. (eot)
pawp% AT
ogpc: u :. sm cour
nl
RO g E V
ANOK A
FI
LED
I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COU RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF V I N I
CT
RGI A
RO AN OK E D I I ON
V SI
AkC 2 ? 2 1
95
JULA
I
BK
z ,
J RED B.W I
A
LBU RN ,
Ci lA cton N o.7: 4-CV vi
i
1
00255
Pl ntf ,
ai if
M EM ORANDUM O PI
NION
CI OF ROANOKE,
TY
By:H on.Gl n E.
e
Conr d
a
Chi U nie St t D it i tJ
ef t d a es s rc udge
Def
endant
.
Plitf J rdB.W ibur br htt sacin a i tdee ntt CiyofRoa (lhe
anif ae
l n oug hi to gans fnda he t
noke t
t
Ciy',hi f rempl er Att cos ofpli ifse de a ti , e ntmove f
t ' s onue
)
oy . he l e
antf' vi nce t raldefnda
d or
j
udgme tasamatroflw pu s tt Rul 50()oft Fe r Rul ofCi lPr dur Fo
n
te a ruan o e a he deal es
vi oce e. r
t r s s at d i ope cour a f t e s tf t bel ,t cou tco l ,asa m a t rof
he ea ons t e n n
t nd or hos e orh ow he r nc udes
te
lw,h tar a o a l j r c u dn tfndi fv ro p an if
a ta e s n be u y o l o i n a o f litf.
Fact and ProceduralH i oa
ual
st
The f l i f c s a e undiput d, , he e diput dsa e pr s nt d i t lg m os
olow ng a t r
s e or w r s e r e e e n he i ht t
f vor bl t W ibu n.
a a eo l r
W ibur be n wor ng f rt Ciy a apolc o tc i Ocober1
l n ga
ki o he t s
ie fi er n t
996.W ibur wor d
l n ke
a apar ofi r whih i ve par lng t sr e sofRoanokeon abiycl l De embe
s tol fce , c nvol d toli he te t
c e. n c
r
2 0 W ib r ij r dhslfm ita dh ndwhl ef cuai a ar s a ans a itxiae
01 , l u n nu e i e t s n a
ie fe t tng n re t g i t n n o c td
i vi l
ndi dua .
Afe hsij r W i m rtme t wo ka t Ciy sp lc d p rme ti atih
tr i nu y, l
bu eu d o r the t ' o ie e a t n n ' g t
l
du y' c c t Fis ,he wor d i t t l s r i s de rm e ,t ki phone c l a w rtng
t ' apa iy. r t
ke n he e e e v ce pa t nt a ng
als nd ii
r t . e ,he w or i t pr pe t r
epors N xt
ked n he o ry oom w he e he r e ve a l
r
ec i d nd ogge e de e.I
d vi nc n
addii W ibur w or d a t polc a ade y w he e he a s s e w ih tai ng e c s a
ton, l n
ke t he i e c m
r
s i t d t r ni xer i es nd
w or d on conc al w ea
ke
e ed
ponspe m is
r t.
W ibur ha t ees ge i i or rt i a adevie i hi body t twoul s nd
l n d hr ur res n de o mpl nt
c n s
ha
d e
eecrc lpule t hi s na c um n t r ivepan i hi wrs a ha Durnghi frtt
l ti a s s o s pi l ol
o ele
i n s it nd nd. i
s is wo
s gere ,bot i J y 201 t ba tr f t devi wa ple i W ibum ' butoc . tr
ur is h n ul
2, he te y or he
ce s a ed n l
s t ks Afe
bo h s g i , hebat r m ove outo pl c s ty t r afe . De embe 201 W ibum
t ur eres t
te y
d
f a e horl he e tr On c
r 2, l
ha at r szg y i or rt pl c t ba tr i hi c t t ss ge y wasa s ce sandt
d hid lr er n de o a e he te y n s hes; hi ur r
uc s
he
ba t r ha r m a ne i pl c e rs nce
te y s e i d n a e ve i .
To de e m i w he he he c d r t n t hi pr vi usposton asa polc of i e ,W ib n
t r ne
t r oul e ur o s e o
ii
i e fc r l ur
u nv a s re oft t .l J ar 201 W ibur unde we af tona c pact
nde ent e is ess n anu y 3, l n
r nt unc i l a iy
e m i ton, c c ude t them e t sr ngt gr de f rapolc ofi e . ibur alo
xa na i whi h oncl d ha
t he te h a o
i e fc r W l n s
pas e hi fr r sa baon c tfc ton t sss a tr l Fe a y 201 Dr M ura J ne
s d s iea m nd t erii a i e t oon fe . n bnlr
3, . r y oi r
r l a e W ibur f dut wih c ran pe mane r titonsa trde e mi ngt tW ibum '
e e s d l n or y t e ti r
nt esrc i
fe t r ni ha l
s
ij re h dr a h dma mu me ia i r v me tAc odi t W i un ' tsi n , .
n u is a e c e xi m d c l mp o e n . c r ng o l zs e tmo y Dr
b
J ne ha s c fc c e ns a
oi r d pe ii onc r boutW ibum r t ni t w o k a a pa r of i e .
l
e ur ng o r s
t ol f c r
W ibur as d t Ciy t ac om m oda e hi di a lt by l t r ly tans e rng hi t
l n ke he t o c
t s s biiy
aeal r fri
m o
a he va ntlw e or e e poston.Spe t a l W ibur r quese ta f rt t va ant
not r ca a nf c m nt ii
ci ly, l n e t d r nse o wo c
k
posto :deec i a evi ncet l cin.Bot posto ar S wor ofi e 'posto i
ii ns t tve nd de
ecmi a
h ii ns e ç n fc r' ii ns n
s
whih t e oye c n be c le i t dut a a tm ea ca esafr a m . or ng t
c he mpl e a
a ld n o y t ny i nd ni
ie r Acc di o
W ibur et rposton c dha ac omm oda e hi dia lt Polc Chi Chrsophe
l n, ihe
ii oul ve c
t d s s biiy. ie ef it r
Pe ki de de how e , ha W ibur spe m a tr ti tons asouti by Dr J ner
r ns ci ds
ver t t l n' r nen esr c i ,
lned
. oi ,
woul ha pr ve ed W ibur f om pe f r i asa s or of i e i a c pac t On M a c 4,
d ve e nt
l n r
r o m ng
w n f c r n ny a iy.
rh
201 t Ciy t na e W ibur se pl e i t a ofof e i hi a l t r t a f rw ihi
3, he t enui t d l n' m oym nt ns e d
f r ng m a e al r ns e t n
t polc de rme oral rpad poston outi oft polc de rme .
he ie pa t nt
owe - i
ii
sde he ie pa t nt
Afe e usi hi a i sr tver m e es W ibur fld t sa ton on M a 1 201
tr xha tng s dm nitai e di , l n ie hi c i
y 6, 4,
al gi t tt Ciy f ie t pr dear a ona ea omm odai i vi ai oft
le ng ha he t al d o ovi
e s bl cc
ton n ol ton he
Ameia wihDia lte Ac (t
rc ns t s biiis t ç
ADA',4 U. C.j1 01e s u.OnAugus 4, ,t
' 2 S.
)
21 t e
t 2015 he
c u t e e t eCiy smoin frs mma yj g n . e Do k t 5 OnAug t1 , 1 ,
o r d nid h t ' to o u r ud me t S e c e No. 6.
us 9 20 5
abf r ae jlytil e a o W i u n' ra o a ea c mmo ain cam t e teADA.
iu c td t ra b g n n l r s e s n bl c o d to li md r h
r
b
Tha s day,a t cos ofW ibur se de ,t Ciyma a orlmoto frj
t ame
t he l e
l n' vi nce he t de n a in o udgme a
nt s
a m a t r ofl w ,a gui t tW ibt ' ha notpr e e s fci nte denc t s w t tt Ciy
te
a r ng ha
l un d
es nt d uf i e vi e o ho ha he t
fie t p o i ehm wihar a o bea c mmo to atrhi p nn ne tn u y Th c u t
ald o r v d i t e s na l c o dain fe s e a n ij r . e o r
g a eddef ndan ' moton.
r nt
e
ts i
St
andard o R e e
f vi w
Rul 50()oft Fedea RulsofCi lPr e epr vi t ti apa t hasbee f l
e a he
rl e
vi oc dur o des ha f ry
n uly
h ado a is ed rn aj r til ndt ec u t idsta aSe s n bl j r wo l n th v a
e r n n su u ig u y ra a h o r fn h t l a o a e u y ud o a e
r
l galy s fci nte denta y ba i t fnd f t pa t on t i s ,' he t c t a r ol
e l uf i e vi i r s s o i or he r y
hat s ue ' t n he our m y es ve
teis ea ans t ep rya dg a tamoinf r u g n a amatro lw. d. Ci P.
h su g i t h a t n rn
to o j d me t s te f a Fe R. v.
50() I r lngont moton,heco tmus viw t e de a dr w alr a o bl
a . n ui
he i t ur
t e he vi nce nd a l e s na e
i e e e i t lg mos f vor bl t t nonmovi pary,La k v. a- a tSt r s l ,240
nf r nc s n he iht t a a e o he
ng t
c W lM r o e s nc.
F.d25 , 9(t Ci. 0 ) a dma n ts b t ueis u g n f rt to t j r o ma e
3 5 25 4 h r 2 01, n y o u si t t j d me t o ha fhe u y r k
t
c e biiy de e m i tons Prce v. t ofCha l t 93F. 1 ,1 ( hCi. 996) A
r di lt t r na i , i
Ciy
rotes
3d 241 249 4t r 1 .
-
c u t yg a t u g n a amatro 1w i t et vd nc p e e td s p o t o l o e
o r ma rn j d me t s te f a f h t ie e r s ne u p rs ny n
e
r s bl c uson a t t ve di t' Ba ofM o r a v.Si tBa 1 F. 81 831
ea ona e oncl i s o he r c . nk
'
nte l
cne nk 93 3d 8,
( hCi.1999 .
4t r
)
Di si
scus on
Th ADA p o i t e o esfo i ici n tig a an taq aiidi iiu l n
e
r hbi mply r r m û s rmialn ) g is u lfe ndvd a o
s
d
t eb sso d sbit .. 4 U. C.j1 1 () Dia ii d s rmiainma icu tef ile
h a i f ia l y..' 2 S.
i '
21 2 a . s b ly ic i n to y n lde h alr
t
t
t m ak f e onabl a om m oda i t t known phys ca orm e allm ia i ofa
o
e s as
r
e cc
tons o he
i l
nt i t tons n
o h r s q aiididviu l t ad s bl ywh i a ( e ly e..'ds 1 1 2 b ( )A)
t e wie u l e n i d a wih ia it o s n 1 mpo e .. 1 j 2 1 ( )5 ( .
f
i
'
Thus t pr vai i af iur -o- c m moda eca e,apl i ifmus s
s o e l n a l e t a co
t s
antf
t how
()t thewa a i vi lwhohasadia lt wihi t me ni oft saut (
1 ha
s n ndi dua
s biiy t n he a ng he tt e;2)
t a t e(mpo e)ha n tc o h sd sbi t; 3 t a wihra o a l a c mmo ai n
h t h e ly r d oie f i ia l y ( ) h t t e s n b e c o d to
i
hec dpef m t e s ilf tonsoft poston.. a ( t tt rmpl r
oul ror he senta unci
he ii .; nd 4) ha he e oye)
r us t ma s h ac omm oda i .
ef ed o ke uc c
tons
W is v. l Ge Cop.71 F.d 337,345( hCi. 3 ( i Rhoa v. d. post
lon Dolar n.
, 7 3
4t r 201 ) quotng
ds Fe De i
l .Cor s257F. 373,387n. 1( hCi.2001)
ns p.
3d
1 4t r
).
O nc a e pl e r ques sa r a ona e a com m odaton, he i e ac i pr es i
e n m oye e
t e s bl c
i t nt r tve oc s s
ti r Crbilv. rol M e klnbur Bd.ofEduc,423F. x 31 3 23( h Ci.
rggeed. a l Cha lte c e g
,
App' 4, 22- 4t r
2011. ht e oyera t e oye haveadut t e agei good fih i t i eaci
) Bot he mpl
nd he mpl e
y o ng n
at n he ntr tve
pr s . d.
oce s l The pur e oft i e a tve pr e s i t t de iy t pr i e lm ia i r s tng
pos
he nt r c i
oc s s o t ntf he ec s i t tons e uli
i
fom t dia lt a potntalr as bl ac omm oda i t tc d o r ome t e
r he s biiy nd e i e ona e c
tons ha oul ve c
hos
lmiai . 29C. R.j 1 2494 .
i ttons'
'
F. 630. c 3)
t as
l onabl ac om modaton'm a i ude ç e sgnm e t ava ntposton.'Se 4
Re
e c
i ' y ncl s as i
r
nt o
ca
ii ' e 2
U. C.j1 111 9 . U. Equa Empl ntOpporuniyCommison' r gultons
S. 2 ( ) The S. l
oyme
t t
s i s e ai
i e pr tngt ADA pr det tr s i m e s dbetr tt a C valntposton i
nt r ei he
ovi ha ea sgn nt houl
ls o n s
equi e
ii n
t m sofpa sa us et ,i t i vi li qualfed a i t poston i va ntwihi a
er
y, t t , c. f he ndi dua s
ii nd f he ii s ca
t n
rms l a
e onabe mountoftme'29C. R.Pt 1 App. 1 249. e oye ma rasi
i .' F. . 630,
at 630. c An mpl r y e sgn
a e oye t al rgr d poston i t r a ei a omm oda i t twoul e bl t
n mpl e o owe ade
ii f he e r s cc
no
tons ha
d na e he
e pl e t r m a n i t c r ntpos ton, t r a e no va a e val ntpos to f
m oye o e i n he ur e
ii and he e r
c nt qui e
ii ns or
whi t i vi i qualted wih orwihou r as
ch he ndi dual s
ii
t
t t e onabl ac omm oda i '1
e c
ton. d.
'
I t sc e, heCiy doesnotdiput t tW ibur hasadiabiiy,hati ha notc o
n hi as t
t
s e ha l n
s lt t t d i e f
4
t dia lt a t tW ibur r se ar s bl a o m odai n. The Ciy a s t ,
he s biiy, nd ha l n eque t d ea ona e cc m
to
t s ers
ho ve , ha t r wa no r a ona ea omm oda i a ia et W ibu n be a ehe c d not
we r t t he e s e s bl cc
ton va lbl o l r c us
oul
pe f t es en i f tons oft de e tve a e de e t ehni i n pos tonsw ihi t
r onn he s tal unc i
he t c i nd vi nc e c a
ii
t n he
polc de m e ,a t r we eno va ntpostonsou sdet polc de rm e f
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?