Smith v. McClure

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/9/2014. (tvt)

Download PDF
ctEM s OFFI U. DI COUU CE S. ST. AT ROANOKE, VA FI LED J 1û 2 1 L8 26 I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E W E STER N D I STR I O F VI G I A CT R NI R O A NO K E D I ISIO N V A N TH O NY AN TH A SM I , TH J A . ULI BY' , , ERK CA SE NO .7: 4CV 00285 1 Pl i if a ntf , M EM O M N DU M O PI O N NI CHARLES A M CCLURE, ESQ. , By: G l E .Conr en ad Chi U ni e St esD i t i tJudge ef t d at src D ef endant . Ant hony Ant Smih,a Kent ky i t pr ee ng pr K ,fld a pladi t t he ha t uc nma e oc di o ie e ng ha sylsa aû VI COM PLAI FOR PATENT W FRI te s I L CI NT NGEM ENT.' ( ' Compl 1) Smih as .. t lo movest pr ed i f mapa rs Upon rviw oft r or t c r gr t pli ifi o oce n or upei. e e he ec d, he ou t ans antf q fr p u ei sau ,p ru n t 28 U. C.j1 5 b ,b t fn s t tt e a to mus b oma a p rs tt s u s a t o S. 91 ( ) u id ha h cin t e sl ma iy dimi s d. lm rl s s e Sm ih s s a no dec as d a t ne Cha ls A.M c tr of Le ngt Vigi a,who t ue w- e e tor y, re clle, xi on, r ni r pr s nt d Sm ih i obt ni a 1 pa e f a de c Sm ih i nt d,t C t e Li d e ee e t n ai ng 999 t nt or vi e t nve e he t abl qui por Sa tton Ca t' ( niai r-' Compl2. Smih alge t thee oyedM c ur i 1 t asithi i . ) t le s ha mpl cl e n 995 o ss m n pae t S t s iv n in as k o a a tl s i lLiu d S ni to Ca t' ( mp .2. tni mih' n e to , lo n wn s t o pt q i a t in r. Co l ) ng l a a ' So e i afe obt ni PaentN o. 5 323 f t de c Smih t ufer d a sr a m tme tr ai ng t 918 or he vie, t û f e s toke nd rman d t b et c mmt c t wih oh r f rac nsd r be p ro o tme' (d) S t e ie ma l o o miae t te s o o ie a l e id f i . 1 . mi ' h be ivest twhie he wass i pa ia e M c ur bega ofe i t s nia i c r de c a le ha l o nca ct t d, cl e n f rng he a t ton a t vi e s hi o on hi busnes we ie,Pa e st m,t ale y i rngi on Sm ih' rght t r s wn s i s bst t nt or hus lgedl nfi ng t s i s mde t pae . Smih as e t t tM c ur wr ngf l denid hi alpr ksobt i d t ough lsi he tnt t s rs ha cl e o uly e m 1 ot ane hr itng te c r o t ewe st a d se c mp n ao y d ma e a d a ijmcin a an tM c t et h a t n h b ie n e ks o e s tr n g s n n n t to g is cll o r pr ven hi fo bl ki Smih' exe c s ofhi rght . e t m r m oc ng t s r ie si s Sm ih fl d t s s m e c ai s a i t M c tr i 2008. Sm ih v.M c tr Cas N o. t ie he e n l m ga ns clle n t clle, e 7: 08CV00 4 ( . Va.2008 . The c ts 41 W D. ) our ummaiy dimis d t a ton unde 28 U. C. rl s s e he ci r S. j 1 5e ( )B)f rf i r t saeacam. S cin 1 5i os sama d tr d t o t ec u t 91 ()2 ( o al e o tt li e to 91 mp e u n ao y u y n h o r Eo s re iiilfln s(ub te i f n p u eilt d tr newh t e t e fl wihn a y v c e n nta i g s mitd n o na a p rs o ee mi t i eh r h y al t i n o tec us sf rd s sa s tf rh i j1 5 e ( )B)' n t la pl c mmo s n e rj c t e f h a e o imis l e o t n 91 ( )2 ( 'a d o i p y o n e s , ee t h û f na tc a d r b talg d matr wi j diil n t e b e fcs' 1 ,Sl Op.3 ( oia a tsi, n e u l e tes t u cal oi a l a t.' d. i e h y c ' p nu tn Na i v. ad n. ay a dHo eo Cor, 4F.d9 , 5 ( t Ci.1 9 :. sm w r e M r ln us f r.6 3 51 9 4 4h r 9 5 I Cas N o.7: n e 08CV 0041 t c tf md t tSm ih ha notpr e e f c s s a i a 4, he our ot ha t d es nt d a t t tng ny c am t tM c t e ha i rnge on Smih' pa e by ofe i hi i nton f s e on t l i ha cll r d nfi d t s t nt f rng s nve i or al he Pae t t r we st. The c t tt o j iiln tc t tt e we ie S t rf rn e me ey tns o m b i e ol o k udca oie ha h bst mih ee e c d rl r pr de t g r lpublcwih a opporuniy t s r h and ob an fe c e ofpa e sf al ovi d he ene a i t n t t o ea c t i r e opi s t nt or l pa e e i ntonsfom 1 t t pr e ;t tt we ie is l e es l i or e pa r ns t ntd nve i r 976 o he es nt ha he bst te f xpr sy nf m d to t ti di no ofe f s l a oft pa e e goodsm e i d on t st a t tM cclle ha t d t f r or a e ny he t nt d ntone he ie; nd ha tr wa lsed o t we ie a Sm ih' pa e a t ey,nota a owne oft w e ie. On t s s it n he bst s t s t nt tom s n r he bst he e f c s t co t f a t , he ur ound t t Sm ih had not sa e a c am a i t M ccl e f pa e ha t t t d ny l i ga ns m or t nt i rn e n u d r3 U. C. 2 ()a d s s e tea to u d rj1 5e ( )B) nfi g me t n e 5 S. j 71a nd imis d h cin n e 91 ()2 ( . Smih' c r ntc am of pa e i rnge e mus alo be s ma iy dim is d unde t s ur e l i t nt nfi m nt t s um rl s s e r j1 5e( )B) Fo t er a o ssae i Ca eNo 70 CV0 41 Smihha n tprs ne a 91 ()2 ( . r h e s n ttd n s . :8 0 4, t s o e e td ny a tona e cai agans a c i bl l m i t nyone ba ed on t Pa e st r ' lsi of hi pae i t pa t s he t nt o m s itng s tnt n he s. W he t c ta tmptd t vii t Pa e st m we ie i June201 t diply c itd of n he our te e o st he t nt or bst n 4, he s a onsse a me s get tPae st m i no l ri o r ton. Sm ih hi s fs ae t tM c m e di i s a ha tnt or s onge n pe a i t m el t t s ha cl ed n 2 0.Th , mih scamsf rij n tv r l ft p e e tftzelsig o h sive to o te 01 us S t ' li o nu cie ei o rv n ul itn f i n nin n h e r w e ie o f t e m i us oft pa e i a w a by M c tr m us be dim i s d msm oo . bs t r u ur s e he t nt n ny y clle t s se t 2 For t r a ons s a ed, t c t di m i s s Sm ih' co pl nt plr ua t he e s tt he our s se t s m ai , z s nt o j1 5e( )B) fr fiu e t sae a cam . The Clr i d rce t s n c pe o t s 91 ()2 ( , o al r o tt li ek s ie td o e d o is f hi m e a um opi on a a ompa ng O de t pli if mor nd ni nd cc nyi r r o antf . ENTER: i jN Ths dyo Jn, 0 4 a f u e2 1 . ChifUnie St t DititJ ge e t d aes src ud

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?