Smith v. McClure

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/9/2014. (tvt)

ctEM s OFFI U. DI COUU
CE S. ST.
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

J 1û 2 1
L8
26
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I O F VI G I A
CT
R NI
R O A NO K E D I ISIO N
V
A N TH O NY AN TH A SM I ,
TH

J A .
ULI
BY'
,

, ERK

CA SE NO .7: 4CV 00285
1

Pl i if
a ntf ,
M EM O M N DU M O PI O N
NI

CHARLES A M CCLURE,
ESQ.
,

By: G l E .Conr
en
ad
Chi U ni e St esD i t i tJudge
ef t d at
src

D ef
endant
.

Ant
hony Ant Smih,a Kent ky i t pr ee ng pr K ,fld a pladi t t he
ha
t
uc nma e oc di
o
ie
e ng ha

sylsa aû VI COM PLAI FOR PATENT W FRI
te s I L
CI
NT
NGEM ENT.' (
' Compl 1) Smih as
..
t lo
movest pr ed i f mapa rs Upon rviw oft r or t c r gr t pli ifi
o oce n or
upei.
e e
he ec d, he ou t ans antf q

fr p u ei sau ,p ru n t 28 U. C.j1 5 b ,b t fn s t tt e a to mus b
oma a p rs tt s u s a t o
S.
91 ( ) u id ha h cin
t e
sl ma iy dimi s d.
lm rl s s e
Sm ih s s a no dec as d a t ne Cha ls A.M c tr of Le ngt Vigi a,who
t ue
w- e e tor y, re
clle,
xi on, r ni
r pr s nt d Sm ih i obt ni a 1 pa e f a de c Sm ih i nt d,t C t e Li d
e ee e
t n ai ng 999 t nt or
vi e
t nve e he t abl qui
por

Sa tton Ca t' (
niai
r-' Compl2. Smih alge t thee oyedM c ur i 1 t asithi i
. ) t le s ha
mpl
cl e n 995 o ss m n

pae t S t s iv n in as k o a a tl s i lLiu d S ni to Ca t' ( mp .2.
tni mih' n e to , lo n wn s t o pt q i a t in r. Co l )
ng
l
a
a
'
So e i afe obt ni PaentN o. 5 323 f t de c Smih t ufer d a sr a
m tme tr ai ng t
918
or he vie, t û f e
s
toke nd

rman d t b et c mmt c t wih oh r f rac nsd r be p ro o tme' (d) S t
e ie ma l o o miae t te s o o ie a l e id f i . 1 . mi
'
h
be ivest twhie he wass i pa ia e M c ur bega ofe i t s nia i c r de c a
le
ha
l
o nca ct t d, cl e
n f rng he a t ton a t vi e s
hi o on hi busnes we ie,Pa e st m,t ale y i rngi on Sm ih' rght t r
s wn
s i s bst t nt or hus lgedl nfi ng
t s i s mde
t pae . Smih as e t t tM c ur wr ngf l denid hi alpr ksobt i d t ough lsi
he tnt
t s rs ha cl e o uly
e m 1 ot
ane hr
itng

te c r o t ewe st a d se c mp n ao y d ma e a d a ijmcin a an tM c t et
h a t n h b ie n e ks o e s tr n g s n n n t to g is cll o
r
pr ven hi fo bl ki Smih' exe c s ofhi rght .
e t m r m oc ng
t s r ie
si s

Sm ih fl d t s s m e c ai s a i t M c tr i 2008. Sm ih v.M c tr Cas N o.
t ie he e n
l m ga ns
clle n
t
clle, e

7:
08CV00 4 ( . Va.2008 . The c ts
41 W D.
)
our ummaiy dimis d t a ton unde 28 U. C.
rl s s e he ci
r
S.

j 1 5e ( )B)f rf i r t saeacam. S cin 1 5i os sama d tr d t o t ec u t
91 ()2 ( o al e o tt li e to 91 mp e
u
n ao y u y n h o r
Eo s re iiilfln s(ub te i f n p u eilt d tr newh t e t e fl wihn a y
v c e n nta i g s mitd n o na a p rs o ee mi
t
i
eh r h y al t i n
o tec us sf rd s sa s tf rh i j1 5 e ( )B)' n t la pl c mmo s n e rj c t e
f h a e o imis l e o t n 91 ( )2 ( 'a d o i p y o n e s , ee t h
û

f na tc a d r b talg d matr wi j diil n t e b e fcs' 1 ,Sl Op.3 ( oia
a tsi, n e u l e tes t u cal oi a l a t.' d. i
e
h
y c
'
p
nu tn
Na i v. ad n. ay a dHo eo Cor, 4F.d9 , 5 ( t Ci.1 9 :.
sm w r e M r ln us f r.6 3 51 9 4 4h r 9 5
I Cas N o.7:
n
e
08CV 0041 t c tf md t tSm ih ha notpr e e f c s s a i a
4, he our ot ha
t d
es nt d a t t tng ny

c am t tM c t e ha i rnge on Smih' pa e by ofe i hi i nton f s e on t
l i ha
cll
r d nfi d
t s t nt
f rng s nve i or al
he

Pae t t r we st. The c t tt o j iiln tc t tt e we ie S t rf rn e me ey
tns o m b i
e
ol o k udca oie ha h bst mih ee e c d rl
r
pr de t g r lpublcwih a opporuniy t s r h and ob an fe c e ofpa e sf al
ovi d he ene a
i t n
t t o ea c
t i r e opi s
t nt or l
pa e e i ntonsfom 1 t t pr e ;t tt we ie is l e es l i or e pa r ns
t ntd nve i
r
976 o he es nt ha he bst te f xpr sy nf m d to
t ti di no ofe f s l a oft pa e e goodsm e i d on t st a t tM cclle
ha t d t f r or a e ny he t nt d
ntone
he ie; nd ha
tr

wa lsed o t we ie a Sm ih' pa e a t ey,nota a owne oft w e ie. On t s
s it n he bst s
t s t nt tom
s n
r he bst
he e
f c s t co t f
a t , he ur ound t t Sm ih had not sa e a c am a i t M ccl e f pa e
ha
t
t t d ny l i ga ns
m or t nt

i rn e n u d r3 U. C. 2 ()a d s s e tea to u d rj1 5e ( )B)
nfi g me t n e 5 S. j 71a nd imis d h cin n e 91 ()2 ( .
Smih' c r ntc am of pa e i rnge e mus alo be s ma iy dim is d unde
t s ur e l i
t nt nfi m nt
t s
um rl s s e
r

j1 5e( )B) Fo t er a o ssae i Ca eNo 70 CV0 41 Smihha n tprs ne a
91 ()2 ( . r h e s n ttd n s . :8 0 4, t s o e e td ny
a tona e cai agans a
c i bl l m
i t nyone ba ed on t Pa e st r ' lsi of hi pae i t pa t
s
he t nt o m s itng
s tnt n he s.
W he t c ta tmptd t vii t Pa e st m we ie i June201 t diply c itd of
n he our te e o st he t nt or
bst n
4, he s a onsse
a me s get tPae st m i no l ri o r ton. Sm ih hi s fs ae t tM c m e di i
s a ha tnt or s onge n pe a i
t m el t t s ha
cl
ed n

2 0.Th , mih scamsf rij n tv r l ft p e e tftzelsig o h sive to o te
01
us S t ' li o nu cie ei o rv n ul itn f i n nin n h
e
r
w e ie o f t e m i us oft pa e i a w a by M c tr m us be dim i s d msm oo .
bs t r u ur s e he t nt n ny y
clle
t
s se
t

2

For t r a ons s a ed, t c t di m i s s Sm ih' co pl nt plr ua t
he e s
tt
he our
s se
t s m ai , z s nt o

j1 5e( )B) fr fiu e t sae a cam . The Clr i d rce t s n c pe o t s
91 ()2 ( , o al r o tt
li
ek s ie td o e d o is f hi
m e a um opi on a a ompa ng O de t pli if
mor nd
ni nd cc
nyi r r o antf .

ENTER: i jN
Ths

dyo Jn, 0 4
a f u e2 1 .
ChifUnie St t DititJ ge
e
t d aes src ud