Hutton v. Colvin

Filing 23

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 14 Motion for Summary Judgment; denying 16 Motion for Summary Judgment; adopting 22 Report and Recommendations,. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 08/26/2015. (bw)

CLERK' OFFI :. . ST. Um '
S
CE )s Dh K
ATRM NOKE,
VA
FP
LED

I THE U N I
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COU RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI O F V I I A
CT
RG NI
R OAN O KE D I I ON
V SI

AU 2 s 2 1
C
05
u
Y.

c

ERK

JOHN A .HU TTON ,
Ci lAc i N o. 7: 4CV 0031
vi ton
1
0
Pl i if
a ntf ,

CA RO LYN W .COLV I ,Actng
N
i
Com m i sone ofSoc a Sec r t
si r
i l u iy,

By:

Hon. e E.Conr d
Gln
a
ChifUnie St t DititJ e
e
t d aes src udg

D e e nt
f nda .

Thi m a trwa r f r e t Unied Stt sM agitaeRobe tS.Bal puruantt 28
s te s e e r d o t
ae
sr t
r
lou, s
o

U. C.j636( ( )B)f pr posdfndngsoff ta ar c
S.
b)1( or o e i i
ac nd e omme ddiposton.The
nde s ii
M a sr t J
gita e udges it d aRe ta Re omm e to o Augus 6,201 i whi h he
ubm te
por nd c
ndai n n
t
5, n
c

r c mme d ta t eCo sin rsmoin frs mmayj g n bed nid t th
e o n s h t h mmiso e ' to o u r ud me t e e ,ha te
p an ifsmoin frs mmayj d me tb g a tdi p r, n t a t i c s b rma d dt t e
litf
t o u r u g n e rn e n a ta d h t hs a e e e n e o h
o
Commisone purua t s ne f rof42U. C.j405( f f t rpr e ngs.No
si r s nt o e tnce ou
S.
g) or urhe oc edi )

o j ci n t teRe o t n Re o n ainh v be nfld a dtec u tso t o ii n
b e to s o h p r a d c mme d to a e e i , n h o r i f he pn o
e
t tt Re t Re om me ton s dbea edi ise iey.
ha he por and c
nda i houl
dopt n t ntr t
l i ac or ngl
t s c di y
O RDERED
asf l
olows:

1.

TheAugus 6, 6Re t ndRe omme to ( .#2 i ADOPTED i is
t 201 por a
c
ndain Dkt 2) s
nt
entr yiet ,

Th Co sin rsmo infrs mmayj d me ( c e #1 )i DENI
e mmiso e ' to o u r u g nt Do k t 6 s
ED;
Pli ifsmoto frs
antf
in o ummayj
r udgme ( ke #1 i GRANTED i pa t
nt Doc t 4) s
n r;

Thi ca ei REM ANDED t t Comm iso rf rf rhe c i r ton
s s s
o he
s i ne o u t r onsde a i
c i t ntw ih t r por a r co m e ton. U pon r m a s d t
onss e
t he e t nd e m nda i
e nd, houl he

Comm isone beuna et de det sc ei pli tf sf voront bassoft
si r
bl o ci hi as n a n if a
he i
he
e si r co d, heComm iso rs l c
xitng e r t
s i ne ha l ondud as plm e ala i sr tve
up e nt dm nitai
hea i a whi bo h sde wilbealowe t pr e a tonale denc and
rng t ch t i s l
l d o es nt ddii
vi e
r gum ent
'

The pa isa ea s t tt c tc i st sr ma or t be a
rte r dvied ha he our onsder hi e nd der o
' e enc f 'r mand. Se M el
' nt e our' e
s
e
konya v.Suli 501U . 8 11lS.Ct 2l
n
lvan,
S.9,
. 57

(991 ;Shall v.Sc fr 509U. 292,11 S. .2625( 1 .Thus t s
1 )
aa
haee,
S.
3 Ct
1 93)
,hi
or rofr ndi afna or r L I t Commisone s dagandeny
de ema s i l de . 4. f he
s i r houl i
pli ifscli f s e nt s c iy i om ebe is a s d pl i if
antf
am or upplme al e urt nc
neft , nd houl antf

a anc o et s e u iil e iw,twil en c sayf rp an ift iiit a
g i h os o e kj dca r ve i l b e e sr o litf o ntae
ne cvi aci wihi sxt ( da fom t daeoft Commiso rsfna
w i l ton t n i y 60) ys r he t he
sine ' i l
de sononrma See42U. C.j405 g ;
cii
e nd.
S.
( ) and
Thi m a tri STRI
s te s
CKEN fom t a tvedoc toft c t
r he ci
ke
he our.
The Clr i die t dt s nd ac rii c oft sor rt al cot elofr co d.
ek s rce o e
e tfed opy hi de o 1 ms
e r

ENTER: Aug t J6 ,201
us
5

ChifUnied St t sDititJ
e
t
a e src udge