Hutton v. Colvin
Filing
23
ORDER granting in part and denying in part 14 Motion for Summary Judgment; denying 16 Motion for Summary Judgment; adopting 22 Report and Recommendations,. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 08/26/2015. (bw)
CLERK' OFFI :. . ST. Um '
S
CE )s Dh K
ATRM NOKE,
VA
FP
LED
I THE U N I
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COU RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI O F V I I A
CT
RG NI
R OAN O KE D I I ON
V SI
AU 2 s 2 1
C
05
u
Y.
c
ERK
JOHN A .HU TTON ,
Ci lAc i N o. 7: 4CV 0031
vi ton
1
0
Pl i if
a ntf ,
CA RO LYN W .COLV I ,Actng
N
i
Com m i sone ofSoc a Sec r t
si r
i l u iy,
By:
Hon. e E.Conr d
Gln
a
ChifUnie St t DititJ e
e
t d aes src udg
D e e nt
f nda .
Thi m a trwa r f r e t Unied Stt sM agitaeRobe tS.Bal puruantt 28
s te s e e r d o t
ae
sr t
r
lou, s
o
U. C.j636( ( )B)f pr posdfndngsoff ta ar c
S.
b)1( or o e i i
ac nd e omme ddiposton.The
nde s ii
M a sr t J
gita e udges it d aRe ta Re omm e to o Augus 6,201 i whi h he
ubm te
por nd c
ndai n n
t
5, n
c
r c mme d ta t eCo sin rsmoin frs mmayj g n bed nid t th
e o n s h t h mmiso e ' to o u r ud me t e e ,ha te
p an ifsmoin frs mmayj d me tb g a tdi p r, n t a t i c s b rma d dt t e
litf
t o u r u g n e rn e n a ta d h t hs a e e e n e o h
o
Commisone purua t s ne f rof42U. C.j405( f f t rpr e ngs.No
si r s nt o e tnce ou
S.
g) or urhe oc edi )
o j ci n t teRe o t n Re o n ainh v be nfld a dtec u tso t o ii n
b e to s o h p r a d c mme d to a e e i , n h o r i f he pn o
e
t tt Re t Re om me ton s dbea edi ise iey.
ha he por and c
nda i houl
dopt n t ntr t
l i ac or ngl
t s c di y
O RDERED
asf l
olows:
1.
TheAugus 6, 6Re t ndRe omme to ( .#2 i ADOPTED i is
t 201 por a
c
ndain Dkt 2) s
nt
entr yiet ,
Th Co sin rsmo infrs mmayj d me ( c e #1 )i DENI
e mmiso e ' to o u r u g nt Do k t 6 s
ED;
Pli ifsmoto frs
antf
in o ummayj
r udgme ( ke #1 i GRANTED i pa t
nt Doc t 4) s
n r;
Thi ca ei REM ANDED t t Comm iso rf rf rhe c i r ton
s s s
o he
s i ne o u t r onsde a i
c i t ntw ih t r por a r co m e ton. U pon r m a s d t
onss e
t he e t nd e m nda i
e nd, houl he
Comm isone beuna et de det sc ei pli tf sf voront bassoft
si r
bl o ci hi as n a n if a
he i
he
e si r co d, heComm iso rs l c
xitng e r t
s i ne ha l ondud as plm e ala i sr tve
up e nt dm nitai
hea i a whi bo h sde wilbealowe t pr e a tonale denc and
rng t ch t i s l
l d o es nt ddii
vi e
r gum ent
'
The pa isa ea s t tt c tc i st sr ma or t be a
rte r dvied ha he our onsder hi e nd der o
' e enc f 'r mand. Se M el
' nt e our' e
s
e
konya v.Suli 501U . 8 11lS.Ct 2l
n
lvan,
S.9,
. 57
(991 ;Shall v.Sc fr 509U. 292,11 S. .2625( 1 .Thus t s
1 )
aa
haee,
S.
3 Ct
1 93)
,hi
or rofr ndi afna or r L I t Commisone s dagandeny
de ema s i l de . 4. f he
s i r houl i
pli ifscli f s e nt s c iy i om ebe is a s d pl i if
antf
am or upplme al e urt nc
neft , nd houl antf
a anc o et s e u iil e iw,twil en c sayf rp an ift iiit a
g i h os o e kj dca r ve i l b e e sr o litf o ntae
ne cvi aci wihi sxt ( da fom t daeoft Commiso rsfna
w i l ton t n i y 60) ys r he t he
sine ' i l
de sononrma See42U. C.j405 g ;
cii
e nd.
S.
( ) and
Thi m a tri STRI
s te s
CKEN fom t a tvedoc toft c t
r he ci
ke
he our.
The Clr i die t dt s nd ac rii c oft sor rt al cot elofr co d.
ek s rce o e
e tfed opy hi de o 1 ms
e r
ENTER: Aug t J6 ,201
us
5
ChifUnied St t sDititJ
e
t
a e src udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?